According to BBC rice is a social construct so there's no good or bad way of cooking 🤣 Seriously BBC should just accept they failed instead of bullshiting.
@@romaniagoh8146 hey it's BBC's recipe in UK not everyone has rice cooker and cooks rice that often in the way that reminiscing your culture. They clearly not an expert like people in Asia
Draining rice is not uncommon. In grew up in East India where rice is a staple food and most people put extra water and drain the rice. I guess it depends on the variety of rice you use.
Actually, there is a different type of rice in the West that is not sticky. They are usually cooked that way, drained and rinse in the West. I do not recommend Asians to eat that type though. It doesn't taste like rice either. Like Uncle Ben's rice. They don't exist in Asia. If they do, they are not fed to humans.
BBC is so cunning that you can see the reporter was still trying to direct the accusations to the "cultural difference" between two "Asian's cultures" rather than admitting the channel being ignorance. Shame on you BBC.
I’m sorry but you should make whatever however YOU like it. By the way, the method that she uses (although it isn’t generally rinsed after cooking) is common in India and is used for long-grain ricefor dishes such as biriyani. (This method would not work for ‘sticky’ varieties of rice since different varieties behave differently) Washing the rice beforehand stops the thickening of risotto or paella and the stickiness of other rices but allows for ‘fluffier’ rice. They can coexist. There are different ways of making bread, cheese; why can’t there be different ways to prepare rice? By the way, it’s been validated that draining rice with a collander is an effective method to avoid the risk of Arsenic that one gets from the daily consumption of rice.
@@combatarts192 Yeah you can make however you want but it's the WRONG way. That's it. No one will put you in jail. Just wanna to tell you to STOP RAPING other culture's cuisine!! It's like you fart when you are talking to someone. Nothing wrong. You and the one you are talking to can coexist. But it's embarrassing and disrespectful. Besides, she is NOT making risotto or paella. You won't fry risotto this way and serve it as well. If you tell an Italian that you are cooking risotto this way, I am quite sure they will beat you up. Also, you said "it’s been validated that draining rice..". By whom? Any cited scientific paper for this argument? Don't give me some fake science from content farm please.
@@laujulius3999 The link is in the first reply(just press ‘read more’). This is merely to show the conclusion of the study as well as relevant context. For Context: Parboiled and absorbed (PBA), in which water was boiled first, and then the rice was added to cook for 5 min; the water was then discarded{perhaps with a COLANDER}, and the rice was then cooked using the absorption method in fresh deionised water. Conclusion: In this study, we compared and evaluated the efficiency of iAs removal from three brown and white rice types using absorption methods. The cooking treatments were unwashed and absorbed (UA), washed and absorbed (WA), pre-soaked and absorbed (PSA), and parboiled and absorbed (PBA). Of these treatments, PBA was found to be most efficient, removing 54% and 73% of inorganic arsenic (iAs) for brown and white rice respectively, whereas the other treatments significantly reduced iAs in white rice only. PBA is not only practical to perform domestically, but also was found to be the only method suited to all rice varieties in order to obtain a desirable MOE for all population groups. It increased MOE by factor of 3.7 for white rice and 2.2 for brown rice, allowing us to consume more rice safely. This study showed that absorption methods could be further explored not only due to potential savings of water, energy use and cooking time but also due to its efficiency in removing iAs. In general, brown rice nutrients were higher and better retained under cooking than white rice nutrients. In particular, a crucial micronutrient Zn in rice, was not lost in any of the cooking treatments studied. The loss of K and Mg from white rice in PBA was similar to when rice is cooked with excess water whereas Mn losses were much smaller compared to excess water cooking methods reported in the literature. Further research is required to adapt methods such as PBA for its wider applicability by incorporating regional rice types and water quality levels.
@@combatarts192 First of all, the study you referred to is not cited by any other scientific papers, which means that it's not peer-reviewed and it's not considered to be a trusted scientific resource. Second, the rice is supposed to be wash BEFORE cooking but NOT after cooking. Washing beforehand is already removing the unwanted chemical on the rice. Last, I cannot see anything added in your first comment. I searched the content of the conclusion you provided. I have read something you said like "A more apt comparison is to have someone fart in THEIR OWN KITCHEN and..." Yes, you can fart in your own kitchen but you are farting in an open kitchen and it STINKS. People have the right to say it.
@@ValBoon997 yea definitely when they feel it's personal. Yea maybe it is kinda but we all got a laugh out of it. They just all butt hurt because they know they screwed up 😂😂
lol what? Where exactly did they take it seriously and got aggressive? By making this video? They're clearly not treating this as a completely serious subject
Imagine letting them watch British CZcamsrs who have stayed in Asia and are agreeing to what Nigel says. I don't like the jab that the interviewer made on Nigel.
I feel BBC was trying to attack Nigel in an aggressive-passive way. Asking Nigel if he thought he was being mean? And then asking him if he knew there are various ways to cook rice as if he was a culture-noob? And finally insinuating that he should learn from others? Nigel should not have agree to this interview at all.
Maybe angry video game nerd were being mean to LJN and should learn gamer have differences🙄🙄🙄? First of all, He is playing this angry person, and that's what make it funny, and it's about if you don't wash the rice, it's not hygiene, not just about the way how you cook
It seems like they only want to do some damage control. I can even notice it on the way the one on the middle speaks, she constantly interrupt nigel whenever she hear the voise of the girl on the right
Hersha literally impressed me. She handled the whole thing wisely and turned it into positive way for both she and uncle Rogar. She is a good sport about it. I like her.😂
@@xx_1dreamstanlegend_xx422 i know I'm late but likes aren't valuable, and why do expect someone to make an original joke for you hell why even bother telling them to make an original joke just bc you don't find it funny.
This isn’t cultural differences, you should not cook rice like that in any cultural. Just admit you post the wrong way to cook egg fried rice instead of saying Nigel is mean. Shame on you BBC
Well the way my Pakistani mom (we eat alot of rice) is she boils the rice instead of steaming it.anyways ye I have yet to see anyone make it they way BBC made it
DailyDoesOfENRG Boiling is normal. What’s not normal is adding too much water and then draining it THEN WASHING THE RICE THAT IS ALREADY COOKED. What???
I don't know what cultural war, I am from south India and we cook rice the way pretty much the way uncle Roger mentioned, I am surprised that people think the Indian lady is right, no way we are going to use unclean rice and never ever rinse cooked rice, that part was disgusting in every sense
Everyone is different due to where they live, as you mention many people Actually believe that Indian woman was correct, but that's because they don't cook rice often, we always cook rice as our food, so we know every detail.
I’m sorry but you should make whatever however YOU like it. By the way, the method that she uses (although it isn’t generally rinsed after cooking) is common in India and is used for long-grain ricefor dishes such as biriyani. (This method would not work for ‘sticky’ varieties of rice since different varieties behave differently) Washing the rice beforehand stops the thickening of risotto or paella and the stickiness of other rices but allows for ‘fluffier’ rice. They can coexist. There are different ways of making bread, cheese; why can’t there be different ways to prepare rice? By the way, it’s been validated that draining rice with a collander is an effective method to avoid the risk of Arsenic that one gets from the daily consumption of rice.
You prepare it however you want but you don’t have to be a d**k and call other peoples’ methods of cooking ‘wrong’ because there are no rules! Do whatever pleases you!
Nigel was kinda control himself not to laugh in front of the camera for the “different way of cooking rice”. Once again Nigel was not mean. Don’t mess with Asian food.
Nigel was not mean, his character Uncle Roger is the mean one. That video of his was a satire, he critiqued the cook and her cooking method but he also displayed, as a self-critique, how some asian people can be ego-centic.
@@josephkan8253 "everything she did you were outraged by..." "being a bit mean" 先不論她第一句明顯誇飾了，如果今天是黑臉議題，我不覺得女主持敢用第二句形容那些罵白人的人... Uncle Roger演員人太好，要是我可能笑不出來，或者 至少在節目上據理力爭。 想教亞洲料理 又不用亞洲煮法(而且是超離譜做法)，好啊，請說那是英式炒飯 或是BBC炒飯，大家井水不犯河水。如果今天換成亞洲廚師公開亂改法式料理，歐洲網友也會跳腳的... 該影片有上千萬點閱+各地憤怒的留言，這並不是沒有原因的。
@@bingingwithcomicsnerd8069 I think there's no wrong or right way to cook rice. The most important this is if it tastes great.😊 After all humans didn't create rice let alone Asian people.
