Rush - Neil Peart Drum Solo (Live In Frankfurt) REACTION & REVIEW! FIRST TIME HEARING!
Vložit
- čas přidán 11. 09. 2024
- Rush Fans....Neil Peart Fans.....FEELIN' YOU!!! Tonight we're coming back to Rush, with a spotlight on the legendary Neil Peart as he performs a drum solo. How's this one gonna go? Only one way to find out...
Come on in, enjoy the show...I'll see you inside.
Scoring System Guide
10 = Perfection (Unobtainable)
9.0 - 9.9 = Awesome, Amazing
8.0 - 8.9 = Great
7.0 - 7.9 = Really Good
6.0 - 6.9 = Pretty Good
5.0 - 5.9 = O.k.
4.0 - 4.9 = Not So Good
3.0 - 3.9 = Pretty Bad
2.0 - 2.9 = Really Bad
1.0 - 1.9 = Horrible, Awful
0.0 - 0.9 = A Travesty, An Affront To Nature
Link to Original Video Here:
• Neil Peart Drum Solo -...
My Patreon Page, where you can MAKE REQUESTS (As a Bronze Tier Member or higher) as well as view ALL the videos I try to post that CZcams is forced to block, can be found here: www.patreon.co...
(Please note, you must be at least a Bronze Tier Member to be able to make fresh requests. All requests must be made on the Patreon page.)
My Twitter: / bassist4aw
My Instagram (I've just started learning how to use it): / davidheretic666
Our P.O. Box (yeah, we listened to you all and we got one):
P.O.Box #355
19360 Rinaldi St
Porter Ranch, CA. 91326
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. I have no intent on claiming this music for my own, I'm simply reacting to the video and giving my constructive criticism and feedback. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS
FINALLY - someone who acknowledges and points out the beat Neil is maintaining with BOTH FEET while his upper extremities are totally independent and free forming. That has ALWAYS been what most impressed me and I have yet to hear a reaction channel point it out. GREAT REACTION 👍 DH
I've heard some come close. they'll say: look he's using his feet too.😊
@@cecillegravelle2590 I agree… It’s never mentioned enough! Total limb independence! All 4 limbs keeping different times! Be well, my RUSH family friends! #RIPNEIL
Yeah only one other person I’ve seen point out his feet and hands are in different meters, and that guy was a jazz drummer. Kudos.
Yup. That foot cymbal (tamborine?) he does blows my mind every time...
Yeah absolutely. And he’s right that is the hardest thing for a drummer to do IMO.
A drummer uses a metronome. A metronome uses Neil Peart.
A true percussionist..not just a drummer. Master level.
Instant like! It's not a drum solo it's a drum concerto! African drumming,two kits acoustic and electric,also xylophone. Crossover in arms,waltz feel with feet while playing different rhythms. then ending with big band style with the gong patch. The end 👌
Neil didn't feel this was one of his best performances as he had the flu! That's for the excellent breakdown, not being a musician myself I learned alot from your reaction. Cheers
Just like when I requested Eddie Van Halen last month I was worried you would have already seen this knowing you are a rush fan when I requested it. So glad you hadn't. The reaction was so awesome! I've seen this reacted to multiple times but you are the first to point out how what he does with his feet is equally as amazing if not more so than everything else he does. One of my favorite reactions. Thank you so much!! Stay awesome.
His limb independence is unmatched
As a drummer and a fan of Neil Peart I was excited to watch this even if I have seen it many times. It is so much better to see than to hear a drum solo. Kudos to the drum tech that had to setup for him. I had the privilege to watch him live back in the 1980's (yes I am old). I have never seen Buddy Rich live but if that was his idol then I could only imagine seeing him play back in the day. Thanks for doing this video.
He is triggering those Midi sounds with the cymbals. There is an excellent CZcams video of him at a show soundcheck explaining the triggers and other effects to someone interviewing him. The solo he is demonstrating in that video is the same one he's playing here. He even explains the spinning drum kit, pausing between parts to explain how it's done. You're an inquisitive guy, it seems and you obviously have an eye for details. Let Neil explain it to you himself in that vid. Sorry, I don't have the link but it's not hard to find.
