Yes I know Wind flower is my favourite song from then and them comes Egotistic, and I love Decalcomanie so much too. But every had their opinions and I respect that
Ok but decalcomanie as average... Edit: AND STARRY NIGHT AS PRETTY GOOD? Edit 2: AND EGOTISTIC... ngl I don't usually like the Latin style either but this is AMAZING Edit 3: OK THE REST I CAN UNDERSTAND BUT I WILL NOT STAND THE WIND FLOWER SLANDER ITS MY FAV SONG BY THEM Our opinions could not be more different lmao And the way you don't like slow songs wow haha
Agree a bit more with this. Yellow got Paint Me on it. Red is on repeat at least once every month. Wind Flower and No more drama are awesome. Am probably the only one not really feeling Hip (the shutter/flash high pitch sounds throughout the song are too much distraction)
Lol it's funny because for me Egotistic and Wind Flower are some of my absolute favourites, while Uhm Oh A Yeah and You're the best are probably my least favourites :D
I got into mamamoo a couple months after yes I am came out and I just became obsessed. My favorite era is wind flower because that song is just *chefs kiss* and easy is a full on bop and it deserves so much more attention than it's getting.
i feel bad for wind flower because it’s my absolute favourite era & it just went under the radar like that :( anyway i really enjoyed watching this entire video 💜 stan mamamoo, y’all
9:13 When you said no one knows about it you were pretty right lol. I kinda keep up with Mamamoo and I knew that Solar, Hwasa and Moonbyul had their solo debuts and I was quite baffled recently since Hwasa had a comeback and I though that was kinda weird since Wheein doesnt have a solo yet... Well turns out she does and she was even first to get a solo.
I'm not gonna talk about your music taste(like a see a few ppl doing) because music is subjective and not everything is this everyone. but I will say that Wheein's MV for Goodbye isn't the first in Kpop, to depict a lesbian relationship. there's: Baek Ji Young- I won't love again. Sistar- One More Day. Anda- Touch. After School- Because Of you. Chuu(Loona)- Heart Attack. Yves(Loona)- New. SNSD- Divine(Story version). Gfriend- Navillera. 9muses- Wild and Sleepless Night. Ha:Tfelt(Yueen of wondergirls)- Truth. Miss $- Just Let Me Live. Maman( a lesbian song by a lesbian singer in a lesbian MV)- Obvious Story. Glam- Party XXO(Bi anthem). Sweet Revenge- Cry To Your Heart's Content. there's so much more Lesbian/ Bi mv's but I'll stop at naming 15. Edit: if you want.. maybe you can do a video about LGBTQ+ MV/Songs
Boo this man!! 😂 You're about to get stoned for putting Decalcomonie in as average. Also, Absence is part of a repackaging of Dark Side of The Moon...which RBW did for some reason. My era tiers(top songs in parentheses): Adlib Tier: Reality in Black(Destiny, HIP, and High Tension), Yellow Flower(the whole album), Gleam*, woohoo*, Easy, Candy(Wheein cover of Baekhyun's song) Amazing: White Wind(gogobebe and My Star), Red Sun(Egotistic and Selfish), Wanna Be Myself*, Travel(Aya, Dingga, and Chuck), Dark Side of The Moon(the whole album) Pretty Good: Blue;s(Wind Flower and Hello), Melting(Taller Than You, I Miss You, and You're The Best), Maria(Maria and LMM), Spit It Out, Goodbye Average: Purple(Yes I Am and Finally), Memory(Decalcomanie and I Love Too), Hello(Mr. Ambiguous and I Do Me), Twit Meh: Pink Funky(Um Oh Ah Yeh) *=commercial songs not tied to an album. Please note that the album ranking has nothing to do with how much I like a particular song. The songs in the lower tiers are actually among my top favs but the albums were just really weak. I also didn't consider the videos because 99% of the time I'm listening from a streaming app so visuals aren't a factor. I would also rank the stages separately. The later you get, the more money and care went into the stage so it's kinda mean to compare their MMA 2019 stage for Destiny & HIP to their stages for songs like Um Oh Ah Yeh and You're The Best. Honestly, Reality in Black started a new era of epic stages and even White Wind and Red Sun stages look kinda wack compared to them.
