A Bitter Rivalry | The Island with Bear Grylls | Season 2 Episode 3 | Full Episode
Vložit
- čas přidán 17. 06. 2023
- The Men's Island:
The men have barely slept or had a real meal since landing. And a bitter rivalry between the island's two builders, Paul and Andy, has turned into all-out war.
#TheIslandWithBearGrylls
Bear takes a group of contestants to a remote island with the goal of surviving The Island.
Subscribe: / @theislandwithbeargrylls
All Content Distributed via Banijay Rights - Zábava
![Eminem - Houdini [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/22tVWwmTie8/mqdefault.jpg)
Everyone is talking about Andy and Paul, but no one is talking about Barney, who saved the guy who was gonna get pulled in by the wave and he brought home the iguana. Even executed it himself. A gigachad.
I've only watched the 3 episodes so far but Barney is by far my favourite
L camera man lost the camera
He’s a paramedic, hard as nails and calm as fuck. True hero
Facts
@@mark22377 atleast he didnt lose his life too
Andy isn’t a builder he puts Ikea furniture together 😂
lolll😁
He's a softee
I laughed when he said that...
A professional manual reader
"Forget it We're not eating bats" For some reason I felt so relieved 😅
Cough Wuhan cough
@@DYeTrYn6988came from a lab funded by American Tax money courtesy of ouchie Fauchi, think we can put that wet market bullshit to rest now yeh?
E Bola ...no
Aids ...no
forgot to mention rabies.
Covid came from Wuhan.
@@user-wm3bf7pi3u Covid also😅
their biggest mistake was letting the other builder go. He was way more dedicated, more commited and the only reason he left was this old man complaining all the time
The other guy was being a man-child too. It's obvious he wants to be the alpha and he can't take it when someone else annoys him slightly. He's also not a good person to have around, especially when things get tougher. He'd be the first to curse at everyone else but himself when things get dire.
Not even close Pedro.
Paul was a typical site manager, shouting orders around, trying to elect himself as a leader, without carrying any weight of his own. He did fuck all about from boss other people about as soon as they got off the boat. Typical, loud mouth, fuckwhit site manager 😂
It seemed like the other guys wanted everyone to defend him and pick him which is just as childish if not more.
I, respectfully, disagree. Their biggest mistake was signing up.
BS. He wanted to leave the second he found out that he couldn't be McDonalds ordered. That fat prick had 1 hard day of work and packed it in. Even when he was told the older fella was leaving he still wanted to leave. He had no intention of staying.
"The dogs *know* I'm in charge, my wife *lets me think* I'm in charge and my children look up to me *as if* I'm in charge" true alpha
Cleaning Facilities Manager too be careful, he IS a true alpha
well hes at least honest about it :p
The fact that he joked about it gives him chad energy.
Excellent man, that's a beautiful relationship
😂
andy is such a baby, first saying that he's leaving even if paul leaves and then saying im def gonna make 6 weeks. what a manchild
to the surprise of no one tho. The first night he split from the group, it was pretty obvious he wants to go home and is just using paul as an excuse
What a malcontent child that Andy was. Giving a million excuses while all are looking for one solution.
The group will be far better off without him.
Agreed, he did nothing but complain about the conditions they were all experiencing and was butthurt when his blatantly poor choice for a base camp was rejected. The boys genuinely seem happier without him.
He was still 100x more valuable than the wuss who'd rather have a candlelight dinner and a glass of wine 😂
i hope he suffers, annoying grandpa
He was very annoying how he made a actually valuble person leave because of himself saying he wont leave then left after anyways even tho they made him his own bed and everything.
@@Dom-jf7gf i know, he pissed me the f off. should’ve put a scorpion in his pants
Barney talking about how his friends having iguanas after chopping the head off of an iguana got me😂😂😂😂
Same bro hahahaha q
Bro, u dont know how happy i was when Barny became the men of the horde, by practically feeding the tribe
What a guy. He was genuinely feeling so depressed and then he just got a little hope and it gave him so much confidence and development. I really think he became more masculine by doing so. Props to him, what a guy.
From the second day where Andy decided to stay all daylight sleeping alone he should have been gone, meanwhile Paul was helping organize and being a decent leader. These guys dont know loyalty.
But he stepped out as soon as someone disagreed with him. He was not better than the other guy.
