5 Npc you should always kill

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 12. 05. 2023
  • #reddeadredemption #reddeadredemtion2
    rdr2 edits
  • Hry

Komentáře • 4,5K

  • @bennyindawall
    @bennyindawall Před rokem +25093

    Number 6: literally any NPC that says anything remotely rude to me ever

    • @TacitusKilgore12
      @TacitusKilgore12 Před 11 měsíci +1071

      I had this one npc, super nice, he kept saying how he is placing his trust in me and let me use his fire. But right before I saw him I kill a whole lot on the road, and as I was talking to him, I saw a couple more NPCs become witnesses, I ended up killing them, then I accidentally killed the nice one and now live with guilt

    • @bennyindawall
      @bennyindawall Před 11 měsíci +188

      @@TacitusKilgore12 pain

    • @IMVERYHAPPY1
      @IMVERYHAPPY1 Před 11 měsíci +91

      @@TacitusKilgore12Skill Issue

    • @rj26216
      @rj26216 Před 11 měsíci +142

      @@TacitusKilgore12that’s when you just restart the game

    • @NicholasT588
      @NicholasT588 Před 11 měsíci +140

      I am very much a high honor type of guy, but if you insult my legendary bear hat youre getting my shotgun to the face

  • @thatbloomer5642
    @thatbloomer5642 Před rokem +14983

    Swamp weirdo: "oh hey there.."
    *headshot*
    *lose honor*
    "Worth it."

    • @marcocivalerian9099
      @marcocivalerian9099 Před rokem +474

      you lose honor for killing him?? Wtf rockstar

    • @no_one499
      @no_one499 Před rokem

      ​@@marcocivalerian9099you just lose honor if you kill him before he rapes you

    • @Twister_1996
      @Twister_1996 Před rokem +807

      @@marcocivalerian9099that’s before afterwards you don’t lose honor

    • @rashidrashidaziz3324
      @rashidrashidaziz3324 Před rokem +204

      Na bro just throw a dynamite and than enjoy the VIEW

    • @hugabuga5909
      @hugabuga5909 Před rokem +196

      Neck shots better. Let him suffer

  • @andreavdalyan8626
    @andreavdalyan8626 Před 4 měsíci +3165

    Number 6: anyone at a campsite that says “that’s what I thought” after you defused and left their camp.

    • @ayejason6408
      @ayejason6408 Před 3 měsíci +136

      or the ones on horses that ride by you and the road and start shit for no reason 😂

    • @lukedobbins8245
      @lukedobbins8245 Před 3 měsíci

      @@ayejason6408real

    • @eduardoribeiro6734
      @eduardoribeiro6734 Před 3 měsíci

      @@ayejason6408Jesus, that really pisses me off. Like I’m just minding my own business hunting some ducks, then all of a sudden two hillbilly asshats on horse back ride past and say something like “you best get the hell away from me” you know it’s killing time.

    • @duckonquack1133
      @duckonquack1133 Před 3 měsíci +76

      ​@@ayejason6408 yeah, you can be riding slow and they pass by and say something like "there's plenty of road space, I sUgGesT YouU uSE iT"

    • @DonkeyDickDev
      @DonkeyDickDev Před 2 měsíci

      Or the ones where you help them then they say “took your time”

  • @itsmeeEnder
    @itsmeeEnder Před 6 měsíci +985

    6 : those saint dennis kids

  • @bigbio4286
    @bigbio4286 Před rokem +8215

    Don’t kill raccoon guy, if you beat him up take his hat every time you go in the saloon with his hat on he’ll try to fight and it’s fun

    • @Syte425
      @Syte425 Před 11 měsíci +695

      I rode to valentine and went in the saloon after being far into the game. Walked in and he was in there without the hat (I beat em up and took it early on)
      I ran outside and equipped the hat went back in and soon as he saw me it was on🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @joehanz9217
      @joehanz9217 Před 11 měsíci +186

      I didn't kill him, the Bartender shoot him dead, (im using raccoon guy as meat shield, after doing binoculars glitch to bartender)

    • @cliphahafunny
      @cliphahafunny Před 11 měsíci +48

      @@joehanz9217 the bartender has a gun?

    • @joehanz9217
      @joehanz9217 Před 11 měsíci +43

      @@cliphahafunny *sawed off shotgun

    • @cliphahafunny
      @cliphahafunny Před 11 měsíci +85

      @@joehanz9217 which is a gun

  • @ahme.ddhany
    @ahme.ddhany Před rokem +9034

    Nobody's more deserving of it than charlotte's stalker.

    • @Osama_beenballin911
      @Osama_beenballin911 Před rokem +207

      I can never find him

    • @ArkayaStudios
      @ArkayaStudios Před rokem +326

      ​@@Osama_beenballin911I think he can spawn anywhere

    • @BillyLoo67
      @BillyLoo67 Před rokem +50

      who?

    • @rajugupta_007
      @rajugupta_007 Před rokem +88

      who is charlotte's stalker ??

    • @Osama_beenballin911
      @Osama_beenballin911 Před rokem +544

      @@rajugupta_007 there’s this guy you can find at a campsite with a tent set up with a bunch of pictures of her I never found him just seen a few videos about him

  • @Manudyne
    @Manudyne Před 6 měsíci +196

    Me: "Howdy partner 🤠"
    NPC in his tent: "You should not be here" 😡
    Me: 🗿 🧨

    • @crappyPatty235
      @crappyPatty235 Před 23 dny +3

      NPC: I wish I had a horse like that,
      Me: yeah? [Proceeds to throw Viking axe to his skull] wish no more my friend, wish no more 🪓🗿

    • @Manudyne
      @Manudyne Před 23 dny

      @@crappyPatty235 nice

  • @WillyTeach
    @WillyTeach Před 6 měsíci +894

    There's also that guy and his sister/wife who invite you into their home and try to take advantage of you.

