Tool "Lateralus" // Pastor Rob Reacts // Lyrical Analysis and Reaction Video
Vložit
- čas přidán 25. 02. 2019
- Lateralus Reaction. Lots of links and additional info in the video description.
Song Starts at 7:00 // Analysis starts at 19:30 //My favorite commentary 24:44
Follow us on Social ⬇️
Facebook: PastorRobertH
IG: / pastorroberth
Twitter: / robertdhoughton
_______________________________________________
💲--We are in need of financial support to keep this channel going.
Patreon: / pastorrobreacts
Donorbox: donorbox.org/pastorrobreacts
*All of our videos are monetized by the artists.
________________________________________________
19:40-20:57
Alchemy and the Bible
www.gotquestions.org/Bible-al...
20:58-23:22Gods Sovereignty
www.gotquestions.org/God-is-s...
23:23-24:49Humans divine?
carm.org/if-holy-spirit-lives...
Jesus Divine
www.gotquestions.org/divinity...
24:50-Order or Chaos?
answersingenesis.org/evidence...
answersingenesis.org/intellig...
answersingenesis.org/is-god-r...
God’s Fingerprint: The Fibonacci Scale
• Gods Fingerprint→ The ...
THE GOSPEL!
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
#PastorRob #Tool #Reaction - Hudba
Lots of commentary on this one! I put timestamps in the description. Also, there's a delay on the new website so for now it'll take you to a temporary page.
Please react to unanswered by suicide silence
If you like tool you might also like their song called ( vicarous )
I've been waiting for this one since I first saw y'all do tool
tool vicarious is another classic in my point of view.
i'm a member of an anonymous group of addicts of one variety or another, and I really enjoy hearing the spiritual and religious analysis of tool and a perfect circle. Watching your videos is bringing my own realizations to some of my favorite songs. Thank you for doing this
Ironic that a song about overanalyzing, gets overanalyzed by the fans
Always what I think about when I try to understand tool songs. Perhaps the answer is " there are no answers ".
exactly.. I feel lucky about the fact that I got exposed to this music back then totally "unprepared"
Ironic, he could save others from overanalyzing, but not himself
Pimp_Named SlickBack ROFLMAO....Revenge of the Lateralus :)
I love Tool but Tool fans can be absolutely ridiculous
Can we all just admit that Tool is the best band of all time
I was of the opinion that if their next release maintains the level of their past releases then (in my opinion) they will have surpassed Led Zeppelin as the best. In preparation of the next release I have recently been revisiting their full body of work. I am now galvanized by the opinion that this next release is inconsequential. Tool is the best, ever.
@@42mohawks6 i second that my guy
Hardly man, granted tool is good.
Maynard is the bomb.
You misspelled Opeth
When you try to head bang to a song that changes time signature like 3 times in 20 seconds
That's been an inside joke with them I bet for many a year.
Hence Maynard's rocking posture.
yeah this is more of a sway song, til the end... then its head bang time
Take psychedelics. They are Gods gift.
Actually lol...I remember seeing a show for this album, and yeah...the crowd could not keep time dancing to save their collective lives lol. Intense fucking show tho...top 5.
"I'm kind of sad it's over" Yup, you're a Tool fan.
Welcome! One-of-us
"its a vinyl rip in lossless FLAC format"
yup youre a tool fan
I love how listening to Tool is like being high...but clear minded
A lot of what they try to do with their music, especially with this song, is to open your mind to a higher way of thinking. Think outside the box and get out of your comfort zone. It’s very similar to people who get high to do the same thing. Not the ones who get high just to avoid life or to self medicate but to reach a higher understanding of oneself. What you said was simple but very close to the truth :)
Specifically because Maynard does not do drugs but is such a deep intellectual person he doesn't need them for mind expansion!
@deadend i disagree, my friend, I am more clear headed and focused when I listen to Tool than any other time!
@@AngelaMStovall when I went to rehab, this was the album I took with me. Literally saved my life.
You're absolutely right...
But i really want to see them smoking a joint...
Pastor Reacts to Tool, mid grade marijuana, pizza and sprite...
Tool: "Don't overthink things and just enjoy it."
Also Tool: *Uses deep obscure lyrics, hidden messages and combines songs*
lmao so true ^^ they carved songs as a wood artist could carve his life's masterpiece.
They don't say that. If you just wanna listen and enjoy, do it. If you wanna get to the deeper meanings, search for it. What they say is: "Tool is exactly what it sounds like: It’s a big dick. It’s a wrench. It’s also what it sounds like: It’s a verb, it’s a digging factor. It’s an active process of searching, as in use us, we are a shovel, we are the match, we’re the blotter of acid, your tool; use us as a catalyst in your process of finding out whatever it is you need to find out, or whatever it is you’re trying to achieve."
