Pakistan: Is there a way forward?, Reza Baqir and Atif Mian
Vložit
- čas přidán 10. 09. 2024
- A conversation between Princeton professor Atif Mian and Dr. Reza Baqir, former Governor, State Bank of Pakistan and Senior Fellow, Harvard University.
Speaker Biographies:
Dr. Reza Baqir served as the 20th governor of Pakistan’s central bank, the State Bank of Pakistan, from May 2019 to May 2022. He is currently a senior fellow at the Harvard Kennedy School and managing director and global practice leader for sovereign advisory services at Alvarez and Marsal. During his time as governor, Dr. Baqir negotiated a new IMF program in 2019, successfully completed six subsequent reviews to restore financial stability and growth, and led the country’s financial response during the Covid-19 pandemic. He led several institutional reforms including the liberalization of Pakistan’s foreign exchange market from a fixed to a flexible regime, revision of the central bank law to strengthen its independence, Roshan Digital Accounts for overseas Pakistanis, and several digitization initiatives to promote efficiency and inclusion in the financial sector. Previously Dr. Baqir spent nineteen years with the IMF and two with the World Bank where he held numerous senior policy and country positions in East Asia, Middle East, and Europe. He started and headed the IMF’s office in Egypt as Senior Resident Representative and headed the IMF's Debt Policy Division which oversees IMF’s work on assessing debt sustainability and sovereign debt restructuring. Dr. Baqir resigned from the IMF for public service in his home country. Dr. Baqir’s research has been published in the Journal of Political Economy and the Quarterly Journal of Economics, amongst other journals. He holds a Ph.D. in Economics from the University of California at Berkeley and an A.B. (Magna cum Laude) in Economics from Harvard University. His views on emerging markets’ economic challenges and sovereign debt have been covered frequently in the Financial Times, Bloomberg, Reuters, CNN, and CNBC.
Atif Mian is John H. Laporte, Jr. Class of 1967 Professor of Economics, Public Policy and Finance at Princeton University, and Director of the Julis-Rabinowitz Center for Public Policy and Finance at the Woodrow Wilson School. He holds a bachelors degree in Mathematics with Computer Science and Ph.D. in Economics from MIT. Prior to joining Princeton in 2012 he taught at the University of California, Berkeley and the University of Chicago Booth School of business. Professor Mian's work studies the connections between finance and the macro economy. His latest book, House of Debt, with Amir Sufi builds upon powerful new data to describe how debt precipitated the Great Recession. The book explains why debt continues to threaten the global economy, and what needs to be done to fix the financial system. House of Debt is critically acclaimed by The New York Times, Financial Times, The Wall Street Journal,The Economist, and The Atlantic among others. Professor Mian's research has appeared in top academic journals, including the American Economic Review, Econometrica, Quarterly Journal of Economics, Journal of Finance, Review of Financial Studies and Journal of Financial Economics.
I have to told you something very important
As of my knowledge the one man army Mr Waqar zaka we all know him.
He has the solution of Pakistan Financial Crisis
He proved that and he should be next PM of Pakistan he has the knowledge courage and Ability to lead Pakistan into digital world.
Artificial intelligence can be used in agriculture and will upgrade It to next level.
If you need help call him he is Going to come and come hard wait for it InshaAllah soon PM OF PAKISTAN
Ever thought of calling a guy with futuristic approach? Ever thought of bringing a change? I urge you to invite Waqar Zaka. Nothing but his past advices tells a lot about his approach and competence. He’s the guy who can bring REVOLUTION via technology and even agricultural strategies. May it be bitcoin, may it be curriculums, may it be economy, he always has a solution to major problems of the country. He is the one. I guarantee you he is the one. @waqarzaka we are with you!!
Waqar Zaka should have been invited for this argument as he has been supportive and really concerned about technology evolution in Pakistan. Moreover, He has suggested the use of hydropower project and he has also suggested to make the field of agriculture more sustainable and useful thorough the use of Artificial Intelligence. He would have made more impact as he is one of the persons who have solid future to become prime minister in near future.
