For real. Makes you feel incredible. Too bad knowing what we know now about hollywood i could only imagine what these kids have seen just searching for a singing dream 🙏🏻
I can't believe it's been 8 years and I can't get over this performance of her. I rewatch and rewatch it as many times as I could. Carly, you're soooo goooood!
When I first saw this on TV, at 2:19 and 2:53, those vocal runs made me really sit up and pay attention to this girl...this performance was the only performance from X Factor that I still remember to this very day. AMAZING.
@@kingskid1985 That one she did at 2:31. Fairly simple, but she makes it so fast you can barely hear that she slips 10-12 (I litteraly have trouble counting at 0.25 speed) notes in about 1.5 seconds lol
kinda wish she went on the voice instead. she would have blown all the judges' minds. her control of her voice and the way she knows how to use it is crazy for someone so young. she's incredible.
***** you know all my friends thought she was 16-17 when I let them hear the audition, but when I told them she was 13 they were surprised, she's just amazing.
***** I disagree. The Voice has failed to produce big stars. Cassadee Pope must be the only Voice contestant that got a successful career out of The Voice. With X Factor, on the other hand, we got Emblem3, 5H, Bea all on the charts and they're all from the SAME season (and same season with Carly!). With good promotion, I have no doubt Carly will be on the charts as well. Besides, Carly's performances on X Factor got way more views than the majority of The Voice performances. If she was on The Voice, I don't think her performances would get as many views and that is, I believe, because of the team behind X Factor that helped made her performances so great. The Voice might have some better coaches but remember that coaches/judges don't do all the job, there's still a team behind them that does most of it and X Factor's team does it better!
now I understand why Britney was hesitant to push Carly through because she knew what it’s like to be in the music industry at that age and nobody knew all that Britney went through
+joe ruby But the thing is they all have different styles of singing. Its like comparing apples and oranges. There is not one style of singing that people aspire to have.
It’s been almost a decade and I’m still blown away by this girls talent. The fact I don’t hear from her now breaks my heart because she’s phenomenal. I hope you’re doing well Carly rose! I’d still pay a lot of money to hear you sing girl!
10 years later and this is still one of the best live performances on the entire series. Her voice is shockingly perfect. Her tone and execution are above most professionals. She is a prodigy.
i was 14 when this was aired, and now im 21 and i still come back to her performances. cant believe its been 7 years and i still cant get over how good her voice is
I come back to this performance every other month or so. i really wish she did a full cover of this song!! i can't get enough of it. She's crazy amazing!!!
they edited everything to make them look like they hate each other, you can watch the blond girl's video (bea) and they show like carly doesn't like her. also bea was feeling sick during this.
SAME HERE. i wish she would have made a full version back thing, singing it just like this. i love the one she did recently but holy shit this? and the last run… are you fucking kidding me?
The fact that she didn’t win her season is BIZARRE!!! That was stolen from her and it’s a shame!!!!! Her voice is beyond amazing and her runsssssss 💜💜💜💜
WHAT THE ACTUAL FUCK DID CARLY DO TO GET SO MUCH HATE? Carly is truly a nice person. She is determined, not moody. She is very sweet in person. Wouldn't you give it your all to win? That's what she is doing!
La reed made sure she didn't win cause he wanted Tate to win and fixed it to happen and Leanne rhymes made her lose with her drunken performance when she sang with carly
She should have Won but that country man didnt want to lose to a child and I think she lacked the strength to face the pressures. I wonder what shes doing today! i was just watching law and order and she was on their! i miss her
She is beyond incredible, it's unbelievable. And she'll only get better if that's even possible for her. The other contestants are talented as well but no one is in Carly's league. The level of control she has of her voice is at a professional level already. She is better than the people even judging her, not sure how those two can even try to give advice to someone who's talent far exceeds their own. Simply spell bounding.
Carly has talent, but she's just a little girl without a real music career. So, I'd say the greatest pop icon after Madonna can still give her advice on how to have a real career, can't she? I mean, Britney is still in the industry after 14 years and she's already been on top of the world, and Carly....what has Carly done since the X factor? Is she touring the world, maybe, and I missed it?
6 years later & i still always find myself coming back to watch all her old X factor videos. can’t believe how fast time flies. i hope she gets so famous some day and puts out so much more music. i miss her so much 😭❤️
Laying here and this audition popped up in my mind this song gets me in my feels 😢😔still 9yrs later 2022 and still can’t get over this version she’s amazing!!
I have to Watch this every now and again to remneber that the voting clearly is not legit on these shows. Never heard a voice as good as hers in all of these shows history what a loss to music for her not being signed immediately
+Tyrone McDonald She will get a record contract but she said she wanted to finish school and get an education first. Im pretty sure she had an agreement with simon to go into the industry after school.
