[앵콜캠4K] 에스파 'Savage' 인기가요 1위 앵콜 직캠 (aespa Encore Fancam) | @SBS Inkigayo_2021.10.24.
Vložit
- čas přidán 23. 10. 2021
- [앵콜캠4K] 에스파 'Savage' 인기가요 1위 앵콜 직캠 (aespa Encore Fancam) | @SBS Inkigayo_2021.10.24.
#인기가요1위 #앵콜캠 #에스파 #Savage
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
☞ MORE ＂SBS KPOP＂
Twitter : / kpop_sbs
Facebook : / sbskpop
Instagram : / sbskpop_official - Zábava
![[앵콜CAM] 블랙핑크 'Lovesick Girls’ 인기가요 1위 앵콜 직캠 (BLACKPINK Encore Fancam) | @SBS Inkigayo_2020.10.11.](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/lYnveq4_U4Q/mqdefault.jpg)
![[앵콜CAM] 블랙핑크 'Lovesick Girls’ 인기가요 1위 앵콜 직캠 (BLACKPINK Encore Fancam) | @SBS Inkigayo_2020.10.11.](/img/tr.png)
![[MPD직캠] 에스파 1위 앵콜 직캠 4K 'Supernova' (aespa FanCam No.1 Encore) | @MCOUNTDOWN_2024.5.23](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZxT51ihEfCI/mqdefault.jpg)
![[앵콜캠4K] 에스파 'Spicy' 인기가요 1위 앵콜 직캠 (aespa Encore Fancam) | @SBS Inkigayo 230521](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ghFFHNUsvEM/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Knowing Bros] aespa - HIT SONG DANCE MEDLEY🔥 (including DRAMA)](/img/n.gif)
This is why Bang PD thinks aespa is a threat to kpop industry. Well not gonna lie, aespa is on the next level PERIOD
😅
Can't blame him. They really are!
Vocal wise on par with Mamamoo or RV?
@@FarhanMizamwith diligent vocal training maybe. But isn't ironic comparing a 10 years old groups to 3.5 years one?
THIS IS THE FUCKIN STANDARD. THEY ARE REAL SINGERS.
aespa’s vocalssss I’m still offended we didn’t get Drama encore stage we all deserve 😭
Drama didn't get any win?
@@Blaze72sH it got wins but aespa weren’t on the shows to sing the encore 🥲
Damn they made it really look easy
I see what you did 👀
the difference lol 😂
FR OMFG
NAW
- said by the ones who cant even hold a note while standing😭😭
Ningning probably can't hear herself properly. Look how many times she points to her mic and also points to her ear monitor. That's why she looks kinda worried/nervous. But she still slayed and showed how professional she is.
Karina said on bbl they didnt use iem and yeah probably ning mic got some problem
@@mindungie801 thank you
:(
1:22 Ningning found her Mic has problem
1:33 - 1:39 Ningning kept pointing Mic to remind staff
2:46 Ningning seems cannot hear the voice properly again…
2:55 Ningning pointed her Mic again
3:50 We finally can hear Ningning’s clear voice
Either Ningning’s Mic volume is improper or Her Mic has some problem…😂 Anyways, Ningning did great. aespa slay~
poor girl... she looks so worried... but she slayed anyways
This is a typical encore from an sm artist. And this is my standard of encore
Same
True
NGL
Fuckin true
다른 팀 앵콜 하는거 보면 못하는 애들 부를 때 멤버들끼리 서로 같이 불러주면서 도와주는데 에스파는 그런것도 없음 걍 각자 쿨하게 잘부름 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
맞네ㅋㅋ 다른애들은 군대마냥 하나둘셋 추임새 ㅈㄴ넣어주던데 역시 라이브 자신잇으니까 마이웨이 자기파트만 다해버림
@@mong218 ❤
역시 에스파 ❤
진짜 잘하네.. 실력파라고 해서 애들 잘 부루나 봤는데 진짜 실력파임 요즘 앵콜 논란 많은데 그중에서 논란없을듯
앵콜에서도 자기들 몫은 잘함 sm 가수 중 앵콜을 못하던 사람이 있나 앵콜로 논란 터진 가수들 웃기는거 ㅍㄷ데뷔조로 활동했던 사람들이네
이때는 에스파 라이브로 말 많았는데 다시 보니까 근본 실력 미쳤네.. 코첼라는 긴장을 많이 했던 듯 넥레 때 화제성 다시 찾아와서 1등하면 좋겠다
that's because SM doesn't let aespa sings live so netizen has a doubt on them.