Bands that are way better with headphones on. In my opinion…
Tool, Nine inch Nails, Pink Floyd, and Ministry
Although maynard no longer adopts the attitude necessary for its full force, each and every tool performance is an enochian ritual magick designed to destroy all modern forms of control.
That’s why I love Tool so much .
My first real "experience" with Tool was on April 21, 2001 while storm chasing with a coworker who played the new Lateralus album during the chase. We chased a nighttime F4 tornado which destroyed part of the town of Hoisington, KS. This song was playing while we were watching the storm and made me an instant Tool fan from that moment. I had heard a number of Tool songs over the years, but this song took me to a place that seemed to capture the moment I was experiencing chasing that tornado.
What an incredible way to experience lateraled the first time 💯💯💯
Yea, that's cool
Jesus, besides that unusually way to experience tool xD I hope you are ok man
That's an amazing story dude.
Take it you left the opportunity to swing on the spiral?
Now listen to the entire album. This whole album is one of the best ever. Blows my mind every time.
Better listening while you are tripping
I'm pretty sure that it should be regarded as peak Tool, everything after is kind of less of an evolution and more of a consistent sound. Prior to this Opiate -> Undertow -> Aenima were all building to what Lateralus was like
The Lateralus album was meant to be listened from start to finish, almost like an opera or a novel.
"I like the bass guitar, that was pretty cool"
Welcome to tool my man 😂😂
Justin chancellor is a god among men I’m telling you
Tool is so talented, it's not even fair.
You don't listen to TooL... you experience TooL.
Amen!
Absolutely Correct.
Indeed
Most def!! Live is a whole new experience💪💯🎯
Yes Sir!
Infants see black and white first, then they see red. Yellow and blue are next. Then by five months they see all the other colors. I actually set up my daughter's room colors based on this song.
Not if you are colorblind
@@danielharris5661 Which is rare, so for the majority the order is true.
Nope. Reasonable interpretation and valid subjectively, but the intention of the writers is different. The colors are a reference to occult alchemical symbolism. The alchemist moves through these colors spiritually/mystically/philosophically/intellectually/metaphorically while conducting corresponding chemical reactions that result in these colors in this order. It's a sort of scientific spiritual ritual not unlike old pagan ceremonial magic. There's a ton of alchemical symbolism in the rest of the song as well. "As above so below" is a line that makes it a dead giveaway.
I know this is an old comment, but it's never too late to learn something new. I would encourage you to inspect the lyrics more deeply, and follow the occult symbolism. Really dive into the meaning and do the required studying to understand it all. Perhaps even actually indulge in the symbolism and do the esoteric work...
Yes, this is the reference I see there
I was thinking the same thing
Maynard has, by far, one of the greatest voices in, well, anything really, love his voice
Probably best songwriter also. the whole band is just phenomenal.
Stinkfist and H really show his voice
Yes, his voice is amazingly soothing and gets you hyped at the same time! One of the most beautiful male vocals ever!
I still get goosebumps after the 10000th time hearing this song.
You should check out the cello version
Same here
MDomi this is a musical masterpiece!
I see what you did there 😏
Check out the brass against cover it’s so good
One of the greatest musical feats ever conquered.. The golden spiral. Tool is genius. I really appreciate the research you guys do into the music you listen to.
“To swing on the spiral of our divinity and still be a human” has been giving me goosebumps and chills since I was a teenager.
The most surprising thing is there's an Opeth fan (sweat shirt) who had not heard Tool... :O
I've been an Opeth fan for years. Porcupine Tree and alike bands even longer. Found Tool about a month ago.
@@TFOLLT that's crazy to me especially when Tool is much more widely known. If you like Maynard's voice you should check out his other band A perfect circle.
@@TFOLLT to me that is objectively insane
I know guys, now that I do know TOOL I can see why you think that. But since I've gotta find my own way in music, was raised very sheltered, no one to show me cool bands, my family is only into classical music and my parents think I listen to satanic garbage, I've token a weird way into Prog. For example, I discovered Pink Floyd through Dream Theater...
TFOLLT I also started listening to Pink Floyd because of dream theater lol I remember the first dream theater song I ever heard was a change of seasons and someone made a comment about echoes and away I went
I love how you're helping remove the negative stigma attached to rock and metal within theological communities. Please, keep making these videos. Music is the best way for a lot of people to express themselves. And for those of us who have zero musical talent relate.
Thank you! I'm a metalhead but also religious, and it sucks seeing people judge people's morality based on their music preference, especially with a band like tool, who just puts so much care into their composing process.
Awesome job now I suppose Parabol/Parabola would be necessary now!
Yesssss
My personal favorite
Yes!
