The Fashions of HBO's The Gilded Age // Did they get the costumes right?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 18. 03. 2022
  • Are you watching The Gilded Age on HBO? Personally, I'm really enjoying it! But that doesn't mean I always love all the costumes. So in this video, let's take a look at the costumes from this show, and discuss what they got right and what they got wrong.
    Resources
    Many of these photos come from @gildedageHBO, @ewinterling, @periodcorset, and @kat_stelzer as well as screenshots I've taken and the Facebook Group called HBO - The Gilded Age - Fan Page: / media
    More to Watch
    Learn about Gilded Age Menswear with VintageBursche: • Menswear in The Gilded...
    Check out the Official Gilded Age Podcast: • The Gilded Age | HBO
    See how hidden Victorian day bodice closures actually worked: • The Peppermint Bustle ... and • An Antique 1890's Bodi...
    Get to know me better
    My instagram: / ladyrebeccafashions
    Become a Patron! / ladyrebeccafashions
    Help support my channel on Ko-Fi: ko-fi.com/ladyrebeccafashions
    Recommendations
    My Favorite Sewing Tools: www.amazon.com/shop/ladyrebec...
    My favorite clothing store, Eshakti: www.eshakti.com/invite/b7a075...
    What I use for filming: www.amazon.com/shop/ladyrebec...
    Edited on Wondershare Filmora: alnk.to/flpXG4i
    My PO Box:
    Lady Rebecca Fashions
    PO Box 695
    Auburn, WA 98071
    Business inquiries: theladyrebecca@gmail.com
    Amazon links are affiliate links. It really helps me out if you use them!
  • Jak na to + styl

Komentáře • 344

  • @LadyRebeccaFashions
    @LadyRebeccaFashions  Před rokem +1

    If you'd like to support my channel, you can join my Patreon! Thank you to all my amazing patrons!
    www.patreon.com/ladyrebeccafashions

  • @braydenalexis
    @braydenalexis Před 2 lety +223

    Can we talk about how they're all actually wearing corsets? That was the FIRST thing I saw when the show started and I knew it was going to be good

    • @lornas-w4661
      @lornas-w4661 Před 2 lety +2

      Even the men? (in UK....and without gilding)

    • @annejeppesen160
      @annejeppesen160 Před 2 lety +6

      Chemises!!!!!!

    • @KitKat17700
      @KitKat17700 Před 2 lety +2

      Except Carrie Coon since she was pregnant with her daughter during filming :)

    • @languageresources2314
      @languageresources2314 Před 2 lety +7

      Yet they still had the nerve to say they were "toooorrrrrrrrtuuurrrrrrreeeeeeee" obviously either the corsets were poorly built or the actresses have decided to perpetuate the myth because everyone expects them to say corsets were toooorrrrrrrrtuuurrrrrrreeeeeeee. I was enjoying tge series and the official podcast up to the point when I heard every actress on the show run her schpiel about corsets are toooorrrrrrrrtuuurrrrrrreeeeeeee.

    • @1953childstar
      @1953childstar Před 2 lety +2

      @@languageresources2314 None of them were "Tight laced", which boggles my mind.. I rummaged through old photos of my family and the women from that era through the early 1900's were very much "Tight laced", which is quite different from what we have been seeing on the this program..

  • @evilempryss
    @evilempryss Před 2 lety +110

    I love how Aunt Agnes told her dressmaker to increase the bustle size on her new dress. She may *seem* like a widow disconnected from the rest of society, but every episode you get a new hint of just how "with it" she really is and I love it. ❤

    • @AntiquarianClothier
      @AntiquarianClothier Před 2 lety +16

      like that scene bothered me because the dressmaker made the comment that bustles were deflating....no they weren't they were getting bigger. IDK why but it irritated me lol

    • @syedmazharhasan6803
      @syedmazharhasan6803 Před 2 lety +4

      @@AntiquarianClothier OMG I thought I was the only one! Aunt Agnes knows fashion more than the professional 😄

  • @graphiquejack
    @graphiquejack Před 2 lety +60

    I love the fact that Bertha marches to her own drum and even if she’s trying to fit in to the 400, she wears clothes that are flashy and suit her personality. While her gowns may not be historically accurate, they make sense to her personality. I generally don’t like too much deviation from historical accuracy, but she’s meant to look somehow out of place and I think they exaggerate this by making her clothes extremely flamboyant. I suppose it doesn’t hurt that to modern eyes they look pretty fabulous in comparison to some of the other clothes, that while accurate, look somewhat dowdy.

    • @joeyree22
      @joeyree22 Před 9 měsíci +2

      Actually, she is dresses more in the French style, compared to the English fashion of the time; not a crazy kookie style as indicated in the commentary. The show chose the obvious difference in style/fashion to help her stand out, and indicate that “new money”. It’s a good choice, as it is more likely the “new money” would lean into the more flamboyant French style, over the “standard/boring” English “old money” style/fashion. I’m surprised this wasn’t mentioned.

  • @emanonfox1709
    @emanonfox1709 Před 2 lety +148

    I love how each character has their own style. Marian's hats are a little "country bumpkin" as are most of her dresses. Bertha Russel's outfits are a bit avant-guarde for the time, which fits her character. Agatha and Ada's dresses are a bit dated but very expensive looking. And the Astors! Carrie's are the most fashionable. But my favorite are Aurora Fane's, she tends to wear more patterns and silk lisere with lots of trimmings.

