Were Muslim leaders against partition? I 1947 PARTITION I MUSLIM LEADERS I MAULANA AZAD
Vložit
- čas přidán 26. 08. 2021
- Were Muslim leaders against partition? I 1947 PARTITION I MUSLIM LEADERS I MAULANA AZAD
क्या मुसलमानों की तरफ से विभाजन का कोई विरोध हुआ था? उन मुसलमानों की तादाद कितनी थी? वे कौन से मुस्लिम नेता और संगठन थे जो विभाजन नहीं चाहते थे? देखें सच का सामना। एक विशेष श्रंखला जिसमें वरिष्ठ पत्रकार मुकेश कुमार और प्रो. राम पुनियानी भारत के इतिहास से संबंधित गलत धारणाओं और तोड़े-मरोड़े गए तथ्यों पर से पर्दाफाश करेंगे
Was there any opposition to Partition from the Muslims side? What was the number of those Muslims? Which were the Muslim leaders and organizations that did not want partition? Watch Sach Ka Saamna. A special series in which senior journalist Mukesh Kumar and Prof. Ram Puniyani will expose the misconceptions and distorted facts related to the history of India
सत्य हिंदी ऐप डाउनलोड करें गूगल प्ले स्टोर पर - play.google.com/store/apps/de...
Support True Journalism
Join our Membership Scheme: www.satyahindi.com/membership...
स्वतंत्र पत्रकारिता को मज़बूत कीजिए। ‘सत्य हिंदी सदस्यता योजना' में शामिल हों: www.satyahindi.com/membership...
इस कार्यक्रम पर अपनी राय contact@satyahindi.com पर भेजें।
#MuslimLeaders #1947Partition #SachKaSaamna
बटवारा हिन्दू मुसलमान का नही था सत्ता के लिए स्वर्ण हिन्दू और स्वर्ण मुसलमानों का था जो पाक से स्वर्ण हिन्दू भारत आया उसने यहाँ राज्य किया जो स्वर्ण मुस्लिम पाक गया उसने वहां राज्य किया। दंगे में एक भी सवर्ण नही मरा था।
स्वर्ण मुस्लिम ye ky ahai Islam ko jati swikar nahi hai!
@@jiti5034 भारत के इस्लाम मे मुसलमान है ये कन्वर्ट हुए है और अपना वर्ण और जाति लेकर गए है।
@@premnarayansachan6968 Lekin woh manege nahi .. dosh sirf Hinduoko denge LOL
I am proud to say my grand father who was a political leader in that period and he strongly opposed formation of Pakistan
He opposed Jinah and supported to be remain in India
Thanks Dr Mukesh & Dr Ram Punyani🙏🙏
Professor Ram Punyani is a very honest and knowledgeable person. 💐
Mukesh jee. I am very much agree with your thoughts about partition of india before and at the
Time of partition
Ram punyani ko apne naam. Se Ram hata dena chahiye.... Bharat ke log buddo pe jaldi vishavs kr lete hai..... Ek gunda aur badmash jab budda ho jata hai india me. Respect mil jata hai use bhi
@@narayandas2803 makhi siirf ghaw per baithti hai apne demag ko sochne ki aadat dalen behtar hogo
@@mdmobinmdmobin4499 videshi dharm ko manane wale gaddar hai.
@@narayandas2803 aap ke demag men jo dharm hai wo bhi videsi hai to keya sbhi gaddar hain
Dr mukesh ji or prof puniyani ji ko saadar pranaam aap dono nay patrician ki sahi tasveer dikha di sawarthi na udhar kam thay na edhar kam thay unko satta mele aam jan ko kabhi bhi na sahnay wala dard thanks 🙏🙏🙏
Ek dam jhuth bol raha hai .proof magnitude. Azad shahin him self got defeated.
Mukesh sir aap ka shukriya🙏
बहुत बहुत। साधू बाद। सत्य इंडिया को
बहुत अच्छा और सही वास्तविक जानकारी आप द्वारा नई नस्ल को दी जा रही है। well done.
