Top 5 Brown Bear Cartridges

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 20. 03. 2023
  • In this video I talk about 5 cartridges that would be good for hunting Grizzly/Brown bear. I error on the side of bigger cartridges, let me know what you think of my list. Thanks for watching!
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 193

  • @Shaggy_Rogers0001
    @Shaggy_Rogers0001 Před rokem +28

    A good ol' 180 grain 30-06 would kill just about any animal on the planet at close - mid range.

    • @nayrapepenova9325
      @nayrapepenova9325 Před 3 měsíci +2

      Yeah but it likely wouldn't stop a grizzly charge unless you have extremely good shot placement. Not everyone has that. That's where the big stopping cartridge magnums come in.

    • @Shaggy_Rogers0001
      @Shaggy_Rogers0001 Před 3 měsíci +1

      @nayrapepenova9325 I agree, if the grizzly is charging, than a 180 grain wouldn't stop it dead in it's tracks like a stopping rifle. But the bear would inevitably die from the damage caused by the bullet.

    • @nayrapepenova9325
      @nayrapepenova9325 Před 3 měsíci +2

      Oh totally. The Ole 06 can definitely do the job for sure

  • @bigjon576
    @bigjon576 Před rokem +21

    My personal pick is, 9.3x62
    300 gr bullet
    2300 fps
    3754lb of muzzle energy.

  • @TrapperScottyAlaskan
    @TrapperScottyAlaskan Před rokem +18

    338 win mag is the winner in my book. They are common, affordable, long range, ammo available, down range energy. It will ruin moose meat with its destruction power. Perfect for big bears. Trapper Scotty,Alaskan

  • @paulalderette1255
    @paulalderette1255 Před rokem +19

    The 375H&H is my all time favorite. I've shot an interior Grizzly with it as well as two Cape Buffalo in the most satisfactory way. Happy hunting everyone. 👍 😊

    • @ikeyschultz4969
      @ikeyschultz4969 Před 11 měsíci +3

      This round has been weighed, measured, and found successful on every continent vs every dangerous (small or large) at 100 meters or less.

  • @NYPrepper
    @NYPrepper Před rokem +15

    The USDA made a publication in the 80's for Forest Service employees. Their recommendations for most people are 30-06 with 220 grain partitions or similar (A-frame) and I think you could also use 200 grain TSX. Due to good balance of recoil and commonality. They also say 375 H&H 300 grain.

    • @bennwj
      @bennwj Před rokem +1

      With bullet construction that we have these days a well constructed 180gr can penetrate better than a 22 did back then and have a flatter trajectory to go with it

  • @NYPrepper
    @NYPrepper Před rokem +11

    This is why I got my 416 Ruger. I have shot through 26 2x10's and a two foot diameter oak log with solids. Thing is a monster with 400 grain TSX @ 2400 fps 5,100 ft-lbs out of a 20 inch barrel, leaves a MASSIVE wound channel and penetrates as deep as 300 win mag solids. Thing was made for Alaska.

    • @markloomis1415
      @markloomis1415 Před rokem +4

      I've got two 416 Rugers and think it is a neat package. I've got the guide gun and the African. It is more powerful than the 416 Taylor wildcat and equal to the 416 Remington mag in the same barrel length. I have not shot any game with the 416 Ruger yet, cause I have had a love affair with the 458 win mag and 458 Lott for many years and have taken much game with both, including waterbuffalo and Cape Buffalo! My buddy used a 416 Ruger for his waterbuffalo with great success but I was using a custom Marlin 45/70 for my waterbuffalo that time with great success!
      I think the 416 Ruger should be more popular than it is and hope Ruger will continue chambering
      it!

    • @jamespmullin21753
      @jamespmullin21753 Před 11 měsíci

      @@markloomis1415 Aren't water buffalo domesticated? What did you do, walk up, pat it, then shoot it in the head?

    • @markloomis1415
      @markloomis1415 Před 11 měsíci +3

      No,I gave it a big kiss first. Seriously, you know nothing about Buffalo. All Buffalo in the wild are dangerous, especially when wounded, and have a natural instinct for revenge! Even Waterbuffalo when hit will run a little ways into the brush and then turn towards the hunter and wait in ambush! The first time I hunted in Argentina, A buddy of mine and his PH got charged by his wounded Waterbuffalo in the brush and he and his PH fired 5 shots into it as it knocked them both over. It then turned around for another charge and his PH fired his last shot from his 375 H&H and hit it between the eyes, dropping it at there feet!

    • @davidnikulka1437
      @davidnikulka1437 Před 9 měsíci +1

      Thanks for the imfo .@@markloomis1415

  • @pbisceglie1
    @pbisceglie1 Před rokem +19

    I just picked up a 35 Whelen. I got 2900 fps with Hornady 200gr Superformance factory ammo. Good performance for a non-magnum cartridge. I can’t wait to see what I can get with reloads!

