Justice Must Not Only be Done, But Must Also Appear to Have Been Done: Justice Chelameswar
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 04. 2018
- Is the CJI keeping other members of the Collegium in the dark? Why did the four senior SC judges hold that press conference in January? Should the CJI be impeached? Justice Chelameswar answers Karan Thapar’s questions
Video: The Quint
LEARNING :
"There's great way of doing small things, there's small way of doing great things. " 👌👌
"I don't agree with you but I will protect your right to say so"..!!! Great lines..
We need more judges like these in our country. True to their profession.
Divya Jain Never take them by the words.... it can decieve
abhinav kumar indian people are very emotional and are always fooled by emotional melodrama . Deepak mishra was the cji even before 2014 and bjp forming govt then mr. Chamaleshwar never had any problem , only after formation of govt he started having problems with deepak mishra
akanksha singh .....before 2014 he was not dancing on government stage ......before 2014 he was exercising independently.....
Kudos to your bravery sir...I wish Indias youth gets inspired and b fearless when it comes to injustice... as Gandhi ji said Darr sabse Bada rog Hai...
this is may be the best conversation on democracy... a Senior Supreme Court judge is helping us out to understand the judiciary. wow!
sorry to be so offtopic but does any of you know a way to log back into an instagram account??
I was dumb forgot the login password. I love any assistance you can offer me.
@Dax Chase Instablaster :)
@Milo Hugo thanks so much for your reply. I found the site thru google and Im in the hacking process now.
Seems to take quite some time so I will reply here later with my results.
@Milo Hugo It worked and I actually got access to my account again. Im so happy:D
Thanks so much you saved my account :D
@Dax Chase Happy to help =)
When Judges like you take stand, belief in judiciary restores.
He is best judge in our judiciary
Man He is really Talented ! Hope He becomes CJI soon...!
nayan bukane dear he is retiring for good in June July this year, maybe next lifetime, ok Nayan ji...🙄
Mathson Mathai The current CJI is I believe biased
nayan bukane well..Duh..!!
Nope he will not, Technical issues.....
nayan bukane where is the talent?
What a candid interview. I really appreciate his straightforwardness.
Straight and to the point, Justice Chelameshwar.. he knows what he is doing, and doing so in such a way, that it hits the right notes wit the right people.. there will always be a bunch of clowns questioning Chelameshwar's role or whom he met, but the word is clear about his stance and the problems which exist in the judiciary today..
Justice Chelameshwar seems very clear and straightforward with what he's trying to say. I felt Thapar was quite poor in this interview trying to twist words and act smart - very amateurish performance for such a senior journalist.
bn9891 if some one is of such a talent nd honest .....what rather ed u do......I don't think he twisted something......but surely he wanted to corner him into something.....nd tht thing is a distant eternity as far as discussed conversation goesm
That's known as being devil's advocate. This form of questioning is necessary in a democracy irrespective of the personal views and inclinations of the interviewer.
I would not say amateurish.. He is brilliant. It's his way of asking questions.. he just wanted to make it all clear. for public, of course.
IN THE VERY FIRST PLACE judges of supreme court should not stoop to appear before MEDIA, that in itself is flagrant violation of judicial ethics,he can be impeached on this score itself.
Thapar was not poor. He was sitting with senior most judge, The judges is confident what he talks about. He is well composed and controlled what he answers or leaves. Any other journalist would look same in front of him
Very erudite Judge,a man of simplicity and integrity
Bold judge ,i am proud of you i hope new generation will learn from you how to be bold and transparent and not get dictated by one person ,well done .............
Not many knows he had done great service to the country by by judgement on freedom of speech, I'm instant fan of his wisdom... Great men like him are needed, salute🙏🙏🙏
Politicians are sold out, administrative staffs are sold out, police are sold out, media is totally sold out. Judiciary is the one and only hope we have, the pillar that still stands upright. Even if its slow and some times biased against the poor and weak, we Indians irrespective of our languages, religions, caste, gender.. We put our faith in the Judiciary. Because if Judiciary is also sold out, then we have have no hope for the nation. Please don't let Judiciary, or at least the upper echelons of Judiciary but come corrupted and politicised. Stand with justice. That alone will do.