Mukesh ji well keet it up for truth as your channel name best of luck
Politicians mislead people that Muslims are responsible for the partition. Thanks for clarifying that Muslims were against partition
Correct. Only dogs and cats living in West India wanted to call their country Pakistan
@@jamesbond4045 correct. Cats and Dogs have also started to write useless comments and express their lunatic mindset for which I am compelled to reply
Thank you professor Ram Puniyani Ji for your valuable knowledge so you can tell us the truth 🙏 and thank you so much dr Mukesh Kumar ji for this program 🙏🙏
मैंने इस श्रंखला के लगभग सभी वीडीओज़ देखे हैं ! इत्तेफाक से इन दिनों मैं विभाजन पर 2 किताबें भी पढ़ रहा हूँ ! Freedom ar Midnight " तो मैंने पढ़ ली अब बीजेपी के वरिष्ठ नेता मरहूम जसवंत सिंह जी की लिखी " Jinnah India-Partiton Independence " पढ़नी शुरू की है !
लेकिन मुझे आप से और प्रफेसर राम पुनियानी जी से ज़्यादा बेहतर ढंग से जानकारी मिल रही है !! इसके लिए मैं आपका और सत्य हिंदी डाट काम टी वी चैनल का आभारी हूँ !!!
"Opposition to Partion of India " great information on record and excellent quality work of scholars of high caliber.
Sir you are doing great job, please keep it up
to desh kaise bat gaya ha jayda musalman batware ke support me the
Punyani sir aur Mukesh sir, aap dono batware ki sachchai ko logon k samne la rahe hai, aap dono ko salaam..
Kash goodi media is sache patkaar ke raste pe chale
पता नहीं क्यों मुसलमानों को लोग बदनाम करते हैं, जबकि पूरी दुनिया में वो चैन अमन से रहते हैं।
Thank you राम पुनियानी सर
Kaha se study kiya sir
I am getting lot of new information as well as different perspectives. Handfuls from both sides augmented by British to control subcontinent were responsible for this . Fair or not is always debatable. Now I want to know about the stand or views of Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar on this 👍🙏
Yes babasaheb wrote a book named which comes in 21 volumes be babasaheb ambedkar. Book is india and its partition in this book babasaheb had mentioned an incident where he met jinnah in the aisle of today parliament where he again requested him to drop idea of pakistan because a nation which is founded on the basis will no longer sustain in future and we already witnessing state of pakistan. Jai bhim jai bharat.
@@SherSingh-vf3eb I want to know his total process over the years before reaching any conclusions. Especially from Mukeshji and Puniyaniji.
It was not british control but it wS time fir britishers to chale jao movement
प्रो राम पुनियानी जी केलिऐ
ओर
सोशल मीडिया प्रभारी डा मुकेश कुमार
इंटरव्यू सत्य पर ले रहे।
आभार प्रकट करते
ईश्वर से लंमबी उम्र दे
और सत्य को प्रस्तुत कर रहे
बहुत सुंदर
जय हिन्द
Sir aap ka bahot shukriya aap purely truth history explain kar rahen hain bahot si jankari mil rahi h
Professor has great knowledge of history and always comes up with truth.
पिचानवे प्रतिशत मुस्लिम ने पाकिस्तान बनाने के पक्ष में मतदान किया था और एक रात में ऐसा दिल बदला कि उनमें से बहुत से भारत में ही रह गये सरदार पटेल ने खुद बताया कि भला एक रात में ऐसा कया हुआ कि दिल बदल के यही पसर गए
Follow Kangna Ranaut , you are intelligent enough to explain history 😹😃😹😹😃😃
Thank you. You opened me eyes, I was think that demand of Pakistan used to Muslim.
My
My
.
@@ajarkolhapur9202 ji
Good 👍
Dr Mukesh ji Apka dhanywad
बहुत ही अच्छा काम कर रहे हैं आप लोग ।
आपकी उमर मे बरकत हो 🙏🙏
Partition ke liye jitni Muslim League zimedar hai ,us se ziyada sawarkarwadi zimmedar hai ,lekin ab inki satta hai ab yeh deshbhakt aur bilkul doodh ke dhule ban gaye hai
Thanks a lot for fair debates...... I am from Pakistan..... I got lot of information.... first time i heard truth from indian Media. india was good country.......please debate in next session. why, when and where are started misunderstanding between different religions in india. Thanks.....
