I-TRINITY | ITZY VS (G)I-DLE VS IZ*ONE - Ranking Group Songs in Different Categories
Vložit
- čas přidán 8. 06. 2024
- I-TRINITY | ITZY VS (G)I-DLE VS IZ*ONE - Ranking Group Songs in Different Categories
Need to remember that this video is not made for fanwars between midzy, neverland, and wiz*one. This video is made to appreciate the best aspect in all of these groups songs.
The different categories are
1. Pre-Chorus
2. Rap
3. Choreography
4. Music Video
5. Concept
6. Chorus
7. Line Distribution
8. Bridge
9. Dance Break
10. Views
Tell me your opinion about ranking group songs of all these groups but before you give your opinion, make sure you love & stan all of these three groups to prevent biased ranking.
Hope you like this video😀
Please subscribe & like for more videos like this
Thank you so much for watching🥺💞
#itzy
#gidle
#izone
#itrinity
#4rdgengg
Chapters
0:00 - 0:10 intro
0:11 - 1:38 pre-chorus
1:39 - 2:55 rap
2:56 - 3:38 choreography
3:39 - 4:15 music video
4:16 - 4:54 concept
4:55 - 6:23 chorus
6:24 - 6:59 line distribution
7:00 - 8:43 bridge
8:44 - 9:47dance break
9:48 - 10:29 views
10:30 - 10:50 outro - Hudba
![4th Gen GG Ranking In Different Categories 2021[IZ*ONE, ITZY, (G)I-DLE, EVERGLOW, AESPA, LOONA]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wlT-4lrckbg/mqdefault.jpg)
Well in rap, I couldn't agree more!! Jeon Soyeon, Queen Rapper of 4th Generation Kpop Girl Group!!
What do you mean couldn't agree more? The creator put gidle no 1 in rap
@@leofrant7471 Oh, it's not a negative comment... I mean I totally agree, Soyeon is the best rapper
@@leofrant7471 you misunderstood dude
@@checkmateyourhighness1047 she should say I couldn't disagree more, who is misunderstood here
@@leofrant7471 nah man, we be writing like this. Couldnt agree more= the maximum point we could agree to a statement or situation 🤔 It also creates another meaning but as she praised aswell we can say she meant that in positive way (-▽-;)...
Regardless any of the other new, big, popular groups coming up... aespa, ive, nmixx, lesserafim, regardless of all of these... the I-trinity will always be the best of 4th gen! The most creative, the most talented and the pioneers of the next era of kpop! Absolute legends (G)I-DLE, IZ*ONE & ITZY
and everglow... Period!!!!
Super duper agree🙏
(G)i-dle getting recognized is the best thing. After all false allegations and such bad mistreatment from the company, they still came up more successful 😭 ot6 forever. If they were from big3 then they would have been such a successful aswell as famous group
If I-dle was part of the big 3 it would have been a waste of talent since they probably wouldn't have the authorization to create their own music.
@@davidmonnier2856 oh- facts 😂
Fun fact:
I-dle is cubes most successful group
Ikr!
@@davidmonnier2856 probably still possible for yg/jyp tho, just look at ikon and stray kids. both have self producing members. but yeah not so much for sm
(G)I-DLE🔥❤️💜
Yes!
Princess 👸 of kpop 🇰🇷🎤💜
(G)I-DLE is QUEENS
Good ranking, but I have to disagree with the MV and Chorus, for me Idle MV’s are something else, just Oh My God by himself is pure art, and even with a low budget video they make it iconic, Latata for example, they filmed it in a warehouse with makeshift lights attached to a truck, and even so it is one of his most representative videos, As for the chorus, they all tend to be repetitive across all bands, the difference is that Idle's always leave an impact, let's take Oh my god, Lion, Hann, Hwaa and recently Tomboy for example, as for the bridges, so on a regular basis the voices of Miyeon and Minnie always stand out in an almost seductive way, but in all cases it is only a matter of personal taste, I personally find Idle's proposal more attractive, since their music is not focused on dance, it is more looking for the artistic side of them as performers, always leaving their mark even in the B-Sides, and live stages (with some of the most iconic ones I must say), and then composing, writing and producing their own music is always a plus..
