Laina Nambinga I cried so loudly that my eyes were swollen when he officially left EXO!. afterward, I decided to live exo too 😭. but after I watched this video, I wanted he to join Exo and sing together with other members😢😭😭
you all here saying about Luhan Baekhyun Chen and D.O. and I'm here like Hello My Lay looks awesome when he plays piano, I'm taking piano class because of him and Suga Lay is so damn cute when he plays OMG MA FEELS
Whats wrong with his visuals . Kfans may not be appreciated his talent but korean public .Here he looks like a prince so adorable . He is not typical flower boy idol he is so handsome manly idol with so much masculine facial features yet so gorgeous features too.
@@fanchenworld Nothing wrong with his visuals at all. But they were always underrated amongst kexols. My point was that Luhan was always the most popular bc of his visuals.....even if his vocals weren't at strong as Jongdae's.
@@NelleBear my friends who have bias sehun and kai, they move to chen after know and see chen in real life when to concert exploration Indonesia. They say to me chen more more more handsome in real life and have special face as like an angel
@@tiaratia5271 and here I have fallen for him even without seeing him in real life. Well, fell for his voice first. Now with his whole personality and everything
6년 전 영상에 며칠 전 댓글들이 많이 보이네요,, 다들 저와 같은 마음으로 들어오신거죠...?ㅠㅠㅠ 이땐 진짜 엑소가 최고이자 주변 모두가 엑소 멤버들의 부인이었던 시절이었고 너 아이돌 누구 좋아해? 가 아닌 너 엑소 누구 좋아해? 로 통하던 시절이라는 말이 괜히 나온 게 아님,,, 돌아가고싶다
until now, luhan's departure is greatest loss for SM. Bcs this guy has complete packaged. He was born being celebrity, visual, singing skill, dancing skill, sport, modelling, acting, (i forgot he can play instrument or not) plus great attitude. Imho.. yeah i miss him ;(
but it was luhan who left sm entertainment though, both party has a loss, but i really wished he didn't leave sm and exo, i like him also, it's a sad event, it reminded me of tvxq hiatus, wherein jyj left sm and tvxq.. history repeats itself i think.. :(
Chen's voice- Can make you cry just like that Baekhyun's voice- flutters your heart D.O's- voice that melts your heart, warmth in the voice. Luhan's voice- Soft and make you at ease.
I'm sorry but I miss OT12 so damn much that I still cry when I watch their past performances together...Even though it hurts us..It probably hurts Exo more
The feeling of wanting to turn back time.... Luhan... I wish I was a fan even before you and Kris left.... You're still my ultimate bias until now :( I feel so guilty for ignoring your whole existence on my elementary days.... I wish Tao's super power is real and he could turn back the time where you guys are still complete. You guys worked hard and you deserve all these achievements you have right now, but something's never changed through the past years. OT12 is still here inside our hearts.
그 시절 초딩이었던 현.고3이 요즘 애들에 속한다면 알고있습니다. 저뿐만 아니라 친구들 대부분 알고있는데 말해줘야 자각하는?? 잊은건 아니고, 현 체제가 이젠 익숙해져버렸달까요.. 그 당시엔 폭풍이 몰아치는 시기같았고 엑소가 정말 해체되는건 아닌가...걱정 많이 했는데 아직도 1군 자리를 굳건히 잘 지키고 있는걸 보니 제 학창시절이 아직까지 남아있는(?) 보존되어있는? 느낌이랄까요....
I still remember being so sad when i heard luhan was leaving the group feels like it was yesterday but it's so surreal how times flies so fast but I'm so happy for luhan🤍
This is the reason why I can't unstan EXO, why I can't stan other group. I'm stuck with EXO's voice, I'm stuck with their vocals, with these guys. Talented guys. AND I MISS KRISTAOHAN ALSO.