    • @nobody-yk2hu
      @nobody-yk2hu Před 6 měsíci +79

      Pretty sure this is well known but you can use that encounter to get Arthur's money as John

    • @meredithmorgan3383
      @meredithmorgan3383 Před 5 měsíci +24

      The Aberdeen siblings

    • @janelian1324
      @janelian1324 Před 5 měsíci +25

      ​@@nobody-yk2huyou can get the money back as arthur💀 and in the back room there is like 80$ extra

    • @nobody-yk2hu
      @nobody-yk2hu Před 5 měsíci +27

      @@janelian1324 I know that but since Arthur dies and loses all the money the player made up to that point it's better to leave it for John

    • @janelian1324
      @janelian1324 Před 5 měsíci +2

      @@nobody-yk2hu its just better to get them back at the same moment as arthur

  • @joshuaking3731
    @joshuaking3731 Před 11 měsíci +7979

    I never kill the clan members. They usually kill themselves in either more ironic or embarasing ways than I ever could.

    • @mitchellreineke3024
      @mitchellreineke3024 Před 11 měsíci +702

      True, theres a couple events with them and their incompetence is always hilarious

    • @ayeronwhodis
      @ayeronwhodis Před 11 měsíci +306

      There’s always stragglers for you to kill tho

    • @Vloakanio
      @Vloakanio Před 11 měsíci +456

      @@mitchellreineke3024i remember one where they were trying to put a cross up a shot up in the air and they got scared and dropped the cross on themselves 🤣

    • @BURDENOH
      @BURDENOH Před 11 měsíci +186

      @@VloakanioI just had that happen in my game a few days ago! Two dudes in white were putting up a cross while the grand dragon watched. The cross fell and killed the two dudes in white, and the dude in the black was all sad and shit.

    • @dant3838
      @dant3838 Před 10 měsíci +23

      dangit i killed them i didnt know this

  • @ColonelStickman
    @ColonelStickman Před 11 měsíci +4743

    honorable mention - that guy who slaps his horse when he loses the race

    • @cliphahafunny
      @cliphahafunny Před 11 měsíci +83

      YES

    • @srgergelim7297
      @srgergelim7297 Před 11 měsíci +375

      Chances are he'll ask for another race after a few days in the game, if you win again he'll kill the horse. You have to be quick to kill him.

    • @foxguy1590
      @foxguy1590 Před 11 měsíci +58

      He also shoots it, I believe

    • @PfeiferHollz
      @PfeiferHollz Před 10 měsíci +41

      Oh my god I shot him so fast

    • @TheOldMan-75
      @TheOldMan-75 Před 9 měsíci

      Yeah, just did that a couple of days ago. Fuck that guy

  • @VladamirInhaler
    @VladamirInhaler Před 6 měsíci +668

    Why the actual fuck would anyone kill Grizzled Jon, when it's SO MUCH more fun to antagonise him by wearing his hat in the Saloon?

    • @Randallcatmorganplays
      @Randallcatmorganplays Před 3 měsíci +4

      NOOO IM SI LATE TO READ THE COMMENTD I KILLED HIMM😢😢😢

    • @Hurricane-428-11
      @Hurricane-428-11 Před 3 měsíci

      @@Randallcatmorganplays me 2 :(

    • @Ex-memegodita
      @Ex-memegodita Před 2 měsíci +7

      Somehow sometimes he respawns​@@Randallcatmorganplays

    • @Angus-wt1qw
      @Angus-wt1qw Před měsícem

      Ikr

    • @McNuggins
      @McNuggins Před měsícem

      ​@Ex-memegodita back in them days, when men were MEN, people died all the time, but just cause you got yourself dead doesn't mean you get to slack of your chores and sich!

  • @PrinceDuarteOfTheSacredKnights
    @PrinceDuarteOfTheSacredKnights Před 7 měsíci +78

    Number 6: Literally Any Bounty Hunter

  • @TrainedArcTrooper
    @TrainedArcTrooper Před 11 měsíci +3175

    The NPC that tells you to back off after you run around his camp

    • @clef9883
      @clef9883 Před 10 měsíci +84

      It’s his camp idk why you gotta shoot him it’s his property not yours

    • @TrainedArcTrooper
      @TrainedArcTrooper Před 10 měsíci +32

      @@clef9883 it was a joke

    • @TrainedArcTrooper
      @TrainedArcTrooper Před 10 měsíci +15

      @@LadyEvil. yes, or throw them into a waterfall

    • @rhysabbasi9682
      @rhysabbasi9682 Před 7 měsíci +55

      @@clef9883it is not his property

    • @dje3.16
      @dje3.16 Před 7 měsíci

      @@clef9883and it’s my game that I bought for 50 bucks so fair square

  • @SZpotol
    @SZpotol Před 8 měsíci +4847

    Number 1 : Micah
    Number 2 : Micah
    Number 3 : Micah
    Number 4 : Micah
    Number 5 : Micah

    • @ChristianAlvarado-tz3er
      @ChristianAlvarado-tz3er Před 7 měsíci +17

      Lol

    • @user-co9gz4nc8g
      @user-co9gz4nc8g Před 6 měsíci +60

      I don't get why people hate Micah 😂
      Edit : This is probably my most hated comment.

    • @Deezisnotsfree
      @Deezisnotsfree Před 6 měsíci +165

      @@user-co9gz4nc8gbro?? Have you finished the game??

    • @UhhZane_
      @UhhZane_ Před 6 měsíci +70

      @@user-co9gz4nc8gso you didn’t finish the game… lol

    • @user-co9gz4nc8g
      @user-co9gz4nc8g Před 6 měsíci +17

      @@UhhZane_ I did but I didn't get attached to Arthur

  • @giovannibrooks9354
    @giovannibrooks9354 Před 5 měsíci +51

    Another honorable mention: The man who kills his horse with a knife in Saint Denis

    • @Benijizer
      @Benijizer Před 5 měsíci +22

      In nearly one and half thousand hours of gameplay I don’t think I’ve ever seen that

    • @jflo30
      @jflo30 Před 5 měsíci +9

      Never seen that before. Also after starting a new playthrough I just found out there's a random event where bill get captured by bounty hunters.