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před rokem +2

      Have fun!

    • @deanmuir511
      @deanmuir511 Před 8 měsíci

      Hmmm fat utard that probably never has or will even see a bear telling me which gun to use!!! So funny

  • @brandonrenner9597
    @brandonrenner9597 Před rokem +13

    35 whelen preferred but I'd trust my 30-06 with 200gr

    • @b01tact10n
      @b01tact10n Před rokem +4

      I'm well practiced with my REM700 in 30'06. I'm going to Kodiak this fall and coming back to the Kuskokwim for Bull Moose. I've got great 5 shot groups inside of a dime @150yds with the 200gr Partition. I get as close as I can get for good headshot placement
      The 35 Whelen is one awesome cartridge 😁👍👍

  • @chriskendziora5424
    @chriskendziora5424 Před rokem +11

    The 338 win, 45-70, 35 Whelan. 350 remmag, 358 Norma, 375 ruger.

  • @fedup3582
    @fedup3582 Před rokem +9

    It wouldn't surprise me to find out that the 30-06 has been used to kill more brown and grizzly bears than any other cartridge.

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před rokem

      Probably

    • @SamLloyd-fp8dq
      @SamLloyd-fp8dq Před rokem

      Actually Alaskan residents and eskimos kill more grizzly/brown bear/kodiak than any other carriages
      Now in lower 48 states 30-30 is number one and been out longer than any other cartridges exist

    • @SamLloyd-fp8dq
      @SamLloyd-fp8dq Před 4 měsíci

      Doubt it. Most Alaskans and Alaskan natives uses 30-30 more than anything else. Especially on big grizzlies

  • @David-bf9ux
    @David-bf9ux Před rokem +15

    . 338 Win Mag.

  • @johnvillalovos5082
    @johnvillalovos5082 Před rokem +5

    Always a great and interesting subject! Nice video with different cartridges than the last. My overall #1 choice would be my 338 Win. Mag. If I knew that I had to take , or was very likely to take a 200-300 yd. shot, ahead of time, then my 338-378 Wby. It hits at 100 yds with the same energy as a 340 Wby. at the muzzle, or at 200 yds. what a 338 Win. Mag. does at the muzzle. More power than needed, for sure, but, it may provide a big margin for the job at the distances, I mentioned. Optimum bullet construction and good shot placement are assumed of course.

  • @NYPrepper
    @NYPrepper Před rokem +5

    340 weatherby is a great choice, I would try to get some heavy TSX and solids to handload. Cutting Edge makes 338 cal solids. I agree on 300 win mag I am working up handloads with 210 grain solids. I think for 300 win mag the best choices would be 200 grain TSX and 210 grain solid alternating in the magazine.

  • @bennwj
    @bennwj Před rokem +5

    Any good 180 gr partition/bonded bullet that is designed to expand and stay together in 30 cal will certainly do the job. .300 Win Mag, .300 Short (Winchester or Remington versions). 7mm mag is also a good choice. If you can shoot a .338 well, that is also a great choice, but its more of a “want to have” instead of a “need to have” cartridge.

  • @cw2a
    @cw2a Před rokem +14

    When I began reading on bears and I was plesantly suprised to find my beloved 358Norma Magnum was well received used and accepted. Its more power then the 338 plus better bullet diameter. Sends 250g bullets past 2850 fps. Ability of 300g bullets in the excellent Barns Original design. Solidly past low 4000 fpe.

  • @richardkramer1094
    @richardkramer1094 Před 10 měsíci +7

    My preferred chambering for Browns and Other big bears is the .35 Whelen loaded with a 225gr Swift A-Frame at 2750 fps. The .35 Whelen is too often overlooked.

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před 10 měsíci +1

      Yes it is. I'm tempted to get a 35 Whelen

    • @richardkramer1094
      @richardkramer1094 Před 10 měsíci

      @@ReloadingWeatherby I also use it when I’m hunting in grizzly country as a camp protecting gun, however it is loaded with 250gr Swift A-Frames at 2570 fps for stopping power.

  • @markloomis1415
    @markloomis1415 Před rokem +8

    I've got lots of suitable Brown Bear rifles but would definitely put my 340 Weatherby at the top of the list. I really love the 458 win mag and have shot a lot of game with it. It's versatility is unmatched and shoots 250gr to 500gr bullets with moa accuracy. I think for big bears I would choose the 400gr Swift A frame at 2400fps! My Dakota 458 Lott loves that bullet at 2500fps!

