It just makes so much sense with 2 accordions! The counterpoint is now an actual conversation between two instruments. The phrasing is emphasized by dynamics not available to the organ. The tone is rich, the bass is full and the highs are flute-like and pure. What a brilliant interpretation! It just feels like it was written with two instruments in mind.
Vielen Dank, dass ich diese virtuose Spitzeninterpretation von Bach sehen und hören durfte. Noch nie habe ich gesehen, wie Menschen mit ihrem Instrument und der Musik derartig verschmelzen. Jede Note wird empfunden und gespürt, so dass ich als Zuschauer dass Gefühl bekomme, dass diese Empfindungen, als ein Tanz der Neuronen von Bach in unser Bewusstsein hineinkomponiert wurden und in mir allein durch die Betrachtung die gleichen Emotionen auslösen wie die wunderbar vorgetragene Musik. Ich danke den beiden Musikerinnen, die mir gezeigt haben welcher Meistergrad der Musik erreicht werden kann. Liebe Grüße aus Deutschland.
I've always felt that the original organ version, despite its magnificence, is sometimes too 'thick' to see through the detailed structure. This version has both it glory while transparent. Amazing job!
though I like this accordion version very much, the problem that you mention about (some) organ versions, is not caused by the organ as an instrument, but by the players ;-) ... at least if it's a quite good organ (you can play also very 'slim' on an organ, if you choose the fitting registers) -- What the accordion is able to do better is the dynamics
You might want to hear Michael Murray playing the Passacaglia, and for that matter, the rest of his Bach recordings. His clarity is phenomenal. He was also a student of Duruflé. czcams.com/video/3P7bBsQrrH4/video.html
Your performance proves that Bach’s music is universal, and when played on other instruments, like an accordion duo, it sounds as if it were for them. Beautiful performance!
Sometimes I sit and practice all I can. When my wrists hurt I like to hear others play the accordion. I love when I land on a video that makes me tear.
Magnifique interprétation de cette célèbre pièce d'orgue de J S Bach ; les deux accordéons lui confèrent un ton moins solennel mais tout aussi émouvant et mélodieux; Bravo et Mille merci à nos deux talentueuses musiciennes pour cette vidéo; Tous nos souhaits de vous entendre dans un futur proche dans la fugue, complément indissociable de la passacaille
There's something I love about how much sound you can get from such small instruments. And the playing was excellent. I saw a comment chastising the poster of this video for not naming the musicians. I believe that the musicians themselves posted this video. They are Renée Bekkers and Pieternel Berkers of the duo TOEAC, whose website is in the description of the video. Accordions need to be taken more seriously as musical instruments. Maybe if I ever get rich, I might get my hands on one and try to learn it myself. After all, my grandfather played the instrument, though the last time I saw him was when I was 5, and he has died since.
Belle la musique . Version pour passionnés . A voir les yeux fermés. La vie ainsi , que de plaisir de se la faire partager avec JSB. Merci a nos deux talentueuses musiciennes.
So glad I discovered these intimate angels at 1:45 a.m. This time facilitated for me the depth of silence necessary to more fully perceive the opulent intimacy which so graces their performances. Indeed, 'performance' is insufficient for what they accomplish. With their videos, I'm now finally getting in my later years the depth of the accordion and the powerful grasp of it's gripping intimacy through such artistic souls, assisted with exceptional instruments, as well. I'm fairly blown away. Wish a CD were available, I was only able to get an MP3 of their work.