Saaaaame. I tried to stan other groups aside from them, but Im stuck with Exo's vocals, visuals and talents. Before 2012 Im a multi stan but now I only stan Exo even though Im listening to other groups like NCT. No one can ever beat EXO for me.
Just like in the lyrics, "Stopping the time, (I) go back to you" When the issue came up, (May 15, 2014) I was still full of hope, that it's too impossible for him to leave, like it's a late April fool's joke, the fandom is full of jokes. I was too positive. But when everything was falling apart. Doubts started to fill my heart. "I open this book of memories and I open up your page And in the book I’m in there, in there with you" I imagine Kris and Luhan doing this and opening the book to their OT12 page.. "I’m struggling to find you who I cannot see I’m struggling to find you who I cannot hear" I thought of this song, I wanted to stop time so badly. It really hurts me that it's so accurately meant for EXO. Now that every time I watch EXO, I wouldn't be able to see nor hear Kris and Luhan anymore.. I try to move on, I tell myself that I have moved on. But I'm just making a fool of myself. I can't pretend that I'm okay, because no, I'm not okay. Only OT12 can make me feel that way again. I'm sorry, I just.. I don't know. Sometimes I watch EXO's recent videos and promotions, I feel proud of them, but I tend to go back and watch the old ones, MAMA, Wolf, Growl, MID, even Overdose. Because OT12 era was their stepping stone, and I become irrational and hate the fact that EXO's doing great now, but they're not together. They're not complete. I want them to reach the top, together. I'm sorry, but for me, the number 12 is the only number that I'm allowing to say that EXO is complete. I respect OT10 stans, but this era was really, really precious to me. I was so down. They cheered me up indirectly. They don't know it. They don't know me. At times I hear EXO, an image of 12 individuals flash in my mind, and I feel like I'm going to explode at any moment. I mentally question them, "Why did it have to happen? And I repeatedly tell myself, "Why are you damaged this much?" It just had to happen... Why.. oh why.. those questions just run in my mind non-stop until now.. begging to be answered. And I have no idea when those questions will be satisfied.. Perhaps, never.
Wu Yi Fanfan I feel you...I can't stop myself from missing OT12, even if I still follow and love them now... It hurts weirdly. It's my first time stanning a band and I can't believe how much I love them. I discovered them through Miracles in december so it'll always be a precious memory for me as well
Is anyone here in 2020? I really miss Luhan tho actually all of them, OT12 :((( edit: Yo, hold up! I didn't thought this will blew up! Lets Support them Always ❤️
I miss these days seriously 😢 I know maybe Kris,Luhan and Tao are more successful as solo artists than they would ever be as Exo group but I still miss them all. This video made my heart hurt so much!
I don't like the pain, the tears and the heartbreak, but I still come back here to celebrate the magnificent voices of these gifted young men! Facts: EXO slays any genre! I will love and support them until the very end!
Why can't lay be with ot9? Is he even gonna be part of their shows in 2019. He said he'd be there when the boys need him. Don't the boys need him now? Ohh luhan!!! He's a jack of all trades. Want ot12-- Kris tao
they are all amazing but CHEN IS A WHOLE DIFFERENT LEVEL like his voice is a light through the clouds from heaven to people's heart and oh his superpower is lightning
Even though I became EXO-L when EXO already lost three members, I promised to myself that I'll support them 'till the very end. I feel the pain you feel as I watched their video as ot12. I miss them even though I'm not by their side from the very start. You, senior EXO-Ls--Exotics are so lucky. You know everything that happened to them---tough times or not. You're so tough and brave too. You make our boys so famous. You defend them. You stay by their sides when they need the strength even though it's hard for you too. Respect. And the fans of KrisHanTao who still supports EXO until today, I respect you. You didn't let go. And my respect to yours is growing knowing that you defend them too. You're tough. And me, as an EXO-L, promised to stay by their side until the very end. To be their shield. To support them. To defend them. Let's all stay as ONE. Are we one? EXO-Ls, let's love! Saranghae💖
If you look into lyrics you ll understand this song is a mixture of emotions , mainly D.O and Baekhyun's parts are about sweetness of love ,sweet memories they had,thankfulness towards her wanting to be with her again but Chen's part mainly is regret , blaming himself for selfishness , and longing with regret . What a masterpiece .