  • @jk-kr8jt
    @jk-kr8jt Před rokem +1

    Hi RW,
    Good to see one of your videos again. All good choices. Naturally you can't name them all. A big part depends on which one has a manageable recoil for the shooter, the terrain that will be hunted and what other game is on the menu. The ones I've shoot big bear with or seen friends shoot them with are as follows.
    416 Weatherby
    416 Remington
    458 Winchester
    340 Weatherby
    300 Weatherby
    300 Winchester
    375 H&H
    Recently I did a grizzly hunt, didn't get one, with a 338 RUM. I'd imagine it'll do what my 340 does. This is in no way a complete list and I'd say use what you're comfortable and familiar with. If that is a 30-06 than use it. Of course shot placement and bullet construction are paramount, since that is your only connection to the animal.
    One cartridge I have wanted to try for years and never have is the 358 Norma Mag. When I was a kid I read a story about trying this cartridge to protect pipeline workers. 250 gr bullet cooking at 2900fps will do the trick. Oddly the only rifle I've ever seen in that cartridge was an Omega. Love at first sight for a gun crazy 10 year old. Also the only Omega I've ever seen.
    Keep up the videos, RW. They're fun.
    Cheers, Jeff.

  • @larrybassett5559
    @larrybassett5559 Před rokem +11

    . 338-06 and .35 Whelen good choices as well.

  • @markcox2870
    @markcox2870 Před rokem +4

    There is a famous story of a man hunting trophy black deer in Alaska with a 7mm Rem Mag. He and the guide happened on a brown bear that charged them. The bear took the entire magazine of 7mm Rem Mag. The guide paid the insurance at just 20 feet with a 416 Ruger. The guides that I know personally insist clients use 300 Win Mag at the absolute minimum. It the locals want to use a 270 Winchester that's magnificent have at it. The locals in Zimbabwe also use hand lines to catch Tiger Fish.. Sound it out in your head guys.....

  • @jamespmullin21753
    @jamespmullin21753 Před rokem +5

    My fang and claw rifle is a Ruger M77 Alaskan rifle in 416 Ruger.

  • @kylemartin832
    @kylemartin832 Před rokem +4

    Can't stop thinking about that Weatherby Vanguard Talon you showed us a few videos back. I pick that in 300 Weatherby Mag for my Grizzly hunting rifle. But, for those real big brown bears way up north I'm taking my model 70, 375h&h 👍🙏✌

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před rokem +1

      You going to get that Vanguard Talon?

    • @kylemartin832
      @kylemartin832 Před rokem

      @@ReloadingWeatherby Hard to beat for the money. The Peak 44 stock alone is almost $800. If my shop can get one in I'll probably grab it, caliber depending. Would you recommend a Vanguard? What caliber would you go with in the Talon?

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před rokem +1

      @@kylemartin832 I would absolutely recommend a Vanguard rifle. What caliber would I get? Depends on what I already have. For me I would probably get it in 6.5-300 WBY. I already have a lot of the calibers it's in.

  • @jamespmullin21753
    @jamespmullin21753 Před rokem +7

    Bart the bear said that the 22 short, or the 25 acp, in his' opinion, are the best calibers for defense against grizzly bear.

    • @keyjam9
      @keyjam9 Před 8 měsíci

      Haha. Good one. And the bear is a great movie. I watch it often. How did they get those shots with no computer stuff in the 80's?

    • @bluebeastsrt
      @bluebeastsrt Před 29 dny

      Watch the 22 for self defense videos. There will always be one guy in the comments. That had an uncle or a buddy that dropped a deer or bear at 300 years with a 22.🙄

  • @Finnbearl61r
    @Finnbearl61r Před rokem +3

    For the Woods the 35Whelen with 275gr Woodleigh PP @ 2350fps (19”) and 358Winchester with 250gr Norma Oryx @2280fps (21”) are my favorites.

  • @gunman-6646
    @gunman-6646 Před rokem +3

    Great video! Makes me interested in the 375 ruger. In Montana last week I found a mark v .300 weatherby mag for 794.00, could hardly believe it.

  • @NYPrepper
    @NYPrepper Před rokem +2

    200 grain TSX for 300 Win mag best choice if only for bear. I would not load it too fast I would keep it slower so it doesn't over expand and limit penetration.

  • @cw2a
    @cw2a Před rokem +6

    Something else not voiced.
    Defensive use. You wont find many "magnums" on that list. 12ga, 45/70 are gonna be tops. But 444, 450Marlin, 458 Socomb and 450 Bushmaster are newer arrivals that deserve consideration.

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před rokem +3

      True, I was naming cartridges you would use to hunt brown bear

    • @justahologram2230
      @justahologram2230 Před rokem +1

      You could argue that .500 S&W has a spot among those though it's only in one repeater as far as I know

    • @cw2a
      @cw2a Před rokem +1

      Good point 2230. Then there is best HANDGUN's /Calibers of hand guns! 💪🏼

    • @justahologram2230
      @justahologram2230 Před rokem +1

      @@cw2a I was thinking about it out of Big Horn Armory's 18" lever action

    • @cw2a
      @cw2a Před rokem

      @@justahologram2230 AWESOME GUN! Yes Would be excellent short range defensive!

