Muslims in India: Children's faith, friendships, and future | BBC News India
Vložit
- čas přidán 27. 06. 2024
- What is it like to be a Muslim child growing up in today's India amid growing religious differences and intolerance? In the first part of our series, ‘Being Muslim in India,’ we explore how the changing social and political environment affects Muslim children. How are they coping, and how are their parents managing? The BBC's Divya Arya examines this through the experiences of two children and their mothers - one from Bihar in the east and the other in Noida, adjacent to the national capital.
Reporter: Divya Arya
Camera-Editing: Premanand Boominathan
Watch the series, 'Being Hindi in India' here:
1. • India's Dalit communit...
2. • Caste Pride on Instagr...
3. • The Hindu priests coun...
#muslimsinindia #indianmuslim #muslims #muslimchildren #muslimwomen #indianmuslims '
#bbcnewsindia #bbcnews
Click here to subscribe to our channel 👉🏽 bbc.in/3whmDp3
-----------------------------------
This is the official BBC News India channel. If you want to understand and follow the India story, we hope this will be your home. Here, you’ll find stories that move your heart and explainers, interviews and documentaries on issues that you care about.
Don’t expect a 24/7 stream of news, we are not that channel. But you can look forward to top-quality BBC journalism that will help you make sense of what’s happening around you.
Do comment on our videos and posts because we will be reading them and taking them on board, and if you like what we do, you can also find us here
BBC Website 👉🏽bbc.in/3XjgjcP
Instagram 👉🏽 bbc.in/3GNTSVW
Facebook 👉🏽 bbc.in/3XgMc5M
Twitter 👉🏽 bbc.in/3XlbAXZ
Thanks for following us!
#BBCNewsIndia #India
Salute to Aiza's mother , that's too much courage, No need to fear, This is our India as much as anyone else
Our India???? Lol, just coz a constitution which had been made by the nexus of Communists and Marxcists had allowed your LOT to stay in India makes India your home LOL
India belongs to Indian Muslims in the same way as Palestine belongs to the Europeans settlers
Our India??? LOL just coz a marxcist contitution allowed you to stay in India, makes India your home???
India belongs to the Muslims in the same way as Palestine belongs to the settlers
BBC stop ur propaganda. There is no Islamophobia in India. It is islam o recognition. That is knowing the true face of Islam. And what do you mean their own country. Their rightful own country is Pakistan. Here they are on khairaat. Since they had demanded Pakistan. Make no mistake the Indian Muslims most of whom stayed back demanded partition that is batwara. After doing batwara of the house they stayed back. And now they say this is also their own house. What logic is that bbc can you explain. Why don’t you implement this in the UK since there are many Islamic lovers in your country asking for Sharia.
Rani Begum is also equally brave if not more. It's much easier for rich people to say this kind statement because they rarely face communal violence. It's poor who always suffer most. They face real Islamophobia. Rich only heard on social media.
Its not true.islam always trying to impose their religion.
Its funny how RW hindus does not even deny such allegations. Instead points fingers back
BBC stop ur propaganda. There is no Islamophobia in India. It is islam o recognition. That is knowing the true face of Islam. And what do you mean their own country. Their rightful own country is Pakistan. Here they are on khairaat. Since they had demanded Pakistan. Make no mistake the Indian Muslims most of whom stayed back demanded partition that is batwara. After doing batwara of the house they stayed back. And now they say this is also their own house. What logic is that bbc can you explain. Why don’t you implement this in the UK since there are many Islamic lovers in your country asking for Sharia.
Cause they have won.
No one asks how we got here. If there was bonhomie and peace between the two, hindus and sikhs wouldnt need to get visa to visit their religious shrines which are now is ppaxtan/bungledesh
@@voidMainReturnZero u think muslims have free entry into pakistan?😂
@@mohammedisham7295 you think Hindus and muslims have always been at peace? Pakistan was made for muslims by muslims.
Will the BBC investigating the plight of Hindus in Pakistan and Bangladesh?
Al least u admitted that muslims are suffering in india same as other minorities suffering in pak nd Bangladesh.
Or are u implying to bbc if you don't report about other countries then just be silent nd watch muslims suffer here??
@@nithinjohn4425 I think he pointed out that most of the western leftist media want to portrayed the islamophobia and want to established in front of world that muslims are the only minority.
