What If Obi Wan Kenobi Had a SECRET Daughter

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 19. 12. 2022
  • What would've happened had Obi Wan had a secret daughter with Duchess Satine of Mandalore
    #skywalker #StarWars #AnakinSkywalker #anakin #starwarsedit #theclonewars #maytheforcebewithyou #obiwankenobi #macewindu #shorts #short
    Community Discord: / discord
    Support the Channel: / ppsw
    Twitch Account: / pentepatrol
    GIVEAWAY: docs.google.com/document/d/1a...
    THUMBNAIL BY: Tilian_Creative: www.picuki.com/profile/tilian...
    Pente Patrol Team:
    Voice Actors:
    Concordia Jedi: / @concordiajedi
    James: / jamesmck345
    Jordan: / @spectrum_country1028
    Silver Bullet:
    Bly: / @jackogeography3950
    Cole: / connerthehonker
    Editors PPT:
    Jakub: / jakeup
    Nnaemeka: nwosennaemeka.artstation.com
    Saito: teambellaro...
    ATLAXS: / @atlaxs
    Writers:
    Cameron Hall: linktr.ee/spproductions
    Support My Other Channels!
    PPR: / @pentepatrolreacts
    PPMP: / @pentepatrolmusicprodu...
    Support This Video's Musicians!
    The Way of Water - • 🎥 Epic & Trailer (Free...
    In Search of Solitude - • 🌳 Classical & Cinemati...
    Permafrost - • 💭 Meditation (Free Mus...
    Fire & Thunder - • ⚡ Free Epic Music (No ...
    Unexplored Moon - • 🌙 Copyright Free Orche...
    Eight Mountains - • Eight Mountains by Savfk
    The Epic Hero - • 💪 Orchestral Trailer P...
    Dunes - • ⏳ Soundtrack (Free Mus...
    Refusing the Ultimatum - • 😟 Tense & Orchestral (...
    Passage of Time - • ⏱️ Cinematic & Backgro...
    Love - • ❤️‍🔥 Romantic & Piano ...
    Resolutions - • 👼 Hopeful & Angelic (F...
    What Happens When We Die - • Sad Soundtrack (Free M...
    The Preparation - • 🔭 Soundtrack (Free Mus...
    Eglair - • 🚤 Epic & Cinematic (Fr...
    Instructions for Living Life - • 🎹 Piano Instrumental (...
    Terminus - • 🎖️ Free Epic Heroic Mu...
    Still A Long Way To Go - • 📽️ Free Film Orchestra...
    Magic - • 🍬 Free Classical Fanta...
    Pirates of the Quarantine - • ☠️ Free Pirate Music -...
    Long Way to Go - • ⛓️ Sad & Beautiful Orc...
    Age of Wonder - • 🌁 Cinematic & Epic (Fr...
  • Zábava

Komentáře • 404

  • @PentePatrolStarWars
    @PentePatrolStarWars  Před rokem +24

    Subscribe and Share

  • @RyanTheDark
    @RyanTheDark Před rokem +556

    I can see Obi-Wan's daughter and Anakin being friends and prank Obi-Wan like siblings. Lol

    • @juanma250297
      @juanma250297 Před rokem +109

      Like using the force to take Obi Wan’s lightsaber and tell him “what’s wrong Obi Wan, I thought your lightsaber was your life” while Obi Wan is annoyed at his daughter and Anakin pranking him

    • @jayparkes1420
      @jayparkes1420 Před rokem +26

      That should be a video

    • @Menhtrol
      @Menhtrol Před rokem +47

      @@jayparkes1420 What if Satine and Obi Wan raised Astrid and Anakin on Mandalore.
      Really want to see that get made into a video

    • @alextheamethyst5262
      @alextheamethyst5262 Před rokem +11

      Girl looks like anakins sister from that one video

    • @mikefishpaugh3672
      @mikefishpaugh3672 Před rokem +3

      I was thinking that

  • @theseekerofancienttruth3873

    There needs to be an "Alternate Ending" Version. Anakin would likely have trusted Kenobi more had he told him thr truth about Satine and his Daughter. This means he would have told him about his Nightmares, and Obi-Wan would have been able to calm him enough to prevent his Fall to Darkness.

