Why People are Siding with Palestine
Vložit
- čas přidán 12. 10. 2023
- It’s not as black and white as it seems
Check out my new channel with Sam Ellis - Search Party: / @search-party
Get access to behind-the-scenes vlogs, my scripts, and extended interviews over at / johnnyharris
Do you have an insider tip or unique information on a story? Do you have a suggestion for a story you want us to cover? Submit to the Tip Line: docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FA...
I made a poster about maps - check it out: store.dftba.com/products/all-...
Custom Presets & LUTs [what we use]: store.dftba.com/products/john...
About:
Johnny Harris is an Emmy-winning independent journalist and contributor to the New York Times. Based in Washington, DC, Harris reports on interesting trends and stories domestically and around the globe, publishing to his audience of over 3.5 million on CZcams. Harris produced and hosted the twice Emmy-nominated series Borders for Vox Media. His visual style blends motion graphics with cinematic videography to create content that explains complex issues in relatable ways.
- press -
NYTimes: www.nytimes.com/2021/11/09/op...
NYTimes: www.nytimes.com/video/opinion...
Vox Borders: • Inside Hong Kong’s cag...
NPR Planet Money: www.npr.org/transcripts/10721...
- where to find me -
Instagram: / johnny.harris
Tiktok: / johnny.harris
Facebook: / johnnyharrisvox
Iz's (my wife’s) channel: / iz-harris
- how i make my videos -
Tom Fox makes my music, work with him here: tfbeats.com/
I make maps using this AE Plugin: aescripts.com/geolayers/?aff=77
All the gear I use: www.izharris.com/gear-guide
- my courses -
Learn a language: brighttrip.com/course/language/
Visual storytelling: www.brighttrip.com/courses/vi...
Israel does not represent all Jews and Hamas does not represent all Palestinians. I want peace for both sides.
Edit: imagine wanting peace being a hot take🤦♂️ What a world we live in man…
Except the vast majority of Palestinians support Hamas...
Its this contradiction. on the one hand jewish people deserve a state, on the other hand the community lived there feels like it was pushed out and the land was theirs. Where else can you go in and claim land based on historical claims now?@@rd-ot1ju
Don't be simple minded, not supporting the colonizer state of Israel does not automatically means supporting Hamass. Do you have proof of what you claim, otherwise your statement is just assuption and lie. Can you even know what's exactly on the mind of 2 millions people, unless you are a telepathe. In fact, how can they exactly support hamass if they can't even support themselves ! 🤔
@@rohanshirmard2485majority of the Jews around the world should hate the Zionist too. They give them a bad PR
are we witnessing a dawn of a WWIII? 🤔😲☹️
Palestinians have a right to defend their land.
Agreed
And so does isreal.
State of Israel doesn’t have the right to defend itself because it’s built on stolen land.
@@cheddahc6686oppressor can't be defender.
@@cheddahc6686 so does a rapist?
And who elected Hamas? Palestinians!
Hamas only won 44% off the vote, what about the 56% that didn't want them.
Hamas Rose from the frustrations of the PLO and the PA after decades of Israel taking more and more land, shutting the gazza in with a giant wall, not letting Palestinians travel and giving them the bare amount of food to survive. The evil that is Hanas is just the byproduct of Irsraeli oppression.
Who supported and gave money to fund Hamas ? Netanyahu
So what, under this logic, Germans elected Nazis, should they have been annihilated?
Israel created and funded Hamas. Source: Dr. Ron Paul and Daniel McAdams.
The vast majority of Palestinians voted Hammas into power though
No, Hamad got about 45% of the votes in 2006, when the last elections were. So every palestinian below the age of 36 hasn't voted for Hamas, aince they were too young theb, and only 45% of the people above 36 years old voted for them
So what. Doesn't justify genocide.
Free Palestine has been a thing for 75 years. Hamas didn't exist until the 80's.
No, but the Black Hand had existed since 1930, and Palestinian terrorism in general since 1920.
@@lad7436absolutely not, and the black hand was a Serbian organization that got founded in 1901, which has nothing to do with Palestine.
@@lad7436what are you on about black hand, that has nothing to do with palestine
… and they ran in 2006 as a moderate political party but changed after and have not allowed for democratic elections in the 18 years since. They also won in 2006 and have been strengthened because Israel propped them up the PLO (the group that were interred in a peace deal and land swaps ) would lose power.
Do you even know what black hand is it's not even in the same continent @@lad7436
If Hamas is terrorist, what would you call Israel? Angel?
No, you would call them God‘s children
@@MadlyParrot5345god's children who killed women and children? Are they going to heaven? Is that what your god's saying? Wow
@@Va-dy8pdso what would you suggest Israel do after what Hamas did to all those women, children, kids going to a peace festival? people are yelling at Israel for a cease fire but there was one already until Hamas broke it by burning babies and raping young girls.
@@MadlyParrot5345every religion says they’re gods chosen. In what way does that mean they’re right? They cant be all right. On that same vein, no religion excuses genocide. And Judaism does not equate to Zionism. There are many Jewish people standing with Palestine…
@@viridia1526 I didn’t say they were right or wrong. I’m just saying that they’re God’s children, and that’s who they are.
But the vast majority of palestinians in gaza support Hamas.
@@WiseWolfofDeck6 dont have to support Isreal or the US. Im just saying supporting people who use you as human shields then complaining about being human shields while still supporting the people using you as a human shield seems a bit backwards. Just my thoughts.
Imagine yourself in the shoes of a Palestinian, you are living in an open air prison and you are constantly harassed and even killed by the occupying forces. In some cases families are destroyed and people are broken and devastated. You have very limited prospects as you are a second class citizen in your own country. Your house can be raided anytime by Israeli forces terrorizing you and your family. You or your family members can be killed by the Israeli forces without much ramifications. What else do you do except to support the resistance.
@@seanathanconmanary40 You really have to put this is real world terms, not media driven labels and narratives. The palestinians have been denied their own actual military since the Oslo Accords. Hamas gets things like rifles, rockets, and grenades off the black market.They have no air support, no armored divisions, no electronic warfare capability. They attacked one of the most politically and militarily powerful countries on earth, one that enjoys blank check military support from the Western nations that established it.
