THE 5 BEST MEN'S BOOTS YOU CAN BUY - Toughest, Most Versatile, and More (plus the runners-up!)
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 08. 2024
- ✪ SEE THE UPDATED LIST: • THE 10 BEST BOOTS FOR ... ✪
FULL REVIEW + PICTURES: stridewise.com...
I’m always surprised by how many terrible boots are on the market, so I decided to make the definitive list for this Fall. Which are the best boots for 2020?
BEST BOOT: THURSDAY BOOT COMPANY'S CAPTAIN BOOT
Designed to be the perfect combination of dressy and casual, Thursday reinvented the boot ground up: instead of going with Chromexcel® leather they devised their own leather called Thursday Chrome; instead of going with pricy Dainite soles they came up with their own rubber which, in my opinion, performs just as well.
But this company is no imitation of anything. Original in its every atom, the Captain is sleek and handsome while maintaining an unusual durability. The leather is tough but not too thick and the shoe has a full 360-degree Goodyear welt that's remarkably subtle.
Another bonus is the Dura EVA comfort strip, making it feel more sneaker like than its competitors, but the real icing on the cake is the ludicrous price: $199.
FULL REVIEW: • Thursday Captain Boot ...
VISIT THE SITE: thursdayboots....
TOUGHEST BOOT: TRUMAN JAVA WAXED FLESH
Truman aims to compete with Viberg with a very solid construction that's about $150 cheaper. Personally, I feel Viberg is pretty overpriced and overbuilt whereas Truman’s boot fits better and is a bit more flexible.
You’ll get a tough as nails Commando sole followed by a tough leather midsole and leather insole just like old school work boots, so they're great for working in all day.
The Horween leather is a very thick roughout with a thick sheen of wax that makes it seriously resistant to the elements. When you’re wearing these, nothing can stop you.
FULL REVIEW: • TRUMAN BOOT COMPANY RE...
BEST CALFSKIN BOOT: R.M. WILLIAMS COMFORT CRAFTSMAN
Indisputably the national boot of Australia, this is one of the most aptly named boots because it is seriously, stupidly, crazily, insanely comfortable.
Designed with a flat yet somehow very grippy rubber sole, there's also an "airport-friendly" fiberglass shank for arch support and stability plus there's a leather insole and padded heel lining. All this makes for a boot that does a great job of absorbing shock while remaining comfortable enough that, honestly, I don’t always want to take them off when I get home.
The leather is also pretty great, technically it’s yearling leather so the calf is slaughtered at a year old, and it makes for an upper that’s both soft and durable, it wrinkles finely but it takes damage like steer leather. It’s a little pricy, but they’ll probably last long enough for you to be buried in them.
FULL REVIEW: • Review: Australia's Na...
MOST DISTINCTIVE BOOT: TAFT JACK BOOT
The most eye-catching, unusual, distinctive boot is the flagship boot from Taft called the Jack. Is it weird? Sure, but it’s unforgettable.
The upper is mostly raw Portuguese wool but the toecap and counter are made from this oxblood crust leather, making for a grey-on-red motif that just works. It’s available in more muted color schemes (like black on black) as well as even weirder ones (like white on tan) but the grey and oxblood is definitely the brand’s signature boot.
The calfskin leather lining makes it extra comfy and the sole is a super soft rubber that some might feel is too soft, but I quite enjoyed it. The downside of such an unusual shoe is that it’s not all that versatile, plus the wool upper means it’s not absolutely fantastic in wet weather. But if you know the outfit and you know the forecast…
FULL REVIEW: • TAFT JACK BOOT REVIEW ...
BEST MID-RANGE BOOT: ALLEN EDMONDS HIGGINS MILL
Made with the beloved Chromexcel® leather and Dainite sole this is a classic shoe with an uncomplicated service boot aesthetic. Not too slim and not too wide, versatility is the name of the game with this boot; I’ve worn it with a t-shirt and I’ve worn it with a blue suit (no tie) and somehow it just works.
The slim-ish silhouette means it’s less workhorsey than a Wolverine 1000 Mile but it also means that it hugs the foot just right, cradling it without squeezing it, making for a remarkably comfortable boot.
But it is still durable, as exemplified by the storm welt, a kind of Goodyear welt that’s extra resistant to water and dirt. The downside is that Allen Edmonds doesn’t have the best quality control and my boot had a fair amount of loose grain, but if you can buy your shoes in-store and you can do your own QC, I think it’s a solid buy.