    • @graciebrown4480
      @graciebrown4480 Před rokem +23

      I think this would be a lovely story.

    • @magical_universe793
      @magical_universe793 Před rokem +4

      obi wan would never stoop to anakins level

    • @graciebrown4480
      @graciebrown4480 Před rokem +11

      @@magical_universe793 I think he would for satine.

    • @magical_universe793
      @magical_universe793 Před rokem +2

      @@graciebrown4480 why didnt he then?! he loved the jedi order way more than her

    • @graciebrown4480
      @graciebrown4480 Před rokem +8

      @@magical_universe793 He didn't feel any emotions growing up like anakin did thus probably making the feeling of unknown very worrying.

  • @ttlghosty
    @ttlghosty Před rokem +259

    We need an alternate story to this! What if Astrid called Obi-Wan 'Dad' infront of Anakin?

    • @General_Kenobi_212
      @General_Kenobi_212 Před rokem +82

      Anakin and Ahsoka would NEVER stop teasing Obi Wan lol

    • @graciebrown4480
      @graciebrown4480 Před rokem +21

      I would love to see that.

    • @ttlghosty
      @ttlghosty Před rokem +37

      My running theory is that if Anakin knew, he maybe would have consolidated Obi-Wan about him and Padme officially, and spoke to him about his night terrors. May even save him from certain death, or at least being crispy fried!

    • @nearwateryt2070
      @nearwateryt2070 Před rokem +1

      IMAGINE XD

    • @nearwateryt2070
      @nearwateryt2070 Před rokem +16

      Anakin: Bro Kenobi you disobeyed the Jedi co-wait I’m alright with it cuz I’m married to padme

  • @Zminator1986
    @Zminator1986 Před rokem +66

    This is a cute scenario of Obi-Wan having a daughter and getting the life he deserved. Although I do kind of wish that Obi-Wan introduced Anakin and Ahsoka to Astra and see the chaos these three will cause and accelerate Obi-Wan's aging.

  • @nxblelxrdjova7147
    @nxblelxrdjova7147 Před rokem +64

    1) What if Maul was the chosen one?
    2) What if Palpatine cared about Maul like a son?
    3) What if Qui Gon turned Maul to the light before what would’ve been their final duel?

  • @dianesinger9729
    @dianesinger9729 Před rokem +44

    Great story I liked that Obi-Wan and Satine found their happiness in the end

  • @rashworth080
    @rashworth080 Před rokem +86

    I agree with you about Satine being the one to redeem Mandalore. Mandalorians through the centuries have viewed themselves as warriors throughout the galaxy, but to others, they were seen as ruthless conquerors with armor that would challenge a Jedi's lightsaber. Though Satine's way was far from what the Mandalorian way was, that was pretty much the point to renew itself from the feared warriors of the galaxy and stand proud to be peaceful and remain mutual to not make itself a path to its own destruction. But of course, Bo-Katan already pretty much does that at some point during the last few years of the rebellion against the Empire. Just hopefully that during the Mandalorian season 3, Din Djarin and Grogu can help Mandalore become better and make Bo see that the warrior ways doesn't always have to be the way of the Mandalorians. Even maybe make peace with Jedi and they could be great allies instead of enemies.

    • @TheVocalTune
      @TheVocalTune Před rokem +3

      And then Mandalorian Jedi along with Jedi Mandalorian can exist in the galaxy too.

    • @Katelink_
      @Katelink_ Před rokem +2

      @@TheVocalTune this is the way

    • @jasonskeans3327
      @jasonskeans3327 Před rokem +1

      if one is incapable of great harm then you are not a pacifist you are harmless Satine was a bit to extreme if Mandalore had a standing army/defense force then death watch never would have gained control

  • @ch62013
    @ch62013 Před rokem +124

    What if Anakin was raised by the Mandalorians?

