The Great Debate: THE STORYTELLING OF SCIENCE (OFFICIAL) - (Part 2/2)
Vložit
- čas přidán 5. 04. 2013
- Link to Part 1 (of 2): • The Great Debate: THE ...
Join the Origins Project at ASU for the final night in the Origins Stories weekend, focused on the science of storytelling and the storytelling of science. The Storytelling of Science will feature a panel of esteemed scientists, public intellectuals, and award-winning writers including well-known science educator Bill Nye, astrophysicist Neil deGrasse Tyson, evolutionary biologist Richard Dawkins, theoretical physicist Brian Greene, Science Friday's Ira Flatow, popular science fiction writer Neal Stephenson, executive director of the World Science Festival Tracy Day, and Origins Project director Lawrence Krauss as they discuss the stories behind cutting edge science from the origin of the universe to a discussion of exciting technologies that will change our future. They will demonstrate how to convey the excitement of science and the importance helping promote a public understanding of science. The panel discussion is sure to be a provocative and entertaining finale to our Origins Stories events. We look forward to seeing you there!
VIdeo by Black Chalk Productions.
Get the most recent updates from the Origins Project by following us on Facebook /ASUOriginsProject and Twitter @asuORIGINS. Contact origins.project@asu.eduwith questions.
"But Neil, they outnumber you 1 to 7"
"Then it's an even fight"
lmfaaaooo
Idk,not judging anyone, but i don't like people(Neil degrasse) screaming or being aggressive to prove or implement their point.
And another thing, he doesn't even listen and think about what other people are saying he just have a preconceived answer to everything,which he just don't want to question.
Pratham Bansal he was right though. NASA started and was funded solely because the U.S. wanted to step up to the Soviet Union and prove that capitalism is better than communism. He was angry that they were naive about that FACT. If you watch carefully, you’d see Lawrence agreeing with him too.
@@prathambansal8951 he is not wrong tho
so many snow flakes here. Neil is king.
Tyson: "now I'm going to be silent"
Lawrence: "no you're not"
neil to himself: "nope i'm not"
@@aaronrajadurai1167 “damnit how’d he know “
LMAOOAOAOA he knows him fr
They're both asshats. And idiots. Listen to their nonsense...somebody ask them how the astroNOTS got thru the van Allen radiation belts. Aka the firmament. Hint hint hint. They didnt
When Neil degrasse tyson sits quiet, he's actually recharging himself to explode. Love this guy.
Mars is a wondering star.
And no body can leave earth ..
No one has ever gone thru the impenetrable firmament..
More lies
Not funny@@dannystefanovski5513
He loves himself too
"I think fun and entertainment are overrated". Prof. Richard Dawkins
You gotta love this man🤣🤣🤣
The godfather of memes
@@emperorthylord literally haha
17:27
As if art is just funny and entertainment. Dawkins is a clown
That's because you are British 😂
"I had fun once. It was awful." - Richard Dawkins.
Grumpy cat vibes 😂
Oh man.. Spot on, hahahha
Dawkins is magic in his way and the way the dont accept God
@@michaelwallden7261
😂😂😂😂😂
😂
"Science is hard, but it's worth it." Well said, Richard.
I just read this as he was saying it!!!
AliceDiableaux Because ya gotta learn math, which is even harder
worth has zero to do with effort-- the value one gets out of an effort has nothing to do with it "worth". I get a great buzz out of an old TV show-- the only "hard" part is finding the remote so I can turn on the TV.or walking my mutt. and he gets value out of a cheap and easy approach to a simple bush of little value, I assure you.
@@SangeevSelvaratnam me too lol! i was like wow that was a big coincidence
I don't think he's very social. That's why he only says cliches. " science is hard but it ..."
Tyson & Nye are two natural comedians as well as being brilliant. Just imagine if all your teachers were the same.
They were nemesis in tbbt. They r the energy😂
Both extremely narcissistic
Nye is an actor. Lol he is full of more shit than passion. Tyson on the other hand is great .
Guy in white shirt is shitty comedian. Just made the show horrible
@@Jay-ln7ov You know who are narcissists? Stupid people. Tyson and Nye are not stupid people.
