Buying & Testing a CHEAP Fly Rod!
Vložit
- čas přidán 30. 10. 2019
- How well can a cheap fly rod work? I ran across a bargain fly rod last summer and tested it at Roaring River State Park near Cassville, Missouri. For about $40 I got a rod, reel, backing, fly line, leader, rod case, reel case, and fly box. The results were...interesting.
Fly Shop:
www.etsy.com/shop/TheShowMeFl...
Blog:
showmeflyguy.blogspot.com/
I''ve been using a 10 foot, 4 wt MaxCatch Euro Nymphing rod for the past year, and caught hundreds of fish with it last summer (2020) during the pandemic in Montana. Looks good, built well, and works just as well as my old Fenwick. Gotta love it.
That's awesome! If you were able to get it cheap, even better!
Great, you got me very interested in your comment. Which Maxcatch rod did you use for euro nympfing? Thanks.
Metal and Fly Fishing should be mainstream...kudos to you for being original. Thou hast earned my subscription with in a minute, that and I freaking love Roaring River.
I’m glad we see eye to eye! Thanks for the kind words and I’ll send some more metal your way! Any requests?
Fun vid. And thanks for the review. It's encouraging since i just got the maxcatch, 9ft 5/6wt. Hoping to take a bash at fly fishing.
Nice rise @ 4:51, Cheap rods are underrated... unless you're getting a handmade bamboo rod (because they are more art than function), or 18 weight salt water rods (for going after manatees and basking shark), you don't need a really expensive fly rod. But seriously as junk as the fly line likely is, that's a hell of a value for a serviceable reel, rod, flybox, rod case and reel case. I've seen basic rod cases cost > $150 for "cheap" options.
Thank you for the kind words and input. I could not agree with you more about cost. Thanks for watching for adding your thoughts. Both are greatly appreciated.
I enjoyed the video, I've always been wary of cheap fly equipment
Question, I live in the KCMO area and am wondering if you fish the stocked trout ponds in winter. How do you do it, assuming you do, and where can I find out when the ponds are stocked cause the hotline doesn't seem to work (as of a few minutes ago)?
Thank you for the kind words and hopefully I can help. Funny you should ask about fishing stocked trout ponds in winter because I actually made a video about that about a year ago. As far as finding out when they are stocked, I tried the hotline too and it hasn't worked. I try to post on my blog when I find out that they have been stocked so if you want to check that out, it might be helpful. Here are a couple of links:
Video- czcams.com/video/_mDBeDEUctE/video.html
Blog- showmeflyguy.blogspot.com/
That is not a bad deal at all. Considering fish were caught even better yet. Been looking into fly fishing.... Man can it get pricey. Thinking my best bet is to get a inexpensive kit like this before really investing money into it. Thanks for sharing.
7:50 lol that fence I remember that me and my dad got in trouble for going under it. Meanwhile for three hours at least 15 people were going in and out of that area
*I like the feel of the reel **enjoyable.fishing** recommend in my hand and the weight is just right for my rod. The drag settings took some time to set correctly but work well. Great looking reel!**I like the feel of the reel **enjoyable.fishing** recommend in my hand and the weight is just right for my rod. The drag settings took some time to set correctly but work well. Great looking reel!*
Great fun video and good review. Thanks from the U.K. 👍😀
Thank you! I always appreciate a kind word!
Where did you get this at for the price of $40
Love the amity police patch !!!! Jaws is the greatest movie of all time!
Most people don't catch that and I agree that it is the greatest movie of all time. I have a Jaws poster hanging up above my fly tying desk!
just stumbled upon this vid. nice catch n release. been 20 years since I have used my fly rod. I am inspired to dust it off! Sub'd
a cheap fly rod will work just fine. If someone tells you different is trying to sell you something. Sure a more expensive fly rod may be better all around, but any rod/reel will do for most applications
I agree! I think in a lot of instances, you get what you pay for but there ARE diamonds in the rough out there!