All I can see is arrogance. The entire thing is someone points out the mistake, instead of fixing it, BBC just makes the claim that it is not a mistake but a "different method", and make the person who points out the mistake embarrassed by putting him on spot and makes him admit it is a "different method".
Exactly. The food culture and culinary tradition should be respected rather than trying to adapt it to "other methods" so that it won't hurt someone's "feeling"...
Thank you，I'm from China，I actually felt offended when I watched that video from BBC. I mean，it's BBC! How difficult it is to find someone who actually knows how to cook rice! I mean how difficult it is to find a CORRECT RECIPE! Now they try to explain this wrong recipe as "cultural difference"，I don't know what to say🙄
I think BBC is a platform to embrace different options and possibilities. I do agree those mistakes cooking this way (I’m from HK). I’m looking forward to watch the video, though. It’s not that bad ( if this happened in some ‘country’ then will be gg)
They both seem offended, Hersha went on and on about how it wasn't her recipe to the point of repeating herself and the anchor interrupting her so she'd stop 3:34
First off, this is a complete false equivalency. I’m sorry but you should make whatever however YOU like it. By the way, the method that she uses (although it isn’t generally rinsed after cooking) is common in India and is used for long-grain ricefor dishes such as biriyani. (This method would not work for ‘sticky’ varieties of rice since different varieties behave differently) Washing the rice beforehand stops the thickening of risotto or paella and the stickiness of other rices but allows for ‘fluffier’ rice. They can coexist. There are different ways of making bread, cheese; why can’t there be different ways to prepare rice? By the way, it’s been validated that draining rice with a collander is an effective method to avoid the risk of Arsenic that one gets from the daily consumption of rice.
@@combatarts192 bruh no asians care about arsenic dude. Where're you from. You white people are saying cooking rice has different methods. Ok then, let's cook spaghetti by not boiling it first just by roasting them on the grill *cultural difference*
BBC must have pressured Nigel to do this interview, just to save their face. There is no reason why Nigel need to explain himself or ‘admit’ that he was being ‘mean’ on his video. He wasn’t criticising the woman, but the technique of how she cooked rice for CHINESE EGG FRIED RICE. If you’re going to cook Chinese fried rice then cook it the Chinese way, not some western method. Besides, fried rice is best cooked with overnight rice because it becomes dry and soaks up more flavour. Imagine how that gloopy rice must have tasted. Learn from the epicurist, BBC.
Wait I don't understand.. so she is using the BBC's recipe to cook the Egg Fried Rice? So, is the BBC fault? I don't quite understand..sorry my English is not that good. It is not my mother language.
She also said there are a lot of people in the world who cook it like that. You do need to remember we are almost 6 thousand million people living on this planet, and there are many ways to Rome.
@@maggie198333 That's not how YOU cook a fried rice, I mean there can be many methods to cook a food. For example, someone boiling chicken, someone frying chicken, it's just difference on how they cook it.
but really uncle roger is saying the truth about how Asian cook rice like, most of the time. And we definitely won't use TAP WATER to rinse the rice AFTER its cooked, you could get sick! It's already about hygiene!
yes, you can present and cook food in different ways. But still, there are commonly agreed rules to treat food, and there is an objective BAD for basic things like rice (soggy, smelly, etc...) The recipe is bugged, what's that to do with "cultural acceptance"?!
I read some comment that said this is how southern asian people cook rice. This lady's last name is Patel so I think she is of Indian heritage and she also said she learned the recipe from her mother
there is no bullying. it is a comedy show and the problem is her cooking method. he points out the mistake in her cooking, how is that bullying? As a matter of fact, if you go to a food channel and demo how to cook a dish, shouldn't you do some research first?
這很像在公審羅傑叔叔.....，那個女主持人一開始就直接先酸羅傑叔叔刻薄跟過分，不是啊你們用錯誤的方式教「中式炒飯」還怪到文化差異，那一開始就應該稱之「英國炒飯」，雖然它看起來還是超級難吃 This is very similar to the public trial of Uncle Roger....., the hostess directly irritated Uncle Roger to be mean and excessive from the beginning. You used the wrong way to teach "Chinese Fried Rice" and blamed the cultural differences. It should be called "British Fried Rice" from the beginning, although it looks super unpalatable.
Hersha is awesome that she takes it in her stride n didn’t loose it. What she did and how she reacted to uncle roger was awesome something we should learn
Every chef must know the know how cooking for a specific dish. She should have learned and research the chinese way if she wants to create a fried rice. What shes doing is Its like cooking italian dish in a asian way. Will it still be called an italian dish? I dont think so. If you want to be the dish to be an italian dish, then you must do it in an italian way. Even other chefs, go to other countries or a specific country just to learn the dish to the locals and i dont think she or bbc did.
um no .. bbc messed up but in india we cook rice with a lot of water ( but we do wash rice and we dont use collander .. we have separate utensil for making rice).... no one uses rice cooker in india or majorly south asia
@@anweshadash6212 Not using rice cooker is not the issue here, every Asian knows it's ok to use a pot but it's more difficult. And the amount of water depends on the type of grain.
@@Ghosty716 it's not . i know that putting pineapple on pizza is crazy. but washing the rice after you cook it is idiocy. Plus western people are too arrogant to learn from asians, so they invent ways to be different even if it is stupid.
@@bingingwithcomicsnerd8069 no, they're same because pineapple pizza means to Italian👉🏻 disgusting，washing the rice after boilled it means to Asia 👉🏻 disgusting
@@bingingwithcomicsnerd8069 What are you talking about this is exactly the same case..... Pizza on Pineapple Italians goes Outrage for it We Asians cook rice and if someone doing it wrong, Ofcorse we will gone for outrage.... its the same case on this here....
@@rhaastlong6892 Lol do you actually not get the whole point of this comedy? He is actually making fun of people like you! Through his use of comedy and the characterisation of 'Uncle Roger' he is critiquing his own culture. He is trying to show how culturally-egocentric Uncle Roger actually is and encouraging us to stop thinking that our way of doing things is always the superior or the 'right' way. It's more clear in some of his other videos - you can see how he obviously makes fun of asian people's intolerant views on allergies when Uncle Roger arrogantly calls people weak for having peanut allergy. It's actually amazing satire.
NOT HATING ON ANYONE, THIS IS WHAT I THINK HONESTLY: Yes, Nigel’s bit is a comedic strip, but it was somewhat true. the way she cooked the rice is somewhat disturbing. You do not rinse after cooking, you do not DRAIN after cooking, coz u gotta let the water boil off by itself so the rice is actually FLUFFY. I get that we have different ways of cooking rice but jeezus ;-; For BBC to actually give her this kind of way of cooking, I feel bad ;-; I nearly tore my hair out watching it, just to be honest.
like she said, this wasnt her recipe. its not like her background is scotish, her last name is patel and the rice produced in the video is nothing like what u might get at an india/pakistan restaurant. infact, they normally have fairly dry rice that would work well for fried rice. first time i watched the video i was wondering why they would cook congee to make fried rice lol
Michael Sullivan yeah, I know. She could have pointed it out to the producers, but then again, it’s not in her control. She was just doing her job, and kudos to her for putting up with that
I just wander if anyone tried to replicate the recipe or did the author or Hersha even tasted it. Because based on my limited personal experience, just like uncle Roger said in his video, there's no way to get extra water out after the rice being cooked. I mean, what's the point to argue about ways of cooking rice if the rice doesn't even taste good?
I wish society as a whole learn about maturity from these two brilliant people. Many will think it's only about rice but there's more to it. Humour. Culture. Respect, Conflict resolution. Diversity. Positivity . Lessons from humble grains of rice.
I’m sorry but we are disappointed in you BBC. It’s not “different ways” of cooking rice, it’s just the wrong way. If you are teaching others then you should know the right thing first. Nigel is not being mean, it’s just the way Chinese talks, and he should not apologize for that. The people who attack Hersha should be apologising.
@Jacky Phantom Because in some parts of the world "Asians" generally refers to East Asians. It's all relative. We all tend to think we are the world & everyone else think like us, but we're all just conditioned by our own history & surrounding.
Culture issue is so difficult! But very happy to see both of them tried to think things positively and showed the sense of humor to all over the world! Two wise people and BBC did a good job too!
Not him, not her. It wasn't a cultural issue until BBC decided to do this interview. Passive aggresion is what this interview was about, not about the cooking video.