You are told its because they just darn don't like the Israeli's.
And if that narrative doesn't make sense then there HAS to be another reason to try and fight.
Why won’t they ?
They don’t want to end up like West Bank either
And not to forget 90% of Israeli wants to wipe them out they don’t accept the 2 state solution
Unlike Hamas does ACCEPTS THE TWO STATE SOLUTION
@@seanathanconmanary40human shield ?
Let’s not forget whom USA Israel and turkey supported in the Syrian civil war
'Losing a war you started does not make you a victim'
And that is what Israel is doing - it is losing a war it started.
@@happynaturalist1793no Israel is winning and Palestine started the war
@@happynaturalist1793 How does it losing?
@@happynaturalist1793huhhh??? They’re winning so badly people hate them for it
@@happynaturalist1793 More like it's re-winning a war they didn't start.
When Ukrainian people fight you call them heroes and freedom fighters. But when Palestinians fight they become terrorist 😂
What a double standards
I mean, Russia invaded, where as Hamas attacked. People rarely side with the aggressor, especially in acts like these.
So you agree that those terrorist attacks were done by palestine?
@@ne4549d Don’t be racist, says the person dismissing the massacres of civilians as them being ‘invaders.’ Which would be another difference between Ukraine and Hamas, they didn’t go into Russia and start massacring innocent people.
@@nevermore7285 do you have any evidence of Israeli getting massacred by Hamas or just headlines by white media? Because Hamas didn't start the war last month, the zionists occupation started it decades ago
@@ne4549dmunich terror attacks? both intifadas? attack on the concert? black september in jordan? lebanese civil war?
all instigated by the PLO or other palestinian terror groups
Palestinians have the right to resist and fight back against israel.
So does Israel it’s the Palestinian’s faults for putting Hamas in office
Palestine started the October 7th war goofy Wym fight back
Does Israel have the right to fight back?
you suddenly support palestine, after october???? real trendy here. israel also has the rights to defend itself from countries of terrorists. oh wait, “countries”? oopsies.
@@77xurcoBro the war has started in 1948 when Israel was born
Israel has besieged Gaza for 15 years and everyone was silent. Israel occupied 75% of the Palestinian lands and displaced people from their homes, but everyone was silent. When the Palestinians responded, they defended themselves and their land. They became terrorists! I hope that you will experience the suffering that the Palestinian people have been experiencing for 76 years at the hands of the terrorist occupation.
Incorrect. Learn history.
@@Matt-ff3jl you need that education
@@user-fg8fz1ui3h I'm very educated on this region's history but sure I am always down to have a proper discussion and each provide evidence for what they claim. How about that? Everything you said in your initial post is incorrect and you know it.
Mate, Palestine literally went to war TWO times with Israel, and you call the Israelis "occupiers" ? Hamas came to power in Gaza because PALESTINIANS voted them in power, of course Israel should have the full right now to supervise the territory of Palestine, their people have supported terrorism, through the process of democracy.
Learn history that is not lied told by Palestinians who can't read or write
What makes the support of Palestine so much more difficult is the fact that Palestinians themselves, in majority, support hamas, display antisemitism, and the term “from the river to the sea” shows a very clear idea that Palestine as a whole doesn’t just want Israel to abstain from convoluting the affairs the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, but to abolish the state of Israel.
Palestine is not even a legitimate entity.
Thank you. This video is very over simplified, and disingenuous at worst.
Truth
Anyone who lives under oppression is going to eventually join or support a group of "resistance fighters" as they would advertise themselves. Also the people could hardly have foreseen what hamas was going to do in the future.
The only thing that bothers me is why israel had no problem allowing auch a thing as a "resistance group" like hamas to be officially formed and elected when they had complete controle over everything else in the lives of the Palestinians.
I find this 'antisemitism' tag extremely racist. Or is it tribal? Both Palestinians and Jews are semites. But the tag is used only where Jews are targeted. Does this mean Jews are more human, therefore more semitic, than Palestinians? Hence the (semitic) Palestinians become 'antisemitic' when they resist oppression by (semitic) Jews who can of course oppress lesser humans.
Palestine has the absolute RIGHT to defend itself!!!
Israel has the absolute RIGHT to take back their lands that were stolen from them a 1000 years ago
Fr!!
But it didn't have the NEED to defend itself before it started "defending itself". They're basically trying to put out a fire they started by using a flamethrower on it.
No everything was normal israel provided them electricity, water and food but hamas chose to invest their money on terrorism and making gaza better, palestinians chose this government so its THEIR FAULT
By slaughtering children?
Palestine has been attacked for 70 years and no one said nothing about it but when they finnaly decided to defend themselves they get called terrorist thats not okay.
The UN has had plenty to say about it for years but the US govt prevented all 47 (?) times they tried to pass a motion to stop them committing crimes against humanity
75 actually 😐 it’s crazy!!
Palestine have only been existing since 1948. It was never a country until then.
@@N00RAMINA Wake up!!! Break your algorithm. Propaganda man. You all have no idea what you are talking about. If you don't want to take the time to learn it, please stop spreading the rhetoric. It takes a lot of time and care to know it all.
@@JessJoanneyou're the one supporting rhetoric
Palestinians are being GENOCIDED, are you insane???
Most Palestinians support Hamas.
Who else should they support ? Israel who is keeping them stateless for life ?
@hello2bharath obviously you know nothing about the history of the conflict. The Palestinians have been offered peace numerous times by Israel and always responded with violence.
@@hello2bharath Honestly? Yeah. There are a lot that have moved to Israel and are doing way better.
If the protestors are there for Palestinians but against Hamas, why do none of them condemn the actions of Hamas?
"them" who are you referring to? The protesters? Because most protesters go out their way to make sure ppl understand them defending Palestine is not them defending hamas or do you mean Palestinians? Because surely you can understand if you live in a constant state of fear you won't go around condemning a group who can send its members to your home and do anything they wanted and no one in the world would say a thing, much less lift a finger to help
Hamas was democratically voted in which literally means that the Palestinians voted for Hamas. DUHH
Mf how many condemnation do you want to hear? Have you seen interviews from pro palestinians? they literally have to preface condemning hamas first.
