OSEE GoStream Kit versus ATEM Mini/Pro
Vložit
- čas přidán 19. 07. 2024
- This kit was given to me free of charge from OSEE in exchange for making this video. They did not tell me what to say, have not paid me further, and have not reviewed this video prior to posting. All opinions shared here are my own.
In this week’s episode we provide an overview, not a full review, of the OSEE GoStream Kit - a livestream studio with a switcher/deck and a 14 inch monitor in a hard Pelican-style case. This little livestream switcher supports 5 sources (4 HDMI inputs, a USB input, NDI source, or playback from an SD card), along with the ability to power the kit via USB PD battery bank, cine battery, or AC power. Let’s see how it compares to the very popular Blackmagic Design ATEM Mini and ATEM Mini Pro.
If you’d like to learn how to make great dialogue audio for your film and video projects, please have a look at my courses including processing dialogue audio in Adobe Audition and DaVinci Resolve/Fairlight, recording sound, how to use the Zoom F4, F6, F8, and F8n, and how to get the most from the Sound Devices MixPre series of recorders. Our latest courses cover Sound for Live Streaming with the ATEM Mini and an Intro to Izotope RX. See school.learnlightandsound.com for more info!
Support my work creating videos by donating at Ko-Fi.com: ko-fi.com/curtisjudd
Gear used or mentioned in this episode. The links below are Amazon.com, B&H Photo, Sweetwater, or other affiliate links. As an affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases:
- OSEE GoStream Deck - Amazon geni.us/xAJpmz
- OSEE GoStream Kit (with the monitor and hard case) - Amazon geni.us/ut47DA
Some of my other studio gear:
- Earthworks ETHOS microphone - B&H, Sweetwater, Amazon geni.us/8G8UdBB
- Sound Devices MixPre audio recorder - B&H, Sweetwater, Amazon geni.us/O8e0
- Sennheiser MKH50 microphone - B&H, Sweetwater, Amazon geni.us/iYb065
- Impact Turtle-Base C-Stands - B&H, Amazon geni.us/8a8tt
- Aputure LS 600x Pro Bicolor LED Light - Aputure, B&H, Amazon geni.us/EreRQa
- Aputure Light Dome III Softbox - Aputure, B&H geni.us/AVHU1p
- Amaran 300c RGBWW Single-Point LED Light - geni.us/uGkDX
- Amaran Spotlight SE - Aputure, B&H, Amazon geni.us/4DuyTz
- Rosco Prismatic Glass Gobo in Cool Lavender - B&H geni.us/GWKt
- Canon C70 Cinema Camera - B&H geni.us/ABYB
- Canon RF 24-70 f/2.8 lens - B&H, Amazon geni.us/qwsEs
- Panasonic GH5 camera - B&H, Amazon geni.us/InspOl
- Panasonic 12-35mm f/2.8 II lens - B&H, Amazon geni.us/gr47
The intro and outro music for this episode is from Musicbed - “Dynamo” by Virgil Arles. Take your films to the next level with music from Musicbed. Sign up for a free account to listen for yourself: geni.us/G7by
Copyright 2024, Curtis Judd
#OSEE #GoStream #livestream
Index
00:00 What is the GoStream kit?
00:29 Similar to ATEM Mini
01:04 Who this kit is for
01:47 Inputs and outputs
02:42 Powering options AC, DC, USB
03:50 Fan & chassis & monitor
04:03 More on who this is for
05:33 Who is it NOT for?
05:48 What’s included in the kit
06:01 Mac, PC, Companion control apps
06:34 SD card recording and playback
07:13 Macros to automate things
07:28 Manual control of color format and luma range
08:13 Stream to 3 destinations at once
08:48 Audio inputs
09:07 Headphone output for monitoring
09:57 Configuration audio offset for sync
10:55 T-bar!
11:39 Supersource - multiple inputs on screen at a time
12:27 Build quality
12:48 No audio processing
13:23 No audio meters on control app mixer page
13:40 Cannot add case without deck
13:52 Control app is not as mature as ATEM app
14:00 App walkthrough
15:35 NDI sources!
17:24 GoStream versus ATEM Mini
18:30 Please buy my courses
Update: There is an active, private Facebook group dedicated to the OSEE GoStream for those who work with the GoStream.
Hi Curtis, I'd love to hear your impressions and realworld reality check of the 32-bit audio feature on the Lumix GH7 with the updated audio module 💎🦘
@@fellowcitizen Me too! First camera that can record 32-bit float (with an attachment).
DSLR Video Shooter was ahead of the curve making his diy version back in the day. Cool to see companies making it a final product with a screen you can buy
Agreed!