I’m sorry but you should make whatever however YOU like it. I am Indian and I DON’T CARE if you don’t make an Indian dish the traditional way or even butcher it. I’m honoured to even see you attempt to appreciate and enjoy the culture that I grew up with. It’s all good as long as you enjoy it. By the way, the method that she uses (although it isn’t generally rinsed after cooking) is common in India and is used for long-grain ricefor dishes such as biriyani. (This method would not work for ‘sticky’ varieties of rice since different varieties behave differently) Washing the rice beforehand stops the thickening of risotto or paella and the stickiness of other rices but allows for ‘fluffier’ rice. They can coexist. There are different ways of making bread, cheese; why can’t there be different ways to prepare rice? By the way, it’s been validated that draining rice with a collander is an effective method to avoid the risk of Arsenic that one gets from the daily consumption of rice.
Yeah, but if you present yourself as someone who "loves to cook" as Hersha Patel claims she does and you have at least some self-respect as a cook, then you're not going to cook rice that way just for some money.
What a wonderful collaboration between these two. Ms. Hersha is brilliant for her idea to collaborate, with a sense of humor, knowledge, and pleasure of cooking between different cultures. Just please allow your characters to grow. There is so much material for you two to mine. Both attractive, interesting, knowledgeable. Great chemistry gets across the screen with you two.
Bullying Nigel on "Shut up. Don't tell us wtd EVEN IF WE WERE WRONG!!" 😠 Bullying Hersha on "AND U!!! WE'RE UR BOSSES [AKA *LORD + MASTERS* ]. U WILL SAY NOTHING BAD ABT US. SAY IT'S UR FAULT. UNDERSTAND??? 😡
Ok, no matter how diverse cultures are, everyone needs to wash rice BEFORE it's cooked. Geez! 🙄🙄 Edit: thanks for all the likes 😁 (and any dislikes that I might get in the future 😜)
Not actually true, look up how risotto is cooked. Various rice dishes are made without rinsing the starch out. The real issue with the BBC video was not letting all the water evaporate and using a Colander to drain the rice, and also rinsing it after it was already cooked. That was the objectively wrong thing to do.
Lol do you actually not get the whole point of this comedy? He is actually making fun of people like you! Through his use of comedy and the characterisation of 'Uncle Roger' he is critiquing his own culture. He is trying to show how culturally-egocentric Uncle Roger actually is and encouraging us to stop thinking that our way of doing things is always the superior or the 'right' way. It's more clear in some of his other videos - you can see how he obviously makes fun of asian people's intolerant views on allergies when Uncle Roger arrogantly calls people weak for having peanut allergy. It's actually amazing satire.
"Cultural differences", so basically BBC is saying there are still cultures in the world not washing rice before using it? Erm.... really? When it is 2020?
afwruh Yes, we wash rice when it is still RAW(uncooked, but we don’t rinse it after it is cooked! Especially that kind of rice Hersha used in the video should not be rinsed after it is cooked. This whole rinsing in cold water after it is cooked is the main reason that has driven many Asians nuts.
UNCLE ROGER’S VIDEO REPRESENTS THE OPINION AND REACTION OF ALL ASIANS. JUST ADMIT THAT YOU GUYS ARE WRONG OR ARE YOU GOING TO WAIT FOR OUR ASIAN GRANDMOTHERS TO CRY FROM THEIR GRAVE FOR YOU TO LISTEN OR WHAT??
@@icringechannel2312 em Gordan Ramsay actually did it perfectly correct without using an electric rice cooker... and I just watched the video you talked about
The interview seem so passive aggressive. Yes everyone has their own method for cooking fried rice. But when you showcase how to do cooking to audience do it properly.
Rice is life in Asia our parents work hard everyday so we can eat rice everyday 3 times a day . Rice has a big part in every Asian's life that's why we reacted like this. Rice represents the hardwork and life of every asian. Especially rice is not easy to grow.
Every Chinese children have to learn this poem by heart when they first learn literature, it roughly translated like this: The farmer work under a very hot sunny day in noon, His sweat drop into the soil which grow the grain, Do you know the rice in your bowl, Every single one meaning hard work. So if you respect other people's culture, you won't cook rice like this, just get a rice cooker, and stop wasting rice.
BBC should stop being arrogant and post an official apology, these clowns need to stop using excuses to run away from their mistake. Seriously, you don't see the asian community cooking and preparing pasta in a "different method" or screw it up and make soggy pasta. BBC Food is just another example of cultural appropriation as they're clearly presenting food from a less dominant culture in which is offensive to the Asian community... They even stated that there's other methods to cook rice around the world so they should've pointed that out in the original video to let the audience be aware that it's not the og Asian method but an uneducated guess or something. Since the lady strongly points out that she only followed this recipe by BBC, I really hope she educates herself in the future and the entire production/writing/filming team about Asian cuisine before they face more backlash in the future. #justice4rice #justiceforuncleroger #ripbbc
Totally agree! The BBC recipe doesn't understand egg fried rice: not how to cook it, nor how to taste it. If the BBC thinks they know a different way, they should call their dish with a different name. Imagine a Chinese demonstrating the risotto in public totally disrespecting the Italian tradition nor following the rigid method only to end up with the rice too hard (or too soft...mushy) without the trademark creamy consistency. Imagine how many red-blooded Italians will react? Will the BBC say the Chinese way a different method to cook risotto? What double standards!!
@@JustinChow0601 Yes, the British arrogance, pretension, feigned regard...and their special technique of brushing off:-) One of the reasons Washington, Adams, and Jefferson wanted to divorce them:-)
tlee035 ... we’re not all arrogant 😌 some of us are actually educated!, those 3 names you listed though - Lol who gives a shit if it wasn’t for the french the yanks never would have won.
@@chloeware1874 arrogance and condescending have nothing to do with education. An educated you might not be civilized nor enlightened:-) Without the French, the Americans might become the first "Canada"... Yes, be proud of keeping your grieving partner in the relationship by brutal force. yes, power and abuse trump all. Be very proud. You go, big girl!
Bottom line, the BBC still has no idea how to make rice correctly. Hiya.
Aiyah
Hiya
According to BBC rice is a social construct so there's no good or bad way of cooking 🤣 Seriously BBC should just accept they failed instead of bullshiting.
BBC people are stupid cooking people. Hiya
Aiya! What a FAILURE.
host : "different culture cooked rice differently"
Nigel Ng : "yeah"
uncle Roger : "just some culture is wrong"
Lol haha
Hahahahahahahahaha
Draining the rice is still dumb. Makes it soggy. Just add less water
@@romaniagoh8146 hey it's BBC's recipe in UK not everyone has rice cooker and cooks rice that often in the way that reminiscing your culture. They clearly not an expert like people in Asia
Draining rice is not uncommon. In grew up in East India where rice is a staple food and most people put extra water and drain the rice. I guess it depends on the variety of rice you use.
Plot Twist: Uncle Roger fakes speaking english fluently
@Godon Gurando is another T-800 OK i think he’s trying to say ‘he is not playing uncle Rodger, but uncle Rodger is playing him’
@Mr T-800 Who cares. It's funny.
@@ThePitaPaz not funny..
That is Malaysian Chinese slang
I assume that BBC use uncle Roger hologram. This is definitely not him.
As an Indonesian, I agree with Uncle Roger's way.
Anjay
@@edwardgerald7567 awas di laporin ma lutfi anjim 😅
@@Idy0621 hahahaha anjayani
@@edwardgerald7567 wadoooo parah wkwk
As a mainlander, I can’t agree with uncle roger more, lol
BBC: "there are different ways to cook the rice"
Me: yeah. The right way and the wrong way.
Preach it sis haha
yes
Lmao YESSS
This needs more upvotes
Hahahahayes
is funny that BBC is taking this so serious.
the old media is just full retard.
everyone IS taking it seriously - regards, your asian friend
Rice is serious!
I respect BBC than the verge build pc
well atleast BBC is willing to admitt to their wrongs.. which is quite admirable nowadays!
The fact that we all, Asians, united when our rice were being insult is just UNBELIEVABLE hahahahaha
I mean, it's okay to criticise but not insult. I'm also an Asian myself
Actually, there is a different type of rice in the West that is not sticky. They are usually cooked that way, drained and rinse in the West. I do not recommend Asians to eat that type though. It doesn't taste like rice either. Like Uncle Ben's rice. They don't exist in Asia. If they do, they are not fed to humans.