@@julicor98 Yeah, Paul was behaving like a man-child too. He wants to be the alpha and can't stand anyone who slightly annoys him. He won't be a nice guy to have around when things get tougher.
Just in case you forgot, Paul became so whiny too when Andy was presenting confounding statements. He could’ve manned up and stayed determined to help the guys out if he truly were the leader you’re making him out to be, but he isn’t. There’s no doubt Paul would’ve been a lot more useful, but if you can’t handle opposition and just throw the towel at the slightest hint of it, you’re no better than the troublemaker.
You speak like they didn't try to stop him leaving
Neither were confident leaders.
Even Andy knew that the guys made a big mistake counting on him, and letting Paul go.
I don’t think they did. Paul gave up as soon as things got difficult.
@@aaronbutler8061 Paul was the trailblazer and a leader, however a bit stubborn and headstrong he might've been.
Andy was just there whining about comfy beds and restful nights while nobody else even gets it.
@@marion_soda777 Agreed. Both gave up when things actually got tough. I wonder how things would have been if they couldn’t have gotten a ride out.
@@aaronbutler8061 No, I disagreed with you and pointed out who's better as a survivor.
Paul didn't gave up. He left because he felt unwanted. Andy did even after everything the party had done FOR him.
@@marion_soda777 Paul threw a tantrum and bitched out because he couldn’t handle disagreement.
Vic
-Comes on the island with a high morale
-Raises the morale of others
-Personal arguments are ended by him easily
-Makes jokes about "alpha male"
-Has actual good ideas
Absolute fucking chad
NO. He's just a highly insecure beta that feels like he has to DECLARE himself one. He is in reality, quite weak. a TRUE Chad would have obtained food after 2 or 3 days, TOPS. Insane how the internet has made weak men look impressive to other, weaker men. There is truly an epidemic of low-T men in the west, today.
Never underestimate the straight-forward, 'simple' men, who don't overthink this. That is why whenever I say that a particular man is 'simple', by that is far away meant from being an 'insult'.
Proper Yorkshire boyo top banana!!! 🤍💙💛💙🤍
I love Vic’s positivity always boosting moral even in the hardest situations
I built a shelter in the red woods with a group of strangers who were homeless drifters like myself. We lived in it during an intense 4 day rainstorm. We rebuilt a shelter as a group after day one improved it and moved locations and never were at each others throats even once, even found another guy in the woods and had him stay with us too.We all became like family in just a couple of days.
I think the first people just made excuses why they left. If it was a real life or death situation, they would have been forced to stick it out and grow it to stronger men. It's truly 99% mental.
Yeah they had it hard like everyone else. Paul got irritated by Andy so he left. The other guy left for no reason
That's the issue with this show. Everyone knows the option to leave is always there. In a real survival situation that's not something anyone can just fall back on and of course that knowledge is in the back of everyone's minds when things start to get ugly. I think if they were not able to jump ship, the psychology of the whole endeavour would have been different. When you know you have no choice but to cooperate, you find a way.
Oh yeah definitely, this is a TV show that's why. I'm not familiar with Bear Grylls but I'm pretty sure it's supposed to be more entertainment than it is education. Issa drama.
I mean you can’t force anyone to stay unfortunately… my wife taught me that. And you would be better off with people who WANT TO BE THERE anyway. But yeah in a surgical situation with no way out you learn to cope and solve the issues. We’re literally seeing the issues of a civilized life Play out here. Whenever you’re bored or don’t like something they jump ship! 😢
its also different when you are being symbolically judged at every angle by cameras on you that you know millions of people will watch. its different when you are actually naturally roughing it with no judgement
Them: "There's nothing to eat"
Meanwhile: fully grown coconut trees behind them
Fun fact, and correct me if I'm wrong, but a lot of the coconut trees that grow on islands aren't good for you, they give you the runs. Now saying this, I don't know mu coconut enough to say if it's good to eat or not, but I'd say they did the right thing.
@@51anomalies54 All coconuts are good to eat. Unless you're picking up the rotten ones on the ground. There are many island nations that export coconuts.
@@geneil26 if you eat and drink too much they can give you the runs
@@briton3851 Anything will if you ingest it too much.
What did Andy even actually do? Praised for his building background, but was a net-negative every day.