But what about IDF bombing civilians, and their act of genocide? Or does it anti semitic to condemn them?
I'm a protestor and I condemn the attacks on October 7th (and all other terror attacks). Many protestors condemn those attacks.
If you justify Israel's crimes then just give your country to Israel!
There will be no suffering let alone Hamas which only existed after Israeli colonialism
The brits after drawing funny line on map: hmm, this is a surprising outcome
I'm going to whatever the muslims and/or Jews consider hell for laughing at that
Search the 12 tribes of Israel, Judah is a big give away, funny lines aye?
@@75Saxon_25Celtic In 135 CE, after stamping out the province of Judea's second insurrection, the Romans renamed the province Syria Palaestina.
in some country like Egypt and Sudan the Brits just put a ruler and made a straight line
Actually the UN drew a map, and divided.
Jews said OK
Arabs said NOPE KILL THE JEWS
and lost
A different line was drawn.
Until 1967 no palestinian movement was present in the west bank nor Gaza, as they were under the direct control of Jordan and Egypt
After 1967 suddenly such a movement was encouraged by the arab league... Weird. Why did the arab league not champion a palestinian homeland before 1967.
And why did Egypt not want Gaza back when they also got the Sinai back?
Think a bit on these facts and you will notice that the standard palestinian narrative is deceptive at best, fictional at worst.
“Why did you bomb 3 hospitals today isreal”
“uhh we thought a hamas soldier was under it”
The way one of those hospitals was so close to the sea it’s impossible to build a tunnel under it too. That or Hamas are mermaids. Israeli worshippers will say they’re mermaids
@@hysteri which hospital was close to the sea?
Did you know that the hospital hamas claimed an israeli airstrike killed 500 people is completely fabricated? Look at actual photos, the damage is pathetic compared to what an israeli airstrike does, zero damage to the hospital, just a courtyard that is scorched with burnt out cars. No crater at all.
And it has been debunked that it was a jihadi rocket, a Hamas rocket that malfunctioned and fell in the courtyard of the hospital. So keep reading BBC, Al Jazeera, NYT and their bull shit😂
@@hysteri israel supporters are mostly bought
There was. This is litteraly what Hamas does, they put it in civilian areas so people like you look at it and say “Free Palpatine”
Don’t let yourself be manipulated, the IDF is an extremely careful but powerful force, they do NOT want to hurt innocent palestinians.
In the Israeli media, around November, someone published a survey saying the 70% of Palestinian support hamas.
Please don't say "Palestinian aren't hamas" if it's not the truth.
See that’s just not how it works. Firstly you can’t just say “someone” you need to say who. Secondly Israel has been known for lying, in fact I’ll tell you the name of a study done and you can check it out for yourself. IMEU HISTORY OF ISRAELI DISINFORMATION
FREE FREE FREE THE HOSTAGES!
As a Christian, While I’m against Hamas, I am praying for both sides to end this war. The civilians do not deserve this.
@@Amirat-ax3 they quite literally said "I am praying for both sides to end this war. The civilians don't deserve this" if that's not a clear statement of wanting peace and non-violence idk what is.
Fyi: israel is arming azerbaijan against orthodox christian armenians. So
I dont agree with war crimes but both sides, but I support palestine, in my experience muslims have been more respectful and tolerant of me as a Christian than isrealis or Jewish people have, when i went to palestine on a religious pilgrim i was spit at my jewish people
@@Amirat-ax3with this question, are you implying that christian’s are not humans?
@@BuddhaMelffyQueen praying isn’t enough I think if you saw the children suffering. West needs to send medical aid to both sides. Not warships and ammunition.
as Vietnamese ... I hope the best for Palestine people
Palestine and Vietnam both are victims of American backed war crimes.. also Afghanistan is similar to Vietnam aswell
Tunnels are the best for resisting occupations
❤❤
@@GoingToAFuneral this war is in no way backed by the US, the US is the only reason a ceasefire and hostage exchange occurred, the US is the only reason the war has been contained and not spread through all of the Middle East, the US is the only reason Israel has taken measures to reduce civilian casualties. Vietnam is also incredibly friendly with the US and is in good terms in both military and politics. You have absolutely no idea what you are talking about
@@reberror7942Your president literally said that they will support Israel with whatever it needs as long as this goes on like weapons, planes, money etc.
Israel hasn’t taken measure to decrease civilian casualties since the death toll in 2 months is higher than Ukraine from early 2022 till now. So either its cap or your country is doing a bad job at it.
Besides, what does Vietnam having good relations with them now have to do with how they were treated 50 years ago?
@@reberror7942 not really u.s is the main reason this shit happening specially when u.s spend trillions of dollars puting it self in crushing debt just to save israel that way politicians realize the only way to get rid of israeli government is to harm u.s and its interests i mean my country iran spends alot of money to make a military industrial complex just to rival u.s and steal the u.s costumers in a hostile take over
Go to a protest on a US college campus. Ask a Palestinian immigrant student if they will denounce Hamas... overwhelmingly, they will say "no".
Cause Hamas is Israeli 😂
I think it’s a pretty safe bet that you haven’t been to these protests or talked to the students.
Having a camera pointed at you is now “violence”😂😂😂
imagine if someone kept a camera in your house, constantly surveilling you 24/7. Yeah, im pretty sure you wouldn't be so peachy after that, would you?
Social media when October 7th Isreal get attacked:😢😢
Social media when Palestine get attacked for 70 years: 🫣🫣
Agreed
Gaza wand trust attacked recently it got attacked for a long time I can even see soldiers joking about this
Yeah western media wants Israeli freedom although 100% of Israeli supporters can’t get there butt of the computer and go protest
Guess the six days war don't mean shit
So you must have missed quite a few massacres and wars to make such an incorrect statement. It could not be more twisted.
NOT one word from your ancestors when Israel was attacked by all surrounding nations while Egypt had the strip and Jordan had the West Bank? What have you been taught?