Tom
as you said .... all systems are failing....
this nation is getting super-critical
all failsafe are failing. ... only this last one remains. judiciary. but it too has started corroding. .... all thanks to a certain some party n its ideological believers.
the day this last failsafe blows.... india will cease to exist the way it is.
it will crumble, and breakup into petty states and fall into chaos . have you seen some middle east nations just dont exist anymore.
amazing what vision the Chai wala has
This exactly is why the people have lost faith in this Government....fuck the pm fuck the government
DEVL SLYR ....can you elaborate what you mean by "waiting for next Prophet Muhammad" ?...
You might have no upadated knowledge...its there where you are thinking that it is not there..i hope you got it...
This bloody bugger Chalameshwar is the only Mofo who didn't obey CJI when he said all judges need to come in summer aborting their summer leaves because of high pendency in SC.
This type of judicial machinery which is still in colonial hangover and work for not more than 100 dyas in an year is a Greatest Sin and injustice to the citizens of India.
Please check SC calendar for 2019.
Profound, erodite and precise.Justice Chelmeshwar indeed a great personality.
Pride of Andhra Pradesh.
Great journalist with honest judiciary person
He is there one who insured that Indians freedom of speech..... Which govt opposed a lot....
Saurabh Anand 😂😂😂😂😂😂
This guy.... Im speechless .. he is smart n witty ... No doubt he is at such a high position ... Nice ... Truely brilliant .... Clear minded sir .. i have not heard him very much but this much was enough to show how brilliant person he is
Why Modi ji please stop polluting to judiciary system. U brought media now u wanted to buy judiciary... Please stop.
siddharth wadgavkar he is polluting the nation as well
Modi and Amit shah polluted the system to the core...cbi, judiciary,ED, etc...your Modi showing Hindutva card for votes and using Indian army also for mileage...
U all stop giving him brutal majority.
Justice the only medium where whole India believe...we want honest judge like you
All judges are as corrupt as any other judge
Bhishm Kapoor
whas logic behind it..
Madhav Tiwari sir he have given judgement on medical college problem in mp he give judgement to form commit but cji as reverse the judgement how can we trust cji now he is honest only
Mohammed boss
this government is threaten for democracy... before 14 no one question about cji but in this government even judes of supreme Court told democracy is in danger.....so we need change in 19 election
If same judge who gives clean sheet to mecca majsid bomber then you will say democracy is dying :p
Really people like judiciary only when the judgement it is on their side :) It's not about BJP or Congress. Same congress is happy when 2G scam prosecutor has given clean sheet.
We people should accept the outcomes, no matter we like it or not.
IT CELL IS active to make anti national for this judge I am proud of you sir you come public told what is happening in our supreme court
Truly correct value of justification of judgement guideline no 9
Watching this in 2019
Proud of you sir
Salute🙋♂️
One of the most self assured men ever.... Owned Mr Thapar through out the interview...
mithun murali there was nothing to be owned.. He answered questions bravely, given the ruling cowards in executive
that is what is meant by "owned Mr Thapar"...he answered all his provocative questions with the prudence and eloquence of a seasoned jurist
The most vocal justice SC ever had.
His personality says everything , honest judge .
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️great justice...
Man of knowledge, wisdom and truth...
Very good interview
OMG!!! Thanks Quint for this video.
Pure wisdom and sheer intelligence
love you Quint for sharing great interviews of Great people.
keep going
Justice must not only be done but must also appear to have been done ..justification its merely true
Judges must refrain from interacting with public outside court. They need to find a remedy within their system to clean up the mess,and avoid washing dirty linen in public.