I come here after watching exo performance killing voice at dingo, i’m cried so bad when their started to sing miracle in december, remember when their sing it with luhan :(
I always come to cry because I miss them so much when Luhan is with EXO I really miss them a million words I can't say only love, love and miss you all (EXO ot 12) always😭😭😭
Whenever I listen this song I cannot appreciate them individually because there song touched me as if one person is singing this song . Chen was so amazing , I can feel the song better because of his voice and same for beakhyun . D.O was as amazing as usually , beautiful voice and finally luhan , luhan voice look soo youthful and and he always will be my bias . Love luhan , love exo
My Luhannie 😭💔... I can't even describe how much I miss him, he was the reason I got into exo/kpop I really just wish sometimes that none of 2014 events happened. Seeing his face in the thumbnail made my eyes tear up instantly... I miss you bambi ❤💔 #ot12
Luhan and Kris and Tao have their own path. I have to admit they left a big hole in EXO but day after day I can see that it okay if they leave cause EXO WILL STAND TALL AND STRONGER THAN EVER
![Mnet [엠카운트다운] 엑소(EXO) - 월광(Moonlight) + 중독(Overdose) @M COUNTDOWN 2014.06.05](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pjnEeYAn4SQ/mqdefault.jpg)
루한 진짜 뒤지게 잘생겼다 ㄹㅇ 루한으로 엑소 처음알고 존나 연옌중에서 찐 첫사랑이였음ㅋㅋㅋㅋ반갑네
ㄹㅇ
루한 사기캐죠..중국인치고 잘생긴 얼굴에 노래랑 춤도 ㅅㅌㅊ고 에혀 ㅋ 뭐 런멤버지만ㅋㅋ
@@zzzz71717 중국인치고는 ㅋ
@동당 그랬나요 ㅋㅋ 전 데뷔초에도 크리스 너무 중국인 느낌나서 별로였었어요 데뷔때도 루한이 갑이라 생각ㅋㅋ뭐 사람마다 보는눈은 다르니깐요!
크리스는 데뷔초에도 딱히였던거 같은데 엑쇼에서도 활약못하고 그 당시에 크리스 ㅂㄹ 인기없었음
뭐야 피아노 치는 사람 그냥 세션인 줄 알았는데 레이였음 왜 기껏 나와놓고 피아노만 치다가 들어가는 거야 당신 ,,,
이 댓글 개웃기네 ㅋㅊㅍㅍㅌㅋㅊㅍㅊㅌㅋㅋㅊㅊㅍㅊㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ와중에 피아노 잘 쳐ㅠ
일본 정본대 경찰대 첸 오빠 안녕 난 엑소 루한 에 유전자 피주이자 막내여동생이에요
첸 오빠 안녕 난 엑소 루한 에 유전자 피주이자 막내여동생이에요
타오 오빠 안녕 난 엑소 루한 에 유전자 피주이자 막내여동생이야
시우민 오빠 안녕 난 엑소 루한 오빠 의 막내여동생이야
와 이게 2013년 거구나....생각없던 5학년이 벌써 고3이 됐다니 안믿긴다...ㅅㅂ 이땐 진짜 엑소가 최고였는데
나는 그때 고3이었는데 스물일곱대따....
@@user-bh5hg1jd5b 이때 20살아니셨나요?