Love these fun moments
6:14 head move
7:48 it just because
13:25 oh wow
17:26 fun overrated
21:46 opinion
30:00 my generation
31:33 no brother Neil
33:48 do you know
34:54 gotta sit
thanks brooo
30:54 watch me
"You can´t argue with the facts."
"Watch me."
Now that´s an attitude.
Right, I kind of want to see a comic book based around Neil Tyson, with that as his catchphrase.
Yes, because he has made an effort to learn all the facts and has the conviction and courage to make them known
Brilliant Neil was on fire.
Don't believe me just watch 😎
prove it's a fact! Otherwise, explain why it's not.
And some people say scientists are boring...
Not everyone but Richard is
@@kamranbegakafr3ak it comes across like that but he just doesn't give a shit what people think of him, just says it like it is
yeah but he is boring i enjoy watching other but he is the most boring
Kamran Beg yeah just like you.
@@tengentopka727 hah I myself think I'm boring thanks for confirming
The best CZcams video for me.
8 years ago I watched it at school, and it inspired me to go into science.
And now I almost got my PhD in physics thanks to these guys.
Awesome
Can't pronounce your name but crossing the boundaries I can extend my love respect to you young mind. Let your journey continue with the amusement astonishment and continuous association with wonder.
@AMB my emotional concurrence with you. Let me share my part of overwhelming joy even a person been confined with basic arithmetic geometry and excel or Autocad types of software professionally for my bread & butter but I do communicate others with the jewels of science and scientific temper. Try to enjoy the reading or anykind of association with the know how.
this comment made my day
👏👏👏
I imagine Richard Dawkins narrating everything in his head like a nature program.
Lol 🤣
“The bombastic nature of these mammals to loudly propound their knowledge in a public gathering is a sort of human equivalent of the brilliant plumage of the male peacock.”
This should have been named: "The Great Debate: Neil degrasse Tyson vs everyone"
lol
😂😂😂
Hahaha
Very True. People find Neil's interruptions very annoying, but on the contrary, I believe that is what brought the humour and entertainment in this event. It just makes people experiencing this the first time, realise how FUN and VAST science is and you can be a part of it and contribute to the community.
For Science!
Because he talks a lot of shit, yeah he makes sense (sometimes) but he only talks in laymen and my god he’s up there with the greatest minds and he’s still talking in idiot language, he’s talking to the crowd not the qualified scientist.
Agreed
For my whole life I have been in my wheelchair. Today I stood up to turn the volume up
Very deep👍👍👍
Legendary quote man
Benefit thief
And then Tyson started shouting and you went straight back into a state of paralysis?
😂😂😂
It's unbelievable how we're all so lucky to be alive in a world where science is this entertaining and I'm SO HERE FOR IT
Them: you’re outnumbered Neil!
Neil: well you’re outmatched
Nice comment !!
I swear if you gave Neil all the time in the world to debate, he would use every second forever lol
+Dylan F (DJBluff22) And we would love every single microsecond of it.
+abschussrampe just reading all these positive comments make me soooooo happy...I'm an ex Muslim atheist...
+abschussrampe every single femtosecond
+khairowensullivan but if you love Sience you don't need to be atheist
+Bilind samank But it helps. ;)
Neil and Kraus are the two reasons i decided to do a physics degree at the age of 32, Brilliant men.
Hypernova Collapsar ...dude YOU ROCK!!
I’m 34 and just decided to look into it as well... it’s never too late!
Thanks for writing that. I'm just starting an engineering degree at 35.
Hypernova I just got accepted into North Carolina State University where I’m also getting a degree in physics! “Science is hard but it’s worth it.” - Richard Dawkins
@@tjug0f3m yes but is very hard for someone whose maths are weak or am i wrong?
Gotta love Neil, his energy, passion, charisma, jokes, knowledge such a all rounded guy!
He really loves himself too
Neil agrees
He is a bafooooon
He showed his true colour at 13:25... He is not interested in a conversation if he is not the authority. He is very smart but also a narcissist.