I have to agree here. I would love to hear Robert’s analysis of the lyrics for Parabol/Parabola specifically. It is also my favorite song on the album. It’s another song in which the music invokes feelings deep within you.
imo the song's on the same level as lateralus in terms of being a masterpiece
over-analyzing: putting religion where there is only maths
Reaching out to embrace the random: don't try to explain everything, let it flow.
separates body from the mind: don't over explain... it's reducing what is really happening to your sole denominator. it's like explaining 3d with a 2d point of view.
@Miko to avoid the drug copyrighted name. yeah. satan is more a catholic thing than to me. in fact i'm an atheist, i prefer self confidence science and objectivity than belief founded above nothing but an old lie
i don't need an hypotethic god to live under a mace of "don't do bad for nothing unless you'll live after death in the worst place ever imagined"
but i know for sure people need this paternalfigure to remember to do nice things around them. as a parent "threatening" children "you won't ever go to the park if you're not nice with your sis or bro" and i can understand that.
but these 2 on video, i'd certainly be happy to be around, still. they seem soo nice guys :)
@@666neoselen so much edge, don’t cut yourself bro
You are missing that mynard, as well as alex grey (who made the art of the album of tool and work with fibinacci) have esoterical belives and egipcian teological back ground.
In this ways of faith, god is not a selfaware being. Its more like a primigenial force that ptoyect itself and creates everything, making every thing divine (even the rocks and animals for example).
So the human exploring the divinity is not about trying to reach god (the Cristian one) but too recognize that the human is part of a whole and not set apart of the rest of the universe.
And the spiral is also interpretated as the limitless potencial of growth and evolucion, of the human being.
Sorry for my poor english
"This dude's got a cool voice"
Give it a minute...
Vicarious is a MUST listen to by Tool
And reflection
Anything by Tool is a must, but honestly I’d like to see what they think of anything off the undertow album preferably intolerance .
jambi is awsome hell everything tool is awsome
@@toolfool82mostrom63 or Bottom
H
Actually, the reference to “black and whit” and “red and
yellow” has to do with our visual acuity as infants, which is without color.
Until the cones in our eyes develop to a point where we can discern color. The
first two colors we are able to see are “red and yellow then came to be, let’s
me see…”
Finally, you nailed it. So many get this wrong!
You do realize it can have multiple meanings right?
I thought I was the only one that got that lol thank you!
@@goatinstein exactly...most people think a part of me is about Maynard "member" lol
But listen and read the lyrics again..from a point of view that he is talking about his mother....at thos point in his journey he was angry at her for abandoning him, for still having so much faith. But she was only a good outlet to blame..she can't leave, can't speak, can't hurt me, just her for moe to use...as an excuse...
He later came to terms, that she did not abandon him. Like some kids who blame mom for making dad leave ect.
I have heard that song 1 million times, and only yesterday did that parallel hit me...
It can also refer to indigenous peoples thoughts on prime
i love how their headbanging is just all over the place because of how intricate the rhythm is lol
"I wanna be friends with their bass player."
I thought he was sitting next to you.
He does resemble Justin.
Justin Chancellor is one of the best bassist in the business.
No doubt eh lol
I wanted to like your comment, but since you're at 69 I'll just tell you I thought the same thing
Hahaha now that you mention it...
The Fibonacci sequence is also found in nature in tons of different creatures and plants, pretty interesting.
the face is based upon the Fib sequence as well. thats why when you see some with deformity of the face like downs your brain can imiditly tell. is so we dont mix our genetics with faluty ones.
@@squirrel3244 come up with that all on your own or you watch Joe Rogan and Maynard like everyone else?😂
@@brandonshepherd3317 look Brandon he doesn't even know how to spell immediately either lol...
Most of these claims are way over exaggerated.
I found a few I couldn't find serious faults in
@@squirrel3244 Actually the whole human body is based upon the fibonacci sequence
When I listen to Tool I feel like I'm taking my mind to the gym.
Outdoor New England time for you to listen to A Love Supreme
Listen to tool in the gym next time lol
@@nuckels188 with pre-workout as well
watching Christians rock out to pagan metal and actually grasp the meaning of it on there own level within the confines of their own path what a age we live in BLESSED BE YOU TWO
Not exactly pagan metal, though
@@janisbuss6334 not exactly ? but it has a lot of pagan ideological reoccurring themes in the lyrics like as above so below however all art is open for interpretation i think if someone assumes that it has nothing to do with paganism they don't know much about the meaning of the lyrics or where they come from whether the band themselves is or is not i m not sure but the lyrics are clearly taken directly from pagan ideology so whether they personally identify as that or just consider them selves spiritual most of there songs have a reoccurring theme that is pagan i think what you mean to say is its not just for pagans to enjoy... and your right its open for interpretation and for all people of all walks of life to enjoy whatever meaning they find it is no more or less valid then anyone elses
natty features EVERYTHING “as above, so below” is a concept, derrived from hermeticism. That’s western esoterics, not paganism. While Tool have focused more on themes from hinduism/buddhism in this one.
