2022 MG ZS EV vs Tata Nexon EV Max - Within Range | Comparison | Autocar India
Vložit
- čas přidán 16. 06. 2024
- With the introduction of the ‘Max’, the Tata Nexon EV aims to enhance its value card, and offer a lot more in terms of kit, and all-important range. But is it worth paying a premium over the standard Nexon EV? And if you are stretching your budget, should you go all the way up to the MG ZS EV? Jay Patil finds out.
Cameraperson: Mrityunjay Chakraborty, Shreyans Chordia
Editor: Mohit Sharma
0:00 - Introduction
0:45 - Exterior
1:36 - Interior space
2:33 - Boot capacity
2:42 - Equipment and safety
3:01 - Testing parameters
3:45 - MG ZS EV Performance
4:23 - Tata Nexon EV Max performance
4:57 - Tata Nexon EV Max highway
5:54 - Highway Stability
6:10 - Uphill driving
6:59 - Sport Mode Activated
7:19 - Handling
7:36 - Range after uphill
8:59 - Downhill driving and regen
9:40 - Range test final numbers
9:48 - Recharging times
10:27 - Price and verdict
#AutocarIndia #GoProHero10Black #SonyAlphaIn
SUBSCRIBE to Autocar India for the hottest automotive news and the most comprehensive reviews ► bit.ly/AutocarInd
Autocar India is your one-stop source for test drive reviews & comparison tests of every new car and motorcycle launched in India. We also offer a great mix of other automotive content, including weekly news, motor show reports, travelogues and other special features.
Website: www.autocarindia.com
Facebook: / autocarindiamag
Instagram: / autocar_india
Twitter: / autocarindiamag
New car reviews ►bit.ly/ACI-NewCarReviews
Comparison tests ►bit.ly/ACI-Comparison
New bike reviews ►bit.ly/ACI-BikeReviews
Features ►bit.ly/ACI-Features
#nexonevmax #mgzsev #autocarindia - Auta a dopravní prostředky
I had almost chose MG Zs EV. But at last moment to nexon ev max and I am happy with the decision , saved ₹7 lakhs. Completed already with 1500 kms in city traffic. And the in comparison I feel nexon ev max to be better.
Congratulations on the buy 😍 What is the on road price??
I think one of the factors to consider regarding these EV is reliability when we hear the news of battery related mishaps. Nexon EV is the most selling model in EVs (30000+) and hence proved itself over a period of time.
i calculated cost of 1km range for both cars by dividing price by range and MG gets 7373/- while Nexon gets 7233.
So both are almost equal in this regard. I would like to see more options in India, maybe 15-20 EV's more.
if you just want to drive within city limits
i think nexon ev is a better value than nexon ev max
I searched for this comparison just last week luckily the review come this week.
U should try including a short drag race between cars in ur comparison vids
Yes
Very well done guys... Great content... Thank you
I really appreciate the work. Can you guys do a long trip version of EVs together for better comparison.
the NEXON EV could do with a proper 4WD & a twin motor arrangement . . . a 63.2 kWh battery pack is very much needed in the NEXON EV . . . the twin motor will come in handy especially when going uphill as in this test . . . same can be requested of the MG ZS EV as well . . .
For people saying MG is a Chinese brand , so let's buy Tata. The battery pack and the electric motor of tata EVs are also made by Chinese companies. So just go for the one that best suits your budget and use
That 80kms difference is alot when you plan highways and makes it a significantly better choice also considering better cabin space and comfort
Excellent video and comparison. I personally like the MG ZS EV and i prefer it over the Nexon EV. zs ev looks so much premium and offers a great claimed range.
Gotta appreciate Autocar for being the first. I am running an i20 & Eon for last 10 years. Whilst it’s tempting to switch, I’m holding off on an upgrade until cars are able to reach atleast 330/350 kms real world range alongside a wide charging network in the 20L category. Until then, i20 it is.
You are a wise man👍🏻 sir
If you have the budget for the ZS EV just go for it... nothing better than it.
Autocar always does it first ❤️
I'm sorry but why would anyone buy the nexon max if you have to sacrifice the rear seat seating position ( knees up ) for the rear seat of a 5 seater suv.