my taste is really the opposite of yours in almost everything, but I love the way you explain it, I can see why you feel or think a certain way though I feel the complete opposite, and that is what I like about this video :) Thanks for sharing your opinions, it was really interesting
I'm sorry but to me it's a WHY TF WERE "MARIA" AND "SPIT IT OUT" SO LOW ON TGE LIST Like i definitely respect your opinion But maria was such. A. Bop. For me it would been on the adlib tier tbh Because it was *SUPERIOR* And spit it out was such a cool concept for solar I would've put it on the amazing tier Because it's just so energetic and i loved solar's voice in it So spit it out is just *chef's kiss* for me
every time a new era came up i was like please don’t react it low even though that’s part of the video... but i really broke with wind flower, eclipse, spit it out, and absence
i've been watching your more recent videos and i had no idea you were a mamamoo fan so this was nice to see! your tierlist is almost the opposite of mine though hahaha
Okay that’s just a no no!! I mean I respect your opinions but what??? 😭 the moment you put Decalcomanie in the average I was already shocked but then Egotistic and Wind Flower too?? Man that hurts.... and THEN you actually went and put Goodbye in Meh....????? I can’t, this just broke my heart 💔 Decalcomanie, Starry Night, Wind Flower and Goodbye are masterpieces, I can’t believe you 😭
SIR EXCUSE ME SIR I KNOW THATS ONLY YOUR OPINION BUT IT HURTS IT REALLY HURTS WHY PUT STARRY NIGHT IN PRETTY GOOD IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN AMAZING OR ADLIB AND DON'T GET ME STARTED ON EGOTISTIC AND WIND FLOWER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (no hate though just saying)
I remember Yes I Am, New York and Easy being the first few songs I knew about them. And Im pretty sure Um Oh Ah Yeh was one of the first kpop mvs ive watched. so its kinda sad that New York, and Easy didnt get much attention.
This is of course based in the opinion of the own of this channel which is ok. But if we based in musical criteria I have to say that I disagree with the majority of things said here specially when it comes in musical production, quality and concept ( specially in solos) but I understand that that music have two faces one subjective ( taste) and objective (musical criteria/technique) and this video was made in the first option. It was an entertaining video though
@@zahraisalubis7236 i wasn’t attacking.But I saw comments down that started to said that the person who made the video have bad taste so I wanted to clarify that this video is based in a personal opinion. I said too that the video was entertaining so don’t problem ✌️
@@laleja994 I see, sorry if what I said sounded rude 🙏 I'm genuinely curious, thanks for the chill reply! And agreed, I also saw that comment and thought just the same as you!
Everyone has an opinion, so I cant really agree or disagree. but this is pretty good in general! but here's some of my opinions: Easy underrated bop idc what anyone says Piano Man is their best title track Aya deserved better from the general public
Its weird watching this video because my top mamamoo eras are the opposite to this video. Egotistic, Decalcomanie, Goodbye, Windflower(get better day by day is so inspiring), Maria, Eclipse.
Okay, but if we’re talking about Reality in Black we HAVE TO talk about Hello Mama. I know ballads aren’t everyones thing, BUT this song made me cry. And I don’t even like ballads myself!
Okay, everything is okay But how can you put STERRY NIGHT in PRETTY GOOD (No discrimination, everyone’s taste is unique and different, but that’s my favorite song from mamamoo and one of my favorite song in general, so it just seem impossible for me to put it too low :0)
Adlib Tier: You’re the Best, Wind Flower, Gogobebe, Hip Amazing tier: Mr Ambiguous, Selfish, Twit, Good Bye, Dingga Pretty Good tier: Easy, Starry Night, Egotistic, Water Color Average tier: Piano Man, Decalcomanie, Aya Meh tier: Um Oh Ah Yes, Yes I Am
I'd rank Um Oh Ah Yeh and Starry Night as their worst eras and put them in the pretty good tier soo.....Yeah I love all the eras so much and would have only 3 tiers Except Red Moon's bside "Sky, sky" that song goes below meh
Don’t we all fall down the moonbyul rabbit hole at some point in our lives 😌 Edit: I DESPISE SLOW SONGS TOO!! I feel like you’re just saying what I think hahaha
umm whee ins mv for "Good Bye" is not depicting a lesbian relationship...if you watch it more closely you'll see. not that i would complain if it were just its inaccurate to say that.
