Ann Merc I absolutely agree. IMHO it's hard to write a good musical finale. I think Starkid does better than most professional musicals - think AVPSY and Twisted - but Inevitable is even better. It manages to both thrill me and scare me. And Emma's 4th wall break during the credits is just perfect. The only better one is Black Friday's "What If Tomorrow Comes", which in my opinion blows away anything Starkid has done before.
I love the ending of black friday because it's uncertain and all the people singing are just... Normal people. People just trying to survive in an apocalypse and I think that makes it a very haunting ending.
I SOOO agree. I can't believe HMB was rated higher. For me What If Tomorrow Comes is not only the best ending of a SK show, but tops anything they've ever done.
TGWDLM is number 1 for me. Everyone's acting, singing, and dancing is incredible in this one (especially Lauren), Jon gets to sing most of the soundtrack, and its both hilarious and terrifying. Perfect ending imo.
Personally, I feel like Days Of Summer should be much higher. It beautifully sums up the mix of emotions you get at the end of a school year; happiness that it’s over, but a little bit of sadness that you get from missing your friends. It just hits a little different than the other endings for me.
I heard it right after moving on to high school, and I sobbed so hard, because it reminded me of just how depressed I was over the summer that all of my friends would be staying in middle school
Her limping around the stage while the others take their bows warning the audience to save themselves, then getting hauled offstage, is the most hilarious 4th wall break I've ever seen. It's my #2 ending (after Black Friday, which blows everything else away).
damn, AJ really only knows how to write one finale song, huh? i love that man. also: one day i won’t cry at “days of summer” but today is not that day.
What If Tomorrow Comes is definitely nr 1 in my opinion. It's chilling, it's beautiful, the melodies and general composition of the song is so mucially interesting and my music nerd is happy, it fits the show so well, the callbacks to the ticking clock, the ambiguous open ending, i mean.. I love it so much. Though i am glad HMB gets the recognition it deserves.
Also I feel like the acting in What If Tomorrow Comes is very overlooked. Kendall not singing the whole show and then taking the lead makes you focus in on it all, her increasingly panicked repetition of the title throughout the song, ending in her interrupting the countdown and then not finishing the phrase because it's over. The other characters milling about almost aimlessly as they realise although they've stopped Wiggly, he's still won. The coming together in acceptance as they countdown until their death. (Sorry for the long response, I'm a theater/English nerd)
@Tyra, @ Omniscient Same! Loved your insightful analysis. For me What If Tomorrow Comes is not only the best ending, it's the best thing Starkid has ever done. A community of flawed people come together to face the end of the world, and all they have is each other... the touch of other hands...
I totally agree with you on "not alone reprise." Its a great song, but as a finale, it just lacks that finale feeling. - Also totally agree with tgwdlm and hmb. They both make you feel sooooooo nostalgic. I especially get chills during the hmb finale.
I personally would have put Firebringer higher because I love how the finale's such a good respons to 'We Got Work To Do', both for the main plot and Jemilla and Zazzalil's conflict. (I also may or may not be biased because of that proposal part 😢) But 'Super Friends' fills me with a million megawatt worth of energy and it deserves that top spot 👌
I personally think Black Friday is the best because like. Most of the endings didn’t really make me feel any emotion really and what if tomorrow genuinely shook me the first time I heard it and still does honestly. So yeah Black Friday for the win in my opinion
I fricken cry every time I hear even one line of Days Of Summer. Like once my gf (who is determined to not be sucked into the Starkid universe) said ‘I don’t wanna see you go’ and then I legit burst into tears and screamed ‘BuT iT’s NoT fOrEvEr NoT fOrEvEr!!!111!!’ She facepalmed. We were in public.
Faithful Gryffindor I think that Devin is friends with her or something so she asked Evanna if she wanted to be a part of it. I’m not 100% sure but that’s what I’ve heard
The first time I heard Days of Summer i sobbed my eyes out, because it was right after a summer where I had multiple break downs about moving to high school while my friends stayed in middle school
I’m so glad you put inevitable and tomorrow will come so high up. Honestly both of them give me chills and I can tell we’re definitely gonna get more amazing closing numbers in the rest of the hatchettfield series
YEAH they left such chills! the harmonies in what if tomorrow, and the sudden ending and the fear- and in inevitable, it was comedic but also so beautiful, and then Lauren yelling and screaming is just a perfect ending!
