50 Years of Fall of Dhaka | Sheikh Mujibur Rehman: Hero or Villain? |
Vložit
- čas přidán 13. 12. 2021
- مشرقی پاکستان کی علیحدگی کا ذکر شیخ مجیب الرحمٰن کے کردار کے بغیر ادھورا ہے۔ ایک وقت تھا جب شیخ مجیب تحریکِ پاکستان کے سرگرم کارکن تھے۔ پھر وہ اسی پاکستان میں غدار قرار پائے۔ شیخ مجیب نے یہ سفر کیسے طے کیا؟ جانتے ہیں سقوطِ ڈھاکہ کے 50 سال مکمل ہونے پر وائس آف امریکہ کی خصوصی سیریز کے پانچویں حصے میں۔
He was not a villain, He was the real hero for us till now and forever..
In Pakistan is called traitor.
@@safdar1178 yes i know that but why you know? Because your leaders they are not want to losses their image, their egoism. So they always want to say that Sheikh Mujibur Rahman and her party was a traitor.but it’s not right...
@@safdar1178
Who is the traitor?
Those who killed their unarmed brother and sister in the dark of night are talking about faith and betrayal.
Shame 😒😒
JOOOOY Bangla 🇧🇩
You are right @md rony islam. He was the only organic leader at that time. West Pakistan did not recognize and understand him and paid the price.
Mujib was a great leader and hero no doubt
Sheikh Mujibur Rahman support Pakistan when the time of Pakistani independence. He was the side of Muhammad ali zinnah in 1947..but after 1947 when Pakistan treated us like a puppet. Discriminated us from all sector then Sheikh Mujibur Rahman change his mind.. So if Pakistan gave us the proper right then it never happened.. So the Fault is Pakistan.
But Alhamdulillah we separated from Pakistan. We are proud of our country.. Bangladesh is now far better than Pakistan in every sector. Alhamdulillah
We Pakistani always helped Bangladeshi people during disasters faced by Bangladesh...i rember that myself at class 4th in 70s collected food items for you people when a cyclone hit your coastal areas...
@@syedraza7299 then why your discriminated with us? Why your politicians wanted to take our mother language? Why the maximum money invested for developing west Pakistan? Why didn’t give our right properly?
Look I know at that the citizen of Pakistan didn’t know about this factor but you don’t deny that your politicians did wrong with us. Your army did wrong with us. In fact my uncle was killed by Pakistani army in 1971. My father's teacher was killed by Pakistani army. We were victims.. If you deny it, if you want to hide your fault then I have nothing to say.
@@kafeespondon1608 we people of Pakistan never ever discriminated you, we always gave affection by providing help during different occasions, urdu is being used in sub-continents as a communication language like English in whole world...i can't speak Bangladeshi but Bangladeshi people can speak urdu thats why urdu is preferred in sub-continents for communication purposes only its not because of hates or something other...
I cannot agree more
@@syedraza7299 if you want know about the truth then please read the hamidur rahman commissioner book.he was Pakistani.. You never know because your media never reveal the truth..we were victim.. You didn’t give us the right..we won the election but your Bhutto didn’t give us the right.. Anyways whole world know the truth and the truth is bitter for you..Your army did wrong with us. Bangladeshi not talking urdu. They are behari who is talking in urdu.. At that time majority was Bengali. But you never accept your fault.. I knew..
My love Bangladesh and Sheikh Mujibur Rahman
Being a Pakistani we should be accepted his patriotism
Thanks vai, I also respect Pakistan but Pakistan should be officially sorry for what they did to us, they killed lot of general people in 1971😥😓
We know the history
🇧🇩❤️🇵🇰
شیخ مجیب الرحمٰن ہی تو اصل پاکستانی۔اصل مسلم لیگی تھا۔ مگر ہمارے بندوق بردار مافیہ نے ذاتی مفاد اور حاکمیت کو تحفظ دینے کیلیے ملک کو دولخت کردیا
শেখ মুজিবুর রহমান ছিলেন সত্যিকারের জননেতা আমাদের হিরো ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩💃🇧🇩
Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman gave us freedom and People's Leader Sheikh Hasina gave us economic freedom. Joy Bangla 🇧🇩
Ek muslim kabhi bhasa ke adhar par des no maanta Bangladeshi country is athest country love from Nepal
@@mdnehalalam591 not atheist. Secular
@@ashishverna4016 I believe the word secular was removed from Bangladesh's constitution when Ziaur Rehman came to power after Sheikh Mujib was assassinated.
