The Untold Issues with Elon Musk's Mars Dreams
Vložit
- čas přidán 15. 06. 2024
- Step up your style game with Gentlebands' unique rings, made from rare materials like retired spacecraft and genuine dinosaur fossils. Visit: bit.ly/3U0lzBy and use code WHATIF for an exclusive 25% discount at checkout.
Elon Musk's claim of having a million people on Mars by 2050 is just one of his many bold, yet dubious, statements about Mars. This video will review his assertions over the years, including ideas like Martians not needing to worry about radiation and the benefits of dropping nukes on Mars. We'll evaluate the truth behind these claims and explore the possibility of such a future.
Get the What if book: bit.ly/ytc-the-what-if-100-book
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @whatifscienceshow
Interested in sponsoring our episodes or collaborating? Email us: contact@underknown.com
Our other channels:
How to Survive: bit.ly/how-to-survive-show
Aperture: bit.ly/aperture-show
T-shirts and merch: bit.ly/shopwhatif
Newsletter: bit.ly/whatif-newsletter
What If elsewhere:
Discord: / discord
Whatsapp: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va8V...
Instagram: bit.ly/whatif-instagram
Twitter: bit.ly/whatif-twitter
Facebook: bit.ly/facebook-whatif
Produced with love by Underknown in Toronto: underknown.com - Věda a technologie
Step up your style game with Gentlebands' unique rings, made from rare materials like retired spacecraft and genuine dinosaur fossils. Visit: bit.ly/3U0lzBy and use code WHATIF for an exclusive 25% discount at checkout.
Cool
You are a blessing. Well done on exposing the lies [that the narcissist] elon musk has spread.💛
Hi we watch your videos and my people love you. can i translate your videos? 💫❤️THANK YOU Slovakia Space and UFO❤️💫
Doesn't nuclear energy require water or coolant to cool off
It’s easy for a wealthy billionaire to spew out ideas cause the media just needs sound bites
That's it. All Elon have is money. That's like people hang to his words like gospel.
😂 @MrDmoney1984 you sound like a retard, like 98% of americans.
"I think we should prioritize sending robots to other planets to gather essential minerals, rather than sending humans. Human exploration should come second. For now, we should focus on saving the Earth first".
Planet Earth forever 🌎
Particularly you are so bad and worst forever 😂😂😂
What's wrong, is your soul weighed down by gravity??
No Earth, Yes Other Planets But Habitable/Superhabitable
I like mars
Good
People that are alive today don't need to worry about ever setting foot on mars. None of us will live long enough to see that become reality.
No one born in the next 100 years who doesn't become a super top expert in something related to working in space or a colonisation program will have to worry about ever setting foot on Mars. Ordinary people won't be going there for centuries, if ever. Of the experts who *do* go some day, many of them will be driven mad by life on a totally inhospitable world. Constant worry about radiation, temperature, the integrity of shelter, the availability of food and water plus the insane winds and sand storms, the differences in day length and gravity, the confinement to small spaces with other people, the near-impossibility of real-time communication with Earth and the inability to leave at will is going to annihilate even the toughest professionals. Hell - working in Antarctica for a year is enough to send a lot of people off the deep end. Mars will be like that dialled up well past 11.
That’s what they said after America dropped the 2 nukes.
I’m a lot more optimistic.
Must be terrible to be you and have that belief. 😀
What? I believe a million people at Mars will happen next 80 years or so.
I believe in Elon Musk a lot. Look how far Space X has come. Breaking records after records each year and are growing so quick that nobody else can keep up. To then get those space ships to Mars and back safely is the hard part. But once that’s under control with minimal risks and cheaper transportation I believe humans building its first city on mars is 100 % gonna happen
I'm sure my gen will see it since were really young by12-27 so
If they get us at Mars by 2050 and one of us is one of the million then we could
Elon Musks cant even create a reliable pickup truck, how tf is he going to go to mars.😂
Even musk does not believe in any of his bS about mars colonization. But he knows his followers will.
@jikan-tabi-1888 Given his history of making outrageous claims I think he definitely does.
@@David-bg9od Well, you might be right. But trips to mars and the logistics of colonization are not possible during our lifetime.
