I think TD was eliminated originally because they were considered overpowered, Teardrop was silent, but that also prevented her from being hated by other contestants as there wouldn’t be any arguments, and she also cooperates with her team well and does good in challenges. There would be no other reasons for viewers to vote her out asides from not speaking. If anything, it would have convinced viewers to keep her on with the hopes of hearing her speak for once. It seems that Cary and Michael chose to eliminate her for being very likeable.
i agree fully with this since why would pencil choose sb and endanger bubble her alliance member, plus the tiebreakers he won we’re literally just breaking a tie.
Woah another video!! You are pumping these out fast ngl. Also why are these always so much better then the canon elim order?? like this is like all my fav characters making it far omg This isnt really a suggestion, but i'd love to see a worst to best from you or a my way of any season you feel like.
THANK YOU! they are just so fun to make you know! also you literally read my mind cuz i’m working on a worst to best rn LMAO but i stopped for a little while as i continued my what if series and BFDRD 5 but it’ll be posted soon!
You forgot Golfball's Win token she received in BFDI 3 for getting the highest test score. (Assuming she didn't use it in BFDI 11 against Rocky in which Rocky would be eliminaed anyway)
This is a pretty cool what if Bfdi Video. I don’t know if you’re taking suggestions for a video ideas but I have one, What if Profily competed in Bfdi?
Great video and idea love it can u pin so no one will spoiler
you want me to pin you?
Yea no one will say like OMG td make to the finale
@@Pin-neddle yeah ok i did! good thinking
@@pencilsanimationare you doing Battle For Total Drama Extended (BFTDE) in summer 2024?
@@SmileyRobloxium what?
I think TD was eliminated originally because they were considered overpowered, Teardrop was silent, but that also prevented her from being hated by other contestants as there wouldn’t be any arguments, and she also cooperates with her team well and does good in challenges. There would be no other reasons for viewers to vote her out asides from not speaking. If anything, it would have convinced viewers to keep her on with the hopes of hearing her speak for once. It seems that Cary and Michael chose to eliminate her for being very likeable.
i agree fully with this since why would pencil choose sb and endanger bubble her alliance member, plus the tiebreakers he won we’re literally just breaking a tie.
@@pencilsanimation my vid is already at BFDI 18
@@pencilsanimation before today it was at BFDI 13
I thought they eliminated her bc they had no plans for her; they weren’t gonna do anything with her.
@@pencilsanimationwhy did he choose snowball she should’ve went with HER ALLIANCE!
35:08 Dotless Dicey😂
Suggestion: What if Spongy and Balloony were in TPOT, with two other characters from TPOT being in post split instead?
Woah another video!! You are pumping these out fast ngl. Also why are these always so much better then the canon elim order?? like this is like all my fav characters making it far omg
This isnt really a suggestion, but i'd love to see a worst to best from you or a my way of any season you feel like.
THANK YOU! they are just so fun to make you know! also you literally read my mind cuz i’m working on a worst to best rn LMAO but i stopped for a little while as i continued my what if series and BFDRD 5 but it’ll be posted soon!
I actually like this version more. Td and Gb staying for longer.
yessss they should’ve stayed longer
Everyone forgot that firey switched teams in before the 3 team phase
You forgot Golfball's Win token she received in BFDI 3 for getting the highest test score. (Assuming she didn't use it in BFDI 11 against Rocky in which Rocky would be eliminaed anyway)
you’re right
How do you keep coming up with this stuff?! Your a great theorist and just keep being a good person! Excited for the tutorial vid :D
Awww your the sweetest!! thank you 🙏🏽 the tutorial video is coming in a few hours!
37:40 she got a vote in the thing where only firey was safe
oh yeah ur right! that means she’ll be even less targetted
Here’s a suggestion: What if the Grapes were on a losing streak instead of the cherries?
OHHHH that's so interesting! will do!