@@janisbuss6334 i think your confused hermeticism is a branch of or one form of paganism and this concept is found in many pagan faiths as well paganism can encompass many spiritual paths and faiths both western and eastern and many if not most eastern philosophical spiritual paths are it isn't always about wicca or witches that is a crude stereotype note both hinduism and buddhism fall under the pagan umbrella of alternative faiths
natty features EVERYTHING that’s not a branch of paganism. This is just namedropping different things, that aren’t connected that much, if only in the sense, that they are all spiritual teachings or practices of sorts. Of course, if you look further, even christianity and islam take many events or elements of “pagan” religions, like zoroastrianism and ancient egyptian cosmology.
And “as above, so below” has originated from “The Emerald Tablet, which are the key writings of hermeticism.
I see tool. I upvote
Too much reddit
I see "I see tool. I upvote" in comment. I upvote
"I see Tool. I upvote."
I see simpleton. I down vote.
"Almost did the horns - we do pray hands here" love this wholesome acceptance and passion for music that is normally scorned by religion. Good job guys
But the horns originally were meant as a symbol to shun away evil. Ronnie James Dio's grandmother used to use it and he adopted, and that's where it came from in the metal world
@@imetzl9340 I'm not debating any of that, it was just cute
Sam Reeve the horns are for protection from the Devil. Pastor should of thrown the horns up. There is much hate on the horns. It is not to bring in the Devil and evil.
@@jasonarbogast3691 as I just said before, I'm not calling into debate any of the meaning, it was just funny
Dude kinda looks like Chancellor
Great analysis. But remember over-thinking, over-analyzing separates the body from the mind.
Withering your intuition, leaving opportunities behind.
Howard Roark most relevant comment here. Nonduality.
Howard Roark your analysis
That's where I believe most people go wrong. Never in the song is it stated nor suggested that overthinking is a bad thing. What if separating the body and mind is the goal?
But who is John Galt?
Kyle Motty indeed that is the goal
I’m not a Christian but I appreciate your take on this. You guys seem like really cool people.
AT LAST! Huge fan of the channel as well as Tool.
sirhandelno3 congrats.
tools the best band in the world
23:24 _"Swing on the spiral of our divinity and still be a human."_ The golden spiral, Fibonacci, the gold ratio (phi) are reflected everywhere in nature. These lyrics mean, roughly, to embrace the randomness of life by putting yourself out there to experience new things. To understand that the mathematics of God are present, to understand that there is actually _order in all of the chaos,_ and to still be a human simultaneously living your life as if fate was not decided for you.
the balance of free will and fate
Hey guys, love the fact that you are looking at Tool and being so open minded and putting your own thoughts into it and trying to find meaning in the music. It's also amazing that you are applying the lessons of your faith to the lessons that I think Maynard tries to put into our minds as an audience. The one that I wanted to say in respect to what you were saying was on the discussion on the verse "swing on the spiral of our divinity and still be a human."
In respect to the verse, and in respect to the theme of the song. This verse is a humbling lesson. As humans, we are constantly on a path of discovery and invention, through our actions and our thoughts we are constantly in a processes of transcendence, and by this it is our own divinity that we exercise our own small stretch of power that we are able to use to bend and make and affect our surroundings and impact our world. The humbling truth is our divinity does not fathom the truth of the divine beyond what is attainable by our hands or our minds. And that our divinity, though we may see it as being great and mighty, is a scrap and limited for after all we are only human, and our only course to be more is to seek more and to "spiral out, keep going" to see further into the truth and to reach for greater.
Please give a reaction to"Schism" by Tool. You'll enjoy it
I see what you did there... 😁😉
Amazing message... As a major Tool fan and a devout Christian, you really brought a powerful message. This is the first reaction video of yours that I have watched, but I am hooked! On thing, any true Tool fan would not get angry at your message. Tool is all about peace, inside and out.
I believe when Maynard says to embrace the random, he is saying to embrace change, much like Bruce Lee said be like water. If one can learn to be flexible in life then Murphy's Law will be much easier to accept in occurrence.
I came here to say the same thing. Like being open to all possibilities without expectation.
Funny cause both, Maynard and Bruce Lee were born in the year of the 🐉. Like myself. Understanding the Tao comes natural.
Yes.
you are thinking of this too logically. over analysing it haha. maynard is a spiritual man. Think of it more like following your intuition and that the universe has always got your back
8:35 "hmm, kinda moves through ya"
Yes. Yes it does. This is the magic of TooL
This song is about the most intimate aspects of knowing thyelf, and the process of consciously ascending through the realms of “higher” conscious experience.