    • @jaysuho2917
      @jaysuho2917 Před rokem +11

      Please let there be a story about this and how it can lead to many type of possibilities

    • @Dark_Lord_of_Mustafar
      @Dark_Lord_of_Mustafar Před rokem +3

      I would like to see how that would change me

    • @yoyoyburokoy1337
      @yoyoyburokoy1337 Před rokem +1

      @@Dark_Lord_of_Mustafar Its over anakin i have the high ground

    • @ch62013
      @ch62013 Před rokem +3

      @@Dark_Lord_of_Mustafar There are like all kind of possibilities, but I definitely want to see one where Anakin doesn't need activity bring balance to the force.

    • @Totomy2011
      @Totomy2011 Před 26 dny

      I think I saw a video about that

  • @jskyrim8341
    @jskyrim8341 Před rokem +16

    Obi-Wan would be a wonderful father and I'm sure his daughter would take after him.

  • @shaveyodamust8505
    @shaveyodamust8505 Před rokem +46

    Another great story Pente! I’m glad that you gave Obi-Wan a happy ending with Satine. Best couple in Star Wars. Yes I said the best.

    • @PentePatrolStarWars
      @PentePatrolStarWars  Před rokem +4

      I'm so glad you enjoyed! And yes Obi Wan / Satine all the way!

    • @CAPTAIN-REX
      @CAPTAIN-REX Před rokem +1

      space Jesus and his wife

    • @Sven73524
      @Sven73524 Před 3 měsíci

      This is even more funny considering Christianity is by it's texts A religion all about pacifism and Satine is the most pacifist person in all of mandalore​@@CAPTAIN-REX

  • @chasetauscher9544
    @chasetauscher9544 Před rokem +37

    What if Luke Skywalker was raised by Boba Fett?

  • @satmtca
    @satmtca Před rokem +16

    I really liked Satine’s character cause she is also what Padme is to Anakin and they also go on their own adventures both in the book and show as well.
    I really enjoyed this story and did a great job

  • @cureselene3544
    @cureselene3544 Před rokem +25

    Loved this what if. I was wondering if two possible what if scenarios could be what if Fives joined the Bad Batch and what if Kanan survived.

  • @seekingtruthministrys4119

    Woulda been nice to hear a convo between anaikin and obi wan before order 66 about how their relationships and their children perhaps both leaving the order. But this story was amazing none the less

  • @satinekenobi4ver855
    @satinekenobi4ver855 Před rokem +13

    Lovely story but it’s a shame obi wan never told Anakin about Astrid that could have helped him reassure Anakin that he could help him and understood why Anakin would want to save Padme. Plus I m glad that Satine is still alive in this story because he was completely broken After he lost Satine and Anakin and I always found it so sad that Obi wan and Satine never got to have a second chance at being happy together like deserved.

  • @lottieparish1715
    @lottieparish1715 Před rokem +38

    What if ahsoka Got the powers of the daughter please I’m begging

    • @darthnihilus1310
      @darthnihilus1310 Před rokem +5

      It's on what if films

    • @Dark_Lord_of_Mustafar
      @Dark_Lord_of_Mustafar Před rokem +5

      Nobody gives a damn about Ahsoka

    • @hollunk6969
      @hollunk6969 Před rokem +6

      @@Dark_Lord_of_Mustafar you would say that Vader

    • @BXtr3m3ty
      @BXtr3m3ty Před rokem +3

      Would you chill please?

    • @Dark_Lord_of_Mustafar
      @Dark_Lord_of_Mustafar Před rokem

      @@hollunk6969 Yes! I did. That ungrateful Torguta brat abandoned and betrayed me when I needed her the most. I rejoiced striking her down on Malachor V

  • @benjaminparker671
    @benjaminparker671 Před rokem +25

    What If Satine survived

  • @anthonykodaski6161
    @anthonykodaski6161 Před rokem

    Why are you so fucking good at writing these emotional stories? Seriously you’re really good at writing the emotional bits and reading them.

  • @matthewmann8969
    @matthewmann8969 Před rokem +18

    What if the battle Obi Wan had with Anakin on Mustafar was not a lightsaber, unarmed combat, and or force power duel but one where it was a dog fight on there ships of there piloting skills?

    • @elderliddle2733
      @elderliddle2733 Před rokem +5

      Anakin wins. Kenobi’s piloting skills pale in comparison to Anakin. Kenobi gets frustrated easily when flying, so this would disrupt the fight. Anakin loved the thrill of flying, even as Vader. Anakin doesn’t have issues making risky maneuvers to win.