I don't agree with a decent amount of these (to be fair I feel like my starkid/tcb opinions are controversial for the most part) but I always love seeing these videos. I like seeing people completely vibe with songs that I like well enough but maybe aren't my favourite, so you keep doin you, friend. 👌
i know it’s so low because it’s so short, but the twisted finale is just PERFECT for the show in my opinion. that being said i agree pretty much completely with the ranking and i love the hmb love!
a) you're the first person i've seen that's given justice to twisted + starship b) i was smiling and having such a good time, especially with trail to oregon because it's such a bop, and then it went straight into the dark hatchetfield shows and i had to go back to crying, being scared and wondering what was number one because i couldn't remember what hadn't been done... c) ...and then holy musical b@man came on and my heart EXPLODED because hmb is my favourite show and 100% the best finale!!!! thank you so much for this
Okay 1) I find it interesting how little overlap there is between this and the openings list in terms of the ranks? 2) I can't believe how many of these songs I'd completely forgotten about, even those of shows that I love. I guess this is making me realise that I don't generally care for Starkid closing numbers? I mean not that they're bad, per se, they're just not all that memorable. Except at the same time, for some reason I'm just really into all the Very Potter Musical -verse finales? And a couple of others. But I'm suddenly glad I only did a top 6 for the opening numbers because I found exactly 6 closing numbers that I liked enough to rank. xD 6. idk which song title to put here (A Very Potter Senior Year) - I had to actually go watch the entire ending to this show to figure out where I thought the closing number starts lol. And tbh I still don't know. But like, I know this is purely sentimental but the entire ending of this show is just so emotional. Okay the performance was clearly not very well rehearsed and the songs are reprises of songs from the previous shows, but it feels very right and it works. Whether I count everything from Everything Ends onwards or even just the "bonus" clip, idek, either way it works for me. It probably wouldn't if I didn't love the first two shows so much but I do. 5. Inevitable (The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals) - It's a nice medley of some really great songs and the dissonance between the cheerful tone and the bleakness of the ending is always great stuff. 4. Finale (A Very Potter Musical) - Look it's cute and emotional and it's a great and satisfying end for this classic show. It's all that I need. 3. Super Friends (Holy Musical B@man) - It's just so cute, uplifting, catchy, memorable and heartwarming. That's all honestly. Pretty much the same as above but I'm putting it higher because I like that it's not *just* a reprise (not that I have anything against ending with a reprise). 2. Days of Summer/Goin' Back to Hogwards (A Very Potter Sequel) - I just love this song so much and it makes me tear up every time. It's a cheesy one but it works for me. Also it's the perfect Last Day Of School song. And of course the GBtH reprise is always good, there's never been a GBtH reprise I didn't absolutely love. 1. What If Tomorrow Comes (Black Friday) - What else can I say but CHILLS Also oh my god Kendall's voice is absolutely amazing. I didn't even particularly care for this show in all honesty but I can't deny that this is an absolutely amazing closing number.
Jesus, I will never get over Jon’s, Robert’s, Kendall’s, Dylan’s, Joey’s, Lauren’s, Darren’s, Corey’s, Jeff’s, Kim’s, Jamie’s, Jaime’s, Joe’s, Meredith’s, and Mariah’s vocals!! I’m missing a lot of people here but its because I can’t remember their actual name or I can’t recall a solo they’ve done that makes my soul fly.
The only thing I'm upset about is naked in a lake. Its really just not good as a finale song. So many other songs that were lower work better as a finale cuz they draw in so many elements from the rest of the show. Its not a bad song but its a bad finale
Idk why but the sudden 4th wall break when they start the Show Stopping Number part is my favorite. The sudden edit with the color change, Emma's scream of pure horror....its so SO good.
Controversial comment of the day: while musically speaking the finale for Black Friday is really good, from a lyrics stand point it's a little nonsensical.
I will go on my little rant now. I will try to keep it short. The reason why it’s confusing is cause y’all are really reading “What If Tomorrow” deep enough. By “Do you all see the memories” she knows how all the memories are suppose to be, but wiggly ruined them. “Do you all see what I see?” Is saying that Hannah sees al other mayhem and chaos that’s happening in the mall, but none of the adults can. They just see the doll. Okay that’s my rant.
