Her Bb4, C5 and C#5 have less rasp and tone!!! (Way better than 2022) Her voice is pretty healthier! And i feel she’s still resting her voice for lovers and friends 👀
It's amazing! You can tell her sounded freer and, she's so confident. She attempted some amazing falsetto runs, so glad she did, and she'll always be one of the best vocalist of the world!❤
I wish she could focus on Vocal Training like she was in 2003. But as I knew and Learned from her, she need something bad/accident happened during her concerts or she got very bad critics to get motivate to sing good. Ussually Mariah will be Transforming into Beast mode. Lol For ex: Mariah on 1996, 2003, 2009, and 2017.
I honestly thought that the Christmas shows in 2022 would be an eye opener or honestly any performance in 2022. None of them were good, at the most they were okay…but none showed her true capabilities. This performance had good vocal moments but she still has some issues and she seemed so nervous to just sing out here. At 3:01 it’s clear that when she does sing out it sounds great. I wish she would just sing out like in 2015 Jamaica show or honestly any Vegas 2016 performance like in Thank God I Found You.
People, why are you hating on Mariah’s vocal condition in 2022 when YOU KNOW that she has been in the studio for the past 2 years at that time recording 3-4 different projects. Mariah has ALWAYS been vocally tired after her recording sessions throughout her career that’s why she was raspy in 2022 ( such as in 1999 and in 2006/2008) ! Now that she had timed to rest the vocals are here
@@charmriah3607 We don't really know that. Considering she seems to have improved, and this is such a short amount of footage... She might be ready 🤷🏼♀️
She’ll never be comfortable enough to sing confidently as long as people are hypercritical of her voice. She’s gonna always dodge notes to avoid being picked apart further. Just let the woman sing how she sees fit. Celebrate her voice for what it is at her current age. We all KNOW what she could and can still do. And no singer sounds exactly how they did 30+ years ago might I add. Not a single one of them. If she decides to stop performing live, blame yourselves.
This perfirmance were from france (Apr 29, 2023) and this performance were from a resort/hotel for a wedding day thats why the stage is small and people keeps talking 😭
I like the way she prolonged the "you" at 3:22 HERO I just hope she wont use any pre recorded stuff anymore and just improvised. People will only drag her to lip sync issues and then she will keep on proving herself if thats the case. She needs to let go of lip syncs.
I honestly thought that the Christmas shows in 2022 would be an eye opener or honestly any performance in 2022 of how bad her vocal condition was. None of them were good, at the most they were okay…but none showed her true capabilities. This performance had good vocal moments but she still has some issues and she seemed so nervous to just sing out here. At 3:01 it’s clear that when she does sing out it sounds great. I wish she would just sing out like in 2015 Jamaica show or honestly any Vegas 2016 performance like in Thank God I Found You.
Yeah I know that her voice was WAY better in 2014 but that was 9 years ago, and I feel she’s getting closer to 2018 caution vocals tho 2018 was better, both 2018 and 2023 are shown with fragile vocals, time will tell if she improves 2023. Also from 2022 perspective she has improved in rasp, transitions, and confidence! (Hope this helps)
Je sais que jvai m'attirer les foudres des fans de Mimi mais please... Vous ne savez plus quoi faire pour essayer de faire croire qu'elle n'a rien perdu... Soyez honnete, en 93 cetait wawawaw en 2005 c'était waw et maintenant c "mouai pousses ma trop ta voie, a pris un coup". Perso jle regrette.
Too much lipping. Her tone sounds better in a very basic range but as soon as she goes for anything more the strain creeps back in . My all is very poor.
Mariah refuses to evolve ... I adore her, but holy shit hang up these songs already. She is a songwriter. Write new material! One thing about an artist like Taylor Swift I respect so much is that she stays working on her craft and is brave enough to try new things. Mariah started out as that kind of artist, but her insecurities have stopped her from evolving. It's either that or she flat out doesn't care anymore. There's nothing impressive about this vocally or in the performance itself. Shes singing with her eyes closed hanging on to the mic stand for dear life. It's embarrassing.
girl.... Taylor swift is a great songwriter but lets not talk about her on a video about vocals... homegirl still hasn't learned to sing in tune, she should try that instead of "new things"
@@summerwind919 she's definitely not a good vocalist live, agreed. But I do find what she does interesting and beautiful despite the flaws in her vocals. There's just nothing here with MC any longer. Her vocal is in constant struggle to sound good. It's present in her performance that she's struggling. And to just grip a mic stand and close your eyes at this point in her career is just insane. I don't understand why she does this ... She's incredibly talented. I'm not a hater. I just don't understand her choices.
