Theocratic Judges Who Find Source Of Law In Religion Than Constitution Increased:Dr Mohan Gopal
Vložit
- čas přidán 23. 07. 2024
- LiveLaw brings you the latest legal news and updates from India and beyond.
We are into fact based legal journalism.
Endeavour of LiveLaw is to play an active role for a transparent and democratic legal ecosystem, in the larger public interest.
This video is an intellectual property belonging to LiveLaw Media Pvt Ltd. Any unauthorised usage of this video/script in any format is prohibited and will be subject to prosecution.
Stay updated. Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/2pskgB3
Support Us: bit.ly/35qFj6A
Visit Our Website: www.livelaw.in/
hindi.livelaw.in
Facebook: / livelawindia
/ livelawhindi
Twitter: / livelawindia
/ livelawh
Instagram: / livelaw.in
/ livelawhindi
Linkedin: / livelaw
/ livelaw-hindi
Live Law app is India's fastest legal news app that will keep you updated on the latest law/legal news from India and across the world. Download now.
Android: bit.ly/2toaimp
iOS: apple.co/39dQ0vh
The tribe who believe that pea hen drinks peacocks tears and delivers eggs have increased.
That's what his was told in childhood.
Some people don't mature with age.
Unquestionably Incredible Analysis !!
A wonderful and deep incisive presentation on functioning and rational out look for selection of the judges to the higher Judiciary.The constitutionalism must be the only guiding force for collegium and its functions.Democractic out look is the bedrock of the justice system.The rainbow collegium is the most welcome.🙏
Brilliant oration replete with sincerity, coming from an extremely erudite mind. He is the brother of my friend G Balagopal IAS and I have had the privilege of interacting with him several times.
Collegium system was brought into practice whether to safe guard constitution or to safeguard judiciary from executive?
Only a truthfully BALANCED mind could have presented this analysis. Most deserves to be on decision making bodies.
As ordinary citizens we are helplessly watching the throttling of democracy. Now after watching the live law, there is hope at the of the tunnel. Thanks.
Well said prof MOHAN GOPAL no other said so explicitly so clearly and what is lurching. Before late time to act cohesively
A very brilliant analysis and suggestion. Thanks sir
Very good analysis sir
when 102 Christian countries and 52 Muslim countries in the world, why can't Hindus have one hindu county as hinustan? India should become a hindu country even before 2047.
Nepal is a hindu country.
The cast system is your weakness
100 corore Hindu yahan rehte hain. Log ise Hindustan kehte hain.
To specifically Hindu rashtra name de Dene se kya alag ho jayega??
Hindurashtra name dene ki koi jarurat nehin hai. Jo hai, thik hai.
The caste system was implemented by the British to keep a peaceful community at each others throat. Divide and rule policy which is seen everyday hindu muslim anarchy yet India is a hindu country created in 1947during partition so muslims who remained should be treated as outsider's just as pakistan and Bangladesh does to the hindus.
Jai hind
What is Hindu or non Hindu has to do, if Hindu relegion can not stand on the basis of truth. If Hindu religion has to be proved supremacy based on hatred of other religions, and to speak lie and or can not do justice of human belonging of other relegions which Hindu religion you are talking about. Does any true Hindu religion exist.? Peoples in other communities asked this questions.
Are you a true Hindu? If you are Hindu based on hatred of other, what kind of Hindu India you will support. First think about yourself, your believe of hatred and level follow of true Hinduism and what is the place of other human who follows other. First become of true follower of your faith in true sense. Don't try to terrorise other.
All these speeches must be spread in simple terms to the entire population.
Nicely highlighted the dangers of development of theocratic mentality in the judiciary and need for upholding the spirit of the constitution.
The threats and dangers to constitutional sanctity alongside democracy, federal and socialist fabric of nation is well highlighted by the learned speaker. Definitely there are far more greater challenges before judiciary to tackle than like never before.
Please read the constitution
why shariat LEFT to determine
when it COMES to Muslims
but for HINDUS common law
PROBLEM is in the CONSTITUTION
WHICH give life ti shariat
Read "Riddles of Hinduism"
By Ambedkar...
Ambedkar gave BJ to britishers.
there are religious laws for hindus . example . Hindu undivided family law under income tax act. laws for cows and severe penalty . cow law ravaged rural economy .
The persons who are making a promise in the name of God to follow and implement the Constitution of India and not following it then they are not religious persons, would say that they are fake religious persons ... Even Vedas must not be above God for religious person...
A very brilliant analysis .Sir, thank you .
I don't understand one thing, every intellectual speaks about secularism but why only Hindus have to follow secularism more specifically, why not by others?