FULL REVIEW: • Allen Edmonds Higgins ...
SEE MORE REVIEWS:
Red Wing Vs. Wolverine: • FIGHT! Red Wing Vs. Wo...
Thorogood Vs Chippewa Vs Red Wing • THOROGOOD VS RED WING ...
Viberg Service Boot: • REVIEW: Is the Viberg ...
UPDATED: Check out my latest list of the top _10_ boots you can buy (in under 10 minutes!)! czcams.com/video/9kuHyyefNGE/video.html
Greetings from Sydney, Australia! I've had my R.M. William Comfort Craftsman with a square toe for over 12 years, and they're still going strong!
Yeah those boots are unkillable, Sam!
I like this video a lot because it's not your usual, red wing this or wolverine that. Your review are based on actual wear in urban environments. On top of that, your love for the Captain boot comes off very genuine. Other you tubers also present Thursday boots like they are trying to make a sale. Great channel!
Thanks a ton, Miguel! Glad you find value here and glad to see you commenting again :)
Side note: wearing leather soled shoes for ANY sidewalk/outdoor use just doesn't make sense
@@saynotowoke.8492 the concrete chews them up
@@saynotowoke.8492 Yea handmade artisan things are definitely not the norm and are very expensive. I only have rubber soled boots, the softer the compound the more comfortable. My most comfortable boots are definitely some 10 year old redwings that are worn down, but work surprisingly well on the concrete with foam insoles. I'm quite surprised you have leather that has held up to regular wear for over 35 years, you should make a video or fourm post on them. A lot of people would appreciate it and maybe hoard less artisan shoes knowing that they can keep theirs for decades
@@StridewiseAre johnston & murphy boots
I bought a pair of Frye boots. They are the perfect boot for me. I had been shopping for a while and tried on so many boots. The Frye boot was my favorite and they look like they were made for all the clothes in my fall/winter closet. It is best to go with the boot that fits your wardrobe. Nothing worst than having a clothing item that you cannot wear because you have nothing to wear it with.
I am from Costa Rica and I can get higher quality boots for $70.00 made in Salvador by hand so now I can see the business here. Great video!!!
Thanks! Would love to try some of those Salvador boots, got a favorite brand?
Its because they're made in sweat shops.
What is the average salary there?
Not many people can pay $500.
And labour is waaay less expensive.
Materials and labour can give you boots for $70. But you have to be local.
I love my Hanweg Grünten, it's just my favourite pair of footwear.
I live in Northern Ontario, Canada. I wear red wing iron ranger boots every day in all seasons. Whether it's -30 or +28, they work perfectly for me. I fish, hunt, walk to the office and spend a lot of time in the bush. I recommend them to anyone and everyone based on the quality and not the name.
Yeah those are solid boots for sure!
I live in Ottawa and own a pair of Redwings. They are ok in the winter if you are going from your house to car, nothing more than that. Saying you use them in -30 is absurd.
@@sweetskeetz I don't know about you, but I don't get cold as often as most. I normally just throw on a pair of wool work socks and I'm golden. Definitely not absurd.
-30 is kinda reaching i wouldn't wear leather boots in -30.
Nick I have watched a lot of your videos. It is because of you that I bought my first pair of civilian boots. Thursday Boot Company-President. I have only worn them one time to the VA hospital but I am very satisfied.
Oh cool! Glad you like 'em Mark, I just got a pair in Terracotta.
Top notch review! Thank you for your time and effort in educating all us consumers. Cheers mate!
Glad you found it useful dude!
One of the most important factors to consider.. How will the boots hold up after 3-5 years? Doubt the Thursday Boot's Captain will hold up as well compared to its competitors. But then, its over half the price. Pretty good review, wish you would consider some UK brands such as Crockett & Jones and Tricker's. But then, where do you draw the line?
I just wanna say thank you.Thank you for your great content.Because of you ,i bought my first "proper" boot,the Iron Ranger and im loving them so far.Keep making them videos,cheers!
Oh, that's so good to hear! Thank you for saying that. They were my first good pair of boots too, my first brown pair of boots anyway. Did you go with Amber harness?
Correct,8111.They are already almost broken in.I had some terrible blisters the first 3 days,but after that it got great.I in no way regret my purchase.
Yeah Red Wing is a nice blend of tough to break in but not so tough to break in that you want to hurl the shoes into a ditch, haha. Glad you dig them.