My top three have got to be 1) Black Friday (the acting gives me chills and the harmonies are so beautiful, its just perfect in every way) 2) TGWDLM (I love the little csmeo to all the other songs, as well as how gut wrenching Emmas screams are, and Jon can act like a deranged alien mad man so well its haunting) 3) Firebringer (once again i love when closng numbers allude to all the previous songs in the musical, but also that double proposal? Lauren and meredith getting married? My baby gay heart cant cope lmao) Its so hard to rank the others though bc theyre all so goo
I knew inevitable was gonna be ranked high and I was pleasantly surprised that super friends was number one. HMB is my favorite Starkid musical and TGWDLM is my favorite musical so it made me pretty happy to see them ranked so highly
I don't know what it is about seeing Draco on good terms with Harry, Ron, and Hermione, but that's one of my favorite relationships in all of Starkid, man
If it’s not too much work, you should put a bit of reasoning on why each song ranked where. There are some songs I personally don’t agree on, seeing your reasons for the ranks would be really cool.
Lauren, Darren and Joey trying not to cry at towards the end of AVPSY always makes me ugly cry.
I'm ugly crying while reading this 😂😂😂😭😭😭
Wait there’s such a thing as beautiful crying? Someone teach me please
You can see the tears in Lauren's eyes
i love tgwdlm’s ending because so many musicals start off great and get worse as they go, but inevitable is one of the best songs in the show
And Inevitable wrapped the musical so well
I so agree. It was a GREAT ending
When it comes to tgwdlm, I personally vastly prefer the second act’s songs to the first act’s.
@@nineof_clubs I know! A lot of musicals have the opposite, but the second act is so good in TGWDLM!
Ann Merc I absolutely agree. IMHO it's hard to write a good musical finale. I think Starkid does better than most professional musicals - think AVPSY and Twisted - but Inevitable is even better. It manages to both thrill me and scare me. And Emma's 4th wall break during the credits is just perfect. The only better one is Black Friday's "What If Tomorrow Comes", which in my opinion blows away anything Starkid has done before.
“I hope you find that swimming pool.”
Why does Darren make me cry with the dumbest lines 😭
fully crying seriously
@red rvr same
"Naked in a Lake" over "Days of Summer" is a HOT take lmaooo
No naked in a lake is musical genius
@@sapphire3215 I love it
I’m confident that naked in a lake was there partly for Jeff’s sax
I love the ending of black friday because it's uncertain and all the people singing are just... Normal people. People just trying to survive in an apocalypse and I think that makes it a very haunting ending.
I SOOO agree. I can't believe HMB was rated higher. For me What If Tomorrow Comes is not only the best ending of a SK show, but tops anything they've ever done.
Ikr? Like we could totally get a sequel out of this
@@frogsayspeace332 there is a show called Nerdy Prudes Must Die coming out. It's the third show to the Hatchetfield series
I’m just waiting for December 31 so I can listen to “What If Tomorrow Comes” timed perfectly so it ends at midnight
@@justalizardd I wish I saw this comment in December cus I so would’ve done that
AVPM HITS DIFFERENT BC OF THE QUIRRELLMORT MAN
I ruined your 69 likes
so true
I just realized that Nick sings « no more dark sad lonely nights » and I’ll never hear it the same again. This is amazing
Super friends is an amazing finale song, it's like a mini rewind but everything is good now and it's just so good I love it so much
its lauren + nick
Abhi Prabakar I Think Jamie sings it too
@@kris6507 yeahhh
I'm so happy to see that HMB finally made it to first place, on an entirely different note Meredith as Wonder Woman is a big reason why I'm bi
But what about Lauren as Arrow??
Brian Holden as Superman is a big reason that I'M bi
Dan Mapplebeck Lauren in general is the reason wlw exist
@@danmapplebeck3182 WAIT LAUREN IS ARROW how dare they not give us a whole dance scene of lauren fighting as green arrow 😭
The change from the upbeat, fun, silly Naked in a Lake to the dramatic, serious, chilling What if Tomorrow Comes made my head spin
same
same for tgwdlm versus hmb
I got whiplash from that
This is one of the first times I've seen HMB take first place... I feel so happy.
It’s such a good song
I haven’t seen HMB yet I got that song stuck in my head
nick lang singing soprano in super friends is the equivalent to me singing tenor in into the woods
He’s my hero. Just because of that fact.
Honestly Robin would totally be a role that I play( male, but pretty high voice)
TGWDLM is number 1 for me. Everyone's acting, singing, and dancing is incredible in this one (especially Lauren), Jon gets to sing most of the soundtrack, and its both hilarious and terrifying. Perfect ending imo.