@@EmalynneWilderbooks I find what Taylor does interesting and beautiful in the studio but there's no excuse for not getting ear training after almost 20 years in the industry. she's had almost 20 years of criticism for her vocals and pitch issues and not an ounce of improvement or any evidence of an attempt to. that's way more egregious than singing with your eyes closed at the mic
@@summerwind919 what do you find good about Mariah's performances these days? As a whole? Do you think she honestly sounds good? I haven't watched a Mariah performance since her butterfly era that was impressive. She would have to have an untouchable vocal performance to make up for her lack of stage showmanship and presence. At least 90's and early 2000's mc was adorable on stage. I don't care if she doesn't dance, but dang she had personality and it was fun to watch. This is a disaster. I don't understand what others see or hear that I'm missing... ?
With all due respect, people engage in magical thinking here when they say Mariah sounds good. No, she doesn't. Unfortunately, she's lost the technique and form. She ain't got it no more for live performances. I believe she could get it back, but for whatever reason she choses not to. When your skill is going down the drain, you gotta put your pride, and "I'm right", and "I do what i want" attutudes aside, hire a vocal coach/speach therapist and re-learn how to use your instrument again. Gotta learn new vocal techniques as you age because your vocal cords grow with time. Can't ride the whole career on the same techniques that worked for you in your 20s. It's just not physiologically possible. Also, gotta be disciplened with practicing, and Mariah has always been taking pride in not being disciplined, it's as if she even looks down on vocalists who actually are disciplined with their vocal practice. Being disciplined with practicing doesn't make you borring, but, seemingly, she thinks otherwise. And it shows..😢
idk what kind of ears you have, she sounds good so far it's her first public singing this year I mean if you compared this to 2022 this is much better.
![[FULL] Mariah Carey - Hero (Live in France - April 30th, 2023)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/OJ1g75Rxb5I/mqdefault.jpg)
0:00 Always be my baby
1:47 My all
2:28 Big energy remix
2:43 Obsessed
2:59 its like that
3:10 Hero
4:23 Heartbreaker (and honey)
4:39 Emotions
I really can't understand how those people could've dared produce all that noise while a living legend was giving them such a good performance!
Her Bb4, C5 and C#5 have less rasp and tone!!! (Way better than 2022) Her voice is pretty healthier! And i feel she’s still resting her voice for lovers and friends 👀
yass and theres like no rasp present in the whole performance
@@DaydreamCarey1234 exactly!
We need that heartbreaker /honey mashup to be officially released 😭
ik like 2 iconic songs combined like omgg
True!
She has unlocked her falsetto again 🎉🎉🎉
2023 is gonna be Mariah's year definitely
It's amazing!
You can tell her sounded freer and, she's so confident. She attempted some amazing falsetto runs, so glad she did, and she'll always be one of the best vocalist of the world!❤
that D5 in ‘its like that’ was so effortless
yasss
Right!!
C#5*
That first ABMB C#5 was so clean
ikkk
her voice is great here wow!!2023riah is slaying😍😍
YES! She has so much new confidence and vocal control!!! She's the best 💖
TONE! Beautiful agility and her voice sounds as fluid as my pvssy 😳
Help-
Her runs and mid-belts are back with more easy. looks like she's been taking more care of her voice.
Her falsetto and whisper always lovely
That D3 the slayage
Ikk underrated moment
hero sounded great omg !🩷
I hope that she improvise the climax of abmb like rainbow did❤️
0:02 that low note sounds sooooo gooood!!! 😩
Hero sounded amazing
Is 3:01 live at D5? If so there was no rasp better then 2022!!!
Also her tone be serving! 💅
yassss its a freestyle adlib.
Pretty sure its supported also
@@DaydreamCarey1234 omg i thought so just the vid was off sync, doing a healthy D5 is honestly amazing compared to 2022!
@@Orange-ug2ps yeh it is but theres one with a sync audio
@@DaydreamCarey1234 oh gotcha, still 💅
Ended 2022
of course
She slayed her
She’s freer and am going for more runs
3:02 her confidence in it’s like that always gets me!!
I was sure that she would have slayed this year ❤️❤️
I wish she could focus on Vocal Training like she was in 2003.
But as I knew and Learned from her, she need something bad/accident happened during her concerts or she got very bad critics to get motivate to sing good.
Ussually Mariah will be Transforming into Beast mode. Lol
For ex: Mariah on 1996, 2003, 2009, and 2017.
