The Hinduization of India | Harsh Mander and Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy
Vložit
- čas přidán 14. 02. 2024
- Despite a secular state, India grapples with a growing trend towards Hinduization, stirring discussions on its potential long-term implications.
Guest Speaker:
Harsh Mander is an Indian author, columnist, researcher, teacher and social activist who started the Karwan-e-Mohabbat campaign in solidarity with the victims of communal or religiously motivated violence. He is the Director of the Center for Equity Studies, a research organisation based in New Delhi. He also served as Special Commissioner to the Supreme Court of India in the Right to Food Campaign and was a member of the National Advisory Council of the Government of India, set up under the UPA government.
The session will be moderated by Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy.
Hinduisation is not the same as islamisation. It is rediscovering your roots and soul in your country
After watching your debut i believe modi can win 400 seat
Hilariously Pakistan doesn't have any minorities left😂😂😂..
Oh another Hindu and Modi hater.! India will always be secular as long as there is Hindu majority
Dr parvej ignored history that babri was build by destroying ram temple ..even in India many more temples were destroyed by Muslim rulers and they build masjid there.... Love India ❤
Hinduisation of India 🇮🇳 is Reaction towards islamisation of Pakistan 🇵🇰
This fellow calls himself as scientist, professor but his mind is full of hindu hatred.
Quick question to Dr Hoodbhoy: Will you invite Dr Anand Ranganathan or J.Sai Deepak to talk about the exact opposite side of the spectrum. Those 2 gents are extremely well read and well spoken gentlemen who dont hit the tangent and always stick to the facts in their discourse.
If Dr Hoodbhoy doesnt do that, then it will be seen as his propoganda to equate to mess in Pakistan to whatever is happening in India (these 2 nations are as different as Iceland and South Sudan).
Thank You.
India is secular only because it's Hindu majority. There are only 2 secular country in the indian subcontinent, India and Nepal, both are Hindu majority
Disappointing. The speaker has a tone of reasonableness and fairness, but his narrative is devious and agenda-driven. He quotes Dr. Ambedkar vis-a-vis Hinduism, but is silent on his trenchant observations on Islam and Pakistan. Such men are dangerous.
Fellow started his conversation by saying that Gandhi wanted unified India with Hindus and muslims together. By that measure, Gandhi was a total failure because the fellow is talking to Pakistanis today and trying to justify that Gandhi was great. End of story😂😂😂
Harsh mandar is a face of george soros😜
Why Jains, Parsis, Buddhist and Christians have no problem with Hindutwa in India amd only Muslims do? Prof Dr Hoodbhai being leftist always invites left liberal guests but never independent or RW guest to give opposite perspective to his audience. Mandar is a hard left activist known as chief Urban Naxal in India. He's rabid anti Hindu. Respected professor being a man of science is actually unscientific in his choice of guests. Professor invites only anti Modi speakers. This is typical leftist trait of cherry picking guests who agree with their narrative. Prof Hoodbhai pet narrative is India turning into Hindu Pakistan. So he invites only those who support his pet narrative. Leftist Instead of allowing facts to decide narrative cherry pick facts or guests who support their hypothesis and bias.
In reality m Harsh Mander NGO is biggest recipient of foreign funds from Soros and Nordic evalengical and socialist charities. During Congress UPA rule Mandar and his cronies and their activism has costed India 1% of GDP. All this interferance, narrative setting and agitation against India economic policies has stopped under Modi. His anger and frustration is evident.
India isn't secular because it's written in our constitution, India is secular because its 80% majority is hindu, it is the way how hindu thinks. Secularism is in blood of every hindu.
Hindu is secular that's why 80% doesn't suppress 15% muslims.
Their are Buddhist, Zoroastrian, sikhs, Christians,.. etc various community living peacefully here. No other community have problem except muslims, although thier population percentage increased every year exponentially. Well
Talking about pakistan, first law mininster of pakistan 'jogendra nath mandal' had to run away from pakistan because the people their didn't wanted a secular pakistan that time and they decided to kill mandal and each and every hindu who was in higher levels then, and issued arrest warrant against mandal, thus this much serious was situation back then in pakistan. Such a shame pakistanis talking about minority rights in another country😮.
It's like cat's talking about mice's Rights😅.
A bunch of jokers talking nonsense. Lol😂
This is the original land of Hindus in the only land, there are more than 50 Muslim countries in the world, so what is the problem? If other religions live peacefully in Bharat as they are doing, is fine otherwise you know what, Hinduism doesn’t support violence.