when you fly fish with that sag# $700 rod or any other fly rod.. who is that trying to impress??? the fish ...only sees the ....fly.... other than that,, you are just trying to impress some other person... i like to catch fish.. really dont need to impress someone on what fly rod i am useing
@@randellgribben9772 In the HiFi stereo world they use the term "diminishing returns" to describe what you get depending on how much you spend on stereo upgrades. For example, the difference in sound quality when you go form $50 speakers to $500 speakers is instantly heard. The difference between $500 speakers and $2000 speakers is subtle, most people wouldn't notice. The difference between $2000 speakers and $10000 speakers is so small they have to use equipment to compare frequencies. I feel it's the same with everything, fishing gear for sure. I've found the more expensive rods usually have a better feel, maybe a little smoother casting, etc, but I don't know where the line is. I have mostly $50-$100 rods, same with my reels. I would rather spend my money on multiple rods for specific purposes than break the bank on a rod that is great for one thing but not so great for other things. If that makes any sense.
Liked and Subscribed.
Question:
What is that which appears like a tag on the back of your vest at shoulder level?
Thank you for both! It is a plastic case for the daily tag that must be purchased each day at the trout park I was fishing at. Trout parks in Missouri (there are 4 of them) cost $4 per day to fish there and it is a heck of a good bargain.
Nice! What were they biting at roaring? Thanks for making this video. Cargo largo has some killer deals.
Just about the only thing I use is a small white jig under an indicator or a griffith's gnat if they are rising. Thank you for the kind words by the way. They are always appreciated.
i love the rls+ 5 wt... its my main fly rod and very reliable. in the past 5 trips ive gone fishing ive caught a total of 14 common carp all ranging from 6-12 pounds.
That’s amazing! You should start a CZcams channel! I would like to see that!
Qt cup and Cargo Largo I know this is an independence man. As someone from indep. Myself, do you have any recommendations on places to try as a beginner angler?
Yes!!!! Lake Remembrance in Blue Springs, Legacy Lake, James A Reed, Bass Pro Lake, and Lone Jack lake are good! If you need any more info, email me at ShowMeFlyGuy@gmail.com. I would be happy to help.
Darth Vader patch on a fishing vest... I'm 100% in! Nice video... Interesting rod... I enjoyed it!!! Hello from MA!
Thank you for the kind words and hello from MO! I can't tell you how many people have asked if I am a police officer because of the Amity Police patch. I tell them that I am just a big Sheriff Brody fan and they look at me confused half the time and laugh the other half. The rod has actually become one of my favorites. A stocker trout or 8 inch bluegill will put a bend in that thing!
ive got a maxcatch 1 wieght and also there 3/4 wieght and then both work like a charm love them.
You have a 3/4 weight?!?! I've never even heard of such a thing but it sounds AWESOME!!!!
Kick asz hat bud. Enjoyed your movie as well.
Thank you very much for the kind words and for watching!
What net
Setup is that? Magnet?
That was the clearest review on the Maxcatch I've found. Thank you! Looking for a backup rod for hiking in and am planning to get something cheap like this. Thank you!
That's great and thank you so much for the kind words! It's nice when social media makes a positive difference. I would definitely buy this rod again and I often carry it as a backup rod. Hiking and fishing in the mountains would be a great application for this setup (I assume)! Again, thanks for the view and the kind words.
Came for the fishing.... Subscribed cause of your humour.
Have you fly fished Australia or Nu Zilund for trout?
The Ranga Pirate thank you so much! No, I have never been but would love to!
Too funny, great video!!
i have a 9 foot 6 weight max catch fly rod.. use it for shad this time of year on the american river.....past 4 evenings sundown to 845.. ave. of 15 hook ups, and 8 to the net.....,, it takes the shad 2 to 5 pounds well, and shad are VERY strong swimmers.. they hit your fly and they dont give up,, close to the net.. and they swing to the bottom of the river.. takes a while to take them to net.. rod still looks like new..
Definitely a best buy
Did I miss the casting part? I saw the bobber lob, but not really casting with false casting, etc., ...
Thanks for the video!
