They Didn't Understand What Ibn Uthaymin said regarding Boycotting! Mufti of Madina Salih al-Suhaymi
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 09. 2024
- 🔵 Join the Telegram:
t.me/Gardenofi...
🟢 Join the WhatsApp Community:
linktr.ee/gard...
🔴 Follow on Instagram:
/ gardenofilm_
🔵 Follow on Twitter:
/ alhaqqan90
How many are boycotting to attend FAJAR Salah in the MASAJIDS every day ?
I think channels like this should always disable their comment section, to get rid of the ignorants who always want to have a say in the opinion of scholars.
Correct
Brothers, I think our own individual monies we decide what we buy. Although we should not go to extremes like forcing others not to buy we can encourage each other to boycott. For eg: if google was helping them, we cannot boycott google it’s almost impossible. On the other hand HP computer company we can boycott and buy some other companies. Also we should not force others to not buy but we should encourage others to avoid as much as possible. That’s the least we can do for them. Oh Allah help us we are so weak.🤲🏻
I think this is a fair response
You can use Bing and not google, or other search engines
the truth is right in front of you and you still choose to deny, akhi open your eyes and learn your religion, pray your 5 daily salah and fulfill your obligations with Allah, for Wallahi that’s better for you then boycotting a HP company
@@MuwahidNaseehaa who said I don’t pray 5 times a day? Instead of preaching everyone to learn and pray have some humility. What is Kibr. Looking down upon others. One who has an atom’s weight of Kibr will not enter Jannah according to Hadith. So be careful.
Also who taught you this closeminded? Why cannot you pray 5 times and fulfill your obligations to Allah and also boycott? Are you a Zionist that you are so hurt for boycotting a company which directly assists in oppressing our brothers and sisters. The deen is not only praying 5 times a day. There is a lot more to it. Having compassion and loving all the Muslims just for being Muslims is part of religion. The Hadith states the ummah is like one body and if one part is aching the whole body is sleepless and in pain. (Paraphrasing Hadith) so yes apart of preaching go learn your religion you should also try to learn your religion.
@@AbdullaShoaibHaris Bismillah, When we as muslims make claims we base it off Allah said, His messenger said, the companions said, and the explanations of the scholars OF sunnah…understand ? ok, you make a claim of “encouraging others to boycott”-the scholars have mentioned this is not permissible ie HARAM like the statement of Shaykhuna al Uthaymeen and others May Allah have mercy on them, i ask you one thing why make something permissible! haram for yourself ? what’s even worse is making it haram for others, some muslims today believe they’re doing good in this situation but are collecting sins without even knowing and that’s due to ignorance and lack of understanding in the religion, what can really help and aid our brothers and sisters in palestine is that we fulfill the obligations that’s due upon us, to pray 5 times a day without missing a salat, fasting voluntary fasts, standing up in the last 3rd of the night to call upon Allah and make dua, WALLAHI , that’s far more impactful for the ummah then to not drink coke and starbucks and whatever else these juhaal mention, people don’t even pray yet they are the forerunners to call to falsehood, our beloved prophet ﷺ mentioned that this ummah will never unite upon falsehood.. akhi i believe that you intend good however that’s not enough, any action that we do it has to have 2 conditions for it to be accepted 1: that it is solely for Allah and 2: that it’s in accordance with the sunnah, now ask yourself does boycotting with the way these people mention today meet this criteria ? akhi Wallahi learn your religion for knowledge wipes away the ignorance we all have, May allah guide us to that which pleases him
stick to The Scholars during the time of tribulation, knowledge doesn't pass to us without scholars. Sh suhaymi is one of the scholars, let us understand the speech of the scholars from the scholars not from laymen
Barakallahu feek. What is the actual meaning of boycotting? For example if an individual chooses not to buy certain brands, this is something he decides with his own choice and does not force it upon others or make judgements on others whether they buy or not buy American/ Jewish products. Jazakallahu khairan.