I'm considering the 8111 going by the great reviews on here as a first proper boot that will age well. I was considering the Thursday Captain Boot but as they don't reply to emails I've gone off them..!! Ha ha
8111s are a great first boot, it's such a different, exciting feeling after wearing sneakers and dress shoes etc your whole life. Good luck on that break in - and make sure you condition with mink oil!
“Which means the calf becomes boots for its first birthday” hahahahaha
I bought a pair of the captain boots based mainly on this video and the others you have made speaking so highly of them. You often mention the comfort but I have been wearing mine and they have little to no comfort at all. I like the way they look but my red wings have more comfort and I’m still breaking them in.
Really? These boots are lined and Red Wings aren't, I find lined boots way more comfy. Some prefer the hardwon comfort of breaking in tough leather midsoles which I can appreciate but for me, I just wear my Thursdays more.
Never looked for contents about boots, but this popped up in my suggestions and I can’t be mad about that. Your videos are super well done so I hope to see it grow in the future!
Are you sponsored by Thursday Company? Your reviews seem biased or alternatively extremely positive for Thursday Company.
Because they’re great boots at a great price. Try a pair of captains.
He just really likes him. You'd talk about smth you rly like even if there are other things you like too
I now own two Thursday Captains. Great boot great price. I also have two Beckett Simonon Dowler boots. Both great
Wesco, Viberg, Clinch, John Lofgren, Role club.
Alden
Check out the Crockett and Jones Tetbury. The suede is super high quality and very durable with the Dainite sole. I put them through a few New England winters and they still look fantastic. Just rinse the boots under water and any salt comes right out. Add to that, you can wear them year round. Also, Heschung makes a very high quality tough Norwegian split toe that is rock solid.Thanks for the great review.
it's so damn narrow and long... too narrow for my taste
Two different price points, but those are nice boots.
I got a pair of Thursday Boots: Barstool II and I frickin love them
You’ve sold me on a pair of Thursday boots! If they’re watching I hope they show you a little love.
Roughdraft214 +1
elijah morris already ordered will keep in mind next time, discount code?
elijah morris captain natural
Great choice
Sorry I just saw your replay. I had already ordered a pair on Amazon. Are you with Thursday?
A channel dedicated to boots? I must have hit the jackpot. Subscribed
Hooray! I've been waiting for you.
Wish boots of this quality were made in the fashion industry
Truman Java and Red Wing Iron Ranger are must for Outdoors man !
Glad you approve, Israel!
The Thursday boot company has the same story as those cheap mvnt watches and the more I dig the more I see similarities in there marketing and not just them it’s a lot of other cheap companies using the same exact cookie cutter marketing strategy. So idk I’m gonna get some red wing instead
yeah the marketing those companies use is literally copypasted. I can't tolerate another company splattering a full page with how they've "cut the middleman" with their "innovative approach to marketing". That being said most reviews on Thursdays are very positive, but I'm still not buying them mostly because they're outside EU (which means huge taxes&shipping)
Throughout all of the 1990s I'd always wear the Havana Joe chukka boot. Amazing footwear.
Redwing Iron Rangers are the best overall boot! .......great price, great look and size options, custom soles available, lifetime care at your local shop, and lifetime replacement laces.....not to mention there are stand alone stores that deliver great service and customer support! Thank you Redwing !
Iron Rangers are great and all, they're just not very versatile IMO.
I’m a reasonably fit 68 year old. I love the casual look of boots with jeans and, being only 5-8, I like the additional inch or so of height gained from wearing a heeled boot. Is there a particular style of boot that works best for a men in my older age group?
If you want a bit of heel, then take a look at the Nick's Robert boot. It comes in two different heel heights and a variety of leathers, colors and soles.
Thursday offers wide sizes in certain models now, love mine. 👍
I have two pairs of Truman and love them both. The black burgundy ramblers are DEFINITELY taking a lot longer to break in than my Kudu smooth out, but that's to be expected given the differences between the leathers. Absolutely fantastic and now that they're doing GYW, a LOT of their stuff is in the $400 range. My AE habit is in serious trouble.
Yeah the Truman brand has evolved a lot, the fit has too so I hear so I might need to do a new video. Glad you like yours, Armed!
I had a couple pairs of Thursday Boots. Did not like them much compared to my other boots in the collection. They seemed to really make my feet hot and the leather did not wear well. This was when they first started out so maybe they got better.
this is a great channel. i can finally afford some decent boots so i'm watching all your videos. top work, thanks
Awesome, thanks for watching and so glad you like the videos!
