Inside Shin Bet | Al Jazeera World
Vložit
- čas přidán 22. 10. 2013
- Israel's internal security service, Shin Bet, or Shabak as it is known in both Hebrew and Arabic, is one of the three branches of the Israeli General Security Service (GSS).
Through personal accounts - from two former Shin Bet detainees, a former agency officer, Palestinian-Israeli lawyers and Israeli legal experts and politicians - Al Jazeera World examines the controversial organisation's methods, powers and history.
- Subscribe to our channel: aje.io/AJSubscribe
- Follow us on Twitter: / ajenglish
- Find us on Facebook: / aljazeera
- Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
I am looking forward to an Aj-Jazeera documentary on the evils of the Iranian Regime including hangings of civilians.
Its walid from faude in the begining
Yes
Yes🥃
Any American who worries too much about what Shin Bet does in Israel, should be more concerned about what CIA and NSA do to its own citizens.
in the words of one of the shin bet director "it's not about moral, only tactics, find moral in a terrorist first"
what the palestinian arabs describe of the shhin bet is a picnic as ompare to what would happen in a palestinian arab jail in gaza r the PA authority
And with this report, the number of perspective recruits for the Israeli security forces most likely doubled.............
If I was Mr Jihad I would add Hitler to my name just to get a bit more oomph
Do you mean castille ?
@@AbdulqadirJilani-cq2pw No, I mean your mother
I believe he means.. All the surrounding Arab countries are doing this as well so if you want to expose Israel, you should expose the other Arab countries for their similar practices.
They do, you obviously dont watch too many documentaries, this one just happens to be about Israel who as you quiet rightly state seems to share similar values.
when a suspect of terrorism is caught, she must be interviewed, its been proved that most of them give essential information regarding potential terrorist acts, proof of that is that terrorism has increased during the last 30 years, and is getting strong how is that Palestine is governed by a terrorist group called Hamas. May Hashem bless the land of Israel.
Ironic that the very persecution of a people helped create a state that now persecutes and tortures people to sustain that state, yet one seems to be justified.....Hmmm...
Truly ironic and sadly many are blinded by the narratives/propaganda written by the occupiers!
What Shin Bet does is no different from what muslim countries do as a rule. At least in Israel they are monitored by the Knesset. In no muslim country do you find any civility for the non muslims. Even in the most "civil" muslim country, the non muslim is usually kept as the lowest class of humans.
immoral tactics are needed when dealing with people who wants ur country extinct. At the end of the day, it’s survival or death.
Utter nonsense.
Of course 🤩. Stealing land, expellation, torture, imprisoning innocent in every muslim country 🥳. Take your medicine 🤪!
Utter bullshit. Seen plenty of non Muslim folks doing just fine in Muslim countries I visited and worked in.
Very true
what about the arab dictators , any documentary about the human right abuses and torture in Qatar n Saudi Arabia ??
You shouldn't mention the Saudi's any more David, they have a renewed relationship with Israel. Keep up!
Torture in Qatar?? Now you're just making jokes. As for Saudi Arabia they're your friends now, don't be snitching on your friends David. Be loyal, or is that utterly impossible for you.
Al-Jazeera will not dare to expose about Qatari Government..... especially about The Ruling Family of al-Thany.😉🤭🤫
@@rondangmonagettypanggabean4606 nothing to expose, the people are happy.
@@SuntzuMocro wow, what a fact.....😂😂😂🤭
When surrounded by people sworn to destroy your existence, I. Applaud their determination to protect their land.
Go eat a pringle.
With American funds
@@ikhlaq786786able who cares about American funds 💀
It was never their land it was Palestine the British gave it to him at the end of the war it was not theirs to give away
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Hamas is much more worse than shin bet...even their own people are scared of them.
No! Hamas wants the Palestinian territories back which are occupied since 1967
@@irondoc1251
Hamas are the occupiers
AJ tries to portray a guy named "Jihad" as an innocent victim of attention.
you mad bro?
I don't expect Al -Jazeera to be objective on this subject , nor any subject in fact.
Funny you say that, that's exactly the same issue the other Arab states have with Al-Jazeera. Seems they cant win.