I KNOW!! The horror musical endings are so chilling and I just love their acting
Personally, I feel like Days Of Summer should be much higher. It beautifully sums up the mix of emotions you get at the end of a school year; happiness that it’s over, but a little bit of sadness that you get from missing your friends. It just hits a little different than the other endings for me.
Days of Summer is one of the only Starkid closing numbers that made me cry.
My_Friends_Are_Idiotas It’s probably the most special to me. I love it so much.
It would definitely be my #1
I had days of summer on loop the week I graduated high school.
I heard it right after moving on to high school, and I sobbed so hard, because it reminded me of just how depressed I was over the summer that all of my friends would be staying in middle school
Everytime I watch HMB I laugh so much at Spider-Man’s dancing after “I wanna be a modern dancer”
Like-
Just watch him.
A vibe.
Chris Allen is a king
The way Not Alone was ranked so low -
Hey 100 like u done good man
laurens acting in inevitable is topnotch. honestly it is so good
Her limping around the stage while the others take their bows warning the audience to save themselves, then getting hauled offstage, is the most hilarious 4th wall break I've ever seen. It's my #2 ending (after Black Friday, which blows everything else away).
FINALLY. THE RECOGNITION "NAKED IN A LAKE" DESERVES
damn, AJ really only knows how to write one finale song, huh? i love that man.
also: one day i won’t cry at “days of summer” but today is not that day.
What If Tomorrow Comes is definitely nr 1 in my opinion. It's chilling, it's beautiful, the melodies and general composition of the song is so mucially interesting and my music nerd is happy, it fits the show so well, the callbacks to the ticking clock, the ambiguous open ending, i mean.. I love it so much. Though i am glad HMB gets the recognition it deserves.
For me What If Tomorrow Comes is #1, then HMB then Inevitable
ta vh I was thinking the EXACT same thing!!
Also I feel like the acting in What If Tomorrow Comes is very overlooked. Kendall not singing the whole show and then taking the lead makes you focus in on it all, her increasingly panicked repetition of the title throughout the song, ending in her interrupting the countdown and then not finishing the phrase because it's over. The other characters milling about almost aimlessly as they realise although they've stopped Wiggly, he's still won. The coming together in acceptance as they countdown until their death.
(Sorry for the long response, I'm a theater/English nerd)
@Tyra, @ Omniscient Same! Loved your insightful analysis. For me What If Tomorrow Comes is not only the best ending, it's the best thing Starkid has ever done. A community of flawed people come together to face the end of the world, and all they have is each other... the touch of other hands...
Starkid and TCB do closing numbers so well
Yes. Starkid and TCB do musicals in general so well.
I totally agree with you on "not alone reprise." Its a great song, but as a finale, it just lacks that finale feeling.
-
Also totally agree with tgwdlm and hmb. They both make you feel sooooooo nostalgic. I especially get chills during the hmb finale.
Glad we agree on number 1
okay but the MAMD finale....underrated
Agree! It should be much higher. Making Love is my goto song when I'm feeling down. You can tell how my week has been by how many times I watch it.
I personally would have put Firebringer higher because I love how the finale's such a good respons to 'We Got Work To Do', both for the main plot and Jemilla and Zazzalil's conflict. (I also may or may not be biased because of that proposal part 😢)
But 'Super Friends' fills me with a million megawatt worth of energy and it deserves that top spot 👌
Senior years is technically everything ends
OH MY GOD IM LAUGHING SO HARD I DIDNT REALIZE THAT MERIDITH PLAYS WONDER WOMEN (YOU CAN SEE HER IN SUPER FRIENDS)
And Lauren plays Green Arrow
And Denise plays Black Canary
@@FloreMar-yp3iz yea I just thought it was funny that Meridith plays wonder woman cause of all of the jokes and stuff Brian makes throughout the show
You don’t know how much I smiled when I realised that
the end of avpsy makes me so so much. just watching Darren sing that adorable reprise made me start crying
Sammeeeee
i literally had to skip when Days of Summer appeared because i was in zoom class (muted ofc) and i ALWAYS CRY, no exception
I personally think Black Friday is the best because like. Most of the endings didn’t really make me feel any emotion really and what if tomorrow genuinely shook me the first time I heard it and still does honestly. So yeah Black Friday for the win in my opinion
IXVMM Plus she’s 14 Kendall and the harmonies are quite good especially compared to the live version of you will adore me
YES YES A THOUSAND TIMES YES
li rvra ok don’t hate but like, as iconic as naked in a lake is I just don’t really care for it oops
ikr Black Friday was robbed
@@seanmcmurphy4744 how was it robbed it was third....