I think shaikh Ruhayli hafidahuLlah said thats ok
If I am not mistaken sheikh fawzan said its ok
Alhamdullah shaykh ibn uthaymeen was clear , there are no obligation for what you buy and don’t buy regardless of the reason , shaykh al albani mentioned boycotting as well . Yes it could be more effective if the ruler facilitated it . However the effect is apparent to the point the media can not ignore it . We shouldn’t blame no one for not boycotting, it is not a fatwa for us to consider . Simply it is a choice , and it is working . And you are clearly hurting their pocket , means that you are able to Partake without a fatwa ….
No need to wait for fatwa to boycott, it’s your choice , no proof from the Quran and sunnah to indicate that .
This is a very deep topic imo
1) If one person doesnt do boycott there is no need to Shame him and act like he did a major sin
2) Boycotting in a muslim or arab country is different because it is owned by Arabs /Muslims and they directly aid Palestinians
3) If at all people are ready for Boycott for the sake of Palestine and Islam
Are the muslims in the west ready to boycott and leave those countries ? Since they directly aid the Zionist
And if it is for the sake of Islam why don't they shame and boycott Shirk and Bidah happening in muslim communities
جزاكم الله خيراً
Ulma’a Al-Sultan عاملهم الله بما يستحقون ورد بغيهم في نحورهم!
Respectfully, the sheikh just waffled for 5 minutes, no Aqwal min Allah ro the rasol. Literally shed no light on the issue which speaks volumes, for me atleast. If i dont want to buy products,A no one can force me and B no ome can prove its haram. If you want then do, if you dont then dont. Allah knows best
Know that allah is watching and knows what you have said and you be asked about this on the day of reckoning
Brother with all due respect, stop jumping into positions and stop spitting dirt from your mouth (meaning your manners), Your manners with a scholar is like a kid who doesn't know what he says entails. So before you start building towers on a foundation of ignorance, learn some manners. The salaf learn manners before ilm.
Now to answer you allegations, firstly, the sheikh is not even talking about personally not choosing to buy a specific product aslan, he is talking about people calling masses to do that, and making agendas on it. Sure, in Kuffar countries it could be one thing, but in muslim countries this is supposed to be done by the ruler, other than that, you can eat or not eat anything you want.
Secondly, the burden of proof is upon the claimant. The asl is that everything in dunya issues is halal, until there is evidence otherwise. So those who are calling to mass boycotts of halal products in muslim countries have to present proof of it being obligatory or mustahabb to boycott in masses, not the other way around.
Another point to note that in muslim countries, products involve the lives and jobs of muslims, and the whole economy of the country. These are big decisions that are for the authorities.
Thanks for the reply most people calling for boycotts are in western countries and not the land of the Muslims. I stress my point and yours, it's halal till proven haram which the sheikh never. I watched the video again to make sure I didn't err in haste, and I stand by my statement that nothing of substance was said by the sheikh. Ad hom attacks about "foundations upon ignorance" literally doesn't disprove what I claimed about waffling, lov it or hate it, it is the truth. Qal Allah Qal Al racoon. Simple@@nahimwasit
@@kebabgangs6557inshallah no problem on my end. I spoke the haqq even though u don't like it. Having an opinion other than your own seems to be gharib for you.
جَزَاكَ ٱللَّٰهُ خَيْرًا
Assalaamualikum ikhwaa anyone know any trusted organization to donate to palestine which doesnt free mix and upon sunnah
Waalaykum asSalaam.
City Centre Dawah from the UK
Aid the needy
Good points 👍🏻
You can disagree with the shaykh while respecting his sanctity.
A franchise such as Starbucks and McDonald's has franchise money flowing back to Israel. The market decides if the Muslims do not want to endorse these franchises then Muslim businessmen should open their own brands etc. Ironically it was the Muslim consumer who made these brands popular in the first place!