:o can I make you an intro you can check out my intro and outro and berryeris intro and outro and loona velvets outro I made them you can tell me the details on the intro group,aesthetic,color,song or instrumental
I assume the 1 dislike on the video is from you. I won't judge you for being upset about whatever you are upset about, but just accept others opinions.
Ok, but decalcomanie and egotistic and wind flower being average hurts, those were literally iconic
I actually agree with axiee😮
@Lavanya Kar because somoneone's preferences differs from others?
Absence in meh tier was sad🥺🥺
Yes I know Wind flower is my favourite song from then and them comes Egotistic, and I love Decalcomanie so much too. But every had their opinions and I respect that
Wind Flower is my favorite mmm title track, and décalcomanie is pretty close, so same
Decalcomanie and Starry Night being in that tiers is a crime.
Ikr 😭😭😭
When I tell you that I SCREAMED when Spit It Out was put in Meh. 💀💀💀 Literally was the first solo song I got addicted to.
Ikr 😭😭😭😭
its so downgraded :c
FOR REAL SPIT IT OUT IS MY FAVORITE THING EVEERR
Ok but decalcomanie as average...
Edit: AND STARRY NIGHT AS PRETTY GOOD?
Edit 2: AND EGOTISTIC... ngl I don't usually like the Latin style either but this is AMAZING
Edit 3: OK THE REST I CAN UNDERSTAND BUT I WILL NOT STAND THE WIND FLOWER SLANDER ITS MY FAV SONG BY THEM
Our opinions could not be more different lmao
And the way you don't like slow songs wow haha
Agree a bit more with this. Yellow got Paint Me on it. Red is on repeat at least once every month. Wind Flower and No more drama are awesome. Am probably the only one not really feeling Hip (the shutter/flash high pitch sounds throughout the song are too much distraction)
@@marthachang47130 i weirdly loved the mv, 4 concept idea and ofc the mama stage of it tho
SAY IT LOUDER QUEEN! EASY IS LITERALLY ONE OF MY FAVORITE SOLO SONGS EVER!!! STREAM EASY💜
Have you heard the acoustic version though?
@@ReapTheWhirlwind yup! That’s beautiful as well
stan axie for clear skin
Ngl seeing the trend with the retro concepts in this 2020 I was hoping for Mamamoo to have a comeback with something jazzy or 20s' or 30s' concept.
dang.. absence, maria, starry night, wind flower.. yeah. idk but they honestly deserved more.
Lol it's funny because for me Egotistic and Wind Flower are some of my absolute favourites, while Uhm Oh A Yeah and You're the best are probably my least favourites :D
hip not being at the top i just don’t understand it
I got into mamamoo a couple months after yes I am came out and I just became obsessed. My favorite era is wind flower because that song is just *chefs kiss* and easy is a full on bop and it deserves so much more attention than it's getting.
i feel bad for wind flower because it’s my absolute favourite era & it just went under the radar like that :( anyway i really enjoyed watching this entire video 💜 stan mamamoo, y’all
MARIA AVERAGE?????
anyway i respect your opinion :)
ikr like how-
Ikr 😭😭😭
9:13 When you said no one knows about it you were pretty right lol. I kinda keep up with Mamamoo and I knew that Solar, Hwasa and Moonbyul had their solo debuts and I was quite baffled recently since Hwasa had a comeback and I though that was kinda weird since Wheein doesnt have a solo yet... Well turns out she does and she was even first to get a solo.