You really did Spy Dance dirty
spies are forever, it’s a musicaaaaaaaaaaal it’s about spies 😩👌
💃 spies are forever
it’s a musical 🕺
🎵 it’s about *spies* 🎶
they included "Do you hear the music? There's nothing to it!" and still ranked it 10th, truly it was done dirty
I fricken cry every time I hear even one line of Days Of Summer. Like once my gf (who is determined to not be sucked into the Starkid universe) said ‘I don’t wanna see you go’ and then I legit burst into tears and screamed ‘BuT iT’s NoT fOrEvEr NoT fOrEvEr!!!111!!’ She facepalmed. We were in public.
AVPS ending is iconic and it gives me the chills and makes me cry every time. Same with TGWDLM
I didn’t know they actually got the actress who played Luna love good to join
Daisy I know like how the heck did they get the evanna Lynch
Right!! I did a double take and I’m still so confused...???
Faithful Gryffindor I think that Devin is friends with her or something so she asked Evanna if she wanted to be a part of it. I’m not 100% sure but that’s what I’ve heard
@Robertson Thirdly i mean its not like its unheard of for harry potter franchises to retcon things,,
I demand justice for Not Alone that song hits me so hard everytime
Yeah in the middle of a show. Not a reprise as a closer.
Can you do act 1 closers next?
Margaret Bonassar we all know twisted would win
it would be Twisted or TTO in a tied first place
Or act 2 opening numbers
Wait, Twisted would win too.
@@FloreMar-yp3iz jingle jangle jingle jangle jingle jangle jingle jangle
@@lobetandsun7584 lmao a fair competition xd
Holy musical batman is criminally underrated and it’s my second favourite starkid show (just because I love tgwdlm with my whole heart)
The first time I heard Days of Summer i sobbed my eyes out, because it was right after a summer where I had multiple break downs about moving to high school while my friends stayed in middle school
Oh no why did you have to end with the Harry/Draco bit? I'm going to cry!😂
During back on top it’s fun to watch the guy holding jabba watching denise
I agree mostly, but Back On Top was ROBBED
Oh my god I hear days of summer and immediately start crying same with not alone its just so emotional for me
I’m so glad you put inevitable and tomorrow will come so high up. Honestly both of them give me chills and I can tell we’re definitely gonna get more amazing closing numbers in the rest of the hatchettfield series
YEAH they left such chills! the harmonies in what if tomorrow, and the sudden ending and the fear- and in inevitable, it was comedic but also so beautiful, and then Lauren yelling and screaming is just a perfect ending!
I don't agree with a decent amount of these (to be fair I feel like my starkid/tcb opinions are controversial for the most part) but I always love seeing these videos. I like seeing people completely vibe with songs that I like well enough but maybe aren't my favourite, so you keep doin you, friend. 👌
i know it’s so low because it’s so short, but the twisted finale is just PERFECT for the show in my opinion. that being said i agree pretty much completely with the ranking and i love the hmb love!
I completely agree!
Lauren having a breakdown in tgwdlm is one of my favorite things
"Why are you clapping?!!"
"Can I use your phone? Please?"
you’re a monster but I also agree with you?
I bet the swoosh at the end of Black Friday is the meteor that hit Hatchetfield :O
Its was implied its a nuclear bomb
@@nora3067 they are literally counting down until the missile was meant to hit, and the woosh happens when they reach 1
if tgwdlm isn't number 1 Ill be surprised bc they stayed in character even for curtain call Edit: I COMPLETELY FORGOT HMB I'm still satisfied
I cry everytime..that avpsy ending. Just kills me. 😭
This just made me relize there's no bad starkid or tcb closing numbers
a) you're the first person i've seen that's given justice to twisted + starship
b) i was smiling and having such a good time, especially with trail to oregon because it's such a bop, and then it went straight into the dark hatchetfield shows and i had to go back to crying, being scared and wondering what was number one because i couldn't remember what hadn't been done...
c) ...and then holy musical b@man came on and my heart EXPLODED because hmb is my favourite show and 100% the best finale!!!!
thank you so much for this
I'd say
12: AVPSY
11: AVPM
10: Starship
9: Ani
8: Twisted
7: MAMD
6: Trail To Oregon
5: AVPS
4: Firebringer
3: HMB
2: Black Friday
1: TGWDLM
Does Spies Are Forever mean nothing to you
Bi Cycle Does Solve It Squad mean nothing to you?