Agree
Call waqar bhai who proposed the idea of crypto mining for economic growth of Pakistan which is copied by Bhutan
Call Waqar zaka who legalize the crypto in Pakistan
Call Waqar zaka who proposed the idea of Pakistan
Call Waqar zaka who has changed the computer science book of Pakistan
Call Waqar zaka who is the best economic analyst
Call the next pm of Pakistan
❤❤
It's better to call Waqar Zaka. He had given multiple ideas and practical implementations to fix economy and how to apply the innovation in agriculture. He has given the bitcoin Idea in Pakistan when everyone was against it
My left tatta is better than this bawaseer waqar zaka
You should call someone relevant to discuss public & finance policy & who is the relevant for this ? Obviously waqar zaka, who have a vast exposure in public & finance policies & not only experience he worked in Pakistan for Crypto Regularization, he worked for hyropower minning which bhutan has adopted, he has relevant ideas for agriculture reforms.
Waqar Zaka should be the face of Pakistan at all Public & Finance forums both domestic & international forums.
#OnlyWaqarZaka.
these were some undeserving people to get this much respect. WAQAR ZAKA is a person that was perfect for in depth conversation about the countries future and growth. These people have an old mindset. Waqar has kept up with everything. From the idea of hydropower crypto mines to bringing agriculture forward. He might be the best person to have a conversation with
Isn't he that one who does Paxi roafies? 🎉😂😂😂
Call waqar zaka he knows how to use tech for making money he is the futuer make him a prisedent these old monks want be able to make are country well developed they are just bullying each other through poltics which is rubbish and immature act
Waqarzaqa founder of Technology movement Pakistan who fought case alone in high Court of Pakistan to change computer book & specifically he also fought to unban crypto in Pakistan.
He is real leader & have credibility to change history.
Waqar zaka is my khabba tatta
Bring waqar zaka to discuss the economic issue of pakistan, he know better pakistan, leading technology movement in pakistan, next PM of pakistan!
Call waqar zaka in this show... He will be the next PM of Pakistan
Call Waqar Zaka Because He'll be the next PM inshallah ❤️
That's not it.... The idea of mining crypto through hydro power is of Waqar Zaka which Bhutan is using sadly 😢... So you should call him he will be the right choice ❤
You should call Waqar zaka.. he is giving agriculture a artificial based idea… he’s the best
I know you are going through bad economic times right now and you should call #waqar zaka he will be the future PM of Pakistan This person gave the idea many years ago which the world adopted today and today their economic conditions are much better.The same person legalized crypto in Pakistan.This man has great plans to take the economy to the moon, you should call Waqar Zaka
for economic betterment call waqar zaka he is so knowledgeable in term of technology as he give id to Pakistan government to install crypto mining using hydropower and he has many ideas to increase farming and empower farmer
Once he will give the idea about mining ⛏️ and now a days Bhutan follow his ideas
He is the one who legal the crypto in Pakistan
He is the one who change the computer book for youth . He has the political party you should invite him and discuss Various agenda! We Pakistani people follow him and acknowledge him.
Atif, I hope you're aware we're proud to count you as one amongst us. There's massive respect and love for you, and all. Stay blessed.
He brings cryptocurrency to pakistan , mined crypto machine hydro power based, his idea mining crypto, the same Bhutan is using, he is critical thinker, you people should invite waqar to tell you
Atif was a treasure that we lost owing to the interference from ISI internal wing. He is more Pakistani to me than those corrupt Generals, politicians and bureaucrats in Pakistan. Hats off to you Atif. We all Pakistanis are very proud of you.
Same here bro
Call Waqar Zaka
He gave the idea of mining Bitcoin using hydropower technology Bhutan working on Same idea and Mined Bitcoin from years
You guys should have invited Waqar Zaka as he's the one who gave ideas to better up the economy of Pakistan for many years. Now, other countries like Bhutan are using his plans to strengthen their economy. Why you invited these people who are the responsible for the economy disaster. They never did anything for us. As for Waqar Zaka, legalized the crypto in Pakistan, modified the CS book of 9th grade of Sindh board education for modern education. He's standing with the youth by helping them earning, teaches them modern education. He's the one I as a citizen of Pskistan prefer to come and talk for the betterment of our country and later vote out as the PM of Pakistan. Please invite him rather than these people who never did anything for us...