    • @dalemoore8582
      @dalemoore8582 Před 2 lety +8

      My daughter kept asking why Marian was wearing a " cowboy hat" in each scene!! Lol

    • @jukukwakuattionu5080
      @jukukwakuattionu5080 Před 2 lety +8

      Same Aurora Fane’s costumes take the cake! By far the best! Love Agnes goes to get a new dress and the dressmaker tells her the bustles are getting smaller with most people doing that and she goes im not most people. Love it

    • @puggynugz922
      @puggynugz922 Před 2 lety +3

      Arora wears them spectacularly!

    • @jukukwakuattionu5080
      @jukukwakuattionu5080 Před 2 lety +2

      @@puggynugz922 one of my favourite is what she wears in her house when her husband tells her that Mr Russel is going to give them back their money. Literally queen vibes

    • @Birdie359
      @Birdie359 Před 2 lety +4

      I agree wholeheartedly. Aurora Fane’s wardrobe is my favorite of all. She is very fashionable, yet she is also tasteful with a sense of style and class.

  • @elizabethrodgers750
    @elizabethrodgers750 Před 2 lety +68

    I personally think Marion’s fashion choices being older is showing her clinging to the fashions of her childhood. It’s like how some young people nowadays choose to dress in exclusively a 1970’s style or a 1990’s style. It also makes it easier for us to see her coming into her own in the city and finding her place in society

    • @jessicaraine8403
      @jessicaraine8403 Před 2 lety +15

      It's also more indicative of her small town origins as they tend to be behind in fashion by several years, if not a decade. For me this for her character origin very well.

    • @kjorgenson9236
      @kjorgenson9236 Před 2 lety +3

      i just read yesterday that Louisa said she insisted on a TIGHT corset at the beginning of the show and then was paying and price and very uncomfortable during early filming. She later asked costuming to make looser corset and costumes ( with corset breaks built into her day) She claims an influence of the "Disney princess" figure made her feel like she should have the smallest waist possible - to the side effect of negatively influencing her health.

    • @ScientificallyStupid
      @ScientificallyStupid Před 2 lety +9

      I thought Marian's dresses looked the way they did because she was "country" and didn't have a lot of experience with dressing fashionably, and when she moved to New York, Ada and Agnes sent her to THEIR dressmaker- who would have experience dressing older ladies in older styles, but who wouldn't necessarily have a sense of what was the cutting edge of fashion, or a sense of what a younger clientele would want to wear. Marian wouldn't know enough at the beginning of the series to say, "I don't like this" or, "this skirt should be like this". The dressmaker probably had less experience dressing younger ladies in young styles and would mimic things as best she could, but it would always be "off". As Marian develops relationships with people her own age, she develops more a sense of her own style that is in line with her peers.

  • @rachelmeier6514
    @rachelmeier6514 Před 2 lety +47

    I’m so glad I’m not the only one who was totally thrown off by Mrs. Russell’s blue dress in the first episode, as well as her overly shiny fabrics!! It made me worried about the other costumes!

  • @historicallyfashioned
    @historicallyfashioned Před 2 lety +63

    Peggy has the absolute best costumes in the show. They are beautiful.

  • @marywest2896
    @marywest2896 Před 2 lety +69

    to me Marion's pastel clothes were what she brought to New York, the later were the ones her aunt bought fro her, they did have to be made for her, so while they were getting made she just wore what she had brought with her.

    • @LadyRebeccaFashions
      @LadyRebeccaFashions  Před 2 lety +12

      I hadn't thought about it that way, but that's an interesting concept!

    • @amiejo
      @amiejo Před 2 lety +11

      This is what I assumed also. As her character feels more confident navigating New York Society she her fashion assimilates. Same with Mrs. Russell, she dresses over the top trying to fit in with the cool kids it looks gaudy and wrong. Everyone knows the established rich have money, they don’t need to bother proving it- and I’m sure the designers want to visually create that difference in style between the VanReijn s (old school rich, buttoned up) vs Mrs. Russell (new money, showy, gaudy)

    • @karlisgama7316
      @karlisgama7316 Před 2 lety +2

      Exactly what Mary West points! And also I feel Marion’s fashions are odd cause the ones picking her styles are her old aunts (or at least, heavily influenciated) when she firsts comes to NY; as the series goes on, she keeps some of this dresses and starts having her own point of view of her style; her charachter develops and is shown in the way she dresses.
      Greetings from México.

  • @MizzMaree7
    @MizzMaree7 Před 2 lety +53

    I was so disappointed to learn that the actress playing Marion didn't understand corseting and chose to be fitted for her costumes in a tight laced corset instead of using padding as we all have learned is the correct way to get the silhouette.

    • @LadyRebeccaFashions
      @LadyRebeccaFashions  Před 2 lety +37

      Right? Like, duh, don't go into your very first fitting and tell them to tightlace you into your corset. 🤦‍♀️
      I loved that Taissa Farmiga took the opposite route. She said in the podcast that she went and ate a big meal before her first fitting, so then she never had to worry about lacing too tightly after that! 😂

    • @emanonfox1709
      @emanonfox1709 Před 2 lety +12

      just butting in to say... Lousia Jacobson is Meryl Streep's daughter, isn't that crazy?

    • @LadyRebeccaFashions
      @LadyRebeccaFashions  Před 2 lety +5

      @@emanonfox1709 yeah, I hadn't realized that until about midway through the season, when I looked her up!