Follow constitution it helps u ppl 👍🤣
You don’t have to but if you want to do things that are idealistically correct and is worlds best judicial standards and Raj dharma, then we should do. With all its flaws USA is the beacon of democracy and constitutional values ,where people from all around the world want to come, is no 1 , why not India be in that league. And the world should say that about us and not some IT cell sending WhatsApp messages that we are Viswaguru.
It needs courage at today's time to speak such clearly
You are correct if you are saying about Indian Judiciary co-opting Islamic-Christian Theocracatic laws !
Thanks. Very nice lecture
Collegium promotes oligarchy, family succession and nepotism. Whom this collegium is accountable to?
Its a mind boggling speech. Both in its clarity of thought and the way its stiched together.🙏
Thank you Dr. Mohan Gopal. You have rightly shown the lacuna in Collegium. Hope Collegium henceforth adopt your guidance.
❤👌👍👍
Thanks Live law for these news.
The discussion should be on appointments of judges to HCs.
The HCs provide feeder to SC.
with due respect, If you hear this you feel wow these judges are truly great pillar of nation and ideally this should be in ideal scenario; but than as a common citizen I see corruption in judiciary right to last drop of ocean...right below the nose of these judges....Shahrukh son case has pained judge but a common man is daily struggling in many of such type of cases....infact Shahrukh has money but common man goes bankrupt in fighting legal battle....why can't judges be appointed on merit by examination not collegium system and for examination qualification one of criteria should be the history of judge where his judgements, controversy, etc should be considered .... question should be asked by judges themselves within that why judiciary is compromising.....I feel the three fingers needs to be corrected before pointing others
Excellent presentation
If we strive for perfect constitution and perfect democracy, then ultimately we will end up with perfect sharia.. bcz shantidoot know how to use democracy to grow their influence and number.. Europe is going through that transition, and it has become quite evident..
bang on
Great explanation
Entire speech reeks of shallow western view of constitutionalism that had to deal with their medieval challenges. Given that India is a Hindu majority country, it's obvious that judges too get appointed from the same society. In ancient times, people spent entire lives learning the shastras and how the law applied to the society. That's why when kings were defeated, their ministers were retained to ensure continuity in the society. Didn't we have a judge who didn't want to hear the cases on Easter or on Christmas?
Constitution is to serve the people who live in its jurisdiction and not itself. That's why legislature that represents people is empowered to amend the constitution even it's preamble. Judges should stick to interpreting the laws based on constitution and nothing beyond it. Last thing we need is activist judges regardless of their socio-economic or religious background
Extremely well spoken. This gentleman has just opened up a can of worms. There will definitely be a backlash on this speech and the judiciary needs to stand strong and firm on building a Representative Government. Hats off to you sir for raising this issue.
However what about meritocracy , by giving representation one has to look at meritocracy as well.
The problem is everybody wants to be gaurdians but none have any way of doing it.
Very nice 👍
Sitting on any post which is of Social nature, whether it is of Govt or Social, Ngo, etc.. the person must not be biased based on any kind of matter, whether it is religion or even for family members...
👌👌👌
Hmmm , bitterness after all these years, why not look at 1947 to now when the bench was loaded in favour of congress, seriously no need to kneel and suck up.
Excellent lecture microanalysis of the idealogical rule rather than constitution as therule oflaw
Appointed Judges at all levels should have clear understanding of law, intelligent and innovative. Above all they should have backbone to stand up to authoritarianism.
Good speech - yes representative is good idea
No qualms or excuses in referring to Irish, British n American constitutions n courts which r predominantly Christian background,but if v refer to Vedas or puranas or Dharma of this land it is to b resisted!!! What a logic???
U r lack in knowledge 😂
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Good
If religion can give better solution than constitution there nothing wrong in pronouncing judgement basing on religion
Sir, collegium has to be broadened in SC and HC ie why 3 or 5 judges collegium , why not 9 or 15, one day brainstorming once in a quarter to appoint best judges for better future with better & faster judiciary. Judiciary has to be made financially independent through court fees from civil matters and to finance for free criminal justice system
Scoundrels in the power made the entire intellectuals of this country to ring SOS calls after observing other constitutional bodies are already turned as their servants.
Lalit also contributed by ensuring one or two in the panel who had record in the past against reservation based on social criteria which decided EWS
There were judges who referred to Islamic jurisprudene , specially the judge who handled the Coimbatore Bombing.
Excellent and daring presentation of facts..... Wish we had many Dr Mohan Gopals in our judicial system.
👍👌👏
The concept of a judge is that he he is the impartial representive of God. So the best way of selecting judges is to maintain a biodata from high school level, of all lawyers enrolling to the bar . If any of the persons took part in any type of political or religious riots or held positions in political and religious positions should not be selected because they can't be impartial by what they turned during the life.