Who would've thought Asians, a group of people constantly fighting and arguing with each other, suddenly united together online, FOR RICE
lmao
BBC is so cunning that you can see the reporter was still trying to direct the accusations to the "cultural difference" between two "Asian's cultures" rather than admitting the channel being ignorance. Shame on you BBC.
I’m sorry but you should make whatever however YOU like it.
By the way, the method that she uses (although it isn’t generally rinsed after cooking) is common in India and is used for long-grain ricefor dishes such as biriyani.
(This method would not work for ‘sticky’ varieties of rice since different varieties behave differently)
Washing the rice beforehand stops the thickening of risotto or paella and the stickiness of other rices but allows for ‘fluffier’ rice.
They can coexist. There are different ways of making bread, cheese; why can’t there be different ways to prepare rice?
By the way, it’s been validated that draining rice with a collander is an effective method to avoid the risk of Arsenic that one gets from the daily consumption of rice.
@@combatarts192 Yeah you can make however you want but it's the WRONG way. That's it. No one will put you in jail. Just wanna to tell you to STOP RAPING other culture's cuisine!! It's like you fart when you are talking to someone. Nothing wrong. You and the one you are talking to can coexist. But it's embarrassing and disrespectful.
Besides, she is NOT making risotto or paella. You won't fry risotto this way and serve it as well. If you tell an Italian that you are cooking risotto this way, I am quite sure they will beat you up.
Also, you said "it’s been validated that draining rice..". By whom? Any cited scientific paper for this argument? Don't give me some fake science from content farm please.
@@laujulius3999 The link is in the first reply(just press ‘read more’). This is merely to show the conclusion of the study as well as relevant context.
For Context: Parboiled and absorbed (PBA), in which water was boiled first, and then the rice was added to cook for 5 min; the water was then discarded{perhaps with a COLANDER}, and the rice was then cooked using the absorption method in fresh deionised water.
Conclusion: In this study, we compared and evaluated the efficiency of iAs removal from three brown and white rice types using absorption methods. The cooking treatments were unwashed and absorbed (UA), washed and absorbed (WA), pre-soaked and absorbed (PSA), and parboiled and absorbed (PBA). Of these treatments, PBA was found to be most efficient, removing 54% and 73% of inorganic arsenic (iAs) for brown and white rice respectively, whereas the other treatments significantly reduced iAs in white rice only. PBA is not only practical to perform domestically, but also was found to be the only method suited to all rice varieties in order to obtain a desirable MOE for all population groups. It increased MOE by factor of 3.7 for white rice and 2.2 for brown rice, allowing us to consume more rice safely. This study showed that absorption methods could be further explored not only due to potential savings of water, energy use and cooking time but also due to its efficiency in removing iAs. In general, brown rice nutrients were higher and better retained under cooking than white rice nutrients. In particular, a crucial micronutrient Zn in rice, was not lost in any of the cooking treatments studied. The loss of K and Mg from white rice in PBA was similar to when rice is cooked with excess water whereas Mn losses were much smaller compared to excess water cooking methods reported in the literature. Further research is required to adapt methods such as PBA for its wider applicability by incorporating regional rice types and water quality levels.
@@combatarts192 First of all, the study you referred to is not cited by any other scientific papers, which means that it's not peer-reviewed and it's not considered to be a trusted scientific resource. Second, the rice is supposed to be wash BEFORE cooking but NOT after cooking. Washing beforehand is already removing the unwanted chemical on the rice. Last, I cannot see anything added in your first comment. I searched the content of the conclusion you provided. I have read something you said like "A more apt comparison is to have someone fart in THEIR OWN KITCHEN and..." Yes, you can fart in your own kitchen but you are farting in an open kitchen and it STINKS. People have the right to say it.
@@laujulius3999 It only stinks if you stick your head into other peoples’ business.
BBC: tries to ruin Uncle Roger
Every Asian: HAIYA
Who are they fooling? I've seen even africans react the same way,lol
Asian have never said "HAIYA".
@@kennyjiang9587 haha ~ I said AIYO btw~
kenny jiang ya like 唉呀 "aiya" ！while he's like 嗨呀！ It's very understandable and similar to aiya the one we always use
@江緯娣 you're right
Ok wtf. Did BBC took this seriously and also tried to attack Nigel aggressively and passively at the same time?
Idk man
Well British always get triggered so easily
@@ValBoon997 yea definitely when they feel it's personal. Yea maybe it is kinda but we all got a laugh out of it. They just all butt hurt because they know they screwed up 😂😂
lol what? Where exactly did they take it seriously and got aggressive? By making this video? They're clearly not treating this as a completely serious subject
Imagine letting them watch British CZcamsrs who have stayed in Asia and are agreeing to what Nigel says. I don't like the jab that the interviewer made on Nigel.
uncle Roger speaks normal english
me: wait, that’s illegal
Watchu mean, this one nephew nigel, uncle roger dont waste his time on BBC
Haiya
It's niece nigel
Considering he is from Malaysia and we’re a Commonwealth country, the ability t speak in fluent English is common among most Malaysians.
@@user-sr2zo7lt8q lol
British: MAD when American called tea bag as BRITISH TEA
When British recipe ruined the FRIED RICE : There are different ways to COOK
I can't agree with u more.. the best thing the british gave us was Mr Bean and thats abt it.. 🤣
And more ironically the culture of tea actually came from East Asia as well.
true!
js some of them are wrong lmao
"do you think you were being a bit mean there?" bruv, it's a joke. Dude's a comedian, that's what he does.
I feel BBC was trying to attack Nigel in an aggressive-passive way. Asking Nigel if he thought he was being mean? And then asking him if he knew there are various ways to cook rice as if he was a culture-noob? And finally insinuating that he should learn from others? Nigel should not have agree to this interview at all.
i think it was not mean enough
People unfortunately did not know that it was just a character and for comedic purpose
That only shows BBC still can't figure out how to cook fried egg rice LULW 3head
Maybe angry video game nerd were being mean to LJN and should learn gamer have differences🙄🙄🙄? First of all, He is playing this angry person, and that's what make it funny, and it's about if you don't wash the rice, it's not hygiene, not just about the way how you cook
The whole idea of this video is protecting Hersha and making Nigel the one who's mean. I'm disappointed to you BBC.
It seems like they only want to do some damage control. I can even notice it on the way the one on the middle speaks, she constantly interrupt nigel whenever she hear the voise of the girl on the right
Agree. It's easy to realize that black woman was really angry and wasn't able to realize she messed up with other people first
Online bullying sucks, so taking the heat out of the situation is a positive thing to do.
she is stupid just following the recipe but not thinking
I agree .
Hersha literally impressed me. She handled the whole thing wisely and turned it into positive way for both she and uncle Rogar. She is a good sport about it. I like her.😂
Yea especially when the tons of ppl criticizing her and she still made it positive. That's not easy
Nigel : yeah
Uncle Roger inside him: yeah, a right way and a wrong way
why, just make your own comment...
@Encik PakLan is Malaysian bc it's annoying to constantly see people mindlessly copy other comments for likes. It becomes especially unfunny.
@@xx_1dreamstanlegend_xx422 i know I'm late but likes aren't valuable, and why do expect someone to make an original joke for you hell why even bother telling them to make an original joke just bc you don't find it funny.
@@adude8579 why bother asking questions when you answer them at the very end anyway with "bc you don't find it funny"? lmfao
@@xx_1dreamstanlegend_xx422 lmao is that all you have to argue, that pfp really shows how smart you are lmfao
This isn’t cultural differences, you should not cook rice like that in any cultural. Just admit you post the wrong way to cook egg fried rice instead of saying Nigel is mean. Shame on you BBC
Well the way my Pakistani mom (we eat alot of rice) is she boils the rice instead of steaming it.anyways ye I have yet to see anyone make it they way BBC made it
@@byakupe same here my does it too
Indonesian do boil and then steam it
@@byakupe after she boil the rice, will the rice still soak in water?
DailyDoesOfENRG
Boiling is normal. What’s not normal is adding too much water and then draining it THEN WASHING THE RICE THAT IS ALREADY COOKED. What???
I don't know what cultural war, I am from south India and we cook rice the way pretty much the way uncle Roger mentioned, I am surprised that people think the Indian lady is right, no way we are going to use unclean rice and never ever rinse cooked rice, that part was disgusting in every sense
Everyone is different due to where they live, as you mention many people Actually believe that Indian woman was correct, but that's because they don't cook rice often, we always cook rice as our food, so we know every detail.