@@bi_cycle i mean its not technically starkid
I totally agree but I'd switch 1 and 2
HOLY MUSICAL B@MAN! FINALLY GETTING THE RESPECT IT DESERVES, I'M HERE FOR IT!
Okay 1) I find it interesting how little overlap there is between this and the openings list in terms of the ranks? 2) I can't believe how many of these songs I'd completely forgotten about, even those of shows that I love. I guess this is making me realise that I don't generally care for Starkid closing numbers? I mean not that they're bad, per se, they're just not all that memorable. Except at the same time, for some reason I'm just really into all the Very Potter Musical -verse finales? And a couple of others. But I'm suddenly glad I only did a top 6 for the opening numbers because I found exactly 6 closing numbers that I liked enough to rank. xD
6. idk which song title to put here (A Very Potter Senior Year)
- I had to actually go watch the entire ending to this show to figure out where I thought the closing number starts lol. And tbh I still don't know. But like, I know this is purely sentimental but the entire ending of this show is just so emotional. Okay the performance was clearly not very well rehearsed and the songs are reprises of songs from the previous shows, but it feels very right and it works. Whether I count everything from Everything Ends onwards or even just the "bonus" clip, idek, either way it works for me. It probably wouldn't if I didn't love the first two shows so much but I do.
5. Inevitable (The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals)
- It's a nice medley of some really great songs and the dissonance between the cheerful tone and the bleakness of the ending is always great stuff.
4. Finale (A Very Potter Musical)
- Look it's cute and emotional and it's a great and satisfying end for this classic show. It's all that I need.
3. Super Friends (Holy Musical B@man)
- It's just so cute, uplifting, catchy, memorable and heartwarming. That's all honestly. Pretty much the same as above but I'm putting it higher because I like that it's not *just* a reprise (not that I have anything against ending with a reprise).
2. Days of Summer/Goin' Back to Hogwards (A Very Potter Sequel)
- I just love this song so much and it makes me tear up every time. It's a cheesy one but it works for me. Also it's the perfect Last Day Of School song. And of course the GBtH reprise is always good, there's never been a GBtH reprise I didn't absolutely love.
1. What If Tomorrow Comes (Black Friday)
- What else can I say but CHILLS
Also oh my god Kendall's voice is absolutely amazing. I didn't even particularly care for this show in all honesty but I can't deny that this is an absolutely amazing closing number.
The ending to black Friday lives rent free in my head since I watched it as it went live on CZcams
Spies are forever its a musical
It’s about spies
tomorrow gives me chills.. many songs from black Friday give me chills
That ending with Lauren and Darren... I'm actually crying.
I agree with most of these but avpsy is soooo underrated
i was getting to the end thinking 'omg what could be better than inevitable' but of course HMB is superior
Holy Musical B@tman finally getting the recognition it deserves. That’s seriously one of my favorite Starkid songs of all time
Totally agree with the top 4, all brilliant closing numbers
Spy Dance is one of my favorites of these just because it makes me smile so much and no other reason
I would've taken FOREVER to decide which of top 3 came before which, I LOVE all three
Jesus, I will never get over Jon’s, Robert’s, Kendall’s, Dylan’s, Joey’s, Lauren’s, Darren’s, Corey’s, Jeff’s, Kim’s, Jamie’s, Jaime’s, Joe’s, Meredith’s, and Mariah’s vocals!! I’m missing a lot of people here but its because I can’t remember their actual name or I can’t recall a solo they’ve done that makes my soul fly.
The only thing I'm upset about is naked in a lake. Its really just not good as a finale song. So many other songs that were lower work better as a finale cuz they draw in so many elements from the rest of the show. Its not a bad song but its a bad finale
HMB is finally first!
Also I'm slightly sad TTO was higher on the list than Firebringer and Twisted but that's just me lol
THE SWITCH FROM INEVITABLE TO SUPER FRIENDS IS SENDING ME
Idk why but the sudden 4th wall break when they start the Show Stopping Number part is my favorite. The sudden edit with the color change, Emma's scream of pure horror....its so SO good.