이때도 잘한다고 말 많았지 않나
이제 1황아님?
@@comotosk4579 저 대단한 라이브를 보고도 발성이 안좋네 발음이 구리네 뭐 엄청 많았어요 저리 잘하는데...
Other groups have NO excuse, this song is actually HARD and they're doing it like it's nothing while dancing and no ear monitors.
RIGHT!!!!!!!
They’re soo talented!
Uhhh many songs are hard to sing live/while dancing???? Their talented yes, but don't bring down other groups.
@@Boombayah756 Well, they're not bringing down any specific group. It was a general statement that as a kpop group, they must be good singers.
and it's really true, SM artists are some of the best vocalists in Kpop. I watched a Sticker encore by NCT and there was NO backing track, legit none, and the guys sang and laughed and breathed and spoke while singing, all of it live and very clear, and yet the parts which they rapped and sang sounded exactly like the CD version, absolutely amazing!!! Same with Dream, Shinee, Red Velvet. Go watch SM winning and encore stages, their artists are insanely talented, even their 'visuals' and 'dancers' can legit sing
The fact that they weren’t using in-ears and still hitting all the right notes is really impressive!
REAL TALENT it is
Uhmm what's the problem you can get for not using it?
@@mackloey3504 Since the music is loud, the artists usually wear in ear so that they can hear themselves sing so basically without it they can't really hear themselves well.
@@mackloey3504 you might not get the timing right. you might be out of tune.
@@mackloey3504 you can't hear your voice clearly, sometime delay, so it hard to know and control your voice without in-ears.
Giselle's tone when she raps is amazing, it gets my attention right away.
라이브 듣고 싶으면 1위 시키라는 SM의 전략인가
すごい、この考え天才だwww
確かに！！
@@user-eq3db7ro4l그.. 한국어좀 제대로 배우고오십쇼
hahshahahs
엌ㅋ
본인들도 라이브 잘하고 자신 있다는게 느껴지는 앵콜무대랄까…? 평가에 날선 요즘 시대에 반대로 너무 잘해버려서 다 칭찬만 해버리는 분위기 신기하다ㅋㅋㅋ
윈터,닝닝: 거의 완벽하게 고음처리에 높은 음역대에서의 애드리브까지 잘함
지젤: 랩 파트에서 발성 , 박자감 다 좋게 들어강
카리나 : 고 음역대 소화못함, 중간음역대 4개음정 (도#시라솔#) 다틀림, 자신없어보이는 공기반소리반 창법;;;
실력은 얼마 없어보임---> 외모 때문에
밀어주는듯
실력적으론 카리나 빼고 다 잘한다
@@user-if1cl1vh6m 카리나도 노래보단 댄스로 들어간 것같은데 한 명만 까내리려구 정성이다 참...
@@user-sp1ul4jy6v 이 영상에선 님빼고 모든 사람들이 노래실력을 주제삼아 얘기합니다^^ 춤 얘기로 빠지려하지 마시고 본질을 봐주세요~
@@user-if1cl1vh6m 느그 본진이나 신경쓰셈
@@Idontknownickname ㄹㅇ
They sound even clearer in this encore. PROVE TO THEM HATERS
YASS 🥰🔥
Yess
Yasssss
10000%%%% yasss
Yessss
After watching other groups' encore I came here to say that aespa queens of the 4th generation, sm artists are one of kind
Is it only me who thinks that SM artist have the best encore's, their vocal's sound the same as the studio version. (even better than the studio ver. sometimes)
JAJAJAJA I literally did the same😂
@@ayanahmed8428 I agree sometimes it's better than the studio version and ONLY SM ARTISTS COULD DO THAT
@@emanmoghazy3118 They are so talented. SM=home of vocals
@@ayanahmed8428 I’ve been a kpop fan for so long and noone beats SM stable vocals
무엇보다도 칭찬하고싶은건
외국인 멤버 두명.
박수쳐주고싶다
특히 닝닝, 모국어가 아닌데 대단하네요.