哈哈哈 then you are missing the point, there maybe many “ways”, but they can be differentiated as “the correct way” and “the damn wrong way”
Thank you my friend for clearing that up.
coldhank exactly!they almost make me think ‘oh so that’s how Indians do it’.
dude because in anywhere... this is not how you cook rice....
I'm African ( Ethiopian) and we never boil rice and rinse that's just flat wrong. I don't think uncle Roger is Mean!
I’m sorry but you should make whatever however YOU like it.
By the way, the method that she uses (although it isn’t generally rinsed after cooking) is common in India and is used for long-grain ricefor dishes such as biriyani.
(This method would not work for ‘sticky’ varieties of rice since different varieties behave differently)
Washing the rice beforehand stops the thickening of risotto or paella and the stickiness of other rices but allows for ‘fluffier’ rice.
They can coexist. There are different ways of making bread, cheese; why can’t there be different ways to prepare rice?
By the way, it’s been validated that draining rice with a collander is an effective method to avoid the risk of Arsenic that one gets from the daily consumption of rice.
You prepare it however you want but you don’t have to be a d**k and call other peoples’ methods of cooking ‘wrong’ because there are no rules!
Do whatever pleases you!
@@combatarts192 calm down bro its not that deep
@@combatarts192 chill it's just rice
@@dod-rw9xl Lol Indians man they are some emotional bloke
BBC的訪問跟安排方式有點過分，好在兩位受訪者都十分機智的回答問題。
這根本就不是不同文化的問題，煮飯的方法有千百種，作為廚藝節目卻做了最糟糕的選擇。
這種煮飯方式就跟把A5和牛弄到全熟然後說這是文化問題一樣既不尊重食材也不專業。
不然怎麼辦? 我們就在pizza上面加了鳳梨 我們就用了濾網在洗飯 我們就放了輪胎在奶奶身上 我們可是大不列顛的代表性節目 當然要自己蓋樓梯 不然怎麼下來!?
泰國米就是那樣煮的，那樣不尊重食材？？？？誰說的？？？？
「不同文化用不同的方法煮飯，只不過有些文化是錯的」- Uncle Roger
@@rrrrtztttt3612 我這個從小吃泰國米印度米長大的可以告訴你無論是南亞還是東南亞，沒有一個國家像她那樣煮飯和處理米飯的。
Chew Chuancheng 我一开始也这么觉得，后来其他人告诉我，以前农村里就是这样煮的，因为土灶的火力不够，直接煮的话根本煮不透
Nigel was kinda control himself not to laugh in front of the camera for the “different way of cooking rice”. Once again Nigel was not mean. Don’t mess with Asian food.
Ikr , 😅🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Nigel was not mean, his character Uncle Roger is the mean one. That video of his was a satire, he critiqued the cook and her cooking method but he also displayed, as a self-critique, how some asian people can be ego-centic.
BBC yeah I know BBC
B - Can’t
B - Cook
C - Rice
I think your English have some problem…………( I am Chinese So I Maybe don't know the meaning…………)
@@sheepmeamea probably getting baited here but his comment was a joke
ok…………
@@sheepmeamea well...you got a really bad sense of humour
Sorry，I am HK people…………
女廚師很有風度，但這個女主持人讓人好不舒服... 充滿文化優越感，又不願意去理解亞洲人生氣的點在哪。何不稱那道料理為 "英式炒飯" 呢？這樣我就對那位女廚的奇葩做法沒什麼意見。
BBC這段訪問讓我更生他們的氣了。
三位都很以幽默看待 是你太入戲了
@@josephkan8253
"everything she did you were outraged by..."
"being a bit mean"
先不論她第一句明顯誇飾了，如果今天是黑臉議題，我不覺得女主持敢用第二句形容那些罵白人的人... Uncle Roger演員人太好，要是我可能笑不出來，或者 至少在節目上據理力爭。
想教亞洲料理 又不用亞洲煮法(而且是超離譜做法)，好啊，請說那是英式炒飯 或是BBC炒飯，大家井水不犯河水。如果今天換成亞洲廚師公開亂改法式料理，歐洲網友也會跳腳的...
該影片有上千萬點閱+各地憤怒的留言，這並不是沒有原因的。
@@psyrmc 影片女主廚已經有提到是BBC的食譜了 基本上就是BBC炒飯了 不知道你在認真什麼 大家都是酸一下而已 不到憤怒留言吧 我覺得你的反應真的太激動了 顆顆
@@josephkan8253
好吧，每個人看法不同，尊重您的意見。不過我絕對不是少數對BBC不滿的人，這裡上千則留言中，許多網友也覺得主持人太過傲慢，或是在"公審" Uncle Roger.
我的工作常常和歐美人士往來，他們有些人骨子裡就是有文化優越感，改也改不了...
在多年前 在台灣 綜藝節目 看過 就是 用這沸水 可以快速 把米 煮成飯。所以這方法是對的 米成飯後， 沸水就倒掉了
Yeah culture differences do exist
But you still cooked the rice wrong.
Yes. I think asians should be the only people to have the right to determine what is correct or wrong way of cooking rice.
@@bingingwithcomicsnerd8069 wdym, that is the only way to cook rice. Stop being fancy with your kitchen gadgets.
@@bingingwithcomicsnerd8069 I think there's no wrong or right way to cook rice. The most important this is if it tastes great.😊 After all humans didn't create rice let alone Asian people.
@@elijahsmall5873 czcams.com/video/8-rj3gVOAnM/video.html
Just...look at this
@@bingingwithcomicsnerd8069 you do realise rice isnt just an asain thing.
All I can see is arrogance. The entire thing is someone points out the mistake, instead of fixing it, BBC just makes the claim that it is not a mistake but a "different method", and make the person who points out the mistake embarrassed by putting him on spot and makes him admit it is a "different method".
Agree, they are just damage repairing which they are not doing a good job #justice4rice #justiceforuncleroger #bbcyoudontknowshit
Exactly. The food culture and culinary tradition should be respected rather than trying to adapt it to "other methods" so that it won't hurt someone's "feeling"...
Thank you，I'm from China，I actually felt offended when I watched that video from BBC. I mean，it's BBC! How difficult it is to find someone who actually knows how to cook rice! I mean how difficult it is to find a CORRECT RECIPE! Now they try to explain this wrong recipe as "cultural difference"，I don't know what to say🙄
I think BBC is a platform to embrace different options and possibilities. I do agree those mistakes cooking this way (I’m from HK). I’m looking forward to watch the video, though. It’s not that bad ( if this happened in some ‘country’ then will be gg)
Bbc is just trying to protect their brand, oh well we r already now how stupid they are so lol
The anchor is more offended than Hersha, WTF lmao.
They both seem offended, Hersha went on and on about how it wasn't her recipe to the point of repeating herself and the anchor interrupting her so she'd stop 3:34
hahaha i know right
BlackPink is the rEVoLuTIon what do you mean with anchor?
Well, the anchor is rep for bbc. Of course she must be offended.
The anchor woman is part of BBC, it was probably her recipe.
Yes, her response is so foreign in the age of the internet, where people get butt hurt, she turns the situation into a positive.
I love that she knows that the BBC recipe was terrible, and points that out during the interview.
"Cultural differences"
So next thing I know cooking pasta and then burning it on a fire until it is black is also cultural differences lmao
I'll cook the pasta with rice cooker *cultural differences
South Asia And East Asia Cook Rice very Differently. No one Is wrong Bro . And Stop bring Toxic 🙏.
First off, this is a complete false equivalency.
I’m sorry but you should make whatever however YOU like it.
By the way, the method that she uses (although it isn’t generally rinsed after cooking) is common in India and is used for long-grain ricefor dishes such as biriyani.
(This method would not work for ‘sticky’ varieties of rice since different varieties behave differently)
Washing the rice beforehand stops the thickening of risotto or paella and the stickiness of other rices but allows for ‘fluffier’ rice.
They can coexist. There are different ways of making bread, cheese; why can’t there be different ways to prepare rice?
By the way, it’s been validated that draining rice with a collander is an effective method to avoid the risk of Arsenic that one gets from the daily consumption of rice.