@@22RedEyeJedi22 humm i have seen that part and i dont se any think as narcissim, i think that you should more learn about what you say(narcissim) and more understand the relation and dynamics among those people before judging them. "Most people judge men by their looks, a few judge them by their reality, and very few judge them by truth." - Seneca
If I hit the mega millions , I’d pay for this group to gather up like this at least 4 times a year and do this
I think Lawrence did an excellent job moderating. Everyone seemed like they were having fun. Even Richard lol.
good point
The host was annoying and trying way too hard to be funny and each time it was at someone else's expense, primarily Dr. Tysons.
Pretty sure Neil and Stephen are good friends in real life, which is why they don't mind acting that way towards each other.
joshy2 boss+ They are friends.
Not to mention Tyson has a tendency to dominate discussions and it is hard for others have their say.
@@joshy2boss931 All these scientists you see are friends. They dig at each other all the time. I can understand how that could be taken the wrong way.
Tyson and Nye would be the greatest comedy double act!
+melancholiac - I agree Neil and Nye would make a great team, teaching and entertaining at the same time!
Laurel and hardy
A comedy fraud act!!!!😂
More pseudo-babble bullshit from Neil degasbag with Bill Nye the non-science guy added in!!! Shill's for the system of lies ruling the world!!!
wow, a mechanical engineer with Boeing is not a science guy? cool. I guess everybody who builds and designs the actual applications of scientific discovery is a non-science person.
"The good thing about science is that it's true whether or not you believe in it."
- Neil Degrasse Tyson
What do you mean "true"?
@@primeminister1040
in accordance with fact or reality. Accurate or exact.
@@EnlightenedEyes11 what is fact and what is reality? Must the fact be observable? Is reality only what we can see?
@@primeminister1040 the world or the state of things as they actually exist, as opposed to an idealistic or notional idea of them.
He should revisit that statement and use it against himself...
13:30 / 13:50 “like of wow”...“am I like thinking? Or am I thinking that I’m thinking?” (Pretends bong hit) He is such an icon!!! Nye is that guy
"Am I just like .... thinking? Or am I just like... thinking that I'm thinking?" That Bill Nye stoner thought lol
lol
Thats why bill nye is so awesome. Hes not only very well-educated and smart but hes also socially intelligent. He just spits out creative quick-witted jokes when everyone else is thinking logically and seriously about something.
I laughed so hard when tyson compared learning algebra to learning a language like chinese "If you want to study chinese it looks completely intractable" and bill nye just throws in "it looks like greek". Great sense of humor.
I had just passed that part of the video and had to go back to catch the joke. xD Bill Nye is great @Free Dom
Even old uptight Dawkins can't resist a chuckle or two in this setting/
it was a surprising GREAT imitation
"No you damn well haven't got to respect their opinion" [21:52]
- Richard Dawkins
I am gonna use that on so many idiots on the internet. THANK YOU RICHARD, you are a hero of reason!
That's right and it goes for him as well.
That he is called Captain Logic by his sycophants is funny. Here's why: he said his Oxbridge college has more Nobel Peace Prizes than 'muslims'; but he failed to realize 'muslims' have infinitely more Nobel Peace Prizes than Richard Dawkins.
Enjoy that one sycophant.
Oh and there's just as many psychotic Muslims as psychotic Westerners, Richard Dawkins does have a mental health issue from his 'public' school upbringing, chances of him dealing with that are minuscule.
Faesen "Oh and there's just as many psychotic Muslims as psychotic Westerners"
Yup we're taking our shoes off at the airport right now because of the Westboro Baptists.
Faesen It is obvious that you are trying to participate in this stupid internet phenomena known as "trolling". It is either that or you are breaking records for stupidity.
John McKay So you don't even have basic mathematics, science and logic: well for free zero equals nothing and 1 equals absolute certainty.
Absolutely anything is an infinite compared to zero. It's why the Big Bang happened, maybe you can try and rap your mind around from one particle came the entire universe.