  • @twebn8r908
    @twebn8r908 Před rokem +1

    You’re a really good story teller. Thank you

  • @locoarticwolf2181
    @locoarticwolf2181 Před rokem +11

    Good for Obi-Wan and Satine!

  • @spencerasakura542
    @spencerasakura542 Před rokem +8

    What if Katooni stayed with Hondo and his crew?
    What if Anakin was trained by Pong Krell?
    What if Anakin fell in love with Bo-Katan?
    What if Padme fell in love with captain Rex?
    What if Ahsoka was count Dooku’s padawan?

  • @mldean50
    @mldean50 Před rokem +6

    As always I love your stories keep up the phenomenal work

  • @eduardoe4670
    @eduardoe4670 Před rokem +4

    Astrid... What a beautiful name

  • @neophytealpha
    @neophytealpha Před rokem +9

    Could easily see Obi-Wan having a child with Satine, and that child was in Jedi training or a Mandalorian foundling.

    • @neophytealpha
      @neophytealpha Před rokem +3

      If she didn't tell Obi-Wan about the child, that child could have been around after she passed and ended up as an assumed orphan and actually ended up as a foundling or jedi youngling.

  • @mr.oddball.
    @mr.oddball. Před rokem +11

    What if Anakin fell in love with Obi Wan and Satine's Daughter?

    • @blinksfandom4370
      @blinksfandom4370 Před rokem +2

      My eyebrow went up like the rocks and I had a slight pause when I read obi wan which led to an oh hell nah

    • @satinekenobi4ver855
      @satinekenobi4ver855 Před rokem +2

      Oh can you imagine it every time Anakin screws up and upsets her Obi wan removes a piece of Anakins anatomy 😂😂

  • @allanwhite5747
    @allanwhite5747 Před rokem

    This was by and large the best story so far, it was beautifully written and told I thank you for the holiday gift and hope that somehow you top it 😊...happy.

  • @MrProp16
    @MrProp16 Před rokem +17

    What if Depa trained Anakin?
    What if The Ones of Mortis raised Anakin?
    What if Galen Marek was Anakin's Padawan?
    What if Obi-Wan & Depa fell in love?
    What if Obi-Wan & Luminara fell in love?
    What if Shaak Ti was the Chosen One?
    What if Depa was the Chosen One?
    What if Depa was Anakin & Kanan's mum?
    What if the Knights of Zakuul were the galaxy's primary peacekeeping force, instead of the Jedi?
    What if Revan was Mand'alor?
    What if Senator Chuchi was the Dark Lord of the Sith?
    What if Shaak Ti went to Kamino with Obi-Wan, in attack of the clones?
    What if Omega was in Attack of the Clones?
    What if Kal Skirata & Shaak Ti fell in love?
    What if Omega was Shaak TI's Padawan?
    What if Depa & Commander Grey fell in love?
    What if Ahsoka killed The Son of Mortis instead of giving him the dagger?
    What if Tarkin was framed for the temple bombing?
    What if Kal Skirata adopted Ahsoka?
    What if Ventress was the Chosen One?
    What if Bail sent the Bad Batch to rescue little Leia?
    What if Anakin was raised in the Eternal Empire?
    What if Hondo was the Chosen One?
    What if Qui-Gon's ghost visited Dooku?
    What if Omega accompanied the bad batch to Onderon?
    What if Dooku & Jocasta Nu fell in love?
    What if Katooni & Petro fell in love?
    What if Hunter & Fennec fell in love?
    What if Fennec killed Cad Bane?
    What if Galen Marek joined the Bad Batch?
    What if Yaddle trained Luminara?
    What if Palpatine & Talzin fell in love?
    What if Dooku was visited by three spirits on Life Day eve?

    • @Totomy2011
      @Totomy2011 Před 26 dny

      How would Galen join the bad abatch

  • @imember7375
    @imember7375 Před rokem +12

    what if barriss offee bombed the senate (maybe killing padme or palpatine)

    • @linda-0587
      @linda-0587 Před rokem +9

      If Padme died….heh, no chance of “Cease Hostilities!” Anakin is straight up Dooku-ing her

  • @danielharman572
    @danielharman572 Před rokem

    Very cool video I liked it a lot. Satine living and also having and raising obi-wan's daughter absolutely brilliant idea. Please keep up the good work.