외국인이면 더 잘해야지 한국인보다 케이팝인데 뭐 하나라도 더 잘해야 외국인껴주는게 맞는거야 다른 그룹이 이상한거고
@@xixi1175여기저기 댓글 다느라 고생이 많습니다~ 그럴 시간에 책이나 읽으세요
내가 본 여돌 앵콜 중 최고. 이 노래 고음과 어려운 애드립이 많은데 모두 완벽하게 힘들이지 않고 성공해냄. 에스파는 신이에요.
@@dr6354 누가 걔네 못한다 함?
@@dr6354 그분들 못한다고 아무도 뭐라 안했어요 "이분이 본" 여돌 앵콜중에 최고라잖아요;
@@dr6354 dibaca yang bener paman bukan di simpulin sendiri 😒
@@dr6354 네 당연 스테이시나 있지도 잘하죠. 근데 제 기준이긴 히지만 에스파 새비지는 음역대나 기교면에서 난이도로 따지면 라이브로 부르기 굉장히 어려운 노래라고 생각하는데 이 정도로 잘 소화했다는 점이 놀라워서요.
나무 존나 친구 없게 생김
Sometimes it's hard to believe that they are rookies. They exceed power and confidence 😂😂😂
says every fandom ever.. ever had an original thought? or do u just copy
@@바보Queen to be honest that's my original thought, or you just being sensitive 😉
I have seen you in several comments when it comes to aespa, what happens because of so much hate.
뜬끔없지만 코디분 진짜 지젤 추구미에 맞게 찰떡으로 코디 해주셨음ㅠㅠ 최고ㅠㅠㅠ
맞아요ㅠㅠ 젤이 저 의상 진짜 찰떡이었어요ㅠㅠ!!
젤이도 최애착장으로 뽑았던 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 레전드긴 함... 저 하트바지
걍 넷 다 진짜 잘함…각자 알아서 잘 하니깐 불안해보이지도 않아서 좋음
those vocals!!!!!! insane!! aespa literally slap those haters with this encore
Ning ning slayed hard omgosh 😳😳 DAMMMMM
*biggest gg in next 4years indeed go argue with wall end of discussion*
we still don't know what will happen in the future I mean ygngg, hybengg, and jypngg or other unborn gg is still out there so we still don't know what will happen let's just hope for the best for our girls
@@trixiacaras1242 but still they're not yet part of the context
@@blackpinkflopaespabetterth880 u spoke the truth..
The satisfaction I'm feeling right now knowing the haters, doubters and naysayers are probably crying in bitterness. When aespa said "I'll make you cry", they meant this.
에스파는 라이브 정말 잘하는듯 앵콜 많이 볼수있으면 좋겠다
@국뽕충박멸 ㅋ 과거사진보면 똑같이예쁨 ㅋ 열폭은
@@user-jw1yy2ze7k ㄱㄴㄲ ㅋㅋㅋ 어디서 이상한 사진만 보고 온 듯 개이쁘던데
@국뽕충박멸 너같은놈들때문에 내채널에 과거사진올려놓음 저거외에도 많음 ㅋ
@국뽕충박멸 니같이 생긴 ㅅㄲ도 유튭 댓글 달 자격 있는거 보면 쟤네는 저기 있어도 됌ㅋㄱ
@국뽕충박멸 기겁 이ㅈㄹ 니 취향이 ㅈ같애서 ㅈ같은 사진만 ㅊ보니까 그런거임
뭐 눈에는 뭐만 보인다더니
할짓 ㅈㄴ없어보이는데 위에 배들짝님 채널 영상이나 보고오셈
에스파 선플 댓글에다가 다짜고짜 시비거는 수준ㅉㅉ
진짜 안정적이다..실력에 자신있으니 앵콜때 자신감 있게 부르는 모습이 인상적이다
I don't know why giselle's rap is so addicting to me. Her tone is😭😭
이런 게 진짜 가수지.... 춤만 잘 춘다고 가수할 거면 댄서지 가수가 아니지.... 진심 음원인지 부르는 건지 구분 안 될 정도라 너무 신기함. 진짜 가수다 짱스파
아이돌인데여;
@@user-nt8wb7tk8i 아이돌은 가수아닌가요? 댄스가수잖아요ㅋㅋㅋ
@@user-nt8wb7tk8i 아이돌같은 노래로 무대나가는 사람들을 가수라고 부른답니다~~~~~~
닝닝 마지막 부분 딱 봐도 발성 기술적으로 엄청 뛰어난데 저평가 받는게 너무 아쉬워
ㄹㅇ 코첼라 그부분 하나만으로 까이는게 안타까움 그리고 그 당시엔 데뷔 1년 반밖에 안된시기임..그리고 그부분도 그냥 긴장되서 떨린거 아닌가 진짜 음정 박자 다 잘맞았는데 그냥 목소리 떨린거로 까이는게 개 안타까움 ㅆㅂ
중국인만 아니었어도 인기 진짜 많았을거임
@@user-on4tn9hn6t너같이 편견있는 놈들만 아니면 지금도 인기 많을듯
@@user-on4tn9hn6tㄹㅇ... 외모실력 다되는데 중국인이라고 무지성까임
지금보니까 존나 든든한 언니들이었음 존나 사랑한다....에스파
People were really concerned about whether or not they would sing good live. Like they’re literally in SM… a company filled with vocal kings and queens 😭
those are just haters that can’t accept the fact that aespa can sing live 😭💀