  • @1953childstar
    @1953childstar Před 2 lety +35

    In my opinion, many of the fabrics used were obviously heavier "drapery fabrics" and trimmings for home furnishings..It made me think of the scene in "Gone With The Wind", where Scarlett made a dress out of her mothers "Poitiers".. I know "realistic period " fabrics are difficult to find… But !!!

  • @kirstenpaff8946
    @kirstenpaff8946 Před 2 lety +61

    I have found the plot of The Gilded Age to be a bit meh. It is pretty predictable and I often feel like little happens during the episodes. Agnes and Peggy are probably the two most interesting characters in terms of personality and in Peggy's case plot.
    The costumes and sets are really fun though. I agree that the costumes aren't always strictly accurate, but they do generally capture the more is more mentality of the time. I also think the show has avoided some of the standard period drama costuming pitfalls. The actresses are corseted, but it isn't turned into a big deal (no scene of Agnes forcing Marian to wear a corset to show how Marian is being oppressed). The ladies wear hats when out and about. Granted, it helps that the hats of the era don't cover the ladies' faces, so the old we must see the actors' faces at all times rule doesn't come into play here the way it does in earlier bonnet eras. The hairstyles are not blatantly modernized. Gladys is the only one wearing the half-up half-down look that so many shows use for "old timey" hair, and for her it actually makes sense, because it is a way to show how she is still being treated like a child by her mother. All of the other ladies, including young women the audience is supposed to relate to like Marian and Peggy, wear their hair up.

    • @kathrynabbott5032
      @kathrynabbott5032 Před 2 lety +2

      I agree, I much prefer the cosiness of Downton Abbey.

    • @saungaye9717
      @saungaye9717 Před 2 lety +6

      Then watch Bridgerton and come back here again 😀. Nothing but catching husbands stuffs.

    • @starshinedragonsong3045
      @starshinedragonsong3045 Před 2 lety +2

      As far as the acting and the writing goes I've been calling it The Gilded Dreck. My husband loves to watch it so he can see me cringe at the appallingly predicable, rushed story lines, the stiff and emotionless acting, and pathetic dialog. Such a talented cast to be wasted on such absolute drivel!
      The clothes are good to look at, but they wear them like costumes rather than clothing.

    • @1953childstar
      @1953childstar Před 2 lety

      Once a young woman "comes out" she may wear her hair up...

    • @jojomakes
      @jojomakes Před 5 měsíci +1

      Am I the only one who had no idea that _Marian_ was Meryl Streep's daughter??

  • @cynthiaguest4509
    @cynthiaguest4509 Před 2 lety +7

    It would seem that the fabrics are primarily synthetic? And what really tortures me (besides the zipper-like back closures and machine made embellishments) is the clunky draping which would have been better in real silk. I realize that to have so many costumes made my hand would be impossible but it really shows in the finishing. Still fun to watch! Just an aside, I had an elderly aunt who was a teenager in the Edwardian era. She said that her governess would tie her arms to the bed posts when they had a pre-dance nap so that the lack of blood would make them paler.

  • @nicolemarkham1145
    @nicolemarkham1145 Před 2 lety +11

    I don’t have HBO so I haven’t been able to watch the first season yet. However, I am the curator at the International Tennis Hall of Fame and at work the days they used our property for filming the tennis scenes. Seeing the wide variety of costumed actors and extras in person was awesome.

  • @tiredoftrolls2629
    @tiredoftrolls2629 Před 2 lety +34

    I saw that Marian (sorry, haven't seen the series yet so may have the names wrong) had wardrobe tightlace her at the beginning as she wanted a smaller waist. After awhile, she asked wardrobe to loosen the laces and let out the seams of the costumes. That might explain why sometimes she looks better than others, they were before the alterations.

  • @sabrinabaskerville
    @sabrinabaskerville Před rokem +7

    I love Berthas costumes. It feels like they’re showing how she’s outside of the norm but also ahead of her time.

    • @joeyree22
      @joeyree22 Před 9 měsíci

      Actually, she is dresses more in the French style, compared to the English fashion of the time; not a crazy kookie style as indicated in the commentary. The show chose the obvious difference in style/fashion to help her stand out, and indicate that “new money”. It’s a good choice, as it is more likely the “new money” would lean into the more flamboyant French style, over the “standard/boring” English “old money” style/fashion. I’m surprised this wasn’t mentioned.

    • @sabrinabaskerville
      @sabrinabaskerville Před 9 měsíci

      @@joeyree22 right it is more French. That’s why I said she was ahead of her time, because pretty soon after this, French fashions/culture would start to become “en vogue”. I think the most important thing to point out was that it was an obvious difference from the rest of the cast.

  • @studious_nonchalance
    @studious_nonchalance Před 2 lety +11

    I am absolutely in love with this show. I get sad at the end of every Guilded Age episode because I am not ready for it to be over!

  • @tinamvin5359
    @tinamvin5359 Před 2 lety +2

    Peggy’s red plaid look was my favorite of the entire season!

  • @davidrutter9786
    @davidrutter9786 Před 2 lety +7

    Great commentary on historical accuracy. I like the fact that some ensembles were replicas of period fashions. Mrs. Russell was always so obviously overdressed especially with low cut bodices & shiny silks & satins. Aunt Agnes, Aunt Ada & Peggy Scott really looked the most historically correct. Aurora Fain also always "showed her bosom b4 3 o'clock". The rear closure on bodices was a great observation for day wear when this style was only used for evening wear. Also very few bonnet style hats were designed.

  • @michellecornum5856
    @michellecornum5856 Před 2 lety +13

    I love how you ran down each character, and their clothes. I especially love how you went through the actual fashion plates by month. I was interested when I saw the trailers. I am VERY intrigued now.