It’s not just that India is getting Hinduized but the whole world..with the growing acceptance for diversity, non violence, vegetarianism, pluralism, yoga, meditation, pratyahar or dopamine fasting, devotion for nature due to climate change, study of consciousness….wealthy educated people of US/west/Arabia..all are getting Hinduized
Request Dr to so invite Dr Sudhanshu Trivedi to speak on the same Topic.
You should be asking such questions from an Indian nationalist rather than from people like Mander who are far away from general public in his thinking.
Harsh Mandar was part of Sonia Gandhi’s National Advisory Council which in effect ran the government. Harsh is deeply political and it’s common knowledge that these Sonia’s loyalists hope against hope to overthrow BJP
Pak youngerster are worried about BABRI, what about SHARDA PEETH of Pak??????????????????????
Please discuss how many Hindu religious temples were destroyed in Pakistan from last 75 yr
" I find no parallel in history for a body of converts and their descendants claiming to be a nation apart from the parent stock. "
- M K Gandhi .
Now.....WE ARE FULLY CONVINCED THAT......CONGRESS MUKT BHARAT IS A MUST.....
Unfortunately Dr Hoodbhoy's understanding of Hindutva is entirely misplaced.
Harsh Mandar is distorting much history and is ideologically driven.
You should invite more objective people rather than ideologically driven if you want to have real discussions and don’t want to have an echo chamber.
Sanatan isn't exclusive and doesn't call for Jihad.
I am proud to be hindu
The Hinduisation of India is happening due to- the Congress's Muslim pleasing policies and brutal behaviour of Muslims wherever they are in majority in India. That is why people turned towards Modi and starting liking him due to his policies. Most of the Indians were not happy for the 1947 partition but now think that it was nice incident to happen. if the Pakistan was formed due to Two Nations Policy, the Muslims should not have been allowed to stay in India. Muslims behave differently when they are in minority and their behaviour changes drastically when they are in majority.
If your enemy starts to worry about you that means you are in a right path😊
Hinduism is not a religion like Islam so there is no comparison
1:04:00 The othering, deservedly, happens only to those Muslims who claim they are descendants of invaders...such as Ashrafis, Sayyids, Khans etc. An eg. would be folks like Saif Ali Khan who would name his child with his Hindu wife as 'Taimur' and rationalize it as pride in his genealogy. Also, Parsis, Jains, Jews, Buddhists, Atheists, Ex Muslims etc have no issues with Hindutva for the sole reason that like Hindutva they are not supremacist.
I am surprised this guy is comparing Gandhi with Jinnah. Jinnah was certainly the guy singularly responsible for the partition of the country.
Pakistani mandir kitne giraye Gaye hai , prevez sir ye bhi discuss karo
This lady has never read Gandhi Ji’s , “ my experiments with truth”. He never advocated Hinduism in that book, except his belief against, “ conversion”.
Hell with secularism. Hell with non violence.
He is elite punjabi who easily migrated without much violence thats why he is preaching those bullshit co existence with muslim.Never entered on ground to know the real mentality of muslims.
Jai Shri Ram my so called Momin brothers 😊😊..
Anti Modi, Modi haters are isolated and exposed.. Kindly bring Prof Rangnathan, Sai deepak, annamalai, they will show ur right place,
Right..
Proud of snatan who unites nor divides, understand
"No true place of worship can be built on the desceration and disrespect of the place of worship of another religion." Thank you Mohandas Gandhi and Harish Mandar for giving the rationale for the Ram Mandir as Babri Masjid was built by destroying an earlier Hindu Mandir. Lets take this logic forward to Kashi, Mathura and right across the country, where Mosques have been built by destruction of Mandirs.
Call JAI SAI DEEPAK and SUDHANSU TRIVEDI on debate.Calling someone who could defame INDIA .Lol
Please invite Sai Deepak and Ranganathan if you are genuine enough
You should read ambedkars view on islam and muslim 😂
Temple in Arabastan is main issue of today's open discussion
Maulana Azad, as the first education minister of India, established thousands of madrasas in India and these were funded by Nehru with government money.
How is it secular??
☪IF it is OK for Pakistan to be ISLAMIC REPUBLIC.
🕉WHAT IS WRONG with India being HINDU REPUBLIC.