The elected Government has a role to play in appointing Judges, as they are responsible for the masses .
I think the collegium should have a search committee in which government representative, eminent person from society, renowned artist, educationist and even a renowned retired judge from a foreign country should be a part. Their job should be only to search for competent judges who can be appointed to High Courts and SC. The final appointment should be done by the collegium. The appointment should not be left only to collegium. It should be structured and must pass the rigour of minute scrutiny.
Waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah
The people who believe in the constitutional philosophy should now deliver and rise to the occasion.
Constitution itself was created by British chamcha lawyers.
This is s good sign . Delayed Decades together
Theocratic judges must be thrown out. Post retirement assignments, particularly MPs, MLAs, Governors etc. must be banned. These are the roots of all mal judgement in judiciary.
This is not new.
5:20
Beautifully spoke of the social injustice and bringing sanathan dharma to overtake constitution, yes collegium should notice the importance of his speach 🙏👏👌👍💐
Absolutely these judges go by theocracy than sound reasoning, logic and constitution.
Nonsense
Really? Shariyat Acts and Waqf Acts
Ganga of vassepur in the meetings
.
The SubContinent47
Or
The Land beyond the Indus River ..
gave the 🌎
......... philosophy,
..... which includes
the NirIshwarwadi thought..
.
.
.
The citizen of the SubContinent47...
..know better
.
The governence, , the executives must have a safer distance from collegium to function constitutionally without any Bias of religion and discrimination for the progress of social justice
@Basheer. There are no provisions in the constitution that provide for 'the collegium'.
Please soeak on hindi
So we have to wait for twenty-four years for Hindu rastra!!!!
Law is codified commonsense. It changes from place to place and time to time. Culture of a country also do prevail.
Constitution was written under the supervisory guidelines of England and their B team Congress, to watch the interests of Chruch. Even seats of Anglo Indian MP were provided. There are various sections in constitution which are designed to tax Santan Sanskriti. Even Indian languages were put on back burners and a foreign language English was given supremacy.
Even Judicial processes had helped the mighty.
Dr Mohan Gopal must start to recognise Indian Laws, but not to English Laws or Roman or Islamic Laws. Is He an Indian or a European.
His point on ologicracy is worth noting.
Bigoted view of perception targeting only sanatan dharm, not mentioning verdict on basis of Quranic verses... shameless judges showing their hypocrisy and hatred against one particular community i.e. sanatan dharm 🙏🙏
Your brain only this big.
@@arunkumar2111 same feeling for the likes of u 🙏🙏
@@saketkumar5568 do you realize that the judge is clearly trying to improve diveristy and wants it to be independent in every way. You are just trying to throw mud in the name of targeting only one religion. Only tell me why sanatana dharma is better than our constitution.
@@arunkumar2111 unko diversity nahi dikhana, they just have to implement the the constitution properly and define the Indian law as it is. By the way sanatan dharm is already diversified. Once the Muslim reach the threshold of 25% u will see what happens...15% hai tab itna bawaal kar rahe hai Bharat ke harek Kone me 🙏
Huge respect to Dr Mohan Gopal for his bold speaking on many drawbacks of the Supreme Court
secular judges who makes one particular region as holy cow for sacrifice also increased ? is not it. Looking everything from colonial mindset with western culture alpha male interpretation may be cause of it.
@@rozraat1021
The analysis put forth by 'RAVI PRABHU' is mumbo-jumbo. He/she/it probably blindly laps up whatever the ilk of Sai Deepak spew, just because it makes him/her/it feel superior.
@Heavenslightourguide understand, who is the P. M of U. K now. We should export our indian culture to west than importing post Abrahamic culture to our country. Anti Hindus should not use any indian languages as their mother tongues. Indian languages are Hindu languages.
@@vijayakumarpoovar8890 write in Hindu language. Why you are commenting in English ?
Hypocrisy.
@@Look_who_is_talking தமிழில் எழுதுகிரேன், படிக்க தயாரா?
@@Look_who_is_talking English is a Hindu language. There are more Hindus speak English than the English speakers in Britain.
It should not be allowed to be interfered upon by govt esp NDA
No need to go to the Vedas
😳2 Timothy 3:1-5
[1]But mark this: There will be terrible times in the last days.
[2]People will be lovers of themselves, lovers of money, boastful, proud, abusive, disobedient to their parents, ungrateful, unholy,
[3]without love, unforgiving, slanderous, without self-control, brutal, not lovers of the good,
[4]treacherous, rash, conceited, lovers of pleasure rather than lovers of God-
[5]having a form of godliness but denying its power. Have nothing to do with such people.🙏
Bible is the Ultimate Holy Book. 👌
Bible is full of anti- hindu versions. Don't talk about Bible to Hindus. Still remembering about colonialism.