I have 2 pair of Trumans. They main problem with Truman is their inconsistency. if you get a perfect pair great! if not your kinda bummed your paying for a boot with: loose grain, wonky stitching,diferent height heels etc.
That's very true, the stitching is asymmetrical in those boots. Not a huge practical importance when talking about "toughness" but I'll mention it in the full review, whenever I get it up!
Yeah I own a bunch of boots but haven't pulled the trigger on a pair of Trumans for this exact reason.
Great video - thank you, though I don't think I'd be sloshing through avoidable puddles wearing a $550 pair of boots!
Super helpful video, dude. Very in depth, and I can tell you know what you're talking about. Now I know what boots I'm buying this fall!
Great! Glad you liked it Charlie.
This is a great video. I am 43 and due to health issues I have had to change my style. I am really struggling. I mean 43 years I wore the same style. This video helps. Thanks 👍
So happy this could be useful to you, Mr Bennett!
The best boots are my boots! Love the video! Thank you!
Bed Stu's are my favorites. Good price and great quality. I tend to buy them used but you sometimes find them for a steal at the Rack.
Life can be so strange (or should I say google). I’m about to go on a trip and I was looking for a good pair of boots add some swag to get up. I have a hard time with these kind of shoes because I have wide feet. After parsing through many websites and online stores. I found the Thursday boot company, I liked the look and they had some colors in the wide fit.
For the first time ever I decide to check CZcams for boot reviews and lo and behold I see your video with you recommending a pair of shoes that I was already on the verge of buying. Thanks for helping me make up my mind.
You're welcome!
So glad you found us :) We hope you're enjoying your boots. All the best, Team Thursday!
I know they're made in China now, but my go-to boot has been Doc Martens since 1987, when they were still make in the UK.
Best comparison of boots I've seen! Great work! Love how you have a best for each category! Keep up the great work! PS will you be reviewing any boots from John Lobb, Edward Green or Berlutti?
Thursday Captains are amazing for 199 but they don’t compare to Nicks, Whites or Truman’s. Completely different level of materials and craftsmanship. The price is completely different too though
The chromexal on the AE Higgins boot is easy to work out scratches by rubbing with fingers. I have the brown color and they are aging well.
Just stumbled upon this vid as I was looking for new boots as I am not the greatest mens fashion shopper.. more of a working outdoor guy. Thanks for the help! Much appreciated 👍
Oh I'm so glad I could help, Mr. Of The Walkers! Which one did you decide on?
I think the Captain boot looks the business, I like what you were saying about the quality materials. Kind of like what Arc'teryx do with their gear. I think it is very important. Thanks again.
Yeah! They actually just came out with a slightly more outdoorsy version of the Captains and the Presidents if that's what you're looking for: thursdayboots.com/collections/mens-boots-rugged looks like it's mostly a tougher shank and better shock absorption, but hey it's the same price!
Good afternoon Sir, been watching your reviews for a while and you made me a subscriber out of me. I gain so much knowledge about leathers, brands, construction, durability, and care for them. Thanks for your all your excellent work 👍
Means a lot, Julio! Thanks a ton.
Really good video dude. Exactly what I needed. I think I'll go with the Thursdays but they all look beautiful.
Glad you liked it Nick! I did an updated one for this year here too: czcams.com/video/9kuHyyefNGE/video.html
My Redwings are on point. Yeah they are expensive, but I bought them on sale and got two pairs for almost half the cost.
Nice buy Brandon! I'm never lucky when it comes to sales. Which ones did you get?
Cole Haan my favorites right now but have a pair of TB captains on the way.
Hope you like 'em!
Red Wing Iron Rangers
blocky
Played out
I want the RM Williams boots. Great video, even though I'm way late to comment.
I still see you there Mega Bullfrog 09!
Well good fella...you left out the best boot of all...The Australian Redback Boot...by far the best boot I have ever owned!
Have you ever done a review of the NPS Gladstone? They're really nice handmade boots for an amazing price.
Ok here’s one for you... Rm Williams or the Viberg? Great videos by the way!!
I haven't tried Viberg's Chelseas! RMW is dear to my heart though, I'll always exalt them
Dayton from Vancouver Canada great boots
Those Tafts look great! Thanks. Glad I waited until the end.
hey me too dude! they're a special brand it makes me happy when someone likes them
@@Stridewise my eldest son is getting married in October so I've ordered the Taft Jack Boot in Tux! So cool and thanks again!