To be honest, on the small body of water that I was fishing, a lob was about all it took. I should have thrown some dries and streamers on bigger water. The way it plays fish is outstanding though!!!! Thanks for watching. PS- my cast isn’t much to look at anyway!😂
I see what you did there…nice TLC reference.
Just got back from roaring river and got into fly fishing. I am ordering a Maxcatch outfit do you think that this outfit would be a very good beginner/intermediate combo for me to use while I get better at fly casting?
Absolutely! This is a great outfit to get started. When you get chances, cast as many rods as possible to see what you like and don’t like. I like 9 footers but dislike 7 and 1/2 footers. I LOVE graphite rods and HATE fiberglass rods but that only can from experiences.
@@TheShowMeFlyGuy I used a 9 foot rod and thought it was just a little long so I switched to a 8 and a half and I think it will be perfect for what I am doing.
@@southerncastin2552 that’s great. Finding a length you are comfortable with is really important. I just got a 10 foot 4 weight and I’m nervous about whether I will like it or not. I’ve never owned one before so we will see.
@@TheShowMeFlyGuy its whatever you enjoy to throw. Since I don't nymph that much I don't need a long rod. Once I go out of state then I can get nymphing rods but for now I only need a rod that will throw and work dries and streamers and its working out so far. Thanks for responding to my comments.
I believe I would’ve gone back and bought 4 or 5 more of those kits…That was an incredible deal…
Looking back, I wish I would have!
I bought the FairPlay combo for fifty bucks to compare to my orvis and sage and I have to say it is not bad it is perfect for a backup rod or for a loaner for beginners.
It is ALWAYS a good idea to have a backup and loaner! Great call. Those cheaper combos can save fishing trips!
this was a really good MOVIE!!!!
Thank you very much! I appreciate the kind words!
I have that rod I got it off of Amazon for $80 same thing with all the stuff that comes with it and I have to say I will take it over a $200 TFO 9' 5 weight any day it is in my opinion a fantastic beginners combo I've had it i believe for at least a year and a 1/2 to 2 years now and it is still running strong no maintenance on it my size is 3/4 I'm going to type down the prices for everyone this is off of Amazon
3w 8'4 4pc Rod 3/4 reel $79.99
5w 9'0 4pc Rod 5/6 reel $84.99
8w 9'0 4pc Rod 7/8 reel $89.99
There is the prices of the ones I have found on Amazon
@Jacob Davis It's a nice little rod it's handled a 2 pound trout and it's handled a 10 pound channel cat wasn't going after the catfish but it worked it on 5X tippit and drug him through some weeds little 3 weight did well
I bought the ultra lite 3wt a year ago from their website with 20% off for 27€. It was dirt cheap and i like the rod very much, it did the start for me. This year been to czech republic and i was a glad i did take it with me. Euronymphing was no problem and i caught 26 trout and 3 grayling! I am hoping for another sale so that i can finally get myself the nano nymph😁
Nice
Pretty jealous. Love a good sale.
Same here! Finding inexpensive fly fishing equipment isn’t easy!
I wouldn't normally consider fishing a 3 weight but this seems like a nice cheap way to experiment.
For smaller trout, bass, and bluegill, it is a blast! I would NOT use this when targeting fishing bigger than 13 or 14 inches! And you’re right, you’re not out much money if you don’t like it.
I love cargo largo!
Dakota Davis me too! It’s a little odd but you can find some amazing deals!
Brands makes us think that normal price is way more expensive. Huge money margin I bet.
Did you use the flies provided with the set?
Thanks for the review btw.
Pika Tchoum agreed. I never did because they were mainly western trout flies and I just don’t have a need for them. They didn’t look that great either. Thanks for watching and commenting!
it's actually not, high end graphite is expensive. it's just that past $50 worth of graphite or glass construction, you get rapidly diminishing returns.
For $35 I would have bought 2. Cool video.
I almost did! I have a buddy that bought 3! Thanks for the kind words.
Here's the thing that $50 flyrod combo for me might be the most expensive setup I can afford. Now someone else might be able to afford $1000 setup that's the best that they can afford...but is that $1000 setup really better? Will it catch me more fish? I highly doubt it. I've proven it over the last couple months...I think you're going to raise your skill level to match the quality of your equipment.