apparently shes working on a solo rn from what ive heard from other ppl
my jaw actually dropped when you put decalcomanie in average x) one of their best songs for me ;)
I was so mad when Egotistic went on average but I calmed down when gogobebe went in *insert adlibs lmao
Me too-💀
I'm not gonna talk about your music taste(like a see a few ppl doing) because music is subjective and not everything is this everyone.
but I will say that Wheein's MV for Goodbye isn't the first in Kpop, to depict a lesbian relationship.
there's: Baek Ji Young- I won't love again. Sistar- One More Day. Anda- Touch. After School- Because Of you. Chuu(Loona)- Heart Attack. Yves(Loona)- New. SNSD- Divine(Story version). Gfriend- Navillera. 9muses- Wild and Sleepless Night. Ha:Tfelt(Yueen of wondergirls)- Truth. Miss $- Just Let Me Live. Maman( a lesbian song by a lesbian singer in a lesbian MV)- Obvious Story. Glam- Party XXO(Bi anthem). Sweet Revenge- Cry To Your Heart's Content.
there's so much more Lesbian/ Bi mv's but I'll stop at naming 15.
Edit: if you want.. maybe you can do a video about LGBTQ+ MV/Songs
Starry night is literally their most popular song in korea atm... and decalcomanie second most popular...
Popularity doesn’t have anything to do with their personal opinion about the song
@@cbcimutebi5564
I get it but they are really good. I liked Decalcomania more than hip at first
as wind flower / blue;s enthusiast im like: 👁👄👁
YES!!!!! EASY AT INSERT ADLIBS TIER!!!!! YOU'VE WON MY HEART!!!
as soon as they put goodbye in meh i literally clicked off bc i had to take a moment to process what just happened
BAHAHA SAME but axiestan looks like they vibe to more fun and energetic songs so I can't say much lmao
@@nsnhsjs3688 yeah i can definitely see that but it still hurts LMAO
@@arshiaaja tbf it's also one of my fave songs out of mamamoo I was *shooketh* lmaooo
@@nsnhsjs3688 yeah but when they put windflower and egotistic in average, windflower is my favourite mamamoo song tbf 😔
@@arshiaaja YESS WINDFLOWER AND BLUE;S SUPREMACY PERIOD
maria in average and twit in pretty good just HURTS
Boo this man!! 😂 You're about to get stoned for putting Decalcomonie in as average. Also, Absence is part of a repackaging of Dark Side of The Moon...which RBW did for some reason.
My era tiers(top songs in parentheses):
Adlib Tier: Reality in Black(Destiny, HIP, and High Tension), Yellow Flower(the whole album), Gleam*, woohoo*, Easy, Candy(Wheein cover of Baekhyun's song)
Amazing: White Wind(gogobebe and My Star), Red Sun(Egotistic and Selfish), Wanna Be Myself*, Travel(Aya, Dingga, and Chuck), Dark Side of The Moon(the whole album)
Pretty Good: Blue;s(Wind Flower and Hello), Melting(Taller Than You, I Miss You, and You're The Best), Maria(Maria and LMM), Spit It Out, Goodbye
Average: Purple(Yes I Am and Finally), Memory(Decalcomanie and I Love Too), Hello(Mr. Ambiguous and I Do Me), Twit
Meh: Pink Funky(Um Oh Ah Yeh)
*=commercial songs not tied to an album.
Please note that the album ranking has nothing to do with how much I like a particular song. The songs in the lower tiers are actually among my top favs but the albums were just really weak. I also didn't consider the videos because 99% of the time I'm listening from a streaming app so visuals aren't a factor. I would also rank the stages separately. The later you get, the more money and care went into the stage so it's kinda mean to compare their MMA 2019 stage for Destiny & HIP to their stages for songs like Um Oh Ah Yeh and You're The Best. Honestly, Reality in Black started a new era of epic stages and even White Wind and Red Sun stages look kinda wack compared to them.