Pakistan don't need a prime minister like Waqar Zaka ,
If anybody hold coin and become millionaire it doesn't mean we put anyone on prime minister seat
First he should must have to respect ex prime minister Imran Khan
I support Waqar Zaka as a social worker not as a prime minister thank you
Pakistan was also there before imran khan so your there is no need to idolize any single person whether it be from military or a politician
Waqar zaka a well know influencer and well educated and he was the only oone who gave the idea of crypotto mining back in 2018 which if was implemented Pakistan would have been standing at a much better performing country just like the news came that Bhutan was mining btc too and it was the same idea Waqar zaka gaved
Waqar Zaka You have to be the Prime Minister ❤️
Waqar Zaka Zindabad ❤️🇵🇰
Waqar Zaka Crypto King ❤️👑
Waqar Zaka 1st Godzilla King Trader In The World ❤️
Waqar zaka you have to be LUN ❤
@@hassaanawan367 Like Your Father 🥴
You call #Waqarzaka inshallah he is the next Prime minister of Pakistan he have a lot off ideas and genius mind he explain to you how to grow economy i sure to you he give better ideas he is giving agriculture a artificial based idea,crypto ideas gold idea he is the best teacher in the world thanks.
Call Waqar zaka for advices about economic growth of Pakistan
Call next pm of Pakistan Waqar bhai
Who is the founder of crypto and hydro power in Pakistan
Waqar Zaka is a pioneering figure in Pakistan's technology movement, credited with being the first to propose the idea of earning money from cryptocurrency and successfully legalizing it in the country. He is also known for his innovative ideas, such as introducing the concept of hydropower in 2016, which has since been implemented in Bhutan. Additionally, Zaka has proposed the use of artificial intelligence in agriculture, among other things. Given his extensive contributions to the field, it would be worthwhile to get in touch with him. #waqarzaka
Ex Muslim Channels --
The Jinn and Tonic show (Hyderabadi USA) ,Afif Khaja (Hyderabadi USA), ex Muslim DARASIKOH telugu (Telangana) , Ex-Muslim Zafar Heretic, Ex Muslim Ali, ex muslim zeeshan, apostate imam, exmuslim little faizu, ExMuslim Shahid, Ex muslim Yasmin Khan, Ex-Muslim Samim, Ex Muslim Sahil Official, Ex Muslim Sameer, Ex Muslim Sachwala, ex Muslim AL-Gaddar,Ex-Muslim Herotic jaffer, ex Muslim Adam Seekar Ex Mulsim Uzma Khan ExMuslim Ahmad Ex Muslim Ahmed Ali Ex Muslim Abdulla Sameer Ex Muslim Pervaiz Upadyay Ex Muslim Amina Sardar Ex Muslim Kalidasi Exmuslim saraswati dasi Ex muslim Ghali Kamal Ex Muslim Harris Sultan Ex Musim Qureshi Ex Muslim Christian Prince. Faiz Alam - The Humanist Murtad, Puppet Mohammed
Call waqar zaka he will be next pm of pakistan insahallah
As we can see now that these governers and other old politicians with old mind thoughts are being continously doing efforts but no major change is happening so we can give new young influencer who is giving his all efforts for the benefits of pakistan but no one is focusing on his ideology he is the man of the game (in modern world orders) and known as Mr Waqar Zaka. He has thousand of valid ideas which can improves pakistan’s economy as well as poverty as we can see in back of 2023 he said that we can setup hydropower plant for Crypto mining farm as this the future of the world as we are moving forward to latest technology i think we can give him a chance.
"Thanks. I tried to listen to the entire discussion but was fed up after 15/20 minutes and had the distinct feeling that the principal speaker lacked the moral and intellectual courage to speak the truth, the whole truth and nothing but the truth.