  • @lilykatmoon4508
    @lilykatmoon4508 Před rokem +6

    I loved this show and can’t wait for season two. I’m really appreciative for this video bc I was wondering how accurate they were. Peggy’s wardrobe was my favorite and when I saw all the plaid, I was wondering if all that wonderful mess was accurate. Sooo psyched that it was.

  • @infamoussphere7228
    @infamoussphere7228 Před 2 lety +29

    I was so glad to see this video! I've been pretty thrown watching The Gilded Age because some characters look accurately dressed (like the aunts, and Peggy and her parents) and some look COMPLETELY off. I think with Marion, they've made the choice to dress her in a way that they think will appeal more to modern audiences, and so it doesn't quite work. She wears these weird dresses that look almost like a 1950s pinafore/jumper dress, with a blouse underneath, and the sleeves of the blouse are too tight for what I would expect for a blouse (plus I think blouses without jackets are more of an Edwardian thing? Certainly not with those narrow sleeves.) I've never seen pinafores for the 1880s. And Bertha's outfits are just plain weird, and not in the "the 1880s was weird" way, more like a kind of 1950s dior imagining of what an 1880s outfit would look like. I think what frustrates me is this idea that we won't relate to the main character unless she's dressed in less alienating "weird" clothing, and that we won't know that Mrs Russell is tacky unless she's dressed like someone from Panem in Hunger Games.

    • @AlexaFaie
      @AlexaFaie Před 2 lety +3

      Pinafores were a thing for the 1880s, but mainly for kids. Like you'd see them worn by schoolgirls. I've not seen the show yet as its not available here yet but if that character is a younger woman, perhaps it was a conscious attempt to make her seem younger than her years? And aside from that they turn up more in working class/farm worker attire. In both cases they were worn to protect the clothes worn under.

  • @onegirlarmy4401
    @onegirlarmy4401 Před 2 lety +11

    I've been in love with New York during the Gilded Age since Newsies (haha). I'm so excited to see this show touching on many of the technological and cultural changes of the time. Things like the Statue of Liberty hand and the coming of electric lights. Hopefully, they'll continue to show more layers of the Gilded Age beyond the household servants. I'd love to hear you talk more about this show!

  • @vanessadalpiaz6423
    @vanessadalpiaz6423 Před 2 lety +15

    My mom and I have been watching the guilder age together and are loving it. I’ve been waiting for a video from one of my historical fashion you tubers on this so I’m so excited you’re covering it! Also love that you got to talk with the costume maker that is super cool!

  • @quinnagiebelhaus5704
    @quinnagiebelhaus5704 Před 2 lety +15

    Perhaps Mrs Russell.s embellishments we’re to distract from the actress’s pregnancy? That could explain some design choices as well. Also the kitchen maid’s dress is very realistic. While the upper classes were concerned with fashion and following trends the working class made do with hand me downs and couldn’t afford to discard a dress just because it wasn’t in style.

  • @krystynarohde9005
    @krystynarohde9005 Před 2 lety +3

    Thank goodness someone else loves this show!! I stumbled upon it and am OBSESSED

  • @alexandrumugurelcicu1238
    @alexandrumugurelcicu1238 Před 2 lety +1

    Would love to see an episode dedicated to Bridgerton as I believe is a lot of material to talk about it. This episode is fantastic! Love your dedication and how well documented you are!

  • @camspks
    @camspks Před rokem

    My absolute favourites are the yellow dress Marian wears to the Russell soiree and the apple-green dress with the deep red accessories she wears to Gladys' debut. And I also love the baroque interiors of the Russel house! The programme is a visual treat to be sure. 😀👏👍

  • @RussellGrayson3340
    @RussellGrayson3340 Před 2 lety +1

    I ADORE Bertha’s costumes!! I love every single outfit more than the last! I’d even dare say she’s the best dressed woman in television history! ❤️

  • @nothingworksworks3511
    @nothingworksworks3511 Před 6 měsíci

    Some gowns look like a textile hoarder all glued together. Thanks for acknowledging the "kooky"

  • @melissa16melz
    @melissa16melz Před 2 lety

    I was sooo excited about the gilded age series. It's one of the most intriguing ages to me. You are so knowledgeable and I shall enjoy watching the remainder of the season with a more tuned eye after this video. Thank you!

  • @lindakrol5376
    @lindakrol5376 Před 2 lety +2

    I love the show and the costumes-Your pictures of the original fashion plates were the best-

  • @wendywhitley4611
    @wendywhitley4611 Před 2 lety +4

    I enjoy the look of the show. I think dressing Mrs Russell "futuristically" is a not so subtle nod to leaving the old ways. And, goodness anything had to be better than Bridgerton season 1.

  • @diannes3804
    @diannes3804 Před 2 lety

    Thank you for such a wonderful and informative video! I love this show, and love the costumes, so seeing them compared to actual pictures from the period was really interesting.

  • @sweetlorikeet
    @sweetlorikeet Před rokem +1

    I really, really want to see if Gladys will start wearing her hair up in season 2 now that she's finally out! Although if she does get a more age-appropriate wardrobe it'll be a bit of a shame, I actually love her pastel doll outfits haha.
    I KNOW that we will never get period-accurate makeup on a network like HBO but gosh some scenes were excessive even by those standards.