일해라절해라 앗 네,, 재수해서 고3이라고 생각했네여 ㅠㅠㅠ
@@user-bh5hg1jd5b 에고 ㅜ 저랑 동갑이시네요 ...아픈곳을 찔러서 죄송해요 ㅠ
저랑 동갑이시네...02년생 ㅠㅜㅜㅜ
난 아직도 이노래가 겨울만 되면 떠올라… 뭔가 주변에 눈 엄청 내리는데 나 혼자 거리 걷고 있는 기분… 진짜 추억돋는 노래임
근데 이거 원래 3명이서 부르는 노래 아닌가요?
왜 여긴 4명이지..
저두 추워지면12 월의 기적 이 떠올라요 빨리눈내리는 겨울을보구싶네요
팬 어닌데 알고리즘으로 떠서 보는데 진짜 오랜만이고 ㄹㅇ 추억이다... 저때가 그립다
BCDE A 초딩? 헐 나는 중딩이였는데
난고딩이엿눈데,,, 다어리시네 ㅠㅠ0ㅠ
저도 초딩이었어유..근데 이젠 고딩 ㅠㅠ격하게 돌아가고싶다
곧 중졸입니다...😩😢
초6이었던 것 같은데 올해 스무살 됐어요ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Lets talk about Lay played the piano. I MISS U YIXING
The piano is the real highlight... I just knew it right now its Lay who played the piano 👏 👏 👏
😞 I miss him
Me too
Me too. I miss him so much😞
일본 정본대 경찰대 안녕하세요 저는엑소루한에친유전자이고 막내여동생이에요
썸네일이 살짝 흠칫 했음..
좋아했다 루한 내가 존나게 사랑했었다...
헐 여기도 계셩ㅋㅋㅋ슴덕이신가 보네용
우리얘들 내꺼임 당연하죠..^^이수만 발닦개입니다..^^
헐 저 엔시티 영상 댓에서 봤는데 여기에도 게시네요 저두 슴덕이라 가끔 슈주 영상도 봐요
벗어날 수 없는 수만의 굴레
와 시즈니다
2022년에 추억 따라서 찾아오신 분 계신가요
형님, 제가 한국어를 할 수 있었으면 좋겠어요. 시간이 되시면 어떻게 하는지 가르쳐 주시면 감사하겠습니다 🥺😩💔
12월만 되면 들으러 와요
I'm from the future (2023)
La canción se llama diciembre in 2014 esa🥺🥺❤❤❤🥺
2023我还在追忆
ㄹㅇ 아이돌계의 레전드다 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 엑소없인 말할 수 없음 ㄹㅇ 굿즈 걍 엑소걸로 도배... 당연한 엑소 사랑... ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 모두가 다 변백현부인이였던 시절 그립다
와 .. 추억이다 나는 김종대 부인이였는데 지긍 왜좋아햏는지 참.,
저는 도경수부인...
방탄소년단뷔 거짓정보 때문에 모두보이그룹들이피해봐요
방탄소년단뷔 기자들이 이렇게 말했습니다 제가 직접 연락을 하고 있습니다 체포영장을 발부했다 누명을 쓰고 있습니다 협박까지 하고 있습니다 체포영장을 발부했다
첸 오빠 안녕 난 엑소 루한 에 유전자 피주이자 막내여동생이야
im a simple girl. i see Luhan, i click. i cry my eyes out
Laina Nambinga I cried so loudly that my eyes were swollen when he officially left EXO!. afterward, I decided to live exo too 😭. but after I watched this video, I wanted he to join Exo and sing together with other members😢😭😭
Hannisa Haris ahhhh same i rlly miss ot12 but i support what they are doing now
첸 쟤는 무슨 데뷔초때부터 노래를... 개잘했었네.... 솔직히 아이돌이란 걸 제외하고서도 첸이 노래하나는 기가막히게 하는데; 참...
1. I miss them
2. Chen's voice SO POWERFUL
3. Lay is a very talented pianist
Thank you, i was just about to ask if it was Chanyeol on the piano
하....루한 얼굴.. 진짜 겁나 좋아했다...
you all here saying about Luhan Baekhyun Chen and D.O. and I'm here like
Hello My Lay looks awesome when he plays piano, I'm taking piano class because of him and Suga
Lay is so damn cute when he plays OMG MA FEELS
Yixing is so beautiful playin the piano and in that outfit. Please please never leave Yixing I am so worried I can't handel it again.