@@jikan-tabi-1888 How old are you?
@@zhchbob Too darn old.
If NASA had the budget of the U.S military they done it years ago.
They wouldn't because the US would get invaded
no, NASA will waste that money on SLS.
@@zhchbob Actually it would be wasted on obozo's muslim outreach.
Lot of people believe blindly what this elon says instead of doing research on own that mars is totally different and inhospitable
right wing cult members
I can’t believe I was so much a fanatic with Elon Musk. That I completely forgot about the laws of physics, and reality. I’m just glad that I had friends who helped me see what a fraud he is.
🤣
Elon is awesome. So what if he dreams big? At least he’s working toward something.
@@Lovell93 dreams lol. He is bafoon
@@rousbagaming Whatever you say man.🤣
@@Lovell93If you say so man 😊 , this is the same bloke that while being interviewed on the telly proclaimed to be the most knowledgeable car maker on the planet , I nearly fell off my chair laughing , and there is the abomination that is the Cyber Truck 😂😂😂😂😂😂 , that thing breaks so many automotive rules in the car design , and not in a good way 😊.
And the one million people to mars thing ? Yeah I believe itm😂.
Do you remember when he had a robot demonstration , and it was a person in a robot suit dancing around on stage 😂😂😂😂😂😂 kinda reminds me of an old style circus host 😊.
This is the same dude selling Tesla buyers for thousands of dollars self drive ….. when it is actually not 😂😂😂😂😂 , , seriously you can’t make this stuff up.
Humanity will die even before reaching mars... I am not a pessimist, but the rate at which we are destroying our planet, we need to think about sustaining it first rather than showing something that is out of our reach.
yeah back in the 80s the climate experts LOL said we only had 20 more years to live and now 40 years later they are still using the same scare tactics.... We aren't doing much to this planet after all..
Honestly the best thing we can do for earth IS to go to mars. And by going to mars we literally will have to start from the opposite end. Creating it to be like earth. It would cause us to think outside the box and learn how to stop using all the toxins we do that are killing the planet.
The filthy rich want a planet to escape to after they’ve trashed planet earth.
As long as we got egocentric leaders around the world thinking about how to get richer rather then saving the planet then this choice to colonize mars is the best option. Elon isn’t getting controlled the way the population on earth is getting controlled. To save humanity if an earth changing catastrophe is happening then I believe Mars is the right choice even if it sux too… Who would want to leave earth for Mars? Right? But still…
I don’t believe in the good of those leading our planet right now.
Could also actually land on the moon first as well
Humans can't live in mars what is the point of going to mars. Protect earth by planting more plants and make earth more green. Save earth, it will save us
We can't live in Mars doesn't mean we don't have to explore it but sending people over there is also absolutely bullshit (currently)
And also earth will still kill us at some point even if we worship her😂 we are in due for multiple natural disasters💀
Four million years ago, there was a group of apes leaving the trees, exploring the unfamiliar grasslands. They are our ancestors. Those stayed in the forests become chimpanzee.
Exactly what "cave men" ideals are. No innovation. Scared to explore the world
Rather than go to mars why dont we start trying to fix the problems we have created here first. Ridiculous
So we aren’t trying to fix things on earth? And why can’t we do both? The scientific breakthroughs made by colonising mars would most definitely help solve problems here on earth.
@@michaelholmes8848how?
@@michaelholmes8848 brain fog
@@michaelholmes8848except the amount of money that’s been invested and wasted on space - could’ve already solved a majority of the problems on earth.
I just wanna go for scientific purposes
Not only is it a lie, but it's a stupidity, too. What are we doing planning to live on Mars if planet Earth hasn't fully been explored yet. Lol. We're still not even type I civilization, and we're already thinking about settling on another planet? What are we doing? Fix our home planet first before moving to the next.
Because we can! We should as a species..
cleaning up all the pollution on earth is harder than you think
@@supanance Yes, the pollution that you created in the first place. Great response. Where's your thought process, sir. No offense.
@@GameKai51well, many scientists believe that global warming has been irreversible and will continue to worsen soo
What can I say, Human are selfish. People who have the power to change our world don't care about our world. They only care about themselves.