  • @warreng2885
    @warreng2885 Před 8 měsíci +3

    338WM using 250 NP at 2820 fps has accounted 2 brownies, 3 moose, 5 elk, 2 eland etc. I also like the 210 NP and believe it's as effective

    • @bearhuntd
      @bearhuntd Před 8 měsíci

      Are you runing a 26" bbl om your winmag?

  • @hopefulballistics
    @hopefulballistics Před rokem +4

    I’d pick the 375 Ruger with short barrel and suppressor.

  • @anthonybonavia2570
    @anthonybonavia2570 Před rokem +1

    I just got a 378 Weatherby, which if I was going on a Brown Bear hunt, would be my choice. I also have a 340 Weatherby which would be my second choice. My third choice would be my 338 Lapua, only because my 340 Weatherby is much more easier to carry. My 338 Lapua has a 26in barrel, with a muzzle break, my 340 has a 24 in Barrel. My 4th choice would be my 300 Weatherby. My 5th choice would be my 7mm RUM shooting 180 grain bullets at 3100 fps. My 6th choice would be my 300 Win Mag, Weatherby Weathermark, synthetic stock.
    Realistically, most people will never go Brown Bear hunting, the cost will be around $35-40,000. It is nice to dream though. If I was hunting other game like Moose or Caribou in grizzly country, I would still pack one of my top 3 choices just in case I came across an angry Grizzly wanting to do my or someone in my hunting party harm.

  • @Jeff_Seely
    @Jeff_Seely Před rokem +1

    Man, I absolutely love your choices and you really create some fun content. If I added one that I would really like, it's the 416 Remington. I think if you use a 400gr bullet, you get ~2500fps for a muzzle energy of about 5400. I've actually fired this round one time and it left a welt on my shoulder for a month! I think it would only take one to take a brown bear 🤣. Really great topic my friend. Very fun!

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před rokem +2

      Thanks for watching Jeff! I've shot a 416 Remington. It's a beast!

    • @Jeff_Seely
      @Jeff_Seely Před rokem

      Always my pleasure. Please keep em comin!

    • @andrewcleveland
      @andrewcleveland Před rokem +1

      @@ReloadingWeatherby love my 416 Remington and 416 Taylor Improved. I have lots of practice with them since I use them as my deer rifles. If I ever got the chance at brown bears I’d have to go with one of these rifles. I don’t use the 400 grain bullets though, mainly use the 300-350 grain loads for my whitetail loads. Great video as always!

  • @justahologram2230
    @justahologram2230 Před rokem +3

    It's a good list if you're keeping them at a decent range, if you're in the woods the list would be quite different. Also surprised that there was no honorable mention for .460 WBY or .450 NE

  • @MrJtin69
    @MrJtin69 Před rokem +3

    Funny enough i got all the rifles you mentioned and my most succesful cartridge is a 454 casull on a scary grizz charge 1 shot it went down and ill tell ya never in grizz woods without now that being said when hunting my 30-378 has been a beauty but im leaning towards my 375 ruger for a light carry and surprisingly the 375 rounds are amazing i have also took a elk with a 375 cheytac

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před rokem +2

      I love and hate the 454 casull. It's fun to shoot, but I'm done shooting it after the second shot

  • @davhuf3496
    @davhuf3496 Před rokem +3

    338 WM/ 340 WBY, 9.3x 62/ 9.3x64, 375 H & H/375 Ruger, 416 Rem, 45/70 heavy load

  • @highcountryadventures9606
    @highcountryadventures9606 Před 2 měsíci

    I was hoping to hear the mighty 378 wby magnum, but can't argue the other cartridges. I am in the process of building a 378wby right now. Looking forward to loading for it and using it on game.

  • @leeadams5941
    @leeadams5941 Před rokem +8

    good choices but you missed the .35 Whelen which is one of the best

    • @jw-sigp2258
      @jw-sigp2258 Před rokem +2

      I love the 35 Whelen. Great power and brass can be made from 30-06.

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před rokem +1

      I wanted a cartridge that came in a bolt action. I definitely didn't forget about the 35 Whelen.

    • @cw2a
      @cw2a Před rokem +2

      35Whelen was born in Bolt actions. Used in Remington pump and auto and more reciently some single shots when it was legal as a primitive caliber is some states.
      This one defineatly deserves consideration & mention. Its a "poor mans magnum.
      Why 35 Calibers are so often overlooked is simply beyond me. Many times they offer superior power and bullets.