Because of the elite class in both hinduism and Islam, like rss vis-a-vis muslim league
Excellent
Thaks.sir.salam.aapko. puniya. Sahab
मुकेश जी मैं आपको बताना चाहता हूं कि पंजाब व हरियाणा उस समय का पंजाब से बहुमत में (ज्यादातर ) मुसलमान पाकिस्तान चले गए थे चाहे वे असरफ या गरीब कोई भी हों । पूरे गांव के गांव उठ कर (उजड़ कर) चले गए थे । आज के हरियाणा से रोहतक , हिसार करनाल , जींद और अम्बाला जिले के सभी के सभी को जाना पड़ा था। किसी से विकल्प नहीं पूछा गया था ।
Good information
Very nice and interesting debate puniyani ji views and thoughts are outstanding
क्या आप यह कहना चाहते हैं की भारत का बटवारा हिंदुओं ने कराया। भगवान ही मालिक है ऐसे विचारवानों का।
ये सच बताना चाहते हैं ,
50% अंग्रेज , 25% हिंदू सांप्रदायिक , 25% मुस्लिम साम्प्रदायिकता विभाजन का कारण बने। आम लोगों के पास कोई विकल्प नहीं था ,केवल विभाजन विभीषिका झेलने के सिवाए। जिसका दिवस , समारोह आयोजित कर आप मुसलमानों को ज़िम्मेदार बताएं।😇😇😇
Bahut bahut shukrya Sr Sach dikhane k liye
Mukesh Kumar is a fearless& bold journalist
Great program 👍
गजब की जानकारी मिली
आप बहुय अच्छा काम कर रहे है।
Good
Thanks
I am very glad to know that history of Muslims Desprem
RSS की भूमिका पर भी बोलें
Bahan aap shayad rss,se hain,to suno.......
RAMAYAN AIK MAHAN MAHA GRANTH HAI,JISKI shuruaat hi SHAAPSE hoti hai,shravan baal ka shaap,
Bhagvan shriraam khudbhi aur apne pitakobhi nahi bacha pate,
To bekasur muslimoko moblinchingme maara ja raha hai,
NRC ke bahane bhartiy be kasur be gunahgar muslimoki nagrikta khatm ki ja rahi hai aur detention centre me dalkar maara ja raha hai,
Kya inka shaap nahi lagega ,rss,bjp valonko,
Bravo" thanks for bringing true facts for us.
Bahut hi shandar charcha
Mukesh ji aap ka ye kadam journalism me hamesha yaad kiya jayega
Kyonki aap bahut rochak tareeke se vistar se jankari de rahe
Iss kaam ke liye hum sab ahsanmand hain
70 saal me achcha nahi to galat bhi nahi bataya gaya
Par 7 saalon me itni galat bayani ho rahi ki sabko sach kya tha yahi nahi samajh aa raha
Satta ne Charon taraf agyan aur jhuth ke ghore chor diye hain aur jhuth ka hi vistar ho raha
Itni mushkil ghadi me aap sahi jankari de rahe
Iss ke liye hum hamesha aabhari hain
Bahut shukriya
God bless
सबसे बड़ी बात यह दोनो इतिहासकार नही है। केवल एजनडे के तहत झूठ बोलते हैं।
Follow Kangna Ranaut 😹😃 मे
Nice information towards partition thru This Vedio Hats off to Ram Puniyaniji & Mukeshji
Sirji kabhi aap dono direct action 1946 bangal ki baat karege
Mukesh ji 1 program RSS Ka azadi me contribution aour partition me roll per rakhain
Thanks
Ram puniya ji providing the good information this current situation, Muslim stay here by choice not by selection,This side Muslim always love to India
Muslim religious leadership was against partition is partially correct. After all, it split up ummah in 3 parts. If you add up Muslim population of India ( about 20 crores ), Pakistan @ 23 Crore and Bangladesh@ 20 crores, it adds upto 63/65 crores. As against that non Muslim population will add up to barely 110 crores. Thus Muslim population would be close to 33 percent plus So a mere 14 percent population is intransigent enough in India. Imagine condition of united India where Muslims were 33%.
Now I got got confirmed from your logic ,Muslim were against partition !! it’s the Hindu mahasabha and RSS we’re behind indian partition!!! Since partition protected the hegemony of hindu in India .