Zero is awful, having no Nobel prizes and having the nerve to lambast others, oh and to bring his college into disrepute as well. Dawkins reminds me of a gobby kid who'll go and get his brothers if his bullying doesn't work and someone splats him. Of course all around the world there there are those who are as cowardly as he is, and in fact much worse.
I graduated from a top 10 UK university, the last thing I'd do is leech off others achievements, though I know people like yourself that's how you operate.
And you're in the military?
Well I guess you send a wacko to kill a wacko.
The way brian green run away at 33:53 and comes back at 34:00 is so comedic, and bill came to help to takedown neil and neil trying to escape 33:57 is even hilarious. even though these are very intelligent people, they still know how to be a goofy.
intelligent people tend to be goofy and funny..some are so funny that its hard to work with em..like literally..but its fun tho..
They tried to distract Bro .
This is like a rap battle but with scientists. Love it!🥰
Tyson was great. His point about politics and science was unbelievably true.
Dominic London. Wrong.
@@greatbritain5355 3 year later and that's what you choose to comment, not even explain why. You sure live up to your name lol.
That was the most hilarious moment of this debate. I love Neil for that
@@greatbritain5355 Dumbass
@@greatbritain5355 You wrong
*Aight i won the debate*
Tyson: "now I'm going to be silent"
Lawrence: "no you're not"
Tyson less then a minute of being silent... "YES! BUT! BUT! I AGREE! BUT! LISTEN!"
Not for long.😅🤣
I remember actually being in the crowd for this. It’s one of the best Origin’s lectures I’ve ever been to.
Neil deGrasse Tyson, is the only person on the entire planet that makes me look up and wonder instead of looking down at my feet. He is a pioneer of both space and time, let's hope that the cosmos calls upon more of the consciousness than just him and you and I.
"Am I, like, thinking? Or am I just thinking that I'm thinking?" *takes a puff*
Classic
Ya I saw that part too
smoke weed everyday
Why am I laughing in a science class for 45 minutes straight
31:10 Neil: "Everybody mentioned there book its time for me to mention mine."
Lawrence: "I dont think anyone mentioned there book actually" 😂😂😂
Note: "their" and "there" are very different words. How I wish you could learn the difference 😉
@@gerrytushh You must have a pathetic life to be bothered by such things
@@colby9945 am not pathetic at all. As a teacher, I get paid for precisely pointing out that kind of thing 🤣 Very important 😂
@@gerrytushh Lol got ‘em.
@@acemxe8472 😂some basic grammar never hurt anyone 😂
Leonard and sheldon fighting in that science talk just pops in my mind😂😂
"I think fun and entertainment are overrated"
"That's cause you're British, that's cause you're British"
Thanks! I had no clue what he had said.
Jorge Ruiz 🤣
Remind me again who brought Football.. thats real Football into the world???
Captain Jack Sparrow china
'cause*
Richard is just sitting there like, "those bastards."
+Robin Could "I wonder if my tea and biscuits are ready."
+Sebin Puthenthara Suresh "Bloody hell,where is my turn mate"
+Joshua Gomez *when
+Joshua Gomez no. WHERE IS IT JOSH
+Robin Could
I don't think he had any ill thoughts of his contemporaries at all. He was simply being the polite fellow he always is. and you know his mind is taking it all in and deeply contemplating all the while. That's the kind of man he is.
I've watched this debate several times over the past years. We need more like these.
Man Neil degrasse tyson is so passionate about science you can't help but listen
I wouldve gotten straight A's if he was my teacher every year growing up
I have noticed that Neil can exist in two states. He is either uncomfortable and silent, or content and talking...and there is no in between. I like the guy, but if you watch he is either out-talking the entire group or sitting there looking horribly uncomfortable.
That means he's a good listener. You can't learn and think at the same time. He is listening to everyone. He only comments when he's asked or he disagrees.
+quest 757 I'd say that's certainly incorrect. In order to learn you do have to think because that is the process for progress. Certainly if you just didn't think when learning and just processed all the information as fact, that is why everyone thought the earth was the center of the universe for so long. In order to learn things have to be processed and so rationally thought about in order for progress to occur.
+quest 757 he did not "comment" he interrupted others.