+Gray Scheff Yea, she may not be ready yet. Britney knows the industry and made a comment that in her opinion, Sonenclar may not be able to cope with the pressure at that point.
all the judges say that. "I just hope they can deal with the pressure". Which is true, some people definitely deal with pressure better than others. I think she has an excellent voice. wow!
This actually had me tearing up a bit because it was just so beautiful. Lol Like, omg. I wanted her to win since day one though. She'll have her moment one day. Bet on it.
Who’s here in 2024? 🎉🙋
Here
April 2024. I’m here too.
April 18th 2024✨
April 22nd 😢❤
Me 4/22/24
Til this day I think Carly deserved the record deal
she has one soooo
Sadie Goulooze ooh glad she does
Life with Thalia Shes signed with syko but she wanted to finish school first
aw thats good
+Marco Creen Nope it's really Syco music.
11 years later. And i still look for this performance every once in a while
Same. Lol. And she was so young too. Talent!!
Same
Same
Same
For real. Makes you feel incredible. Too bad knowing what we know now about hollywood i could only imagine what these kids have seen just searching for a singing dream 🙏🏻
I can't believe it's been 8 years and I can't get over this performance of her. I rewatch and rewatch it as many times as I could. Carly, you're soooo goooood!
Same.
Somehow I thought of this
Same
girl me too!! I remember when this first aired on television and I wass blown away! I still get chills every single time.
GIRL. SAME. GIRL!!!!
Diamond was the only one admiring Carly for her talent and not worrying about the competition.
I love Diamond White
They edit it to make it look a certain way it's not what actually happened most of the time
Dan and Krypto watch Beatrice millers video about X factor she talks about why she's making faces.
Agreed
Dan and Krypto i know right, she was so kind!! She even smiles and said "WHOA" and I agreed she's so amazing
It's been 4 years, and I still can't get over her and her voice.
Same here!
maria fernanda morales ...
5 years now lol
It has been 5 years, and I still can't get over her not winning
6 years for me 🤷🏻♂️
Who is still watching in 2020?
ME!!!
😂👀👀👀
She’s the best voice this show ever saw
@@matthopkins8222 X Factor USA 3 seasons? I'd say YEAH!!! Who else was eve
Oops!! Who else was even any good? I liked Panda, the young black guy, that cute short hot little mustang.
Her vocal run on “I can’t seem to let you go” at 3:05 is absolutely INSANE. I’ve replayed that line about a thousand times.
This is a church run 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
When I first saw this on TV, at 2:19 and 2:53, those vocal runs made me really sit up and pay attention to this girl...this performance was the only performance from X Factor that I still remember to this very day. AMAZING.
And at 13!!!! I just know her voice is perfect at this point🔥🔥🔥
@@kingskid1985 That one she did at 2:31. Fairly simple, but she makes it so fast you can barely hear that she slips 10-12 (I litteraly have trouble counting at 0.25 speed) notes in about 1.5 seconds lol
YES. Probably the best thing I’ve ever heard honestly.
The CONTROL of her voice she has at THIRTEEN is sooo unbelievable. I'm soo jealous
she's 15 now! :)
I meant when she sang this...I dont care how old she is now...
ok sorry smartass
kinda wish she went on the voice instead. she would have blown all the judges' minds. her control of her voice and the way she knows how to use it is crazy for someone so young. she's incredible.
***** Yes! The Voice is so much better, and that's why I watch it, not X Factor. Her voice was so mature for a thirteen-year-old.
***** you know all my friends thought she was 16-17 when I let them hear the audition, but when I told them she was 13 they were surprised, she's just amazing.
***** I disagree. The Voice has failed to produce big stars. Cassadee Pope must be the only Voice contestant that got a successful career out of The Voice. With X Factor, on the other hand, we got Emblem3, 5H, Bea all on the charts and they're all from the SAME season (and same season with Carly!). With good promotion, I have no doubt Carly will be on the charts as well.
Besides, Carly's performances on X Factor got way more views than the majority of The Voice performances. If she was on The Voice, I don't think her performances would get as many views and that is, I believe, because of the team behind X Factor that helped made her performances so great. The Voice might have some better coaches but remember that coaches/judges don't do all the job, there's still a team behind them that does most of it and X Factor's team does it better!
true, I personally think xfactor is more entertaining than the voice myself. but to be fair, the voice does have a large audience too.
TowelBowels i agree
now I understand why Britney was hesitant to push Carly through because she knew what it’s like to be in the music industry at that age and nobody knew all that Britney went through
This makes so much sense!