I totally agree with you
though I understand the video author points and think this ranking is not bad at all
In matter of taste and art I do prefer I-DLE
I agree for me Idle is smt different they have such an amazing discography i can find smt for every mood and all the MV suits it perfectly with still showing Idle personality. I absolutly love how artistic and cinematic Lion is. Best mv for a side track.
@@orinarose8397 The producer line definitely leave their signature, and that is certainly reflected in their sound, Lion is simply a gem, both MV and sonically, Idle is simply one of a kind...
GIDLE OMG was nominated for VMA lol
Unnecessary comment but *itself
Oh my good was amazing
No one can match gidle's versatility 💜
@Medic Blackpink? The group that has been doing girl crush since debut? No hate to them, they always deliver when they comeback, but they are far from the most versatile group
@@marcelo335 medic is a blonk... no wonder they said nonsense =_=
@Medic They never did anything more than i am a powerfull solo girl with an attidute xd U would actually see if only they make more music. Idle is the real group of artists not dolls to do what company tells them to
@Medic uh
Ikrr
Miyeon+Yuqi=Best pre-chorus
I love Idle's MVs!! it's not just about the quality of editing and transitions, the way the song is conveyed through the symbolisms and story line, pure art ✨But yeah, I like ITZY MVs too, they're so catchy and fun to watch
Nobody :
(G)I-DLE ANOTHER LEVEL 🤘🤘🤘🤘
QUEEN
i think comparing these groups is really hard cause they all have vastly different concepts. itzy is a performance based group that tries to make the individual members stand out in their own way. itzy's members are all super different in the way they perform but the members' individuality is what makes them stand out. iz*one on the other hand is very clearly going for the image of elegance and perfect synchronization. their choreos are like an art form and it's super impressive how they all manage to keep up with each other and stay synchronized despite the difference in skill. (g)-idle looks to me like their focus is on the music itself. they have a different concept each comeback and manage to pull every single one off really well.
(G)I-DLE 🥰👸🤗💞🤟
*G IDLE* ✨👸🏻
Gidle The Queens.👑of 4th gen
I dle supremacy
idle and different, they have the same vibe as mamamoo... always bringing something new and they know how to use their vocals in an attractive way. and nobody's touching soyeon when it comes to rap 👀👀
Yeah if someone talks about rap “Soyeon” will always at the top👑🤟
I have found someone who actually have a sense in music.
Mamamoo and G-Idle all the way. Red Velvet too are pretty awesome when it comes to music.
In my perceptive, Gidle is queens of Gen 4. She win in visual and talent 😊❤️ You can dislike them but can not refuse their talent and affordable
They are self produced queens that what makes them more special and worth stunning. I hope they will get more recognision and not disband after 7 years.
@@orinarose8397 yepp
imo i wouldn't give them the full title of "queen of gen 4" they are def one of them
@@Ja.de. If it comes to results in Korea they are definitelly Queens. They just couldn't get to the USA market because pnademic that cancelled their tour. But they will and it will be great.
@@orinarose8397 but there popularity has dropped a ton over time so im not so sure🤷🏽♀️
l like gidle mvs.their songs are really good and soyeon rap also make the song too beautiful. 🤩🤩
imo Iz*one has one of the best bridges ever in kpop. La Vie En Rose's prechorus is one of the best pieces of music i have ever listened. On the other hand, their choruses for me dont usually stand out. Sometimes too many things happened there
Gidle pre choruses connect well with the choruses but they dont stand out alone
Gidle bridge on tomboy is bop🔪
I love it but I don’t think it deserves to be ranked as one of the best bridges of 4th gg and please don’t attack me because I love them with all my heart 😭😭
IDLE
Iz*one is an all rounder group hehe
Any Wiz*ones here? 💙💙💙💙 Support all the members
👋✌️
Yo we all knew who was gonna be on top for rap. Soyeon the rap queen 👸🏼
WE LOVE OUR I-TRINITY!