I think that video is from the RTB tour. Great video.
doesnt hid drum tech have a midi rack behind neals drum kits where he changes all of the mdid sounds. i am pretty sure neal doesnt change any of the midi sounds. i dotn think neal plays toa click track .
czcams.com/video/Nd2hRpVFRTQ/video.html&ab_channel=floyfo
NEIL KILLED IT. The beginning of this solo is all types of paradiddles. Very cool. I saw him 14 tours and he was perfect Everytime! Better Everytime!
«No changes are permanent, but change is.» & «We're only immortal for a limited time.», Neil Peart
DUDE!! Even though you're a Bassist, you're the FIRST Reactor I've seen (out of about 200) to Notice that he used the MIDI Pad as a High Tom! PLUS, YEP, You Called It!!!!
There is a great video of him doing a tribute to Buddy Rich. He helped put the concert together with other drummers and during the concert he does Cottondale and it's great.
@David McGlocklin most people doesn't no,that Buddy Rich's Daughter,is the one who came to Neil Peart,and asked Neil to set up everything during the (BURNING FOR BUDDY RICH TRIBUTE!)
and it has been said he was feeling sick at this concert. still puts on this great show. AMAZING.
Got to see Rush 13 times and the solo was never the same! He always was improving and adding to it!
My first and only favorite drummer. Loved RUSH since the late 70s.
As others have commented, Neil is triggering all sounds from different points around the drum kit. During the solo, his drum tech (Lorne) is manually switching the patches to get the correct programmed sounds for each section of the solo, and to hear Lorne tell it, the timing was crucial and hectic in parts. There are great videos out there showing the setup of the kit and breakdowns of how the solo was composed and constructed, with great explanations of the techniques and exercises being showcased and which parts allowed for improvisation each night during the performance.
czcams.com/video/Nd2hRpVFRTQ/video.html&ab_channel=floyfo
The 3/4 obstinate under all the crazy hand stuff ( including varying time signatures) always amazes me. His newer solos started incorporating a Latin flavored obstinate. There are so many amazing drummers but Neil's solos are the most soothing to the ears. Some guys throw tons of chops or speed but Neil's are like songs. This one goes from early tribal history to big band ( with lots in between)
I am so thankful I was able to see Rush and this solo just once.. It was like a fireworks show
I have been a drummer for 40 years now and I have to say your reaction was spot on. Great video!👍🤘🏻🔥🎧
Glad you finally got to hear a NP solo. Impressed that you gave a more detailed technical analysis of numerous points than any other reaction I've seen, even "drum teacher" channels.
Outstanding reaction/review David. I have never been a big on drum solos myself but I can appreciate them and I can watch Neil all day. Thanks for doing this, Peace.
There's a brief shot of Buddy, during the solo. It's a known fact that he was one of Neil's inspirations. You should check out his cover of "Cotton tail".
Neil wasn’t just a drummer he was a composer. I can’t say if he was the best over all,but when it comes to composition and execution you would be hard pressed to find someone better. At least in the rock genre.
"I don't really care for drum solos, and I'm not a drummer."
**proceeds to give THE most in-depth, insightful analysis and commentary on this performance BAR NONE on CZcams**
AND you spotted Buddy Rich up on the screen. Yes, this whole solo was composed as a journey through the fundamentals of drumming with a particular focus on homage to Buddy Rich, who was indeed one of Neil's idols.
Well done, sir. Well fucking done.
Thank You @David Heretic !!!!!!!! Neil Pearts Abilitie to be (INDEPENDENT) Between his feet and arm's,is truly MIND BLOWING!! That Takes Extreme Talent!! (ITS DEFINITELY A GOD GIVEN TALENT!!!)
I'm always amazed at the time keeping underlying the flash as well. Here's an in depth explanation from the man himself...short version is he's triggering not playing along.
You gave the best breakdown of his drum solo. And I have watched a lot.
In his mid 50s here and keeping this energy up for the nearly three hour show 😃
One additional comment - the section where you commented on his feet keeping perfect time during that "1-2-3, 1-2-3"; that was Neil's tribute to The Drum Also Waltzes, a Max Roach song that was also famously covered by Bill Bruford.
As for the triggers there are 6 he's using during that segment (after the crossovers) 2 V-Drum pads on the left. 2 V-Drum pads on the right. 1 pad just above his snare (11 o'clock) and trap at his left foot.