@@fraa888grindr6 ya they're great for weddings!
Hi Nick,
Enjoy your videos! Do you own the Allen Edmonds Dalton boot? Please do a review if you do as I am planning to buy one soon. Thx
Ah, you know for the next AE boot I was going with Sullivan! Might do Dalton down the track.
I'd also really like to see a Dalton review.
You know, I had ordered a pair of Daltons from AE not to long ago from their factory seconds and after a few days I noticed the order status always just said 'being processed'. I finally called them and was on hold 19 minutes, according to my phone and I checked on the status of my order. They said they were cancelled due to not being in stock but no one bothered to contact me, as a matter of fact the money is still on hold on my credit card, so I really was looking forward to trying out those Daltons but unfortunately I never got mine. I'm wondering if AE has bad service or if it was just my experience? I've been wanting to try another pair but have been really put off by that experience.
@Daniel Brice Taylor 210e with laminate back and sides and made in Mexico for $999 isn't that great of a value...
But 10 years later it's still my favorite guitar
Does it matter what it's made of or where it's made if it looks great and lasts forever like the genuine USA made ones?
@Daniel Brice That's why I went with the thursdays - CHEAP but I agree if the budget allowed i would have opted for American made!
Bro I love your content it’s awesome! You should branch out into style as well as you have good style and it would diversify your content likely getting you more views and a larger following 😊 cheers! 👊
Haha that's so nice of you to say. I really just try to stick to the basics with style, I don't know if I'm much of a thought leader in that respect but it's definitely something to think about for down the line!
Stridewise of course bro! And something I learned is that you’re never gonna think of yourself as knowledgeable enough to do something so ya kinda just have to take that leap of faith you know. I’m sure as soon as you put yourself in that position you’ll really take the initiative and try and learn all you can! 👊 you’re in a good starting place for sure seeing as you love footwear so much! You could start talking about matching shoes to your outfit/buying shoes to suit your wardrobe there’s literally endless things to talk about. You could work your way into the grooming department too! Literally endless things to talk about! Ha well anyways bro I hope I helped n whatnot thanks for the great content and keep on keeping awn 👊
Wow you are one supportive dude! Thanks for the kind words John, you've given me a lot to think about! You're right, there are endless possibilities :)
Been wearing boots for years. Was in the Cadets 6 1/2 years. Anyway Thursday boots 🥾 are the most comfortable. The leather can be mat or gloss, depending on what area you polish. I like to shine the cap and back, mat in the middle. Gives a great look
I love it when a guy personalizes his boot slike that!
I need to break out of my RM Williams shell. As an Australian that rocks Akubras also I find it hard to want to wear anything else. I love that they’re Australian and also that they are Australian owned again now that Twiggy brought it back.
Hey Nick, can you review a pair Cheaney's boots? Preferably their chukkas but any pair would work. Thanks
I'll put 'em in the pipeline!
Ill stick with my Redwing Iron Rangers.
Also very fine shoes!
@swellingsuperman itll take more then that to earn the comfort of the iron rangers , try wearing them twice a week in the mornings till your feet really start hurting and then change them out. After about a year they should be amazing.
I'm not sure where this 3 year break-in comes from. I wore my Iron Rangers every other day. After 2-3 days, they fit like a glove. I'd wear them for some of my 12-14 hour workdays and completely forget that I'm wearing them. If you want to break them in quicker, add a generous coating of Obenaufs Oil (not the LP) and it will speed it up.
I have a couple small issues with them that the White's Service MP solves....albeit at a much higher price.
My iron rangers took about a week to break in they fit amazing you could add some redwing boot oil to soften them up some but really not needed in my case.
my black Thorogood "6 mocs are awesome. super comfortable but in the beginning the left boot was so tight over the instep it felt like it was cutting my toes off. I had to get it stretched twice and lose the inserts but love them now.
Hi there,
Perfect video. I actually bought a pair of Thursday president boots in brown, I love them. I also want to get a pair of red wing iron ranger, but I am confused between 8111 and 8085. Could you please help me choose between these two. I want to wear them for everyday use and also want to choose the one which is easy to maintain in the long run.
Ever check out Indie Ridge boots? Incredibly comfortable right out of the box.
Really good review, feels like it only runs for 2 minutes!