Yeap
Most definitely protecting her. ❤
This will forever remain the best vocal performance that exists
🗣🗣🗣🗣!!!!!!!!
Truth! Ever.....❤️❤️❤️❤️
Truth. But then realising that she was singing grown up lyrics
👍👍👍👍
stay optimistic 😊
She have the most beautiful voice in the world. i'm so in love seriously
ndk2k4 The worst part being that he wasn't even a decent country singer.
Branden V yeah, I would have been fine if he was something special. Carly has a voice that is one in a 100 million.
The funny thing about it is she,s better then both judges put together
Right 😂😂😂
+joe ruby But the thing is they all have different styles of singing. Its like comparing apples and oranges. There is not one style of singing that people aspire to have.
+Garhon Wong I think he mean vocal technique, then yes, Carly is way better than those 2
That's not surprising at all.
lol yup
It’s been almost a decade and I’m still blown away by this girls talent. The fact I don’t hear from her now breaks my heart because she’s phenomenal. I hope you’re doing well Carly rose! I’d still pay a lot of money to hear you sing girl!
I Agree...i feel same
Shes got a youtube channel
I’m pretty sure she landed a record deal but wanted to finish school first
Right on 💯
Same
Watching til now 2024❤
She can legit SING. The other kids sound alright. But her voice is so strong. She has emotion. I love it.
It's so hard to believe that she sang this live...it's fucking outstanding. It's like it's been recorded in a studio it's that perfect.
I totally agree. Couldn't said it better myself.
not outstanding its outJUMPING :D
2021 and I still can't get over 2:31
Or 3:05 👁👄👁
Omg SAME!!! I’m not even sure if she knew that agility was gonna come through like that.
SAME
literally
2:15~2:20 for me
10 years later and this is still one of the best live performances on the entire series. Her voice is shockingly perfect. Her tone and execution are above most professionals. She is a prodigy.
WTF how is she so good
yeah she is
aliens
dragons
Reptilians
julian apel cyclopes
Fuck. Thirteen? Who the hell sings like that at thirteen.
Carly Rose Sonenclar sings like that at thirteen
+SunburntComposer The only other female singer that I can think of that could sing that amazingly at age 13 is Judy Garland
JoJo had an ablum out at that age
Well she had vocal training before auditioning
+SunburntComposer Angelina Jordan
Who's still watching in 2024 😅
I wish I could buy this version of the song. I love her voice and her rendition.
It’s on Spotify! :)
@@jadele111 THANK YOU. I keep trying to recycle this version
@@jadele111 not anymore :(
She’s re-recording a new version for the 10 years anniversary she been on X factor…. Check on her insta
she’s releasing it on spotify this week!
Her voice is a blessing, got me in tears, incedible
*Incredible
OMG BEAUTIFUL👍👍👏👏👍👏👍👏👍👏👍👏
+Brianaliz Moreno true!!!😭😭😭😭👏👏👏👏
Me too
She didnt Loose x factor, x factor lost her.
Who did she “loose” with?
Lose*
You right. I stopped watching x factor after this season.
i was 14 when this was aired, and now im 21 and i still come back to her performances. cant believe its been 7 years and i still cant get over how good her voice is
ur 21 and ur names lisa nation which means ur an immature lizard on twitter ewwww even worse u stan a black fisher grown as hell
Sadly, she didn't get famous. Apparently all u need to be successful in the music industry is beauty and good connections...
she is releasing her new rendition on spotify 16 sept!!
the control and clarity of her voice is AMAZING!
I come back to this performance every other month or so. i really wish she did a full cover of this song!! i can't get enough of it. She's crazy amazing!!!
Kaolag Xiong She did include the rap part in some of her live performances
i agree. she really did a beautiful job with this song.
I loved her so much then cece frey much better pitch and control loved it.
+scanlon1201 she was way better than every other person on that season definitely the only reason I watched.
ikr its like, damn she just that good i keep wishing there was more !!
SHE'S THE BEST THING TO COME THROUGH THE XFACTOR
Agreed
3 seasons of X Factor USA, yeah probably yes. Definitely in my Tops as favorites .. worldwide.
nopee.. go check louisa johnson
Gkampriel Tsetsos I LOVE Louisa Johnson yet Carly is better than her.
@@MinusMask no she is not...
2021 and I’m still obsessed with the way she covered this song!! 😭❤️
UPDATE: 2024 and i’m still here!🥹
It’s been 7 years, and I still can’t get over her and her voice. Who’s still whatching in 2020?