@@ankanroy2931 neither cooks rice like she did though, it’s a basic one way thing that she got wrong
@@combatarts192 bruh no asians care about arsenic dude. Where're you from. You white people are saying cooking rice has different methods. Ok then, let's cook spaghetti by not boiling it first just by roasting them on the grill *cultural difference*
BBC must have pressured Nigel to do this interview, just to save their face. There is no reason why Nigel need to explain himself or ‘admit’ that he was being ‘mean’ on his video. He wasn’t criticising the woman, but the technique of how she cooked rice for CHINESE EGG FRIED RICE. If you’re going to cook Chinese fried rice then cook it the Chinese way, not some western method. Besides, fried rice is best cooked with overnight rice because it becomes dry and soaks up more flavour. Imagine how that gloopy rice must have tasted. Learn from the epicurist, BBC.
Exactly! That's how I felt too!!
Wait I don't understand.. so she is using the BBC's recipe to cook the Egg Fried Rice? So, is the BBC fault? I don't quite understand..sorry my English is not that good. It is not my mother language.
Kori On'nanoko yes correct she was following what BBC told her to do so it’s their fault
@@user-we3vm7fw8t oh okay thank you. 😁
Remember the verge build pc, every comment consider racist to them, I really respect BBC & that ladu
BBC just admit you don’t know how to cook rice, don’t use this “everyone has there way” as excuse. There are simply correct way and wrong way.
Just smurf the web and you'll find some country are actually using this way to cook rice
@@jiuyuan106 not for fried rice or that type of rice grain
yes, I agree pineapple piazza is tasty. LOL
They r just trying to make them sound right.
@@jiuyuan106 where? Give me proff!
Uncle Roger and Nigel seems like a whole different person here. 😂
Love how mature Hersha is with all of these LOL
The way she speaks and smiles sparks out positivity ❤️
cause she is confident in your self
Wrong is wrong, it’s nothing about culture 🤷♂️
But there's actually many methods to cook a rice, maybe she is not wrong? She is just different from us.
She also said there are a lot of people in the world who cook it like that. You do need to remember we are almost 6 thousand million people living on this planet, and there are many ways to Rome.
哈哈哈 But she was cooking fried rice though. That’s just not how you cook fried rice.
@@maggie198333 That's not how YOU cook a fried rice, I mean there can be many methods to cook a food. For example, someone boiling chicken, someone frying chicken, it's just difference on how they cook it.
哈哈哈 Every single person who cooks fried rice disagrees with you.
but really uncle roger is saying the truth about how Asian cook rice like, most of the time. And we definitely won't use TAP WATER to rinse the rice AFTER its cooked, you could get sick! It's already about hygiene!
yes, you can present and cook food in different ways. But still, there are commonly agreed rules to treat food, and there is an objective BAD for basic things like rice (soggy, smelly, etc...) The recipe is bugged, what's that to do with "cultural acceptance"?!
@@joshuayung2818 你看得懂中文吧
@@joshuayung2818 其實日本的自來水就可以直接喝
I read some comment that said this is how southern asian people cook rice. This lady's last name is Patel so I think she is of Indian heritage and she also said she learned the recipe from her mother
Woi have u see any indian cooks rice, after cook they remove the starch usually..just because some never see it does not mean its wrong..
兩人都很有風度
網路世界應該多一些這種能量
我不覺得翹腳是一件有風度的事
@@hwalalatw 翹腳跟風度有甚麼關係
@@natsuyume 別人跟你講話的 時候翹個二郎腿好嗎??有怎樣的選民就會出現1.5個博士當總統
@@hwalalatw 看不出來那是影片效果嗎
@@hwalalatw 翹腳是那個羅傑叔叔的梗……那是他扮演的人設之一……
I love the reaction of Hersha when she faced bullying. It's very positive.
Completely agreed. She turn the whole situation around and become everyone beloved auntie.
there is no bullying. it is a comedy show and the problem is her cooking method. he points out the mistake in her cooking, how is that bullying? As a matter of fact, if you go to a food channel and demo how to cook a dish, shouldn't you do some research first?
@@rahxfeng late but they’re talking about the comments she receive
Hersha: "It's the BBC's recipe"
Host: "Oh okay so it's my fault now"
People: Yes it is.
Poor uncle Roger, BBC prolly threaten him for the interview
Based on his facial expressions, he gets paid🤨
I think everyone who watch this VDO agree with u.
Liu Ge Uncle Roger sad now
@@rigorousbabe5305 haha, so you know how to read facial expression ?
If FBI agents can read facial expressions then the person that commented about Nigel’s Facial expression can probably do that.
這很像在公審羅傑叔叔.....，那個女主持人一開始就直接先酸羅傑叔叔刻薄跟過分，不是啊你們用錯誤的方式教「中式炒飯」還怪到文化差異，那一開始就應該稱之「英國炒飯」，雖然它看起來還是超級難吃
This is very similar to the public trial of Uncle Roger....., the hostess directly irritated Uncle Roger to be mean and excessive from the beginning. You used the wrong way to teach "Chinese Fried Rice" and blamed the cultural differences. It should be called "British Fried Rice" from the beginning, although it looks super unpalatable.
Hersha is awesome that she takes it in her stride n didn’t loose it. What she did and how she reacted to uncle roger was awesome something we should learn
East Asia? The whole Asian continent was triggered, woman!
Agree with ya!
Definitely right....
+1...
True. 😂😂😂
How to trigger chinese and british in one momente
「put the rice in a tea cup」😂
"Cultural differences" seriously BBC?
We don't fry pasta here in Asia nor boil a steak now do we?
FYI, There's only one way to cook rice.
actually, we have fried pasta in hong kong. lol
So let's pan fried a steak and then wash and drain them. Yummy
@Rs Cag Nope, she said that method was from BBC and she only know is how to cook Basmati rice which is a little different.
Every chef must know the know how cooking for a specific dish. She should have learned and research the chinese way if she wants to create a fried rice. What shes doing is Its like cooking italian dish in a asian way. Will it still be called an italian dish? I dont think so. If you want to be the dish to be an italian dish, then you must do it in an italian way. Even other chefs, go to other countries or a specific country just to learn the dish to the locals and i dont think she or bbc did.
@@JoshWuelSeonsaengnim What do you think I said? It's not even the Chinese way, this is an Asian way... and to think she's Asian, is ridiculous.
She is a good sport. We admire you Hersha, even if you don't cook the rice correctly. Uncle Roger, keep it up! 😂
czcams.com/video/wtbcaWnybzs/video.html
Auntie Hersha is such a positive woman i love her 😇 Uncle roger is really hilarious 🤣
czcams.com/video/wtbcaWnybzs/video.html
The host really trying to guilt trip nigel for "not respecting the different ways of cooking rice" miss, i just know u cook rice like that
um no .. bbc messed up but in india we cook rice with a lot of water ( but we do wash rice and we dont use collander .. we have separate utensil for making rice).... no one uses rice cooker in india or majorly south asia
@@anweshadash6212 girl chill i was making fun of the host for guilt tripping, not the way of cooking rice
@@anweshadash6212 nah majority asia use rice cooker
Yes oh my gosh! They also have that Indian chef who showed people how to cook rice. And that wasn't anything like what BBC showed.
@@anweshadash6212 Not using rice cooker is not the issue here, every Asian knows it's ok to use a pot but it's more difficult. And the amount of water depends on the type of grain.
She wasn't making rice, she was making congee (but still wrong).
She 's making joke
@@tanlizhang4748 No, she's a damn circus 😂🎪
@@tanlizhang4748 the how to cook fried rice video was a joke?
@@heic1971 what you want me to say! So errrr basically BBC get her to insult the staple food of Chinese..
@@tanlizhang4748 Are you the type that even when some one is across the street from you, you call them racist because they are not Chinese?
"Cultural Differences"
Ask an Italian What they're opinion about Pineapple Pizza
It's not the same case
@@bingingwithcomicsnerd8069 it's exactly the same case
@@Ghosty716 it's not . i know that putting pineapple on pizza is crazy. but washing the rice after you cook it is idiocy. Plus western people are too arrogant to learn from asians, so they invent ways to be different even if it is stupid.
@@bingingwithcomicsnerd8069 no, they're same because pineapple pizza means to Italian👉🏻 disgusting，washing the rice after boilled it means to Asia 👉🏻 disgusting
@@bingingwithcomicsnerd8069 What are you talking about this is exactly the same case.....
Pizza on Pineapple Italians goes Outrage for it
We Asians cook rice and if someone doing it wrong, Ofcorse we will gone for outrage.... its the same case on this here....
I must commend Aunty Hersha, how beautifully she's taken all of it. I mean i couldn't have handled it cooly like she did
Hersha looks like Pocahontas..