But Lawrence Krauss did a very good job to moderate the whole debate. He really appears to be able to read Neil's mind and calm him down by rephrasing his thoughts in a slightly more moderate way.
Ralf Oltmanns
He did. He's good at reading the subtle cues and keeping things civil.
I wish I could put the passion and drive of Neil Degrass Tyson into our government!
It is possible but policies have to be created where educators have a stronger influence on the electoral collage so that any action they undertake will be based on objective truths
i wish i could put it to my son
@@brentbeepath7457 WOW...that doesn’t sound dehumanizing or fascist at all.
HIs aggression make him look like a neanderthal
@@brentbeepath7457 If education wasn't as corrupt as government that would be true.
i love this debate, i wish it could've gone longer
13:35 One of the most brilliant moments in the history of science debate
The beef between lawrence and Neil is hilarious..
keshan Krauss comes off as a bit of an ass. I say this even though I know how annoying Tyson can be
@@alexwex123456789 Emotionally, they both have plenty of room to grow. And, I love you reply to the OP. I have no argument to it.
A lot of people state that these scientists don't like eachother or are arguing. They're not arguing, they're debating. They all respect eachother. In fact, Nye and Tyson are friends. They disagree on something's but they respect and look up to one another
Exactly. A lot of people seem to confuse "fighting" with "debating."
Tyson definitely has a real problem with Brian Greene though, astrophysics and string theory don't blend well and he takes it way too personally. If you watch him when Greene is talking he doesn't laugh and looks disgruntled the whole time. It's unfortunate because they're both such informative scientists.
@@patrickcompton1483 That's true
The ancient greeks and romans had social forums called gymnasiums where all the great thinkers and scholars got together and talked about science and philosophy. That became the cradle of modern scientific aptitude. This programs reminds me of that.
That's what it reminded me of too. I wish society would embrace this more.
I didn’t want this to end!!! Just keep talking and sharing your knowledge!!!
That was way too short!
Right?! I think so too!!
There is a part 1 to this, this is part 2, I agree though that this part could have gone on for hours and hours
Where is part 3689??
That's not what she said
I can't get enough of these guys.
This was a GREAT find. I found a new respect for Neil and Bill. I was terribly disappointing that Brian was not more involved.
Thanks for Neil for making me proud to be African American. You gave me the power to speak .
Have you noticed he does not dumb himself down so as not to make them look less smart?
Speaking up entiles you know the subject matters. Don't thank Tyson, know your subject matter & be able to articulate it very well that it generates interest in people wanting to know you more.
Just speaking up is not going to cut it.
Richard: -"I think fun and entertainment are overrated" and the face he did the following second just seems like the meme. Hilarious.
gotcha987 time?
The Rickest Rick around the 20 minute mark.
30:56
"You can´t argue with the facts."
"Watch me."
Gotta love Neil.
Neil degasbag is full of crap. czcams.com/video/Q8tZaOu-30g/video.html
@@jeremiahdssdentmorgan3341 stfu you moron
Incredible conversation, even decades later. 👏👏👏Loved it!
Having all these people in one room debating each other is so amazing!! A lot of Personalities but pure passion for science and development 🙌
Love Neils passion. That's what we, at least in America need. We need the Bill Nye and NDGT type of scientists to light a fire about science in kids, as well as adults!
Brian Greene & michio kaku too
Michio kaku for sure Is up there
It starts at home. There are only so many NDGT's and Bill's to go around. Parents have to start allowing their children to experiment and ask hard questions.
Will your half right but no 1 needs to mimic Tyson and how rude he is And loud like A Neanderthal
This was eight years ago, and since then, Neil was right. String Theory is obsolete. Many grants and funding-many many grants and funding-have done nothing but been a waste of money. Greene is still spewing string in argument for this theory when it is proven it can not answer anything. In this timeframe we have a new theory, as of 2014: Emergence Theory-E8-of Quantum Gravity. Garrett Lisi found the answers with mathematical theorem, and with that knowledge has started a group known as Quantum Gravity Research.