Febuary 2021!!!!👍👍❤️❤️❤️
@@tuamigamoni yessss
september 2021
December 2022
I just love how humble she is.
It's fun to look at the other kids. They are thinking, "Shit, we have to beat this girl":-)
So true😂
Right
actually only the blond girl looked jealous,the black girl and others were just admiring her,atleast that was what it looked to me
they edited everything to make them look like they hate each other, you can watch the blond girl's video (bea) and they show like carly doesn't like her. also bea was feeling sick during this.
I agree didn't you see the blond girls face?! Haha
Still on repeat of 2023- for this young lady and now, young woman. A-Mazing 👏🏾 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
SAME HERE. i wish she would have made a full version back thing, singing it just like this. i love the one she did recently but holy shit this? and the last run… are you fucking kidding me?
@@morganbarfield108czcams.com/video/ZbQMCFknS4c/video.html
The fact that she didn’t win her season is BIZARRE!!! That was stolen from her and it’s a shame!!!!! Her voice is beyond amazing and her runsssssss 💜💜💜💜
I completely agree
everyone comment about carly's voice and i just be like... "wtf, i want a house with that kind of view" 😂
tho😂
Her voice is pretty, but nothing special when you compare it to other voices in The Voice and X Factor....but the house....man, that's special.
Surya Jaya I'm sure Britney wanted that house too because it wasn't her house LOL! It was a rental
Surya Jaya aahahahahah omg u just kill me, i notice just now and i want to
YOU GET ME.
WHAT THE ACTUAL FUCK DID CARLY DO TO GET SO MUCH HATE? Carly is truly a nice person. She is determined, not moody. She is very sweet in person. Wouldn't you give it your all to win? That's what she is doing!
Why have I been watching this for 9 years
Same here luv.. same here
2024 and still keep coming to watch these videos of her!! Still one of my favorites! 🫶🏼
Carly straight up killed this audition
I think she should have won.
La reed made sure she didn't win cause he wanted Tate to win and fixed it to happen and Leanne rhymes made her lose with her drunken performance when she sang with carly
So does everyone else in the world.
She should have Won but that country man didnt want to lose to a child and I think she lacked the strength to face the pressures. I wonder what shes doing today! i was just watching law and order and she was on their! i miss her
I agree
She should be the singer of cartoon characters.
Anyone here in 2019? She got it ✊🏾🤞🏾💖
🙋🏻♀️🇧🇷 i love her
🥰
I loved her back then and still doooo 😍👏🏽
*2022 anyone?*
You know that a performance is so good that after all these years, you're still going back to see it again.
still one of the best voices I've ever heard!
Jonathan Gurley still
You havent heard a lot of voices I guess
I come back to her every time
Me as well so beautiful !!!
I still can’t get over how insanely talented she is at her age - the control here is flawless, I could watch this performance all day
it has been 9 years and I still can't get over the fact that she didn't win that year!!!!! It was criminal!
Her voice gives me goosebumps
bea over there lookin jealous but she actually dying of a heat stroke 😂😂😂😂 me
Ikr😂
She won lol
Still watching in 2024 I cnt get tired ov it
I still listen to this.. and its 2019!
Where's our studio version? 😅
Lol the girl should be the mentor to both of them
ikr
for real lol
Carly Rose Sonenclar for Judge on one of these singing shows.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
4 years later still loving this...gets me so emotional
I’m still here in 2021 she a straight beast I swear
2022 and still very good
She's a dragon for real.... Wills face at the end of the performance is awesome.
He was seriously impressed. Surprised even. His interview on here somewhere about Carly explains just how much.
I dont know how many times I watched this video. Love her and this song!
Mizz Foyt I feel like it's better than the original
To this day, still the best audition ever👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾!!! Would’ve given her the record deal right there!
3:10 ..... those runs though?!!? LIKE HOW!!!! It's like impossible!
She sings with her heart ...love it ❤️
Oh my god
she's so amazing
Watching in 2024.. real ppl real talent...were are we at in this world today in music?
I still come back to this
This is magic....
She is beyond incredible, it's unbelievable. And she'll only get better if that's even possible for her. The other contestants are talented as well but no one is in Carly's league. The level of control she has of her voice is at a professional level already. She is better than the people even judging her, not sure how those two can even try to give advice to someone who's talent far exceeds their own. Simply spell bounding.
Carly has talent, but she's just a little girl without a real music career. So, I'd say the greatest pop icon after Madonna can still give her advice on how to have a real career, can't she? I mean, Britney is still in the industry after 14 years and she's already been on top of the world, and Carly....what has Carly done since the X factor? Is she touring the world, maybe, and I missed it?