    • @jw-sigp2258
      @jw-sigp2258 Před rokem +2

      @@cw2a Whats up CW. I’m a huge fan of 35 cal as well. For PA my top 35 cal pick is 35 Remington. But for elk, moose, and brown bear it would be 35 Whelen for sure. Are there any decent 35 cal wildcats off of the 300 win mag case?

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před rokem +1

      @@cw2a Does anyone make a 35 Whelen in a bolt action right now? I think it's a great choice. I just don't want to bear hunt with a break action single shot.

  • @dustindias645
    @dustindias645 Před rokem +4

    Im gonna list the 5 i own
    1.375 rum
    2.340 wby
    3.8mm rem mag
    4.300 rum
    5.458 lott
    Thats the order id use them

  • @jasonforester4572
    @jasonforester4572 Před měsícem

    For me, the 9.3X62 is my choice. I live in B.C.
    Unfamiliar with 9.3X62? Think of it as a .35 Whelen that has been Ackleyized (< Look at me inventing new words!😆) in a .366 caliber.
    Heavy bullets. Projectile weights usually from 300grns to 250grns. "ish".
    With 286 the most popular for large game.
    Ruger, Tikka, Sako, Sauer, Blazer chamber rifles in that caliber. You can also find some good old Swedish Husqvarna's chambered in 9.3X62. If you find a Mauser actioned Husqvarna in good or better condition in that caliber, or any other cal, then you've got a great rifle. Mauser action, Swedish steel, back up iron sights (Insert Chefs Kiss here).
    As for recoil, it doesn't start to become a problem for me as far as quickly getting back on target for a followup until I get to about the .300WinM.
    I've heard some compare the recoil of the 9.3X62 to the .300WM. Personally, I don't feel that it is. I have both. The 9.3X62 has a kick, but I'm never concerned about it before I shoot it. The .300WM gets a little tiresome after a few shots at the range.
    This year I'm going to go with the 9.3X62 for all my hunting. The area I'm going to be in is mountainous and heavily forested. I definitely won't have any shots over 300 meters. Probably 200 max with the most likely ranges being 50 to 100 meters.
    But no matter the caliber, the top 3 things to ensure a successful harvest are
    1) Shot placement
    2) Shot placement
    3) Shot placement.
    Practice and only use good, bonded or mono projectiles and fully understand the "effective range" of whatever caliber is your preference and how barrel length affects it.

  • @brisnwinters8161
    @brisnwinters8161 Před 10 měsíci +4

    I have used 3006 with 180 grain premium bullets to take a 800 lb grizzly and a 1300 lb bison.

  • @thomasrohloff3418
    @thomasrohloff3418 Před rokem +4

    I'm surprised the 325wsm didn't get in here

  • @johngeddes7894
    @johngeddes7894 Před 10 měsíci

    One little factoid to think about is on the Alaska DFG website, they specify the Nosler ABLR, not the AB, for grizzly bear. One shot kills on big bears like that are rare, though. Proceed at own risk.

  • @wahiawabound808
    @wahiawabound808 Před 4 měsíci

    So the Weatherby is the strongest out of the 30 cals or is it the 338 win I'm just curious I just purchased a savage 110 tactical 300 wm but before I purchased it I been hearing 300 wm was the way to go as I was looking for a very strong 30 cal or bigger something right below 50 Cals However I live in hawaii so feral hogs on the island I'm on is the biggest game we hunt but other islands has deer axis deer wild cows big horn sheep mountain goats so one day I'll be going there to hunt with the 300 wm i heard the 300 wm is perfect for those games.

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před 4 měsíci +1

      30-378 Weatherby is the most powerful factory offered 30 caliber. Weatherby does make a 338-378 Weatherby which is also the most powerful 338 factory cartridge.

    • @wahiawabound808
      @wahiawabound808 Před 4 měsíci

      @ReloadingWeatherby ok got it thanks man.

  • @jmgates09
    @jmgates09 Před rokem +7

    325 Wsm 338win mag 300win mag 300wsm 300weatherby mag

  • @keyjam9
    @keyjam9 Před 8 měsíci +1

    375 h&h does not require a 24 inch barrel. I have a sako Kodiak 375 with 21 inch barrel. Lots of ammo available.

    • @bearhuntd
      @bearhuntd Před 8 měsíci

      Like your rig. I have a sako m995 trg w/20" bbl. Love it. Accurate, fast 2nd shot, easy to pack and carry. 2,400 w/300 grn projectiles. Fast to action.