And let me add that human are also dumb. Well most people are anyway. Anyone who is willing to spent 10 mins to learn anything about the science behind space travel will immediately call out Elon Musk bullshit. But for some dumb reason, people idolize him and will believe anything he said.
Musk needs to get his Cyber Trucks here on Earth working first, and a car that will operate if it’s Cold, Hot or if you go through a puddle of water 🤦🏽♀️.
What are you talking about?
@@michaelholmes8848 what @bonniewatson178 is saying is Tesla vehicles suck.
you could just buy a proven concept instead of being trendy lol
@@yavindesolate6444 like what?
@@yavindesolate6444 like what?
Mabey people should try helping him instead of criticize
The physiological effects on the crew when they see Earth vanish before their eyes and that six month one-way trip to uncertainty. 😬
After the dream about space travel is broken, will the human appreciate and respect the environment they are living in more?
Nothing can replace our Mother Earth, ❤❤❤
So you stay with your mother forever?
Every planet in the the solar system is literally inhabitable.. except Earth , all that money Elon has and he couldn’t buy himself a clue smh
Every inch of land was literally inhabitable before the first fish landed on the soil. Every acre of savanna was dangerous to the apes before they started to walk upright and invented stone tools. You stay in water, you are fish forever. You stay in forests, you are apes forever.
Elon go back and re-designs your stupid cyber truck before you talk about Mar.
Multi year wait list, looks like a LOT of people disagree with you. My guess is you’re just mad cos you can’t afford one.
@@michaelholmes8848and ur a broke dude defending a billionaire 😅 pathetic
The guys a dreamer lol
@@Angela-cj9xf a dreamer? The guy literally gets shit done.
Still mad that Elon Musk bought Twitter? Lol.
Thunderf00t has just joined
Elon Musk has left the chat
I’d rather he leave the country.
@@INgirl812I mean Elon can stay and you can leave, how about that?
@@Lovell93 Naw, he can go any time. YOU can leave though, fanboy.
I don't trust a word Elon Says
That is if you can make out actual words in his mumbling….
This video really made me rethink what I knew about Elon Musk's Mars settlement plan. While the idea of a multi-planetary future is appealing, this video points out some practical issues that we need to consider more closely.
So if you take water off earth for every launch, won’t that mean each trip irrevocably removes water from our planet till we lose too much? It’ll take time, but I don’t think that’s a good idea if it’s true.
If you believe global warming will cause melting of the ice caps, rising sea levels and the displacement of people from coastal areas, this wouldn’t be a bad outcome.
Comets brings water to earth everyday.
Radion during the journey: Because some water is required during the journey, it will be this one which you keep as a shield.
These people cant even go to the moon and talk about colonization of mars in near future
Moon sucks. We have been there before.
General question could we possibly use cloud seeding to teraform mars?
“A magnetic shield is critical to preserving Earth's atmosphere and habitability. Without it, Earth would resemble Mars.” All the problems pointed out could be solved but it would be a colossal waste of time and effort since Mars lacks an Earth like magnetic shield.
We may not be able to build a planet scale magnetic shield. But it is easy to build a local magnetic shield. Go google "CREW HaT: A Magnetic Shielding System for Space Habitat".
Love your videos. Please do a video about planets sharing the same orbit. The whole 42 earths theory. Please 🙏 and thank u.
Mars by 2050? Highly unlikely. Mars by 2350? Still unlikely. Keep dreaming to all aspiring Martians.
Ten year ago, they said it's highly unlikely to reuse rockets, and they said the starlink will fail, and they thought Boeing will beat spaceX in sending human to ISS.
I love your comment
Even a stupid person can see through elon musk. People fall for anything.
You sound really stupid.
There is actually nothing sinister behind it. Scientists often exaggerate possibilities to receive more funding. This is very normal and even a good thing because it accelerates the process of achieving their goals. Imagine if someone told you that something would take hundreds of years to accomplish-would you be interested in funding or even researching it to make it happen? Probably not, because you would never see it with your own eyes.
However, it is still better to be optimistic about these things. Elon Musk is passionate about his work, and as a result, he is going to live a life full of passion, which is certainly a life worth living.