Hey Curtis, I wanted to express my gratitude. I finally bought the OSEE after carefully studying it for some time. Your video was the final push I needed to make the purchase. Thanks for your help!
Happy streaming!
Another excellent video. One tidbit if I am not mistaken is the most recent firmware update for the Osee allows you to also record to an external USB drive.
Cool!
Always ready for all hr videos ❤
🙏
Thank you for another great upload Curtis 👍
👍
So Curtis, I tweeted out OSEE and asked my question. I got a reply: "Hi Matt, We have a plan for the Duet with Kit. However, it really takes time and costs more. But yes, it will be available in the future."
Thanks Curtis a great video. I'd love to see a deep dive.
👍
Excellent overview! Yes, OCEE is something us streamers want to know more about ...
👍
Thanks for the video. Do you know if they are working for something similar for SDI setups?
Yes, they have a new GoStream Duet deck with SDI inputs, though I don't believe they have a kit yet with that version (monitor and hardcase)
Thanks, Curtis. I am glad to see you review this unit. I bought the original deck earlier this year and ended up returning it after being disappointed by the audio quality - I could only get rid of a nasty buzz with a ground lift on a DI box and felt like the unit really cut out the low end of the audio signal as well.
Curious about your thoughts on the audio quality?
I run my audio through my camera which has pretty decent audio converters. My take is that audio inputs are an area for Blackmagic Design and OSEE to improve.
Is there some kind of cover for the ports on the back of the case to protect them during transport or are they always exposed?
I'd love to learn more about this :)
👍
Really cool. For $900, it's a good pitch. What I'd really like this for is a go-bag for an operator who needs to record a guest (with a presentation) for a conference. Stick a camera and a Wireless Pro on it and you're golden.
I wouldn't use it for much else due to the audio limitations. If it could handle an interchange with an audio mixer - XLR, MADI, Dante, whatever - then that would be great. As it is ... I rarely have livestreams simple enough that two mics would cut it, and I wouldn't use 3,5mm cables even if I did.
Perhaps a future iteration will incorporate pro audio connectivity.
Nice compact system for live streaming. Question: Why don't these products have xlr inputs for microphones?
I wish they did!
This is great Curtis, how would you say it compares with the Atomos X Cast? I acquired a X Cast as I currently own a Ninja V, and it made sense for the rare occassion I might need to do a stream. However, this unit looks perfect. One thing I'm particularly in is the fan noise, I still haven't got to the bottom of whether it's my unit or if all Atomos Ninja Vs are as loud as the unit I have, however I do find the fan noise sometimes is a real detractor of good quality audio if in close proximity to the unit, if the GoStream is quieter then I'd definitely be interested.
It is definitely quieter than the Ninja V. That's the main reason I stopped using ATOMOS recorders unless they're off in video village, at least 5 meters from the microphones on set.
@@curtisjudd so I take it my unit is not broken, they're all this loud? Good to know. Well definitely keep the GoStream on my radar.
@@HumblyNeil All the Ninja V's that I've used were ridiculously loud.
Really nice device! I currently use OBS proxy + Atem mini. What obs proxy does intuitively is to add support for multiple views with many different gadgets (text, web/html/scripts). For example, outputting local time clock is of interest to me if there is a schedule in local time and audiences may be in other locality. “Next talk begins 14:00” is easier understood if the wait screen includes the clock :) currently working on some 12 video edits and thinking about how to make life easier. I kind of want to remove obsproxy from the workflow to get one less place to push buttons. Less risk of messing up if only one device to manage.
So, OBS Proxy is sort of like a supersource plus has various plugins like timers?
I like that... if the price ever comes down just a little bit. I hope to get one.. that is neat
I think the GoStream is better than the ATEM. The Kit is a great Idea but they just released a GoStream Duo, which I would want as it has 4 SDI and HDMI. You can also use the Macro/Companion to switch between SDI and HDMI and can, with planning, basically give you 8 inputs (4 SDI and 4 HDMI).
Yes, looks neat. Would love to see it support 8 inputs natively and fit it into a kit like this 👍
You can also record to a SSD with the usbc input. It records one input of your choice and you can also use the usbc to add a hotspot. Overall very cool but I really want iso recording. The other thing is I Already use DR for editing and the atem pro iso makes those files for you to take into DR ready to go.
Thanks Curtis for a very clear and concise comparison. I have one question for you. I do corporate training and I have a very sophisticated set-up, including the basic ATEM mini. I facilitate very complex sessions, using a 3 camera set-up and multiple info sources. Why do you use an ATEM Mini Extreme, with 8 inputs, when your set-up looks much less complex than mine? What am I missing? Thank you, as always, Peter.