  • @the.unhappy.mechanic
    @the.unhappy.mechanic Před rokem

    Awesome viedo, great job I never saw this viedo coming.

  • @Shalyse1
    @Shalyse1 Před rokem +6

    One thing I like about these stories is I never know how they're going to go. I honestly wasn't sure how the duel between Vader and Kenobi would go

  • @darthnexus9570
    @darthnexus9570 Před rokem +3

    Wow I'm going to be able to see it from the beginning today...

  • @tianoc-g4811
    @tianoc-g4811 Před rokem

    You should definitely make a Short video of this intro it never gets old and it always makes me laugh every time I see it. Trust me it will be popular!
    Also this Theory I kind of wish was true, it would have been interesting to have this link to Rey making more sense then her being a Palpatine.

  • @benjaminobienu5297
    @benjaminobienu5297 Před rokem +5

    Obi-Wan having a secret daughter from Satine would make Obi-Wan a great father since he cared for Anakin when he was a boy. I really like Satine and Obi-Wan raising Luke and Leia as their adopted parents and their daughter as their older sister. My question related to this video is whether Bo-Katan will be a good influence on Astrid or if she will be far away from her. I like how you made your point of Satine being a well-written character, for she is the savior of Mandalore and does stability to her people. Bo-Katan wouldn't have the chance to do it because she prefers living the Mandalorian ways instead of accepting changes and maybe considering possibilities in the galaxy. Also, I watched the Kenboi show, and it was great you're not the only one who cares about that show this Christmas; I'm going to get the Jedi Survivor game.
    This is a great video, Mr. Pente Patrol; keep up the fantastic work, and may the force be with you!

    • @PentePatrolStarWars
      @PentePatrolStarWars  Před rokem +3

      I'm so glad you enjoyed! I think Bo-Katan could come around, but you never know with her. And I'm glad you enjoyed Kenobi! Survivor will def be a good game too!
      Thank you, will do, and may the force be with you!

  • @sonicforce8302
    @sonicforce8302 Před rokem +1

    Awesome videos as always

  • @ZackarySchejbalCODBO2RGM2

    Anakin: I'm going to have a kid.
    Obi-Wan: Welcome to the club

  • @Rtrstormghost327
    @Rtrstormghost327 Před 10 měsíci

    Welp that was actually heart warming and almost made me cry

  • @fumkioyuki8457
    @fumkioyuki8457 Před rokem

    man this almost made me cry.

  • @savagethepunisher
    @savagethepunisher Před rokem +1

    Obi wan kenobi's daughter: hello there
    Obi wan kenobi: oh Ithey grow up fast.

  • @Ale12287
    @Ale12287 Před 9 měsíci +1

    28:25 given that he was the most wanted being in the galaxy at the moment

  • @seanmalloy0528
    @seanmalloy0528 Před rokem +2

    Very interesting work on this, hope for an alternate ending with Obi-Wan telling Anakin about his daughter.

  • @declanminecrafter828
    @declanminecrafter828 Před rokem

    All I could think after he said he didn't like and then get freaked out by his lightsaber, was : LOL, while I was laughing

  • @dannylopez5976
    @dannylopez5976 Před 4 měsíci

    Love the take on the story, different then what most people would think.

  • @CT--eb2xr
    @CT--eb2xr Před rokem +6

    What if the Yuuzhan Vong attacked the galaxy during the Clone Wars.

    • @CAPTAIN-REX
      @CAPTAIN-REX Před rokem

      so my copy that's not a good idea personally

  • @notapplicable1296
    @notapplicable1296 Před rokem +4

    That was best obi-wan story I've heard

  • @jedi2685
    @jedi2685 Před rokem +14

    Love this story. This is what Kenobi deserved truly. I wish lucasfilm made a what if series like marvel.
    1.What if obi wan Kenobi was framed for the Jedi temple bombing.
    2.What if obi wan Kenobi was Count dooku's son or grandson.
    3.What if Obi wan and Anakin are the chosen ones.