How long have you had your Thursday Boots? I have a pair of Presidents myself and love them. On Carl muwaskis taft vs Thursday Boot video he said his insole pretty much destroyed within a year.
I've had them about 6 months and haven't had any issues, will report back if anything changes!
Hey! So glad to hear you love your boots :) Welcome to the team. If you do have any issues with your boots be sure to reach out to us at founders@thursdayboots.com. We'll be sure to take care of you!
hi, i just brought a pair of willam lennon boots from the uk, best boots by a mile ,and believe me ive had some boots
I have a few of thursdays offerings(captain, diplomat, vanguard and their runners) but my next boot I want to step up and I think next year I’m going to pull the trigger on either some whites MP or Nicks Falcon. Leaning towards the falcons.
Need to retitle it "Best Fashion" boots
If Thursday were made in China, it will be accused for stealing tech from other brand XD
Looks like Thursday makes the Captain in a "Midnight & Brown" colour that's quite distinctive.
Oh wow I hadn't seen that color before, I think maybe it's new. Reminds me of Taft's stuff
Great overview. Helped a lot!
Glad to hear it Meter!
Panama Jack
Bear in mind, Thursday’s insoles go out very quickly. The mark of a quality boot is an insole.
I just ordered a pair - I guess time will tell - hope its not too good to be true
Haven't had any issues with that myself! The good thing with boots is a cobbler will almost always be able to fix up stuff like that if it arises.
M A I had mine for years and they haven't ran out
No problems on mine going on 18 months
And can’t you just put another insole? I always wonder why people make it such a big deal when it’s a simple thing
I have some Allen Edmond Park City boots with rouhh out looking leather. They have a heavy vibram sole. They are definitely a work boot for me. I am semi-retired but I wear them at my ranch doing all sorts of work. So far, love them.
You make a good csse for the Thursday CPT boot. At their price, not too risky. Even the USA Vanguard Thursdays would be good, though slighly more in price.
Good video. Informative and expanding my knowledge of different brands. Thanks Nick.
Love this video. Covers all the boots that aren't the classic custom boot companies, and the elite tier of work-grade, production boots which really are the best--Nick's, Whites, Viberg, Red Wing. Red Wing is a little unfair because of what they've built over the years and what they can deliver at their low price point. Hope all these companies make it to their 100th anniversary and build that real "need" following. Don't scoff because some of the boots in this video are clearly office boots. In fact 2 are decently durable, but I wouldn't pay that much for them.
I can't make the figures work for the Thursday boot here in Australia. By the time I get them shipped the are about 400 AUD. I think I'd rather spend an extra $150 on some 1000 Mile or even Iron Rangers.
Yeah same for me. Ended up buying red wings from a shop on melbourne for about $470. Expensive but awesome
@@kman49 what Red Wings did you get and how do you wear them. I'm looking at 1000 Miles because you can wear them casually but they also look a bit more formal.
@@leftspeaker2000 i got iron rangers 8085. I got them for casual wear. I have rm Williams for anything more semi formal. I like the wolverine too but i see there are too many complaints about loose grain so opted for the iron rangers. Leather quality is excellent.
@@kman49 I had not heard that about the lose grain on the Wolverines. I do know that the heel falls off. I think I'm leaning towards the iron rangers.
@@leftspeaker2000 i was thinking the same as you. Wanted the wolverine for looks. Switched to the idea of iron rangers because of what seemed like too many complaints about loose grain and heels coming apart. Looked at the iron rangers for a while online and i liked them more and more. Took the plunge and glad i did. Quality is excellent. Loving the look even more now.
Grant stone is about the same as AE on full price but a million times the quality
Not a bad review. I wanted to turn it off when you started with a Thursday boot. No offense to you or those that like them but they are absolute garbage. Even at 200 they are no bargain. Mine literally fell apart after about a year. I own white's, nicks, rangers and Indy's also and would not recommend Thursday to anyone
Nicks Urban Logger deserves a spot on this list.
IMHO, Allen Edmonds ‘Sullivan Street’ hands down beats the Thursday Captain
Man everyone is talking about that boot lately. I'll have to order it.
Those should be in different categories. The Sullivan Street is most definitely a DRESS boot and is more than twice the price. I own both. I consider my Captain's more of an ass kicker boot that doesn't need to babied. My Sullivan Street boots only come out for special occasions.
Those Java's look like you can kick someone to death with them. Nice boot.