I can say he is best justice in India
The occurrences of certain events in respect of the judiciary which indicates that the govt is unduly interfering with the functioning of the judiciary, it is the duty of the people to dislodge such govt.
Looks like... first time the Judge is being Accused by Someone...😂😂
shreyash Chaudhari yes it's a serious situation for Indian judiciary. But remedy must come from within and not from the public or media.
Justice chalmeshwar is far better than Modi, justice chalmeshwar in his limits, whatever he could do, he is doing it, respected you sir.
His thought process is crystal clear. Respect to institution of justice.
I recollect Justic Chelameswar having been extremely effortlessly gutsy enough to remind the prime minister (Mr. Modi) who was sitting on the podium with several others, in front of a large gathering of people from the Supreme court, of the pathetic state of infrastructure in the Supreme court itself.
That was the day he became one of the many people I admire.
This talk shows his sharpness and straightforward method of speaking facts.
Hats off to him and people like him.
50 years later, people will be cursing folks like Narendra Modi, spitting on people like Amit Shah, and will be speaking with appreciation about people like Justice Chelameswar. As for Arun Jaitley, he will be as less discussed as many of the ministers and cabinet of the 1960s whose names we today don't even know!
Just need honest judges like you sir🙏
The supreme court has to become transparent. It can't stay closed out of a misplaced sense of judicial independence.
wow! such a wise and talented man we have in Judiciary.Thats why we trust our judiciary.He deserved to be the CJI
I still can't believe the fact that interviewer is one of the great journalist of India.
he is absolutely right
Where is the full interview
Current CJI and Justice Chelameshwar were appointed on same day to Supreme court... So that Justice Chelameshwar should not become CJI because of less experience in High Court...
Z
थापर जी को नमस्कार
आप द्वारा लिए गए इन्टरव्यू बहुत ही प्रभावी एवं भविष्य के लिए भी अच्छे पथ प्रदर्शक लगते है ।अच्छा हो अगर हमे इनका हिंदी अनुवाद मिल जाए ।
धन्यवाद ।
Nice discussion 👍
it was great to listen your conversation who are at top of the two institutions of our democracy
Awesome reply for all questions..
Courageous man. Thanks for your time
A true Gentleman. A Briliant Judge. Atleast someone should raise voice against the partiality.
This what we all need to know what is happening in our country no media so called "godi media" reports such incidents on television bcs they did not want us to be aware of such reports makes us away from such reports nd puzzled in Hindu Muslim topics...due to this we all are facing today a very serious problem of communal rights , unemployment ,corruption, economy falling down gradually, in hunger index today India is 100th position from 110 countries which was below Pakistan #shame on government
Thank you. Quint..you are the one... maintain unbiased...whoever is in power
Met Honourable Justice when he visited our college as Chief Guest ☺️☺️☺️😊blessed
one of the best jurist ......
जज साहब बाहर निकलिए ओर पूरा पूरा सच 2 टूक जनता के सामने रख दिजीये।
We need more judges like him..
Really we missed you as a CJI Sir.. Its a India's Bad luck.
Hope the CJI soon....salute
Sir your views are always great to save our constitution. You are just different from all others. I like your sir.
Bad luck that you could not be given that much deservation for your merits.
All the respect to Honble Justice Sh. Chelameshar . You were so calm still very very effectice.
जनतालाई न्याय जनता कै भाषामा ।
He is nice justice
a true soul .. god bless you
you are the best judge i have ever seen.🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏.
Very intelligent judge
wid grace🤗🤗👌
This fellow must be thrown away immediately out of the court.
Now, Justice Ranjan Gogoi is the member of parliament (MP) in RajyaSabha.