It's like Nigel being forced to apologize for being to "Mean"
if it wasn't for the whole 'cultural appropriation' thing, that Hersha has disrespected the Asian culture. They would demand an apology
@@DeeJay34554 Lol.. how uneducated of you... I think Hersha comes from an Indian background which means she IS Asian.
@@MapleMeHoney and didn't know how to cook right way. How shame
@@rhaastlong6892 Lol do you actually not get the whole point of this comedy? He is actually making fun of people like you!
Through his use of comedy and the characterisation of 'Uncle Roger' he is critiquing his own culture. He is trying to show how culturally-egocentric Uncle Roger actually is and encouraging us to stop thinking that our way of doing things is always the superior or the 'right' way. It's more clear in some of his other videos - you can see how he obviously makes fun of asian people's intolerant views on allergies when Uncle Roger arrogantly calls people weak for having peanut allergy. It's actually amazing satire.
@@MapleMeHoney write shorter, kid.
NOT HATING ON ANYONE, THIS IS WHAT I THINK HONESTLY:
Yes, Nigel’s bit is a comedic strip, but it was somewhat true. the way she cooked the rice is somewhat disturbing. You do not rinse after cooking, you do not DRAIN after cooking, coz u gotta let the water boil off by itself so the rice is actually FLUFFY. I get that we have different ways of cooking rice but jeezus ;-;
For BBC to actually give her this kind of way of cooking, I feel bad ;-;
I nearly tore my hair out watching it, just to be honest.
like she said, this wasnt her recipe. its not like her background is scotish, her last name is patel and the rice produced in the video is nothing like what u might get at an india/pakistan restaurant. infact, they normally have fairly dry rice that would work well for fried rice. first time i watched the video i was wondering why they would cook congee to make fried rice lol
exactly, and they read this mistake as culture difference???
Michael Sullivan yeah, I know. She could have pointed it out to the producers, but then again, it’s not in her control. She was just doing her job, and kudos to her for putting up with that
I just wander if anyone tried to replicate the recipe or did the author or Hersha even tasted it.
Because based on my limited personal experience, just like uncle Roger said in his video, there's no way to get extra water out after the rice being cooked.
I mean, what's the point to argue about ways of cooking rice if the rice doesn't even taste good?
@@bobomono7 actually I do see quite a few youtube videos that tried cooking using the bbc recipe. The rice did not come out good at all.
uncle roger speak fluent English
Asian : HAIYAAAA, apa lannjiooooooooo
Host: Differently
Everyone else: I think the word your searching for is wrong.
Even Gordon Ramsey is dying inside while watching this
Korea fish hi
Yo
Please let’s get Gordon Ramsay to interview with hersha 😂😂😂
Korea fish will you grant me prosperity and wealth
I hope you win the Taiwan elections, good luck!
uncle roger: GETS FAMOUS
everyone : WE LIKE THAT
Ever heard of flightreact
my mayor's name is Babatunde Deinbo. Babatunde must be a pretty common name :-)
I wish society as a whole learn about maturity from these two brilliant people. Many will think it's only about rice but there's more to it. Humour. Culture. Respect, Conflict resolution. Diversity. Positivity . Lessons from humble grains of rice.
You forgot to mention publicity.
They're obviously putting him on the spot. 🙄
I’m sorry but we are disappointed in you BBC. It’s not “different ways” of cooking rice, it’s just the wrong way. If you are teaching others then you should know the right thing first. Nigel is not being mean, it’s just the way Chinese talks, and he should not apologize for that. The people who attack Hersha should be apologising.
Some of you act like Hersha isn't Asian, SMH
saeefa exactly
@Jacky Phantom Whereas in the UK "Asian" actually generally refer to Indians & others from the sub-continent, not "Chinese" & other East Asians.
@Jacky Phantom Because in some parts of the world "Asians" generally refers to East Asians. It's all relative. We all tend to think we are the world & everyone else think like us, but we're all just conditioned by our own history & surrounding.
@Jacky Phantom What about Koreans & Japanese?
basically, she is saying she is an actor instead of cook. By watching this, you know how much credit BBC can get for their news.
標榜中式炒飯食譜，但是內容卻跟中式差很多，難道不是BBC食譜的問題？約談兩位視頻上傳者說煮飯的文化差異？感覺只是不想承認是BBC食譜的問題
Culture issue is so difficult! But very happy to see both of them tried to think things positively and showed the sense of humor to all over the world! Two wise people and BBC did a good job too!
Honestly I am very disappointed on BBC’s end. This is not much of an interview, it seems more like a passive aggressive dig towards Nigel
Not him, not her. It wasn't a cultural issue until BBC decided to do this interview. Passive aggresion is what this interview was about, not about the cooking video.
Asians love food. We don't like people making fun of our food. That's it.
I’m sorry but you should make whatever however YOU like it.
I am Indian and I DON’T CARE if you don’t make an Indian dish the traditional way or even butcher it. I’m honoured to even see you attempt to appreciate and enjoy the culture that I grew up with.
It’s all good as long as you enjoy it.
By the way, the method that she uses (although it isn’t generally rinsed after cooking) is common in India and is used for long-grain ricefor dishes such as biriyani.
(This method would not work for ‘sticky’ varieties of rice since different varieties behave differently)
Washing the rice beforehand stops the thickening of risotto or paella and the stickiness of other rices but allows for ‘fluffier’ rice.
They can coexist. There are different ways of making bread, cheese; why can’t there be different ways to prepare rice?
By the way, it’s been validated that draining rice with a collander is an effective method to avoid the risk of Arsenic that one gets from the daily consumption of rice.
@@combatarts192 validated sure but it don't mean it tastes good
@@paulvalera588 Well, that’s a matter of debate.
The phrase when, “ if you can’t win them, join them “ comes in pretty motivational now 😂
Well I didn’t believe Hersha wouldn’t know how to cook rice properly, she’s an Indian descendant. I knew It must be the bbc! I knew it!
Yeah, but if you present yourself as someone who "loves to cook" as Hersha Patel claims she does and you have at least some self-respect as a cook, then you're not going to cook rice that way just for some money.
hersha patel can cook rice czcams.com/video/XeaKatzTlmc/video.html
@@icringechannel2312 Wow, you just saved her career
She could have tried to voice out but she didn't.
@@user-ef1ob4sb4o anf that video is from 4 years ago
Her rice was terrible and deserved to get dragged. The fact that the BBC is trying to save face is garbage.
Indonesians: We agree with uncle Roger
What a wonderful collaboration between these two. Ms. Hersha is brilliant for her idea to collaborate, with a sense of humor, knowledge, and pleasure of cooking between different cultures. Just please allow your characters to grow. There is so much material for you two to mine. Both attractive, interesting, knowledgeable. Great chemistry gets across the screen with you two.
BBC, just admit it that you are wrong,dont bully those two people
Bullying Nigel on "Shut up. Don't tell us wtd EVEN IF WE WERE WRONG!!" 😠
Bullying Hersha on "AND U!!! WE'RE UR BOSSES [AKA *LORD + MASTERS* ]. U WILL SAY NOTHING BAD ABT US. SAY IT'S UR FAULT. UNDERSTAND??? 😡
Ok, no matter how diverse cultures are, everyone needs to wash rice BEFORE it's cooked. Geez! 🙄🙄
Edit: thanks for all the likes 😁 (and any dislikes that I might get in the future 😜)
Not actually true, look up how risotto is cooked. Various rice dishes are made without rinsing the starch out. The real issue with the BBC video was not letting all the water evaporate and using a Colander to drain the rice, and also rinsing it after it was already cooked. That was the objectively wrong thing to do.
Mmmm...I dnt knw about Rendang too...
Sean Chen rendang is not a rice-
@@kaimiralis I know but this problem also like the "fried" rendang case. 🤦♂️
Sean Chen you mean the crispy rendang?
那個主持人一直插嘴。雖然他有説“對不起”，但我還是覺得她有點沒禮貌或有點沒耐心
Roger's tone and the way of talking are killing me. So funny😂
雙方充滿殺氣尷尬不失禮貌的微笑
哈哈哈哈😂
I have no idea wtf u guys are talking about
人家現在是好盆友了啦～～
,#_# some way to cook a “#”
@@jasmine1432 對啊還一起拍了影片的
What cultural difference? Its common sense you woman!!! Who rinse a cooked rice? Want me to rinse my freshly baked muffin?
