EP 133 | Muhammad: Fact or Fiction? with Al Fadi of
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 06. 2024
- EP 133 | Muhammad: Fact or Fiction? with Al Fadi | Redeeming Truth
In this fascinating and controversial episode of Redeeming Truth, host Jon Benzinger joins former Muslim Al Fadi to unpack the complex figure of Muhammad in Islam. They dive deep into Islamic sources about Muhammad's life, including obscure Hadith and Sira, analyzing his marriage to Aisha, his commands to kill opponents, and more.
Al Fadi candidly discusses aspects of Muhammad that Muslims don't like to talk about. They also debate whether Muhammad truly existed, examining arguments from critical scholars like Dr. Jay Smith and Robert Spencer. According to Al Fadi, Muhammad likely did exist but his story was greatly amplified over time for political reasons.
This is an eye-opening discussion about the deep connections between early Islamic history centered around Muhammad and trends we see today like jihadism and anti-semitism. Don't miss this brave conversation!
GIVE TO THE MINISTRY: redeemeraz.org/give
Click here to Subscribe to our channel:
/ @redeemerbiblechurchgi...
REDEEMING TRUTH MEDIA: redeemingtruthmedia.org/
Follow us on Instagram / redeemerbibleaz
For more information about Redeemer Bible Church in Gilbert, Arizona, or to help support this ministry, please visit us at www.redeemeraz.org
Join our Facebook Group: / redeemeraz
Follow us on Facebook / redeemeraz
Never miss a sermon, find our Redeeming Truth Podcast in your favorite player, and subscribe!
Navigation
00:00 Intro
00:47 You used to be Muslim
2:33 Who is Muhammed in Islam
4:05 Is Muhammed in the Quran
5:17 Where do Muslims learn about Muhammed if not in the Quran?
6:37 No eye-witnesses?
7:06 No evidence?
8:08 What Muslims don't talk about / Marriage to Aisha
10:08 Hadith fabricated?
11:04 Is Muhammed in the Bible?
13:36 Did Muhammed exist?
17:47 Is Muhammed a Christian?
18:44 The legend of Muhammed
20:23 Important to understand about Muhammed
22:49 Terrorism and Muhammed connection
23:58 Anti-Semitism in Islam
26:08 Closing
I am so thankful that more ministries are talking about Islam. I used to be a Muslim before coming to Christ about two and a half years ago, and I’ve tried to tell fellow Christians about Islam so that they better know how to reach Muslims. This conversation does a great job at bringing up some of the major inconsistencies in that faith; points that would be useful when trying to help Muslims understand why their faith is flawed and that they need the Gospel! God bless you guys! Love your channel and ministry! 🙏🏽👏🏽
Please tell me... were you a Sunni or Shiite or what?
And if you were a Sunni... then... from which sect or school of thought?
Thank you for the truth.
peace to the world.
Welcome to the Family sister! 🌟👏
@@TomTorbeyns Glad to be here! May the Lord bless you! 🙏🏽☺️
@@KREG875 ................
Oh, how pity you.
@@defenderoftruth3212 the feeling is incredibly mutual. 👌🏽
The internet is number one enemy of islam
Saint Al Fadli. Blessings upon him. He is taking huge risks trying to expose the truth. Thank you.
I'm Christian but I love Islam friend god bless u to say the true god love Islam people please safe them 🙏🙏
God truly bless your channel and Al Fadi, and send his holy angels to protect you in all things. I particularly love this man and all he has done with his message.
Thank you - great conversation!
Hi my dear brothers in christ Jesus am from Trinidad now seeing this episode thank you for speaking gods true
Great video guys!
Excellent discussion with AL FADI !
very informative - mentioned by name only 4x - astonishing
Another informative video. Thanks guys!
a.kay.c lol! Another drama filled with wild lies, and pathetic childish misinformation.
@@MohammedNazrullaDo you actually have any writings about Mohammed from the first century of Islam? (You don't.)
@@MHMD.IS.Jesu.3110 lol! Why 1st century dude? He is predicted in the bible as the virtuos person to complete what Jesus could not. He was predicted in hindu scriptures too.
Thanks Al Fahdi, great advice. It’s all about Jesus! The most praised One.
Thank you for this important information. It helps to connect the dots in the End Times which we are in now.