He was right and great leader for their peoples
Now same happen with Imran Khan 🇧🇩
Right
Mujib our pride 🥰😍😍😍😍 great leader
Mujib was traitor.
@@safdar1178 for those who are illegitimate like you. He’s father of our bangali nation .
Mujibur Rahman Our Hero ❤️🇧🇩
Joy Bangla 🇧🇩
Joy bangla
He is our father of the nation, a hero
He was the only organic leader left in Pakistan,. Ayub crushed any independent thought that was left in west Pakistan. His vision of united Pakistan was far better, which would have been better for Muslims of entire subcontinent.
We are proud for our great strong dionamic curismatic peace leader Bongo Bandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman of Bangladesh.
He was a hero
No he was traitor to his muslim brother
@@safdar1178 you guys will do discrimination with bengalis, won't give us govt jobs and you guys will export esat Pakistan's products but in the case of development, 95% development you guys will do in west Pakistan and just 5% development you guys did in east Pakistan. So my question is, how you guys believe and think that we bengalis will want to stay with you guys. Mujeeb was not a traitor, he was a hero of bengalis, and also before 1947,mujeeb was so mad for Pakistan,even he didn't miss a single meeting for creating Pakistan, he was the right hand of Sahrawardi, who was the famous Muslim league leader in undivided benagl. But wht our Pakistan gave mujeeb for this abounded love for Pakistan. Pakistan is juts a nonsense, for that reason they are still being poor to poor. Still 73 years running and their GDP is just 285 billion, while our GDP iz 320 Billion+, big big lol
@@safdar1178
Who killed Muslim Bengalis?
Who raped Muslim Bengali women?
It was never a war of religion, it was a war of nations.
And there was an attempt to wipe out a nation.
I don't to fight with both my Pakistani and Bangladeshi brothers ,but I have a ques from both of u.
Why our people at that time deside to make an Islamic country ?
May be your answer is
1. to counter the sense of disbelief for Hindus that they will dominate and do injustice
2 .to establish a country based on Islamic laws.
If I am correct for above ,where were both of u when Babri masjid were dimolished,where are you when we are being killed for eating beaf ,for offering namaz ,for wearing skull cap .With tears in my eyes I say both of you have failed ,and none of u have helped up despite having everything.
@@taif1505answer me , If Pakistan is a bad country, did Bangladesh helped us ? Did they have an Islamic law ? Did they have intrest free economy ?
Man collectively we all ,muslims of India , Pakistan and Bangladesh have failed to be on the path of Islam 😢.
Hope we could understand this and inshallah work accordingly.
Really correct information
Sheikh Mujeeb is our leader before Imran khan ❤️
The Pakistani government was discriminating and greedy, which is why the country is divided. Now you see, Bangladesh has surpassed Pakistan in GDP. If we were living with Pakistan now, Bangladesh would be poor today.
It is an undisputed fact that Shaikh Mujibur Rahman was a patriotic leader. Our common enemy exploited the opportunity.
Please share link in English discussion from BD scholars and historians with a balanced reports as you saw from the Pakistan side.
At this stage we have to forget and forgive each others. We have to strive to find common ground where we and our children can live happily. We have to build bridges and break walls.
Allah apnader kay shob shomai hashi khushi rakhen. Ameen. 🤲🏼
Agreed. In past they used to take all our jute export money to develop west Pakistan and didn't contribute a single Penny to east. Nothing unexpected from them. Pathetic Pakistani rulers
They weren’t discriminating
12:38 - 13:14
The summary of this video. 👌
Yes indeed brother
100%... what's the name of this wise man?
Very good and balanced program based on reality. Thank you VOA. Wonder if we can have a similar or same program dubbed in English for the new generation. And second request if you can include the views of intellectuals, historians and academics from BD as well. This will make the report much more credible.
Sheikh Mujibur Rahman is a Super man great leader of Bangladesh May allah rest his soul in peace amin
Any body win at the war he is Hero.