Cela ne se discute même pas le millième d'une seconde ; Bach a été dans les lieux célestes et nous a ramené un aperçu de ce qui s'y pratique au quotidien
Et la BWV 582 certainement la plus grande pièce musicale de tous les temps. Question étude des harmonies, c'est véritablement un traité encyclopédique. @bon claudy > il est évident qu'il y en a eu des très bons, avant, pendant et après Jean-Sébastien, cela ne se discute pas. Il n'empêche que, dans beaucoup de domaines, le natif d'Eisenach se tient une marche au-dessus de tous les autres. Nettement. :)
prachtig gespeeld,heel kunstig met al die knopjes,ook die ene dame die de triolen speelt ,maar ook het samenspel heel knap gedaan ,dit werk wat eigenlijk voor orgel is geschreven ,hebben ze mooi weer gegeven in beknopte wijze,
Bach a l epoque voulait composer pour violon sauf qu il a joué a l orgue tout en gardant l esprit du violon pour sa composition. Mais l accordeon et l orgue sont assez proche c est pour cela que Bach se joue aujourd'hui régulièrement a l accordeon
Superb performance I am glad that you understand Bach I must say that you are lucky that you are able to understanf Bach.It is very clear from your playing.No jokes.Hats off.India
Sensacional interpretación por este duo de acordeonistas. Le dan un aire de magia y delicada sensualidad difícil de encontrar en otras de las numerosas interpretaciones de esta obra . No se pierde ni una sola nota . ¡Bravo ! será una de mis interpretaciones de referencia
WOW!!!! This is the most passionate rendition I have ever heard!! ENCORE!!! ...And by that, I mean... THE FUGUE!!!!!! :D Greetings from the States. You have earned my subscription!
It just makes so much sense with 2 accordions! The counterpoint is now an actual conversation between two instruments. The phrasing is emphasized by dynamics not available to the organ. The tone is rich, the bass is full and the highs are flute-like and pure. What a brilliant interpretation! It just feels like it was written with two instruments in mind.
Vielen Dank, dass ich diese virtuose Spitzeninterpretation von Bach sehen und hören durfte. Noch nie habe ich gesehen, wie Menschen mit ihrem Instrument und der Musik derartig verschmelzen. Jede Note wird empfunden und gespürt, so dass ich als Zuschauer dass Gefühl bekomme, dass diese Empfindungen, als ein Tanz der Neuronen von Bach in unser Bewusstsein hineinkomponiert wurden und in mir allein durch die Betrachtung die gleichen Emotionen auslösen wie die wunderbar vorgetragene Musik. Ich danke den beiden Musikerinnen, die mir gezeigt haben welcher Meistergrad der Musik erreicht werden kann. Liebe Grüße aus Deutschland.
I've always felt that the original organ version, despite its magnificence, is sometimes too 'thick' to see through the detailed structure. This version has both it glory while transparent. Amazing job!
though I like this accordion version very much, the problem that you mention about (some) organ versions, is not caused by the organ as an instrument, but by the players ;-) ... at least if it's a quite good organ (you can play also very 'slim' on an organ, if you choose the fitting registers) -- What the accordion is able to do better is the dynamics
You might want to hear Michael Murray playing the Passacaglia, and for that matter, the rest of his Bach recordings. His clarity is phenomenal. He was also a student of Duruflé.
czcams.com/video/3P7bBsQrrH4/video.html
Your performance proves that Bach’s music is universal, and when played on other instruments, like an accordion duo, it sounds as if it were for them. Beautiful performance!
Wtf, this version is one of the best I've heard. Wonderfully done, both of you, really!
Agree. Very wonderful version of this melody. Great performance! 🤟🏻👍🏻♥️
Their look at each other is so beautiful, so deep and passionate with their playing and complicity, all for the music. Magnificent !
Sometimes I sit and practice all I can. When my wrists hurt I like to hear others play the accordion. I love when I land on a video that makes me tear.
Божественно. Девочки, спасибо! Вы восхитительны.
Superb rendition of Bach's masterpiece. Brilliant performance from two very talented musicians.
Magnifique interprétation de cette célèbre pièce d'orgue de J S Bach ; les deux accordéons lui confèrent un ton moins solennel mais tout aussi émouvant et mélodieux; Bravo et Mille merci à nos deux talentueuses musiciennes pour cette vidéo; Tous nos souhaits de vous entendre dans un futur proche dans la fugue, complément indissociable de la passacaille
Two artists at their best and a beautiful and spiritual piece of music.