----- Without optimism in the human's body we would never be as far as we are today
@@staying_substantially6186 musk cares more about tweeting his policital views then space x
I don't know...look at some of these comments. People actually think he is some kind of genius that invents things.
Smart people said reusing rocket is impossible. Luckily, I am not that smart.
after the poll this video actually came faster than i thought
impressive
people have been exposing elon LONG before he bought twitter
@@travishylton6976 real
It was already in the works! We needed help with the title
@@WhatIfScienceShow epic
I am open to any idea, fiction or non-fiction, realistic or unrealistic, that's the only way we can reach new frontiers
Even the ones that will kill people, such as "radiation isn't a problem"?
@@GunUDwnAt2nd Yes! Which means we just need to find a solution
@@vascodagama6310 lol
I don't think humanity will made some significant step until 2100 and if we don't fix some things here on earth we will be probably gone soon.
Where were we at 1924? And don't forget tech is accelerating, esp. the AI tech.
Damn I never thought of that 😅
I would have thought that there would be more dislikes from the Elon d riders. Only 97 at the time of this posting. Elon has lied to all of us, i cant believe at one stage i thought he was smart. The then opened his mouth and the idea quickly dissipated.
blud looks like elon musk💀
Fully self driving cars in 2020 (or 2018? i forgot)
2024, the Smart Summon from parking dasn't even work
What have you done for society
Nothing your opinion means less than nothing
@@Anonymous-pr1bx dude. u are rly dumb :* Its not Elon getting new things - he didnt explore anything - he got lucky having a lot of money and hiring smart people. he isnt the smart guy, its his employes.
@@Anonymous-pr1bx at least i didnt scam milions of fans, time and time again
Just look at cybertruck, its a disaster
@Anonymous-pr1bx You bot can't even insult right, like what, you didn't do anything either, neither really did Clown Musk, that's not even an argument.
Plz make a video with the title -
What if we humans had 2 hearts 💕
What would happen?
It's not About Mars. It's about asteroid mining. That star ship today is a cargo Ship tomorrow .
This is an intelligent direction to take space travel. After all, asteroids visit us frequently enough. It is just a matter of a rendezvous, or blasting off a section of the passing asteroid.
it would not surprise me if we had a milion people on Mars by 2050, nor would it surprise me if we have no one on Mars by 2050.
You know how when you hit the poles of a bees nest the swarm comes out :/ scary.
Supposedly theres geo thermo heat....I'm not sure melting poles with that and solar lasers would be a good idea?
Also, why are we not staging the moon as a better launching pad, or at least one of many along the ways . . whether towards mars or venus. some way stations for supples and mini launches or mini lunches.
Love this channel😊
Thank you!
Although all that bad news won’t ever effect me I’m getting anxiety for our future.
We can’t solve Mars problems and are only creating more on our perfect planet. Devastating
My boy went johnny dang
Getting to mars using electric vehicles. Ha ha ha
The fact is, who on earth gonna go to Mars tho? Lol
seems like musk could cover his statements with, 'not likely in our lifetime", or not by saying "this time next year". year after year. In essense, he puts forth time tables not feasible and then moves the goal posts to keep the interest and the dollars.
Using earth's resources to build civilization on Mars 😅😅😂
why not?
As cool it would be to live on Mars we as humans need to travel at the speed of both ships from Star Trak or Star Wars or better yet create a portal from Star Gate and we can easily teleport there
We don’t know really how many people would be willing to go to mars until it’s actually offered to them. Everyone sent there would need to have a trade because becoming self sustainable is very important, manufacturing and construction would be key
l prefer live in desert instead of mars, at least thee is atmosphere and air, even we can see alive (animales) in desert
@@nordeenhasan8630 yeah mars wouldn’t be a nice place to live. Although a lot of people say they would go to mars, I don’t think they’ve 100% thought it through 😂 so good luck to Elon finding a million people willing to leave earth!!!
Elon musk seems to have the same form of reckless stupidity seen in Stockton Rush
Keep talking...he's the one who is going to go down as one of the greatest engineering and influential figures in human history; not you
We need to send unmanned fully automated robots and drilling equipment. Certain things need to be ready for people before we send people
Until they discover a rare mineral on Mars and then it'll be 2040, didn't you take notes from Open AI?