@@mi1ntys they sound just like the studio track 😭
I mean it should already be considered a fact that any idol group SM debuts are good singers so yea idk why they were doubting them lol
Only fools would doubt an artist from sm in terms of talent and especially their vocals , well not gonna lie there are a tons of fools from the start who are barking up the wrong tree now those
@@kittyshua8832 exactly like is it their fault that they're so stable?
Okay this was definitely hands down the better encore! Shoutout to Ning Ning for telling the sound team to turn up their mics 🙌🏼😍
YESS!!
내가 지금까지 들은 앵콜중 최고다.
에스파 곡중 이런 대단한 명곡이 있을줄이야..
닝닝..저 애드리브를 실제 할수 있을까 했는데..찐으로 하네. 닝닝 mz세대 탑이다 ㄹㅇ 저그룹엔 구멍이 없음 카리나 지젤까지 1인분 깔끔히 해내고.. 이게 앵콜이지.
Giselle's rap here is way more satisfying than the original album audio.
True
she did better than audio
Karina said on bubble that they're not wearing in-ear during the encore so they don't know how they sounds like but it still manage to be this great!!!!! SM artist never dissapoints with a vocals
The wonder they keep covering one of their ears
☺️💕
oooh that explains covering the ear perfectly
@@airflyer5238 it like hear ur own sound better. Kinda like pulling ur ears close to ur voice
@@ninalovely1374 yes bc they can’t hear the music they are trying to block out the outside sound to hear what they can
개쿨하게 자기 파트만 딱 부르는거 멋있다…. 실력 되는거 본인들이 아니까 나오는 바이브
This is how an encore should be! The girls are clearly chill and happy for their win WHILE being able to sing comfortably on tune to a difficult song with many HIGH and DEMANDING parts. My girls never disappoint😊
Well they're SM
SM only debuts all rounders
And most best voices in Kpop
The fact that they can't even surely hear themselves tho because they didn't wear an in-earpiece.
here after itzy's latest encore
@@goddessofkwangya155what did u watch tho?
They can sing it Easy !
The fact is Giselle's rap here is better than the original; her energy- 😳🔥!!
Yes I'm shocked, her voice is so versatile
no its aenergy 😉😉
Yes , and they use pre recording encore ,Queen of Lipsynce
@@tt-qr2dx jealous
@@tt-qr2dx learn English before criticizing
The way SM artists always project such a healthy high notes. SM vocal trainers are daebak!
Agree👍👍
Totally shocked with Karina’s vocals!She sounds so good! And y’all see how comfortable they were when performing, it’s because they’re confident with their vocals.
I came here after seeing leseraffim encore
Why tho?
lol same
@@gwenhanahbalana2401 to cleanse the ears
SAME
Same
Aespa vocal queens. Breathe if you agree.
*breathes heavily* 😤😤😤
Breathing 24/7
*hyperventilates*
@@Ichigo-dh9rd hahahaha
🤣🤣
The fact that they sound exactly like the studio version is so impressive!
*SLAYY QUEENS*
Yeaah. That’s why some people said they’re lipsyncing even though thery are really singing live.