YES, October 7th was unfathomable. Maybe look up the footage. And YES, one baby was baked in an oven. It was confirmed. By the way, October 7th is not over. Hostages are still missing. Hostages from multiple nations. Maybe not yours?? People from all over the world were killed by terrorists.
Israel has been attacked. The descendants of the people who were persecuted and expelled from the same land. They were attacked before the current state of Israel was declared.
War is awful yes. Hamas not protecting their people is the reason, yes. But in your statement, the only thing that makes a bit of sense, is admitting they were attacked Oct. 7th. Therefore, self-defense. NEVER AGAIN means NEVER AGAIN.
Please look at the past wars, and multiple massacres. Then make an accurate statement.
GET ISREAL OUT OF THEIR HOME NOW
Imagine you get bullied by a rich guy for you're whole school life and on day you slap that guy and the whole school calls you violent kid
👏👏👏👏👏
You call rape and murder a slap.
@@dragontyrant5607what about killing the Palestinians for 75 years straight? Nonsense 😡
@@dragontyrant5607 me when I speak but have no evidence
Typical western mentality. Hang by the sideline while the bigger one bullies the smaller one, then when the smaller one bites back it's suddenly bad.
You can see this mentality play out everywhere. Even in schools where the bullied kid gets reprimanded the moment he bites back at the bully.
No idea where the twisted mentality comes from. Probably some twisted sense of protecting bad people so they're at least nice to you.
Fun fact: Israel and the Israelis existed in the region first, but were destroyed and scattered by the Romans
So what these protestors are saying is that if Ukraine goes on the offensive and starts capturing Russian territory, they will support Russia?
You put your boot on someone's neck for 75 years and expect him to just be cool with you?
The same misguided fools who said no to the UN in 1948 when offered a Palestinian State of their own much larger than Israel today. The same Palestinian Arafat who said no to the West Bank and East Jerusalem.
He did not understand
you pretend that all of Israels Arab neighblurs have attacked it hundreds lf times since day 1, in the form of terror attacks and with full on militaries, Yom kippur or 6 days war fkr example, or the countless Intifadas.
Mmm nope. Palestine was a province of the Ottoman Empire, they sided with Germany in World War 1. If you participate in wars and you LOSE obviously there are consequences. Choose your allies carefully next time
Who invaded who in 1948 and 2023?
crazy how pro-palestinian supporters have to condemn hamas about 50 times in one statement whilst stating their own views.
These days the pro Hamas people mix in with the pro Palestine people like a mixed drink. It’s hard to pick them apart sometimes
It's strange. I've heard the "We're not defending Hamas, but..." kind of statements a lot lately. It's usually followed by a defense of Hamas. Even stranger when polling data shows a huge majority of the West Bank believes that what Hamas did on October 7 was a good thing. Gaza doesn't even hit 60% in support of it - this was from late last year if I recall.
I don't know where I stand on the conflict. To be fair, I don't think most who talk about it have a position either - they pretend to because it's in the news. All I'm saying is that if you claim to support Palestinian rights, then don't support a group that uses Palestinians as human shields.
Edit: I mean "You" in the general sense, not the OP.
Meanwhile slavery in africa 🌍
@@thebleckBieber45 meanwhile, my comments disappear. Hmmm.
Oh yeah, and don't forget the Rohingya. Ignored or turned away by everyone.
@@BiggestManOnCZcamsThere would be no Hamas without occupation, oppression, apartheid and genocide by the Israeli regime for 75 years against the indigenous Palestinian. The IDF are responsible for war crimes. Do you condemn them?
80% of Gazans support Hamas....
The Palestinians helped Hamas for years to build the thousands of miles of underground tunnels!
nope. hamas used aid money from israel that was intended for civilians
@@Andrew-hf31mq This is even worse
@@shellya66 exactly
Just to inform its NOT a WAR It IS a GENOCIDE
You're right. What Hamas did was quite genocidal.
Explain how it is a Genocide when Israel kills Palestinians in Gaza but does not kill any of the 2 million Palestinians in Israel. Lol is that like a half genocide or something?
@@GenghisKhanPolitics😂😂 biggest joke of the year goes to you my friend 👍
@@soledout6776biggest joke is you my friend
Genocide is defined by The UN, “…a crime committed with the intent to destroy a national, ethnic, racial or religious group, in whole or in part…”
“Give me liberty or Give me death”
~Patrick Henry
'Both the oppressor and the oppressed must be liberated' ~ Nelson Mandela
Guess the Hamas got the latter
Because Hamas have been attacking Isreal for decades... Palestinians voted for Hamas... so most supported Hamas...
Really?
If you say you will give them freedom then they will support you and vote for you.
How difficult it is to understand?
Or you stopped being a human or started believing that only you have the right to be free?
Change your mind please and do what is right.
Free palestine =no hamas. No attacks on Israel. No Iranian threats.
Peace for all.
There hasn't been an election in Gaza since 2006.
Half the current population were not even alive in 2006 so that half didn't vote for Hamas .
In 2006 70 percent voted for Hamas who were eligible to vote . There are also a large number of younger adults who make up the current Population of Gaza who were too young to vote back in 2006 .
So in reality about 75 percent of the current population in Gaza didn't vote for Hamas in 2006.
How do you vote out a party that doesn't hold elections ?
The people who voted for Hamas didn't really like or support Hamas . They voted for them out of desperation and saw them as the lesser of Two evils .
@@adamwatson6916 You also forgot to mention prime minister Benjamin propped and funded this so called "t***ist group" for years in order to make a 2 state solution impossible. It's not even a conspiracy, there are enough research articles from reliable sources on this very matter.
They have every right to fight back against their occupiers under International Law
Z1onists are ignorant. Hamas is founded in 1987. Israel have been treating Palestinians just as bad before that.
no one is free until Palestine is free🇵🇸
Social media before October 7th: 😊😂
Social media after October 7th: 😡🤥
Fact 😅
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
I hate palistine
After 1948?????
Social media has ben 😡🤥 for ages now. My entire feed is always full of people shitting on one minority or another.