Gidle always have miyeon and yuqi for pre chorus I noticed in tomboy oh my god and itzy have their best rap line ryujin rap u can see in their mv and yuna's rap in twenty is overflow 😭❤️
tomboy second prechorus is actually shuhua and miyeon. But lots of gg follows similar line distribution in their songs. It's normal.
People like to talk about rap line, so they dont have to include soyeon. But with "My Bag" Idle is gonna be first in rap line.
@@orinarose8397 yeah I like how shuhua got atleast average lines in tomboy 😭
@@executorkpop She is only a sub vocal with a lot of hate for her korean and vocal ability so she HERSELF asked Soyeon not to give her too much lines. All the part giving proces is a discusion between the members and if u want to hate smb for Shuhua getting fewer lines u have to critic all the I-dle
@@orinarose8397 okay 🙂
POV : Idle Queens of 4th gen
Muy de acuerdo con tu top, son muy buenos grupos mi top es I-DLE, ITZY y IZ*ONE, el hecho de que I-DLE cree su canciones y varíen en sus conceptos es lo que me encanta de ellas.
GIDLE OMG was nominated for VMA so GIDLE is #1 for MV
Do u know IDLE is queen of 4th gen?:)
yes! :D
YES✨✨✨✨💜💜💜💜
No
Yesssssssss!!!
@@mochiflake8694 welp now u know
I'm a neverland and I love this video 💗
Thank you so much
Yeah me too, everytime I see gidle at the top it makes my heart flutter and I can’t resist to smile 😊
ITZY deserved the top spot for choreography. Their dances are always insanely hard and incredibly precise.
Not to mention very catchy!
And they break peoples bones!
@@grahh__lol Lol🤣 they havent broken my bones still so im lucky✨
@@kayla_playz1026 lol
same with rap and build up
1. (G)I-DLE self producing 💜
For me MV ranking: 1.(G) idle
2.Iz*one
3.Itzy
Concepts: 1.Itzy
2.(G) i-dle
3.Iz*one
Agree with everything else!!
For mv itzy is best in mv
@@yuvrajjhori7625 Except the great edits, I don't see anything special in Itzy's MVs
So (G) i-dle still have the best MVs for me
Really 😂😂
i mean ur opinion but for me i like gidle concept more im not saying it only cuz im a fan of them but cuz they do a diffrent concept for every song and they make it look so good they dont have only one concept they try a new one for every song and i just love it :) (not hating on itzy or izone btw)
Gidle concepts are more versatile and they always come back with something new so I think gidle first with that one
I think this rank is fair
And well they're called I-trinity for a reason B)
But in my opinion I'd prefer ranking the song itself than splitting in part because it is about songs and a song is a whole, if some parts seem less they do have a purpose, this is why I prefer I-DLE, each song is a whole, each part is not here to stand out alone but to compliment itself and all other parts, and it is actually the same with the vocals and line distribution, I-DLE songs are known to be hard to cover for a reason, the line distribution is not about fairness but makes each part compliment itself and others
But I understand that some prefer "more fairness" over "choosing how to make shine each member even if that means less lines" both opinions are legit
I think Itzy should be first with choreography. But it’s your opinion 🤷🏼♀️
PLUS GIDLE SONGS ARE MADE OF THEMSELVES
(G)I-DLE queens 👑🤟
I-dle!
So pretty IZ*ONE ITZY and (G)I-DLE
I have weakness for (G)ı-dle✨💞😩
I'm so so see this positive comments gidle are the best love them Thaks for sopport them. Always nerveland. Only queens👈😎❤. And i love many Group too
I love it when they are compliment gidle in the comments
@@zealara8579 Yes me too
Gidle ❤️
I thought i was not going to like this ranking, but it was very well done and pretty fair overall. FYI, I am an GIDLE fan, but this was well done
Agree with everything except for the mv, in my opinion Idle has amazing mvs, better than the mvs of itzy
Icy and wannabe had amazing mvs, but all their mvs look similar to each other (maybe also because of the concept) that's why I like idles mvs more
Idle 4th gen queens 🔥🔥🔥🔥
I sometimes feel a bit diffrent, but i think its a really fair raking. God Video!