Omg... lmao. "Ohh heyy... wanna taste my rinsed baked muffin?" XD
Lol do you actually not get the whole point of this comedy? He is actually making fun of people like you!
Through his use of comedy and the characterisation of 'Uncle Roger' he is critiquing his own culture. He is trying to show how culturally-egocentric Uncle Roger actually is and encouraging us to stop thinking that our way of doing things is always the superior or the 'right' way. It's more clear in some of his other videos - you can see how he obviously makes fun of asian people's intolerant views on allergies when Uncle Roger arrogantly calls people weak for having peanut allergy. It's actually amazing satire.
If you rinse a baked muffin, the egg and other ingredients get washed away and you end up with a little piece of gluten in the sieve.
@@MapleMeHoney How tf is Uncle roger critiquing our culture. We wash the rice, We dont rinse it in a sieve.
@@MapleMeHoney The peanut thing is a fucking joke. Itd a joke character. Have you seen Liza Koshy and Her joke characters?
I like how Hersha take it as humor, and turn the bullying into a positive thing 👏🏻
This whole saga was such a genuinely fun thing to happen during quarantine. Thanks to everyone for being a good sport.
"Cultural differences", so basically BBC is saying there are still cultures in the world not washing rice before using it? Erm.... really? When it is 2020?
White people who mostly eat bread and potatoes. I've seen a hell of a lot of white Americans not washing rice either. The British must be the same.
@@Anacaona4 OH MY.. 🤐
Oof
I found out barely two months ago that rice should be washed. I'm from South America.
afwruh Yes, we wash rice when it is still RAW(uncooked, but we don’t rinse it after it is cooked! Especially that kind of rice Hersha used in the video should not be rinsed after it is cooked. This whole rinsing in cold water after it is cooked is the main reason that has driven many Asians nuts.
people: 2+2=4
bbc: 2+2=5
bbc:people can do math in different way
Even do Maths in a different way
People: but 2+2=4 is a fact
BBC: have you heard of room 101?
People:2+2=4
BBC:1+3=4
The result is more important than proses. Even had different ways to cooking rice, but at last we can still find the answer
蠻可愛的料理方法，也請大家多給這位女廚師加油&鼓勵👍👍
she turns things into something positive, we must follow her!
UNCLE ROGER’S VIDEO REPRESENTS THE OPINION AND REACTION OF ALL ASIANS. JUST ADMIT THAT YOU GUYS ARE WRONG OR ARE YOU GOING TO WAIT FOR OUR ASIAN GRANDMOTHERS TO CRY FROM THEIR GRAVE FOR YOU TO LISTEN OR WHAT??
I'm Asian. I was afraid my grandmother had turned in her grave when the BBC ricemaking video came out !!
I have to cover my great-grandpa's eyes
I think if the Gordon Ramsay was right there, he will say idiot sandwich. 😐
I’m dead
I think he will say: get out of my fkin kitchen donkey
are u didnt know?? even Gordon Ramsay cooking rice wrong, he even the worst, i dont get it why every one think he is masterchef?
iCringe Channel First, show us how is he wrong. Second, download Grammarly.
@@icringechannel2312 em Gordan Ramsay actually did it perfectly correct without using an electric rice cooker... and I just watched the video you talked about
some people are just so stupid. Attacking her like she's gonna break in your house and force you to eat her rice. Just so stupid
really!! I am really glad that they meet up and collaborate.
She doesn’t even cook rice in this retarded BBC way in her recipes. She was just following her script because she works at BBC.
The interview seem so passive aggressive. Yes everyone has their own method for cooking fried rice. But when you showcase how to do cooking to audience do it properly.
At This moment I knew how Italian feel about adding pineapple on pizza😂😂😂lol
But hawaii style is good!!!
Rice is life in Asia our parents work hard everyday so we can eat rice everyday 3 times a day . Rice has a big part in every Asian's life that's why we reacted like this. Rice represents the hardwork and life of every asian. Especially rice is not easy to grow.
@Ark Mobile Evidence I am not mad at her I saw the video that she told us that recipe is from BBC not hers and she knows how to cook rice.
Yes, if I cook rice this way, my parents will punish me, cuz they think it’s wasting food
@@user-jt4pw6no2x same 😂 my parents will kick my butt and smack my head 😂
Every Chinese children have to learn this poem by heart when they first learn literature, it roughly translated like this:
The farmer work under a very hot sunny day in noon,
His sweat drop into the soil which grow the grain,
Do you know the rice in your bowl,
Every single one meaning hard work.
So if you respect other people's culture, you won't cook rice like this, just get a rice cooker, and stop wasting rice.
@@djjohnization that's a beautiful poem even though we aren't Chinese I will definitely teach my future offspring this poem too.
The BBC lady teaching you how to make egg fried rice is like "BBC teaching you about China" in a nutshell.
this
BBC needs to be canceled
Both Nigel & Hersha has very nice character. Love their positive vibes. Peace ✌🏻
虽然对方是脱口秀演员,但BBC你真的不会做蛋炒饭.对方并不是在恶搞或搞笑
撇去不洗米的部分人家這樣煮還真的沒毛病，要用現煮的米飯做蛋炒飯真的可以照她這個方法做。
@@kospencer1 呵呵,你的脑子是BBC给的吧
god loveall 不信你自己煮一次看看
@@kospencer1 用煮意大利面的方式煮饭，很正常吗？
You Tube 炒飯大家公認要用隔夜冷飯炒才好吃，BBC這個方法就是用剛煮好的飯也能做出有水平的炒飯，腦子不要這麼死好嗎？
ok....so who's behind the BBC recipe?
Yes. Good question. This is the right question to ask!!!! It's not her fault then.
Im shookt hearing him speak normally
Love both of them and their videos. She's such a great sport and very funny
BBC should stop being arrogant and post an official apology, these clowns need to stop using excuses to run away from their mistake. Seriously, you don't see the asian community cooking and preparing pasta in a "different method" or screw it up and make soggy pasta. BBC Food is just another example of cultural appropriation as they're clearly presenting food from a less dominant culture in which is offensive to the Asian community... They even stated that there's other methods to cook rice around the world so they should've pointed that out in the original video to let the audience be aware that it's not the og Asian method but an uneducated guess or something. Since the lady strongly points out that she only followed this recipe by BBC, I really hope she educates herself in the future and the entire production/writing/filming team about Asian cuisine before they face more backlash in the future. #justice4rice #justiceforuncleroger #ripbbc
I agree with ya. It seems to me that, BBC still has not gone out from the "British Empire rules everything so go f yourselves" mindset...
Periodt.
Americans and British arguing how to make afternoon tea....
LOL
they didn't even pronounce his last name correctly how do we expect them to cook rice properly
God bless you, Hersha. We need women like you. 🙏
Massive respect to Hersha for the way she handled this. She is an amazing role model and human being. Should totally win the peace prize.
It is not about rice cooking methods. It is all about BBC can't be wrong, or white people must be correct
Totally agree! The BBC recipe doesn't understand egg fried rice: not how to cook it, nor how to taste it. If the BBC thinks they know a different way, they should call their dish with a different name.
Imagine a Chinese demonstrating the risotto in public totally disrespecting the Italian tradition nor following the rigid method only to end up with the rice too hard (or too soft...mushy) without the trademark creamy consistency. Imagine how many red-blooded Italians will react? Will the BBC say the Chinese way a different method to cook risotto? What double standards!!
@@tlee035 they are very good on doing that. No worries. And they never think that is double standard. Their standard is the only standard.
@@JustinChow0601 Yes, the British arrogance, pretension, feigned regard...and their special technique of brushing off:-) One of the reasons Washington, Adams, and Jefferson wanted to divorce them:-)
tlee035 ... we’re not all arrogant 😌 some of us are actually educated!, those 3 names you listed though - Lol who gives a shit if it wasn’t for the french the yanks never would have won.
@@chloeware1874 arrogance and condescending have nothing to do with education. An educated you might not be civilized nor enlightened:-)
Without the French, the Americans might become the first "Canada"...
Yes, be proud of keeping your grieving partner in the relationship by brutal force. yes, power and abuse trump all. Be very proud. You go, big girl!
he is Malaysian not Chinese
he is banned by Chinese government recently
Nigel Ng is ethnically Chinese. Also, being a Chinese does not necessarily mean endorsement to Chinese government.
@@haochen8179 he is who he defines himself
uncle roger is the best thing to happen to rice EVER and auntie hersha is a champ