Hi Peter, I typically have 6 sources: main camera, live chat, iPad with slides/agenda, computer for demos, overhead camera, and hyperdeck with background animation for the super source where I combine the slides and main camera over the animated background. I don’t know that my setup is complex, but it does consist of 6 sources.
@@curtisjudd Hi Curtis and thank you for your prompt response. Straight away, I can see what I am missing: Simplicity! You have a complicated set-up, but it looks simple - Perfection!!! I began livestreaming at the start of COVID and, then, I did not even know what a preamp was used for! Over time, I developed a set-up using a combination of the ATEM, various input sources, glued together with OBS and controlled via a Stream Deck. This set-up allows me to do super sourcing via OBS. I am really happy with it and it works fine, but it is very complicated to work out the solution to a problem caused by an OBS update etc. If I was starting out tomorrow, I would probably buy an ATEM Mini Extreme as it would facilitate super sourcing and it would facilitate the design of a far more simple solution. Thank you for your response and I always appreciate the content in your videos. Cheers, Peter
@@petermcginty3636 Thanks Peter! Yes, we all learn. I've iterated through several overcomplicated setups so I definitely hear you!
The links don't work this side of the "pond" so checking, can you input 4K over the HDMI or is the input still restricted to FullHD?
I didn’t realize this takes the processing away from the computer that changes my thoughts on these, I’m looking at the black magic stem mini pro iso because it lets you record multiple cameras and audio separately. Does this allow for something similar?
This does not currently support iso recording. I will record one channel (presumably the program in most cases).
Is it possible to make the audio source sticky? I would like to use the xlr inputs on my C70 but be able to switch to powerpoint on my computer while keeping the audio from the C70. I am currently using a Ninja Cast and have found the video quality for a computer to be so low as to be unusable. Did you see any video quality issues from a computer source with this unit?
I read the manual and see the answer to my first question. I am still curious about the video quality from a computer.
I have had the standalone version of this since before the app came out, and I have to say, being on their Facebook group, they do a lot of firmware updates. I suspect they will aggressively update the app and keep adding features. They have even released a version of the Decl that has an additional 4 SDI inputs.
Yes, the pace at which they're developing this is impressive. 👍
What are your thoughts on this versus the Yolobox Ultra? It's less expensive but doesn't offer ISO recording.
If you need ISO recording then the OSEE is not an option. I haven’t tried the Ultra, but I’ve had all sorts of software/firmware issues with the other Yoloboxes. Maybe they’ve fixed the issues by now, but as recently as early 2024, I wasn’t impressed.
@@curtisjudd Thanks for the quick reply. I've had pretty good luck with the Yolobox Pro. Though I use it mostly as a switcher and we on rare occassion stream from it. This is not something we do a lot and ease of use and less setup is important to me. So the ATEM gets too complex with the necessity of a laptop and additional screens to see what you switching. An all in one seems more up my alley.
@@OrigEntertainmentOfficial Glad to hear it fits your needs! 👍 Happy switching!
I recorded a few clips on an SD card but it would not play on my Mac. Is there a reason for that?
Not sure. Probably should contact OSEE support.
@@curtisjudd Thank you
If you fed analogue audio from, say CEntrance's English Channel, would that solve audio issues and provide needed flexibility?
Yes, if the English Channel has all the processing you need 👍
Can you Test IT with the VDO.ninjia ?
How so? Does VDO.ninja now support NDI?
@@curtisjudd they support webrtc but much better to handle than the proprietary NDI. Up to 4K extreme low latency and high quality audio. Works P2P. And most important, compliant to European privacy laws.
@@DanielaTocan Cool. As far as I'm aware, the GoStream cannot receive a VDO.Ninja stream, if that's what you're asking?
@@curtisjudd Yes... i look to get something with obs together. in fact in case of Zoom to stream to youtube. in princible i bought VST connect from Steinberg to get a reasonable audio quality. the zoom quality and skype you can forget. i like to give you a use case.On sundays after yours 1 hour livestream. Its just easy in the Livestream you can post a romm in the chat you have build up. and we can than hang out a bit for talk each other. share experience... show gears we have and so on...
Not available in Europe. And Amazon as Warehouse is not something where i would buy.
Damn that's a shame, I was getting really excited about this product.
Similar to Samyang etc, OSEE goes under a bunch of different names, I think that’s their US name. CVP has another brand name for their brand iirc. Haven’t searched myself but the annoying “different brand name in different stores” can mess with searches.
@@randomgeocacher Good to know, thanks!
@@randomgeocacher yes i know
Thanks for the callout.