But why do you have a view ranking? :D
The thing about idle is they are unpredictable, the rest kind of stick in their usual concepts which there's nothing wrong.
I miss the I-trinity, but I couldn’t agree more, g idle has the queens of raps and vocals, izone has the queens of concept and Itzy has queens of dance and carisma. I personal think that Itzy are the 4th gen queens since Gidle lost their main dancer (no offense to their dance line, but it’s just not it) and izone disbanded (and even if it didn’t their company was doing our girls so wrong) anyways their were/are all amazing and I miss their sm, especially their colab stages, cause THEY ATE ALL OF THEM
GIDLE ❤️❤️
I love gidle so much
I’d definitely put Itzy 1. for choreo
As much as Iz*ones choreos are stunning and synchronized. Itzy’s choreos are on a whole other level.
They’re catchy and distinct, they capture the group’s concept perfectly, and are widely recognizable.
Plus extremely complex and difficult to pull off
Not only is the Itzy dance line insanely talented but they all have unique styles which makes their dances so fascinating to watch
There is a different with CHOREO and DANCE. Choreo is a whole group dance and formation. Iz*one totally grabs this instantly because they have 12 member and its easier to make more "stands out" choreo.
Itzy master in Dance line. But sadly this video only include Choreo and not a member dancing ability.
@@itztomato44 I get what you’re saying about the difference between dance and choreo and I accept that, although personally I still rank Itzy’s dances higher
No u don't have to explain about itzy in dance break bcoz they have a strong dance line
the queens of 4th gen
"Itzy have a pretty good rap line..."
Itzy rap line: All members
gidle forever no.1
You should do more videos ike that, I rally enjoy it!
The ranking was really not biased
It was super fair (imo)
Btw can you do:
Blackpink vs Twice vs Red Velvet vs Itzy vs Mamamoo (the top 5 most popular gg)
@LostOnes yes but they're still popular than most of the grps Google it
As a nevie I think it were really fair you didn’t mess anything
I miss Iz*one🥺❤️
ITZY💖
I-itzy forever✌️!!
I think itzy deserve #1 on choreo
I think you got mixed up with Choreo and Dance. Do you mean Itzy dancing abilities? If so Choreo DOES NOT mean that. Choreo is a dancing formation of a song for a group. Dance is individual.
Its clear Iz*one owned the choreo ranking. Sadly this video only have choreo and not dance
@@itztomato44 R u trying to say that itzy has bad choreo? What if they understood the meaning of choreo?
@@na_yu_ri And are you saying Izone have bad choreo? Someone gotta be last. Just because Itzy isn't the first doesn't mean they are bad. Yall delusional as fuck.
@@itztomato44 I don’t think they got it mixed up lol. I actually agree with them
@@ashtoncooper5478 Itzy choreo is plain and bland💀
I-TRINITY 4TH GEN LEADERS!!
IZ*ONE❤️❤️❤️
Please next IVE, Kep1er, Nmixx, lesserafim
Gidle songs are built around vocal tone and if they work in the song, not positions.
I miss izone so much ;_;
🌸🌺🌸IZ*ONE 🌹🏵🌹
think idle has better mvs, just watch OH MY GOD, also they have 2 nomination to mtv music awards for best video kpop
Hi! I know I made a request before 😭 but I want to make another one. Today, a group name Elast has finally released their new comeback. Would it be a good time to make a video of them? It doesn’t have to be this week or next week. If you can’t right now, it’s fine. You probably are trying to work on other videos ☺️.
Just in case you need their comebacks
- Swear
-Tears of Chaos
- Dangerous( does this one count too?)
-Dark Dream
-Creature
I agree with everything except, personally I prefer Itzy choreos to Iz*One.
I think big part why I-DLE is able to kill it with so many different concepts is the work Soyeon puts into creating their concepts, and the trust other members and the company have in Soyeon's artistic point of view.