It is obvious that we have arrived at this stage by doing what we were doing since the last fifty years and the only step forward is to stop doing it,do a little bit of soul searching, see how the people we once looked down upon, moved ahead of us with much lesser resources, opportunities and challenges.
That's not a tall order, it's not asking too much, but a little bit of sacrifice, a little less hubris, and a little less effort in treating the others as fools and the belief that we can get away with murder and there is nothing anyone can do about it.
I am sorry for the outburst, but I see the country unraveling right before my eyes."
The Mullahs and the Military will simply HAVE to apologize for what they have done in the past 70 years.
Agree
Very well said Javed Sb. Unfortunately most of this video is waffle.
See this is one of the reasons of our demise. The addiction to masala and short attention span for boring and technical talks (although this one had little).
@@ibratnak
Can you please tell me what your take away was after watching this video?
@@george4vIogging zilch, zero, nada. But I'm only replying to Mr Javed. I have mentioned in my previous comment that this video is short on substance.
Waqar Zaka ❤
Call waqar zaka
He will be the next PM Of Pakistan
He has the ideas towards agriculture
He has ideas about AI
He is pro in crypto 🎉 He is the the first Pakistani who came live and make profits
We 🇮🇳 are proud of Jinha.... We 🇮🇳 thank Jinha for creating Pakistan and successfully Seggrigating the Jihadis
Yes thank you Jinnah for letting Muslims get their separate country otherwise they too would be treated worse than dogs today like minorities are being treated in Hindustan. Not just Jinnah but Gandhi knew also the true nature of people there. Thank you Gandhi jee too.
@@faautobahna9416It's bad in the North. South is a lot better.
Call waqar zaka founder of technology moment pakistan.. he is the one who can change the current crisis situation in Pakistan.. He proposed the idea of crypto mining by hydropower many years ago which was copied by Bhutan.. He has great ideas to improve agriculture by using AI... He is the one who always fight for Pakistan's betterment.. No matter its about legalising crpto or changing the computer books... He always want to see Pakistan at the top and not just want he puts so much effort in it and still doing his best... Should be the next PM of Pakistan...❤
Wakar zaka is the one man who have the great and brilliant idea's to good build pakistan economy .and he knows how to get best improvement in agriculture.He have been given already ideas about crypto mining that's one adopts BHUTAN and many country so in pakistan all politicians are stupid .ONLY THE LEGEND OF WAQAR ZAKA (TENOLOGY MOVEMENT OF PAKISTAN HE CAN GIVE THE GOOD DIRECTION TO PAKISTAN ON PROGRESS WAY.
Disown old discredited concepts of 'strategic depth' in Afghanistan, Jihad in Kashmir and the boogeyman of India, downsize the army that possesses the ultimate defense weapon - the nukes and normalise ties with all your neighbours. Also de-radicalise the general public by removing extremism from school curriculum.
Pakistan will be back in the list of Asian Tigers.
Black vigo wants to know your location 😂
Just do land reforms, everything will fall into place.
Pakistan didn't reach this stage in 3 days. It's an accumulation of terrible decision-making and lopsided priorities of the last 75 years.
Interestingly the diagnoses of Pakistan’s sick economy by Atif Mian (an economist) are social (lack of women’s participation, lack of tolerance). It’s like a doctor telling his patient (with aching joints) that his problem is mental.
The other guy (Reza) deliberately confuses expenses with investment, probably for political reasons (since he worked for Imran’s Roshan plan). Overseas Pakistanis sending money to pay for the parent’s utility bills/ cars isn’t an investment - that money isn’t going into an asset that will return a profit.
You Have To Call Mr. Waqar Zaka ❤️🇵🇰
What works in Chile may not work in Pakistan. India is the best place to learn from but ego and political correctness prevents one from saying so
India has its own problems which arent worth emulating. They mention Chile because it is relevant.
No matter how many scholars you invite and do lengths of discussions, but when you establish a country based on a lies and hatred there is no way forward or backward, Only way is downward to the abyss.
Pakistan was not established on lies or hatred. Pakistan was created for the sake of safeguarding the political and economic rights of Indian Muslims. Educate yourself, you are deeply ignorant.