@sneksnekitsasnek
Keep your freinds close.. and your enemies closer
Then why watch if you don't trust the source?
His name is Jihad and He raises goats.....Adam Sandler could be proud of this...Jihad guy!
🤣🤣👍
You know there is something wrong when even Israeli officials admit its wrong it then shrug it off with a "Uhh, what are you going to do?" type attitude.
Did I come hear to read or watch?
Aljazeera,also make a documentary on Pakistan's secret service i.e ISI.
We will love to watch it as we have never seen any such documentary.
Dear Al Jazeera, your translations from Hebrew and Arabic are horrible.
41:55 "not especially" -> "absolutely not"
5:52 "[starts] the shin bet is very interested in the Arab citizens"->"Shin bet can be a threat even to those in authority"
----and many more----
I'm serious, check it for yourself. AJ- It is clear that your reporting is biased one way or another. This is bad journalism. Please stop.
Not many more. Only those two you liar.
Bad translation, yeah. Biased? I doubt it. The reason Al-Jazeera is so popular is for their LACK of bias.
@sneksnekitsasnek Both are bad, wouldn't you agree?
@1:06 min. the actor of Fauda, Waled😂
2001 and 2002 I used to live in Eilat,Israel for 18 months Shalom from Slovakia I got beautiful memory Israel was cool.:)
keep up the good work, shin bet!
Murders 🔫💩
@@irondoc1251, Hamas?
@@randeldaniel5437shin bet
Support for Israel from Serbia!
why doesn't,aljazaria caritizisise Hamas and all the other terrorists.
israel is cancerous tumor that has to be eradictated
Read what @@fitzgeraldalexander6029 or any other "pro-Palestinians" (anti-Semitic, Islamist, neo-nazis) are saying, and then try to listen to the Al-Jazeera propaganda about the methods the Shin Bet is doing against enemies of Israel, and see if you feel much sympathy for the "victims" being portrayed. If you do feel sympathy, you simply don't know what is really going on in the Palestinian territories and what kind of enemies Israel really have.
Please , we all are brothers and sisters , we together all are family , God has given us only 1 life , please Love each other and understand what Life is all about .
Shocked at some of the comments and how some people accept torture and an illegal police force. I really feel sorry for the Palestinians and everyone who has suffered unnecessarily. I wish there was an easy solution- Vicky your comments are very welcome.
Find a solution for peace and stop gibberish talks about religion.
See both side of the coin.....have you done an equal docu from the jewish pov?
I totally support shinbet and Israel..
Such a filthy nation and virus of Middle east....According to Tayab erdagon you will face taste of your own medicine soon.....
Can you also indicate when? we have been waiting so long.
u are supporting a terrosist organization
To obtain needed information sometime the use of physical pressures is necessary.
But there is those who use quiet physical tortures to identify somebody.
That is absurd and violent in vain.
I have been watching about Israel for the past 2 month , starting from its independence in 1948 till up to date about it's progression , as developing nation , her hostile Neighbor's , its triumph in handling every situations by its own. They are really worth to be praised and congratulated .
Unfortunately dear Israel citizens , your home is in the enemy territory , in that case how can you leave peacefully.
Even though we can support Israel but your unhealthy methods against innocent Palestinian citizens is not encouraging . I think you should stop that .
If you find guilty that a person( A real terrorist from Hamas or any other group) was a perpetrator on the conspiracy prove all the evidence and give me him / her the punishment which is equivalent to every body.
Do not target innocent people and stop your torturing with innocent civilians.
You are good in many things and you have gone through the Nazis death camps , now please be as humans and do not behave like devils .
Wondering what would it look like if AL Jajera did the same for Qatar security service.....!!!
who would not resort to forceful interrogation with terrorists?........What has been done is for the security of Israel....
only in jewish state can arab be candidate to post of prime minister, ask azmi bashara
I totally understand why Israel takes so much measures to protect a group of Arab states wanting to crush them
Because they had stolen the Gaza Strip and the Westbank from the Palestinians and also the Golan heighs from Syria.