I had that same rod reel broke with in two trips out. Got a nice rod and reel combo instead.
That stinks. While I don't care much for the reel, the rod has actually been pretty good for me. Did you see if the company would replace it after it broke?
@@TheShowMeFlyGuy Amazon refunded me and due to covid I could keep the rod and I will get another reel to use with it.
I enjoyed this very much
Thanks for the kind words and thanks for watching!
@@TheShowMeFlyGuy I bought a cheap fly rod / reel combo, came with 15 yards of 1.15mm white running line and 2 tapered leaders. I am ordering a spool of flyline today, do I really need special backing for just perch and panfish here in East Texas? There are no trout rivers, etc, I won’t be saltwater fishing. I was considering 20 lb braid, which I will doubtless never see once it’s on the reel.
@@pastorharrison48 great question! While you don’t necessarily need the backing for big fish that make long runs, it DOES help to fill the spool. By that, I mean that it helps the fly line reach the edge of the spool. I would have at least a little backing just in case you hook a monster while perch fishing. I am a firm believer in the idea of “I would rather have it and not need it, than need it and not have it.” As far as the braid idea, that’s pretty clever. I’ve never heard of anyone doing that but that doesn’t mean it’s wrong! I say go for it. I can mail you some backing if you want though. I have a spool that probably has 30-50 yards left on it and I’ll never use it.
If you hate fish hitting the indicator use a bung float
Great channel content. new subscriber here.
Thank you so much and thanks for subscribing!
that's the slowest moving river ive ever seen
And to think it’s called Roaring River makes it even more comical.
@@TheShowMeFlyGuy haha!
very nice... I would buy it.....Thanks, for making the review!
Gregor Sidler thank you and it was totally worth the money. Sometimes you just stumble on a bargain!
Im using maxcatch products from 2 years ago.
😄 low budget but it actually works
Mine is still performing well too! Finding inexpensive but durable fly fishing equipment is CHALLENGING!
Nice! Anyone know if they still have them?
I wish they still had some because I would have bought another. I think they were all gone by teh end of the day to be honest. Word spread quickly.
On their website you would be able to buy one.
Wow heck of a deal IMO but I'm new to fly fishing.....I wld buy for sure I wld pay 50 or more lol
They're not too bad of fly rods. I have a 5 wt and a 10 wt from maxcatch and they work pretty well. And casting is fairly smooth.
They are $90 now
nice i have thought about buying a reel
I don’t put a lot of money into reels to be honest. I rarely need a good drag system and if I do, I just use my hands on the reel to apply pressure if necessary. I put my money in the rod if I’m going to splurge and even then, there are some great casting rods out there that don’t cost premium prices!
How does it cast?
It feels like a midflex rod and the casting is pretty smooth. It isnt' a fast action tip flex but it isn't a slow, fiberglass rod either. I really like how it casts and would buy another if I broke this one! I hope that helps!
35 Buks is a steel, my fishing line alone costs 50:}
Imagine being one of his students.... first hour was the best last year -Jackson w
$79.99 on amazon now 😢
Man, stumbled accidently into your channel. I was on fly tying. ;-) Got hooked by the djent, what a hammermusic. ;-) So I watched the whole video, because this set is here in Germany also avaible. A friend of mine got it and he was enthusiastic at first, in the long run, the rod was not up to the task. Its usable, at least. There is a reason for the pricetag on Hardy,Grey,Loomis,Vision, Sage or Walton Powell. ;-)
I agree that in many instances, you get what you pay for and if you pay for quality, you usually end up with quality. On the other hand, I have found a few (and I mean few) times where rods of less name notoriety and lower price perform at a similar level as the more expensive rods. You have to look hard, but they are out there.
Haven't heard of cargo largo. Then again been eyeballing the ozark trail combo off and on.
It carries a lot of overstock stuff and you just have no idea what is going to be there!
Not surprised either. I live in Springfield, so it's bass pro, Walmart, or the only hole in the wall bait and fly store.