Neil would tell you... it’s all about your practice ...practice is training...”Neil is the only person I know who rehearsed for rehearsal”
Geedy Lee .. Bass Player, lead vocalist and piano player. RUSH
Thank you! I'm not a drummer, but I have watched a number of drummers analyze this performance and none of them mention the feet or how "the things" work. I appreciate that very much. I'd noticed the feet and was looking for recognition that what he was doing was amazing.
❤❤❤❤ RIP , Professor
Awesome work by Peart there. He does things no other drummer would ever consider. As good as this is, his solo on Rush in Rio is even better.
He was a drummer of drummers. A one man drumline. RIP Professor
Awesome breakdown bro!!!!!!!!! R.I.P. Professor
The triggers are the roland drum pads. there is two over the floor toms on his left and one next to the floor tom on his right when playing the Roland Kit.also he has a paddle on the floor next to his bass drum paddle.. Credit go to his drum tech Loren Wheaton who off to the side helps to switch all of this . By the way the kit takes almost two hours to set up.
My very first concert was Rush, Grace Under Pressure tour, 1984. I was 16 and already an obsessed fan.This was the year Neil incorporated electronic drums (Simmons pads in those days) and built his first hybrid kit. I got to see Rush at the Pacific Coliseum in Vancouver and in those days, Neil did in fact spend a portion of his performance with his back to the audience whenever he switched from one kit to the other. I don’t know what year it was when they finally built him the turntable riser, but yeah bro I was there at the start of the concept ✌🏻🤘🏻👍🏻👋🏻🇨🇦❤️
Edit: Neil’s tech Lorne Wheaton activates the triggers when needed, but Neil controls them
Great very detailed reaction. Would love to see more of Neil Peart's drum solo reactions from you such as time machine tour "moto perpetuo" and clockwork angels "the percussor". There are like none reactions to these especially in comparison to this r30 drum solo.
It’s not as much about Niel’s speed and timing as it is about his creativity. Look at how Niel brought the “drum solo” to the audience. With the pounding bass drum at the beginning to the melodic xylophone to wowing you with his double bass and high-hat work to the horns he triggered at the end. His creativity in the songs he plays with Rush is like no other I have ever heard or will hear again. Whether he's the GOAT of drumming or not, that’s all subjective. I’m ok if he’s not considered “the best”. I just know what his drumming does to my sole. When Niel is playing with the band, the seamlessly smooth transition to the next phrase of the song is largely (but not solely) Niel. RIP.
Near the end, when Neil flipped one of his sticks in the air, Niel caught the drum stick the wrong way (With the but end out), But he immediately noticed this, flipped it around with his fingers on one hand and, even after this, he left himself with plenty of time for that next “hit” on the symbols. This is why he is called the professor. He didn’t even panic. He just knew how to get the job done and he did it. Effortlessly.
You nailed it. Great analysis. Most reactors would look at the Mona Lisa and say Wow that is really cool painting. Damn! Leonardo was a good painter. But you did the very best review of this video EVER.
Wow, I think this is the best, most comprehensive breakdown and reaction of this performance I have ever seen. 👏👏👏 Thank you so very much 🤘👍
What you witnessed is the living breathing example of hard work and focus. All the real GOATS have this in common .... great review
Neil was good friends with the buddy rich family and was asked by his widow to play with the band at a tribute concert. There is a video of it and I believe an interview of him talking about it
His performance is probably my favorite video of Neil. Just seeing him behind that little kit and playing with the band was so cool to see. What I love most about it was his face. You can see how much he loved what he was doing. I'm sure you know, how concentrated Neil always was during a Rush show. It was rare to catch his smiles and relaxed is not the word to use when describing him during a show. So I guess it is nice to see him just enjoying himself. ♥😊
In reference to the triggers, he is hitting his Roland electronic toms and he is also hitting a small electronic pad just above his snare. For the last section he programed the big band music to play along with. All the sounds were done by him using the electronic pads and his foot triggers. Very musical for sure.
Fantastic review of ‘The Professor’!