  • @Suslord907
    @Suslord907 Před rokem

    i used a 7.62x39mm for a black bear. in a ar-15 platform, was unusual sighting where i live especially for a black bear. i used that ar until i got the 6.5-300 weatherby magnum. since i got that one don’t touch my other guns. laser beam out to 530 yards, that 6.5-300

  • @bobby34u
    @bobby34u Před rokem +3

    340 Weatherby with 260 grain hammer bullets

  • @jamespmullin21753
    @jamespmullin21753 Před rokem +2

    340, 338 RUM and 338 Lapua are ballisticly about the same thing.

  • @blaserlongrange7616
    @blaserlongrange7616 Před rokem +3

    I take my 8,5x55 blaser loaded with 225gr ttsx at 2800fps 💪

  • @craigleibbrand7761
    @craigleibbrand7761 Před rokem +2

    Brown bear. Weatherby's magnificent 378 magnum will pulverize them.

  • @The_Judge300
    @The_Judge300 Před rokem +2

    First of all do the hunter need to be able to hit where he/she needs to hit.
    The size and power of the cartridge is totally useless without that happening.
    So, in many cases will it be much better for a hunter to use a 308 Win with a high quality bullet on brown bears instead of a huge magnum cartridge.
    Having a cartridge that goes faster than 2800 fps is rather pointless for most bear hunting.
    Of course there is no drawback in having that as long as you can handle the recoil well.
    If you can handle a recoil stronger than from a 300 Win Mag, you will for sure benefit much more from increasing the caliber instead of increasing the speed.
    In most cases you will benefit more from increasing the caliber instead of increasing the speed of what a 30-06 can give.
    As soon as you reach a speed of about 2800 fps and can handle more recoil, you benefit more from increasing the caliber instead of the speed.
    338 Win Mag, 35 Whelen, 9.3x62 and 375 Ruger are all good brown bear cartridges.
    And why not something like a 416 Ruger as well if you can shoot well with it.
    As long as the bear is calm and minding his own business, then he is rather easy to kill, but an angry bear because it is wounded or just has a bad attitude and he is full of adrenaline, is a different story, and that is when heavier cartridges really makes a difference.
    I prefer to use my 375 Ruger when I hunt big critters with an attitude, no matter where it is in the world.

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před rokem

      Making an assumption that if you get a big magnum... you will actually shoot it, and practice with it

  • @sugargoldy
    @sugargoldy Před rokem +2

    You forgot the 6.5 Creedmoor LOL I'm just kidding you bigger the better for me on this one.

  • @Brandenuzis
    @Brandenuzis Před rokem +2

    Black bear I’d be fine using a 240 wby. For brown bears you would want more horsepower

    • @genxiong2695
      @genxiong2695 Před 9 měsíci

      Good luck if you run across a big 400pounder

  • @DaBellyMan318
    @DaBellyMan318 Před rokem +3

    416 rigby

  • @user-mt4si1zg3t
    @user-mt4si1zg3t Před 9 měsíci +1

    Brown bear? I'd use a LAW (light anti tank weapon)!

  • @TrapperScottyAlaskan
    @TrapperScottyAlaskan Před rokem +4

    Your beloved Weatherby gets the job done here zeroed in at 300 yards, 180 partitions. Trapper scotty,Alaskan

  • @inupik23
    @inupik23 Před rokem +3

    All that "power" in the big 30s mean nothing if you don't pick a good bullet. Speed is only an advantage at distance. 338 win mag would be my choice as an Alaskan if I were to go after griz or brownies. I wouldn't feel undergunned with my 30-06 with a good tough bonded bullet though.

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před rokem

      Bullet selection is very important

    • @inupik23
      @inupik23 Před rokem +1

      @@ReloadingWeatherby and how well someone can shoot said gun is important as well imo.

    • @TrapperScottyAlaskan
      @TrapperScottyAlaskan Před rokem +1

      Well said bro. Trapper

    • @TrapperScottyAlaskan
      @TrapperScottyAlaskan Před rokem +1

      Ever shoot the 220 round nose through the 06 ? They hit hard

    • @inupik23
      @inupik23 Před rokem +1

      @@TrapperScottyAlaskan never, but I have some for when I am walking though some thick griz country while carrying my 06.

  • @jamespmullin21753
    @jamespmullin21753 Před 4 měsíci

    Bearclaw bullets and Nosler Partition.

  • @Longtrailside
    @Longtrailside Před rokem +1

    I think the guys over on Rokslide might beg to differ with you and their 223's loaded with 77gr sierra tipped match kings. Me personally I'll go with a 300wm with barnes 180gr ttsx, or federal terminal ascent and good shot placement.

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před rokem

      Never heard of Rokslide. They really say to bear hunt with a 223 Remington?

    • @Longtrailside
      @Longtrailside Před rokem

      @@ReloadingWeatherby Yep, theres a huge 168 pages of people showing graphic pictures of after the shot of shooting animals. From coyote, deer, elk, bear, and moose. Look for forum labeled, 223 good for bear, deer, elk, and moose. Though lemme check that first, but i know im close to it.