THANK U FOR DOING "EASY" JUSTICE, IT'S GREAT!!
my taste is really the opposite of yours in almost everything, but I love the way you explain it, I can see why you feel or think a certain way though I feel the complete opposite, and that is what I like about this video :)
Thanks for sharing your opinions, it was really interesting
19:00 their mama 2019 performance of hip was literally what made me stan them. it was so beyond perfect. i love them sm ughhhh
Same
I'm sorry but to me it's a
WHY TF WERE "MARIA" AND "SPIT IT OUT" SO LOW ON TGE LIST
Like i definitely respect your opinion
But maria was
such.
A.
Bop.
For me it would been on the adlib tier tbh
Because it was
*SUPERIOR*
And spit it out was such a cool concept for solar
I would've put it on the amazing tier
Because it's just so energetic and i loved solar's voice in it
So spit it out is just *chef's kiss* for me
for me, eclipse and absence are god tier(I LOVE ABSENCE SO SO SO SO MUCH)
every time a new era came up i was like please don’t react it low even though that’s part of the video...
but i really broke with wind flower, eclipse, spit it out, and absence
Tbh easy is my favorite mamamoo song ever like WhEEiN has the best solos ever she is my ult like I luv all her solos
i've been watching your more recent videos and i had no idea you were a mamamoo fan so this was nice to see! your tierlist is almost the opposite of mine though hahaha
I can imagine the hardwork in this video
Okay that’s just a no no!! I mean I respect your opinions but what??? 😭 the moment you put Decalcomanie in the average I was already shocked but then Egotistic and Wind Flower too?? Man that hurts.... and THEN you actually went and put Goodbye in Meh....????? I can’t, this just broke my heart 💔 Decalcomanie, Starry Night, Wind Flower and Goodbye are masterpieces, I can’t believe you 😭
SIR EXCUSE ME SIR I KNOW THATS ONLY YOUR OPINION BUT IT HURTS IT REALLY HURTS WHY PUT STARRY NIGHT IN PRETTY GOOD IT SHOULD HAVE BEEN AMAZING OR ADLIB AND DON'T GET ME STARTED ON EGOTISTIC AND WIND FLOWER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! (no hate though just saying)
I'm happy to see a person who like mamamoo's jazzy music ✨
I remember Yes I Am, New York and Easy being the first few songs I knew about them. And Im pretty sure Um Oh Ah Yeh was one of the first kpop mvs ive watched. so its kinda sad that New York, and Easy didnt get much attention.
I start laughing when they put Maria in average
Random question: How does the pronunciation of Twit upset you? No hate, just curious...is it because Hwasa doesn't exactly pronounce the "t" in it?
she says "twite"
@@axiestan ooooh okay
This is of course based in the opinion of the own of this channel which is ok. But if we based in musical criteria I have to say that I disagree with the majority of things said here specially when it comes in musical production, quality and concept ( specially in solos) but I understand that that music have two faces one subjective ( taste) and objective (musical criteria/technique) and this video was made in the first option. It was an entertaining video though
Did you not read 0:21? It is clearly stated that this video is based on personal opinion
@@zahraisalubis7236 i wasn’t attacking.But I saw comments down that started to said that the person who made the video have bad taste so I wanted to clarify that this video is based in a personal opinion. I said too that the video was entertaining so don’t problem ✌️
@@laleja994 I see, sorry if what I said sounded rude 🙏 I'm genuinely curious, thanks for the chill reply!
And agreed, I also saw that comment and thought just the same as you!
I hoped you would make a Mamamoo Version. I'm glad you did. Nice video. You deserve to get 10k! I love how creative your videos are
Wind flower would _easily_ get the top tier in my list. It's just such a great song, truly timeless.
Where's taller than you???
The most honest ktuber I know I have watched your videos over a billion times
I'm a girl btw
Dude please don't put 'I'm a girl BTW'
Like its annoying as heck
It feels like everyone forgot about Wanna Be Myself. It was a good era, idk what y’all were doin sleeping on this song.