So much negativity and fear to reach out for Mars and beyond. It's amazing that people are not afraid to walk in the rain.
I prefer to walk on the Mars than in some LA streets.
You wait. When tesla bot is learning they will send thousands of them to set up the bases
I'm really glad you made this video.
Elon isn't the designer of most of his companies, he's just a slightly Autistic capitalist building 💰 from his tribes of real creators.
His change politically and his statements since 2014 tainted my opinion enough to realize he's not that learnedly smart or people smart, instead more like a salesman trying to pitch things to fool his fanbase rather than to really advance humanity. (Gwen Shotwell is the real reason SpaceX has become the top launch provider and trusted by the US government and military.)
A few O'Neal cylinders rather a million walking dead on poisonous Martian soil by 2029 would better serve to save humanity from his greatest hits list, and Starship could be a very big part: First by making a moon base to both exploit resources and learn how to better survive in space, then helping gather asteroids for O'Neal cylinder resources and building them in less time (2060 to 2100) than terraforming Mars (starting 2035 to 3200}, and for less 💰.
All this from research and IMHO.
And I expect to be criticized by Musk fanboys and girls because that's what happens when you don't agree Elon is always right or a super being (I always said he was a real life Tony Stark before I saw through it all).
@@TomTRay dudes a cult leader
@@TomTRay please take your meds and stfu!
@@travishylton6976 Agreed, 💯%! The problem is his Kool Aid needs rational thought to dilute it, and he is smart enough to spin things to seem like being on the edge of possible (like the rescue sub for the boys in the cave) to well-soaked sci-fi acolytes. It wasn't until I began deep research for a sci-fi novel series that I realized what he was doing. So, multiply time lines by a minimum of 1.5 , normally 2.25, costs by 1.5, and tech development by as much as 5 because he tries to be Tony Stark spread far too thinly over massively hyped projects. His Tesla people he has treated like indentured servants, the staff that made guardrails for Twitter like excess overhead, Boring company a rich-people express lane demo, and PayPal another stolen PR hype that he was barely a part of. His NDAs are vicious, he's used women (Grimes, even some employees) as incubators for his legacy (except for Amber Herd, who refused and broke up, breaking his heart.) SpaceX only survived and prospered because he HAD to hire and pass control to Gwen, Bill Gerstenmaier, and Tom Mueller to make it and understand how to sell it to NASA and the Pentagon. After his betrayal of Ukraine by switching off Starlink just before they could drone strike the Black Sea Fleet and piers he cost literally thousands of Ukrainian lives, military and civilians, by letting the missile ships escape to later attack far inland. That to me was his final flaw ... He fears Putin's propaganda so badly he runs away, thinks he's saving humanity when he is enabling a force that will kill millions of not stopped. That's what summed him up in a nutshell... A fearful opportunist who the Pentagon should force to agree to work with national security or be excluded from contracts until he does.
He's looking at possibilities and as of right now we are only limited by our level of technology. But that doesn't mean in the future we will still be limited.
The problem with your statement is that Musk said this will happen in just 5 years. Lol! Don’t believe someone who says “radiation risk ‘isn’t a problem’.” Musk is wrong. If he thinks radiation is no big deal, then he must be on his pretend starship. Let him risk his life with radiation. He is NOT an expert.
Our technology will be super advanced in 20 years, assuming there are no significant setbacks like societal collapse or that we don’t go extinct. There might be an AI singularity in the next decade or thereafter, and when that happens, a lifetime of scientific, technological, and medical discoveries/breakthroughs will be happening in a single day. There’s no predicting how advanced we will be as a civilization in 10 years, let alone by 2050.
@@thedannybseries8857 Dude what you're saying now, people used to say 20 years ago. Go and tell this to a real expert in AI, they'll laugh in your face.
Can you make video about australia please ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
They also said electric cars are impossible to mass produce
You are making this up. Don't you?
Who said that electric cars are impossible to mass produce?
A planet with no water. No air and atmosphere, no magnetic field can replace earth? Humans will live in special camps. Like they're jailed . Earth is the only home. Its magical and beautiful 😍
Is this a simulation where we can see how much we can advance
You can grow meat from just a few animal cells. Would you really need insects?