Chen's vocals are just next level. Kfans never appreciated his talent enough; sad how visuals still remain most important.
Whats wrong with his visuals . Kfans may not be appreciated his talent but korean public .Here he looks like a prince so adorable . He is not typical flower boy idol he is so handsome manly idol with so much masculine facial features yet so gorgeous features too.
he is just as handsome as the rest members. as expected for EXO being no Visual Hole group
@@fanchenworld Nothing wrong with his visuals at all. But they were always underrated amongst kexols. My point was that Luhan was always the most popular bc of his visuals.....even if his vocals weren't at strong as Jongdae's.
@@NelleBear my friends who have bias sehun and kai, they move to chen after know and see chen in real life when to concert exploration Indonesia. They say to me chen more more more handsome in real life and have special face as like an angel
@@tiaratia5271 and here I have fallen for him even without seeing him in real life. Well, fell for his voice first. Now with his whole personality and everything
I went back here because of EXO's performance in 2018 Gayo Daejeon and I think I just want to hurt myself more. I miss Luhan.
Me toooo!!!!!
Samme I end up crying 😭
Same.
Same
Same babe. :")
진짜 추억이네... 저때만 생각하면 눈물만 나... 너무 행복했었는데 우리.. 엑소 쇼타임 때로 돌아가서 그 시절의 행복과 추억을 다시 보내고 싶다
6년 전 영상에 며칠 전 댓글들이 많이 보이네요,, 다들 저와 같은 마음으로 들어오신거죠...?ㅠㅠㅠ 이땐 진짜 엑소가 최고이자 주변 모두가 엑소 멤버들의 부인이었던 시절이었고 너 아이돌 누구 좋아해? 가 아닌 너 엑소 누구 좋아해? 로 통하던 시절이라는 말이 괜히 나온 게 아님,,, 돌아가고싶다
이노래 들으면 많이 그립다... 지금은 팬 아니어도 이노래 자주 듣는사람은 있쟈나... 우리 오빠들 응원하지 않아도 좋은데 노래는 여전히 노래실력은 더 좋으니까 가끔 들어줘..
It's unbelievable how Luhan looks like an angel!
He is definitely an angel!
He's Cuter and cuter
Yeeah right.
He is angel in my heart
ㅎㅏ... 루한 내 최애였는데 진짜 존나 열정적으로 사랑했다
i'm back here in 2018 and its almost december. can't believe its already 5 years since this song is released, and i still miss ot12 so much 😭
이제 8년 지났는데 아직도 겨울이 오면 크리스마스 오면 꼭꼭 듣고싶어짐….저때가 진짜 행복했다……..진심 그립다 이젠 볼수없는 그 모습들
until now, luhan's departure is greatest loss for SM. Bcs this guy has complete packaged. He was born being celebrity, visual, singing skill, dancing skill, sport, modelling, acting, (i forgot he can play instrument or not) plus great attitude. Imho.. yeah i miss him ;(
Yes!! He's even the number 1 most valuable person in China aside from the officials. Lay is #2
he is so sucessful in China now!
but it was luhan who left sm entertainment though, both party has a loss, but i really wished he didn't leave sm and exo, i like him also, it's a sad event, it reminded me of tvxq hiatus, wherein jyj left sm and tvxq.. history repeats itself i think.. :(
i still miss our deer luhan😢
he is still with sm ent though until 2022. so somehow they are still earning money from him.
Chen's voice- Can make you cry just like that
Baekhyun's voice- flutters your heart
D.O's- voice that melts your heart, warmth in the voice.
Luhan's voice- Soft and make you at ease.