Ok lindu
All countries are like that. What lies?
Prof Atif Mian has forcefully made a case for reforms in the Society ! But he is a non resident- do we hear similar sentiments from the current ruling class living in Pakistan ? Hopeful some reforms will come with the country in turmoil !
Good point... but doubt it will happen 😊
Waqar Zaka only solution..
Quran has the solution.. let molvis figure it out
ha ha ha a
The government and establishment both have completely lost their credibility
Waqar zaka have done So much things in crypto mining .. He Made Bitcoin Legal in Pakistan … He is Right about the hydro power … there are many much chances that he is going to be the next PM of Pakistan..
👍
Atif mian for prime minister of pakistan ✋
call waqar zaka he has political party known as technology movement pakistan he is so knowledgeable in term of technology as he give id to Pakistan government to install crypto mining using hydropower and he has many ideas to increase farming and empower farmer and last but no least he also raise voice to change computer studies book at school which were too old dated and after his hardworking finally computer book is changed
Waqar Zaka is a Pakistani social media personality who is well-known for his work. He has also formed his own political party called Technology Movement Pakistan, which aims to improve Pakistan through technology. He has handled various cases in Pakistan, such as changing outdated computer books in schools. He also worked to unban the PUBG game and legalize crypto in Pakistan. He had an idea of using hydro power for crypto mining that could have benefitted Pakistan, however, no politician paid heed to his suggestion. Now, Bhutan has implemented a similar idea and is progressing. Waqar Zaka has ideas related to technology for every occupation, and his political party's aim is to introduce technology in farming and help farmers too. As a Pakistani, I request you to invite Waqar Zaka on your platform to educate people about his ideas and awareness in Pakistan, as we need young leaders like him in our country.
Call to Waqar Zaka
Call to waqar zaka ❤
Wasteful discussions. Pakistan have to have products and services which are exportable and target market. Unfortunately east of Pakistan is only Bangladesh. Normal behavior not expected from any Pakistani and everyone wears Islam up their sleeves. Moreover God helps those who helps themselves.
U need to do some soul searching and stop making generalisations. Best wishes 🙏🇵🇰😊
Indians always ready to insert their opinion, despite never having stepped foot in Pakistan or ever having met a Pakistani.
I'm afraid you are right! 😢
People forget that both Atif Mian and Reza Baqir are number crunchers. Such professionals play a very small role in the overall direction of a country. Change always happens at the micro-level. If you own Chinese mobiles, Korean electronics, Indian pharmaceuticals, Japanese automobiles that run on Saudi petrol, then you're already consuming dollars. How many dollars have you earned in your life (actual dollars, not converted value)?
Individual actions at a micro-level are a by product of macroeconomic policies and regulations/inventive structures.
Greetings from 🇨🇳. I really love the discussion. As a student of Economics, I believe that by promoting merit, posting a right person for the right job is the only way out for the countries like Pakistan to get the sustainable development
It was an insightful discussion. Obviously the problems facing the country are too deep rooted to expect a one hour of deliberation to cover micro solutions for all the ills. So for those who are critical should take a deep breath and revisit the discussion with an open mind.
One observation i would like to make is that all the deficiencies pointed out have their root cause embedded in self serving attitude rather than serving the national interest and it is amply demonstrated in the actions of majority politicians, bureaucrats, business community, the establishment etc. it is a cancerous mind set that needs to change to move forward.
Surrender as a bankrupt state then reform and go on like Sri Lanka. How long a country live with foreign financial assistance and loan
Waqar zaka have much ideas how to fine Economic and much Knowledge how to control Inflation and Remove loans
Call waqar zaka 😉❤️
These guys can’t have a discussion without talking about india q
The number of views on THIS video as compared to other ones on this channel speaks volumes about THE importance of Pakistan 🇵🇰 economic issues to the globe
Every time I eat Atif Mian I a left wondering wat a waste g such a genius mind .if he was in India he wid have been the next Manmohan singh who heralded the change for a few decades .
Har h s tearing his hair ( which he doe not ave too many left 😂😂) begging and showing whole way forward to the leadership in Pakistan ad no one listens to him.