15:03 quantum locked gyroscopic electromagnetic induction is the future of energy. It can also create an electromagnetic field around anything and protect it from radiation.
We can even go back to the moon
Can we make planets like the ones that stop us in time like eve garden
what if we have Sun's magnetic field
Instead of colonising mars with these silly ideas why not spend that money on EARTH!
This is not Star Trek. He’s not a scientist, just a man with an awful lot of money.
American donated billions to African countries before. Any changes? The earth is doomed, look at the Africa, look at the middle east, look at the Afghanistan.
Automatic thumbs up for calling it twitter. THANK YOU!
Imagine they sell ships for 7,000,000ES
99% criticises the 1% that tries. Society
Haha trying something you even know it’s impossible?
10000% agree, most of the people in these comments, are criticizing too much, whereas they should be doing their share to make an impact, and aid in expanding the advancements of human civilization
Lol we ate not criticising
We are saying billionaires are making plans to run away after destroying earth and we will suffer
@@specialuser3455 exactly
This CZcamsr underestimates the power of technology. He probably is part of the group that criticized the release of the iPhone.
That’s weird I never heard Elon say anything remotely like that
Can we go to small long distance
musk -- the world's only "serious" scientist who announces his discoveries on late night television. What a serious scholar. And I am the King of Alaska (J. Bravo @ 1990).
Rings from fossils? Sure. They can say anything…
Elon Musk's Plan Nuke Mars Really Reminds Me Of Genes from Star Trek 2 Wrath Of Khan. I Just Hope Works Out Better than it did in the Movie. As I am Indifferent on Colonizing Mars.
Think he meet flying Tesla EV’s to Mars with a sting of a Million Tesla charging stations along the way…👀
Elon forgot to tell us , the travel thing , thats already solved , we just get Scotty to beam us to mars , no problems 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂.
We should send AI powered robots with solar charger or batteries in the space shuttle to Mars
And then let them terraform the planet for us
He'll no but you can go, if there was a factory for robots there could be a million robots.
We would live underground at first on mars
He is super optimistic but we need people who dream big
I think a million people on Mars won't be a reality till 2150-2200
Love what if videos❤❤❤
Wait.... you thought one million alive people? You know how Elon is! 😂
Send Tesla bots to Mars first to build a habitat for humans.
The answer is: FUSION! Not only would we have all the power we need from all the household fusion devices we will take with us to Mars, but plants and animals love fusion too! And as fusion is a panacea, it can probably help us with the cosmic radiation and low gravity problems too! Just throw some FUSION at it and voila…no more problems! Well except maybe for John Carpenter’s ghosts
I have all the symptoms that astronauts get after spending time in space and I think I've never been to space
If you want a colony, just think of an oil rig. It has to be supplied, but you have at least:
- oxygen 24/7
- rescue operation
- temperature survivable for humans
(- water with desalination)
- no radiation on the surface
- very profitable 🤑
I Antarctica 🇦🇶 you have:
- oxygen 24/7
- rescue operation
- water (you melt the ice)
- no radiation on the surface
On Titan you have:
- water (you melt the ice)
- oxygen (electrolysis)
- no radiation on the surface
- ❌ no rescue operation
- ❌ temperature is 2x colder then in Antarctica !
On Mars you have:
- ❌The temperature of Antarctica (best case spring temperature)
- ❌ no water
- ❌ no oxygen
- ❌ radiation on the surface
- ❌ no identified natural resources
To terraform the Mars a lot of comets from the Oort cloud a required to crash on the Mars!
It's not about the time line It's about saving humanity from extinct by its own or natural so space x is building transportation mechanism others will do the other problem to be fixed
Have you thought about what if there is no god?
Means we just existed from dust
And no hell
And no heaven
And no other life after death?
MOON CHAN FIRST
It's definitely going to happen.
Yo! So, what if he creates the robot bodies and transfers human minds thru neurolink as the inhabitants that start the initial development?
He hasn't created anything yet...why would he create that?
Please send more there, so we got more resources here. Else Thanos is gonna snap. Wahahaha.
Submarines provide the crew with water and oxygen. They require the outside salt water.
👉This technology is mastered. ✅
Thanks ❤❤❤❤