Yuki Hwa Yang Yeon Hwa Luhan doesn’t need a voice to make us cry
Lay's piano skills - makes you cry even more
Chen’s voice does all that
@@jisungpork9342 because he leave?
Lay is a Super talented pianist
I'm sorry but I miss OT12 so damn much that I still cry when I watch their past performances together...Even though it hurts us..It probably hurts Exo more
ღAzmalie Stylxღ i feel you :’)
مادرو عنهم
Love the old exo
Me too ㅠㅠ
I’m a new exol and I’m almost in tears everytime aswell when it comes to OT12
The feeling of wanting to turn back time.... Luhan... I wish I was a fan even before you and Kris left.... You're still my ultimate bias until now :( I feel so guilty for ignoring your whole existence on my elementary days.... I wish Tao's super power is real and he could turn back the time where you guys are still complete. You guys worked hard and you deserve all these achievements you have right now, but something's never changed through the past years.
OT12 is still here inside our hearts.
요즘애들은 엑소가 12명이였던걸 알려나
@@user-jx9wf6vv4i 한국에서 활동하는 엑소-K와 중국에서 활동하는 엑소-M 이었는데 K랑 M사이에 L이 있어서 엑소엘이 된거쥬...
그 시절 초딩이었던 현.고3이 요즘 애들에 속한다면 알고있습니다. 저뿐만 아니라 친구들 대부분 알고있는데 말해줘야 자각하는?? 잊은건 아니고, 현 체제가 이젠 익숙해져버렸달까요.. 그 당시엔 폭풍이 몰아치는 시기같았고 엑소가 정말 해체되는건 아닌가...걱정 많이 했는데 아직도 1군 자리를 굳건히 잘 지키고 있는걸 보니 제 학창시절이 아직까지 남아있는(?) 보존되어있는? 느낌이랄까요....
그냥 엑소도 모르는 애들도 있던데,,,
수호가 애들한테 엑소 아냐고 물어보는 영상 있는데 아예 모르던데 그거 너무 기분 이상했음
@@user-sg5cd4zu3n 솔직히 초등학교 저학년이면 방탄이나 유재석같은 초초레어급 인지도가진 연예인아니면 모르죠.. 그러다가 중학생 쯤 되면 ses 이문세 이런 가수들까지 다 알게되죠..
WHO SEE THIS IN 2019 ?
this video made my heart hurt
iftitah shf yeah
Yeah
Meee this song will forever be one of my favorites EXO songs ever
2019
Me too 😢
chen voice like an angel ~~I become tears when I was miss 鹿含
me too
Is 唅instead of 含
it’s actually 晗
+Hans Zee i know but I type it wrongly
Me too. His voice is so powerful, it never fails to make me cry.
I still remember being so sad when i heard luhan was leaving the group feels like it was yesterday but it's so surreal how times flies so fast but I'm so happy for luhan🤍
썸네일..........ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 너만은 믿었었다.. 솔직히 저때가 너무 좋았긴 했는데.. 띵곡도 많고 지금처럼 음악차트에 막 술먹고 우는노래, 이별노래만 꽉꽉 채워져 있지 않았는데 저때가 그립다.
This is the reason why I can't unstan EXO, why I can't stan other group. I'm stuck with EXO's voice, I'm stuck with their vocals, with these guys. Talented guys. AND I MISS KRISTAOHAN ALSO.
King of Vocals. Missed them so much. 😔
How can anyone ignore them!! They are just perfect..
Saaaaame. I tried to stan other groups aside from them, but Im stuck with Exo's vocals, visuals and talents. Before 2012 Im a multi stan but now I only stan Exo even though Im listening to other groups like NCT. No one can ever beat EXO for me.
Same!
Same
Came here because i miss luhan sang in korean.. 😢
수능끝나고 두근대는 20대와 대학입학을 앞둔 2013년 12월에 들었던 노래인데 어느덧 벌써 2023년 12월이라는 10년의 시간이 지나있네요...