Wish he was born in some country which appreciates his intelligence.
Call Waqar zaka
Call Waqar Zaka
He will be the Next Prime Minister for sure we need Waqar Zaka only.
He has only solutions to make the economy better.
He already give so many solutions like Artificial Intelligence based Agriculture system and hydropower Bitcoin Mining Bhutan is using Waqar Zaka idea but our so called politicians are still sleeping only solution is Waqar Zaka Technology Movement Pakistan
Unless something gives in the present alliance between PML N, PPP and Army, the partnership which is safeguarding the criminality of all three parties, Pakistan is never getting out of its multiple crises at least in the short term.
Before I request you to snap out of the partisan debate, I'd like you to ponder on what was different this time around? The thieves and the company have always been there, but never before have we been in such a grave turmoil. What changed? That said, the actual problem is far deeper than merely a person or five. The longer people take to realize their own laziness, incompetence, extravagance, short-sightedness and delusions are the root cause, the more we'll sink.
@@ibratnak here's another interesting opinion. People "realizing" they are lazy, incompetent or hell even toxic to Pakistan is a very VERY idealistic thing to say. Unless there is an active incentive for parties within the political sphere to change, they won't. Sure the entirety of the economic crisis on the poor isn't really giving the best of outlooks for the country but when it comes to those in charge, it's not really them who face most of the meaningful difficulties that can instill an intention for change. Even a 'change in the structural sense' is surely required but practically implementing such a change to any extent meaningful will have to involve the already dominant structure in place to change, which again, nobody really sees an incentive in achieving.
@@hamzaahmed1279 yes you are right. But it is a chicken and egg problem. What concrete first step should we take to start the cycle of change or break out of the cycle of decline?
@@ibratnak oh i honestly don't think its in the hands of the citizens to do so. Sure they can and they should participate in elections but so far as what will bring meaningful change in the long run remains a mystery. I do like the idea of international lenders keeping our expenses in check but that only works for so long as the government wants to deal with the lender itself. Moreover such lenders often are predatory so that's again, not a viable option. At this point, I honestly don't know but what's more concerning is the low magnitude of conversation happening which actually contextualizes the issue in the said 'chicken or the egg' manner.
@@ibratnak Naivete on steroids if one dreams Pakistan can ever get out of its disastrous state without the present pact between three criminals - PML N, PPP and ARMY - breaking. Yes the bad was there before, just that it continued to aggravate and is showing itself in the concoction that we are witnessing currently. Yes just the breaking of pact between the three criminals won't suffice but it is essential if we are ever going to climb out and meaningfully address things that you mention and what Reza and Atif state.
Kindly Invite Waqar Zaka, Chairman of Technology Movement Pakistan. He has brilliant ideas on how to improve the economic condition of Pakista. He has great knowledge of Crypto and WEB3 and all the emerging technologies of world. He has advised the government to open crypto mining farm on hydroelectricity back in 2017 which now Bhutan is doing. He told everyone to buy Bitcoin at $268. When no one was talking about crypto, he advised everyone to buy some bitcoins which is now around $29,000.
Atif Mian is far more mature & seems credible than the other Princeton Chaploos.
He is an Ahmeddiyah Kaafir
No Thanks
@@khittaykachoudhary2360 What does his faith has anything to do with competency?
@@nishomzawan5196 Everything
@@khittaykachoudhary2360 Not sure about him but You certainly are not a Muslim with the hatred and prejudice that you have.
@@khittaykachoudhary2360 name one thing mulla einstein
Interesting conversation -we need more of these. Thank you.
Waste of 1 hr. listening. No grip on issues. Some wishful thinking. Reminds one of two mechanics who do not know what has gone wrong with a scooter, and keep guessing, tinkering and chatting. Only thing of value comes in comments on women and blasphemy laws - that courage because they are in USA.
This is our tragedy. Everyone from doctors and scientists to engineers and economists is a melodramatic politician here. Everyone prefers sensationalism and quick fix over grinding hard and empirical reforms.