@@irondoc1251😂😂 islam came in 4th century 🥱so it belonged to Jews...so taking back what's yours isn't crime....be happy coz they are showing mercy....u can't even compete with them....if they seriously decide something there won't be even single Arab Palestinians 🖕
@@irondoc1251 They did not steal the Golan it was taken during a war that the Arabs lost and as the allied did after WWll they kept land they taken in battle from the Germans. If they had not the Arabs would have continued shooting at Israelis farmers in The Galilee from their bunkers in the golan heights.
As if Al Jazeera would get information about the shin bet 😂😂😂😂😂😂
Shin Bet is an absolutely necessary piece of the security apparatus of Israel. If they are engaging in questionable activities then they need to be held accountable but indicting Shin Bet as an institution is faulty reasoning. The Palestinians need to respect Israel's right to exist and Israel needs to crack down severely on illegal settlements. The settlements are a slap in the face of the "peace process," if one can call it that. Palestinians also need to understand that Hamas' leadership (or Hezbollah's) is not in their self-interest. The Palestinians are more concerned with hating Israel than building a thriving, peaceful state; but if Israel would commit to demonstrably removing settlers, then that hatred may eventually dissipate.
Israel is not supposed to exist so what is this talk about Shin Bet being necessary?
Give them an inch and they'll want a mile. That's what they do !!
Does this remind anyone of a german organization in ww2
no
Anyone saw The Gatekeepers?
So what you want the actual interrogation tapes and a reality TV show about Shin Bet
Something like this was done in you know in “‘no good land 80 and som years ago” which the Shin Bet is probably well aquatinted with from old times
There is no information about Shin Bet in this video clip....only these few people kept talking about being interrogated! They could be actors and actress....boring
Yes they could be, so could the similar documentaries Al Jazeera does about Arab states committing torture. Your ideals match your name sake.
i doubt shin bet would transfer someone to 3 police stations for a knife
01:05 - Walid Al Abed from "Fauda"!
Yes
That guy portrayed that character too well
מי שמדבר מדינה כמו קטאר. העריכה והביקורת היא יותר תעמולה. מאשר אמת. החמס הרבה יותר נוראי.
I am absolutely convinced that Shin Bet and Mossad also have arab Israelis in their organisation
Very interested in all news aljazeer
Dauphin River First Nation Manitoba Canada 🇨🇦
only in israel arab lawer can critisize government for not superwise security service. no in any of 21 arab states...or any 66 muslimn states.
Good job
i would never understand how is it legal for al jazira to just shamelessly lie with the translation every single time
Arguing bellow ^^
This is a great warier in the world history
I am so Happy to listen to the Hebrew spoken in the Video. I have no idea what they are saying...but it is a chance to listen to beautiful Hebrew while i am washing The Dishes...(I need a Wife). I have a book on the Mossad and i dont know if it is the Same as Shin Bet.
Dr. G
#IsraHell
Shadi Mar'ie in this vlog. 😁
Nov 6 finding svells connection to dentist here and connection to USA
From a nationalist point of view, maybe an argument can be made that unpleasant choices need be made for the purpose of self-protection. Even in that narrow context, it is still problematic whether that helps or hurts over time. From a wider point of view, human history suggests that a universal concern for everyone including minority populations under occupation should be treated with respect and recognition for their human rights. Necessity is always appealed to when justifying injustice. Sometimes, of course, that argument has merit. However, an occasionally justifiable necessary act is not justification for a punitive policy broadly applied.
No
Israelis are not special but they experience inordinate terror. As do Americans abroad. It cannot be tolerated
with agency like shin bet and mossad ... i believe there cant be large scale attack in israel .
i am big fan of dedication of Israel ... really inspiring
nepaliman kkkk
One must remember with who does the Shin Bet deal with: with people of the radical islam, that are willing to die while exploding themselves in heavily crouded buses. Now imagine what would you do if you were a shin bet investigator trying to prevent such actions before they happen
BS... you are tarring everyone with the samew brush...Israel has commited more human right violations than anybody else in the middle east...
".Israel has commited more human right violations than anybody else in the middle east"-do you know how many people died in syria in the last 4 years?more than 200,000.do you know how many people died in the entire 120 years of arab-israeli conflict? less than 100,000 (arabs and jews combined), and syria is in the middle east'just to remind you.So where are the bigger war crimes committed?