    • @Pds255
      @Pds255 Před 2 měsíci +2

      @@jflo30yeah i got that too

  • @WalterWhiteIam
    @WalterWhiteIam Před 7 měsíci +15

    Number 6: anybody that has a minor inconvenience with me

  • @michaelvakarian7906
    @michaelvakarian7906 Před rokem +2757

    I don’t kill grizzled John because I enjoy returning regularly as both Arthur and John to repeatedly kick his ass

    • @austenmoorehead4946
      @austenmoorehead4946 Před rokem +255

      Me too lol I always fight him. He puts up a good fight and that makes it funner

    • @MicahMotion
      @MicahMotion Před rokem +144

      ​@@austenmoorehead4946untill you accidentally hit another random npc and the law shoots you up

    • @arthermorgen2767
      @arthermorgen2767 Před rokem +50

      Same when i fight him i get wanted and sheriff maloy just watches

    • @conchoid5749
      @conchoid5749 Před rokem +13

      ​@@arthermorgen2767I love sherriff maloy

    • @Nuuk_
      @Nuuk_ Před rokem +15

      I also like to listen to him rant because I think it’s entertaining

  • @sharkbait5557
    @sharkbait5557 Před 10 měsíci +1416

    Grizzled John is actually my favorite npc of all time. If you beat him up and take his hat, you can wear the hat into the bar he was in and anytime he’s in there he’ll just get mad and try to brawl again it’s funny as hell. He hates seeing you wear his hat

    • @JimmyJohnson7077
      @JimmyJohnson7077 Před 6 měsíci +32

      I've had my fair share of decent punch ons with John

    • @Live2Laugh27
      @Live2Laugh27 Před 6 měsíci +2

      Where do I find him?

    • @LuckyKlvrSyx
      @LuckyKlvrSyx Před 6 měsíci +4

      Smithfield ​@@Live2Laugh27

    • @ctkelley27
      @ctkelley27 Před 6 měsíci

      Yeah exactly

    • @TaIIer
      @TaIIer Před 6 měsíci +32

      Reminds me of family guy whenever Peter sees the Chicken they always fight lol

  • @user-iw7kw2lh5o
    @user-iw7kw2lh5o Před měsícem +1

    I got traumatized by swamp guy 💀💀

  • @ajdez8871
    @ajdez8871 Před 6 měsíci +16

    Dont forget that rich old man that smacks his horse in the face when you beat him in that race.
    -Barz

  • @jelado6155
    @jelado6155 Před rokem +3750

    I don't kill Jeremiah because it's worse to live like a ghost than to become one.

    • @PrescottSF
      @PrescottSF Před rokem +72

      Fax

    • @ThatHelldiver69
      @ThatHelldiver69 Před rokem +172

      Also its his job, there was also black slave catcher's and owners. Yes its wrong but so is murder.

    • @SamP-by7iv
      @SamP-by7iv Před rokem

      ​@@ThatHelldiver69 lmao nerd

    • @alienpizzaparty9996
      @alienpizzaparty9996 Před rokem +52

      True or you could simply throw him into the fire

    • @alienpizzaparty9996
      @alienpizzaparty9996 Před rokem +175

      @@ThatHelldiver69I don’t think you realize what you do in the game imma be honest

  • @alexthebigmac4497
    @alexthebigmac4497 Před rokem +777

    The men who killed all the bison in that one side quest with Charles

    • @zintxh
      @zintxh Před rokem +8

      @@Nope-vm6js oh well life isnt always fair :)

    • @caseyboyer7395
      @caseyboyer7395 Před rokem +5

      ​@@zintxh💀

    • @chestermicgun
      @chestermicgun Před rokem +5

      @@zintxhbased

    • @nbu692
      @nbu692 Před rokem +31

      Nah I always let the fella go

    • @pascalg16
      @pascalg16 Před rokem +7

      ​​​@@Nope-vm6js How is it better if they do it for the government? Jesus.

  • @syebyte3992
    @syebyte3992 Před 22 dny +6

    That guy in saint denis faking blindness

    • @bassnoob8214
      @bassnoob8214 Před 14 dny

      How do you find out he's faking? Unless there's several blind people and I just haven't found the right one

    • @rthurMorgan1899
      @rthurMorgan1899 Před 12 dny +2

      ​@@bassnoob8214 You hold a gun to their face, if they react, their faking

  • @DuckyEditzYT
    @DuckyEditzYT Před 5 měsíci +12

    N. 6: Evrey NPCS when u greet them and they insult you after

  • @monsterbash9758
    @monsterbash9758 Před rokem +589

    Don't kill grizzled John. Beat him up and take his hat. Next time he's there you just have to walk in wearing his hat and he'll try to fight you again! XD

    • @austinfrye5374
      @austinfrye5374 Před 11 měsíci +11

      He will fight you anywhere in town I went to the sheriff’s to drop off elli swan and he came in to beat me

  • @GojGoiOi
    @GojGoiOi Před 11 měsíci +1046

    Highest Priority Kill: " *MICHA: THE RAT* "

  • @theosolomon9948
    @theosolomon9948 Před 6 měsíci +10

    Number 6: The friendly young man that happened to be riding by while I was bored

  • @gabrielvalle9420
    @gabrielvalle9420 Před 5 měsíci +3

    Number 6: Any Night folk on the bayou

  • @account_made_for_posting
    @account_made_for_posting Před rokem +286

    Charlotte's stalker: "hey"
    *brutally stabs him to death*
    *lose honor*
    "I had honor?"