Praising God for His grace that been lavished on us unconditionally. Deffinitley agreed on his ways and approach when dealing our bro. and sister that we should present first the gospel instead of approaching on theological side. The same approach that has been my sister are doing for me for 17 years as a Muslim and shes faithful on doing so. And by God grace I'm now believer of Christ now for 11 years . Lets be faithful in sharing the gospel. Lets starts by having a personal relationship with them and ask personal questions about them with love about on how we have assurance of salvation from Christ. Thers a lot of subject that can be discuss and praying that all of us will be the vessel of sharing the gospel to all the people around us.
Christ is King
No historical work biography of muhsmmed until over a century later abd even hadiths written 2 to 3 hu sreds years after Muhammed contrast that fir Jesus eyewitbesses wrote of his words abd deeds in lifetime
Very good you telling about what is what. I know, but a lot don't
Does anyone ever question how someone was able to collect 700,000 Hadith? It would take months just to count to 700,000, let alone to read 700,000 sayings and decide which ones were reliable and which were not. How long does it take to read the average Hadith? A minute? Now we're up to a lifetime of doing nothing but read Hadith just to get through all of them.
They were much like the legends and extra-Biblical stories added in Europe about Jesus and Mary.
❤❤❤❤
Did u know the Gazan health ministry adds civilians and combatants together to get to 29,000 deaths, in Gaza war. Other reports say 12000 Hamas combatants have died.
There must be a powerful person who used his power and money in the 9th century to create the Islamic narrative through Sira and hadiths, could it be Abdul Malik Marwan?
hi Al Fadi
In the Quran there isn't a single clear unambiguous verse where Allah said he revealed the Quran to Muhammad through Jibrael. So much for the huuuge claims of Islamists.
Kumarvt785 if you do not know do not display your hate filled ignorance.
Quran 2 -97
Say, "Whoever is an enemy to Gabriel he who has brought it [Qur’ān] down upon your heart [Muḥammad], by permission of Allāh, confirming that which was before it and as guidance and good tidings for the believers."
@@MohammedNazrullaWho inserted 'Muhammed' and 'Quran' in brackets in the verse. Can anyone understand the verse without those 2 words in brackets. Raising a doubt or showing error is not hate. It's freedom of expression.
@@kumarvt785 yes! For sure, all muslims and knowledgeable humans who have graduated some high school understand very well. Common sense my dear, which is very un common!
Thank u brothers u both are well knowledge about jesus christ from bethlahem israel holy place.
Really really I would say about
Dr Al fadi , he is very smart intelligent! According religious way!
I watched many of his videos!
According a Quran verse!!
He has proving words by word in Quran!!!
Religion is a faith which human creat to unite people to follow and obeyed and make it such a way that they will follow without question and deviation to the faith. Although religion is to make human united by its faith in the same religion yet they are divided and become enemy of each other although of the same faith and religion. This is human being nature as all living creature have this behaviour to each other and at loggerhead because of different behaviour not of the same mind thinking.
Did TRINITY not a 3 in 1 coffee mix？😆😆😆
Al fadi lies does not stop he should
Debate sheilk uthman face to face
Al Fadi mentions here that according to SIN, M fought against 1 tribe far north, near Petra. WHERE? 🤔
Aa a redd❤
A lot of your objections would lead you to also leave the Old Testament, you’re telling a lot of lies Fadi, so as a non Christian how could you ever guide people to Christianity
But that is another discussion based on the "tu quoque" fallacy. Stay with the topic under discussion.
@@ArroEL922 I don’t think it is at all, the point is that the very objections you make renders your own beliefs 0
@@maxk8396 Do you understand what is a "fallacy"? Especially a "tu quoque" fallacy ! It does not seem so since you continue to double-down in this fallacy.
Now do Genghis Khan.
Did he start a new religion that has 1.6 billion followers seeking world dominion today?
When you understand how Islam developed out of heretical misunderstandings of Catholic theology in the 6th century by illterate arab nomads and weaponised down through history by warlordism ideologies, Islam and Muslim culture can be logically contextualised in todays religious geopolitical environment.
Warlordism ideals. With this ADDED threat: Changing Islam ideology is as bad or worse than Apostasy!
And the TITLE Mohammed means honored one. It was about Jesus.
Mohammed a title used for jesus also in the arabian area ,an abbayisid ,robin hood figure...base mainly on fiction.😊
Over 5 thousand denomination useing the one bible to defined god and all have different teaching's do you find this confusing it's all the work of insecure men's no god coming back to save you.
