its like thom went back in time to 2005 from 2016 to perform it with an orchestra, causing the real 2005 thom to hear it and use it for in rainbows, creating a time paradox.
Every time I hear Radiohead early versions I think, Imagine having the amount of talent and beautiful songwriting abilities to abandon these early works as unfinished... I think 99% of people, if capable of making something like this, would be immensely proud
@@sean1445 that's true, they did a killer version of where bluebirds fly there too. but it's still pretty impressive they wrote a full orchestral arrangement for a song that was probably just written as a few arpeggiated guitar chords, and only had that arrangement performed once. it's not even like it's just the standard "strings playing sustained chords, a view pizzicatos for flavour" kind of arrangement, because this clearly had a lot of thought put into it for a one-time deal
@@pimposki6232 Yeah so much effort would've been put into it and yet it was for barely anything. There's a few Radiohead orchestral arrangements that didn't get put to record or performed much.
I could listen to this in the background for the rest of my measly little life and not get sick of it, I think. Because it is that organic. The perfect fix. It covers the all the bases of emotions that I think I care to indulge in anymore for this go 'round. Not up enough to make me jump up and boogie, but not down enough to trigger a teardrop. He keeps the ball safely within the boundaries of joy and agony for a safe run to the endzone, but still flirting with the boundaries to the left and the right. For a minute there you forget about the line of scrimmage. It's got just enough of the "Goldilocks Zone" as far as sound driven emotion for me. Not too little and not too much. Thanks for sharing.
This is astonishing. It's little glimpses behind the curtain such as this, that affirm to me how Radiohead are in a league of their own. ...astonishing 🙏
I remember when the original live version of this was posted. I watched it so many times. Glad to find such a perfect version of the recording 16 years later
I have been hoping to hear this version again for over a decade! Someone on Reddit found a comment of mine in a r/Radiohead post from three years ago asking for this version. They linked me to here today and I am over the moon! Thank you for posting this!!!
Living at the bottom, looking up at the sky through water, and trying to leave... but caught and killed by the weird fishes. Being trapped in a life you never asked for but don't want to give away.
@@soundstation8343 el primero, en el desierto de Atacama, en el norte de Chile. El segundo en el sur del país...un lugar lleno de lagos, ríos y montañas...el Lago Ranco es mi favorito! Saludos!
I knew this version first (because Limewire), so when I heard the full band version on In Rainbows, I was originally taken aback that they make it fast and guitar based
Radiohead is a landmark in music history. In a time of commercial music they spend decades perfecting songs instead of just using their names to throw shit out. This song was already good, but overtime it became something just unbelievable
Interesting, agreed the strings give it an interesting vibe, not sure about the programmed synth goes with the strings 100%, but still get to hear all the lyrics which are even better than I originally thought. Thanks for the upload, great tune.
This is pretty amazing but I personally prefer the energy of the original. Would be great to just amass an entire album's worth of this material for In Rainbows - like for every track.
hearing this version so long before In Rainbows came out really spoilt the studio version for me. As much as I love the one on In Rainbows, this one just hits different. So special.
Johnny Greenwood composed this piece as a piece of concert piece for the London Sinfonietta. It clearly became Weird Fishes. And the recording has been slowly surfacing across the internet.
can anybody name the main electronic instrument it starts out on that continues the whole time in the background? or what kind of instrument it generally is?
@@alex11v3 Yeah but the again almost all of their songs has it and even more complex.. the version plus the song in itself is the just heartbreaking but so beautiful. This has the guitar in it ;)
I wonder if that's what Thom meant when he defined music as life affirming. He formulates a more melancholic version of a song and then, by trying to encounter patterns to form a resolution, to get to the next day, he elaborates a more accessible and alive version of the same piece, as if it was an antithesis to suffering, finding meaning in life itself. Just thinking about it.
its like if weird fishes was minecraft music
It’s like seeing a childhood photo of a very well known friend
Nice words. I felt something like that too.
It really is. The instrumentation here sounds almost naive, like a child
this is such a beautiful way to put it
I love poetry S2 S2
Yep…a nostalgia trip with all that made just the existence of this song so impenetrably relevant to our day to day lives, past and present. 😫
i’m so happy the final version is the one they went with, and i’m so happy that this version exists
The ending of this version is incredible. A Moon Shaped Pool vibes
the intro sounds exactly like a section off of Ill Wind. or to be more precise, Ill Wind sounds a lot like this
exactly, which makes it even harder to let it end. it was just getting better and better..then...it's over.
its like thom went back in time to 2005 from 2016 to perform it with an orchestra, causing the real 2005 thom to hear it and use it for in rainbows, creating a time paradox.
@@oui2611 I love that idea. lmao
@@ComicSansaMSyess!! that last part of Ill Wind especially
Johhny actually wrote all the music for this
Every time I hear Radiohead early versions I think, Imagine having the amount of talent and beautiful songwriting abilities to abandon these early works as unfinished... I think 99% of people, if capable of making something like this, would be immensely proud
This is filled with Jonny Greenwood's DNA 😂
I love you can clearly hear the Arpeggi in Weird Fishes/Arpeggi in here
One of the tracks from There Will Be Blood has exactly the strings at 3:44. Jonny probably didn’t want to waste such a great arrangement on a demo.