    • @smash3394
      @smash3394 Před 9 měsíci +3

      Преследователь Шарлотты? Надо её проведать

  • @theearthrexden
    @theearthrexden Před rokem +1712

    Don’t forget about the goat at Butcher Creek that always rams into you

    • @Bloodanna
      @Bloodanna Před 11 měsíci +37

      OMGODS, YES!
      i was starting to think it was just me!
      My spouse never gets rammed by the animals and i have gotten pushed to my death off cliffs by elk at least thrice.

    • @thehomiebee
      @thehomiebee Před 11 měsíci +26

      Then all of butchers creek 😈

    • @Jakeyisdead
      @Jakeyisdead Před 11 měsíci +6

      DUDE i thought that just happened to me i even posted it on facebook back when the game first came out i had no idea it was a reoccurimg thing

    • @theearthrexden
      @theearthrexden Před 11 měsíci +4

      @@Jakeyisdead haha, I actually posted a short on my channel showing it. Literally every time I turned my back on it, He rammed into me. I ended up kicking it which got me into a full on gun fight with the whole town

    • @Primata_Sulista7037
      @Primata_Sulista7037 Před 11 měsíci +5

      Wait, does that happened to y'all too?! That goat is a fuckin menace 💀

  • @fknobody4674
    @fknobody4674 Před 6 měsíci +2

    You forgot the weirdo close to emerald ranch who stalks Charlotte

  • @xxclutchxx8078
    @xxclutchxx8078 Před 6 měsíci +5

    Smoking that clan pack😮‍💨🚬💨💨

  • @EYCualquiera
    @EYCualquiera Před rokem +1388

    Kill Grizzled Jon? But Without it, John won't be able to see Bigfoot. 😢

    • @MicahBellEdits
      @MicahBellEdits Před rokem

      you eat BABIES

    • @alonepl4yer
      @alonepl4yer Před rokem

      ​@T-90A🇷🇺 we eat berries and mushrooms you fool

    • @Scared_Yoda
      @Scared_Yoda Před rokem +50

      @T-90A🇷🇺 everyone knows that
      _Edit: this is a continuation of the dialogue, not a negative reply to T-90A_

    • @Scared_Yoda
      @Scared_Yoda Před rokem +37

      Also Jon isn't the one you meet in Undead Nightmare, it's the same hunter guy from GTA 5's last stranger mission called "The Last One"

    • @Somecaveman223
      @Somecaveman223 Před rokem +85

      @@Scared_Yoda “WE DON’T EAT BABIES YOU FOOL
      WE EAT MUSHROOMS AND BERRIES”

  • @koray624
    @koray624 Před 8 měsíci +217

    Number 6: Murfree brood Guys who threaten you if you camp in the NorthEast of the map.

    • @Jakobs86
      @Jakobs86 Před 6 měsíci +11

      The same with Skinner brothers. They do the same shit to you but they’re in Tall Trees

    • @mastersinthe5114
      @mastersinthe5114 Před 4 měsíci +6

      "How about I camp where I want?"

    • @Stacked3403
      @Stacked3403 Před 4 měsíci +5

      Now I understand those npc's who get agitated when you come around thier camp

    • @Dylan-iw7ct
      @Dylan-iw7ct Před 4 měsíci

      If you kill the king they will all hate you and try kill you

  • @dutchmccutch615
    @dutchmccutch615 Před měsícem +1

    I love the racoon hat guy. He was cussin me out like a dogg while i was gettin my haircutt! 😂😂

  • @BrayWs
    @BrayWs Před 19 dny +1

    The raccoon guy is a legit terminator 😂😂put 8 shots in him and still got up swinging

  • @DOOMSlayer6476
    @DOOMSlayer6476 Před 8 měsíci +328

    You forgot to add the NPCs that respond rudely when you greet them

    • @Vertex_vortex
      @Vertex_vortex Před 6 měsíci +9

      Now I’m being hunted by the police force

    • @mattl8774
      @mattl8774 Před 3 měsíci

      Get out my face.

    • @masonmorley5065
      @masonmorley5065 Před 2 měsíci

      ​@@mattl8774
      What was that, you son of a b**ch?

    • @samael5200
      @samael5200 Před 2 měsíci

      At Emerald Ranch especially 😏

  • @14_CheesePuffs
    @14_CheesePuffs Před rokem +816

    "Hey, you're killing my favourite people"
    -👴

  • @odio88
    @odio88 Před 4 měsíci +1

    I just love walking up to grizzled jon wearing his hat and watching him get enraged

  • @sedxseed7675
    @sedxseed7675 Před 5 měsíci +1

    I always see grizzled jon in the saloon at valentine

  • @LaggingLeland
    @LaggingLeland Před rokem +128

    Jon was just a tough old man who was stuck in the past, I actually didn’t hate him at all. He was a tough and experienced fighter, soldier, hunter and gunman that might have been a bit of an *ss, but was imo better than a lot of the other people you encounter in the game.

    • @-Tomus-
      @-Tomus- Před rokem +12

      Fr I like Jon

    • @pascalg16
      @pascalg16 Před rokem +18

      Oh he was a hunter alright. He hunted native Americans and bison.

    • @BonesYUP
      @BonesYUP Před rokem +9

      ​@@pascalg16Yeah but he probably saw some messed up shit they did too

    • @The_Couriersmile
      @The_Couriersmile Před rokem +3

      ​@@pascalg16based

    • @Anonymous-fn8nj
      @Anonymous-fn8nj Před rokem +14

      @@pascalg16 that doesnt make him a bad person, both was incredibly profitable and anti native propaganda was so strong back then, you really couldnt be blamed for beliving they were evil...

  • @sethhynds2274
    @sethhynds2274 Před 3 měsíci +1

    Nobody gonna talk about the eugenics dude?