Teardrop went from getting eliminated before the merge to making it io the finale
YEAH SHE HAD SO MUCH POTENTIAL
@@pencilsanimationWHY DID PENCIL PICK SNOWBALL SHE SHOULD’VE WENT WITH HER ALLIANCE
You forgot to give tennis ball points in the challenge after the rejoin
oops
Not the pencil gets "rewarded" I hate that she won for nothing
10:14 Golf ball Turned to Bozo 💀💀💀
LOL
I love this theory idea ❤👍
tysmm!!
I liked this and do this in bfdia but like match is on the team of new people cuz it has to be equal then other old contestants on the other team
oooo interesting, sure!
Didn’t pin say in bfdia that teardrop is her friend?
This is a pretty cool what if Bfdi Video. I don’t know if you’re taking suggestions for a video ideas but I have one, What if Profily competed in Bfdi?
i am and that’s pretty cool!
Thanks!
@@adventuregamingkidd of course
...he did?
He did but nobody could see him.
hey man what app do you use to edit
“Powerpoint” for the actual video, “Capcut” for the editing (music), check out my “How to make a What If video” for more tips
What's the name of the song that plays when you reveal what contestant is getting out
home - were finally landed
If I created BFDI, I would make Bubble the real winner
I would too, she's my favorite on every single season of BFDI! (Minus TPOT because she has had 0 screentime. TD is my favorite in TPOT)
If I created BFB, I would make Teardrop the real winner
@@Usamapper-o7p I would be happy with that because Bubble is the only one that I like more than Teardrop.
Thanks
Next what if do what if the alliance was never made
Yo which editor do you use?
it’s in my other video! it’s called capcut.
@@pencilsanimation Holy shit, how do you edit so good with Capcut?
@@Lefty2763 oh ty lol idk i be very precise with my audio placements
@@pencilsanimation I thought it was powerpoint
@@Coffeeytbh yes, powerpoint for the actual video/what if and capcut to add video effects and atuff
Fiery couldn’t switch in ep.7
thats an exception
I had this idea and i even requested neverbutter to do it
OH WOW luckily i did!
Great video! Yes I am very late
it’s okay!! and thank you so much
Cool! Can you make Bfdia with flower, leafy and bubble present? I want to see how this turns out, (not including woody)
OOOOO it’ll go in my ideas list :)
@@pencilsanimation You need to also find out how leafy wouldn’t steal dream island that caused leafy to go to yoyleland.
@@bfdileafyfan yeah it probably will be a sequel to another video!
@@pencilsanimation do one if armless people could bowl
this might change everything quite a bit
@@Diamond-OSCandMarblestuff oooo yeah
I respect this channle because it's named after me
hahahahaha yessss
@@pencilsanimation respect earned from the one and only 😎
@@Pencil_Freesmart glad it was from my fsvvv
@@pencilsanimation yep 🥰🥳
Love this video wish this was real
so do i.
Eraser had 2 win tokens at this time id imagine he would use one and survive over match
oooo i didn’t think about that! i need to be more careful with wintokens then.
@@pencilsanimation i mean he would only have 1 as in this world you made the Cherries got 2nd in BFDI 10
@@Diamond-OSCandMarblestuff yeah
@@pencilsanimation also i'm unsur if GB would use her win token in this world
golf ball would’ve still left before merge
If her team lost again yes, but they don't in this video.
3:52 that is not what escaping the bottom two is
yes it is
@@pencilsanimation that is AVOIDING the bottom two, escaping it is being the last one safe
@@jpvera3042 but one of the bottom 2 leaves the team and one gets eliminated so it is escaping, escaping safely
@@pencilsanimation don’t you remember the time Two said “With Fanny narrowly escaping the bottom two for the second time!”
@@jpvera3042 but when i said it in this video had a different system then TPOT
If you couldn't switch teams, that means episode 6 wouldn't happen.
wdym?
Why? It was just teams in teams. Not switching teams.
Okay.
@@pencilsanimation i'm doing my version :)
@@Diamond-OSCandMarblestuff ooo nice!
5th liked