Exactly they said he was valuable as a builder but I don’t remember him building anything?😂
"He's a builder by trade, he could shortcut so many of our processes" - Phil
Hasn't been a great help shortcutting anything so far, has he? As in, other than driving a more motivated chap off the island and wasting another guy's valuable hands building him his stupid bed when he could have done something actually productive.
He helped construct a pretty good quality bed
So he can sleep while everyone else worked
I knew from the start Andy just wanted Paul to leave. He was never going to stay himself he did everyone so dirty. Paul was so dedicated and hard working.
He was useful but still equally a problem with his behavior
Nah Paul was a fuckwit as well. Knew it from the start when they traversed the jungle. He led the way and carried NOTHING. He's a fuckwit and Andy is a fucking baby
@cy-taku3952 I'd rather have a useful egoistic man-child over a useless egoistic man-child anytime.
@@cy-taku3952To be frank, he would have been less problematic without a 51 year-old complaining manchild. Two days he spent doing fuck all. Everyone would be pissed if a twat like that said “Yeah if he leaves I’m staying”. He did jack shit all along, and got pissy when Paul asked him a question. If you can’t handle living without all the comforts of modern city life, don’t sign up for this.
In ancient times, disputes would have been settled with a big rock to the dome when your enemy was sleeping. They're lucky they have the option of leaving.
they know they are being filmed. Assholes end up underground in real situations ... later on they will send a woman to men's cap. In a real scenario you know the unhappy ending
But Andy never slept.
Paul had such a nice energy around him, strong.. wel spoken, entertaining. so sad to see him go on the first episode and don't have more footage of him in the group.
Why Paul felt scapegoat all of the sudden?
What a man child being all rude saying " ID LIKE A BOAT HERE NOW OVER AND OUT BYE " and he made an actually valuable person leave the island.
12:23 - "A deaf man could hear us coming" hahaha🤣🤣🤣
I love that. Barney stays so positive through all this.
I know plenty of 60+ men that would thrive on this Island. This "Builder Andy" was just not cut out for it.
Calling his self a builder but all he can do is talk and complain
@@kingmacapagal8127 He's a builder in minecraft.
My grandfather would have been fine at Andy’s age.
Andy = Trash
Paul = Unpolished diamond
Andy = crybaby
Paul = pussy
Joe = useless
The minute he pushed them to make it to the beach, he had my support. He’s probably watching it and was fuming when Andy left.
Andy justa childish man
Have to disagree on Paul. He got threatened into leaving so easily. "I don't want to be responsible for Andy leaving" my ass. Grow a pair and stand your ground. Not to mention that he is loud, though that is a personal issue nothing more. Credit where credit is due. His pushy and loud character was helpful putting some haste into the group reaching the beach though, definitely did his part that day. I think Paul would have been great if he'd know when to shut up, swallow his pride, and not let other's remarks influence him so much.
I agree that so far Andy is not worth anything. Will have to see the next episodes if changes or not.
Edit: didn't even make the end of this episode, what a waste of time.
@@ruud9761 Two little boys with way too fragile egos.
The biggest problem they had was leadership.
A good leader was to send off the old builder n stayed with the site manager
No way, i was giving some break for andy sincr he was 51 years old, but this other dude is 58 and have not complained at all
season 1 guys were hard AF compared to these guys lol
Who is 58?
@@OfficialDenzy I believe it's Phil.
@@karthus006phil is cool asf
@@Big_Red_Wadeseason 1 guys didnt get rained on daily, i dont think it ever rained in the month they were there; they slept out in the open first few weeks. They would've had mental breakdowns if they did.
Andy was a cry baby. Paul got them to the beach. Paul also was doing what was needed for the sake of the team. The team babied Andy and got what Paul told them they'd get.
All that physical labor and Andy can’t get a good night sleep 😂
he was up thinking though...
One thing I have noticed from this season and season three is when someone gets hurt, mother nature brings forth some food! I see now why indigenous tribes used to give sacrifices. They surely noticed the pattern.
Btw, Andy was not a builder! Maybe a Lego builder!!! He let it slip that people call him to build their IKEA furniture... Hahaha. When he was bragging and basically trying to give his building credentials. Hahaha yah
Or maybe the show is edited for maximum drama.