Harsh Mandera and his ilk (of course, conveniently) forget the entire history and choose only that which is convenient to their narrative. E.g., they forget 500 years of Hindu's efforts and struggle to get Ram Janmbhoomi restored to them, and choose only to remember that Babri masjid was demolished. That's onky one example. Quoting Ambedkar selectively in another example. No point in giving more importance to them than they deserve. Listeners, please beware of such opinionated 'liberals', what they say.
Times have changed. Hinduization is certain. Aap Pasand Karein ya na karein , Aayega tho Modi hi😂
Who told Dr Hoodboy that Modi is establishing a “ Hindu Rashtra”?
Gandhi Ji conceived an India that consisted of people observing other religions, particularly Muslims and Christian’s. However the Hindus were about 68% in population followed by about 30%. After partition in India, Hindus were reduced to about 85% .
Golvalkar and Savarkar advocated Hindu Rashtra and thought it fair to keep India free of Muslims.
Arundhati Roy matters more in Pakistan than in India
*_why was india partitioned? Why do muslims stab? Why french riots?_*
If u are really interested to talk about India then bring J Sai Deepak or Anand Ranganathan or historian Vikram Sampath.....they will clear your all doubt regarding RSS Hindu hindutva Modi Savarkar
Comparing ziaulhaq with Modi is like comparing Osama bin Laden with Mohammad Ali jinah.......
🤦🤦
Professor Sahib, you get only biased opinions in the name of "information"about India.
Prof.(Dr.) Prem Khosla
Comparing hinduism with religions is like comparing civilization with various ideologies....
what does the speaker say about " kuwwat ul islam" mosque near qutub minar which is a blatant sign of Muslim oppression of hindus. In fact over several years we have had lost our self esteem and pride and we use to ridicule ourselves of being hindus. The so called ' hinduization' of india can never be seen from the lens of pakistan because pakistan clearly and loudly proclaims itself to be a muslim country while this hinduization' is in fact an effort to realise self-esteem which the community has lost. i beg to differ from the view point of our esteemed speaker because he not even for once spoke about the general appeasement of so called minorities in our nation to which this reaction is seen.
Be it Neharu, or Modi all the Indian leaders use Temple money & Temple Property to fund their state gdp deficits... Hindus literally still pay the Jazia. Mr. Hoodboy, please check why temples of india are in control of the Indian govt whereas mosques& Church r free
All Jokers are here and Circus is empty - the great Pakistan circus 🎪
Babri masjid was built on TEMPLE.. we just TOOK BACK...ಜೈ ಶ್ರೀ ರಾಮ್ ಜೈ ಜಗದೀಶ್...jai bheem jai shree ram
Dr. Hoodbhoy, we respect your knowledge. Intellectual of one field doesn't mean expert in every field. Comparing "Islmalisation" with "Hinduism" ? How it is possible. You need to know Hinduism. Please organise a seminar on crueality of historical evidence of Hinduism vs historical evidence of cruelty of Ismalisation. This is a challange towards your intellectual capacity. It is the value system of our society which is always absorbed various other belivers in own country. Instead of inviting to share individual openion, compare the society behaviour. Selective evidence is neither going to help you nor your society or the world as a hole.
For doing this you need to remove Islamic goggle.
Sir, answer your question is - Late Indira Gandhi has started 'Muslim Voting Bank' politics in the election. Their congress party was given money to muslim for the 'Macca - Huj' tour. Everything was done for 'Muslim Vote Bank'... So, people are supporting 'Narendra Modi's... For today's politics is totally responsible for Late Indira Gandhi... Sir, please read the history of the Indira Congress....
A Pakistani anchoring a discussion from Pakistani soil on state of religious tolerance in India under Modi is shockingly odd. The guy from India side is one being investigated for offences. Modi believes in Vasudhaiv Kutumbakam, that is, the whole earth is one family and seriously works for that goal. That's the secret of his popularity. At the same time, there are more Hindus than Muslims who dislike him. That's perfectly understandable. As for Babri, Gyanvapi, be brave to tell the whole truth. No decent Muslim should feel attached to a mosque built by destroying a temple, an iconic one at that. The reforms that are happening now are essentially egalitarian in nature - not pitting one against another, nor any kind of chauvinism, religious fanaticism. Muslims, in general, are happier than before. They've started understanding matters.
Angrez ne kala paani aise hi nahi bheja hoga Savarkar ko....he was the freedom frighter of india.
Your first comment itself is incorrect. If pakistan can be islamic state then why India cannot be Hindu Rashtra? Any reason for you to expect how we should live when you didnt ask ua how you should live? Fair question?