Remain silent when kids sleep, not when they die.
👌
Are u hating on him or what cus he literally said that aplestine just wants freedom
@@OscarFootball9233Palestine never existed. It was a construct of British colony. Just like the Romans they hated the Jews so they created Palestine.
i agree, but i just dont know whats going on so i stay silent
@@OscarFootball9233Palestinans don't want freedom they've have 10 chances at freedom.
It really makes sense that the UN exists, I don't see the benefit for the people, it is rather an expense in which it is not known who the beneficiaries really are.
All I know is I saw with my own eyes Palestinian flag waving and joyous celebrating here in USA right after the October atrocity. How can I forget that? They’re not Hamas but they don’t really condemn Hamas either so
Did you watch Star Wars and cheer for the empire?
@jimsanfrey6385 false equivalence fallacy. Are you happy, innocents died?
@LeanForLife989 oh spare the ludicrous outrage amd over reading of what was stated... that is not what the dragon stated or even inferred. Perhaps if the Palestinians didn't vote Hamas, the terrorists, in thier govt perhaps things would be different
@@jimsanfrey6385Yeah I did watch it was mid tho
@@LeanForLife989 no, we're not happy... But did anyone give a shit for 75 years for innocent palestinians who died, were kept in prisons concentration camp, made homeless.... And the innocent Israelis live in their land and their homes peacefully ,while their military continues to kill and terrorize these people for 75 years...oct 7 was sad however did you expect peaceful protests and love by Palestinians at this point
Hamas would not have exist if israel never attacked palestine
Yes but if not for israel palestine wouldnt have existed well ever
@@idk-yj5zfWhat?
@@Covid-bv4hp in 4tg century the romans changed the name of the land from israel/judea to syria-philistina to mock the jews but the philistines werent arab the arabs came in the 7th century
@idk-yj5zf ethnic groups move. Claiming land because your ancestors had it is the quickest way thousands of people die, just loom at the Yugoslav wars. Sorry a mediocre kingdom was destroyed almost 2 thousand years ago but that doesn't justify the things the British and Zionists did to the Palestinian people.
Sure it wouldn’t 😂
The most majority of Palestinians are kids
Cause the adults are jailed or dead
Thanks to Apartheid
Being raised from birth to hate and murder their Jewish neighbors by groups like Hamas. There has been lots of reporting on this for many years.
True most Palestinians are youth and your beloved regime is bombing indiscriminately bombing them and their families, And you wonder why they take up arms against you after 75 years of this never-ending cycle.
@@xvphysics673 : Civilians in Gaza are not bombed indiscriminately and certainly not targeted by the IDF. No nation tries as hard as Israel to avoid civilian deaths when striking back at terrorists who use civilians as human shields. It's Hamas oppressing the people in Gaza. Israel just doesn't want to be murdered by groups like Hamas, rightfully so.
@@ricfax But what about what the IDF has been doing for decades, that is bombing innocent Palestinian people? If they want to stay away from killing innocent people, they wouldn't be sending missiles and have war on the borders of Gaza.
Palestinians voted for Hamas to rule them by over 75%. How is that not supporting them ?
Tell the whole story.
It's lies and repeated lies all the way down.
U cannot separate Hamas and Palestine ..what u even talking about
As a Native American, I understand the pain of being dragged thru the mud to make way for other societies
Preach
Meeting one of you would be an honor
@@Itchy1958do you know what the word “indigenous” means?
@@Itchy1958wait, what? Who are you referring to?
@@Itchy1958 As far as we know the american indias are the closest descendants of the first american settlers, thus they are the natives and inheritors of that land. Just as the first Europeans were black people who migrated from africa, and their descendants became the inheriors of that land.
Funny how we hate HAMAS, rightfully, but never ask where they came from or what is their origin.
jordan
Action always have consequences no one wakes up in the morning and decided to be a terrorist Palästina where oppressed for decades
adolf hitler came from austria, do we stand against austria?
@@spaghettiwithmelatonin3312Austria started WW1, and yet the Allies blamed the Germans.
Israel literally created and funded Hamas
Shouldn't the people be fighting Hamas? It seems that they do support Hamas.
The world will remember Israel very, very differently 50 years from now
No one ever in history has received their freedom by talking nicely to their oppressors.
Staring a fight then losing then crying about being oppressed is because you did it to yourself
@@yshouldifoogle6724 sounds like your history started October 2023. Excellent job ignoring what's been happening up to this point but can still remember the holocaust in detail.
Yeah, puff your chest to look tough, then cry when you're in defeat... As you're safe and sound, nowhere near Gaza.
And don't talk about history bias if you're doing it as well. We can go waaay back if you're playing that game.
Canada, Australia, and New Zealand. And oh yeah, Israel. All got their independent countries by talking to Great Britain.
Did you forget about the Oslo Accords? The had freedom but..
Currently, most Palestinians support Hamas
Like 99%.
Most don't even want to talk about hamas and act like no one rules palestine 💀
@@arminiuszmazowszanin267080 percent. But yeah, still a majority.
Yup😒
Many Palestinian problems with hamas loyal. Troublesome!
@@IPoopOutHailwe never recognized any central authority period
Palestine needs land and NEEDS FREEEEEEEEdom
🇮🇱: Offended at everything. Ashamed of nothing.
Those people who said its all start from 7th oct is like people who start watch straight to season 7.
No one has ever said this.
Okay so its started in the 1929 Hebron Massacre.
Season 1 title- How Arabs occupied Juda land and playing victim.
@@vivekrajeurshere's a scenario, could the ppl u call invaders be children of the j from 1000s of years ago, just converted sometime in history. U do know ancestry is traced through 🧬. Just because j roamed those parts of the world, doesn't make every j nat1ve🧬 there. Wh1te South African converts have no 🧬 ties to the j you speak off
@@vivekrajeurssince when have poles and brits been nat1ve to Africa? Ancestry works on 🧬 not what or who u believe in. E.g African cath0Iics have no link to wherever the first of their faith Iived.