Some punctuations would help, but. Islam has 34 versions of the Koran at least that have such stark differences that Shiite and Sunni go to war with each other when there is no war against Christianity or Judaism. There may be 5000 churches but I don’t think you are using the term denominations correctly. But these are minor doctrinal differences not core Christian beliefs. Like in some denominations we call the pastor, Brother. Some call a priest, Father or Pastor. Small differences in how services are held and such. Christians all believe in Christ.
Would be great to do a comparative applying your same standards to thy if the existence of Jesus lol
Why he called muhammad prophet? What is the prophecies made by muhammad and his actions very bad like marrying a child
No one existed before. We just hatched out of eggs.
No such thing as a prophet outside of Christianity. ✝️
But these guys believe in Jesus and the Bible when none of the authors of the gospels ever met Jesus? Lol
And there was never a Bible found until the medieval ages.
Matter of fact, manuscripts of the Quran are older than the oldest Bible found. That's a fact
I'm not a christian, but the Quran also says that the gospel is true. Sura 5:46
By the way - Mohammed died as the Quran intended for a false prophet:
Sura 69:44-46
Had the Messenger made up something in Our Name,
We would have certainly seized him by his right hand,
then SEVERED HIS AORTA,
Sahih Bukhari 4428:
The Prophet in his ailment in which he died, used to say, "O `Aisha! I still feel the pain caused by the food I ate at Khaibar, and at this time, I feel as if MY AORTA IS BEING CUT from that poison."
Sahih Bukhari 5777:
(...) "Have you put the poison in this roasted sheep?" They replied, "Yes," He asked, "What made you do that?" They replied, "We intended to learn if you were a liar in which case we would be relieved from you, and if you were a prophet then it would not harm you."
Get real! And dig in instead of spreading lies. And that guy was never a Muslem. Never.
But here is the bread that comes down from heaven, which a man may eat and not die. I'am the living bread that comes down from heaven. If anyone eat of this bread, he live for ever. Jhon chapter 7 : verses 50 and 51.
Hallelujah!
I also heard the Vatican created Islam used Muhammad to convert pagans Arabs. Then from 19.00 mark I heard above that he could be a Christion too , then it may make sense. Maybe Muhammad turned against Vatican Romans then now we have 3 Abrahamic religions.
You started with a conjecture, _"...you cannot understand Islam without understanding the prophet Muhammad..."_
The truth is you CAN understand Islam without understanding prophet Muhammad because EVRYTHING you need is in The Quran.
However you CANNOT understand Sunnism/Shiitism/Sectarianism without understanding what long-dead Arabs & Persians say about prophet Muhammad.
To qualify for the Christian version of heaven, a person MUST accept Jesus as The Christ.
To qualify for the Sunni/Shiite/Sectarian version of heaven is to *bear witness* that prophet Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah.
So, the real question is, *"Did Jesus, The Christ and prophet Muhammad really exist?"*
The Christians and the Sunnis/Shiites/Sectarians have been debating on this topic for centuries and centuries to come. But they will never come to an agreement.
Until, of course... the Day when everything will be settled.
Although, the One True God has sent down, through the ages, Scriptures... but each group made it about themselves, i.e. the human element, instead of THE CONTENT OF THOSE SCRIPTURES!
peace to the world.
Regarding the ahadith, compare your same standards to the Bible lol, you being very naughty not telling people the truth fadi
Now do about the zoroastrean religion. Its roots are in iran and Iran is your number one enemy
So stupid and child like to say that number of times the is mentioned makes one authentic
Buddies discuss something more of substance ex values spirituality etc
I have no doubt mohammad existed for if he had not existed, they would not have not begun to ascribed such foolishness to a legendary person.
✝️✝️✝️🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
So if your looks are great withought the nasty red headgear stick to a trousers and a T shirt.
Compare our diners abd holy Jesus to sinner muhammed to a Muslim mindset muhammed sins excused due to Allah commanding him to do all of his gross sins
Fadi is afrawd !
So sad I didn't know that you are bald ,you look like the bald Eagle.
How old was Mary when she became pregnant with Jesus ????
May be 16 years old
A part of a sect or cult is Islam a military figure indeed,the Prophet indeed.
maybe the persian empire just needed a different religion to Christianity so one was invented ....
One fine day these both schalors say their father did not exist at all
Standing independtly and losing the deposit u people disown ur fathers once in ur lives