Jai abul kalam azad......amar raho
बहुत अछा किसा है जी
Very grateful information thanks sir
Facebook pe bhi upload kare in episode ko
Allah aap Dono Ko hidayat ata farmaye.Aamin
Bilkul sahi baat thanks mukesh ji👍🙏
Aaj Kay is daur may aap nay jo sahi cheez batanay ki kosish ki hai uskay lieay dil day shukriya.Umeed hai Bharat zinda rahaeygha
Allah salamt rakhay
Dr Punyani is a secular man
I like this vedio .very good & neutral based on reality vedio
Maulana Abul Kalam Azad wasn't a Indian. He was Turkish who migrated to India at the time of khilafat movement.
People can see the names of Muslim freedom fighters on India gate. 2/3 name are Muslim names
85 soldiers have been killed by the Britishers In 1857 revolt of meerut in which majority of soldiers were Muslims.. Total 52 soldiers were Muslims
Sir, No doubt i always enjoy your program. As because you are informing true history to the new generation so automatically a duty comes on your shoulder to say true story about the Taliban.
Here i want to refer a book " Taliban the true story world's most feared guerrilla fighter" written by James Ferguson.
Dear Ram punyanisahib and Kumar sahib,I am a Pakistani by birth.I often listen to your programmes.Recently your programme on partition on 13-1-2023,Ram punyani and you did not mention the rollof congress in partition.QuaidiAzam Muhammad Ali Jinnah was also against partition.But attitude of Hindues specially towards Muslims was lukewarm.Even the Hindues attitude in Nehru report and their refusal to kmuslim demands proved a last nail in coffee of Hindu Muslim unity.pls comment.
Bahut khub sir yai hai patition ki asliyat......
.
It was the British colonial sub continent that was partitioned. From the British colonial sub continent 2 Sovereign independent countries were born in 1947 August. Plz. Just go through the book " India Wins Freedom " by Maulana Abul Kalam Azad and another book " Partition of India Legend and Reality " by H.M. Serwai, former Advocate General Maharashtra and get convinced who were the persons who are responsible for the partition of the British colonial sub continent before turning an accusing fingure against All India Muslim League and its veteran leaders.
🙏🙏
Very good information
समस्या वहा नहीं थी जहा मुस्लिम अल्पसंख्यक थे क्योयकि उन्हे मालूम था हिंदुओ के साथ रहना कितना सहज है
समस्या वहा थी जहा मुस्लिम बहुसंख्यक थे
उनको खुद के लिए एक पृथक देश चाहिए था
नोआ खाली दंगा
मोपला दंगा
वहा हुए जहा मुस्लिम बहुसंख्यक थे
आज भी कश्मीर को लड़ाई देख लीजिए
North Western Frontier Province ke pathan Pakistan banane ke khilaf the.
Sir apka episode bahut achcha he but thoda voice ko clear aur loud kar le please
I went through Wikipedia only two names who opposed partition.The general elections held in 1945 for the Constituent Assembly of British Indian Empire, the Muslim League secured and won 434 out of 496 seats reserved for Muslims (and about 87.5% of Muslim votes) on a policy of creating an independent state of Pakistan,
Please read about voting power. Zamindar & Nawab had voting power. Amma muslims doesn't have vote power.
@@farhathafeez3397 yes about 14%
Muslim conference ke Shekh Abdulla ka aap naam nahin le rahe hain. Baad ki ghatnayen to durbhagya purn hain.
Fair view channel n excellent anchor mukeshji n punyabi saab
Truth is opened
Aap.dono.ki.samaqj.ko.salam
Thanks for telling the truth.
Lekin, kya NAFRATI party ke suporters is TRUTH ko accept karegi? Kyoki inki satta palat jayegi.
Both this duo rewriting history a fresh.& if muslim were against pakistan.then how it was formed.these are leftist journalism.producing distorted history
Ager batwara na hota Muslim Hindu milkar rehte .ladai jhagda hi na hota.
Aur ek sab se Vishal taqat war mulk hota
मुकेश जी किसानो के साथ लाठीचार्ज किया गया है उसे क्यो नही दिखा रहे है ।
Ham Bharat Wars kee Musalman Kabhi Bharat kaa batwara Nahi chahtey thee.Even Deoband kee taraf see uswaqt fatwa bhii Aya thaa kii Bharat kaa batwara gair Islamic hai.Jai Jawan Jai Kisan.Jai Hind.