Thapar is interviewing one of the best judges of the supreme Court of India, it is not so easy counter him. Justice Chelameswar😘
Justice chelmeshwar was admittedly a big & judge of impeccable judicial integrity but they have not told the country that from whom democracy is in danger,they made press conference only when CJI neglected them from important cases alloting cases to Junior judges not for the public issues pending during their times,babree mosque was demolished only when Supreme Court permitted kar seva otherwise it is on record that most senior lawyers cautioned SC,the story goes upto Raffael,EVMS & VVPATs,with the case of lady employee who alleged against CJI Gogoi the last golden dictum that Caesar,s wife must be above suspicion is gone,public is getting educated,atrocities in the name of judicial independence is not going to last forever,aura can not be imposed on public by might of state through police or favouring the political masters,naked truths are surfacing vastly,oath to constitution doesn’t make a person upholder of majesty of constitutional values,it only saves one from direct prosecution like common man molesting the law
Ur the best sir
Role of judiciary democracy
This legend of jounalist deserve to interview such sinor judge
🔥🔥🔥
He should have been the CJI... 😟
Xelent...
Did you asked him about “Not before me” ? They are useing it to escape from few cases to deliver through them? If any judge purchased corporate company’s shares and at the time of their case hearing , last minute disclosed of the same and askeing to shift case to another judge ,..saving / favering corporate houses?
The appointment of judges should have a change..IJS (INDIAN JUDICIAL SERVICE) should be there like IAS..IPS..IES...there is a suggestion in the original constitutiin but so for its a dead letter...to become a smaller most judge ue JFCM ...competitive exam is there with nearly 30 major and minor acts as syllabi...to become an ADJ competitive exam ...but to enter higher judiciary why not a competitive exam....BECAUSE all NATIONAL parties wants to keep judiciary under their control....this selection process has a different competitive exam that syllabi will not be notified it depends upon individuals nexus with XYZ...(you can interpritate this at your own choice of WORDS) ...in our country so far higher judiciary has been filled on the basis of ancestral grounds ...just you can check it out by going through the list of judges since the days of independence...PRESENT APPOINTMENT SYSTEM IN HIGHER JUDICIARY MAKING THE SYSTEM MORE DEPENDENT but not INDEPENDENT...if the exam is kept like ADJS 99% of the bench comes out and has to sit in the BAR ....i am writing all this to make the future indian JUDICIARY brighter...more democratic...INDEPENDENT...i wish to see intellectual brains in the higher judiciary ....from inside the sytem there is a lot of tug of war between the political parties to plant their men in higher Judiciary ....WITHOUT TALKING ANY THING ON THIS PARTICULAR POINT EVERYONE TALK TO PROTECT THEIR INTERESTS...so much to say but i have my own work....YOUTH OF INDIA WAKEUP AND QUESTION THIS AT LEAST YOU CHANGE THIS AND SAVE JUDICIARY....demand for IJS...
He should be made president of India so that he can take revenge on mishra.this Mishra should be taught a stern lesson by public flogging with live worldwide TV transmission.
Hmmm...
What's happening in this country??
Really a thorough gentle judge
What a man. True human i must say!! Nd after that i m proud he ia an indian
न्याय के देवता my lord....
He should have been the CJI. He might have brought some landmark reforms in the judiciary...
In current situation / in Modi regime and under such circumstances , i think next CJI certainly not Justice Gogoi , though he is Senior most and meritorious
How about you publish the video without any editing?
There are people who say that he is a great judge, there is no doubt in that. But the dissent in NJAC was also noteworthy. We need separation of powers in our system. But that doesn't mean that the creatures of the Constitution will become superior to it. There has to be a check on each organ be it the legislature, judiciary or the executive.
Legend
Very nice person.
Justice Chelameswar is tHe reason wHi i believe in constitution
We are sorry honourable justice chalameshwar sir , we the people who voted those thugs to power and all this is happening because of that big mistake of us. That's it the only last hope was judiciary and now that too is in danger . This country is not for good and honest people .
😢
To be very honest- Justice Chalmeshwar sounds like a Superme Court of India and he proved that he was not a Supreme Court Judge just for a heck