Queens indeed!
@@loreen__8545 it's because they only show their live vocals in this era. from the previous eras sm won't let them sang full live there is always loud backtrack. if only sm let them sang live like this since black mamba era then ppl would not say a thing about their vocals bcs they really can sing live and they slay. i really hate sm sometimes.
@@seempt yeahh ikr
The reallll Impressive 🤩🔥
@@seempt who needs to sing live when there is no audience at all.
확실히 애들이 보컬 기본기가 있고 자신감이 있어서 그런가, 자기 파트때 크게 긴장 안하고 편하게 잘부르네 ㅋㅋ 그래서 음원이랑 별반 다를 거 없이 나도 편하게 감상함
이게 첫 앵콜이었나?? 그래서 애스파 까내리려는 애들 앵콜 보러 왓는데 잘해서 아무말도 못 했다는 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 조회수가 답해준다
우리 닝이 긴장하면서 음 맞출려고 하는 거... 존나 기특한데 슬퍼 ㅠ 다른 애덜 다 잘하고 닝이도 잘하고 있으니까 맘 편하게 불렀음 좋겠어 ㅠ
닝닝이 자신감을 가져ㅠㅠ 충분히 잘 하니까
울 막닝이 최고야 ❤️🔥❤️🔥
닝깅 노래 넘넘 잘하고 목소리 너무 예뻐ㅠ 그러니까 자신감 가져 돼!! 사룽한다
this is sm artists. they never disappoint when it comes to live vocals.
Ningning gave a sign to staff about her mic
@@hightree9295 at what minute?
@@nafimaha5527 1:34-1:37
@@hightree9295 poor mingming her mic doesn't load before
Omg I'm typo😂
이 앵콜은 에스파 음치무새들의 근거인 코첼라 영상 ’전‘인, 데뷔 ‘11개월’차 에 올라온 앵콜임.
+ 슈퍼노바 앵콜에서 에스파 노래가 가창력을 논할 난이도인 곡이냐는 댓글 보고 추가함.
이노래 진짜 엄청나게 어려운노래임. 4세대 모든 걸그룹 노래 중에서 최소 탑3은 할듯. 박자 진짜 장난 아니게 빠르고, 음 개높은 주제에 올리면 다인 노래도 아님. 느낌 못살리면 진짜 개유치하게 들림.
어디 보고오니 선녀? X
딱히 비교 안 해도 잘하는 그룹 O
돌판사상 이정도로 저평가 심한 아이돌은 처음 봄
얼굴이 너무 뛰어나서 실력이 저평가돼버림
@@user-gb1ix8pv9j이게맞는듯 ᐲᗨ ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㄹㅇ...
에스파 노래 쉽고 별로 안 높다는것도 이해 안됨.. 새비지 직접 불러보면 저 암어새비지~ 랑 애드립 파트 빼고봐도 두번째 김미김미 부분도 개높음
아니 스파이시 앵콜 보고 싶은데 제발 1위 한번만 해줘라ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
이번주 일위입니다~
czcams.com/video/edHydgKcCwQ/video.html
역시 스파이시 찢었죠
미쳤어요💥💥💥
오늘 찢음
백보컬도 빠짐없이 다 부르네...진짜 데뷔한지 1년도 안된 신인 맞는지 가끔씩 까먹음ㅋㅋㅋㅋ ㄹㅇ 레전드 그룹
윈터랑 닝닝이는 진짜 잘부르는게 신기하고 카리나랑 지젤은 저 음색이 라이브로 가능하다는게 신기하다ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 진짜 개성있고 예쁘고 잘하고 다한다 다들
인기가요 mc누구에요? 여자..ㄷ ㄷ
@@user-py8ox9kl3g 안유진님 이세요!
라이브 하니까 춤은 아예 출 엄두조차 못내네 게다가 라이브도 mr에 목소리 다 깔려있어 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@user-mr3dq1mn3p 뭔개소리임?
@@user-py8ox9kl3g 뭐여 조선족이여? 한국말 뭇알아듣냐?
WHAATTT?? why did I just knoow this video exist?? What a vocal. All the adlibs was on point. why SM let them lipsync when they have this kind of vocal. Even Karina, their main dancer, was soo goood.
exactlyyyy! The girls really have great vocals but it's very rare to hear them sing like this.