You KNOW your shit! Love this reaction man. I as a Rush fan even learned a lot from your reaction, that I did not know before. So thank you for that. For the record, I have always (still am) been wondering about his triggers for the big band section. XD
Yes he's got at least one trigger to the left side of the chime his left foot. Look up Neil Peart plays Raw no background and he explains where his triggers are. Definitely has at least one on the side of his chirp chirp pedal. All the sounds you hear he makes like the symbols combined with a sound he knows to hit that one to do that like when he goes to the swing mode. By the way he's not just a drummer he's a composer. Of course he had Idols initially Buddy Rich which he hosted and played in a tribute video that he learned from. I believe the foot chirp the independent playing of the limbs Freddy Krueger help him with that
Best review ever of the best drummer ever
One thing to remember also about the digital triggers, is that it let him GREATLY reduce the size of his kit. In the 70s and early 80s, every sound you heard in that solo (bells, marimba, chimes, tubular bells (not in this performance as I recall) he played then all, physically analog with the same proficiency (obviously not the brass samples and band loop)... kit was MASSIVE compared to this. He'd stand, grab mallets for bells, play temple blocks, full size floor gong, literally while the drumkit was spinning he be playing chimes and bell trees in the transition from one position to the other... a legend.
Great reaction. This is the best reaction I’ve seen to this solo. It’s a bassist you sure seem to know a lot about drums. I’ve seen supposed drum teachers react to the solo and that point out at 10th of the things that you did. And you were spot on regarding the difficulty doing the kick tambourine tambourine independently from the hands. I also agree with you regarding the who is the better drummer argument. Neil Peart, John Bonham, Phil Collins, and buddy rich were my idols when I became a drummer. I love Danny Carey also and I could go on and on. It’s hard to explain. They are each completely different but fantastic in their own right, if that makes any sense.
Yes it is the pulse of what he does. Nice that you noticed ... wait till you hear what he says about it look up a work in progress
Great job! No other reaction channel had ever pointed out the "right hand" sound.
I think it is his feet for the music. Seen Rush 9 times his kit kept getting bigger at 1 time he had chimes also.... Crazy good Him Bonham and Moon are the goats!!!! Yes Buddy Rich, Max Roach. Neil worked for years to make his feet and hands independent
The Rush album 'Hemispheres' was all about the two halves of Neil's brain which independently controlled his hands and his feet...probably.
I was privileged to see that solo live in the UK and the Netherlands.
there is a foot pedal that changes the midi cymbals to be either a cymbal or a horn or a combo horn with a light cymbal during the hit. it was all Neil. live play.. not pre programed. now the video behind him was started. however during the video playing some how Neil plays the licks on the drums exactly like and when the drummer in the videos plays the same lick. Now either Neil starts the video with a foot pedal or his crew starts the video... I think the crew does that but only neil can know the timing to match it.
The swing part is from a Buddy Rich tribute consert he was part of, I'm sure you could find it if you want to give it s play through.
Great reaction. Thanks. Really enjoyed they. I’ve watched a few reactions to this and I learned some new stuff with your reaction. Personally I like both drummers and appreciate them both for different reasons. They have their own styles. They used to play together in California. I could be wrong but I think they jammed with Stewart Copeland in someone’s basement when they all were together at home.
Great reaction David
Since you enjoyed this so much, and you're into Big Band jazz, you ought to try the "Burning For Buddy" series produced by Neil Peart. He gathered together some of the greatest drummers (including himself) to do covers of big band tunes that Buddy played on. There were two CDs made in the 90s. Check them out.
What’s more amazing was he had just had his first round of chemo the day before this. The man was incredible.
@22:22... he does hit the hats with both left and right.. he just don’t really cross.... look again.
Slow mo if you need but he definitely hits with both L & R
Fun fact: Neil Peart is your favorite drummers favorite drummer.
What you thought were roto toms, are actually tightly tuned 6, 8, and 10 inch tom-toms. And no, there is not a Gibraltar rack. Drums and cymbals are on DW hardware screwed into his riser.
Not pre-programmed, no click - the cymbals are his horn triggers. Yes, Buddy was one of his idols, notice his little 6" splash cymbal on top of the kick, just like Buddy.
Neil was more sophisticated then the other & more talent then them & his drums always sound diferent. Go and listen more from rush and listen how he remember so many trasition he play'd in every song. He was a real professor.
I think Neil's lyrical talent informs his drumming: not many drum solos feel like a story! Probably the reason I don't often enjoy drum solos is because they don't seem to have context, beyond being demonstrations of technical skill strung together in time. I mean, I appreciate technical mastery, but, musically, there should be additional...dimension, I guess. Did you know both Neil and Buddy Rich died of brain tumors? Some might implicate "infrasound"...chronic exposure to very low frequencies has been linked to a varieties of injury. Great review and score, Dave!