I honestly thought that the Christmas shows in 2022 would be an eye opener or honestly any performance in 2022. None of them were good, at the most they were okay…but none showed her true capabilities. This performance had good vocal moments but she still has some issues and she seemed so nervous to just sing out here. At 3:01 it’s clear that when she does sing out it sounds great. I wish she would just sing out like in 2015 Jamaica show or honestly any Vegas 2016 performance like in Thank God I Found You.
THIS WAS V GOOD!
Damn her voice is loke honey.. It's like our ears understand it as perfection lol... It feels so good to the body to listen to these vocals
5:12 the fan thou
People, why are you hating on Mariah’s vocal condition in 2022 when YOU KNOW that she has been in the studio for the past 2 years at that time recording 3-4 different projects. Mariah has ALWAYS been vocally tired after her recording sessions throughout her career that’s why she was raspy in 2022 ( such as in 1999 and in 2006/2008) ! Now that she had timed to rest the vocals are here
She sounds amazing I'm so happy
That live was so great
Can you do her low note compilation in 2010-2023 ,is so overlook
I LOVE YOU MARIAH CAREY IT WAS SO AMAZING WHAT YOU SAID YOU WILL BE MY BABY WITH A SMILE SINGING THE SONG WITH YOUR BEAUTIFUL ANGELICA VOICE
Her tone ❤❤
We need the hero bridge and the full emotions!!!
❤❤❤❤❤
we need a new album and world tour
No shade but vocally she is not world tour ready
@@charmriah3607 her vocals get stronger night after night usually
@@charmriah3607 We don't really know that. Considering she seems to have improved, and this is such a short amount of footage... She might be ready 🤷🏼♀️
Seeing her this weekend in Vegas :) excited for her to kill it !!!!
omgg urr so luckkyyy
oh my god
Omgggg 2023 with caution tone with that agility 😍😍😍
She was in good shape. The legato is there.
The tone in Hero is amazing, there is still some hope 😌
Wow she sounds so good compared to December 😳
THAT D5 WAS ALSO EFFORTLESS WTF she was barely belting in the 5th octave last year im so happy
Diva world no 1
5:46 spilled
She’ll never be comfortable enough to sing confidently as long as people are hypercritical of her voice. She’s gonna always dodge notes to avoid being picked apart further. Just let the woman sing how she sees fit. Celebrate her voice for what it is at her current age. We all KNOW what she could and can still do. And no singer sounds exactly how they did 30+ years ago might I add. Not a single one of them. If she decides to stop performing live, blame yourselves.
omg where was this performance?? why people keep talking over her singing??? the stage seems so little!!
This perfirmance were from france (Apr 29, 2023) and this performance were from a resort/hotel for a wedding day thats why the stage is small and people keeps talking 😭
Well... Hero, ABMB and Emotions are slayage!
I’m living for the lamb during Emotions.
funny cause hopelessly devoted to you labelled the first low note E3 and the « baby believe me » growl D5
Hoplessly devoted did right one on E3 but the Abmb is a C#5
Ended 22
Not u keeping the lambily alive
Fishriah could never 😂
let me do that ❤ pls
@@lanaandthediamonds3651 😭😭
wait the c# was literally EFFORTLESS at 0:38
I like the way she prolonged the "you" at 3:22 HERO
I just hope she wont use any pre recorded stuff anymore and just improvised. People will only drag her to lip sync issues and then she will keep on proving herself if thats the case. She needs to let go of lip syncs.
Yass it sounded more connected!
What event was this?😊
It was a wedding day event for someone 😭
She needs to retire my all already.
Definitely not. My All is an amazing song.
Hi
hii
Mariah needs to get her vocal ndules removed. It's time.
I honestly thought that the Christmas shows in 2022 would be an eye opener or honestly any performance in 2022 of how bad her vocal condition was. None of them were good, at the most they were okay…but none showed her true capabilities. This performance had good vocal moments but she still has some issues and she seemed so nervous to just sing out here. At 3:01 it’s clear that when she does sing out it sounds great. I wish she would just sing out like in 2015 Jamaica show or honestly any Vegas 2016 performance like in Thank God I Found You.
Yass i feel like she has those things now but shes still scared and wants more warm ups.
Just watched a 2014 vocals compilation video…guys she’s not even doing half of if now…what happened?
Yeah I know that her voice was WAY better in 2014 but that was 9 years ago, and I feel she’s getting closer to 2018 caution vocals tho 2018 was better, both 2018 and 2023 are shown with fragile vocals, time will tell if she improves 2023. Also from 2022 perspective she has improved in rasp, transitions, and confidence! (Hope this helps)
Voice lowering.