    • @Longtrailside
      @Longtrailside Před rokem

      I cant post the link here but i might be able to type it out if you cant find it on google or on the site. You dont have to be a member to view the forum unless if you want to comment. Their are some pretty impressive pictures, and make you rethink some of your thinking of needing big calibers, seeing what they post. Bullet technology has come a long way from the days of the nosler partition.Though for me im comfortable using what i have.

    • @Longtrailside
      @Longtrailside Před rokem

      You must have gotten lost over their. Ill check in on you next week when your done reading the forum. I know its lot to take in, though a great read and lots of knowledge.

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před rokem +1

      @Longtrailside I'll eventually take a look. Seeing how I like magnums... for me it's not about what can be done with the lightest caliber.

  • @DaBellyMan318
    @DaBellyMan318 Před rokem +3

    338 win mag

  • @jameswilson5562
    @jameswilson5562 Před rokem +2

    340 all the way

  • @Lucysdad66
    @Lucysdad66 Před 3 měsíci +1

    That 30-378 will make you cry for your mommy.

  • @tmut44
    @tmut44 Před 6 měsíci

    my choice would be a 300 win mag. With a 200 gr A-frame bullet.

  • @brisnwinters8161
    @brisnwinters8161 Před 10 měsíci +1

    If 338 win is great the 340 weatherby is a bit more power.

    • @bearhuntd
      @bearhuntd Před 8 měsíci +1

      With a 26" bbl and shnting 250 grain bullets, ht eclipses the win mag by 150 fps. or less. Not necessarily an awesome increase...

  • @Win70ew
    @Win70ew Před 11 měsíci

    How many hunts have you been on in Alaska?

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před 11 měsíci

      5, how about you?

    • @Win70ew
      @Win70ew Před 11 měsíci

      @@ReloadingWeatherby I live here so, a couple.

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před 11 měsíci

      @lloydcoleman9788 So as a resident... was is your preferred cartridge?

    • @Win70ew
      @Win70ew Před 11 měsíci

      @@ReloadingWeatherby you named three of my favorites, 30-06, 7 REM Mag and .300 win mag. The hunt I’m going on in a few weeks, I’m taking my 7 REM Mag.

  • @Tikka510
    @Tikka510 Před 4 měsíci

    What book is that in your vid?

  • @reydelmundo9444
    @reydelmundo9444 Před 7 měsíci

    What book is that?

  • @Braxtonfontes14
    @Braxtonfontes14 Před 11 měsíci

    Rifle choices
    1.338 rum.
    2.340wby
    3.300 rum
    4.300 win
    5.30-06
    For protection
    1.45-70
    2. 500 s&w
    3. 454 casull
    4. 460 magnum
    5. 44 magnum
    6.Glock 20 10mm

  • @rebelbaron7003
    @rebelbaron7003 Před rokem +1

    RW....honestly,I dont see where velocity carries weight in hunting bears at all.
    A .30-06 has more than sufficient velocity.
    All are close enough,penetration and knockdown power would be key for me.
    We are talking about an animal that if that first shot is not well placed or that bullet doesn't do enough damage is gonna FU up !!!!
    I want energy foot lbs behind me and the best constructed bullet in the market.
    There werent enough comments in the forum about bullet types.
    I believe caliber and bullet type go hand in hand.
    I was hoping someone who actually killed a Brown bear or grizzly and recovered the bullet would have chimed in.
    I seriously doubt most here have gone grizzly hunting,certainly not
    Brown bear hunting.

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před rokem

      I did mention bullet construction a lot. I agree that bullet type is one of the most important

  • @bustabass9025
    @bustabass9025 Před rokem +1

    Good choices. Any of 'em will put 'im to sleep. I always felt safe with my Marlin JM 336 carbine, chambered in .35 Remington as enough gun for anything likely to hunt me.

  • @stevenj2817
    @stevenj2817 Před 10 měsíci +1

    My preference would be a .300 RUM. It's in between a .300 Win Mag and a .338 is a flat shooter with a lot of retained energy at 300 yards.

  • @MangoMike316
    @MangoMike316 Před rokem +1

    😎👍👍👍😎

  • @toddminett7561
    @toddminett7561 Před 2 měsíci

    30-06, 270, 308, 300 win mag.

  • @ericfrontczak8016
    @ericfrontczak8016 Před 11 měsíci +1

    7 doesn't have the weight and lacks t H e frontal area same as 35 Whelan smacks harder than 3006

  • @tacticalmattfoley
    @tacticalmattfoley Před rokem +4

    A guy who went on an Alaskan "canned" Grizzly hunt told me they pulled up on a boat, spotted a Grizzly, landed, walked a couple a hundred feet and shot said bear from about 200yds away on the shoreline. He was using a 338-378Wby. Said the bear dropped on the spot. This was in 2000, so I'm assuming he used a bonded bullet of some kind. I'm guessing most guided bear hunts are similar. If so, any of the cartridges you listed would yield a humane harvest.

