Poppy - Knockoff (Old Original Am I a Girl Unreleased Version)

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 8. 09. 2024

Komentáře • 58

  • @_beank
    @_beank  Před rokem +43

    Official version (way better imo) > czcams.com/video/ag3L1fBPo54/video.html

    • @kentonkruger8333
      @kentonkruger8333 Před rokem +7

      Yup. The improvements show how much she's grown as an artist.

    • @siribubz
      @siribubz Před rokem

      this is the original actually, it was scrapped in AIAG era. the 2023 version's a remake :)

    • @Picklebean72
      @Picklebean72 Před rokem +10

      @@siribubzit says “OFFICIAL” version. Everyone knows this one came first

    • @3407
      @3407 Před 9 měsíci +3

      this one better.

    • @gracedthecosmos_
      @gracedthecosmos_ Před 8 měsíci

      @@Picklebean72 er, it was edited. i'm pretty sure it used to say original

  • @energyismygame
    @energyismygame Před rokem +52

    this is like “dream version” while the version that got officially released is the “nightmare version”

  • @gogogogogoh
    @gogogogogoh Před 8 měsíci +22

    I'm glad it was changed tbh because the album would feel very incomplete to me if there was no "X" 😭

  • @TheEaterofPumpkins
    @TheEaterofPumpkins Před 9 měsíci +19

    Ok I'm biased because I have adored Poppy from the beginning, but OH MY GODS. I love the official version on *ZIG so much and I love this just as much, it just feels like the disco version or something. Can't help but to dance. Love how versatile she can sound. Seriously one of the best artists out there right now (again, in my humble opinion😅)
    Thank you SO much for posting! I'm obsessed

  • @robinr2740
    @robinr2740 Před 9 měsíci +15

    I think both versions can coexist. I love both. I prefer Poppy's "I wanna know!" in this unreleased version. Also, I LOVE the picture of Poppy you used for this! So lovely...Thanks for sharing this!

  • @terribleterri2738
    @terribleterri2738 Před 10 měsíci +12

    Both versions are good but the released one sounds refreshing.

  • @pp3droo
    @pp3droo Před rokem +10

    the chorus on this is pop perfection

  • @Clarity_of_Light
    @Clarity_of_Light Před 11 měsíci +21

    It's good but the official new version is better!

  • @LibertarianMinded
    @LibertarianMinded Před 10 měsíci +5

    This version is amazing, like something special, real authentic 🎶❤️

  • @clairecelestin8437
    @clairecelestin8437 Před rokem +14

    Thank you for this! I'd never heard this version before, and it's fascinating to compare.

  • @curtisyue182
    @curtisyue182 Před rokem +21

    Wow. This wasn't good enough for the album? This is a such a good & unique song.

  • @AllieBorse
    @AllieBorse Před rokem +33

    Maybe its just cos its a demo but the new version is such a leap forward

    • @daviv
      @daviv Před rokem +3

      this isnt a demo, this is the final version for aiag

    • @KSxKPxLG
      @KSxKPxLG Před rokem +4

      ​@@davivIf it wasn't released, then it's a demo.

    • @daviv
      @daviv Před rokem +4

      @@KSxKPxLG no its not, this is the final version of the aiag version of this song, just bcs its unreleased it doesnt means its a demo

    • @KSxKPxLG
      @KSxKPxLG Před rokem +14

      @@daviv It sounds like a demo, sounds unfinished, like it's missing a little production. Usually demos are turned into the official version only when they are totally sure that its going to be included in the album, otherwise it's an unnecessary expense of money and time.

    • @daviv
      @daviv Před rokem +3

      @@KSxKPxLG im pretty sure this was changed at like the last minute and replaced by X, and many songs in AIAG has that ''unfinished'' sound so i do think this is the final ver, also a snippet of the demo already leaked and it isnt this

  • @qveenspring
    @qveenspring Před rokem +6

    downloading before it’s taken down♥️ ty

  • @aerdeniz
    @aerdeniz Před rokem +30

    I think this version fits the vocals much better

  • @MarieKyriney
    @MarieKyriney Před rokem +21

    i feel like this is the bling bling version of this song before shit got sinister later on ...

    • @stealthis
      @stealthis Před 11 měsíci +1

      Sinister is an understatement BEG FOR FORGIVENESS FROM JESUS THE CHRIST

  • @PlxsteredH34rt
    @PlxsteredH34rt Před 11 měsíci +4

    Funny how am I a girl is my fav album and I love knockoff still

  • @oaktowndimond668
    @oaktowndimond668 Před měsícem +1

    Cool! I definitely dig ali payami's dark electro vibe in the zig version more imho.

  • @lizard.wizard
    @lizard.wizard Před 11 měsíci +26

    how delusional do you have to be to say this version is better lmfao. i know this is an unfinished demo but the the final one is so much better

    • @3407
      @3407 Před 10 měsíci +4

      i've been listening to this regularly for years. and i like it better because it's what i'm used to.

    • @ASadPigeon
      @ASadPigeon Před 10 měsíci +8

      the production of this version is more intricate and unique, imo.

    • @FourthGenerationPark
      @FourthGenerationPark Před 10 měsíci +4

      The fact this one is more authentic than the new one for a start
      Before you jump on me I mean not as much autotune

    • @respectable-username
      @respectable-username Před 9 měsíci +1

      I dance different than Interprative Dark Pop 💀 I want something lighter n bouncier like thisn

    • @pp3droo
      @pp3droo Před 9 měsíci +1

      this is a pop song, the released knockoff is industrial

  • @berkeleymorrison
    @berkeleymorrison Před rokem +9

    i knew it was from aiag

  • @TheWeeabooKid
    @TheWeeabooKid Před 11 měsíci +14

    this version is better.

  • @alexciarlo280
    @alexciarlo280 Před rokem +15

    This was for Britney for glory

  • @ferchemac9451
    @ferchemac9451 Před rokem +13

    this version is bettee

  • @shion1074
    @shion1074 Před 11 měsíci +9

    she should go back to doing this stuff, it suits her better

    • @poppy7740
      @poppy7740 Před 11 měsíci +5

      she doesn't want to do this stuff anymore, music artists aren't just going to do everything you want them to this was years ago she's grown

    • @shion1074
      @shion1074 Před 10 měsíci +3

      @@poppy7740 yeah I know, I was just expressing my opinion. Whether she goes back to this or not, it doesn't change my life anyway, it was just my thought

    • @terribleterri2738
      @terribleterri2738 Před 10 měsíci +12

      Tbh I feel like metal fits her better, especially her genre poppymetal, the lolita voice mixing with the devilish heavy metal sounds always works, she's like this generation Kittie or something. I do miss her pop poppy era because she seemed to interact with us more though.