@@shadowcArey oh yeah that much easier/simpler lol 😂
@Kenny Strydom true idk what happened either but whatever she did in 2014 Christmas shows she needs to do that again lol
This was a private wedding, and not a concert. She probably didn't have a lot of time to perform, like she would for a tour or a concert.
What was this show? Must’ve been some private event, this was not advertised anywhere
yass it was a private concert
The Queen slaying it...Beyonce who?
2:59 I thought that was a C#5
Its C#5-D5 i only highlighted the D5 tho.
The belting is becoming accessible again 😢
yasss
omg,with what fone he record?from 2000?
Did anyone got angry when that guy laughed during hero? 😡
Je sais que jvai m'attirer les foudres des fans de Mimi mais please... Vous ne savez plus quoi faire pour essayer de faire croire qu'elle n'a rien perdu... Soyez honnete, en 93 cetait wawawaw en 2005 c'était waw et maintenant c "mouai pousses ma trop ta voie, a pris un coup". Perso jle regrette.
I hope somebody uploads the entire performances, had to judge with cherry-picked compilations.
Yehhh we all do 😭😭
@@DaydreamCarey1234 and our b!tch better hurry up and drop that rock album already, we’ve been salivating far too long
Ozempicriah come through!
Is it me or is her wig a little far back lol 😬 love her but girl pull it down she singing her wig off 😂
Too much lipping. Her tone sounds better in a very basic range but as soon as she goes for anything more the strain creeps back in . My all is very poor.
Theres no lipped moment in this clips dahhling. And theres no single strsin note. There isnt even a raspy one 😭🤣
Mariah refuses to evolve ... I adore her, but holy shit hang up these songs already. She is a songwriter. Write new material! One thing about an artist like Taylor Swift I respect so much is that she stays working on her craft and is brave enough to try new things. Mariah started out as that kind of artist, but her insecurities have stopped her from evolving. It's either that or she flat out doesn't care anymore. There's nothing impressive about this vocally or in the performance itself. Shes singing with her eyes closed hanging on to the mic stand for dear life. It's embarrassing.
girl.... Taylor swift is a great songwriter but lets not talk about her on a video about vocals... homegirl still hasn't learned to sing in tune, she should try that instead of "new things"
@@summerwind919 she's definitely not a good vocalist live, agreed. But I do find what she does interesting and beautiful despite the flaws in her vocals. There's just nothing here with MC any longer. Her vocal is in constant struggle to sound good. It's present in her performance that she's struggling. And to just grip a mic stand and close your eyes at this point in her career is just insane. I don't understand why she does this ... She's incredibly talented. I'm not a hater. I just don't understand her choices.
@@EmalynneWilderbooks I find what Taylor does interesting and beautiful in the studio but there's no excuse for not getting ear training after almost 20 years in the industry. she's had almost 20 years of criticism for her vocals and pitch issues and not an ounce of improvement or any evidence of an attempt to. that's way more egregious than singing with your eyes closed at the mic
@@summerwind919 what do you find good about Mariah's performances these days? As a whole? Do you think she honestly sounds good? I haven't watched a Mariah performance since her butterfly era that was impressive. She would have to have an untouchable vocal performance to make up for her lack of stage showmanship and presence. At least 90's and early 2000's mc was adorable on stage. I don't care if she doesn't dance, but dang she had personality and it was fun to watch. This is a disaster. I don't understand what others see or hear that I'm missing... ?
@@summerwind919 we can’t talk about Mariah on a video about current vocals now either.
Wow she declined hard huh maybe that's a bad day
With all due respect, people engage in magical thinking here when they say Mariah sounds good. No, she doesn't. Unfortunately, she's lost the technique and form. She ain't got it no more for live performances. I believe she could get it back, but for whatever reason she choses not to.
When your skill is going down the drain, you gotta put your pride, and "I'm right", and "I do what i want" attutudes aside, hire a vocal coach/speach therapist and re-learn how to use your instrument again. Gotta learn new vocal techniques as you age because your vocal cords grow with time. Can't ride the whole career on the same techniques that worked for you in your 20s. It's just not physiologically possible. Also, gotta be disciplened with practicing, and Mariah has always been taking pride in not being disciplined, it's as if she even looks down on vocalists who actually are disciplined with their vocal practice. Being disciplined with practicing doesn't make you borring, but, seemingly, she thinks otherwise. And it shows..😢
idk what kind of ears you have, she sounds good so far it's her first public singing this year I mean if you compared this to 2022 this is much better.
You’ve got a point in the technique thing. But she sounds good. Just because she doesn’t sound like a goddess doesn’t mean she sounds bad.
She had a great night compared to the end of 2022 but it is the exact same technique with a little less swelling in the chords from what i hear.