What's the percentage of Is reali ppl that can trace their family history there at least 3 generations before the 0cupatl0n? Reason I ask is the "invaders's" can trace their history and lineage there going back more than 10 generations
free palestine. Palestine has the right to defend itself.
but... Hamas attacked first.
you know history exists before october 7th right? @@eliherzog6208
@@eliherzog6208t Without hamas in the west bank, palestinians are still killed.. kicked out of their homes, injustice, locked up like criminals since 70 years ago. and you say hamas started first? very funny..
@@eliherzog6208yeah, palestine declared war first.
No they r trying to steal their land first...
The only reason the place is a prison is they consistently act like they belong in a prison.
Israel 🇮🇱 for the win!!!🙋♂️
Palestime have the right to fight to fight back
Then so does Israel.
@@bennettbush3906
So you are saying an oppressor should have have a right to defend them self.you are delusional
@@bennettbush3906 no , it’s not their land , they are literally stealing it from the native people who lived their before you were even alive! You should go educate yourself, you don’t know half the horrors that the civilians of Palestine had faced ! Go see the children who lost all their homes and parents! And go see the Israeli kids
@@bennettbush3906no it is our land what do they fight for??
There was an Israeli state more than 3000 years ago long before the Arabs ever entered recorded history. Let alone the Muslims 😆
"When injustice becomes law,
Resistance becomes duty"
- Thomas Jefferson
How to lose credibility in 30 seconds?
Violence requires physical force. Cameras are not violence. They are surveillance. Surveillance is not violence. Words are not violence unless they’re written on a brick.
Thank you. This video is awful.
My dude needs to read a bit of philosophy, foucault maybe LOL
Fingers are not a fist… it depends on how you hold them and what your intent is! Your logic is flawed. You aggregate when it suites you and isolate when it support your false premise.
Fail!
Israel is cancelled - 2024 Zionism is hate speech!
I thought it was to support Hamas
Damn right
Long live Israel
Ohhh then how can we call Netanyahu???? A Terrorist or a crime minister?????
I agree!
War criminal - Didn't he and his buddies butcher a entire village and parade their kids and women on the streets as trophies?
He's the trump of Israel but still better than Hamas
heck no hes not better than hamas@@jj-mcgreezies
Warlord criminal
HAMAS members are simply the poor kids who go orphaned, when they grew up they joined hamas to avenge their dead families and loved ones
still, it doesn’t justify killing innocents
@@Danny-fh7qu i dont care about ur opinion
u condemn hamas for 7 october attacks but not israel for 75 years of genocide?
@@HalalUser_1602 another reason why a lot of people don’t like u, you’re rude. and i never said i don’t condemn israel because naturally i would. but hey, my opinion doesn’t matter does it
@@Danny-fh7qu nice compliment
@@HalalUser_1602 you’re welcome 😁
So if palestinian isn't allowed to fight back, how do you suggest they should do?
American brain washing 🧠📈
West bank where there is no hamas or resistance normal civilians still get killed
in europe ISIS killed thousands.
in Syria also, arabs fighted arabs.
in Iraq
in Egypt
all this massacres done by no single jew
and all this terror group was DELETED out of earth by the country millitary. but lets believe Hamas is a resistance... ya sure, how prefere rockets over food. you are blind
Hamas exists in the west bank. I mean the PA hasn't held elections in nearly 2 decades because they (Fatah) believe hamas will gain control.
Additionally Fatah has its own issues when it comes to israel relations and overall is only seen as moderate because hamas is a radical genocidal terrorist organization.
See controversial pay for slay
Good joke no Hamas in the west bank
@@TheIdo14Everyone knows that there is no Hamas in the west bank. Are you brainwashed or a Hasbara member?
@@nafmee I live near the West Bank. Plus you can see all the Hamas flags and weapons in the videos that shows the prisoners return to their home so youre not fooling anybody.
As a Filipino, from what I've seen, the Israeli government treats Palestine is the same way China treats the West Philippine Sea. They decided that they should control this area and if anyone speaks out against them, its because of discrimination and not any wrongdoings they've committed.
Everyone keeps saying that Hamas should have expected this retaliation, but can't you argue the same thing against the Israeli government? After years of opressing and blockading millions of people, shouldn't they have expected that eventually some of them might fight back?
Yeah I would fight back if I'm in that situation like imagine living in open air concentration camp where basic necessities like food, water and electricities are being controlled by the more powerful group, everywhere you go will fill with the arm soldiers who could take you away whenever they want if they find you irritating them, and the settlers not all of them but mostly would become violent no matter you're a child or not and assault you, but you have nowhere to report the crimes. No one on your side, no safe place that you could go. You could get bomb anytime yet you still have to be in your home because it's the safest place.
@@zjeee you mean the terrorist organization that Israel funded? Ya maybe don’t give terrorists money.
@@zjeeewhat a terrorist organization??? At least someone does something for those Palestinians suffering from decades . Hamas soldiers lost their family children..many of them grew up seeing their people suffering because of Israel. What should they do?
@@Beef-mutton-chicken-oh1wz the terrorist organization that israel aided. Hamas.
The guys who ruined Palestinians chances to become more.
those guys.
@@zjeee umm basically hamas exist because of what the Israel do to them for decades. If I'm not mistaken, they exist 39 years after the displacement of Palestinians in order to fight back against Israel.
You got one thing wrong: The vast majority *ARE*. It's an overwhelmingly supported local government. There were mass celebrations after atrocities.
This guy is a gaslighter.. he gave 20%facts 60% npc talking point and 20% propaganda nonsense
He just mentioned the actions of Hamas since October 7th, israel killed 27k civilans, since the october 7th and way more civilians since 1948. The Palestinians have the right to resist and defend they're land. Israel has no right to steal the palestinian houses.
fr, as if he was born literally yesterday
Im surprised theres no Israeli bot here yet keep informing everybody man I myself question if im right but these comments like yours makes me realize once again how oxymoronic they are
This video is from October, not from yesterday.
Hamas quiere exterminar a todo occidental no musulmán en esa área. Su causa no es la libertad, es religiosa.