SM is weird I think he likes controversy. aespa in the united states has sung a lot live but in Korea still nothing.
their songs strain vocals if sung too much live + theres just so many highnote belt, in Black Mamba, Next Level, Savage, Dreams Come True(dunno if they will perform that), Illusion, Savage and Girls + dancing along to it takes up stamina and having to perform these live nonstop will strain their vocal, overwork them bc literally 1 song of theirs require 3x more vocal stamina and energy overall compared to other groups.
@@Poop-pd9tg you got a point🤔🤔
@meroja2394 ?? I never denied they sing it live?? In fact I am shocked why SM let them lipsync most of tge time when theirr vocal like this??? Just let them sing live all the time so they can express what they can do.
다른 애들 거 보고 에스파 보니까 존나 천국인데...;;
거의 cd수준ㅋㅋ
라이브 돌아버린거냐.... 이젠 믿고듣는다
이번 앵콜로 우리 짱스파 라이브 못한다고 ar에 입만 뻥끗한다고 까던 사람들 다 입막아주기를 ㅠㅠ 진짜 너무 잘해서 감동 나 살짝 주책맞아서 뭉클함 ㅠㅠ
여기 왜이래;;;
믿을게 그렇게 없냐
Karina's adlibs are shocking in the best way possible, her tone being lower and deeper adds so much to Ningning & Winter's higher ones. She is putting a shift in the vocal department too.
the hexagon all rounder ace so true favourite vocal color in aespa karina is literally so amazing♡
2:56 😍👌4:21
SM artists are really something else. They're vocals are on the next level ❤️🔥
after watching other gen 4th groups’ encore stages, I came here to clean my ears. Aespa is on another level. Can’t wait to their latest comeback and encore stages. It must be awesome
same 😆
Omg yess ahaha I don’t call out on them but…
me too😂😂
Yupp me too😅
Same. After lesserafim
2:36 지젤 랩 ㄹㅇ 개미쳤다 뮤비로 들었을땐 그냥 저는 것 처럼 들렸는데 지젤아 너는 라이브가 최고구나…
보컬 못해서 래퍼된 느낌이 아니라 진짜 래퍼멤버같음 진짜 잘한다
@@zir-xe2nv 영어를 잘해서 그런가 랩할때 오글거리지는 않음
근데 진짜 녹음보다 라이브가 더 좋은거 같음..
근데 보컬도 목소리 정말 예쁘게 잘 부른다는 것.. 그냥 노래를 잘함.. 얘가😊
제스처도 멋있음
2:36 지젤 랩 진짜... 하 넘 좋다...
ㄹㅇ ㅜㅜㅠㅠ 너무 좋아ㅠㅠㅠ 계속 듣는중
지젤 연습 1년정도 한걸로 아는데 왜 데뷔한지 알겠네 ㅋㅋ 개잘함 물론 나머지 셋도 실력이 아주 출중하고 네명 모두 존잘인 그룹은 얘네말고 없을듯
coming back here to watch a satisfying encore aespa slayed all their encores i’m so proud
Giselle line before the second pre-chorus is waaaayy better then in the track. They use that effect on her voice and sound a little bit weird, but listening to it raw sounds so good and powerful
Ikr!! It sounds so much better this way
Felt the same way!!
timestamp?
@@shingibanggi 2:35
와 코러스나 백그라운드로 깔리는거까지 라이브하네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 인이어도 없이 ㄹㅇ 개대단
@@user-ws9dd4qj3s 저기 현장에서는 mr 엄청 울려서 자기 목소리도 바로 안 들리니까 밀릴 수 있고 음정 잡기 어려울 거에요 인이어 없어서 귀 한쪽 막고 자기 목소리 들으려는겁니다
@@user-ws9dd4qj3s 닉값 ㅋㅋㅋ
@@user-hf1vx5fz2r 헤헤
Wow Ningnings high notes never fail, she’s so good and acted really professionally on the mic problem
이번 컴백 꼭 1위 시켜줄게!! 라이브 또 듣고 싶어 우리 엣깅이들ㅠㅜ🫶🏻
some people who don’t believe aespa can’t sing come to their encores just to verify that they can’t sing, and i’m sure they’re very disappointed they don’t find what they want lol
Ning Ning vocals are out of this worls, she is a great singer now, imagine in a few years :O
💯💯💯
현역 4세대 여돌들중 고음 키 가장 높은 그룹이 에스파랑 엔믹스임..진짜 대형은 대형이다
맞아 ㄹㅇㄹㅇ
@@clis.v 4세대 실력파 엔믹스 에스파ㅇㅈ 그리고 스테이씨 피프티피프티도 라이브 지림
서로서로 안싸우고 이런모습 너무 보기 좋은거같아..!! 서로 싸우지말고 응원해주자 ㅠㅠ 마이화이팅 앤서화이팅 허니즈화이팅!!!