@@Demolitiondude I’ve heard good things about plateau fly shop in Springfield. Might be worth a look?
Haven't been in there yet. Went to the sister store fin and feather for shenanigans. That one is a nice place.
@@Demolitiondude I'll have to check that out!
nice 😁👍
Thank you!
They go for a hundreds now hahaha (Amazon)
but still very good price XD
You wouldn’t happen to know if they still sell them?
Danny Miller I think hey actually sold out later that day. Word got around really fast!
YES! I hate when you catch a fish and people move in. Or while surf Fishing how you get asked by every single person "catch anything?"
I understand that it is public water but a little respect goes a long way.
4:56 who else saw the fish jump
Good eyes!
That cheap rod u talkin abt is double the price in India coz of shippin 😂😋🙏
Ouch! That stinks!
@@TheShowMeFlyGuy 😊
What’s backing
Great question! That’s the line that connects the fly line to the reel. It helps to fill up the spool and allow a fish to run further than 90 feet which is the usual length of fly line.
Bring it out to the pacific northwest
That would be amazing! I love that place. Spent some time along the Oregon coast and fell in love with that scenery!
If you close your eyes it's Alex Jones doing a fly rod review
I hope that you only mean our voices are similar?!?! If you mean more than that, I'm terrified of myself.
@@TheShowMeFlyGuy Just the voice..lol
well our forefathers did not have carbon fibre yaddie - yaddie - yaddie... they had cane and thin line and caught to eat... we are just too soft nowadays... i still fish a 1960's rod, 1950's reels and my line is 50 years old... and i get from pike to trout... glad this shows a big wallet means nothing if you know how to fish
my reel scrapes whein i reel in
Me too! I thought it was a one off situation. Thanks for sharing.
@@TheShowMeFlyGuy just reached out the company is sending a replacemnt reel!
@@bodefishing8773 that’s awesome! I’ll probably do the same! Thanks for the info!
Think this is worth 100 Canadian?
That’s a tough call! For that amount, I think you are still getting your money’s worth but still temper your enthusiasm. The reel isn’t my favorite but I like the rod and it casts well with the fly line they include. You might look for more reviews online because I am by no means an expert!
Don, I'm Canadian and I own two setups (3/4 and 5/6wt). I paid $109cad and $119 respectively. They're both well worth it and perform flawlessly. NOTE: Make sure the package you're purchasing has the the reel that is machined, very important. The only thing is, I do agree that the rod blanks are a bit stiffer than a higher end comparable rod. That's not a slam, but rather a heads up. So if you're looking for a 3wt setup, stick with the 3wt setup, you will not be disappointed whatsoever. But from there go to a 5wt, do not chose the 4wt. Bump up two at a time - example: 3wt, 5wt, 7wt, 9wt ect.
@@MichealBacon thank you 🤙
Those fish are dead in a week...
Yep, because someone will catch them and eat them. Trout park fish don’t live too long once they are released into the stream.
i have this rod
Do you like it?
@@TheShowMeFlyGuy haven't got to use much but I caught a small trout and sun fish on the included flies
@@TheShowMeFlyGuy got it for Christmas 2 years ago and the streams around here don't yield much
@@outdoorguy4249 that’s still pretty cool because I thought those flies were trash.
They are pretty bad as i has several fish look but not take
Maxcatch is good stuff
Agreed! I feel like their products are a great value and worth more than what you are spending! I absolutely love this rod and is one of my go-to rods when I want to throw a 3 weight now!
Check the Spine in china they do not know what a rod spine is
Interesting! Thanks for the tip!
@@TheShowMeFlyGuy let me know if they put the guides down the spine center ????
@@flokijhdfjkvnhsdfjkl will do!
Dude all he did was unbox a rod and rip on old people
I think you’re missing a few other things I did unsuccessfully. Come on!
@@TheShowMeFlyGuy lolol
You're bait fishing. Youre not even testing the rod properly
Bait fishing? How so? In terms of not testing the rod properly, what would you have liked to see different?