That’s what happens when Hamas hide underneath their own people and use them as meat shield. Hamas know it’s one of the most populated places on Earth, they know it will cause Israel to accidentally kill civilians when really there trying to kill Hamas. Hamas are brainwashing their own people to making people think they’re good.
You don't need to be a Muslim to stand up for palestine, you need to be human.
Thank you i dont understand why people dont see what the Israelis r doing!!! It makes me mad
It is Muslims who invaded the lands of Christians and Jews (in the 7th century for
the first time), Muslims are the invaders/occupiers/colonisers. Muslims were
killing, oppressing, enslaving non-Muslims for 1300 years. There is already a
Free Palestine for Muslims, it is called Jordan.
@@Saly24211exactly. Hamas is only doing this in self defence. why dont people see what Israel's government has done to the Palestinians. the Palestinians wake up to teh sounds of bombs not birds and it's been like that for 70+ years. Palestinian has no clean water, healthcare, transportation or anything. what hamas did to Israel is NOTHING compared to what Israel's government did to Palestine.
@@Saly24211Thank you I don’t understand why people don’t see what the Palestinians r doing!!!! It makes me mad
Have you ever seen Satanyahu's giant wall cutting them off from their aeonic lands -- or heard of Sabra and Shatila? The bombing of Beirut, then known as "the Paris of the Mideast"?
People forget there was no Palestine before 75 years.
No person would accept living like the Palestinians and not fight for freedom. We all understand how sacred freedom is
Yet Israel has given Palestinians freedom and everytime bombs go off in Israel killing civilians. Israel restrained itself. The gloves are off now.
really???? the American Indian was, is and does....the way you change things is NOT killing women, elderly and children....
Then they should have chosen peace in the beggining? 😂 they literally have full autonomy in their own lands. Egypt and their other neighbouring muslim country are the one that is giving them a harder time. Israel literally build a wall to palestine and Gaza becaude of yhe constant threat of suicide bombing that already had thousands of casualty. They are given billions every year to develop their land and to flourish and yet its israel fault?? Egypt is the one blockading their port in gaza not israel to begin with. Egypt literally built a border against any palestine. This is the same with jordan. Why its so crazy that people are blaming israel. 😂 when they are only doing is literally defending their own country and keeping them out. They have no control on their airports and their ports. They can do literally anything they want. And crazy how people claim israel is committing suicide when palestine has had a steady growth since 1948. Literally the opposite of genocide.
They voted for Hamas. They hide Hamas. They celebrate Hamas. How are they not supporting them?
@@0MeganewguyYes, free Palestine from hamas, and let isreal protect them.
When israel killed thousand of people every week they call it for defense but when palestinian fight back they called it terorism what a double standard, showing how disgusting human being can be
It's the exact opposite. Hamas murdered 1400 men, women, and children on October 7, and shamelessly tortured and mutilated countless others. Israel has the gall to defend itself, and the whole world stays that they are "oppressing" the innocent Palestinians.
Israel doesn‘t kill 1000s of people every week🙄
Every week? Cite your sources.
@@joe5hm03Olas imagination
@@joe5hm03 if they can freely kill hundred people a day so they got thousand people to be killed in a week
The same Palestinians celebrated 911 then voted in Hamas after.
Hamas does a worse barbaric and horrific act and they celebrate in the streets again.
finally an comment that learns history properly and not tiktok
If an occupied is terrorist then what about occupier?
Nah, the vast majority of Palestinans I’ve spoken to here in Canada during the protests we had support hamas. You can’t fool me.
Well do you support Palestinians freedom?
@@alexshane297
I support the right of conquest, Israel conquered Gaza & West Bank. You seem to forget that Israel returned Gaza & West Bank to Palestine(I wouldn't have done THAT) in exchange for peace but did the Palestinians give them peace?
Simple business transaction. If one side fails to honor the deal, then the deal is off.
@@eelchiong6709 If you support the right of conquest then also support "N@ZI", right? they also conquered!!!!!
So what do you want them to tell yeah we support the occupation ??
@@eelchiong6709Yeah but Palestinians right there in the West Bank are still living under apartheid and arresting w/o going under a fair trail even teenagers are not allowed to bring their parents ??? Oh and Gaza they always bomb them every now and then waaay long before October 7th
Youre forgetting the past 75 years man!
Freepalestine 🇵🇸
in 75 years palestine had about 5 opportunities to become a staste but there leaders always chose terror instead of two states, israel is not going anywhere and a free palestine is a palestine that will choose peace
All unity opportunities u said got rejected. We just doesnt know it that the opportunities concluded. All becuz the Western dark agenda.
@@segevsames5 opportunities to do what? To agree to a "solution" that already intended to put them at an disadvantage the first time? Have you ever read carefully what the two state solutions offered by Israel contained? You think anyone who is sane in the head would have agreed to give their oppressors also a legal way to f**k them over forever after what happened in villages like tantura ? Cause that's what would have been happened if they signed that presumptuous resolution. When the PLO was getting back some of the Palestinian land that had been annexed by Israel earlier( in a peaceful and also rightful way), there was no Hamas, no Palestinian terrorism even tho they went through horrible things for years. And yet netanjahu decided to create hamas in 1987 and NOT the Palestinian people.
@@segevsames exactly
@AbhijeetKundu and yet herodot called that region „palaistine“ 500 years bc. Coincidences❤️
Why’d they vote for Hamas?
You would think the people would have a say in this
The Palestinians have the right to defend their land. You killed the people, displaced them, abused them. What did you expect them to do?
Exactly.
You're equating Palestine with hamas
50/50 in 1948. Started 3 wars lost all of them.
If someone attack and steals your home yand you just sit and watch@@arindamchaliha292
Israel bought the land. Palestinians should have moved on. 💙🤍🇮🇱💙🤍🇮🇱💙🤍🇮🇱💙
Why is everybody acting like they have so much information on this subject?
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Let's not forget Hammas is the elected governing body in Gaza and is widely accepted by the Palestenian people.
Except that there's many factions in hamas and the central bodies for it might not have control of the ones that have attacked.
Well of course!