  • @Silveralways1
    @Silveralways1 Před rokem +1

    Your writing is improving.

  • @AlexPerez-yp1mz
    @AlexPerez-yp1mz Před rokem

    This story was a truly aersome, shocking, actin packed, anf sweet near the end

  • @timtam39tw
    @timtam39tw Před rokem

    You had me crying on this one 😭 😢 🤧

  • @KingofFootball663
    @KingofFootball663 Před rokem +2

    Bro this is so cursed obi wan was on Mandalore when he was 17 and she was 14

  • @Allantitan
    @Allantitan Před rokem

    “Except the Dallas cowboys”
    BLASPHEMER!! 😂

    • @PentePatrolStarWars
      @PentePatrolStarWars  Před rokem +1

      See what I did was jinx the eagles, it was a travesty in the making 😪

  • @firehawk7922
    @firehawk7922 Před rokem

    awsome story dude

  • @juanmanuelcardona19
    @juanmanuelcardona19 Před rokem +6

    I have to disagree with Anakin turning to the darkside in this scenario. Obi Wan would tell Anakin about his daughter and Anakin would see that Obi Wan trusted him enough to know something as important as that, so Anakin in exchange for that trust he would tell Obi Wan about his marriage with Padme and when Anakin gets his nightmares, then Obi Wan would help Anakin find a way to save Padme which would lead to Anakin MAYBE discovering Force Healing which would not even be necessary because Pdme ends up having a healthy birth of Luke and Leia so Palpatine's plans would backfire hard and he would be killed by Mace Windu. Obi Wan would leave the Jedi Order to help Satine to teach his daughter about the ways of the Force and Anakin would decline the rank of Master and he would move to Naboo with Padme to raise Luke and Leia and then they would have a third child called Gin Skywalker. Anakin and Obi Wan would remain being brothers in all but blood while the Jedi Order continues becoming more political losing their way more and more. Eventually the Jedi Order would collapse after many Jedi start noticing how the order lost it's way and many Jedi would leave the order after the two poster boys of the order left. Many Jedi would want to make a life for themselves and that woud be one of the biggest reasons behind the collapse of the Jedi Order. Many Jedi would create new Jedi orders all around the galaxy that would be less strict and would allow bonds and love. Luke, Leia and Gin would be trained by Anakin while Obi Wan trains his daughter. Eventually Anakin starts his own Jedi like order with Obi Wan and his daughter which they would lead until Luke, Leia and Gin take their place as the new Grand Masters or the New Jedi order.

  • @thomassicking100
    @thomassicking100 Před rokem

    Best one yet. Love Obi-Wan.

  • @johnpittsii7524
    @johnpittsii7524 Před rokem +7

    What if Anakin fell in love with Dutchess Satine or Bo katan. Also what if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan or Alayua Secura

  • @doujinloverXD
    @doujinloverXD Před rokem +2

    Obi-Wan would have been 14 when Astrid was born, he was 34 - 36 during the Clone wars.

    • @satinekenobi4ver855
      @satinekenobi4ver855 Před rokem +1

      He was 35 when the clone wars started and 38 when the empire came into being. So he would been about 16 to 18 years old when Astrid was born

  • @infinite6458
    @infinite6458 Před rokem +3

    Wow this was really intriguing, you are really good at telling stories. You kinda remind me of another what if youtuber, are you familiar with Missedthepart? He also makes what if video's.

  • @BigBWolf90
    @BigBWolf90 Před rokem

    Obi-Wan: This is the way

  • @kaboom7208
    @kaboom7208 Před rokem

    Loved the video, it was really good, also sorry to be nitpicky but at 13:41 you mention that waxer was in the squad that was sent to mandalore, but waxer died on umbara. Again, great video, love your content man!!

    • @CAPTAIN-REX
      @CAPTAIN-REX Před rokem

      bro it's a what if video like it could be that there wasn't any umbara battle

  • @chrissangenette6359
    @chrissangenette6359 Před rokem +1

    He does her name is Sabine Wren. He went to Satines room for a nightcap after Anakin killed the assassine. They got busy and Satine got pregnant. She gave the baby to her sister to hide for protection who placed the baby with Lady Ursa in clan Wren to protect and foster.