Which tune?
@@baxter.baxter. open spaces
Well, I would say is a technique, not a track
How to Disappear Completely's strings employ a similar technique
This is like, really good. I hope they put these types of songs on In Rainbows' 20th anniversary version.
@The Anti-ISFP unrelated, but i'm loving your username
pdb jumpscare
this version is so good, but you can't beat phil's drums on the album version
Those DRUMMMS!!!!!
One of the best drum beats of all time imo
The amount of effort ( orchestra) they put in a version that never (until now) came to light. This show us how commited with their art they are.
This is taken from a video that came out in 2005.
@@sean1445 that's true, they did a killer version of where bluebirds fly there too. but it's still pretty impressive they wrote a full orchestral arrangement for a song that was probably just written as a few arpeggiated guitar chords, and only had that arrangement performed once. it's not even like it's just the standard "strings playing sustained chords, a view pizzicatos for flavour" kind of arrangement, because this clearly had a lot of thought put into it for a one-time deal
@@pimposki6232 Not saying it's not an impressive composition, just pointing out this version has been available for 16 years.
The score is 100% Jonny Greenwood, their guitarist. The others doesn't have, or have very little say or do in the entire orchestration
@@pimposki6232 Yeah so much effort would've been put into it and yet it was for barely anything. There's a few Radiohead orchestral arrangements that didn't get put to record or performed much.
Beautiful version ... Radiohead is sorely missed ...
What do you mean "sorely missed"? They didn't disband and A moon shaped pool is some of their best work.
We miss radiohead, I don't know what I miss I said
@@jeanreveco5628 do you mean the fact that they didn't make an album in 4 years?
@@zynel413 dude stop patroling around just let him miss rh
@@starosta975 I'm sorry homie
The orchestra is playing Ed's voiced part.
Ed singing his own name
I could listen to this in the background for the rest of my measly little life and not get sick of it, I think. Because it is that organic. The perfect fix. It covers the all the bases of emotions that I think I care to indulge in anymore for this go 'round. Not up enough to make me jump up and boogie, but not down enough to trigger a teardrop. He keeps the ball safely within the boundaries of joy and agony for a safe run to the endzone, but still flirting with the boundaries to the left and the right. For a minute there you forget about the line of scrimmage. It's got just enough of the "Goldilocks Zone" as far as sound driven emotion for me. Not too little and not too much. Thanks for sharing.
You would not believe your eyes
This is astonishing.
It's little glimpses behind the curtain such as this, that affirm to me how Radiohead are in a league of their own.
...astonishing 🙏
Finally: EEEEDDDDD in string sound and orchestral vibes
I remember when the original live version of this was posted. I watched it so many times. Glad to find such a perfect version of the recording 16 years later
That's right. The original poster also had the mp3 to download. I remember hoping that In Rainbows would all sound like this, but it didn't sadly.
The album version's a huge improvement for me, always loved the intensity of that version.
There was a video of this performance way back. It was beautiful, with Thom playing air piano...
I have been hoping to hear this version again for over a decade! Someone on Reddit found a comment of mine in a r/Radiohead post from three years ago asking for this version. They linked me to here today and I am over the moon! Thank you for posting this!!!
Damn I might like this more than the album version. Those strings!
Fantastic, so interesting to hear the evolution of this song
Living at the bottom, looking up at the sky through water, and trying to leave... but caught and killed by the weird fishes. Being trapped in a life you never asked for but don't want to give away.
At this point i tend to believe that Daniel Stashkin is a messiah
Gracias por sacarme del mundo y llevarme al espacio. Amo a Radiohead y a Thom
Y a Jonny
@@AngryTaurus007 también. Ja
Ejercicio:
- Escuchar esto en el valle de la luna.
- Escuchar de noche en el lago Ranco.
Dónde quedan esos lugares?
@@soundstation8343 el primero, en el desierto de Atacama, en el norte de Chile.
El segundo en el sur del país...un lugar lleno de lagos, ríos y montañas...el Lago Ranco es mi favorito! Saludos!
@@victorcalderon8478 Gracias, algún día tendré la posibilidad de llegar ahí.
vivo en calama, intentaré lo primero.. parece buena idea.
- En lo posible bajo el efecto de alguna sustancia, aunque sea de whisky bueno
- Con unos buenos auriculares, parado, sentado o caminando alrededor
I knew this version first (because Limewire), so when I heard the full band version on In Rainbows, I was originally taken aback that they make it fast and guitar based
I love the fact that it was very different but the idea of layering instruments playing arpeggios in different rhythms was always there
c418head
с418 is the same great as radiohead is
@@doomerdream6042 same?
@@lechuzachaquena4604 c418 underrated? On a Friday best band? Smiley face. :-)
Radiohead is a landmark in music history. In a time of commercial music they spend decades perfecting songs instead of just using their names to throw shit out.