하이브도 대형인데 얘네만 특히 문제가 있음ㅋㅋㅋ
@@user-qo2um3hn8i 그래도 지금 에스파 엔믹스 뉴진스가 4세대 걸그룹중에서 유일하게 모든 맴버가 지지음역 가지고있어서 뉴진스는 나쁘지않아!
SM has the best encore !!
이 영상은 지구젤리가 레전드다
지구젤리 랩 넘 죠야
역시 지존이네요
지구젤리 굿
아니 지구젤리 왜이렇게 이쁜건데? 진짜 다리길이 말이 안나와 … 랩은 또 뭐고
근데 왜 지구젤리?
쌩라이븐데 기가막힌다 ㄷ ㄷ 여기서 라이브 인증해버리네 ㅜㅜㅜㅜ 역시 짱스파 ㅜㅜ !!
ㅎㅇ
앵콜은 원래 라이브야.. 제발 좀 …
Came here after watching serrafim's encore.
Ear cleansing 💅
So violent 🤣
Good with backtrack
@@warmestrobot4872 Disini aespa nyanyi live tanpa backtrack, bsa denger gak sih lu, oiya namanya jga haters, mau dikasih fakta tetep aja denial
@@warmestrobot4872 Inkigayo tidak menggunakan backtrack!!!
@@evarohmah7046 padahal dah encore seenak ini masih dihate
I mean why would people doubt them in first place? They are from SM, and we have heard their live vocal before at variety show?
All four of them did good but haters always have complaints.
they sang this without their in-ears??? & they still sound good??? ohmy these girls never fail to impress me, continuing the SM LEGACY 💜
진짜 보고 또 보러옴...볼 때마다 가창력이 대단해서...
ㄹㅇ 라이브 진짜 잘한다ㅏㅏ
저두요 또 보러 옴ㅋㅋㅋ
One of the best encores i've ever heard!
NingNing wanted to slay so bad but the mic didn't help her so she tried her best and she still rock anyway. It was also cute how professional she is by trying to make the staff look at her and solve the problem. I love these girls because they are really good.
So true, it looks like ningning kept giving them signs to do something with her mic (the volume was too low ig) started at 1:34
Everytime they sing live people say Something about NingNing mic's. I think this is not the problem.
@@lucasaugusto36 yes only u think so
@@huong2711_ I won't argue with delulu
@@lucasaugusto36 don't argue with those cant accept facts
Not a MY, but these girls are truly on another level, vocal queens indeed!
역시 짱스파
thank you! 💘
So we’re all here for an ear cleanse after that new gg’s encore performance? 😂😂
yes
볼때마다 만족스럽… 지젤 딕션이랑 뒤에 휘몰아치는 구간 진짜 쾌감
마지막 닝닝이 고음올리는거 라이브라고 믿을수 없다... 미쳤다... 찢었다...
닝이쥨 미쳤어 ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Perfect encore like what you'd expect from SM artists
에스파는 걍 완벽한듯 라이브도 잘하고 각자만에 개성있는데 또 개이쁨
에스파 진짲 ㅈㄴ 잘하네 윈터가 진짜 탄탄하고 카리나는 랩 위주로 부르길래 포지션 랩인줄 알았는데 보컬 진짜 잘하고 닝닝도 메보답게 진짜 잘함 ㅠ 세비지 음원들으면 지젤 랩 부분 약간 발음 뭉게지는 것 처럼 불렀는데 라이브는 ㅈㄴ 속사포 지젤 ㅈㄴ 자래~
Winter was flawless as always! Karina and Giselle were great too! But can I just applaud Ningning’s vocal technique. She is so good most especially during those high notes. She knows how to deliver it while not straining her voice.