That was not fall of Dhaka but Rise of Dhaka cuz Dhaka can never ever fall. 🙏
Hero
We always wanted to live as proud Pakistani since the partition in 1947. But you guys need to go back what you did to us!! 23 years of oppression! You never treated us as Pakistani. Your leaders and military dictators always treated us differently in all aspects. We had no option except independence led by Father of the Nation Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman. Joy Bangla. Long live Bangladesh 🇧🇩 🇧🇩 🇧🇩
Joy bangla
Sheikh Mujib jindabad, Bangladesh 🇧🇩 jindabaad
Great job by voa
totally truth
He was our hero ❤️🇧🇩
The real question should be: Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto & Yahya Khan: Villain or Murderous Tyrant?
Sheaik Mujibur Rahman 💚 🤩
Love from Kashmir
Love from Kashmir under control Pakistan 💕
Our national hero,,father off the nation
پاکستان زندہ باد
Assalamu Alaikum,mahammad moshiur. Joy Bangla🇧🇩 Bangladesh Zindabad🇧🇩 Bangladesh is Independent🇧🇩 Bangladesh will always remain an independent Nation and an independent Country🇧🇩🇧🇩❤️❤️
People of Bangladeshi here claiming that Sheikh Mujeeb ur Rehman was their hero, yes why not he was father of Bangladeshi people but my question is that why they couldn't secure Sheikh Mujeeb ur Rehman and killed him with his family?
what are you telling 🤔🤔🤔when did bangladeshi people killed sheikh mujeeb
Those was traitor and dalal or porkistan
@@aryankhan3619 chuttium sulphate how can Pakistani people kill Sheikh Mujeeb from here in Pakistan? Cow piss drinker get some knowledge..if it is true then you should acknowledge our agency performance...jahil...
Best
Bangladesh Jindabad 💙
Villain for Pakistani but father for Bangladesh. Let's see who wins at the end.
Pakistan still thinking that india is the reason behind to divide Pakistan...but Pakistani never accept that what they do.//
shame Pakistan
Bangladeshi people will respect Mujib and zia equally, they both are respected in Bangladesh and they will remain as our great leader forever..
SHAHRED SHAKH.MOJEEB UR REHMAN ZANDABAD
The real question should be: Yahya Khan and Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto: Villain or evil shayateen?
Sheikh Mujibur Rahman tiger
دشمن نے ہماری کمزوریوں اور خامیوں کو سمجھتے ہوئے ایک مؤثر حکمت عملی بنائی جسمیں 1600 کلو میٹر کا بارڈر اور جغرافیہ اور دنیا کی بڑی طاقتوں کا کردار بھی اہمیت رکھتا ہے اور ہم کیوں قابو نہ پاسکے اس میں سیاسی ناپختگی اور دور اندیشی کا نہ ہونا اور بد نیتی،قوم پرستی کا عنصر نمایاں ہے
It requires real guts to be Mujeeb...
OUR Father Of The Nation
The Bangabandhu Sk. Mujeebur Rehman was the first elected PM of Pakistan. His famous party Bangladesh Awami League won 160 seats out of 162 constituencies. The arrogance of Gen. Yahya Khan & power greedy Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto is responsible for the split of Pakistan. No politician in the world ever achieved the popularity what Bangabandhu achieved. His popularity was sky high. After his assasination the world has lost its most popular political leader forever. May Bangabandhu rest in peace. May Allah grant jannah to beloved Sk. Mujeebur Rehman sahab. Ameen. Arif Diwan from Mumbai.
Hmmm.
Du keno tk khub valo
Mujibur reheman is our real hero 🇧🇩
Few mind set is still repeating that mistakes here in karachi and Baluchistan. They never learn anything. God bless this country.
After studying PAKISTANI HISTORY I as a student came to this analysis that Mujib was treated the same way NAWAZ SHARIF was treated by calling him a Highjacker and Mujib as a Agartalah treater. Now the question ❓❓❓ is who were behind the aligations. They were uniformed Generals who were in power working out of their DOMAIN.
No it is proved by Mujib's diary that he was conspirator of Agartalah.
@@safdar1178 Sir there was a commission headed by HAMUD UR REHMAN if that is public then it's going to be very easy for all EAST/WEST PAKISTANIS to understand what happened to JINNAH SAHIBS country. Today they say don't drink and drive you will meet an accident in EAST PAKISTAN we had a drunk driver YAH YAH so he didn't the biggest accident in the history of world.
@@miansarwar7568 it's already released unofficially.
Agartala treaty was a assumption. No evidence found against mujeeb. So do some research. It was a blunder by Pakistan rulers.czcams.com/video/fzxK9Nb-Pyc/video.html
Shoukat Ali (deputy speaker Bangladesh) confessed that Agar Tala conspiracy was a reality.