Was Andy 51 years old? Im 46 and that dude looks like hes 71 years old. Makes me feel like i have done well in my life. Im in much better shape. I want to do this! if i fail i fail but i so want to try this. Get away from social media. Get away from bills. Get away from dumb bs that we stress about. Have some real things to stress about. Food and water. Shelter. Thats real worry. We could all do some good going back to the basics for a little while and realize how lucky we are. They have the ocean right there full of food. id be trying to catch fish like some sea mammals do. They push the fish towards the shore by surrounding them. they have enough people they can do it. They had basic fishing gear i thought they said. Yet i havent seen anyone break any out yet. They need food bad. If they can gt some food they will start to feel better. Become more positive. This is good to watch. To see how men are tested. And how one day we may be tested. Im a fan pf the dad. His attitude is what is needed more than anything else at the moment. im only in the 3rd episode here so i dont know much yet. they haven't eaten anything yet. But i feel like barney is going to come trough with food.
Okay
I agree
"Can we eat bats or it's what's gives you HIV" lol I love this guy!
I think it gives you covid?
He's asking the right questions 😂
He has his prioritys :]
lather hiv than starve
would of loved to have said gives you more then that
18:20 lmaoo covid could have hit us earlier actually. He saved us that day 🤣🤣
They needed to start working in shifts. It doesn't take ALL of you to keep a fire burning, so work in pairs and allow for sleep, admin and eating / hunting.
Why would 11 guys go hunting with only one spear ? Why would you build a shelter of palm fronds with a flat roof ? Water only runs down hill. Even the " builder" has no clue about watershed.
Sadly they didn’t have a true leader. You got to be able to take in everyone opinion and ideas, be charismatic, organized, and decisive. You also can never lose your cool. Especially in a survival situation with no one having any real survival skills
The old man pestered Paul so much, he left. He was the real leader of the group; decisive, strong, tough, meanwhile the old man wished to doze off and complain when things didn't go his way. He never should have come on the trip because he wasn't committed. He is an old man who is bored and lazy.
@Aarav.B yeah but paul folded too easily thats the point. So he is almost equally stupid
Kinda, but no - the leader listens all the opinions presented, discusses the options with the team and then makes a final decision where the group's direction is going. Once it's decided, no more discussions on the matter - time of chat is over, action time! Only decision implementation related tips and criticisms are accepted. And if someone steps out of line you talk with them first, but if it continues to repeat - you get rid of them, as they're not only undermining your authority, but also decreasing efficiency and morale of an entire group.
Especially in such a survival conditions - these are the grown-ass men on uninhabited island and not some drama queens at kindergarten for everyone to tip-toe around. ABC of organizational behavior (and common sense I would add - you don't need a degree to know all this).
"That's what British courage is." what a load of bollocks 🤣
Who ells just skipped the women's episode i did.
I did without thinking twice
@@ndikabrian4689 yea the most entertaining part with the woman is watching them be as dumb as possible
Me!!!
wait! what? there is a women's ep???
Every other ep is on the women
12:33 Love how he made the other builder leave so he would stay and already thinks about leaving again.
Men Week 1: Found beach, made fire, purified water, built shelter, but three have already left and they are starving, but by the end of it, they found and ate an iguana.
Dude was like, “Didn’t something bad happen with bats awhile back?” 😂
Paramedic got the same energy as Private from penguins of Madagascar
These scorpions can kill a man! Medics - you'll be fine just keep us updated. Haha
“They can give you HIV, forget it we not eating Bats” 😭😂😂 that scene was funny !
everyone else: if you get a good nights sleep you stay
andy: ya
everyone else: time to go to sleep
andy: i dont wanna
He got the best bed too
i found this and started binge watching it so good content
I really am wishing I can try these adventurous moments! one fine day. I'd say these people are very brave enough despite the bitterness surrounding them, the acts portrayed those qualities and abilities we can still bring up in our harshness. Breathtaking journey it is👍
Andy wasn't worth trying to get to stay, he will complain all along and just leave anyway when the next time comes he doesn't get his way. Know his type.
I should have seen the episode before commenting.
So ur not stupid then good,pual would just say fuckit and keep it pushingn
I know this isn't in any way similar, but I feel the galvanization motive is deeply personal. I went through basic training in the US military. I went in older than most, and I liked my personal comforts. When I started to falter, the others seemed to write me off. So I bounced back and doubled down. I completed basic and was recognized by my peers as the best leader. I was told that the men thought that I was done for. My own drill sergeant thought I was a wash out. Being able to push through is a tremendous boost to morale no matter the circumstances.