This song was already good, but overtime it became something just unbelievable
Holy crap, a studio recording of this with the final version's lyrics would be amazing. That orchestral outro alone is worth it. It's so beautiful.
My god...at 4.00, this is really beautiful.
the ending made me cry :;(( so beautiful
Interesting, agreed the strings give it an interesting vibe, not sure about the programmed synth goes with the strings 100%, but still get to hear all the lyrics which are even better than I originally thought. Thanks for the upload, great tune.
So beautiful, amazing!
This is pretty amazing but I personally prefer the energy of the original. Would be great to just amass an entire album's worth of this material for In Rainbows - like for every track.
technically this is the original...
thanks for this, i'd never heard this version until now, its great!
I didn’t know this existed! Absolutely Phenomenal. :)
thanks Daniel
you save my day time and time again
This is so beautiful
This is amazing!
Thank you ~ so beautiful!
Once the strings section came, I got a little teary-eyed.
Wow
Años sin escuchar esta versión
Increíble ❤️
love the art
Utterly sublime nuanced beauty....!!!!
Tellement beau 😍💖
weird fishes if it was on a moon shaped pool?
best radiohead music
Come on , where’s LP 10 ? 😬🤩
Daniel, no tengo palabras. Solo Radiohead.
Can’t wait to see what they do next ☺️
Thank you Daniel Stashkin for this lovely gift on my birthday. Radiohead I love you always.
Oh wow. Oh wow. Oh wow.
Opening sounds like Boards Of Canada
hearing this version so long before In Rainbows came out really spoilt the studio version for me. As much as I love the one on In Rainbows, this one just hits different. So special.
Does anyone have the artwork link?
This version is absolutely gorgeous... When the strings start... It's just marvelous. Really liked this one
sun9-10.userapi.com/impf/YIpxU2gEgbH0OdlZYOqPlT4WocXbRVVKNMs7SA/2JgcvxBOUaA.jpg?size=2000x2000&quality=96&sign=ce4f76644a95bbdce35a73b85a4e15e6&type=album
@@DanielStashkin Thank you so much, Daniel!!! Very appreciated :)))
Daniel Donwood
@@DanielStashkin do you have a link with lots of artwork of Stanley? i'd appreciate it a ton :)
@@Stephuzz some of my favorites:
jamesusilljournal.tumblr.com/search/stanley+donwood
U da real MVP stashkin
wtf i already love this whaattt
Whoa where did this come from it’s awesome!!
Johnny Greenwood composed this piece as a piece of concert piece for the London Sinfonietta. It clearly became Weird Fishes. And the recording has been slowly surfacing across the internet.
Starts out like a song from the minecraft ost
Absolutely
Sosososososo great 😍
Feel like this would've been a proper B-side for Kid-A.
Kid A + Moon shaped pool =
this has no price, thanks
I love your shares man. I'm a dj and would love to play them. Do you upload them in higher sound quality anywhere else?
Where is this artwork from? It compliments the mood perfectly.
Fucking love this song
Esos violines me tuvieron tan conmovido
Lit
გაასწორა
If weird fishes was released in 2016
Steve Reich vibes
They need to do a new song like this with synth noises and orchestra
Listen to the version they played at bonnaroo in 2006
My favorite version of the song, how did you get it?
Daniel... who are you? (we all want to know)
Where did you find this, uploader?
both the early and final versions are heavenly but in different ways somehow
Is this from a festival? Ether festival?? What was the rest of the set?
The beginning sounds like the end of lucky
can anybody name the main electronic instrument it starts out on that continues the whole time in the background? or what kind of instrument it generally is?
Dude , where do you find these songs?
Sound like moog city from minecraft
I like all the early "In rainbow" songs much better.. like Bonaroo " Videotape " version is the best version ever.
People always say that about videotape because the syncopation is more hidden.
@@alex11v3 Yeah but the again almost all of their songs has it and even more complex.. the version plus the song in itself is the just heartbreaking but so beautiful. This has the guitar in it ;)
I'm sure I took a video of this at the venue. Although 2005 probably means the quality is laughable.
I wonder if that's what Thom meant when he defined music as life affirming. He formulates a more melancholic version of a song and then, by trying to encounter patterns to form a resolution, to get to the next day, he elaborates a more accessible and alive version of the same piece, as if it was an antithesis to suffering, finding meaning in life itself. Just thinking about it.
i have heard this before but definitely not this mix, now tell me who are you Daniel
radiohead la unica banda a la altura de los grandes compositores como bethoven , mozart
This on violins!!!
sheet music for this early version?
Alternate lyrics around 03:00?
The *actual* best song.
is weird fishes had the same vibe as the knives out ep
Where was this version from?
does anybody know the name of the artwork in the video?
"Run" by Stanley Donwood, 2007
@@MonheimPort thanks!
Mi fate sognare ,,, Poi quella voce....
where is this from?
A live performance from 2005, as noted in the description.