But Hindus , christians in bangladesh , pakistan even remains under more oppressions and western leftists do not have any clue about that... So he is taking on biased left media
which is good
@@Bengal2923 Is that so? Those stmts don't indicate that.
Your comment shows no empathy even if it involves children. We are all human beings first. Everything else is secondary!
Bangladeshi Hindus are so happy even more than us.
if u r indian then ask me what u wanna know
Comment section itself proves why BBC is making such video 🙏🙏
BBC should do same program and interviews about Muslims in UK.
Why? This report was about India. Silly whataboutery on your part.
Should we resolve the Hindu - Muslim disputes (like Ayodhya, Kashmir, partition etc.) or push them under the carpet? I believe the only way is to resolve them.
There's no way resolve that because the Muslims aren't looking for peace. Take a look at their Audacity of denying and turning a Blind Eye to the Religious problem in Kashmir and then expect the other community to believe them ........what a Joke !!!
When there's no Hindu Muslim issue then how politicians get the votes 😂 without that actual issues raise like unemployment, water crisis, heath care system...etc which our leaders cannot fix so better keep public in disputes and we can encash their votes
BBC stop ur propaganda. There is no Islamophobia in India. It is islam o recognition. That is knowing the true face of Islam. And what do you mean their own country. Their rightful own country is Pakistan. Here they are on khairaat. Since they had demanded Pakistan. Make no mistake the Indian Muslims most of whom stayed back demanded partition that is batwara. After doing batwara of the house they stayed back. And now they say this is also their own house. What logic is that bbc can you explain. Why don’t you implement this in the UK since there are many Islamic lovers in your country asking for Sharia.
You cannot resolve infinite disputes.
@@mdrafeek786 - I agree politicians take advantage, but Hindu - Muslim disputes are not *false*. There was a bloody partition just decades back. So I consider religious issues far too important to ignore than unemployement.
BBC = Chaos engine
Muslims have no issues in Kerala, India. If Muslims see Bharat as their motherland and give up on Ummah (Muslim Brotherhood). Muslims cry for Gaza, but there is no cry for Sudan and Yemen
They don't really have to give up on their ummah to see india as their motherland, they can go hand in hand.
Every religion at its core strive for truth. There is no concept of blind brotherhood.
@@siddiqhabib9627which truth? That non moslems are dhimmis? That it's fair to ask non Moslems to pay jizya? That non Moslem women are fair game as sex slaves?
@@siddiqhabib9627 Ummah is not a Universal Brotherhood as noted by the Father of the constitution, Dr. Ambedkar. An Indian Muslim will cry for a Palestinian in Gaza, and don't care about the death of Indian soldiers who protect his security.
@@siddiqhabib9627Ambedkar, Father of Indian Constitution “Hinduism is said to divide people and in contrast Islam is said to bind people together. This is only a half-truth. For Islam divides as inexorably as it binds. Islam is a close corporation and the distinction that it makes between Muslims and non-Muslims is a very real, very positive and very alienating distinction. The brotherhood of Islam is not the universal brotherhood of man. It is brotherhood of Muslims for Muslims only. There is a fraternity, but its benefit is confined to those within that corporation. For those who are outside the corporation, there is nothing but contempt and enmity. The second defect of Islam is that it is a system of social self-government and is incompatible with local self-government, because the allegiance of a Muslim does not rest on his domicile in the country which is his but on the faith to which he belongs. To the Muslim ibi bene ibi patria [Where it is well with me, there is my country] is unthinkable. Wherever there is the rule of Islam, there is his own country. In other words, Islam can never allow a true Muslim to adopt India as his motherland and regard a Hindu as his kith and kin.”
What about making a video on divide and rule policy of Britishers ?
200 millions islam in india biggest minority in the world and it's growing how it can be oppressed where afghanistan, Pakistan,Bangladesh and Malaysia minorities deciminated by their Goverment since independence 😂 how is it fair BBC ?
Samething, our schools would only do hindu prayers despite the fact it a secular school where children from all religions study.