  • @Arcifined
    @Arcifined Před 6 měsíci +2

    6: the vampire
    7: Micah (American venom mission)

  • @TheDJLogy
    @TheDJLogy Před rokem +290

    I don't kill grizzled Jon, but instead beat the shit out of him. Next time I see him, I purposely run into him, and he says "I don't want to fight you" 😂

    • @EraldoPiccione
      @EraldoPiccione Před rokem +1

      Yeah

    • @evan1499
      @evan1499 Před rokem +7

      I always do this. One time I got an animation where you put his head through a bar table and it was hilarious 😂

    • @hunterpeterson3205
      @hunterpeterson3205 Před 11 měsíci +16

      If you wear mountain man johns racoon hat, he will fight you on sight no matter what

    • @thedamnedcat3240
      @thedamnedcat3240 Před 11 měsíci +11

      @@hunterpeterson3205 "its on sight" - mountain man john probably

    • @hunterpeterson3205
      @hunterpeterson3205 Před 11 měsíci +5

      @@thedamnedcat3240 I keep his hat on my horse so I can put it on before going inside Smithfield lol

  • @elferson
    @elferson Před rokem +406

    I didnt kill Jeremiah because i thought letting him live with his mistakes would be a worse fate than death. I even gained honour from it.

    • @Polite_chesse
      @Polite_chesse Před 11 měsíci +77

      U gain honor from killing him aswell

    • @Bearical
      @Bearical Před 11 měsíci +5

      I can't remember if i killed him or not tbf

    • @Kevin-qq9dd
      @Kevin-qq9dd Před 11 měsíci +16

      Wait what’s the whole deal with him? I thought if I killed him id lose honor so I left him alone what did he do? I was high as fuck doing that mission didn’t really pay attention

    • @_jokester_8537
      @_jokester_8537 Před 11 měsíci +24

      ​@@Kevin-qq9ddif i remember right hes the slavery dude

    • @spacegoose6358
      @spacegoose6358 Před 11 měsíci +51

      ⁠@@_jokester_8537yeah but people make such a big deal over it even though basically everyone was in the 1800s. People want a game to be historically accurate but then hate when it is

  • @SeanMaguire2
    @SeanMaguire2 Před 4 měsíci +1

    Disclaimer you can blow off the door at the back of the circus wagon

  • @gingeranagram2467
    @gingeranagram2467 Před 4 měsíci +8

    Number 6: "Women's Suffrage Protestor"

  • @KinggOse
    @KinggOse Před 11 měsíci +91

    "Not the cannibal npc who eats people" 💀

    • @yamo511
      @yamo511 Před 7 měsíci

      yeah everyone knows the big scary racists are worse than literal muderers, cannibals, and torturers >.>

    • @CastTerror5
      @CastTerror5 Před 6 měsíci +1

      Name ??

    • @KinggOse
      @KinggOse Před 6 měsíci +1

      @@CastTerror5 skinner brothers or Murphy brother

    • @CastTerror5
      @CastTerror5 Před 6 měsíci +1

      @@KinggOse Oh yeah

    • @CAPTAIN_TERMINOTERROR
      @CAPTAIN_TERMINOTERROR Před 6 měsíci

      ​​​​@@KinggOse Skinner brothers or Murfree broods*😅

  • @BangingMash
    @BangingMash Před rokem +48

    Nah man, grizzled john is the Valentine Saloon’s punching bag. You get your haircut, a shot of whiskey & beat the hell out of him before going on your merry way.

    • @vhego
      @vhego Před 10 měsíci

      A day to remember

  • @alternax9751
    @alternax9751 Před 4 měsíci +1

    It’s funny cause, when I killed Compson, I managed to loot his body, but then it got caught on fire because he fell just RIGHT in that small radius.

  • @CrossEdits.
    @CrossEdits. Před 26 dny +1

    Not the kool kids klub😭🙏

  • @nathanc4298
    @nathanc4298 Před rokem +443

    I agree with all of these but swap grizzled jon for the Aberdeen pig family because fist fighting jon is so much fun, he has so much health and you don’t get in trouble for it. If you just knock him out and don’t kill him he keeps coming back

    • @Dextertonights_thenight
      @Dextertonights_thenight Před rokem +6

      Exactly that’s what I always do

    • @austinwachter7794
      @austinwachter7794 Před rokem +21

      Another funny thing about him is he recognizes you again if you take his raccoon hat, after knocking him out the first time, he starts swinging on sight

    • @iamjacksennui
      @iamjacksennui Před rokem

      Never messed with him until my current playthrough. Knocked him out, then the bartender started shooting at me!

    • @jacksonblitzkreg9774
      @jacksonblitzkreg9774 Před rokem +2

      On my current play through I accidentally killed him after a poker game got a little out of hand. I actually regret it so much, the valentine bar will never be the same

    • @pingchu29
      @pingchu29 Před rokem +3

      The pig farmers are the most important NPCs in the game. It's how you transfer Arthur's money to John. That said, they're weird af

  • @tbiggy
    @tbiggy Před 11 měsíci +67

    Honestly killing Jeremiah Compson isn't worth it, if you leave him alive he'll have to live with all the things he did in his past. That's a more vengeful fate

    • @faridagasiyev7042
      @faridagasiyev7042 Před 7 měsíci +14

      Well, he doesn't regret his actions. Even more, he is proud with them

    • @weskerkings651
      @weskerkings651 Před 6 měsíci

      ​@@faridagasiyev7042chad

    • @yapyapthedestroyer2562
      @yapyapthedestroyer2562 Před 6 měsíci +9

      @@faridagasiyev7042yeah, but with how old he is and on how he lost all he had, his “history”, and just seems to be a drunk hermit, leaving him alive honestly seems fitting.

    • @laylazut5385
      @laylazut5385 Před 5 měsíci +2

      Yeah that’s what I did

  • @vonnheise1896
    @vonnheise1896 Před 7 měsíci +8

    How could you kill John? He provides the best fist to fist combat in the whole game??? And he never shies down. He's at that valentine's saloon every time looking for more. John is a legend you couldn't even comprehend.