Hire half a Tamil Brahmin Bureaucrats for the Financial Ministry. Alternately post a MA(History) Bureaucrat as Central Bank Governor
Sir these person whom you've invited in this meeting, unfortunately, have done nothing for Pakistan, kindly invite @waqar zaka who've done a lots of work for Pakistan and also for other countries like burma/Seria, he changed the computer science book in Pakistan which was older then the 90's and filled a petition to unban Cryptocurrency and Pubg in Pakistan,❤❤
He is the one man army🎉
Waqar Zaka our Mentor, Hero, Teacher
Kaabar zaka Tati Insan To much Spam in private group go in this video comments section type waqar zaka king prime minister etec Lol 😆
👍👍👍👍
Bakir ran Pakistan into the ground - gracious enough of him to now act like he was doing everything to save it
He was gov of state bank not finance minister.
How did he run Pakistan into the ground? I'd be enlightened in knowing what I am missing completely behind your deduction !
@@ibratnak Gov of State Bank sets monetary policy. He was following the IMF playbook which is based on "austerity measures" . This dries up investment and causes higher unemployment. It should help with inflation but even inflation didn't come down in Pakistan. Erdogan / Turkey went completely opposite and are doing much better.
@@faautobahna9416 please see my response to other comment. He follows the IMF playbook which has never worked. Just ask the Egyptians who couldn't get rid of him fast enough
@@aliburney8466 So you want the IMF to give the irresponsible and corrupt state of Pakistan - no questions asked free money basically - spend on whatever you want, keep interest rates lowest or why even charge any interest in the country and certainly no need to end circular energy debt or check tax payers' financed employment brothels (PIA, Steel Mill, Railways etc.) or God forbid do anything to commit the sin of raising tax revenue because well the IMF will gladly dole it out for the folk. There is a very simple solution, Sir, why even bother to get seduced by it and go to her ! Or is the IMF forcing herself upon ---- Toba Toba Astaghfirulla.
Poor public speaking skills. Too much head movement.
I stopped listening when he said 'Pakistan is a noisy democracy'.
@Israr Hussain Pakistan is a military dictatorship with a democratic fasade.
@israrhussain1453 Because pakistan is a military dictatorship country.
They know what the biggest problem is:
That land is the safest and most profitable investment in Pakistan.
And you can’t change that (or tax it properly) because it would be political suicide as that’s where most people (who have assets) put there savings.
And that’s also how the army stay’s in power by allocating plots to their officers (by creating more and more DHA phases).
Maybe the army should start rewarding their officers with stock certificates.
Thank you so much for the wonderful informative session 🙏
All knowledge required by pious Pakistanis is available in Quran. Both the western educated experts should rely on Quran
Untill Pakistan comes out of the Interest Bank Banking system....I don't see any hope for Pakistan.
lol
😂😂 phir Mohammad ki sunnat Puri kaarna Naa Bina bijli , Bina internet ka rhee
Pakistan has been exporting Turck Axle hubs since last 20 years (even after 9/11 impact) to the US. Mack Truck and more - Rastgar engineering... google
Ex Muslim Channels --
The Jinn and Tonic show (Hyderabadi USA) ,Afif Khaja (Hyderabadi USA), ex Muslim DARASIKOH telugu (Telangana) , Ex-Muslim Zafar Heretic, Ex Muslim Ali, ex muslim zeeshan, apostate imam, exmuslim little faizu, ExMuslim Shahid, Ex muslim Yasmin Khan, Ex-Muslim Samim, Ex Muslim Sahil Official, Ex Muslim Sameer, Ex Muslim Sachwala, ex Muslim AL-Gaddar,Ex-Muslim Herotic jaffer, ex Muslim Adam Seekar Ex Mulsim Uzma Khan ExMuslim Ahmad Ex Muslim Ahmed Ali Ex Muslim Abdulla Sameer Ex Muslim Pervaiz Upadyay Ex Muslim Amina Sardar Ex Muslim Kalidasi Exmuslim saraswati dasi Ex muslim Ghali Kamal Ex Muslim Harris Sultan Ex Musim Qureshi Ex Muslim Christian Prince. Faiz Alam - The Humanist Murtad, Puppet Mohammed
He dint answer a single question.