  • @karonyful
    @karonyful Před 2 lety

    Such fun video! Love your enthusiasm and the wealth of knowledge :) I just binged the gilded age and was totally smitten with the costumes. I'm quite happy that I noticed some of the points you mentioned, like Mrs. Russel's new money designs, but your analysis put things in much more context :) I think the costume designer and the makers done a fabulous job

  • @bekytg9393
    @bekytg9393 Před 2 lety +6

    Great video. Thank you so much for showing the plates for each month. That was very cool and informative. That would be great to do for another video for 1890s.

  • @lailadawn8122
    @lailadawn8122 Před 2 lety

    I absolutely love The Gilded Age! You have such a good eye. This video was so fun and informative. Thank you for another great vid, Lady Rebecca!

  • @digitaldgirl4459
    @digitaldgirl4459 Před 2 lety +3

    I am so glad that you did this video. I am in love with the rich detail of the costumes on the show. Peggy's Red and Plaid dress that you showed first is one of my very favorite ensembles. I noticed how yellow seems to be Marion's primary color in the beginning seeming to represent her naivete and youth. Her ill fitting ones probably were supposed to be dresses quickly altered for her until more suitable gowns could be custom made. I could very much see that Bertha was keeping Gladys in much younger styles to maintain that very youthful China doll look. I've always thought her hair was just awful. Mrs. Russell's wardrobe is so over the top, but got to love that Peacock ensemble and her opera cloak. I agree with all of your assessments of the other female characters. Nice job and looking forward to making some of the one's there were reproductions of fashion plates for myself.

  • @jukukwakuattionu5080
    @jukukwakuattionu5080 Před 2 lety

    That green and emerald combination >>>>>>>

  • @whitalleys5893
    @whitalleys5893 Před 2 lety

    This show was super fun, and I am so glad you did an analysis of the costumes! I really like the costumes, even when sometimes they feel weird and out of place. Everything seems to be a conscientious choice and makes the wardrobe feel like another character in the show. Thanks so much!

  • @elewysoffinchingefeld3066

    The one thing that I think that emphasizes the ill fit of some of the costumes is the lack of padding. There seems to be a lot of boob-wrinkle issues going on that could easily be remedied with just a bit of padding to smooth that out. The old-money/new-money costumes are really obvious and clearly a design choice, which is a thing I still have a hard time coming to terms with, but I grit my teeth and just try to enjoy it for what it is. The hair not being dressed up on Blanche is also driving me crazy! The scenes that my friend and I enjoyed the most was at the charity auction where a lot of the extras in the background had some really stunning ensembles! There was one particular red and white number that we were really impressed with! Thanks for sharing this video! I really enjoyed your expert take on the 1880s clothing!

    • @JK-sh8rc
      @JK-sh8rc Před 2 lety +1

      Who is Blanche? Do you mean Gladys? I'm not a hair style expert but I think she wore her hair down to signify that she wasn't officially "out" in society yet. Now that she is, I'm sure her hair will now be always be up.

  • @SewSewDrew
    @SewSewDrew Před 2 lety +2

    I love this show! I had been waiting on someone to do this video & you did a great job!

  • @user-wi2vn7cu4w
    @user-wi2vn7cu4w Před 2 lety +2

    I`m in love with dresses in The Gilded age. The fabrics are so delicate and beautiful.

  • @randeman
    @randeman Před rokem

    One of the things I noticed was during the ball at the end of the season. Based on what I have read (and it's a good amount), the women at the balls of that era wore an insane amount of incredibly valuable jewelry at these events. Some of it once owned by royalty in France as well as the UK. Mrs. Astor was once described as looking like a walking chandelier. These women wore the equivalent today of millions of dollars in gems at every ball they attended. Although there was jewelry worn at this ball, it wasn't anywhere near what was described books like, "What would Mrs. Astor Do?" and "The Court of Mrs. Astor In Gilded Age New York, A Season of Splendor."

  • @Hiker_who_Sews
    @Hiker_who_Sews Před 2 lety +4

    I don't have HBO, but if I did, I'd watch this show.

  • @jilliansmaniotto2326
    @jilliansmaniotto2326 Před rokem

    I think the anachronisms in the costuming are *very clearly* intentional choices meant to distinguish each character among the others and tell a very clear story about their personalities.

  • @suzanmarie5374
    @suzanmarie5374 Před 2 lety +7

    Love this show!! I hope they up their game next season with costuming on some characters.

  • @OldLadyOnTheInternet
    @OldLadyOnTheInternet Před rokem

    The Gilded Age is thrilling and the costumes are scrumptious!

  • @Birdie359
    @Birdie359 Před 2 lety

    The Gilded Age is a wonderful show! I can hardly wait for the next season. This is my favorite era and I have studied the clothing over the years. Like you, those back closures were absolutely glaring and I noticed them immediately. They were disappointing to see; however, having said this, overall I believe the costumes were absolutely stunning. I’ve been dying to see a critique by someone more educated than I and you did not disappoint. I hope you do more of these in the future. In fact, I would love to see you critique the gowns by each show, instead of the entire season. I’d love to delve into some of the specific details of how these gowns were constructed, what specific pieces made up each ensemble, what undergarments would be worn, etc. Specifically, I’d like to know whether the jackets were actually attached to the blouses underneath, or whether they were separate pieces. Many of the gowns worn by our heroine appeared to be one piece, which I questioned, and almost appeared to zip up the back. Thank you for this video! I look forward to seeing many more critiques from you for this show.