In my opinion the only time you're sacrificing passenger seating postion is when you're in the market for a 7 seater, where the 3rd row has a knees up seating position in most vehicles. That makes sense of course because it's the third row in a car that already has a decent 2nd row. Tata has made a mistake with giving the Nexon Max more range in exchange for worse seating comfort. I'd go for the standard Nexon anyday.
When will you guys make a sedan comparision including Virtus, Slavia and City?
I have a strange question. I hope to get one (though the waiting list is enormous. In Thailand where I live, the MG ZS EV is a connected car which I don't like. I have some chats with people on this and the question now is where the antennas for this are because I want to be able to disconnect them. Any idea?
Great comparison review finally. Both are excellent cars in their own segments. One vfm and one luxury.Both are going for different set of buyers. By same logic you are paying 6L between the max & tigor ev for xtra 40kms. Anyways, these cars are miles ahead in performance n safety compared to the Korean ice tincans.
MG ZS ev is a europe spec car and i dont think Nexon meets the quality standard of ZS.
you should compare MG ZS Ev base model which is around 20L with nexon ev max.
What is the battery cost once the existing battery depletes after shelf life
Can you do the comparison with the facelift same versions, please. Thank you
The bad thing about the zs ev is that red closed grill and electric badge
Waiting for this video for months
Tata tigor ev with a 40.5 kWh battery capacity would be my pick.
Don't go the top variant for MG, Elite version which is roughly close to 23L on road. By paying 2.5L extra compare to top variant Nexon EV, u will get better range and comfort, not to forget the premium of MG
Autocar is evolving!
Best comparison 👍
Oddly the Nexon front seats seem undersized with the shoulders left hanging near the head rest while the ZS EV seems to have a proper sized seat.
Nexon EV max 🔥
The ZS looks so much better! And yeah, an extra of 80km does matter.
Paying 6 lack extra for more 80km range is deal breaker
Will it be cheaper to run an hybrid or an EV , maybe we can expect a video on that , say Tata Nexon vs New Brezza ? or the MG ZS EV vs Honda city BHEV .
What do you say autocar?
I don't know someone noticed that or not
Nexon is more stable in high speed
But zs not stable it's jumping
Good comparison
Whats their Crash test rating?
Which car is best to buy?
Both back seats look uncomfortable. The charging port on the zs at the front is so jarring. Interior is a clear win for the mg. But in the end it comes to range and pricing , given performance is similar
Not top choices but I think the only choices respective of the price segment
What is mg zs ev battery pack
The company should include a solar roof to top-up the battery. That would be great 👍
It would be a superb idea to have a review of the lucid air which has a range of 800kms just to compare Indian tech to foreign technology
Love my MG ZS EV.
Can someone confirm is it safe to drive ev cars in banglore - flooded area? Wondering As like other fuel cars is ev also wont kick start if it stuck in water flooded places. #banglore_flood #evcars
Nexon exterior and MG interior....🤩
Waiting for alcazar ev model
You need to do reviews with full car .people drive with family
For city and town tigor is still economicaly wise
New look of MG Grill look Yakkk
It's like "what mouth?" moment of blackbolt ⚡ from Doctor Strange MoM 😶
Can anyone explain what is the use of sunroof? ( Other than aesthetics)
Sunroof is actually needed in cold countries for getting good amount of sunlight in cold wheathers.... For more light inside cabin...
In a country like india where summers are 45 degrees and rains hard in monsoon... Its actually a gimmick more than a use....
Helps heat up the car in cold countries..
And india, Is definitely not a cold country
To make kids pop out their head through the sunroof and put them right in the line of danger. Thats the only use that some ignorant parents are finding of it.😂
indian buyer love to get fooled and then whine about it on inernet
Mg is 6.5 lakh rs costlier .... tata is value for money ....
BYD be like : May I come in.
@@Viveksinghbhadoriya99 I know that its a Chinese automobile manufacturer. But if you compare with MG, It offers the better and value for money at same price
No, don't come in.