  • @aronkoppold3981
    @aronkoppold3981 Před měsícem

    35 whelen is a poor man's magnum and very effective

  • @hoffi9327
    @hoffi9327 Před 2 měsíci

    338win mag vs 9.3x62

  • @Kysushanz
    @Kysushanz Před 10 měsíci

    Well, mines bigger than yours, I use a .50 cal MG.

  • @aronkoppold3981
    @aronkoppold3981 Před měsícem

    Just get a 35 whelen and Bear Hunt

  • @PracticalRedneck
    @PracticalRedneck Před 6 měsíci

    300 win mag is more than enough

    • @nayrapepenova9325
      @nayrapepenova9325 Před 3 měsíci

      No a 300 is not more than enough gun. It's entirely dependent on your shot placement. A 338 and up are stopping cartridges. You want to use a stopping cartridge with heavy bullet on a grizzly.

  • @aronkoppold3981
    @aronkoppold3981 Před měsícem

    You can't shoot the big magnum as accurate as you can the old 30-06 no one can

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před měsícem

      Speak for yourself...czcams.com/users/shorts6h_2FTVhcUI?si=usXt1f8S5horsILx

  • @RobJamesUSMCScoutSniper

    fun fact, the 340 wby mag and the 338/375 ruger have the same ballistics, so with the 338/375 ruger u save money over the 340 wby mag... you're welcome

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před 9 dny +1

      Hmmm... not true. I have a 340 Weatherby

    • @RobJamesUSMCScoutSniper
      @RobJamesUSMCScoutSniper Před 8 dny

      @@ReloadingWeatherby you know you're right I was actually just reading more about it, and seems I was given wrong info, the 338/375 ruger is closer in ballistic performance to the 330 Dakota

    • @RobJamesUSMCScoutSniper
      @RobJamesUSMCScoutSniper Před 8 dny

      @@ReloadingWeatherby I now see why he said that. the guy with the 338/375 ruger claiming close to 340 wby mag has a 29'' barrel. maybe that makes more sense, idk, was just conveying what I heard

    • @RobJamesUSMCScoutSniper
      @RobJamesUSMCScoutSniper Před 8 dny

      @@ReloadingWeatherby just in case u didnt know, the 375 ruger holds 99 grs of h2o, the 340 wby mag holds 98 grs h2o, so says wikipedia. so I say the comparison is reasonable as its possible. remember its not a .375 cal in the 338/375 ruger, its a 33 cal

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před 8 dny

      @RobJamesUSMCScoutSniper FWIW my 340 Weatherby case is 101 gr

  • @jamespmullin21753
    @jamespmullin21753 Před rokem

    I haven't used in a few years, damn cancer.

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před rokem

      Sorry to hear about your cancer.

    • @jamespmullin21753
      @jamespmullin21753 Před rokem +1

      @@ReloadingWeatherby Only 9 treatments left out of 39. Oncologist says he thinks i'll be cancer free by my last appt, July 12. Looks like I'll be able to hunt again.

    • @ReloadingWeatherby
      @ReloadingWeatherby  Před rokem

      @@jamespmullin21753 Congrats!

    • @jamespmullin21753
      @jamespmullin21753 Před rokem

      @@ReloadingWeatherby Thanks Buddy

    • @jamespmullin21753
      @jamespmullin21753 Před rokem +1

      Almost ready to go hunting again. I will take 7mm Remmag and GP100 357 sidearm. They say I'm healed.

  • @b01tact10n
    @b01tact10n Před rokem +1

    Yes sir i agree with all your mentioned cartridges. Id never recommend the 30'06 to anyone because they do not make loads in the 200 and 220gr Partition.

    • @SamLloyd-fp8dq
      @SamLloyd-fp8dq Před rokem

      Lol Remington makes 220 grain for 30-06. Try and fail again.

    • @b01tact10n
      @b01tact10n Před 11 měsíci

      @@SamLloyd-fp8dqthere is corelokt 220s , but ive used 180 Partition exclusively along with the 200, and 220semispitzer is what I would recommend. I've never used the Barnes bullets for hunting anything due to the fact that why change what works well for me for over 30 years.
      I get as close as I can possibly get to attempt to make a clean headshots. The reason why I'd recommend the .338WINMAG because everyone I know take engine room shots from over 200yds. It's way too dangerous to get any closer than 100yds.

  • @SamLloyd-fp8dq
    @SamLloyd-fp8dq Před 4 měsíci

    Most Alaskans uses 30-30