  • @AntiqueAgenda
    @AntiqueAgenda Před 2 lety

    I know nothing about period fashion but am so glad I found your channel today!! You obviously are highly educated and passionate in this subject...I am passionate about watching and enjoying these types of shows though!!! Basically I love the fantasy of period storytelling in either print or screen. I am going to check out your other videos...possibly to look for commentary on Bridgerton, Downton, oh and The Nevers.

  • @kiracraft3360
    @kiracraft3360 Před 2 lety +6

    I was literally saying that about the back closures while my friend and I were binging through the series last weekend! I am loving it overall and have some new dream dresses. Hello sailor dress!

    • @evilempryss
      @evilempryss Před 2 lety

      I swear that for a moment I thought that yellow dress of Marian's was a zipper, and I startled my husband with a sharp "WTF! That *better* be hooks and eyes! It's wrong, but at least it wouldn't be a zipper!" 😆

  • @laurenragle5228
    @laurenragle5228 Před 2 lety +1

    Holy back closing day dresses, batman! 🧐😳 I haven't managed to watch it yet, but I was excited about the costuming just from the promos I've seen. Great video! ❤️

  • @kaylal4926
    @kaylal4926 Před 6 měsíci

    Marion's clothes have also thrown me off quite a bit, but I will say, that dark blue dress she wears with the lacy sleeves and the rosette at the collar looks almost exactly like a dress worn by first lady Frances Folsom Cleveland in 1886. So the timing is a a few years off, but it's one of my favorite historical gowns and I was so glad to see it recreated!

  • @ladydetalle1263
    @ladydetalle1263 Před rokem

    I feel much the same about The Gilded Age costumes: great summarization, love it! The jewelry was much the same: some real antiques and some great accuracy in the Van Rijn household, and then some 1950's surprises for Bertha Russell, lol. I'm sure they had some real budget constraints for Season 1, and made similar design style character choices as the costumes. I'm hoping to see more gorgeous jewelry in Season 2, including hopefully more of my designs, lol. Great video, loved it!

    • @LadyRebeccaFashions
      @LadyRebeccaFashions  Před rokem

      I love that they used some of your jewelry on season 1! Do you know if they bought your stuff for season 2, too?

  • @emanonfox1709
    @emanonfox1709 Před 2 lety +3

    the season finale had the BEST costumes of the entire season! Each actress has 4-5 costume changes throughout the episode PLUS it culminated in a ball. PERFECTION!

    • @LadyRebeccaFashions
      @LadyRebeccaFashions  Před 2 lety +1

      I loved that episode so much!

    • @petat13
      @petat13 Před 2 lety

      I was puzzled by the ball gown Mrs Russell wore…thoughts?

    • @LadyRebeccaFashions
      @LadyRebeccaFashions  Před 2 lety +1

      @@petat13 it's actually based on a Worth gown!

    • @petat13
      @petat13 Před 2 lety

      @@LadyRebeccaFashions Thank you for answering. It’s nice to know it was modelled on something real. Loved this video ❤️

    • @emanonfox1709
      @emanonfox1709 Před 2 lety +1

      @@petat13 at the ball? It was very strange, I agree, with the cutouts poking over the neckline and the odd colored tulle. The black and white pattern was beautiful from the back though, and probably as bold as she intended it to be. "Look at me, I'm the future." Her outfits always have a little anarchronistic twist, at first it bothered me but then I realized it fits the character.

  • @9493time
    @9493time Před 2 lety

    I luv your video analysis. This was just what I was looking for after watching the show,

  • @amyc-puppymom1348
    @amyc-puppymom1348 Před 2 lety +1

    I agree that the costumes are absolutely outstanding. I find myself rewatching episodes not for the story but to look at the costumes again.

  • @loo762
    @loo762 Před 2 lety

    I loved the series. Im a big history, drama, and historical dress buff. The storyline and explanation at the end of each episode was great.

  • @nonazierler5391
    @nonazierler5391 Před 2 lety

    Love this! I binge watched the entire season based off your video. I do get the distraction of the back closures 😉😂 but honestly what a great show. Thanks

  • @melissamybubbles6139
    @melissamybubbles6139 Před 2 lety

    So often a historical show comes out and I don't have access to its host streaming service. Hopefully I'll get to see this one soon. Thank you. So many of their dresses were lovely.

  • @petapendlebury9024
    @petapendlebury9024 Před 2 lety +3

    Such timing! About to go and do a bustle making workshop this weekend! .....I had no plans for making a dress but that blue and white striped one.......💙💙💙💙💙💙💙

  • @welcometoamerica690
    @welcometoamerica690 Před rokem

    Unrelated to the topic of this video, I would like to say that you have a very positive energy and I loved hearing you speak.

  • @eschaefer6512
    @eschaefer6512 Před 2 lety +1

    I enjoyed your explaining the finer details on these fashion. The dresses are amazing and beautiful. I find Mrs. Russell's the oddest though. Peggy Scott's are lovely. Marion's delightful. My favorite was the cape that Mrs. Van Ryin wore to the bazaar with the beaded fringe. It's admirable that the looks were more or less faithful to the time. One has to remember that in real life these clothes would have been custom made and influenced by each person's preferences maybe even altering a previous look to update an already worn outfit.

  • @jenniferstone2567
    @jenniferstone2567 Před 2 lety +2

    I've not watched yet, but now I'm definitely going to start. These gowns are gorgeous.

  • @georgesofield4596
    @georgesofield4596 Před 2 lety

    Fascinating critique!!!