Also growing up, our school used to do assemblies about every religion except eid. The problem is that we accept this as normal. No one talks abou this
SAARE JAHAN SE ACHA.HINDUSTAAN HAMAARA🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤❤
Lynchistan
So what is happening in UK can any one ask BBC to make such programs muslim living in UK specially in London. Why muslim students facing racial discrimination,why so much Islamophobia in UK media , I wonder when BBC will highlight those issue or only here to make propganda video to defame India when muslim are 15% of Indiain population which is more then 200 million where as only 5% muslim live in UK . Waiting to see when muslims have right to protest in UK without facing any discrimination.
I won't deny the facts
BBC is the Left over Daughter of British.
It is a concern but not this big in INDIA as BBC represents all time. Such a Shame!
BBC is funded by islamists ...😂
BBC stop ur propaganda. There is no Islamophobia in India. It is islam o recognition. That is knowing the true face of Islam. And what do you mean their own country. Their rightful own country is Pakistan. Here they are on khairaat. Since they had demanded Pakistan. Make no mistake the Indian Muslims most of whom stayed back demanded partition that is batwara. After doing batwara of the house they stayed back. And now they say this is also their own house. What logic is that bbc can you explain. Why don’t you implement this in the UK since there are many Islamic lovers in your country asking for Sharia.
They probably do that all the time
Bilkul! Humne bhi azaadi li hai. Dharm ki rajneeti khatm honi chahiye. We all are Indians.
Azadi hi nahi balki desh ka hissa bhi le liya tha...
@@WithoutAUsernameChina ne bhi le liya. China ka naam lene se kyun darte ho?
@@astra527 look into the context...
I was talking about division of sacred land Bharat due to IsIam !
Aazaadi ke baad Hindus me sudhaar aaya he. Muslims abhi bhi 7th century me jii rahe he. Apne logon ko samjaao pehle.
BBC stop ur propaganda. There is no Islamophobia in India. It is islam o recognition. That is knowing the true face of Islam. And what do you mean their own country. Their rightful own country is Pakistan. Here they are on khairaat. Since they had demanded Pakistan. Make no mistake the Indian Muslims most of whom stayed back demanded partition that is batwara. After doing batwara of the house they stayed back. And now they say this is also their own house. What logic is that bbc can you explain. Why don’t you implement this in the UK since there are many Islamic lovers in your country asking for Sharia.
Stop Islamphobia
The amount of people "crying" in the comment section that BBC should first look at their home country, is just laughable. - it's not sensible to compare two countries when a finger is pointed at ours.
The fact remains in our country, the situation has gone out of our hands. Too many unemployed youth peddling hatred. We need to improve as Humans. Not as Hindu, Christians or Muslims (to name a few).
That's what we are also telling. first behave as humans not spreading fake news, not spreading your religion, or using abusive words on our Devi & Devatha. We have a lot of tolerance that's why all religion people are living peacefully
@@nikhileshvunnam6345
We have started to worship/work for a particular political ideology. The politicians are our servants, not the other way around. We need to stop boasting the political people/ their ideology.
We have to show them (the politicians) their actual place in the society.
That's what has turned us into what we are. We are not peaceful. Not at all.
@@VibeMD You are not peaceful even we are, because of you people coming to our homes and spreading your shitty religions and dividing our people in the name of religion. Unless and until, the previous governments make good decisions why this much hatred will happen among us. Who is attacking with bombs, what happened to Kasmir the epicenter of knowledge. Yes, I agree with you, we are not living in peace who came from outside and spread hate among ourselves in the name of secularism but are biased toward particular communities, even though we are trying to live in harmony. Whoever doesn't want to live in this country, can leave and go to a place where they can live peacefully, especially Pakistan, UK, USA, China & Canada. At least you can find peace there. All the best brother/ Sister and congratulations in advance if you leave and find peace.
BBC stop ur propaganda. There is no Islamophobia in India. It is islam o recognition. That is knowing the true face of Islam. And what do you mean their own country. Their rightful own country is Pakistan. Here they are on khairaat. Since they had demanded Pakistan. Make no mistake the Indian Muslims most of whom stayed back demanded partition that is batwara. After doing batwara of the house they stayed back. And now they say this is also their own house. What logic is that bbc can you explain. Why don’t you implement this in the UK since there are many Islamic lovers in your country asking for Sharia.
@@VibeMDno more possible.
South Indians live harmoniously with each other.