Neil is great on so many levels but he got way too loud and he should at least let others to speak then debunk them.Richard as always calm and collective
visa422978
Problem with Richard is he projects himself as an expert on waaaaaaay too many subjects. And because of his success in teaching evolution, people interpret his other subject views as viable. He needs to stop talking about religion, philosophy, etc. because he has no credentials.
i think you´re one hot lady, even though you don´t give a damn about what i think. Neil....he just loves the sound of his own voice...but he´s one cool customer.
***** Geez, you sound more like some chick, who is judging a man who doesn't meet her standards, which is as equally annoying as what you just said. Neil DeGrasse Tyson is just another scientist who is very passionate about what he says, and the fact of the matter, is that war does indeed fuel scientific progress and not the need for adventure in the government. Brian Green and Laurence Krauss were both wrong and were about to go on a huge rant about it. If you can't handle the fact that Neil gets passionate over misleading thoughts about what fuels science then you just need to get the fuck over it or get the fuck out.
***** Neil is actually the one with the open mind on the matter. The other scientists are claiming that X has to be like Y. Neil is saying that we have no evidence that X even exists.
*****
Because you used the phrase "turn off" which makes it sound like you're judging his suitability as a mate, not as a scientist, which is something a chick would be prone to doing. I assumed you're a chick because your username is "May Been" and I don't know many males named "May". The man got passionate, you insulted him for it, I don't like people who make disparaging comments toward others who are unafraid to express their opinions with some gusto.
Brilliant...not laughed so hard in a long time ...very inspiring and entertaining. Thank you 😊
American scientists are so fun and culture-moving figures. The best in the world.
and then its government comes in and weaponizes everything the discover.
The best ... group ever. I been laughing so much
Yes yes, that's because they are all clowns!
Yeeeeeaaah...there’s the GROUP of scientists...THEN there’s the journalist
you so funny - you laugh so much -
113 now
Stay Primitive My Friend
Please keep uploading man, we miss you :/
i love how all these guys can sit down and debate and argue about things and have fun, but they don't really really get mad at each other. That's the great thing about rational people, they can argue on views about things and are willing to learn from each other and brush it off. religious people argue about things and take it personal and create wars.
+xGOOFYJELLYFISH that's emotional maturity, not rationalism. look at niel and his frequent outbursts and underhanded remarks.
+xGOOFYJELLYFISH if you really look into it, most wars were started for other reasons. Things like religion, etc are just used as an excuse so one group of people can exert power over another. I'm not a believer btw. With enough scientific, economic, societal advances we can probably eliminate war completely.
Nice generalizations there
+Yijuwarp Scientific evolution is profited through ward, economics are seek through war, and society advances are means of war. Wars are created to be right over other people and assume they are inferior to them. Religion helped to think they were chosen, better people. Look at the Vatican and their Holy Crusades, previously that Religion was into that too, after that too, and in between many religions did that. Anything that divides people in different ranks create wars. Like civil wars.
+xGOOFYJELLYFISH That's complete BS. It's not because they are rational that they get along but because they are part of the same group.
Put christians together or muslims together or jewish together and they'll get along just the same.
The same in politics or for any field for that matter.
And don't forget that they are there to promote science (and not to ruin the show of their friend who happens to be the producer of the show).
Have you ever seen a debate between a rationalist and a religious? Most of the time, it's the rationalist that tends to go nuts.
You can express your dislike of religious people but you can't just invent some BS theory from thin air to do so.
Your comment is uncalled for and is based on nothing but personal bias.
I NEED MORE, this was so good, I enjoyed every second, we need more people like this to encourage science to everyone, and thanks to the internet, I'm sure there will be
internet literally made everything better
Sometimes I still stay awake at night asking myself "Am I thinking? Or am I just thinking that I am thinking?"
lol
30:55 A says" its a fact, you cant argue facts", Neil responds "watch me" lol
Neil thought he was on the jedi council sitting up there
31:43 Bill Nye hyping up Neil is the kind of energy we need.
"No, Brother Neil! No it is not!"
wish they made this a series.highly entertaining with dialogue panel of various interactive scientists
Neil: coughs
Audience: applause!