Yay hmb (my fave!!!!) but why tf is ani so low
Controversial comment of the day: while musically speaking the finale for Black Friday is really good, from a lyrics stand point it's a little nonsensical.
I agree so much! It's so confusing lyrically but musically very beautiful
I will go on my little rant now. I will try to keep it short.
The reason why it’s confusing is cause y’all are really reading “What If Tomorrow” deep enough.
By “Do you all see the memories” she knows how all the memories are suppose to be, but wiggly ruined them. “Do you all see what I see?” Is saying that Hannah sees al other mayhem and chaos that’s happening in the mall, but none of the adults can. They just see the doll.
Okay that’s my rant.
I agree, it's so lyrically underrated.
@@juliana.sirmans Thank you, I think I needed someone to share their perspective for it to click for me.
Bi Cycle it’s also kinda ties together with “What Tim Wants” and “If I Fail you”
*sees TGWDLM at 2nd* what? what could beat th elyrical genius of Inevitable? *sees HMB* OH YES OF COURSE HOW COULD I FORGET
The moment I heard Kendall singing I was like "this is top tier"
LOVE the love for Super Friends. I genuinely think it's the best finale.
I personally wouldn't have put Naked in a lake over 11th, but I guess that's just the beauty of this isn't it? Also yay HMB is first!
What if Tomorrow Comes always gives me chills every single time I listen to it it'd just so good. Black Friday is definitely one of my favorites
I know I just woke up, but Inevitable is the saddest song ever
My top three have got to be
1) Black Friday (the acting gives me chills and the harmonies are so beautiful, its just perfect in every way)
2) TGWDLM (I love the little csmeo to all the other songs, as well as how gut wrenching Emmas screams are, and Jon can act like a deranged alien mad man so well its haunting)
3) Firebringer (once again i love when closng numbers allude to all the previous songs in the musical, but also that double proposal? Lauren and meredith getting married? My baby gay heart cant cope lmao)
Its so hard to rank the others though bc theyre all so goo
You didn’t have to make me cry with the Goin’ Back to Hogwarts Reprise and AVPSY goodbyes 😭😭
I disagree with this list immensely but I still like because the music is just all so bomb
Kaylah Hands same
The Ani dance numbers KILL ME EVERYTIME
THOSE BONUS PARTS AT THE END WHYYYYY ARE YOU TRYING TO MAKE ME CRY? CAUSE ITS WORKING
I definitely feel like AVPM should've been higher but I'm glad HMB got the recognition it deserves
Oh fuck I wasn’t expecting to get jump scared by lightning lol
Crying for 19 min and 32 sec. straight
Omg why'd you have to add that part at the end???? I'm literally sobbing
YOUR RANKINGS ARE THE BEST!!!
putting not alone at #12 is homophobia, but i understand all of your choices lmao
I knew inevitable was gonna be ranked high and I was pleasantly surprised that super friends was number one. HMB is my favorite Starkid musical and TGWDLM is my favorite musical so it made me pretty happy to see them ranked so highly
i had this video as a tab for like a month and for some reason it randomly would start playing so i never got to watch it, but very cool video!
TGWDLM and TTO will always be my favorites
For me Back Friday should 100% be one, such a gorgeous song and that stunning vocal from Kendall!
I don't know what it is about seeing Draco on good terms with Harry, Ron, and Hermione, but that's one of my favorite relationships in all of Starkid, man
You’re my new favorite CZcamsr
14. You
13. Cant
12. Rank
11. Them
10. They’re
9. All
8. Too
7. Good
6. And
5. I’m
4. Running
3. Out of
2. Words
1. Holy Musical B@Man
Yay! My favorite starkid song made it to second!
What if Tommorow Comes is an absolute bop, and a huge part of that is due to the incredible, excelling delivery
The ending of Black Friday always ALWAYS gets me.
AVPSY has the best end
Darren singing 'you get to go to Hogwarts' is the best moment ever. How did noone put it on youtube yet? Or am I the only one who can't find it?
If it’s not too much work, you should put a bit of reasoning on why each song ranked where. There are some songs I personally don’t agree on, seeing your reasons for the ranks would be really cool.
Sorry sometimes I do that but other times, like this time, I was lazy lol 😂
OH FUCK YES, FINALLY SOMEONE IN THIS FANDOM WHO APPRECIATES SUPER FRIENDS!