What Muslim... They are bharati Religion they may be Muslim. They are bharati(Indian)
Thanks BBC for raising voice of oppressed minority in india..
❤
They are not oppressed in any way.
Oppresed minorities are hindus in Bangladesh and pakistan and other non muslims in muslim world.Whereas muslims get minority privilages in India.
3rd largest population you called oppressed ....
Should have checked in Google
Good coverage. But some days ago a tourist was mob lynched in swat , Pakistan. Why no BBC report ?
Don't try to defame new INDIA.Whole world knows how rascist London is.
And their PM is Indian and even all gov their have Indians as party high posts guys.
It cell bale ho keya jo whataboutism kar rehe ho
BBC stop ur propaganda. There is no Islamophobia in India. It is islam o recognition. That is knowing the true face of Islam. And what do you mean their own country. Their rightful own country is Pakistan. Here they are on khairaat. Since they had demanded Pakistan. Make no mistake the Indian Muslims most of whom stayed back demanded partition that is batwara. After doing batwara of the house they stayed back. And now they say this is also their own house. What logic is that bbc can you explain. Why don’t you implement this in the UK since there are many Islamic lovers in your country asking for Sharia.
Or else what?
May Allah bless and protect all the children in the world ❤ ameen
In Kerala Muslims and Christians get same status as Hindus.
Thats because muslim and christian population is half of the total population. The places where the "majority"religion is above 70 percent u will see this magic.
That's because both christian and muslim population comes to 50 percentage. If the 'majority' religion goes above 60 percent, you will see another north india in kerala.
BBC should Raise voice of pakistani hindu and Bangladeshi Hindu.😡😡😡😡
Islamophobia 😂
Har baar Yehi Nautanki hai Inka.........Aatankwaadi ke Namaz e Janaza Mei Inke Hazaaro log shamil hote hai aur phir bolte hai Hum Sacche Hindustani hai hum par shak mat karo 😅😅😅
Hi can u do report on hindus or no islam oppressed in Afghanistan,Pakistan,Bangladesh and Malaysia please 🙏
Thanks, BBC for insight on this issue.:)
British Mind:
Still we can devide and rule them
Indian mind: We will divert and distract with petty religious bickering instead of doing anything to bring down the high youth unemployment or fix the worst pollution levels in the world!
And what you want to say about BBC ???
" UK is not going to give VISA to Islamists or Muslims students "
Insaan Bane...kya aapka Dharam aapko dusray ko neecha samajna sikhata hain... religion teaches humanity
😅😅😅😂😂😂😂😂
What about Hindu Childrens in Pakistan, and chicken shops inside temples...
It is BCC India not Pakistan
Children cannot have a religion any more than they can have a political ideology. A religion is merely an opinion of one's relationship to the universe. How is a child supposed to have one, other than through mindless mimicry? It is abusive to label a child by the religion of its parents.
BBC stop ur propaganda. There is no Islamophobia in India. It is islam o recognition. That is knowing the true face of Islam. And what do you mean their own country. Their rightful own country is Pakistan. Here they are on khairaat. Since they had demanded Pakistan. Make no mistake the Indian Muslims most of whom stayed back demanded partition that is batwara. After doing batwara of the house they stayed back. And now they say this is also their own house. What logic is that bbc can you explain. Why don’t you implement this in the UK since there are many Islamic lovers in your country asking for Sharia.
Ideally true.
it shows how primitive hindu way of thinking is. hinduism not at all a religion, how would they know what religion is
That's applied to all religions aur thats not the issue discussed in this video
No one asks how we got here. If there was bonhomie and peace between the two, hindus and sikhs wouldnt need to get visa to visit their religious shrines which are now is ppaxtan/bungledesh
Thank you for this series❤
Fake news .The Muslims have good lives in India.
SAYS AN INDIAN STREET SHYTR
Proof ??
OMG BBC YOU PEOPLE ARE OBSESSED WITH INDIA
Did you not notice the name of this channel being BBC News India? English comprehension is obviously not a strong point of yours!
@@SenorSol my strong point is in identifying hogwash from the likes of you and the agenda what people like you are trying to spread but sad thing is islam and its sympathizers are exposed by internet
How about Hindu children in Bangladesh, pakistan, malaysia?
Hi leftus BBC can you make some documentary on this?