Marine corps 5 years now as an officer. I can say the older enlisted have always been more successful. Sometimes, being a bit more mature comes a long way. Your focus is sharpened, and you make better decisions.
18:24 "Can we eat bats?" Huh where have I heard that before.
Big boy left because he couldn't boss everyone about. Loved it when the other fella said step back and talk over there. Brilliant top boy x
WHY AREN’T THEY EATING THE FRIKIN CRABS
That's what im sayin!!! And the coconuts
Barney is da man. Looking forward to a hero/leader character arc.
24:13 we have scorpions in Oklahoma USA, except ours are a little lighter in color. My first time being stung... it was Saturday, a sleep in day. I was 16. I woke up at 7am thinking my sack was caught on a spring or something. I reached down expecting to be caught up.. nothing but a sharp burning sensation exactly like a bee sting. I rolled over & pushed my covers off me slowly. Then I felt a sting on my foot. I picked the blanket up & seen the scorpion.
Barney really made his goal true “come out of this island more macho” or he said mature.. I’m not british either way he became giga chad
I love it when Bear gets into the psychology of survival.
Andy shouldnt even be called a "Builder" mf assembles stuff and thinks thats building. Carpentry, Masonry, Etc. THATS building. They should backed paul up. Id trust him before the guy that says "people call me to assemble stuff"
Avengers - ASSEMBLE!
i had to watch him catch that iguana at least four times he was so happy and proud of himself
Andy just wanted to be a leader then when he got his chance he realized he wasn’t a leader
16:40 Will is a fuckin champ of a teammate. Andy is bitching even tho everyone is in a bad-miserable state.
Even then he sees you're down, listens and tries to find solutions/get your mind off the problems
Im convinced these 2 never knew about a thing called tide
I do feel like in a situation like this, you cannot waste a single ounce of energy trying to get people to stick around or get motivated to work. Either they're committed to the group's survival or they should be cut loose. You shouldn't have to convince anyone to stick around. It seems like half of their energy is spent dealing with drama. I'd rather work with 7 out of 14 highly motivated individuals only than deal with the emotional drain of the remaining ones. This should've been one of the first rules set after they introduced themselves. Guys like Paul, Andy, and the kid should've been left behind as soon as they introduced discontent. Fear and negativity spreads like a disease, and these guys are patients zero.
you're grossly undervaluing just having more hands.
like said, having more people allows them to do 7 instead of 6 things at a time
its a %s game, less people = more chance to die
This a very good lesson in our life
Andy is the oldest and yet the biggest child forgot his name but what an absolute legend the guy was that helped him build a bed and tried to cheer him up
Paul is a born leader,he shouldn't have left. Some people didn't want to cooperate with him because they think they can lead better, we will see...
Naah Vic was a better leader. Paul was controlling had had trouble listening to other people
Salute to Barney.. He had the spirit of a survivor and I really admire the way he is trying to make everything seem like a normal tour. ❤ Respect
if there is a cocnut tree nearby .. im sure they can expand their food,..if the they run out of coconut fruit ..they can cut down small coconut trees and shave all the cocnut branches and remove all the branches till they can get to the very fetus of the coconute tree..... which very tasty and can provide them a very thick cocnut meat and juice inside the size of it is almost like a mini log in size...........it could supplement them with potassium and protein..... also they can make a net out of the coconut tree leaves branches if they can knit them properly and catch fish..
.....
23:40 I have been sting by a scorpion when I did my Ranger training. They have neurotoxin, it left my hand numb for 3 days, and that poison feels like a hundred needles moving through your arm.
He saved my life! Now i am saving his. Awesome. Being on a low like that is dangerous for the whole group. Being in a good mental position is the only way you can survive.
my man VIc is TOTALLY THE ALPHA LMFAO
THIS MAN IS A PRIME
shouldve kept and defended paul and said byebye to andy lmao what a grave mistake
29:30 The wave was knee height if we being real...