I'm in admiration of those accordions - serious instruments.
Lovely, thank you. I like seeing the physicality of the interaction/ embrace of the players and the accordions - as with cellists and cellos
Bravo, 1,000 times bravo ! JSB will be very proud of you, beautiful ladies !
Die beste Interpretation auf einem anderen Instrument die ich je gehört habe!
There's something I love about how much sound you can get from such small instruments. And the playing was excellent.
I saw a comment chastising the poster of this video for not naming the musicians. I believe that the musicians themselves posted this video. They are Renée Bekkers and Pieternel Berkers of the duo TOEAC, whose website is in the description of the video.
Accordions need to be taken more seriously as musical instruments. Maybe if I ever get rich, I might get my hands on one and try to learn it myself. After all, my grandfather played the instrument, though the last time I saw him was when I was 5, and he has died since.
I had never heard, heard of or seen classical accordions until a few weeks ago. Now I am a true fan. Lovely performance here.
une des plus belles pièces de Bach, extraordinaire rendu avec ces instruments. Bravo
Love that BASS.....
Космос. Мороз по коже не отпускает...
Awesome! Thank you, from San Jose, California.
Belle la musique . Version pour passionnés . A voir les yeux fermés. La vie ainsi , que de plaisir de se la faire partager avec JSB. Merci a nos deux talentueuses musiciennes.
pourquoi les yeux fermés? elles sont splendides ces demoiselles en plus d'avoir un immense talent! ;-))
Thank you, girls!
- Mesdames, quel beau tandem vous faites, merci !
MAGNIFIQUE !
So glad I discovered these intimate angels at 1:45 a.m. This time facilitated for me the depth of silence necessary to more fully perceive the opulent intimacy which so graces their performances. Indeed, 'performance' is insufficient for what they accomplish. With their videos, I'm now finally getting in my later years the depth of the accordion and the powerful grasp of it's gripping intimacy through such artistic souls, assisted with exceptional instruments, as well. I'm fairly blown away. Wish a CD were available, I was only able to get an MP3 of their work.
Bach est le plus grand compositeur de tout les temps.
Cela ne se discute même pas le millième d'une seconde ; Bach a été dans les lieux célestes et nous a ramené un aperçu de ce qui s'y pratique au quotidien
je suis autism
Scarlatti qui est né la même année à fait des merveilles aussi ;)
Et la BWV 582 certainement la plus grande pièce musicale de tous les temps.
Question étude des harmonies, c'est véritablement un traité encyclopédique.
@bon claudy > il est évident qu'il y en a eu des très bons, avant, pendant et après Jean-Sébastien, cela ne se discute pas.
Il n'empêche que, dans beaucoup de domaines, le natif d'Eisenach se tient une marche au-dessus de tous les autres. Nettement. :)
Bach trasciende la poesía misma. Bach es infinito, el mayor genio del arte
A magnificent effort for a truly great piece of music.
Wonderful.
What a great interpretation of this piece!
Beautiful
Descomunal, inmenso ,fabuloso ,fantástico ,soberbio ,gigante ,apoteosico, poderoso y creo que me quedo corto. Gracias
prachtig gespeeld,heel kunstig met al die knopjes,ook die ene dame die de triolen speelt ,maar ook het samenspel heel knap gedaan ,dit werk wat eigenlijk voor orgel is geschreven ,hebben ze mooi weer gegeven in beknopte wijze,
Thank you so much for this beautiful performance. May God bless you and your loved ones!
Какие красивые девки-баянистки! Вот это дуэт! Вот это музыка! Бах бы, думаю, был в восторге.
Très beau duo et une splendide interprétation. Très grand bravo et merci.
El mejor pasacalles de j s Bach! Ejecutado divinamente,,,,,grandiosas las dos !
Wonderful performance of Passacaglia, deep to my heart, congratulations!
Thanks for this beautiful interpretation
Ongelooflijk knap! Prachtig weergegeven,met zoveel gevoel!
Bedankt voor't delen.