איש צללים HUMAN RIGHT VIOLATIONS i said not deaths but the scummers from Israel are murderers too
Arguing with these people is pointless...
@Azmol Hossain
Condemn Hamas
@8:20 His name is Jihad?! Wow, his parents really set him up for success with that name ...
LisaFM81
It would be more honest if Arabs named ALL of their sons “Jihad”
Walid of Fauda🎉🎉🎉 Series.!!.🎉🎉
Mental comments!!
I'd like to see Iran's secret services documentaries... too
Eh, he talks about the agency getting involved in what imams can preach, what islamic judges can do, and what is tought to arabs in school as it was a bad thing? I wish we would do that in Europe, maybe we wouldnt have a problem with them.
have brian ade bring newspaper phone taps to court...thanks ladies at atf.
You can’t expect non violent methods fighting hostility.
Shin Bet - simply the best. May God protect you! Am Israel Chai!
And all the people that believe in torturing other human beings. I'm with you brother, sounds like fun. Idiot.
Hateful human being.
The best murder company since the SS
Shin Bet is a wonderful organisation keeping Israel safe. With the threats that Israel faces, such harshness is necessary.
ISRAEL is governed by the LAW of GOD, The God of Moses & Abraham! That is why Shen Bet has become a powerful Organization of Israel.
poliwood at his not best
The Muhabarat on the other hand are known to nice with motherly attitude
Israelis are doing what every country should do with their enmies... Respect from india
I've heard Indian police use car batteries in their interrogations?
If Arabs (ungrateful guests living on historical Jewish land) lived with respect for life and property, there would be no need for Shin-Bet
Shin Bet is probably the most efficient and effective security service in the world.
David Franx we have no choice.
it's not about hurting Arabs ..it's about living safe.
hahaha - just no.
@@israelgalile4509 For sure 🤥
Still think that?
This is a biased journalism.
imagine if Israel was not around it would be chaos.
If they're so good at it, it's because God wants to. God is with Israel.
Amen.
what a lack of humanity you have...we are ALL gods children no one race or religion is above another...
God bless you
FAUDA was a better documentary about the Shin Bet.
Svell
this is a joke
Zahala gal on. Wich is the terrorist? Israel ?..I have doubts...
Al Jazeera. A name you can trust... If of course by trust you mean flying the plane you are on into the side of a skyscraper.
How did i not figger this would be anti the good guys
Extraordinary situations warrant extraordinary treatments. It is a necessary evil, harsh realty that can't be wished away.
Rrrrrrrrrrrright
@@SuntzuMocro 2023/10/7 Just proved his point!
@@ishizukahikaru643That was a resistance operation.
israel israel .................. long live israel .........
what does Jihad mean?
ach... Al Jazeera
Shin bet are heroes😘😘❤❤
Olga Grakovski thankx bro
Murders 🔫
Long live jude,Long live israel
biased propaganda... what can I say more, I respect Israel! I cannot blame them and have been there once and the people were great! Loved it there... Do not dare to visit a Muslim country as a blond girl... But in Israel I felt safe. The reality is not what we can see on TV, vids or read in papers, talk to the people on the set place and you will know the truth!
The first 60 seconds of this made it clear that this was a shamelessly biased hit job and I stopped watching.
thank you, aljazeera, for shining your light on this murky heart of israel.
Not "murky": the "heart" of Apartheid Israel is a cold sadistic and perverted stone fist, devoid of empathy for anyone except those deemed by them as "God's Chosen". What a nightmare.
Funny to see all the Israhell trolls in this commentary field.
Israeli history. So interesting and impressive.
Based on wars, thefts, torture, murders, destruction, occupation and liars 👎💩
its a 4th reich doco
If you want to know something negative about Israel, this is your place. Totally biased
There is just as much negative about Israel in wikipedia.. It's Israels bias towards violence.
وأنا أؤيد إسرائيل . تحيا دولة إسرائيل اليهودية
Vive israel vive le mossad god bless israel
Dont F with Israel!
Fake news
What a beautiful Lies