I'm not religious at all, but you both seem cool and open-minded. Keep up the good work.
YOU CAN BE SPIRITUAL AND Christlike without being religious religion means to bind its a bondage created by the Roman POPEARY EMPIRE to bind and distort Christian faith.
These guys should really challenge themselves intellectually and analyze music that has a very opposite to their beliefs, such as, well, I don't know...black metal?
There is a clear distinction between being religious and being spiritual.
@@lastfeatheroffreedom9665 What? Oh, hey! This will upset you I bet, you righteous crusader of God.
Hail Satan ;)
SOLDIER of CHRIST OUR LORD yea, no.
The irony here is that Tool fans tend to overanalyze their songs.
Isn't music meant to be? It's for you... analyze it however, and as much as you want
That's why the line from the song is so genius
Dude for reals lmao. I've known people who overthink the lyrics and the fibonacci sequence and all that. Personally I feel like some of these songs simply came naturally to then. As an artist (I draw) I've done some drawings where I'm literally just doodling away not overthinking the process and when people see it they think I put thought into every little detail of the drawing when I really wasnt yet it happens to flow very well.
@@ArteDelDiablo To be fair artists tend to unconsciously give symbolism to their work. They might say that it meant nothing, but one could argue that your "doodles" might not be doodles at all. Instead, they might be an expression coming directly from your psyche.
Of course we're going to over analyze everything because his audience thinks similar to him & I think he talks about NOT doing that because he does this all of the time!
Not sure if this has been mentioned already in your plethora of comments here but I think there's another point that deserves mention here. Maynard's writing process for lyrics with Tool are unique in that he never writes anything until the instrumentals are complete or nearly so. He immerses himself in the music before ever writing a word. I think this is important especially given the nature of this song.
Top 10 reactions, and ive watched them all. love your take guys
Awesome! Thank you!
in the beginning the lord said.."let there be Tool" and there was
joe mac “And it was good”
It didn't. Even God could not make something so great. Time had to wait and nurture humankind to finally bring tool into existence in the late 1900s.
I'm baked right now.
Yawn...
Pranav Kulkarni. Let’s be honest though... if tool wrote the most popular song in the world and it was famous. Religious nuts praising it as an act of god. MJK would throw a fit and release a shitty underdeveloped song on Puscifer.
False. In the beginning, Tool said "let there be Lord."
I have been Listening to this album for 18 years WOW
Can't believe it's been that long! We're getting old
Yes! Have an original nerve ending hoodie from a concert that's just as old!!!! My favorite article of clothing.
15 years for me. It's been glorious.
I heard Tool for the first time in my mates car. The 1st song was stinkfist. Then I looked them up and found Lateralus. My mind was forever altered. Truly one of those experiences that you never forget.
Tool is and will always be in my opinion the greatest, most talented and creative band ever. Artistry at its absolute best
Seeing them in concert is an experience. There is divinity in the higher vibrations, Lower vibrations , and the instrumental rifts in between
Anyone else notice that the tones in this vinyl ripped version seem slightly off? Like the disc is spinning at a very slightly slower speed
Yeah it sounds pretty weird and it's disappointing
Yes! I noticed the same thing!
It sounds totally out of tune. It's awful.
DEFINATELY not the ideal sound, from the album or live is way better. Still hit me right in the feels though.
It's perfect on our end something changed in the rendering or the upload. Not much I can do about it now.
While I don't share your religious ideas, it's awesome to see you react they way you do to Tool, because Tool is an experience, so I guess music unite us all. and now you need to react to Parabol/Parabola
Parabol/Parabola 100% agree
Would have clicked on this even faster if it was parabol/parabola
exactly!
Kapo Himura Makes sense
Agreed
You should be reading Genesis. Nothing then light. Black then white. Random is Chaos. Fibonacci / Golden ratio. Order. Thinking of these things is trying to understand the Divine. Over analysing separates the body from the mind. You can't understand the Depth of these things and still feel human. Try to talk to anyone about the scale of everything and still feel normal.
Pastor Rob is GETTING IT! 😆 You can tell he loved it. So cool seeing peoples reactions to TOOL!
The anticipation making your heart rate is proof that you can literally feel this music in your veins. Perfection 🙌🏼
The Fibonacci Sequence is found in all life. The song is a reflection of our place in the universe and how all things are interrelated.
Pretty much makes the song more genius.
Why am I watching 2 bobble heads on a car dashboard looped on repeat...
Lateralus, one of my all time favorite songs! I literally travel through space, dimensions and time at light speed listening to this. It’s a great voyage musically, lyrically and Maynard’s amazing vocals!