I'm sure he did , so when was hear say evidence.
What you think has no value until you can prove it.
Losers like the West Pakistani Authorities always have excuses, your evidence lacks any credibility therefore cannot be considered.
Shekh sab wasn't a joke
Need english subtitle. BBC please next time include english sub
As a Pakistan in my accordance 70% to 80% was fault of West Pakistan and 20% to 30% fault of east Pakistan now Bangladesh
How did you work that one out ?
Q nihi kore gah plane . Tumm lok sob Lekar a ja tatha Bangal se,
ab dekho Bangladesh Pakistan se behtor
Joy Bangla❤️🇧🇩❤️
HERO FOR VILLAINS
A villain and master of deception but the father of Bengalis of Bangladesh
What you think has no value until you can prove it.
🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
Sheikh Mujibur Rahman was a Muslim and Bhutto was a Shia
Till Pakistani Punjabi thinks that they own Pakistan more will happen
lol r u Serious....mujhib our reall hero❤️❤️
BongoBondhu Sheikh Mujib is the real hero...
Allah has separated us from you because you wronged us
Firstly shame on Ali jinha who destroyed the feature of muslims of united india.
Shame on general ayub khan who was greedy and living in superiority complex.
Shame on zulfiqar ali bhatu who was power hungry.
Shame on yeheya khan ,bing drunk and unable to introspect on 6point agenda of shaikh mujeeb.
Shame on pakistan politicians who did not introduce landreforms on time.
Shame on punjabi chodheries,sindi wadedars,balochi khans and karachi urdu speakers who were all adament.
Shaikh was more of a pakistani but he was made rebel becs of pak militry....yes that is the history.
United India huh, your result would be in united India as slave of Hindus, today see the Muslim of India running for lives, if Jinnah did not partitioned united India Muslims were slave of the hindus, dominated by them
Punjabis are doing the same mistake against baloch people now a days.
Unraveling of a state that had never been a state. After the hasty birth of a state, the governing men failed to grasp the precarious nature of the state. It never occurred to them that a lucid response was needed to set the stage for a state to move on. Instead, the men in uniform decided to rule. They were no George Washington or even Bismarck. They were local thugs with a uniform. In fact, the first military dictator envisioned himself to be the Bismarck to Pakistan. He was flipping the pages of German history and failed to see the developments that were taking place in India. India: a secular state with stress in education and science.
You should be a writer
What was Bhutto role in creayion of Bangladash, any comments???
In 1969 september pakistan army led by brigadiar zia ul haq ( who later become pakistan president in 1979) led pakistan army killed 20,000 palestinian refugee s in jordan refugee camp. this incident is known as black september. pakistan army killed the palestinian refugees on the order of us president lyndon johnson . pakistan receives us aid in return pakistan does dirty works for usa. more palestinians were killed by pakistan army in 3 days than isreal did in 30 years . this is the true face of munafiq punjabi army
Bangladesh 🐅🐅🐅🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
Traitors are always killed by their own handlers to dump their secrets in the graves.
SHEKH MUJEEB DEKHTA RHA SOR AUTH KAR CHALA GIYA KA KIYA MATLB
CHUP MEIN BHI KUCHH CHHUPA HOTA HE JO BILAKHIR IYAN HOGIYA
YHAN ANSAF NAAN HO WHAN KHATRA TO HOTA HE
ALLAH TALLZH
DANDI MAROON SE
AOR UMHEIN CHLANEIN WALOON SE MULKON SE BCHAYE ANSAF HI SAB KUCHH HE YHXN ANSAF NHEIN
BAGLA DESHOON KI RAHEIN HAMWAR HOTEIN BHEIN
BESHAQ ROZI QIYAMT ANSAF KEMURAKQ SWAL HOGA
Joy Bangla
تھنک یو سو سو مچ voa
To put Bangabandhu Sheikh Mujibur Rahman on the "Blame List" is laughable! It just goes to show how arrogant and how devoid of morality Pakistan's attitude still is.