Mukesh jee sacchaee batane ke liye sukria
Very informative video tnx..
Thank you
इसके लिए सबसे सैक्यू्लर जवाहरलाल नेहरू के लिखी हुई किताब डिस्कवरी पढ़ सकते हैं देश के बंटवारे की कहां और किसने तैयार की अब आप लोगों को गुमराह नहीं कर सकते बहुत सारे तथ्य मौजूद हैं।
You are doing great job 👏
Ram punyani is lieing.
@@vaibhav6222 point out the lies
MK Gandhi was against those Muslim leaders who were against the Partition and promoted Jinnah and Azad. Bux, the chief Minister of Sindh was against the Partition, he was killed by the Muslim League but Gandhi said nothing. Fazal Ul Haq wanted to form a coalition government with the Congress Party in 1937, Subhas Bose was very interested but Gandhi opposed it. Haq formed a coalition government with the Hindu Mahasava of Shyama Prasad Mukherjee in 1941. Baluchuistan wanted to join India in 1947, but Gandhi rejected that after consulting Azad.
Good very good discussion literate views
🌹
Good information.
Aap ka bahut bahut shukriya
Full of truth analysis .
The division of India approved to be very harmful for the Muslims .
Gujranwala Pakistan .
Jinnah & Nehroo ko bahkane me sabse bara hath ( scandal) lard mount batin katha
Usne Nehroo se kaha tha ki jinna itna kabil hsi tum iske samne tik nahi paoge & jinna kobharkaya ki majority hindoon ki hai isliye tum prim minister kabhi nahi ban sakte
Jinnah bahut pahle hi politically zero ho gaya tha
सच्चाई पर पर्दा डालने की भी हद होती है आप दोनों तो उस हद को भी पार कर गये।
💩🐗💩🐗💩🐗💩🐗💩🐗💩🐗💩🐗💩🐗💩
Try to read M J Akbar's Gandhi's Hinduism Jinnah's Islam,how time and again Jinnah trashed Gandhi in Gandhi's efforts to block the creation of Pakistan . Jinnah would refer Hindus as subhuman . British had a big hand in the creation of Pakistan and made hints to Sikh community for separate homeland.
No use wasting energy in the past .Let us take care of present not to repeat past mistakes and build a strong nation.
'Subhuman' ? What does it mean ?
NATION 🇮🇳 DIVIDED FOR PM
ASPIRATIONS OF NEHRU AND
JEENA TWO ASPIRING TWO
CANDIDATES WAS WAS THE
MAIN REASON
Not true...India was never one country one nation before Mughal and British...
Kuchh Bina malumat ke dushi thhahrate Hain wo log is program Ko zarur dekhen
Jinah aur Nehru Hramkhoron ki wajah se desh ka batwara hua kiun ke dono desh Ke PM banna Chahte the.
आर एस एस की भूमिका पर भी बात करें
Rss eak aatankwadi sangthan hai, ye angrejo ke sath the aur desh ke gadhar aur Gandhi ke hatyare the
Rss mob lynching party h insaan k katter dushman ab inke character k bare m har bacha janta h
किस मामले में मुस्लिम माडर्न है?जो माडर्न मुस्लिम इण्डिया नाम गढ रहे हो वो तो अवसर और सहुलियत अनुसार सदियों पुरानी सरिया के पक्ष में है।
Puniyani ji ne jo kaha usase dhwanit hota hai ki congressi muslimo ne batwara ka birodh kiya kintu direct action ke ek mang par sabhi muslim ek ho gaye ya ander se support kiya..Vote bhi yahi darsata hai.
Good job brother
अब तो हिन्दुस्तान और हिन्दुओं को अपने हाल पर छोड़ दो आज का हिन्दुस्तान केवल हिन्दु राष्ट्र बन पूर्ण हिन्दुओं की स्थली रूप में जाना जायेगा जहाँ केवल हिन्दु को ही ठौर और नागरिकता मिलेगी
Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Extremezum will destroy India
My appeal to Justice and Police Dept Please do Justice for the sake of India