She talked about this on I Live Alone/Home Alone in episode she did recently. She has started working on the concept of their next album. And she talked about everything she thinks about when preparing a concept. It's not only very intriguing and unusual, sometimes taboo ideas she wants to execute, but she also pays attention to every small detail making it all come together as a full package. She talks with other people on the company to make sure all of it comes together as a cohesive execution of the concept, MV, sets, outfits, hair and even their nails she has creative input in, so it all comes together.
I love her dedication towards the group and their success, she is extremely interesting and talented artist in much more than performing and music production.
prechorus:
3. izone
2. gidle
1. itzy
rap:
3. izone
2. itzy
1. gidle
choreo:
3. gidle
2. itzy
1. izone
music videos:
3. itzy
2. gidle
1. izone
concept:
3. itzy
2. gidle
1. izone (loved their fairy/elegant concept and how they developed their own sound in such a short time)
chorus:
3. gidle
2. izone
1. itzy (they always have addictive choruses)
line distributions:
3. gidle
2. izone
1. itzy
bridges:
3. itzy
2. gidle
1. izone (their SSOTS bridge is iconic)
dance breaks:
3. gidle
2. izone
1. itzy
views:
3. izone (I think if they were still a group today though they'd have better views)
2. gidle
1. itzy
(G)-idle forever and ever 😇
Ya pre chorus gidle no.1 cause their Main and lead vocalist always sang a pre choruses....slayed!!!! 💕
Miyeon literally makes da pre-choruses legendary…
I still love IZONE without taking any care of other peoples opinion
First tô comment
*to
second
CAN I MENTION SOME GROUPS WORTH MENTIONING WITH BEAUTIFUL UNDERATTED SONGS SUCH AS EPEX, MAJORS, PIXY, HOT ISSUE, BUGABOO, DREAMNITE, GHOST9, PURPLE KISS AND WEEEKLY NEW SONG VENPARA WITH A BADASSS CONCEPT SONG OF THE CENTURY
Idle definitely has the best MVs. Lion and Oh My God especially stand out
I will always be bias to gidle because they are literary my one and only but I agree to all of your ranking. The I-trinity really sets a high standard in 4th Gen girl groups. I- Queens👑
ITZY IS THE BEST
Their ranks
1. Itzy
2. (G)i-dle
3. Iz*one
literally one izone mv had cgi but ok ig
ITZY NO Limit
SECRET NUMBER,CERRY BULLET, ROCKET PUNCH
itzy forever queens
Shuhua never gets as many lines so your correct on that one
I miss izone
My opinion (I'm not really familiar with Iz*one tho so may be kind of unfair sorry) (also these may be very wrong to people who have experience as I'm not experienced in this industry)
Pre Chorus
3 - Iz*one
2 - G-Idle
1 - Itzy
Rap
3 - Iz*one
2 - Itzy
1 - G-Idle
Choreography
3 - G-Idle
2 - Iz*one
1 - Itzy
Music Videos
3 - Itzy
2 - G-Idle
1 - Iz*one
Concept
3 - Iz*one
2 - Itzy
1 - G-Idle
Chorus
3 - G-Idle
2 - Itzy
1 - Iz*one
Line Distribution (imma trust you)
3 - G-Idle
2 - Iz*one
1 - Itzy
Bridge
3 - Itzy
2 - G-Idle
1 - Iz*one
Dance break
3 - G-Idle
2 - Iz*one
1 - Itzy
Views (again just gonna trust you)
3 - Iz*one
2 - G-Idle
1 - Itzy
ITZY QUEENS👑👑👑👑👑
You fav iz*one chorus was paramana but the video you show was fiesta
Itzyyyyy❤❤👑👑
Iz*one's prechorus is pretty good
Can you do blackpink vs twice vs itzy vs aespa
Iz*One music video deserves a better rank. Fiesta music video eats them all up
In bridge it's always yeji and lia In itzy ❤️ izone have only chaeyeon / yuri / minju / wonyoung ❤️in bridge
And in Idle its almost always Shuhua
Itzy
Who miss Soojin 😭😭😭😭😭.
Me 😞
Ive