Exactly. Some saying it's pure head voice but it's a heady mixed.
@@Ornav1005 true! She was using mixed voice which is so good and smart of her!
I know giselle rap is good, but she really amazed me in this encore
Her second verse rap in high tone is so much better live 😳
IKR! Giselle fighting!💕🌙
her voice is so attractiveee
Iya kaann, kita semua tau dia bagus tapi gatau kalo sebagus itu huhuuu
@@taengoonim i noticed that too, the official audio seems to be sounding somewhat thin, but here damnnnn, there's depth to it.
Coming back to aespa encore after watching other group encore, blessed my ear
역시 대기업의 안정성, 고성능이 느껴지는 무대.
ALL AESPA MEMBER CAN SING LIKE A MAIN VOCAL, CAN DANCE LIKE A MAIN DANCER, CAN RAP LIKE A MAIN RAPPER. They can rock anything💅
They all rounder
일위하고도 진짜 맘 편하게 못 즐기는 게 마음 아픔..
에스파 라이브 잘해요!!!!!!!!!!! 찢었어
엥 왜유??
루미나크련이 에스파로 어그로 끌면서 창조논란 조집니다ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
헐 왜용?ㅠㅠ
언젠가부터 앵콜이 실력 검증 무대가 되었는지... 코로나가 문제야 문제..
진짜 어느 순간부터 1위를 맘껏 즐기 지 못하는 무대가 돼버렸어요..그래서 더 칭찬해주고 싶음 너무 잘했다
Are you jealous guys ? Yeah cause Aespa is the next level of anyone
who said their vocal bad??? this song is not easy to sing live and they did so good.
They only say that because their stages are pre recorded, but that doesn’t mean they can’t sing!!
4:30 i mean... They're not even performing a choreo, you can't miss that.
@@gravityVL1485 other group did encore without choreo but their voices weren't as stable as aespa you can't miss that too, bruh
@@loveunta5340 they're always indenial when it comes to aespa lol
I think people never said that their vocals were bad, because they never even sang live until nowadays they are. What the people said is that they’re not singing live and just do lip syncing all the time, which is frustrating, especially that they are under an entertainment that’s known for their vocals.
Ning Ning actually has so much control over her pitch, she knows exactly when to tone down the note, Winter as well!! Karina is just an outstanding ace and Giselle with her rap is just 😍 her adlibs are amazing as well, hopefully we’ll get to hear her vocals more! Proud of them
Agree! They seem confident here than the last encore and it shows.. The debate last time was Ningning’s highnote, people were saying she used falsetto, it’s clear here now that she’s using head voice,so proud! 💕
@@thetiffingpoints i think it's more of a heady mix. Not pure head but mixed with the head voice more dominant.
Winter still went flat at her note tho. I don’t blame her, F#5 isn’t an easy note
Invierno también
At 1:33 onwards you can literally see ningning pointing to her mic as in to signal that it’s not on. The girls obviously want to sing, but SM isn’t letting them. They aren’t sing live....
don't you just love the way WinNing hit their high notes? not to mention Giselle and Karina's rap skills. stan real talent, stan aespa.
Including adlibs, Stan Aespa
하.. 이 안정감에 슴덕한다… 앵콜 안정감.. 좋다..
Giselle who was training in just months can beat a 4 years training. SM really debuting a talent, not just visual like that group and agency. Proud with aespa
one thing about aespa, theyll never disappoint us with their live vocals
OMG, Giselle being confident in live rapping! Such a bias wrecker
윈터가 보컬 꽉 잡아주는거 진짜 멋지다
*Ningning & winter hit the high note perfectly.* *Karina hit her high note part & rap part perfectly.* *Giselle rap was perfect.* Aespa is really perfectionist & true amazing artists of the generation 💕
I think so
@@astheticbrownstall9499 you stan racist RM that not only mouthed the n word but sang it on stage so gtfo with your selective outrage
@@astheticbrownstall9499 bark all you can.
@@arthurmrl Get over it. She already apologized. Gee,
아니 무슨 숨소리도 같이 들리니까 음원보다 더 좋은 거 실화냐..? 와 음색봐 다들 실력파들 모인 그룹이구나
와 미쳤어 자기 테이프를 먹었나봐^^