@@Viveksinghbhadoriya99 Upcoming Suzuki and Toyota EV will use a Byd battery.
@@mohenjokataria1243 MG MOTORS is itself a Chinese company owned by SAIC motors of china
It is not available for private buyers and you can hardly find its outlets
Y the number plates are in Red ?? for EV's it should've been Green right ?
Why number plate is red?
I have test driven both the cars and i feel Nexon ev max is more fun to drive then ZS ev
Tata should bring harrier size EV
Don't even compare nexon to mg zs. No match both in terms of performance and quality
No need of comparison no one will go for zs ev spending 8 lakhs more .
I should have buyed MG ZX EV ,
MG EV line of products are sold with popularity in EU markets like UK, Norway, etc., as well as in many South East Asia countries. Thus the background fact is its huge volume of annual procurement of parts and batteries, globally. But honestly, not many markets/countries heard about or purchase Tata Nexon outside Indian domestic market.
Don't forget that even though MG MOTOR is a British automotive company owned by SAIC- a Chinese Company.
If I were given a choice, I'd pick Tata Motors any day even over Maruti Suzuki.
other things aside main thing abt price diff is taxes mg is 4.3m nexon is 3.9m long so taxes are ~~15%more on zs
I am waiting for harrier ev
Im not an EV fan but still among these I'll choose MG ZS
Everyone:VW polo has the worst back seat ever!
TATA: are you sure about that?
MG ZS EV strongly stands against Nexon EV max,
it offers everything better than EV Max.
MG ZS EV on outside looks more like tesla model X but yk that meme 'copy my homework but dont make it obvious'
Nexon feels very old and outdated. MG is right from the future.
Batman also looks OLD and OUTDATED.🥱😴
Another day another car
Soon there will be a clash between MG and Tata fans
No doubt nexon ev is value for money. But nexon design team must change the back of the nexon. It looks ugly..
I recently have driven both zs and nexon...and surely nexon has better 2nd row space and seating comfort than zs..
India Tata Nexon EV 🙌🏻
Tata is the best 🚀
I can’t trust Tata with reliability of the Max after what we have seen with standard Nexon EV
ZS EV is the choice for me
Hehehe that also unrealiable 😂😂😂😂
Don't judge tata brand by seeing one failed product
@@maneeshgowda4836 tata has a lot of failed products over the years
@@maneeshgowda4836 Yes I am not judging the brand but Nexon EV Max is based on Nexon EV only
Why NEXON EVmax range is very low compare to claimed range i was expecting more than 300+ km range from EVmax
What is the range with 5 average adult passengers and a full boot of luggage with clothes?
and going uphill with speed of 120 km/hr and towing
Those blue elements on Nexon are a bit gaudy
I like Nexon's look better
Nexon looks stunning, like a mini Range Rover. ZS on the other hand looks ugly and like a cross version of hatchback.
When I first saw this MG on road I felt some cheap rider has modified the front grill. My personal opinion that I dont like the front grill. Feels like someone has got it done aftermarket. Over that a hefty price tag it comes with. A big NO for me.
From the video one can easily infer the nexon is more stable than zs.
Mg zx i like
TATA definitely leader
❤️✨✨❤️
Be #Indian Buy #Indian 🇮🇳
MG FOR THE WIN ❤️❤️❤️❤️
you seriously were not paying attention
nexon ev is right choice...
Winner winner chicken dinner!
Most important, Nexon is an Indian Car
I am experienced EV user... believe me. Evs aren't worth the hype.
1. Slow charging... takes hours.
2. Battery-as the weather gets colder so does the range. U will cry.
3. Battery- use sporty n other non economic modes...kill ur range. Will regret.
4. Battery- drive at night, you will be using all lights etc... kills the range again.
5. Charging Stations... they aren't just enough... if u run out of battery..just give up.
Nexon is value for money
EV Max Anyday
Zes EV anyday
MG ZS ev 👍🏻
MG is not big as TATA, and is not going anywhere, so I'm with TATA
Tata best
EV sales will pickup when the range goes to 1000+ KM
No comparison required. Go for Indian.
MG looks more premium
TATA Nexon 🇮🇳🔥