I guess, if Hamass is the only body who opposes the immense Palestinian land reduction, is like if I'm going to take away your home...
In 2006
@@MAC...what are you making up bro, hamas is Gaza and they all love what the sick terrorist did, they don’t want peace they just want to destroy Israel.
Yeah but no people don’t pick the government rich people do.
Correction: that whole land is Palestine, it was stolen gradually throughout the decades
Nope the land was owned by the uk and they gave it to Israel
@@ak8.014 Owned or subjugated? Come on… where got white people own land besides from stealing
There's no proof that there ever was a State called Palestine
The land was Judea before stolen by Roman Empire. So originally it was the land of Israel, then legally given by the Ottoman Empire, nothing was stolen. You just feel that way but it’s false
Palestinians have never run a country.
To call it their land starts off the argument incorrectly
No such thing as palestine
Free Palistine 🇯🇴🇮🇳 from India
wrong flag my friend that is jordan this is palestine 🇵🇸
India send aid to Palestine and so what is your point ? India sent nothing to Israel
Kashmir…why doesn’t India just give that right over to Pakistan then?
🇵🇸 this is palestine.
🇯🇴 this is jordan.
They dont have the same flag.
From map
When I was a freshman in college we had an Israeli on one side of the floor and a Palestinian on the other. Our whole floor was freaking out thinking there was going to be some huge animosity between them but they actually connected and were good friends. Funny how the tension between them was created by folks who only watched their conflict from afar.
that is true in more than a few cases, the problem is with the macro and gov's
i myself (an israeli) have had pretty good times when i interacted with Palestinians when i studied engineering. How did i manage that was simple, i just treated them as human beings....
Hope everyone that reads this will have a nice day.
Free Palestine from Hamas
@@Antihistamine88 NAILED IT!!
@@amirg7225 I vote you for president of the world. That’s what we need right there.
Good story. That said the actual animosity between *the states of* Israel and Palestine is very real and goes back to atrocities committed against each other in the early days of Israel's formation as a state, the Arab-Israeli wars, and the illegal occupation of the Palestinian territories. You know - REAL issues and a history of violence. Glad to hear your two classmates could get along though.
The fact that this was posted like 7 months ago is terrifying. How are people so slow to react?
There is a tiny tiny legitimate movement inside the international movement.
Debating Hamas and Israel whilst kids get blown to pieces everyday.
So, wanting to spread more information about the conflict is now a bad thing?
So that completely justifies murdering and burning kids alive ok.
Give me serenity to accept the things I can't change. The courage to change the things I can and the wisdom to know the difference
@@miagatwa2457no, but nothing is changing
When people and countries are picking the side like the days meal, it is pretty good to debate and discuss it
Calling every Palestinian "hamas" is like calling every(ww2) German a "NAZI" .
Right! Great analogy
@@SJ-oxypeople are dying and you're making food jokes . Get help
He said EXACTLY the opposite. He said that it's important to be clear that NOT all Palestinians are HAMAS.
Its not stopping radical moslems from branding every jew as a zionist. They have different standards when the victims are not moslems.
@@proudkaafir5126 notice how you say the radical ones as in not the whole group are you aware that muslims practice different sects of the religion
Hamas is Biden
Americans are Palestinians
We didnt know what we were getting ourselves into
The new generation doesn't understand..
You can see that it is unfair: when not even the one-sided, propagandistic reporting in the USA can convince the public of the opinion.
Christians don't come out and protest but there's a hell of a lot more Christians than there are anyone else in America
The Palestinian rhetoric is just as one-sided. There is a middle ground and compromise would be possible if both sides weren’t so angry, traumatized, and one-sided
@@alyboatright the one-sided Palestinian rhetoric??
@@alyboatrightNo, it is not.
@@alyboatright What are you talking about? What is one sided? There is only one truth. An entire indigenous Palestinian population was violently attacked, r*ped, and k*lled and expelled from their homeland in the late 1940s by a group of Zionists who in 1948 established a State which then allowed millions of European refugees to colonize their land. If you have no clue about the history of the creation of the State of Israel and the Nakba that followed shortly, just say so. There is no two sides to this, there is the truth and a lie made up by Zionists that claims that the land wasnt inhabited.
My parents used to tell me to never bring up anything to do with israel near my grandfather (may he rest in peace), which when i grew up i learned why, my grandpa was a survivor of the qal-qilyah massacre, he had watched as the israeli soldiers lined up the men before gunning them down, which had included his best friend.
And how do you think Israeli people see after Militiamen gunned down innocent babies?
Palestinians ARE Hamas - they say so themselves.
Shut up, there’s only Palestine
Imagine some group from your own people, who fight for you and your own land, called terrorist by a person who dont even feel your pain.
@@ScilliRhexi6344look up the definition of terrorist and then look up Israel, and what they've done.
@@xatime2833Hamas openly targets civilians to gain bargaining chips in a war they cannot win and their stated intent is to destroy Israel and the Jews. Israel targets military infrastructure hidden in civilian infrastructure, does not publicly seek the destruction of Palestinians and in fact wants to be at peace with a Palestine that is not ruled by a political party/terrorist group that holds on to power by halting elections.
Imagine your land which your parents and your grandparents live in it for "centuries" get invaded by british empire and then they give it to another humans whoes grandparents and there families never leved in this land before, won't you try to return your land??
And why the terrorism of Isreal get ignored and the palestenians resistance become the main focus???
@@Xx_hassan_xX Jews also lived there for centuries. Tell me when was there a palestian state before 1989
@@FrenchRajinMapping
Actually I don't care about this argument because no one will change his belief by YouTupe comments.
For me it is fine if you support the peace and fairness, understanding something wrong dousn't mean you are evil.
Both of us support different parts but both of us support the peace and hope for the better to the right side
The problem is that hamas actually represents gaza they ARE the elected government
That should be pinned comment
@@zoltrixzoltrixlmao do your research
They were elected by a small plurality almost two decades ago. 70% of Gazans are under the age of 30. Do the math.
@@linusmlgtips2123this, + the median age in Gaza is 18-19
How is that a problem though? Would they rather Hebolah represent the Palestinians?