Glad you agree! Heavy boots.
You must have got lucky with your Thursdays' boots, because over at reddit most are not thrilled with the quality and materials of Thursdays
Trickers are the best (but eye wateringly costly)
All these people want to watch this guy talk about shoes
Thursday boots are trash. Whenever I see some fashion bloggers exaggeratedly complimenting them, I stay away from them.
Actually they're quite nice for the price point.
Someone needed a hug.
What makes them trash? Seeing how I've only came across 1 or 2 reviews that had a few cons to the boots, what are your opinions based on? genuinely interested.
Michael Kinney there is a lot of bad reviews on the brands QC . Although they seem to have gotten a lot better in the last year or so
I several pairs of Thursday boots/shoes. Not one pair had superficial qc issues. I can't speak to the durability of all of them. However the ones I wear often are very durable, and great looking.
Which they had a deeper slot on the sole where it’s stitched ,I find the stitches wear out fairly quick ,on the Thursday boot
Great Stridewise. just got a pair of Sutro 'Dupont'.
R.M. Williams's do not last that long now. A pair was cut through at the Bodkin's Bootery in Fremantle. There were cardboard layers in the sole, middle layer. In comparison, hand made Anastazi boots made in Midland are all leather, and far more comfortable long lasting, similar price.
Obviously have never owned a pair of RMs
Thursday is NOT indisputably the best value boot. You haven't experienced Indonesian boots. Some of those companies make far better boots for similar prices.
Javier Rodriguez yea I sold my Thursday boots cause of the quality.
I have heard that from people before. I'd like to learn from myself, but I don't want to waste money on it.
Javier Rodriguez yes if you look at forums like Reddit you’ll see the same. My opinion the best value for a mid range boot are Red Wing Heritage boots; Iron Rangers, Blacksmith’s, Beckman’s etc. You can often get factory 2nds that cost around $200.
Link?
daniel dee Sierra Trading Post and Nordstrom Rack.
Do you never clean your boots, you have a lot of money invested, drives me crazy all the soles are dirty
Haha well I wanted to show that I actually wear them :)
Love the Higgins Mill. Very comfortable.
i have 2 boots you mention, the Thursday captain and RM Williams comfort craftman, and I agree with ur opinion for both of them 😀
Wolverine 1000 miles boot is the best of that style of boots... USA made, USA leather and amazing quality... I own Bespoke Boots made in the UK, and RM Williams boots that compare in quality, even if the style is very different.
Loving my brown captains and looking to buy a pair of black RMs soon.
I have to say I am really enjoying my black blundstone 063, fantastic for under £100👍
I like how the highest end boots I knew to exist like nick's are "mid range" according to this guy
Yeah most guys in the space consider the $1000+ boots from Japan to be the higher end. These days I usually call White's and Nick's 'high end' even though boot snobs always "correct" me in the comments
I agree AE Higgins mills boots is a very very comfortable i realyy love it.
Thursday boots are handsome and affordable, but if you have a high instep there's a seam in the lining that cuts into the flesh for a week or so until the leather breaks in.
I tried to get one..a genuine and original one but I always get the first copy..
Interesting...everything I have read says the Grant Stone boots are easily above and beyond the Allen Edmonds. Have the Higgins Mill and was considering the Ottawa as a second boot to rotate with.
The Caterpillar Raw boots collection has been ignored,
they have a very sturdy soles, the designs are very good and bet bang for the buck.
Gripfast were the best boots I’ve ever worn. I was considering getting another pair, (even though the ones from 2007 have no issues other than scuffs) but the new ones don’t look as good as the old, sadly.
Only two boots in my closet - RM Williams Craftsman Comfort in Chestnut and Indy Alden in Chromexcel. Both are expensive but I've had one for 4 years and another for 8 years and expect at least another decade of wear out of them.
Phew, both very very very good boots. Nice choice!
@@Stridewise thanks!
Excellent review Stridewise! I like them all and I have the The Thursdays Captain, Higgins Mill and the White’s Service Boots.. I personally prefer the White’s MP Service boots out of all that you reviewed .. the Truman’s look very nice I’ve never owned a pair to draw a comparison but I do have a couple of pairs of Vibergs and I have to say I really like the product Viberg puts out , its a very high quality boot the only downside like you pointed out is they’re very pricy but again you’re paying for the quality and also possibly because they’re made in Canada .. but I love your reviews man 👍🏼