Only hindu hum bhaichara nahi chahiye
To the upright audience n the invitee ( Harish ) can u pls tell us what’s happening in Europe , coz where ever ur above 30% u want sharia , n that is what u want in India
Harsh Mander is nobody in India. Listen to him and keep going down the rabbit hole. Instead listen to J.Sai Deepak, Vikram Sampath, Dr. Meenakshi Jain, Rajiv Malhotra.
Babari masjid ki baat karte he pakistani hajaron mandiron ki baat nahi karte jin ko muslimo ne toda😮
Who started direct action day ... Hindu or muslim 'takle'
30 crore muslim are minority? We are then just three times the minority. We are not too big then 🙂. Paimane ginti ke alag alag to ho nahin sakte. Gandhi is the man jisne partition karaya. He was black mailed by nehru. Why? Can be anybody's guess. Now the doubt is what relation they had?
I feel bad for shakil Chaudhry that he has understand bharat from people like harsh mandar jisko hindutva ka matlab bhi dhang se nahi pata.
Mr Mandar is left liberal pseudo secular 😅.
Mr Parvez please invite J Sai Deepak, Aanand Ranganathan. He is true representative of contemporary Right wing. Please invite him sir
Adolf Hitler destroyed Britain completely in 2nd world war and made her incapable of several of colonies being governed by it. And that is why Britishers had to leave lot of their colonies. And India was just one of them. So it was due to Hitler And not Gandhi that Britishers left India.
How he doesn't know about KK Mohamad??
Librandu's problem
He easily ignore on last question on kashi vishwanath temple.
And last sugar
Make your House in Order
Today's test match between India v/s England ,sarfaraz khan from India scores 62 in 66 balls in his debut mach, how can its possible in a Hindu extremist country, (Ha Ha Ha). If I am the PM, I will gave Bharat ratna to Jinnah, for theorem outs all the mad Max from India.
If you think that RSS idology is bad then also see the works of RSS leaders like Nitin Gadkari
And I want to say that no compare BHARAT with pakistan
comparision make only with the worthy see
and also no compare BHARAT leaders with yours
Ye aadmi kitna zhoot aur misinformation spread kar raha hai.Extreme lies.
World mai maximum mosque, India Mai hai , ye bhi ek reality hai
Everyone was already free but the appeasement by Congress politicians and ignoring the HIndus brought BJP in power
The lovers of Ambedkar in Pakistan, please read Ambedkar's views of Islam and Pakistan, he wrote books extensively on them 😂
TRUE INDIANS DO NOT REGARD GANDHI.WE GIVE REGARDS TO GODSE,BOSE,BHAGAT SINGH and OTHERS.
1:14:20 Stockholm syndrome is real.
0:24 Dard se guzre ho to pehle pak ko secular declare Karo phir baat karo .
Otherwise everything you say is nothing but sheer bad faith.
Mr Harsh is living in LALA land. Totally removed from reality!!
Pakistan needs to answer what happened to 26 percent Non Muslims after 1947 where are they now ,then they can discuss India as much as they want just answer this question
Bharat now finding his own real roots❤❤❤
Only three places are under contenion; Ayodhya mathura and kasi vishwanath
Invite neutral person not a biased anti modi
Too much discussion on Gandhiji less on the subject. Guest speaker could not perform well.
I will definitely give my comments after completion of the discussion.
Hoodboy are you really scientist? You should read Archeological survey report about ram temple site by kk mohmmad and team sorry you are scientists from banana republic
Jai Shree Ram🙏❤️🚩🕉
Hello half minds.
No to Hindu Muslim Unity, only Sanatan Dharma belongs to this pious land.
#BycottGangaJamuniTehzib
#BycottBhaichara
Hindu Nationalism and humanity both go hand in hand they are not a separated entities
Gyanvyapi mandir hai ya maszid sirf itna bata do😂😂😂 sab clear ho jayega❤❤❤❤ dekhte hai aapki aankhe thik hai😂😂😂
When in 1947 , where were these contortists ? When Indian subcontinent is divided on the basis of religion .... When two parts became Islamic countries, who kicked out all Hindus..... What logic they say now it's Hinduization of India. .... It started the day there was a illogical and illegal partition ,as per Dr Bhim Rao Ambedkar ! Someone help me get to this logic of hinduvisation junk ?
Call ANAND RANGANATHAN J SAI DEEPAK
Y no one criticise the behaviour of common Indian Muslim who still have separatist feeling like their ancestors who created Pakistan
Please invite ram madhav 😂😂😂