  • @ghostfang1255
    @ghostfang1255 Před rokem +1

    Secret daug- Obi-Wan and Satine already have a kid, who do you think Korkie’s parents are

  • @DLR1997
    @DLR1997 Před rokem +3

    This is going to be good.

  • @darthkuat
    @darthkuat Před rokem +2

    Hey love this what if. A what if I suggest you do is what if Owen Lars went with Anakin to look for Shmi.

  • @stevensmokes5476
    @stevensmokes5476 Před rokem

    Obi Wan Daughter: Hi
    Me: Hello there 😏

  • @pluto5988
    @pluto5988 Před rokem

    Add Shrek "Oh Hello there" into the intro :P

  • @leaaronsanchez
    @leaaronsanchez Před rokem +2

    I think Obi wan loved Jedi Siri Tashi more than he did Satine. Siri was often away on a mission for a year or so so it would be very possible. In fact she looks like Siri Tashi.

  • @anthonytabura6346
    @anthonytabura6346 Před rokem +2

    It would have been funny to watch Anakin & Astrid..
    To play other jokes on her father.
    I also believe that he would have wanted somebody else to train her like Mace or Yoda..
    Not wanting to have a conflict of interest in her training..
    Maybe a fear of being hard or to soft on her..
    It also would have been the perfect scenario for Obi-Wan Kenobi..
    To bring up maybe looking at having attachments to people, relationships what -not..
    Making it much easier for Anakin, to approach the council..

  • @robertruse6552
    @robertruse6552 Před rokem

    I like this story I really do and it would have been interested if they did that for to come the TV show The Clone Wars but they did it I like it because you gave us a glimpse into what it could have been keep up the good work

  • @user-nm1lx8qb3u
    @user-nm1lx8qb3u Před rokem +4

    What if Knox (the blue nautolan boy that Savage killed) survived and was the (hidden) secret love child of Kit Fisto and Aayla Secura but didn't know it?

  • @flynvascense9405
    @flynvascense9405 Před rokem +3

    Dang this is good.

  • @JohnGeorgeBauerBuis
    @JohnGeorgeBauerBuis Před 11 dny

    Usually, poetry in motion involves being blinded with science, but that didn’t happen this time!

  • @CordeliaDoyle
    @CordeliaDoyle Před rokem +3

    It's interesting I came across this video because after completely Jedi Survivor, I'd had a running theory in my own head that Cal is Kenobi's son. And because Cal would have been born shortly before, or right around, TPM, the timelines do kind of add up. Having a daughter who is 21/22 though... wouldn't that mean she'd have been conceived when Obi Wan first came to Mandalore with Qui Gon?

  • @MPhussarW
    @MPhussarW Před rokem +1

    He left for milk

  • @theodorebarton4256
    @theodorebarton4256 Před 4 měsíci

    4:22 the first thing obi wan said to astrid after finding out she was his daughter was to comment on an aspect of something that resembles her mother. So sweet

  • @kevinskywalker5539
    @kevinskywalker5539 Před rokem

    Well, then, she would also pass the kenobi tradition of saying,"Hello, there."

  • @PrestonFitzgerald-nh8zw

    Obi-wan deserved this alternate reality.

  • @danonyt1611
    @danonyt1611 Před 6 měsíci

    Obi Wan being an absolute Chad and ending every single Inquisitor along with Vader, single handedly is really something to me cuz I think Obi Wan is seriously underrated, not as a character ( everyone loves him ) but in how powerful he is

  • @Mori-chandesu
    @Mori-chandesu Před rokem

    I use this trope all the time in my star wars stories

  • @FeuerflockenTv
    @FeuerflockenTv Před rokem +4

    What if Ahsoka and Barris fell in love pls

  • @Kallehson1765
    @Kallehson1765 Před rokem +1

    This is why your What Ifs videos is better than Star wars Theory

  • @Only1199
    @Only1199 Před rokem +3

    What if Vader died on the operating table?
    What if clan ordo and clan fett stopped mauls takeover of mandalore?