Wanna be myself was a CF like ‘Woo Hoo’, ‘Maeil Bio’ and ‘Gleam’
Everyone has an opinion, so I cant really agree or disagree. but this is pretty good in general! but here's some of my opinions:
Easy underrated bop
idc what anyone says Piano Man is their best title track
Aya deserved better from the general public
GOODBYE IN MEH?? BROOO
Its weird watching this video because my top mamamoo eras are the opposite to this video. Egotistic, Decalcomanie, Goodbye, Windflower(get better day by day is so inspiring), Maria, Eclipse.
i love this vid and the way you shared your opinions. also, thanks for appreciating easy 🥺
Okay, but if we’re talking about Reality in Black we HAVE TO talk about Hello Mama. I know ballads aren’t everyones thing, BUT this song made me cry. And I don’t even like ballads myself!
longtime moomoos S ranking: Mr ambiguous, taller than you, yes I am, egotist, twit, dingga
the fact there are songs in meh surprises me :/
Finally someone who likes mr ambiguous as much as I do it seems like no one talks about it.
Okay, everything is okay
But how can you put STERRY NIGHT in PRETTY GOOD
(No discrimination, everyone’s taste is unique and different, but that’s my favorite song from mamamoo and one of my favorite song in general, so it just seem impossible for me to put it too low :0)
OMG I hate what you said and yet agree as well you are making me go INSANE!!!!!!!!! lol
imo, i think you like a pop songs but it's okay i respect your opinion :3
Adlib Tier: You’re the Best, Wind Flower, Gogobebe, Hip
Amazing tier: Mr Ambiguous, Selfish, Twit, Good Bye, Dingga
Pretty Good tier: Easy, Starry Night, Egotistic, Water Color
Average tier: Piano Man, Decalcomanie, Aya
Meh tier: Um Oh Ah Yes, Yes I Am
Your taste and me definitely the same😃
I disagreed with most of the ranks you gave to the songs. But I do agree with some of them.
If i make a video like this....i will put everything on the top hahaha..... So thank you for making this vid✨
I'd rank Um Oh Ah Yeh and Starry Night as their worst eras and put them in the pretty good tier soo.....Yeah I love all the eras so much and would have only 3 tiers
Except Red Moon's bside "Sky, sky" that song goes below meh
Don’t we all fall down the moonbyul rabbit hole at some point in our lives 😌
Edit: I DESPISE SLOW SONGS TOO!! I feel like you’re just saying what I think hahaha
STAN AXIE
STAN TASTE
The narrators mOOnbIyUL 😭👁👄👁
Spit it out is literally so goooooooood how is that a meh, i respect your opinion tho
You should do bp eras tier list!
yes I am>>>>>>>>>>
This made me sad tho.
Didn't you forget Gleam era?
commercial songs are eras?
you should do gfriend!
Wind flower is so good tho
omg decalcomanie average???
girl.
umm whee ins mv for "Good Bye" is not depicting a lesbian relationship...if you watch it more closely you'll see. not that i would complain if it were just its inaccurate to say that.
It is about a girl who likes another girl but that girl is in a relationship with a guy, i think you have to watch it again
❤️
decalcomanie is ma faveeee
omg early
Do you have a link for the tier? I wanna make my own 🥺🥺
in the description
@@axiestan thank you❤️❤️❤️
:o can I make you an intro you can check out my intro and outro and berryeris intro and outro and loona velvets outro I made them you can tell me the details on the intro group,aesthetic,color,song or instrumental
sorry, but i want to keep all the work on my channel original. also i really like my intro rn :( thanks for the offer, though!
@@axiestan okay!!!
not me disagreeing with u most of the time byeee 😂😂😂
I'm surprised that you disliked Delcoline
Jail.
I disagree with you on almost every era :D
.....no
aya flopped
no and no it was a masterpiece imo
It would have been acceptable IF you said it not your taste but no. You're just rude. Correct your attitude plz.
You really has a bad taste
I assume the 1 dislike on the video is from you. I won't judge you for being upset about whatever you are upset about, but just accept others opinions.