Brava -- one of my favorite pieces!
Grazie !
Complimenti siete veramente molto brave !!!
Perfect perfomance !!!
Bravo from Aotearoa / New Zealand!
Vous etes tres beau duo et j'adore votre interpretation organ musiqe !
Очень вдумчивое и певучее исполнение! Спасибо за труд и мастерство, красота спасет мир!
The full version (with Prelude, and Brandenburg Concerto 3 as well) is now released on CD. Check www.toeac.nl/Duo-Toeac/nl-NL/shop.aspx
Besteld 👍
Impressive in every way!. So musical! The classical accordion at it's finest.BRAVA!
Very cool! BRAVO!!!
Je ne l'avais pas imaginé, et pourtant vous l'avez joué merveilleusement, Bravo !
Bach a l epoque voulait composer pour violon sauf qu il a joué a l orgue tout en gardant l esprit du violon pour sa composition. Mais l accordeon et l orgue sont assez proche c est pour cela que Bach se joue aujourd'hui régulièrement a l accordeon
Very sensational (and sensual) performance...
Very very GOOD!!!
Magnífico ...
Superb performance
I am glad that you understand Bach
I must say that you are lucky that you are able to understanf Bach.It is very clear from your playing.No jokes.Hats off.India
wow, that's really very good stuff, thank you so much !
in BACH we trust !
Yes, PLEASE also play the Fugue!
The Passacaglia by Bach is unique giving us a happy mood and you see this first at the faces of the players.
Zeer doordachte en melodieuze uitvoering! Dank u voor uw werk en vaardigheid, schoonheid zal de wereld redden! Met liefde uit St. Petersburg, Rusland.
I adore Bach I.S.
😃😃😃😃😃!
Merci!!
De la grande beauté ! De la passion !! Du respect !
Re- merci !!
Sensacional interpretación por este duo de acordeonistas. Le dan un aire de magia y delicada sensualidad difícil de encontrar en otras de las numerosas interpretaciones de esta obra . No se pierde ni una sola nota . ¡Bravo ! será una de mis interpretaciones de referencia
WOW!!!! This is the most passionate rendition I have ever heard!! ENCORE!!! ...And by that, I mean... THE FUGUE!!!!!! :D Greetings from the States. You have earned my subscription!
Exquisite!
Amazing Rendition
Bravo. Marvelous. Wunderbar. Bach should be proud of this transcription.
Magnifique,merci.
right here there's hope for all...beautiful, just lovlieness, best music ever (love Mozarts operas) divine girls
🕊️♥️🕊️And I have nothing to give that anyone also have🕊️♥️🕊️because GOD is everything and in everyone 🕊️♥️🕊️
Meraviglioso complimenti siete non sollo due bellissime ma anche due grande artista VVB 🌺🌸
Bravo! Very good!!
Amazing work
Thank you so much
Congratulations 👏
Excellent phrasing and velocities! Brave!
Beautiful version.
Emotion pur. Grandios gespielt. Großes Kompliment.
Pure emotion. Played great. Big compliment.
Amazing!
this is my favorite song Amazing!
incredible!
Wonderful
Totally delightful!
lovely ladies with lovely sounds
Amazing . Thank you
Vraiment bravo à vous deux. Excellente interprétation ! C'est poignant et superbement joué
Beautiful interpretation.
one like is not enough to express my admiration
Very nice job ladies.
Thrilling. thanks
Wow, this is great! Thank you :)
Klinkt heel mooi, dank je wel.
Ik heb hier al vaak naar gekeken en word er iedere keer stil van. Zo mooi.....
Fabuleux
Humanity at its best!
beautiful!
Acordeons maravilhosos, essas intérpretes são ótimas.
Obra musical de gran belleza en una espléndida versión con indiscutible virtuosismo. Gracias por compartir
Maravilla!!!
Adembenemend mooi! Bravo!
Congratulations! you made me tremble
Really good playing... ♥
Very musically expressive. I did not know according could be played with such finesse.
Хорошо-то как!