  • @RockstarGhst
    @RockstarGhst Před 7 měsíci +6

    Number six: that one guy that’s leaving human remains all over the road

  • @andymina7566
    @andymina7566 Před rokem +294

    I never kill jerimah compson because I feel him wallowing in his pity and loss of his "legacy" is a fitting end for the type of man he was

    • @Bla3t
      @Bla3t Před 11 měsíci +54

      For me it was a "you'll suffer more if I keep you alive" kinda thing

    • @retrosushi7133
      @retrosushi7133 Před 11 měsíci +26

      No he took an double barrel slug to face then burnt him and his tent and got some honor 👏🏽😇

    • @Roge.M14
      @Roge.M14 Před 11 měsíci +5

      I did the same and plus he would die at an old age and realizing everything he had will forever haunt him in hell

    • @jurekmarkiewicz5837
      @jurekmarkiewicz5837 Před 11 měsíci

      Unless he regrets it@@Roge.M14

    • @thelonelongma5603
      @thelonelongma5603 Před 11 měsíci

      I usually throw an axe at his head, he ain't worth a bullet.....

  • @Dutch329
    @Dutch329 Před rokem +497

    As a black man I didn’t kill Jeremiah, even tho I should’ve, but Arthur/John handled that perfectly. Destroyed the last little things he had left and left him to live and die with nothing. But the KKK… they get dynamite every time. Lol

    • @curiahallen3471
      @curiahallen3471 Před rokem +32

      If you watch the clan for long enough, they'll set themselves on fire 🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂 but not all of them burn up. If you wanna get all of them, go for the dynamite

    • @RobertEdwinHouse17
      @RobertEdwinHouse17 Před rokem +22

      @@curiahallen3471one time the cross falls on 2 of them which is why I don’t kill them because it’s funny

    • @pope_cow
      @pope_cow Před rokem +6

      It’s the Molotov for me

    • @Perkelenaattori
      @Perkelenaattori Před rokem +17

      Don't kill the KKK. Instead you should watch the show till the end because usually the KKK events end with them maiming/killimg themselves in hilarious ways.

    • @acedepth
      @acedepth Před rokem +5

      I usually tie them up and with a mod I hang them on tree branches then set their body on fire and lastly I use their body as a practice pillow for throwing knives and hatches and what not :)

  • @gkvlogs1702
    @gkvlogs1702 Před měsícem

    Me: "Hey there mister!"
    NPC: "You better watch who you're talkin to boy"
    Me: 🤵‍♂️💥🔫

  • @monio_
    @monio_ Před 6 měsíci +1

    Number 6: Micah

  • @ArthurTheGreat
    @ArthurTheGreat  Před rokem +891

    Jeremiah Compson : Slave catcher
    Norris Forsythe : promoting eugenics
    Sonny (swamp weirdo) : rapist
    Grizzled Jon : vandalist / racist
    KKK : terrorists / supremacists

    • @oNWYSL
      @oNWYSL Před rokem

      Kkk is a racket group 😂

    • @duru_equestrian
      @duru_equestrian Před rokem +11

      Jon is also a cannibal

    • @peterhammett2375
      @peterhammett2375 Před rokem +22

      I wouldn’t consider Jon a vandalist, he isn’t destroying anything of anyone’s. I mean he’s a mountain man

    • @friendlyarsenic1547
      @friendlyarsenic1547 Před rokem +29

      Sound like my kind of guys

    • @TrentonCampbell8711
      @TrentonCampbell8711 Před rokem +5

      Micah should be one too after what he did to u @arthurthegreat

  • @Goosiegoose12
    @Goosiegoose12 Před rokem +55

    Quick fact: if you knock Grizzled jon out and take his hat and wear it he will randomly appear out of no where and attack you 😮

    • @EraldoPiccione
      @EraldoPiccione Před rokem

      Yeah

    • @losandos8619
      @losandos8619 Před 11 měsíci +2

      where will he appear? only in the valentine saloon? i'm wearing his hat all the time but never saw him again although i didnt kill him :D

    • @fortniteballer90s
      @fortniteballer90s Před 11 měsíci

      ​@@losandos8619true!

    • @josephstalin2606
      @josephstalin2606 Před 11 měsíci

      @@losandos8619 In Valentine. Usually when you return you’ll see a red dot come running out the saloon and towards you, that’s only if he spawns in tho sometimes he does and sometimes he doesn’t

  • @Typical-Greek
    @Typical-Greek Před 5 měsíci +1

    I tried to comfort Jeremiah Compson

  • @BeanZReTr0
    @BeanZReTr0 Před 8 měsíci +47

    Number 6: Aberdeen pig farm people

    • @LeGmJames
      @LeGmJames Před 5 měsíci

      I mean the wife is kinda hot

  • @Dxthy_
    @Dxthy_ Před rokem +96

    That brother and sister that poison u

    • @lekedi1
      @lekedi1 Před rokem +5

      Definitely

    • @mrnk88
      @mrnk88 Před rokem +13

      Not if you want to get easy money at the beginning of the epilogue

    • @lilbabyjessie8686
      @lilbabyjessie8686 Před rokem +1

      @@mrnk88 do they give you money or something?