Тhis audience in large numbers contains semi-literate shallow people and heavy snobs for sure!
Now
Neil: coughs
Audience: COVID POSITIVE!!!!
@@ssdivizion you sound dumb as hell please calm down...
@@Milky_Cum 🤣
Neil Degrasse Tyson is the fucking embodiment of passion and I fucking love him.
Of all of them, he is the one that makes me want to listen to him. The other ones came with the package.
I bow to the others' knowledge, but Degrasse Tyson is a true educator at heart.
He's got passion, certainly. And quite often, that's exactly what's needed to get people's attention. But just like a black preacher, he often runs the risk of resembling a bull, loose in a china shop...
teppolundgren He's just having some fun up there.
+Mahfuz Hasan Prethul: He gave his opinion about what he enjoyed in the video. How is that right or wrong and not just different?
+1
Gil CJ neil tyson is a narcissistic piece of shit
Tyson doing a Chomskian analysis here, dismantling myths and in a funny way. Love the entire panel and discussion.
You really have to love the American levity, and Richard is enjoying it too.
Can’t believe I’m just now watching the bud for the first time…this is awesome af!!! And these guys are actually funny too, which makes it super awesome 👏🏽 …def gave me some things to think about
learn algebra -nye
ambition -tyson
passion -krauss
empathize -uranium yuri
reiterate empathize switch to poetry -dawkins
tell it so mom understands it -ira
trig and all the calculus classes are so much better ...
Mark Case Try doing calculus without algebra
mobcat40
They were trying to inspire people. Fundamentals can be cool. Algebra isn't.
Mark Case Algebra isn't cool only because you don't know enough about algebra to judge whether it is cool or not
lol alright
Can we just appreciate Biil’s humor for a moment.
Brilliant mix of scientific minds in diverse professions. Entertaining and educational. Inspiring and encouraging. ❤
Just Amazing, to watch these inspirational People, always love these panels
I believe whole heartedly Seth McFarlane created Cleveland to look exactly like Neil
+joseph duenas WTF ITS TRUE LOL
And stewie to sound like Richard Dawkins.
I wish Richard Dawkins had joined in at about the 10 minute mark. I'd be interested to hear his views on how important math is to biology.
+Aeroscience DNA. Your body is an executed program read from the compiling softwares called RNA holoenzyme polymerase and mRNA. Understanding how DNA works, how chromosomes work, understanding the genome and mapping the genome, all of that uses math. DNA is no different than old 1s and Os, except each of the tiniest pieces are two bits instead of one.
+Nigel Kirk in a sense you are right, but unless your discipline is bioinformatics most maths you will encounter and have to apply is pretty basic (although you will encounter maths in some form in every branch of biology)
I would be very surprised if biologists on that level don't have a solid grasp on things like probability, which is part of mathematics.
+Marcel Jones That might be true for high school level biology, but at university the bachelors and masters in biology requires just as much math as many engineering studies.
Martin Jensen
i have a masters degree in molecular biology and i really dont need much maths. certainly nothing advanced
Truly one the best scientific conversations / comedic debates ever had in the English language. 💯
Wow! They are all passionate in their own way! They bring the emotion to the topic. Sure they inspire people.
I love how Neil can say literally anything, and the crowd will applaud him xD
Thats not true the things that neil said were relevant
33:50 lol Brian Greene, Bill and Neil acting out a fight scene was the funniest thing ive ever seen.
I love watching these it gives u a lot of knowledge
While Neal Stephenson may seem diminished in this forum, his prescient style and early books were remarkably accurate as to where science inevitably arrived. Brilliant addition to the group. Loved this dialogue.
Man I wish this was a 4 hour long program. We barely see them have science talks in one stage. Hats off to all the scientist!
Well I wish it's my whole college career.
That last part is what I call real women empowerment. No political agenda, no individual selfishness. Pure encouragement.
We need more programs like this
Omg I love these guys, so goofy! So brilliant! So lovable❤️
"You cant argue with the facts"
Neil- " watch me know" I'm dead
How was this never made into a meme. This is priceless.