  • @knowitnone
    @knowitnone Před 2 lety +1

    17:10 shows what’s off about Marion’s costumes as well, ie the silhouette. The actress (both Marion and Gladys) is very slim, which makes her looks come across as quite “modern”. Slimmer women obviously existed back then as well, but you’d think she would have padded her bust and hips for a more contemporary/fashionable silhouette (like in the painting).

  • @Concepcion30
    @Concepcion30 Před 2 lety +1

    I just finished binging the whole season. And when you watch the episodes back to back, you notice repeated outfits.
    Mrs. Russell repeated the least by far. You could tell that a good chunk of the wardrobe budget went to her attire. It in turn short changed side characters like Peggy's mom, who despite also being wealthy seemed to wear the same green dress in her episodes.
    Overall, seeing the various fashions was part of the highlight of my enjoyment of this show.

  • @leighcraig1091
    @leighcraig1091 Před 2 lety

    Presentation very well done, interesting and educational. Hv not watched the show, but when I do, I’ll know what to look for. Thank you.

  • @seanmcgcostumes
    @seanmcgcostumes Před 2 lety

    I am absolutely adoring this show! (And I loooove the official podcast.) I think one of my favorite aspects was just how well the costumers used visual cues in almost every. single. costume. and it's astounding.

  • @lisafriloux1713
    @lisafriloux1713 Před 2 lety

    OMG! yes when I first saw Mrs.Russel in some of the dresses all I could think of was Carol Burnett in the Went with the wind episode LOL Just saw it in the window and couldn't resist it!

  • @Aldisia
    @Aldisia Před 2 lety +1

    Can't remember last show series that i obsessed over, but this one has my full attention. The ball gowns were divine😘😘 So loving Peggy's wardrobe 💖

  • @QueenCityHistory
    @QueenCityHistory Před 2 lety

    Gladys couldn't put her hair up until her coming out. That's why the last shot of her is with her hair up. The old saying was at 16 the hair went up and the hems went down.

  • @tanyatrotter7179
    @tanyatrotter7179 Před rokem

    Love your comments, fascinated with the era.

  • @cak813
    @cak813 Před 11 měsíci

    I loved ”The Gilded Age”!! I’m glad I ignored some of the advanced press which was quite critical of the show. I loved the show from the very first episode. Too many people were comparing the show to “Downton Abbey” which, to me, was like comparing apples and oranges. Different eras, different continents, and totally different characters. I even bought the DVD of the series because I liked it so much. I hope in time that a companion book to the series will be done similar to the ones that were done for “Downton Abbey”. Looking forward to seeing Season 2!!

  • @dalemoore8582
    @dalemoore8582 Před 2 lety

    I loved everything about this show, the characters , the set decorations, the costumes. This show was wonderful! Can't wait until next season!

  • @debbybolen
    @debbybolen Před 2 lety

    yes indeed very enjoyable and entertaining. great video. really enjoyed it.

  • @ginger1549
    @ginger1549 Před 2 lety

    I think the costume designers did a good job of relating the costume designs to their character's personality.

  • @MildredCady
    @MildredCady Před 2 lety +2

    Some of that show was filmed in my old stomping grounds, Troy, NY.

  • @MadameX_
    @MadameX_ Před 2 lety

    Love the series! Costumes are fab. Was fun to see the art historical references for them. ❣️

  • @lalagonegaga
    @lalagonegaga Před 2 lety +5

    Mrs Astor would exclude you from society based on the historically inaccurate amount of makeup your wearing (JK, of course, you look gorgeous).
    I think what Mrs Chamberlain is wearing is what Bertha SHOULD be wearing if she wanted to appear more classy / civilized / French. Mrs Chamberlain = a few carefully positioned feathers. Bertha = a dead bird on her head. You get the gist.
    The color harmonies of all of Peggy's outfits make me happy.
    Turner is a fashion queen.

  • @brandyloutherback9288
    @brandyloutherback9288 Před 2 lety +1

    I'd say some of the costumes are all over the map of the 1880s. Nothing is really consistent. I love the bickering between Agnes and her son Oscar. It's delightful!

  • @elenamonti8385
    @elenamonti8385 Před 2 lety

    lovely video! so interesting. I wish you had one on Downton Abbey costumes too…

  • @darlenesee2561
    @darlenesee2561 Před 2 lety +1

    i love Bertha's clothing !!

  • @Mrs_Homemaker
    @Mrs_Homemaker Před 2 lety

    I'm so excited to hear someone talk about these costumes. I love them but don't have any professional experience with "is this good or historical"

  • @midnightblack07
    @midnightblack07 Před 2 lety +1

    I'm loving this show! The costumes and set are stunning, and I am both excited and saddened by the fact that the season finale is this Monday. Glad to know we are getting a second season though.

  • @jessieborrell1856
    @jessieborrell1856 Před 2 lety

    I totally agree about Mrs. Russells costumes! lol the blue/silver 'space age' dress you mentioned was the one that made me tilt my head a lot and ask "huh?" haha. I wasn't bothered by Marianne's dresses but I think the points you brought up are definitely valid

  • @Keychain696
    @Keychain696 Před rokem

    Great video! One aspect of the costumes that I've been curious about is whether womens' sleeves in 1882 (or a few years before) would have had slight puffs at the top of them. The character with the biggest puffs wad actually Mrs. Chamberlin and it looked way, way more late 1880s/1890s to me, but I'm not 100% sure they weren't a thing before them too!