    • @mrnk88
      @mrnk88 Před rokem +9

      @@lilbabyjessie8686 You store your money in there as Arthur, then, come back to pick as John

    • @Uncle1899
      @Uncle1899 Před rokem

      ​​@@mrnk88ou can go kill them and get the satisfaction of it just don't inspect their mother picture yet you still be able to retrieve that money as john

  • @ComplainttZz26
    @ComplainttZz26 Před měsícem

    The guy who shows up everywhere asking for GAVIN💀

  • @FlameWolfTFWC
    @FlameWolfTFWC Před 6 měsíci +1

    Not the poor spooky ghosts (joke btw) they at the Halloween party trying to wave out a fire

  • @newplayer2077
    @newplayer2077 Před 8 měsíci +34

    I remember coming back for the swamp weirdo and tied him up, but then he started saying a kinky stuff, and from the clues in the house i learned that he likes to be tied up

    • @Julian-qs8xq
      @Julian-qs8xq Před 6 měsíci +10

      He doesn’t like it so much once you throw him to the crocodiles though

    • @bullet_outsmarter_5000
      @bullet_outsmarter_5000 Před 4 měsíci +2

      Add that to the "RDR2 is the only game" list

  • @foxguy1590
    @foxguy1590 Před 11 měsíci +103

    I'd say the guy in Emerald Ranch who mistreats his dog, but I THINK you can't kill him (unless you use dynamite or fire bottles, I don't really know)

    • @HyperSora80
      @HyperSora80 Před 10 měsíci +58

      If you help him with his dog a few times, you can come back and find his corpse between some buildings, with the dog eating him :)

    • @foxguy1590
      @foxguy1590 Před 10 měsíci +18

      @@HyperSora80 Oh, I didn't know that. Dude got what he deserved

  • @BiggestHater754
    @BiggestHater754 Před 3 měsíci

    Number 6: any NPC that stares at me the wrong way

  • @W1N3H0US3_4EVA
    @W1N3H0US3_4EVA Před 2 měsíci

    Number 6: Those two Murfree Brood guys when you place down a camp near their spot
    Number 7: Any camper you see when they tell you to go away

  • @lane_kraft05
    @lane_kraft05 Před 11 měsíci +21

    If I every accidentally run into a camp and the stranger yells at me to leave then says “guess you ain’t so tough after all.” I make sure he never leaves that camp.

  • @icemanred6891
    @icemanred6891 Před rokem +36

    Jon is my bar fight buddy though, he can take an explosive round to the chest and get back up for blood 😅

  • @Weaselvr
    @Weaselvr Před 8 dny

    number 6: anyone who knocks my hat off

  • @ThelostKoiKiwami
    @ThelostKoiKiwami Před 2 měsíci +1

    you gain honour for popping the triple k

  • @UNSTABLE_Silver
    @UNSTABLE_Silver Před 9 měsíci +47

    You should also always kill the retired gunslinger Emmet, hes a monster

    • @DeadManSinging1
      @DeadManSinging1 Před 6 měsíci +38

      You have to kill him, anyway. The only gunslinger you cant kill is Black Belle, whos fucking awesome

    • @GiggIeshltter
      @GiggIeshltter Před 5 měsíci +2

      ​@@DeadManSinging1 You can lasso Emmet Granger if you shoot his knife.

    • @weswolverine
      @weswolverine Před 2 měsíci +1

      How? He seems like a regular dude living on a farm, what'd he do that was soo bad?

    • @gamergod42069
      @gamergod42069 Před 2 měsíci +1

      @@weswolverine He killed children..

    • @weswolverine
      @weswolverine Před 2 měsíci

      @@gamergod42069 where does it say that? I've tried to research him but can't seem to find anything

  • @rogtronius
    @rogtronius Před rokem +14

    Don’t forget the dude at emerald ranch that killed his daughter’s boyfriend then keeps her trapped in his house

  • @benjihoofficial6788
    @benjihoofficial6788 Před 3 měsíci

    Number 6: every npc who mocks my drip after i greeted him

  • @THECADEMETLYZ
    @THECADEMETLYZ Před 2 měsíci

    that dude who sells his inspirational book on the sidewalk of saint denis

  • @D.E.R.P
    @D.E.R.P Před 8 měsíci +12

    Swamp werido: "Oh, hello again"
    Me: *Drags this b*tch ahh to the closest train tracks and leaves him there*

  • @jakewinters3410
    @jakewinters3410 Před rokem +411

    I always kill npcs anyway

    • @dobremarian1234
      @dobremarian1234 Před rokem +25

      "Petah. The horse is here"

    • @skipper4773
      @skipper4773 Před rokem +44

      Least insane rdr2 player

    • @Bain26
      @Bain26 Před rokem

      Nah

    • @DominoCraft2400
      @DominoCraft2400 Před rokem +11

      ​@SunnyOmori.I feel like im the only high honor player

    • @Magicalmexican09
      @Magicalmexican09 Před rokem +8

      @@DominoCraft2400when I play as Arthur I play high honor but as John I play low honor

  • @suipsycho536
    @suipsycho536 Před 2 měsíci

    Number 6: anything that moves within my line of sight when i get bored

  • @SkudaBillip
    @SkudaBillip Před 4 měsíci

    Grizzled John is just an old loudmouth drunk, seems to me he's suffered enough already 😔

  • @Livinghopefulandhonest
    @Livinghopefulandhonest Před rokem +175

    Before you kill the swamp weirdo you first have to enter inside his house if he invites you, the excitement will literally be inside you💀

  • @pyro_x-x
    @pyro_x-x Před rokem +25

    Nah fight the grizzled dude and steal his hat, go back wearing his hat and he will fight you for his hat every time.

  • @Anonymous_Gentleman
    @Anonymous_Gentleman Před rokem +322

    I can never bring myself to kill Jeremiah Compson because that's my best friend's first name, plus I just feel so bad despite me literally being black

    • @PrescottSF
      @PrescottSF Před rokem

      Let him suffer alive

    • @sullysquid674
      @sullysquid674 Před rokem +35

      It’s fucked up but when a man knows nothing else then what he was doing his whole life and can’t do it anymore he will breakdown, both in good and bad jobs, places and environments

    • @paulklotenkotter6965
      @paulklotenkotter6965 Před rokem +15

      I let him live to suffer from his decisions

    • @MalanjoTheMonkey
      @MalanjoTheMonkey Před rokem

      @tf_u_talking_about do you know him personally? Do you think being black is a flex? What, is it impossible for him to be black? Do YOU wanna be black? Stop being a dumbass and assuming things, cause you’d be sorry if he was.