  • @samuelcaloracan
    @samuelcaloracan Před 3 měsíci +1

    Day 1: What if Obi-Wan Kenobi had a relationship with Satine just like Anakin and Padme?

  • @JayVanSaxman
    @JayVanSaxman Před rokem

    Darth Sidous the unfortunate.....Lmfao

  • @psykosensei550
    @psykosensei550 Před rokem

    I love these fanfics, in that the concepts are incredibly enticing. That being said though, the amount of bending over backwards that goes into the monologues explaining why some things go the way they do is not necessary.
    Alternate Universes and Timelines don’t need excessive explanations to justify them. Just write what things have changed like it was always going to happen.
    My overall opinion of this one - 8/10 because I LOVE outside the box concepts like these.

    • @Caxkj0
      @Caxkj0 Před rokem

      Disagree, the fact this guy makes the effort to go into detail what causes the changes makes it even better. People like consistency and logic, even in their stories.

  • @havesomeculture
    @havesomeculture Před rokem +1

    Pente pente if it’s convenient for you and if you feel like making it, and can pardon for my past mistakes, pls make a video on the same idea from ‘what if quigon fell in love with shmi’ by fantasy folklore

    • @havesomeculture
      @havesomeculture Před rokem

      Pls take your time and make special care with whatever great plot lines you develop, but pls understand how I see that this change would drive Star Wars to a positive and happier conclusion.

  • @thelumious6980
    @thelumious6980 Před rokem +1

    Woahh I'm sure I missed something, how'd it go from Obi Wan returning to Coruscant to Order 66 happening across the Galaxy
    (Although to my knowledge, I'm pretty sure if Anakin went to assist Obi Wan on Mandalore, the chances are he'd open up to Obi Wan ab Padmè given the fact that it was clear Obi Wan and Satine had something going)

  • @chriskenobi4165
    @chriskenobi4165 Před rokem

    Loved the episode in concept, I’m a big fan of the Obi-Wan and the duchesses connection. but a possible what if Korkie Kryze is or was there son?

    • @PentePatrolStarWars
      @PentePatrolStarWars  Před rokem

      I'm so glad you enjoyed! I definitely believe that, I mean he really looks like the two of them. For the purpose of this video I avoided it because Astrid would've been a twin lol

  • @CAPTAIN-REX
    @CAPTAIN-REX Před rokem

    this man is the GOAT the GOAT

  • @dangerousdweisenheimer5597

    This is my favorite what if Star Wars Story

  • @surferdude4487
    @surferdude4487 Před rokem

    What if the prophesy of The Chosen One is just plain wrong?
    I loved this "What If" Thanks for making it.

  • @keithkahler1327
    @keithkahler1327 Před rokem

    the empire would endure for so long as Darth Sidious remained in the pinnacle of galactic politics

  • @KongTheViking
    @KongTheViking Před rokem

    I’m picturing Obi wan and satine and anakin and padmé being neighbours and all growing old together having BBQ’s every weekend 😂

  • @rektnoob101
    @rektnoob101 Před 8 měsíci

    Great what if
    Absolutely amazing
    Obi wan was a legendary jedi for defeating so many inquisitors and vader

  • @crimsontowers1098
    @crimsontowers1098 Před rokem +1

    Now Anikin and Obi-Wan are dad bros.

  • @dakotalange2858
    @dakotalange2858 Před rokem +3

    What if Jango Fett killed Count Dooku when the Jedi were tricked into fighting the mandalorians during the mandalorian civil war he already killed like 6 knights with his bare hands

  • @JadeYagamiKusanagi
    @JadeYagamiKusanagi Před 4 měsíci

    I loved the drawing of the daughter where did you find it?!

  • @Imagination4all
    @Imagination4all Před 8 měsíci +1

    What if the mandalorians served in the clone wars alongside the jedi as commissioned soldiers? There is a lot of bad blood between the jedi and the mandalorians, so what would happen if they buried the hatchet, served side by side with the clones as an alternative to the jedi and fulfilled their need for conflict. And finally, what would be different if the mandalorians were there when order 66 caused it all to come crashing down?

  • @Setton_Exile
    @Setton_Exile Před rokem +1

    Obiwan has a Son Named Korkie Kryze he’s the Son of Obiwan and Satine