Really liking this idea for a channel. There's a lot of stigma against metal in the Christian community due to the echoes of the old satanic panic. I personally have dropped away from structured religion and churches because of their controlling nature. I can't stand that, but I don't equate them to belief like so many do. Jesus was a nonconformist and broke against the flow and I don't deny him, I just deny the masses that enforce control in his name. My spirituality survives and thrives in its freedom from it.
Amen!!! ♡♡♡♡
O' Father! Artist and Art in heaven,
Hollowed be thy name,
by pontiffs come. THEIR will be done
On Earth, because we let them.
Well said.
ANTi GRAV I’d definitely recommend finding a house church or something a little more modern. There are some great traditional churches but I think most of them are getting old and outdated. I’m not saying to stray from Biblical truth, but tradition is killer. Praying for you, dude. Rock on 🤘🏻
Amen I feel the same exact way! I know not all churches are created equal and a lot of that Satanic references to Metal music came from prominent televangelists in the 80’s. These televangelists were nothing like my actual pastor growing up at church though. With that said though the mass hysteria constantly pumped out by similar televangelists today is why I barely attend church anymore. “It takes just a few bad apples to spoil the whole bunch” is a true statement.
Shout out to Gauge for the Opeth shirt!!
I believe he said its one of his favorite bands, when they reacted to Deliverance
@@lachof OH yeah I remember that now. Wise young man that's forsure.
But where do I get the tulip shirt?
I found you by complete accident, watching Tool Videos, and could not stop watching. As a TOOL fan I love your point of view on the songs, and openness.
This album is a masterpiece period.
People are overthinking and overanalyzing the part "red and yellow then came to be, reaching out to me, lets me see" in my opinion. When a child is first born it sees only in black and white. The next color is red then yellow. If you think about that in the context of the song it makes perfect sense. This represents growth which is a the main theme of the song really, always growing, learning or spiraling out
Totally agree, I interpret that part the same way, for my it makes sense
I'm pretty sure it is meant that way, meaning growth, but the colours weren't chosen at random (I'm pretty sure). Looking at the linguistic origin of colours, as a language we first distinguish black and white (light & dark colours) followed by red as a third and yellow as a fourth. If I'm not mistaken, that's why MJK chose those numbers. (There is an amazing video on yt, I believe by Vox, explaining how colours came to be in languages around the world)
It's a reference to the native American medicine wheel dummies hahaha
A reference to the Kabbalistic tree of life? Keter,Binah, geburah, tiphareth. Check the tarot corespondents. What path is being presented?
Possibly off topic but it's crazy how humans didn't use to see blue
SPIRAL OUT. KEEP GOING.
keep going!
@@kasag37 SPIRAL OUT!!!
@@toolxxx420 keep going.
SPIRAALL OUTTT
I've just listened to Tool live in concert in Italy. It is indeed a spiritual experience, and I say that as a christian.
This song is about not overanalyzing, and it really is exemplified in the first verse. When you're born, you can only see blocky shapes of black and white. Within the first few months, your eyes develop enough to where you can see bright colors, with red being the first one to take shape. The first verse is very, very literal! That's the big hint that most of the lyrics should be taken at face value, especially since they explicitly talk about just enjoying the power of music.
Red is the lowest frequency color, followed by orange, yellow, then all the way up to violet 🌈 discerning higher and higher frequencies of color through ever-developing fresh eyes is literal enlightenment, you can recognize more types of light. And so, it can also be tied metaphorically to developing a greater and greater sense of consciousness.
SCHISM, that's awesome too. Time signature changes 46 times I believe. Nearly the whole song is a measure of 5/8 then a measure of 7/8, back and forth over and over again
NO
Schism is so fucking played out, it's not even good anymore. There are far better songs to review.
If you want time changes, The Dance of Eternity by Dream Theater.
Dennis Crider regardless of how “played out” it is, it’s still a fucking fantastic song. It being “played out” is one of the main reasons I found tool and delved deeper into their discography. And it has a lot of meaning to me, personally. So I don’t see how you deciding it’s overplayed makes the song any less good. That’s the second most hipster thing I’ve read all day.
You guys did an amazing job dissecting this song. I love how deep you went in and how you allowed the song to play it's full 9:42 without interruption. Hats off!
Maynard is an absolute genius! As are Danny, Justin and Adam. Each a master of their craft
The song was not written by chance. Danny Carey is versed in numerology and there are many songs that show the mathematics in the writing process. Maynard adds lyrics after the music is written.
@Michellle Foucault XVI
Parody of Sound Garden?
Fopp
Danny Carey is one full on guy. I think his drum kit is laid out according to sacred geometry too. Dude is 57 and can beat the skins better than anyone.