TYPICAL INDIAN STREET SHYTTR TRYNA DEFLECT TO OTHER COUNTRIES
Teaman Feku the founder of modern Indian fascism
Then why Britain deporting poor muslim immigrants
What do these Muslims talk about Love jihad Kashmiri pandits ?
Islamophobia…oh wowoww….fear of getting replaced demographically is what it is
❤🎉
Choootiya Broadcasting. Corporation
Truth always hurts kiddo
Good effort by BBC.❤
For spreading propaganda 😊
Seven children 😢
How can defame a country we can learn from bbc😅😅.
behera too have been brainwashed by those ideology heads and systems who had fucked their roots lineages socially economically educationally and culturally
true true
Also its sister Al Jazeera.
@@silverghost5752 true true
No Documentary On Hindu children in Pakistan. It's BBC.
George sorrows funded media 😅
Muslim of south asia got best deal. They got bangladesh, pakistan also secular india. What about hindus?
Also muslims have problem every where. An interview with british muslim will not be any different.
Please make a programme on condition of Hindus in Bangladesh and Pakistan
7 children's 😂..happens only in Indial. Thus proven., happily living and increasing..,
Tere dada ke kite the
So you accept that muslims are still living in dada ka jamane me@@sadiqsd7800
@@sadiqsd7800 tere baap se to kam hi honge
@@sadiqsd7800Mere dada ke 3 hi bachhe hai. Dada vaala time chodo tum to ab bhi 7-8 bachhe krte ho, jab baaki sab 1-2 hi krte hai.
Such sick mentality you have, are you’ll really humans, religion and bigotry have gotten so much into the head that there are no human beings before you it seems, get well soon
BBC way of fueling …!
BBC rise voice of hindu and Christan in Pakistan afghanistan and in Bangladesh
BBC needs a tuition teacher for study about India...😕
Most of the Muslims in India are richer compared to Hindus. Because of the petrol dollar money coming from GCC nations... 🤷♂
If you are an international audience, watching this video wastes your time. With this video, you can't understand anything about Indian situations...👎
On 27 feb, 2002 women and children in godhara kaand were burnt alive. Did u see that BBC or u were sleeping? I didn't see any homage video for those godhara children on 27 feb on your channel. Why don't you make a video on Pakistan's hindu children and their sufferings, especially about girl hindu child living in pakistan bangladesh. They destroyed their all temples and built mosque. Why do u become blind and paralyzed when u r supposed to cover such story of suffering of hindus children in pakistan.
Indian Muslims are most peacefull in the world
It is reality that now we Indian Muslim are oppressed, underprivileged and backward in education and government post representation. Recently the Indian muslims have been facing financial conditions. I believe that the Main reason of Muslim backwardness is poverty that exists in our muslim community.
Despite the all problems , we Indian Muslim work collectively on education , making good financial conditions, increasing mislim representation in govt organs . Although today we are oppressed , tomorrow Insha Allah we will be good in education , govt representation. We are gradually working on the improvement of our conditions. But changing conditions requires a lot of time .
what's doing Briton to India, Africa, palasthene etc divided and rule 😂... You spread the seed now crying 😂
admit it, Muslims had nothing to do with the Indian
Subcontinent, it was only after the Gaznavids, Sultanates and Mughal when Islam was established in India(and that too aftertge numerous genocides of the Hindus that were committed by the invading Islamists), Indian National Congress was the secular government, they were following the principles of the western backed democracratic values, it was Jinnah and All India Muslim league which had created this havoc along with British in order to counter Hindus, if AIML was having this rift with the INC or with the secular Hindu dominated India, then there was something seriouslly wrong with the Indian Muslims(modern day Pakistanis and Bangladeshis and India's Muslim population) Jinnah had dreamed of this greater Pakistan over the Hindu India in which he had wished to include Hyderabad, Junagrah, Kashmir, Bengal, Punjab, Lakshdweed , Kerala, but fortunetly, Jinnah was partially unsuccessfull in his sinister plans, as Hindu India continues to rule over the majority of land, but still by this time Islamists had occupied Half of Punjab, half of Bengal, Khyber, Boluchistan and Sindh from India, and also Pakistani ideology of Pan-Islamism was a disaster which was witnessed globally by the world,(1970 Pakistani civil war, 1971 Indo-Pakistani war and Bangladeshi liberation along with the Pakistani surrender to the Indian forces), this only prooves that Pakistan and Bangladesh were better off with India, and Pan-Islamism is a disaster ideology
Admit it, Aryans had nothing to do with India, and Manusmriti is foreign invention.