No …i m sorry
The non Muslim whose community doesn't accept the Constitution and laws i.e. will of the people of an Islamic nation has no legal or moral right to get into any discussion about 🇵🇰. He needs to accept in letter and spirit what's written in the Constitution and laws otherwise he is not needed. He can get lost now.
He is a Muslim according to the Quran and Sunnah of the Prophet Muhammad SAW. Your man made Constitution is worthless in front of Quran and Sunnah. Use your brain. You need to stop obsessing over religious issues and focus on the actual problems.
Your hatred and prejudice tells me you can't be a Muslim, as Islam does not preach such mindset.
@@faautobahna9416 siding with the constitution and laws and singling out those who are hell bent against a state is hatred and prejudice to you 👏 I am certain you are unknown to what I am writing. Enjoy your time, it's beyond your scope 😉
@@AAmed1980 He is talking about Atif Mian who is Ahmadi like Dr Abdus Salam , who are non Muslim as per Pak.
Recently a Ahmadi was booked since he had "Syed" in his name.
@@user-bn3ck4jw2x I thank Allah I am beyond your scope that promotes hatred and violent tendencies.
Dr Raza talking broadly and Vaguely. Came with agenda in SBP.
Yes there is way backwards only for Pakistan
In its 75 yr history, India has become 3rd biggest economy in the world yet Pakistan has managed to remain hungry and poor with a booming population. How did Punjabi do this? Nusrat Rizvi, Palm Beach Gardens, FL
India is currently number 6, and it also has hungry and poor there...
@@AAmed1980 Its the trajectory that is worrisome for Pakistan.
@@rsundar1973 Simplify the argument he is a pakistani
Pakistan don't need a prime minister like Waqar Zaka ,
If anybody hold coin and become millionaire it doesn't mean we put anyone on prime minister seat
First he should must have to respect ex prime minister Imran Khan
I support Waqar Zaka as a social worker not as a prime minister thank you
Call Waqar zaka
Waqar Zaka ❤❤❤
Pakistan don't need a prime minister like Waqar Zaka ,
If anybody hold coin and become millionaire it doesn't mean we put anyone on prime minister seat
First he should must have to respect ex prime minister Imran Khan
I support Waqar Zaka as a social worker not as a prime minister thank you
Pakistan don't need a prime minister like Waqar Zaka ,
If anybody hold coin and become millionaire it doesn't mean we put anyone on prime minister seat
First he should must have to respect ex prime minister Imran Khan
I support Waqar Zaka as a social worker not as a prime minister thank you
Pakistan don't need a prime minister like Waqar Zaka ,
If anybody hold coin and become millionaire it doesn't mean we put anyone on prime minister seat
First he should must have to respect ex prime minister Imran Khan
I support Waqar Zaka as a social worker not as a prime minister thank you
Pakistan don't need a prime minister like Waqar Zaka ,
If anybody hold coin and become millionaire it doesn't mean we put anyone on prime minister seat
First he should must have to respect ex prime minister Imran Khan
I support Waqar Zaka as a social worker not as a prime minister thank you
Pakistan don't need a prime minister like Waqar Zaka ,
If anybody hold coin and become millionaire it doesn't mean we put anyone on prime minister seat
First he should must have to respect ex prime minister Imran Khan
I support Waqar Zaka as a social worker not as a prime minister thank you
Pakistan don't need a prime minister like Waqar Zaka ,
If anybody hold coin and become millionaire it doesn't mean we put anyone on prime minister seat
First he should must have to respect ex prime minister Imran Khan
I support Waqar Zaka as a social worker not as a prime minister thank you
Pakistan don't need a prime minister like Waqar Zaka ,
If anybody hold coin and become millionaire it doesn't mean we put anyone on prime minister seat
First he should must have to respect ex prime minister Imran Khan
I support Waqar Zaka as a social worker not as a prime minister thank you
Waqar zaka sir if you're watching this then plz kick this man out from.your group..... he's a stabber