@Michellle Foucault XVI
Find something new to point your finger at.
To embrace the random means allow yourself to be one with serendipity. The random happenstance of life or “go with the flow.” Rather the try to control everything. To embrace the random is letting yourself go with the flow but not letting yourself go out of control.
chuckiebobphil this is precisely how I see it!
Yeah, exactly what I was thinking. Seemingly random, from our perspective. I don't think it contradicts the pastor's beliefs. Although, I do believe that we all have a spark of divinity.
grave dug I agree about the divinity part too. Not to argue with the pastor, but there are passages in the Bible that say just that, (we are of Christ and Christ is of God) it even says in one passage that we are in spiritual infancy, which is awesome, given the beginning of the song
I agree with chuckie. I'm thinking the spiral of the Fibonacci Sequence is the path of life, and the random events are something that divert this predictable path. I think he was suggesting to embrace that change in our lives.
While I enjoy watching people's reactions to songs, it appears that these two are "overthinking and overanalyzing." Lol
The two things I like the most about Tool: 1. It's an immersive experience. They redefine how rock/metal music is consumed. 2. They make you earn the right to "tap your toe" to their songs. The odd time signatures, and how Danny Carey hides them so well makes you have to listen to it over and over to be able to groove to it. Oh, and don't forget the GONG toward the end!
I have to say that I have received more of a spiritual connection to God through Tool than anything in my life. I saw them at aftershock a few weeks ago. I’m much older now, it took everything I had in me to go because I just was diagnosed with leukemia after I bought the tickets. As a matter of fact the very day after they released Fear Inoculum as a single. That song inspired me to be more positive and to “exhale” and “expel” the “contagion”. At the concert, however, I had tears most of the time. I got right up front and with this diagnosis every word meant something different this time and I have never felt so close to god than when they played Parabol/parabola. It was actually that feeling I always hoped to feel in church but never did. It was overwhelming. I haven’t checked to see if you have reviewed that one yet but if not I hope you do. Also the new album is beautiful perfection.
This album is amazing and I remember losing myself to this entire album back in high school. This is possibly the finest musical composition I’ve experienced and each time I hear this song it gets inside me.
"Kinda moves through you". Very fitting first words!!
Great job pastor. You are reaching a different audience that some of us older people who never tried to understand this type of music
I think he was saying the Fibonacci sequence or the golden ratio is in everything including us. And that it is so unlikely that sacred geometry is a cosmic coincidence. That it must be divine and since it's in everything we are also divine.
Steven Bristol we are divine. As is everything around us.
If you listen to the whole album especially songs like The Patient, and Parabola you see that Maynard is trying to engage in looking towards a higher state of consciousness and reflecting on an overall purpose for living.
Solomon from the bible did that same thing, and his conclusion was that purpose of a man is to eat, drink, be merry and find joy in your work and to fear the Lord.
@skyhigh315 To answer your original question - we should "fear" God in reverence and respect of His holiness. Assuming you believe in an omniscient, omnipotent being, shouldn't that be the case? If you don't believe in one, then it's a moot point and completely understandable that it doesn't make sense. To address your further point, in the original Hebrew this fear isn't meant as a cowering or dread of God, but rather a reverence for His sovereign holiness. Similar to a child fearing and respecting the power of a parent, but not the parent themselves (in a healthy relationship).
Hope that paints a better picture for you.
Once you go flac, you never go back.
🤣
@@roberthoughton7127 It's true lol
@@thehllw I wish I would have thought to say that in the video!
The song lyrics are about embracing the random, and yet the song is beautiful because it is so highly constrained in timing and rhythm and every other way. If you took all the musical instruments and sound equipment used in the song and rolled them down the stairs, no one would get chills listening to the sound they make. The song is a mark of brilliant intelligence. So is the Universe.
I loved watching you guys listen to this! This is one of my favorite tool songs! It takes you for a ride!!
This song would be considered art rock/progressive metal.
Hmm I don't think "art" would apply. I started listening to Rishloo some time ago. They feel more theatrical. Check them out ;)
Btw Rob you look like Justin Chancellor-bassist
alaskantool Bear 🐻 I can see it 😂
@@tf19Twigy gets it.
HA! Spot on!
You get it!
Holy shit. He does! Lmao
I love watching people react to this song because its just gives me more reasons to listen to it.
Father-Son bonding shit is good. I'm glad you guys have this.
This is legit my FAVORITE song. Im so glad you reacted to this.
I have this problem where whichever Tool song I listened to most recently is my favorite song ever.
Francisco d'Anconia tbh same😂
how does one wear an Opeth shirt and not even familiar with Lateralus? i'm confused.