@@masterpopeyoda3290 ikr. Make one rn!
And he showed him that his naive idea of why the Apollo program was cancelled was stupid.. I love NDGT and his realism. He's not some hippie scientist who thinks science should be good and a force for good. Atom bomb proves them wrong.
What is people's problem with Richard Dawkins? A Tumblr post brought me to this video and everyone was giving him a bunch of crap. I don't see why. He didn't say anything bad. Can anyone tell me why so many people on that website don't like him? Because I think he's awesome. I get to do a biography on him for my science class and I'm super excited about it.
Same! That's why I'm here as well. I am a huge fan of both Dawkins and Nye!
Bobt Sims That's another thing that was weird. They loved Nye but hated Dawkins. They even acted like Dawkins disagreed with Nye for some reason, when they're really on the same page. It had something to do with the way he was sitting, I think. He was kind of leaning away from Nye and they said something along the lines of, "It's like Bill Nye has an aura that repels assholes." It's all nonsense.
Richard Dawkins is sort of... abrasive. He's honest and he speaks his mind. When he sees superstition he doesn't spare feelings while on his way to pointing it out. It has attracted to him the ire of lots of folks (religious folks mostly) in the past. And for some reason the radical "feminists" seem to hate him, never figured out why but it's most likely on some bullshit reason like most of the things they get their panties up in a bunch about nowadays.
Dawkins doesn't mince words, and tends to speak in a more calm and relatively neutral tone, as compared to NDT's or Nye's extreme enthusiasm. My guess is that those people on Tumblr didn't understand Dawkins or skipped past his chances to speak because they thought he was "boring;" in reality, while he's not the most enthusiastic or prominent member on that board, he has some of the best things to say.
Mattea Williams Yeah literally same, " tyranny is the deliberate removal of nuance ". The post on tumblr used a screenshot and the position Dawkins was sitting in to push an agenda. They presented the photo as if the two had disagreed. I think they just did it for popularity on that post, using bill nye the prominent,social figure as the american champion of " yeah woo equality!" and Dawkins was presented as the antagonist. It was just an opportunity to get some popularity on a post but im glad they did it because i thoroughly enjoyed watching this whole discussion.
“U say u r bad at math, I bet you r not that bad” ...😳 then Neil saves me ❤️ ✌️
We need more talks like this to encourage more scientists.
This is the best thing i've ever watched on youtube hands down.
Neil: talks...
Then finishes his statement
Lawrence: “wait I wanna...I wanna wait wait I wanna...explain about.....”
Neil then talks over Lawrence haha
I let 3 of my kids watch this...and they watched many times by themselves...I amazed how they can understand...while I don't get what some of the scientists are saying...after 3 weeks...I noticed, my house are full of scientists wannabe... sadly my wife has to listen to my kids scientific rambling. Good lord I'm escape to work.
So entertaining. Love this panel of people. Expand on this!
9:00 I think Greene is right here. Tyson opts for the pop sci 'language of the universe' stuff to wow the audiences but in reality, as Greene says, maths is just used in our current logical *description* of the Universe. And an amazing one at that
As much as I love Neil, that's my only critique of him.
I agree with Neil! He’s right though, it is working now! If and when it limits us we’ll try other things but the current math has helped us explain many things that actually work and can be predicted!
Bill Nye made me roll on the floor with laugher when he was like "wow am I thinking or am I thinking am thinking" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
I think a lot of times when people say " i am not good at something" , sometimes it can be about the teacher too, i know i failed algebra in my high school and always thought i was bad at math, But i took physics in high school, and my physics teacher was passionate and loved to teach just like Neil and he made you interested and took the time to explain very well, i got amazing grades in that class and it was the most fun and interesting one i ever took in school. He always took 2 weeks to teach astronomy as well as he was a college teacher of astronomy at a local community college. He may have passed from this earth, but his legacy of teaching young adults good science will always be remembered! Thanks MR. FRED.
We must speak with joy , emotion, laughter ❤❤ when spoken, yes it’s a good thing. So we remember within the spirit, great energy within us all