    • @LadyRebeccaFashions
      @LadyRebeccaFashions  Před rokem +1

      Thanks! Day sleeves in 1882 were almost always fitted. Occasionally, you'll see some looks that are kind of Renaissance-inspired that will have puffs (usually pretty small puffs), but they weren't very common. A lot of Mrs Chamberlain's costumes definitely lean much more 1890s than 1880s.

  • @joiedevivre2005
    @joiedevivre2005 Před 2 lety +1

    I think Marian's clothing, at least at the beginning, are "hand-me-downs", maybe even from her aunts until more "appropriate" items could be made for her. This is probably why they seem a little outdated & don't fit as well. As for Bertha, I think they are trying to establish that she is "new money" by making her outfits flashy & a little gaudy. She has the money and is trying every new trend, to find her own style which is why I think her fashion is all over the place.

  • @donnaleach8119
    @donnaleach8119 Před 2 lety

    I just found you. Love this video and love ‘The Gilded Age’! I could handle ANY historical inaccuracies in the show if I never had to see another silly ‘Marion Hat’! I despise them! 😉😂

  • @johnmills34YT
    @johnmills34YT Před 2 lety

    i've been watching the gilded age since ep 1 and love it! so glad its been renewed.

  • @outsideofenough6466
    @outsideofenough6466 Před 10 měsíci

    I just started watching this show, and I couldn’t agree with you more about Marian’s clothing. She took Ada with her to the dress maker, who certainly knows how to dress appropriately, so I’m at a loss as to how bad her dresses were. Maybe Ada was too timid to correct Marian’s choices, but that doesn’t make a lot of sense. She knew that Agnes would disapprove. Yet Agnes never said anything about the way Marian dressed, so I guess we’re the only ones who think her dresses were just wrong.
    The clothing and accessories are one of the reasons I love this show. It’s so very well done despite the fashion errors. Everything is just so beautiful. I usually like anything Julian Fellowes does and he didn’t disappoint.

  • @peggyriordan9857
    @peggyriordan9857 Před 2 lety

    I have not yet seen this show. I have noticed several CZcamsrs are talking about the show and after seeing all of the costumes in your video, I really want to see it! Congrats on speaking to the designer!!! That must have been so exciting. How did you track him down? It's also pretty impressive for him to be so open with you which means he was very comfortable in speaking with you about the costumes and why most of the day clothes open in the back instead of the front. Let's hope he does make the necessary adjustments for Season 2. Just think about it....you may have given him the push he needed to get the costuming more on point!! Exciting, very exciting! I thought they were all very pretty even if they were not accurate for the time period for the show. Thank you so much for putting all of this together.

    • @LadyRebeccaFashions
      @LadyRebeccaFashions  Před 2 lety

      He is actually one of the costume makers, not the designer, but I follow him on Instagram and he was nice enough to return my messages, so that was really cool!

    • @peggyriordan9857
      @peggyriordan9857 Před 2 lety

      @@LadyRebeccaFashions Very cool!

  • @AlvaroIbacacheS
    @AlvaroIbacacheS Před 2 lety

    I love your video, you are so sweet and informative. Not to complain but a love of historical costumer CZcamsrs are so derogatory and with a “I’m better than this” attitude, it’s so cool to see someone different.

  • @MarquisdeL3
    @MarquisdeL3 Před 2 lety

    I live near Troy, NY, where they filmed some of the street scenes. The set dressing they did to cover up the modern shopfronts was absolutely incredible! It really made the old buildings shine. I'm hoping they'll come back to film parts of season 2.

    • @LadyRebeccaFashions
      @LadyRebeccaFashions  Před 2 lety +1

      I think they're headed back that way this summer. I'm jealous that you got to see it!

  • @manuferguson6564
    @manuferguson6564 Před 2 lety +1

    Agnes is my favorite too, followed by Ada

  • @debbiekp6636
    @debbiekp6636 Před 2 lety +1

    Love the Gilded Age and the costumes are beautiful. So glad that it is renewed….hated that the first season is over :(

  • @camspks
    @camspks Před rokem

    Charming and enjoyable video. Thanks 👏👍. I didn't notice the fastening at the back of day dresses! Next time - I'll look out for that.
    I think Marian may look a "bit off" because she's more Edwardian in style - slim skirts, working woman silhouette. But I do think she looks nice! And I love her velvet chokers or ribbons round her neck, rather than new money bling-bling jewels! Agree with you that some of Gladys' 1882 dresses are straight out of the 1600s & 1700s, rather than being inspired by those times.
    I reallllllly enjoyed seeing the costumes being discussed in the category of wearer/character. Yes, I can't wait for season two either!
    What does everyone think of the dance scenes. I watched Scorsese's 'Age of Innocence' after this and thought the men did a better job here, in The Gilded Age; stronger arms, more definite movements. Looking forward to your next video 😀.

  • @aw62875
    @aw62875 Před 10 měsíci

    The chamberlain costume was artistic foreshadowing. Like a raven or crow in and Edgar Poe she brings bad news, death, etc. Russell was based on Alva who was new money and had the idea of "why save the best for last, I might lose it all again tomorrow (like her father did after the Civil war) so she always wore her best outfits no matter the occasion hence the evening gowns during th3 day. Also jts because even tho she tries, she's new money, and doesn't know that it's inappropriate to qwae certain fits during the day. Just like she calls on Mrs. Astor not realizing the rules are u don't call on someone higher ranked. U wait for them to call on you

  • @margarita8442
    @margarita8442 Před rokem

    One of the vanderbuilts had what was called a " cottage" at Rhode Island -- only 70 staff !!