^^^^this^^^^^
cause teen rocker
I got into Opeth way before I found out about Tool so it's possible
arhyth “Man, I love The Beatles, but whose this Led Zeppelin I keep hearing about?”
probably because Opeth didn't write Lateralus? i might be reaching with that one...
Lyrics= Overthinking, over-analyzing separates the body from the mind
Commentary= "I think I hear some flanger/pinch harmonics" etc.
Maynard= **facepalm**
lmfao SO TRUE!
seriously , people just dont understand
Maynard does not face palm. He simply rocks back and forth and gets in the zone.
That's because they keep the lyrical analysis for the end of the video, so as not to stop the song.
You fail to realize Maynard is a troll....
You guys should react The Humbling River by Puscifer. Maynards other band. It's such a powerful song.
Chris Han I agree.
I came to this video to specifically request that, also wouldnt mind a reaction to "count bodies like sheep to the rhythm of the war drum"
Andrew Suplee YESSS!
This
I like a few songs from Puscifer but I found out tool half an hour ago.
Now I'm binge searching reactions to their songs, I had shivers down my spine when I first listened to tool, to be specific it was mother Mary won't you whisper.
Something was wrong with the recording you played. It had a tape warble and flatness (in terms of pitch). Also seems a few bpm slower than normal. In your effort to have ultimate quality (FLAC) you got something far worse somehow.
I noticed that right away.
I heard it too...he said it’s a vinyl rip... turntable just have been set to a little slows or belt needs replacing or off balance.
This is being played through youtube compression
man i thought i was the only one. i think its something on CZcams's end and i doubt they actually ended up with such an atrocious version of the song. at least i hope not lmao
Ughhhh its so gross
I got this CD when it first came out when I was in middle school. 11:47 was my reaction on the back of the bus listening to it with my friends. This album literally birthed my love for metal.
I was first introduced to Tool by the video sober and I've been hooked ever since now that I'm a 60 year old black man I can't help but dust off the first 4 albums of tool and just rock the hell out my top three bands of all time is tool Living Color and Godsmack.
Having a sip of the TOOL-Aid I see
I love the Tool-Aid... Actually... I like the Maynard-Aid, his voice gives me a chills
The colors reference is what an infant sees first in the order he describes. That's why he says in my infancy. Its what most experts believe we see first are those colors.
I think its more about your mind expanding as you age or become enlightened.
I think its way deeper than that, tool's lyrics are rarely taken literally. Early languages could only describe light and dark, or black and white. Later on came red, mostly describing the color of our blood, then yellow came to be, describing the sun. For example blue didnt exist until recent times in vast majority of languages.
@Crooked Chi I dunno bud, you may be over thinking... over analyzing. Black and White are all I see, in my infancy, red and yellow then came to be, reaching out to me, lets me see... Is pretty much a literal description of how sight develops in humans. Now the "infancy" Maynard refers to may be esoteric, but taken with the warning about thinking too much, it's probably ok to take this verse at face value. www.bausch.com/vision-and-age/infant-eyes/eye-development
I think its probably more so like, black and white imply that one is seeing stark differences in things and dividing them. Ie good and evil. Two additional colors are expanding this mindset
Theres also something called “ the great work” which is an alchemical concept. There are four phases which are tied to the colors black -> white -> yellow -> red
sorry but if infants only see a few colours, they'd have something wrong with their eyes. We are not dogs or other animals that can't observe all the colours in the rainbow, only people with colour blindness have that problem, not infants.
Soo nice to see Christians who don't think metal will make you a sadist .
I actually have swing on the spiral of our divinity and still be a human tattooed on my arm.
I have “With my feet upon the ground, I lose myself between the sounds” tattooed in a spiral around my right ankle. It was designed by the guy who did the artwork in the Lord of the Rings trilogy and put on by the guy who gave the tattoos to the actors who comprised the fellowship.
OOMMMGGG I've watching reactions to Tool songs because I'm dying from impatienceeeeeeeeeeeee. They're coming out with a new album any second now!
yep! got some tabs stashed. i'm F''N ready bro!!!!! :)
Wait it out... Be patieeeeeent
@@lxllipop. I don't want it... I JUST NEED IT! To breathe, to feel, to know I'm alive.
2 weeks later
Or not haha!
Minute 7:22(of the actual song) never fails to bring a tear to my eye and put a giant smile on my face. It’s exciting to see someone experience that moment for the first time.
They never should’ve abandoned this one as their show closer.
Pastor Rob, you're awesome. It's so great to see a man of faith with a such an open mind.
The "horns" are innocuous, by the way. Ronnie James Dio popularized that gesture in the metal community long ago. I saw him on VH1 explaining it, it was his Italian grandmother's superstitious gesture to ward off evil. So ironically, what has come to be known as devil horns are actually the complete opposite...
Wow