Angerezo ki nasal ne Kitna saal sheikh mujib ko bura kaha this man world no 1 leader Pakistan
Sheikh Mujibur Rahman is the REAL HERO👍
اس گھر کو آگ لگ گئی گھر کے چراغ سے
Dear Pakistanio please correct your social studies chapter
joy Bangla 🇧🇩♥️🇮🇳
He was traitor and become raw again for sake of power and involved in agartala sazish ..
he become leader after language conflict in 60s
Pakistani establishment was not ready to transfer power because his plan was to separate East Pakistan with just one resolution in assembly after becoming president
NAPAK wardi of pindi is now punishing another ghaddar in 2023.
Your so called leader has created an opportunity to seperate this land. From inception of the state you always behaved us as a step brother of your. You consider us lower level people of so called Pakistan. You didn't take us in crore activities of the state.
اگر تلا سازش کیس حقیقت می شیخ مجیب کی سازش تھی انھیکالم ی لکھا موجود کے شیخ مجیب نےکھا جب ڈھاکا فال ھوگیامی ,,25 سال سے ی خواب دیکھ رھا تھا اج مکمل ھوگیا یعنی علیھدگی کی تحریک مکمل ھوا دی شیخ مجیب .اگر ایوب خان اگر تلا سازش کے تحت مجیب کو جب گرفتار کیا گیا ھے سزاے موت دیدی جاتی بنگالیون کی ھمت نھی ھوتی کے east پاکستان کو الگ کرسکتے مگر گول میز کا نفرنس می جو کچھ ڈراما بھطو.اصغر خان دولتانا نے کیا کے شیخ ےکو گول میز کانفر س شریک کیا جاے .یھی سب سے بڑی سازش تھی جب مجیب کو گول میز کانفر س می ایوب خان کے حکم پر لایا گیا تو بھطو نے ی کھ کر کے می اس میز پر نھی بیطھون گا جس پر ایوب بیطھا ھوا ھے تو بھطو نے کیون اتنا شور مچا یا کے جب تک مجیب اس میز پر نھی بیطھے گا می کانفر نس می نھی او نگا .مقصد صرف ی تھا کے شیخ مجیب کو پیرول پر رھا کرانا تھا اور شیخ مجیب رھا ھوگیا ی چال اصغر خان اور بھطو. ے چلی شیخ مجیب کو رھا کرا ے کیلے .اصغر خان کا بھی بھت منفی کردار رھا .خدا سب سازش کر نے والون سے بدلا لےلیا بھطو مجیب ا ند را گاندھی جرنل ضیاء الرحمان جو بعد مے بنگال کا صدر بنا اور شیخ مجیب کے قتل کے بعد .خود اصغر خان سے خدا نے بدلا لیا اصغر خان کا بیطا جو جرنل مشرف مرکزی وزیر بنا غیر طبی موت مرا خدا نے اصغر خان کو اس طرح سزا دی کے t.v پر اکر روتا تھا کے پولیس.میرے بیطے کیس حل. نھی کر رھی ھے .پاکستان لاکھون ھندوستانی مسلما نون کے قربانی سے بنا .راتون رات نھی بنا ......
Congratulations 16 Dec Surrender Army
Mujib ji sarabi nhi tha
Sir Jo bhi tha but QUAID ka
Pakistan to in zalmun ny tor diya.
Its karma. Jo divide divide khelte hai unki be divide ho gaye .
This is what happens when you betray India in 1947, like when you betray your own mother, your own offspring betrays you 25 years later.
Mojeeb is hero 🥰
بنگا بندھونہیں بنگلہ بندھو
Not like Pakistan 😡
اج کھتے ھین بنگالی شیخ مجیب ھمارا ھیرو ھے .ی بنگالی اس وقت کھان تھے جب شیخ مجیب کو بنگال رنج منط نے قتل کیا اور 3 دن تک مجیب کی لاش اسکے مکان کی سیڑھیون پر پژی رھی اور جب اس می کیڑے پژ گے اور بدبو ا نے لگ گی تب فوجیون نے اسکی لاش اطھای اس وقت ی بنگالی کھان. مرگے تھے ڈر اور خوف سے اپنے گھرو ن می چھپے ھوے تھے .
He was villain
😂 villain who brought justice for his own people. Who called for freedom. And we are proud of that. We don't any concerns about what Pakistani think about him
Your whole nation forever villain😂
بد بخت انسان شیخ مجیب الرحمن
Toba karo.. bht zabardast tha aur bht zabardast kam kiya. Ab hum log bhi chahtay hai pakistan ky 4 thukray ho ja hai. Pakistan sirf panjab & sindi ka pakistan hai bus