Nephania Black she did tour last year and met fans and she's been working in the studio apparently
6 years later & i still always find myself coming back to watch all her old X factor videos. can’t believe how fast time flies. i hope she gets so famous some day and puts out so much more music. i miss her so much 😭❤️
Yup!! I must have watched her audition dozens of times.
2023 & I’m still here for this moment 😊
From a caterpillar, most turn into butterflies, but this one turns into a DRAGON! lol
😂😂
Thunder Paw AJ Ha ha! It was so much funny! But seriously talking, she is fucking AMAZING!
Thunder Paw AJ lol,it's true tho xDD
Thunder Paw AJ so true
One of the best auditions of all times...
Been 7 years and I still go back for more, chills every time
Same here.
Laying here and this audition popped up in my mind this song gets me in my feels 😢😔still 9yrs later 2022 and still can’t get over this version she’s amazing!!
I have to Watch this every now and again to remneber that the voting clearly is not legit on these shows. Never heard a voice as good as hers in all of these shows history what a loss to music for her not being signed immediately
Exactly!
I could not agree any more . .
+Tyrone McDonald She will get a record contract but she said she wanted to finish school and get an education first. Im pretty sure she had an agreement with simon to go into the industry after school.
+Gray Scheff I think your right can't wait for some of her music
+Gray Scheff Yea, she may not be ready yet. Britney knows the industry and made a comment that in her opinion, Sonenclar may not be able to cope with the pressure at that point.
i wish there was a full version of this song sung by carly. love this version
I'm now 72yo and I still get a bit weepy when I hear her Vocals. Congratulations from New Zealand 🇳🇿 👏 ❤️
This short cover of broken hearted was and still is soooo good!
Her CONTROL
Britney Spears should be the last one to say that she couldn't handle the celebrity life.
lol haha... she cant sing at all at her live performances shes totally lip singing lol haha
i think she's just worried about her coz she seems sweet and innocent , we all know what happened to Britney before ..
Or maybe the first one to say that since she knows how hard it is since she could not even handle it? :)
I know right lol
Anastasia Michaelsdotter people like you make the world go on. you're amazing :)
her runs are so beautiful , her melody is sick . 🥺 she deserves a lot . 💯
Its so rare to find a singer who sings with their entire being in america. With their raw feelings and soul.
1:39 if you are listening to her on repeat.
Thanks Kyla Mahoney much appreciated
linda :-*
Thanks!
Kyla Mahoney theres one with just her vocals instead of the interview
Kyla Mahoney Ha! Thank you..
all the judges say that. "I just hope they can deal with the pressure". Which is true, some people definitely deal with pressure better than others. I think she has an excellent voice. wow!
Her control, pitch, runs and timing!!! Flawless. Sublime.....
This still gives me chills
why r u not a star yet? im still checking up on u ill never forget about u
She need's to be 18 before getting a contract or else they can't sell her body to the public. Therefor, two more years before you will here of her.
Jessy-James Vachon tell that to Beatrice miller whos already selling her body
She has a contract with Syco Music but she has been taking her time to finish and show her album with great songs :)
She in Broadway now
And she goes to school still too.
Wow, no I got chills. That was amazing. She is very talented and I hope she becomes super successful.
8 years and still coming back to hear it from 1:39 👌🏻
I was 14 when I first watched this. It has been 10 years. Damn. She's really good.
This actually had me tearing up a bit because it was just so beautiful. Lol Like, omg. I wanted her to win since day one though. She'll have her moment one day. Bet on it.
Literally when she opened her mouth I felt this sense of comfortablility in my body like a comforter. So brilliant
Who is watching during the quarantine?
ffs idiot
@@ksksdjjd2254 "ffs idiot" 🤪
Hello
I am. She’s amazing. I’m jealous.
@@emmy4537 are you still in quarantine?
Its December 2019 and still think this girl should've won it. Keep coming back to hear her
Britney is the mentor and the girl is better then she...
+Mary Beatrice gotta agree
So true
Britney be like... "Ooooo Gurl you ain't no competition" *banshee screech*
+Mary Beatrice I wanna know why Britney always talks and sings like she got a scratchy throat.
hahahahaha so true
Goosebumps every time I hear her sing this song.
almost 10 years after, and Im still here
Almost 2020 and I can’t get over all of her performances
September 24, 2021 and feeling the same.❤️😻
The pace songs are so amazing when they are sung very slowly lol Like this one, made me emotional
fast pace*
I have never heard anyone sing a better rendition of this song ❤ I can't get over her voice!
I love how her friend just watched in admiration and not being a hater. She is proud of her friend and happy for her. Very sweet.
6 years later and this is by far my favorite x factor audition