@@sadiqsd7800
Aryan migration theory is just a hypothesis !
It's not a proven fact.
There's no significant archeological or literary evidence to prove it.
Dr. Ambedkar himself in his books wrote that Arya are the indigenous of Bharat.
@@sadiqsd7800
IsIamic invasion is a proven fact...
Anyway no one should be proud of atrocities done by invãders
@@sadiqsd7800
Regarding Manusmriti, I will condemn it only when you also condemn Sharia.
Manusmriti was composed in Bramhavarta i.e. Modern Day Haryana.
But Sharia was composed in a foreign & Mleccha land.
So, Manusmriti is not foreign but Sharia is !
@@sadiqsd7800 nothing new here,just an average ajlaf believing in a British fictional theory , no wonder Indian Muslims( Pakistanis and Bangladeshis) were always the biggest pawn of Britishers against the Hindus,
It's sad that they are still hating Muslims, India, not realising they are the same people, they have same dna.
Future will be dangerous for them
You guys started to divide and rule , unfortunately it continues...
True. But no one blames the Christians in India. The blame us always on Hindus and Muslims.
Muslim should study
🇦🇪 ❤
😂 Hope They Got Good Investment From Canndian K Loby And Karachi Loby
It's spelled 'lobby' you muppet!
Is ki roti isee topic k ird gird chalti hai
This is the condition of muslims nowdays in India.
If we criticize Christianity , Hinduism the is no hindufobia and critanfobia. Only due hypocrisy of some" so called secular" makes makes this argument. Blasphemy our birth right 👍👍
7 children is the problem here😂😂😂
7 children ke bad bhi wo 15 cr or tm ek paida krne ke bad bhi 120 cr😊😅😅
@@LKO900 hamara desh hai. Hame to 100% hona chahiye.
@@LKO900 57 countries hai tumhare udhar jaake raho.
@@Truelust29 puri duniya hmari hai
@@ridhamatri9447 to kro na
100 ho ya 80 mughlo se angrezo se Hwa khrab thi abhi bhi hindu khatre me hai
They are going nowhere , they are indian hindu who were converted , we will convert them back and they will safely stay here.
Why do u want to convert them back?
@@tehreemfatima-bn2lrbecause it is our native religion.
Why do you they should remain arabized and not get indianised culturally?
Shouldn't we be promoting our local culture ?
@@SuryaJinping everyone has the right to practice their own religion. And You can never convert muslims. They will die, never convert.
Who converted LOL 😂.
EVEN Southern MUSLIM ARE SO DIFFERENT LOOK AT THEM AND LOOK AT YOU THEY LOOK MORE Arabian
@@baqtiarm4211 who asked you india is multiracial civilization , arab, turks , mongols , indian , tibetan all live here. it is just that islam is bad and we don't our brothers to follow bad , why quran why not physics chemistry science tech , what has quran given to world terrorist but science has given interrnet to discuss this shit.
Such a misleading video😅😅😅😅
Islamophobia😂😂
BBC propoganda news channel 😡😡
Be an ATHEIST and solve all your problems 🤞🏻
Ja ke ahi sab pakistan hindu se pucho bbc
It's bbc India not bbc Pakistan
you peddle divisive narratives about India. Maybe instead of stirring up old wounds, you could reflect on the racism and hatred that still persists in your own country. India's diversity is our strength, and we won't let your biased portrayal overshadow our unity. How about portraying real stories of harmony and progress next time?
BBC stop ur propaganda. There is no Islamophobia in India. It is islam o recognition. That is knowing the true face of Islam. And what do you mean their own country. Their rightful own country is Pakistan. Here they are on khairaat. Since they had demanded Pakistan. Make no mistake the Indian Muslims most of whom stayed back demanded partition that is batwara. After doing batwara of the house they stayed back. And now they say this is also their own house. What logic is that bbc can you explain. Why don’t you implement this in the UK since there are many Islamic lovers in your country asking for Sharia.
7 children 😂