His limb independence came through a process he called, "Breaking the Time Barrier".
Changed his mind in 21 seconds.
The trigger are in the cimbals and there's a vídeo explain that and activarse the trigger with the left foto. There's no number one are top one's in their styles, and Neil was called The Profesor.
This was a concert during the Frankfurt Music Fair, many musicians among the audience.
I heard Neil explain that he has several triggers around the kit, triggering samples he created. Originally, he used Count Basie sounds, but felt guilty about using someone else's music.
I saw it in his 1992 drum clinic. Someone has extracted the relevant section.
czcams.com/video/Nd2hRpVFRTQ/video.html
I am not big on drum solos either but this is not a drum solo, this is a drum song. I do love great drumming but like guitar solos I could do without the "indulgence" ... this has none of that. and yes it is insane how independent his feet are, they are perfect.
I love "unless".
Saw this solo live
I saw this in Montreal Forum
In addition to the visible triggers/digital drums, several of his actual toms have the guts of Roland triggers custom built into them as well. There are of course several CZcams videos on his kits over the years including one that is with his drum tech breaking down the specifics back about 10 years ago. The only part he actually plays "to" is the final jazz loop that he triggers the start of. He rarely played to a click especially in the last 15 years or so, in the 80s when they (the band and he) triggered a lot of loops, or had continuous video to sync with, he would, but he didn't really like having to.
And now you know why he was known as "The Professor". Period. Oh, BTW, the midi was triggered by a pedal kick.
Great reaction and review! I have watched every single reaction of this solo that I have been able to find. A few of them were by drum instructors or drummers. Your review is by far the most in-depth and you did an amazing job of pointing out the the key parts and explaining the skill required. Neil Peart is one of the greatest drummers of all time but he was much more as well. He was a percussionist a composer and a lyricist. To me all of those things together is what makes him my favorite drummer. Thank you for taking the time to do such a thorough review. As others have mentioned his performance with the Buddy Rich band is amazing and something that you would most likely really enjoy considering your appreciation of jazz and swing. I know I would love hearing your reaction and review. m.czcams.com/video/aT9333XiR4U/video.html
Another video to watch of him is while his favorite tom is being fixed or replaced. And he doesnt miss a beat while its being put back on by his drum tech
I saw Rush 15 times and always looked forest to this
Have a look at Terry Bozzio's drum-kit. INSANE!
RIP NP, the best. . . Ever.
A huge miss the the rock world ,2 years this month
he is using his pads to trigger the orchestra patches. Ive seen Rush 30+ times and the drum solos always made the shows complete!
He is playing the triggers with his right foot and pads. The tones are changed by his drum tech.
Danny Carey even Said Neil Peart is his favorite drummer!!!
Triggers at the end are definitely with his left foot
You should watch Masters Of Resonance if you are into drumming ,amasing documentry.
The answer to your question regarding the triggers for the big band sounds can be found at the 46:00 mark of the following video: czcams.com/video/0DXnd-B-t6s/video.html
After seeing this now i want to see a reaction by you in the future to a Kai Hahto drum cam (the current drummer of Nightwish). Nightwish song Weak Fantasy and Wintersun solos are great! He is a bit isolated in the ones with Nightwish compared to former drummer Jukka because the latter the OG one who part of the ambiance and showman just as much as other members. Technical wise though...anyway below the most popular ones...
Nightwish - Weak Fantasy
czcams.com/video/FbWzilsAOYs/video.html
Nightwish - Stargazers
czcams.com/video/3Euvf6MgcBY/video.html
Wintersun - Sons of Winter and Stars
czcams.com/video/tbb8m3wNXbs/video.html
Wintersun - Time
czcams.com/video/AZxk6fsjFi0/video.html
The end swing music is triggered 1 time and the rest plays in its entirety I really don’t know that he uses triggers after the program starts if he does it’s between him and his Tech.
Great solo
Amazing, right? I love the part when he's playing together with the Jazz band. Such a great moment. #NeilIsTheMan!
Here is that video that Neal Peart explains his solo.
czcams.com/video/Nd2hRpVFRTQ/video.html
You missed the stick break, it's hard to see it, tosses the right stick to the left hand and picks up a new one with the right not missing a beat. I believe it happens right at the the cross over section you first hit on and why he skipped the over-under at the beginning of that section.
Horn triggers at the end section
Dang.