    • @unknownguy1727
      @unknownguy1727 Před rokem

      ​@tf_u_talking_aboutnot everyone gets offended like a lil bitch

  • @balconi89
    @balconi89 Před 5 měsíci

    I could listen to Grizzled John all day. His rants are hilarious.

  • @TheRandomDude1011
    @TheRandomDude1011 Před 6 měsíci +3

    I killed the npc with the raccoon hat and he respawned the next day

    • @crafty1620
      @crafty1620 Před 3 měsíci +2

      you probably only knocked him out then, after you have knocked someone out, you can continue to punch them and they will fully die

    • @TheRandomDude1011
      @TheRandomDude1011 Před 3 měsíci

      Yeah

  • @Gholefi
    @Gholefi Před rokem +54

    You can just keep robbing the Eugenics supporter every time you see him lol. Has some pretty nice stuff ngl.

    • @Leywaaaa
      @Leywaaaa Před rokem +5

      Thx
      Taking His stuff is probably more worth them just taking his life

    • @RedTideReject
      @RedTideReject Před rokem +4

      I let him go at least he’s promoting science 🤷‍♂️

    • @nomad__6
      @nomad__6 Před rokem +4

      I only shoot him because I can do it without getting wanted. He did have a few good points tho. (Not all of his ideas were good, but most of them were),

    • @GTAVictor9128
      @GTAVictor9128 Před rokem +2

      @@RedTideReject
      Name and profile picture checks out...

    • @TJXMS
      @TJXMS Před rokem

      @@GTAVictor9128fr

  • @andrewthomas9520
    @andrewthomas9520 Před 26 dny

    Swamp weirdo: oh hi
    John: pulls out gun
    Swamp weirdo: runs inside and says oh your weird
    Me ran: …

  • @ImFabioo
    @ImFabioo Před 2 dny

    The guy who is always yelling Gavin can get it to 😂

  • @astronautcheems7680
    @astronautcheems7680 Před rokem +40

    fun fact, you can actually kill the eugenics supporter in front of a cop and he won't arrest you, and you won't lose honor

    • @AreEnTee
      @AreEnTee Před rokem +4

      I always punch him when im in saint denis

    • @naqwillz1089
      @naqwillz1089 Před 9 měsíci +2

      Oh yeah I Just Pressed R3 Then Marked My X's And then I was wondering why the cop just ran away

    • @gat0anonimo
      @gat0anonimo Před 8 měsíci +1

      I beat him to K.O last time I found him and nobody said a thing lmao

    • @BritishTeeth420
      @BritishTeeth420 Před 7 měsíci +1

      I will never kill my friends the kkk😊

    • @SUCCUBUS928
      @SUCCUBUS928 Před 7 měsíci +1

      You actually gain it

  • @eclipsun0716
    @eclipsun0716 Před rokem +24

    I always go to Valentine saloon just to have a fist fight with Jon

  • @JamesFrederick-bx1no
    @JamesFrederick-bx1no Před měsícem +1

    Don't forget the people that say " WhAt Is YoUr PrObLeM" when u go 0.00001miles per hour

  • @IllusionTheCoffeeAddict
    @IllusionTheCoffeeAddict Před 2 měsíci

    Number 6: Any NPC who jokes about your drip.

  • @hamzajaleel7082
    @hamzajaleel7082 Před rokem +18

    Arthur looks so cold doing the Marston pose

    • @yamo511
      @yamo511 Před 7 měsíci +1

      that's his O face

  • @the98themperoroftheholybri33
    @the98themperoroftheholybri33 Před 8 měsíci +56

    You forgot the guy at emerald ranch who asks you to find his dog, and when you return it he beats his dog (which was why the dog ran away).

    • @ArkayaStudios
      @ArkayaStudios Před 8 měsíci +1

      He can only put so many people in a video dude, calm down

    • @yamo511
      @yamo511 Před 7 měsíci

      so what? it's only a dog

    • @ferstephenking
      @ferstephenking Před 6 měsíci

      ​@@yamo511what the f&ck is wrong with you

    • @LuckyKlvrSyx
      @LuckyKlvrSyx Před 6 měsíci

      Ok....​@@yamo511

    • @Jakobs86
      @Jakobs86 Před 6 měsíci +27

      @@yamo511Dogs deserve to live more than most people nowadays lmao

  • @CaynenLong
    @CaynenLong Před 5 měsíci +1

    I usually just fight grizzled John every time I see him since it’s more fun and he’s tough

  • @ghost_type4943
    @ghost_type4943 Před 5 měsíci +1

    Bro…The Aberdeen siblings

  • @gabrielsalazar3985
    @gabrielsalazar3985 Před 11 měsíci +8

    Bro the triple K end up killing themselves after awhile💀

  • @nobody4692
    @nobody4692 Před rokem +65

    It took me 5 playthroughs and this short to learn of the existence of Grizzled Jon

    • @DaveManPrice
      @DaveManPrice Před 11 měsíci +8

      Bro how he’s right there in valentine at the beginning of the game, are you speeding to the point where Arthur gets TB lol

    • @aidenskomp7305
      @aidenskomp7305 Před 11 měsíci +3

      @@DaveManPriceyou have to go in the Valentine saloon outside of a mission. Even I as someone who pours months into each playthrough, I rarely go to saloons

    • @Taubogason.40
      @Taubogason.40 Před 11 měsíci +2

      ​@@DaveManPriceI just never go to saloons except for the challenges where u gotta play poker or blackjack

    • @cliphahafunny
      @cliphahafunny Před 11 měsíci +4

      @@Taubogason.40 i only go into saloons for the barber shop in valentine
      other than that there is no reason to go into saloons

    • @faridagasiyev7042
      @faridagasiyev7042 Před 7 měsíci

      Are you speedrunning the game or something?