18:20 china :note that down note that dow
"I'll have you tied to a tree before you F@#!$ng go" 💀💀💀💀🤣🤣🤣🤣 W Men
“Huge wave probably about 10 feet” dude it was up to y’all’s waist 😂😂😂
26:05 I dont want to be 'that' guy but he could've done a lot of helpful things whilst sitting/laying down. Things as untangling fishnets, just do stuff by the fire (keep the containers in check whilst they're boiling the water), making cords, one guy bringing trees and him cutting them to the point they could be used in future shelters, making woven roof out of palm leafs or baskets which could hold crabs. One of the guys just had to bring him something to do and he could've been productive
Give him some slacks man.. he was stuck by a freaking scorpion🤣
Eating Bats - sure what could go Wrong :D
Nothing stupid for not eating them and what you’re getting at is Covid and Covid is man made it did not come from bats that’s already been proven
Insert 2020 joke here:
2024 and you still don’t know it was from a lab 😂
That shelter is like childs play.
Keeping Andy over the the other builder was a mistake. From day one Andy was put off that they were leaving him behind when they were cutting through the forest and that along with his personality has made him very resentful of the group from the start. You then take into account the other builders natural tendency to lead lead or take charge, and Andy's age.... It just seems like the other guy would have been a much better person to keep then Andy.
And with this, people must learn that those who cannot work together as a group give up easily. War is only for tough guys.
“Hard hearts win battles.”
the alpha male description is so funny xD
back wit the boyyys 💪💪 🦍🦍
As a chef it hurt watching him sharpen the machete like that.
A machete isn’t a kitchen knife thho
@@bruhtnt4258So, because it's not that, it's okay to not take proper care of your tools? What kinda reality-removed armchair-machoing is this?
when i’m watching this show my commentary becomes British. whenever that guy was comforting andy i was like “good on ya mate” like ?
its weird how so many of these guys want to quit in this survival show.. i feel like that in normal life.. struggling to survive.. feeling like i want to quit... although weirdly.. when ive travelled the world, and mountain climbed to 6088m and lived in poor villages etc with basic stuff, ive often felt stronger and more motivated...
A constant state of problem solving. Where our brains are happiest
I think it looks fun on TV, but when you're there and have to drink dirty water, eat nasty food, and be food formillions of mosquitos and dontseeums, it's time to go.
Bear just called old egoist dude a negative influence 😂
Too bad Paul left. It is great to see the group work better together noe
Why is noone looking in the pools in the rocks In the mornings and evenings like crabs oysters muscles thst literally live on the rocks they all sit on and walk around like midday go stand out in the sand and dig yiur feet in the sand you will find dozens of pipis, see a tiny hole dig it out thats a razor clam they are starving unnecessarily, rhey are also surrounded by insects
Strength of mind is the only true strength.
The show couldn't spring for go pro head mounted cameras?
They have a few, how do you think Barney was able to use both his hands and film?
I dont care about paul and andy, those type of people gonna exist, and its canonically important for the whole team as well, it shows and makes people realised things.
But what i care the most is how positive the others are, man like Barney, Vics, and everyone, contributes to those teams.
What we're actually pissed off about andy is not because he was leaving but he potentially kicked paul off in the first place with his attitude(regardless of what paul is words matter and what paul accused andy was he wanted paul to leave from get go which from the screen time andy is kind of person to say shit like that). Now collectively they're 2 man down because of one man's attitude. Paul might have been moody guy but was doing enough to show he was capable and has the mental capacity to work for the team.
What a group of Divas
12:23 'A deaf man could hear us coming' 😂😂😂
When they said could we eat bats oh if they only knew what they could have brought back in their time 18:18
I would cry if I had to go to Centre parks
"Can we eat bats?" ...... That will give you HIV and Ebola and all sort of things. This cracked me up really hard🤣🤣🤣
If that guy is having second thoughts about killing the iguana, he isn’t that hungry
Isnt the paramedic guy (Barney) in the film Predators? Film where they are sent to the small planet preadtors use for hunting.
Well it was clear from the beginning that andy did not had it in him to do it. And he was ashamed of that so he said "Im leaving cause of paul". Now hes leaving anyway. But also Paul shouldnt have left. If he werent so lets say "emotionally numb" he could´ve maybe see through andys fassade. Well. Also someone could have told him. But nobody did. And that has a reason too. Very interesting haha
They really need to take the rain water for hydration
They are just not very efficiently XD
They using a leaf funnel on the jerry can XD
Horrible design if you ask me
But that rainwater will have all the detritus (think bird poop, iguana poop, crab poop) of the leaves it flowed over to get into the can. It still needs either boiling or filtration of both.