If we are going to enter that discussion
Then don't you think before pointing fingers to Muslims in Muslim countries
Muslims in the west should be questioned?
Personally I am pro choice on this matter if you boycott or not it doesn't affect your Deen or your moral compass but Shaming and playing the blame game isn't good
And yes I do agree we Muslims and Muslim nations need to have our hand in the global economy need to unite upon the right path of Islam without any shirk or bidah
Be helping each other in a union and be a global power themselves
May Allah almighty protect us from these ‘scholars’.
may allah protect us from all arrogance
@@Kayaniz_RLameen
I have heard Shaykh Salih’s statement regarding this but where is the proof for what he is saying? I failed to see anything from the Quran or sunnah or statement of the salaf to support his views. Who amongst the salaf have the view that shaykh Salih is presenting? Please clarify
@gardenofilm Akhi why do i feel this was a very convenient opinion to share instead of the other scholars who are similar or maybe greater in caliber say otherwise, that yes you can boycott if you wish? Almost as if you are part of a group of duat today that are trying very hard for us to not boycott certain companies. Why? Since when did the personal choice regarding money and what we but become related to obeying the ruler? The ruler has not forced anyone to buy anything they don’t want to. Why so much mental complexity bro? You & Faris Hammadi.
Subhanallah
Because people are making it haram to buy from certain companies. They are making takfir of us yet they themselves are rulling by other than what Allah revealed by making haram what Allah did not. And why some people dont boycott in muslim countries, because these companies are franchises so they are owned by muslim in muslim countries ; no money would ever go to that state, it would only harm the economy in the muslim lands
what about Thumamah (may Allah be pleased with him)
People still listen to saudi scholars who are not imprisoned?
Yes Alhamdulillah, because people are not Khariji like you.
This is non sense argument. Ford car or furnitures are bought when harm aggression was not on. Now situation is different and time dictates accordingly. Yes stop buying Ford and furnitures now on until you achieve something some impact. Plus need over luxury. May be one needs car should consider other than Ford or furniture from place and manutfutrer not supporting aggressor.
But you definitely not have need to drink Pepsi or other drinks not now or in future it is not a need. Pepsi is today buying is hurting Muslims today or any other luxury products, just talking to justifying for being mabooth no real knowledge . It has happened in the time of Nabi Allah Alaihi salam.
True Mufti alim will if not lead at this time for protection of fellow brother and sister and children now than when?
Just living in palace driving fancy cars and Mufti alim just mabooth
يحمل اسفاره
Why don't you stop using CZcams and Facebook Sherlock? Mark is Jew. Don't you know that? Or whatever you use is acceptable, whatever someone else does is not?
So if the rules allow free mixing, drinking and Halloween, an individual can blame the rulers and make it halal on themselves.
And yes, if he doesn't consider it halal, he still can't ask others to stay away from such, because the ruler knows what is right and wrong and has allowed those, while he knows it not, although clearly stated in Shariah
Does it go against Islamic Shariah if yes then it stays haram
So Uthaymeen ra was wrong?
The shaikh hafidahuLlah is saying ppl misunderstood his words. Shaikh Uthaimin rahimahuLlah actually said that he was saddened that no country helped the new islamic country tjetjenie by f e boycotting. He spoke when its coming from leaders. Indeed if they d call for a boycot we d be off using internet for exemple? Allahu Alem.
Why don’t you actually study this instead of spreading confusion?
@@eesaabdurrahman1569what a silly response
@@adorablecheetah2930 how so? No one said Sheikh Uthaymeen was wrong. These issues are clear if you study them and leave your ego and emotions aside.
@@eesaabdurrahman1569 I'm not saying you are wrong, just be a little kinder to your brothers. Not everyone is blessed with knowledge or the right people around them brother
.
Ulma’a Al-Sultan عاملهم الله بما يستحقون ورد بغيهم في نحورهم!