30대를 앞두고 20대를 앞둔모습을 추억해보니 감회가 남다릅니다...
진짜 뭔가 지금도 현역이긴 하지만 향수병 그룹인 듯
저 때 저 감성이 모두에게 추억이 되게 만들었던 그룹..
Omg Lay! These boys are earthy angels for sure. They're so adorable.
그래.. 참 좋아했었지..... 정말 좋아했다... 지금도 가끔 예능 나오면 반갑고 귀엽고.. 멈춰서 보게
되더라. 행복했으면 좋겠다.
이 시절을 너ㅓㅓㅓ무 보고싶다 ㅠㅠ 지금 보니 너무 슬프면서 행복해지고도 하고... 엑소의 겨울 앨범들이 진짜 레전드네. 듣자마자 10년 전의 추억이 흐르는 것도 신기하거든. 내 청춘은 엑소라는 말을 이제야 알았다.
omg Lay' is playing piano
Just like in the lyrics, "Stopping the time, (I) go back to you"
When the issue came up, (May 15, 2014) I was still full of hope, that it's too impossible for him to leave, like it's a late April fool's joke, the fandom is full of jokes. I was too positive. But when everything was falling apart. Doubts started to fill my heart.
"I open this book of memories and I open up your page
And in the book I’m in there, in there with you"
I imagine Kris and Luhan doing this and opening the book to their OT12 page..
"I’m struggling to find you who I cannot see
I’m struggling to find you who I cannot hear"
I thought of this song, I wanted to stop time so badly.
It really hurts me that it's so accurately meant for EXO. Now that every time I watch EXO, I wouldn't be able to see nor hear Kris and Luhan anymore..
I try to move on, I tell myself that I have moved on. But I'm just making a fool of myself. I can't pretend that I'm okay, because no, I'm not okay. Only OT12 can make me feel that way again. I'm sorry, I just.. I don't know. Sometimes I watch EXO's recent videos and promotions, I feel proud of them, but I tend to go back and watch the old ones, MAMA, Wolf, Growl, MID, even Overdose. Because OT12 era was their stepping stone, and I become irrational and hate the fact that EXO's doing great now, but they're not together. They're not complete. I want them to reach the top, together. I'm sorry, but for me, the number 12 is the only number that I'm allowing to say that EXO is complete. I respect OT10 stans, but this era was really, really precious to me. I was so down. They cheered me up indirectly. They don't know it. They don't know me. At times I hear EXO, an image of 12 individuals flash in my mind, and I feel like I'm going to explode at any moment. I mentally question them, "Why did it have to happen? And I repeatedly tell myself, "Why are you damaged this much?" It just had to happen... Why.. oh why.. those questions just run in my mind non-stop until now.. begging to be answered.
And I have no idea when those questions will be satisfied.. Perhaps, never.
***** Thank you. :')
Wu Yi Fanfan man i feel exactly the same way! omg I thought i was the only one who was going to die because of the news :{
Wu Yi Fanfan I feel you...I can't stop myself from missing OT12, even if I still follow and love them now... It hurts weirdly. It's my first time stanning a band and I can't believe how much I love them. I discovered them through Miracles in december so it'll always be a precious memory for me as well
+Wu Yi Fanfan I feel the same way T.T
I think I speak for everyone when I say that every Exotic has/had that same feeling. Exo Is 12 members. But thank you for putting in words what I felt
omg i miss this moment!!! When Lay playing piano...T.T i never forget this era...
Lay is playing piano 😍 he is attracting me
This version is better than the recorded one cause Luhan is in it. And its my favorite song from exo!
+Drone Beetle there's luhan in the recorded chinese version of miracles in december
2018 i still love Luhan
Dira Junifa Kato 2019 i still love Luhan
What's wrong with you? He is not dead? He still sings and starred in TV shows only in China. Why does everyone say so about Luhan as if he died?
@@Comebackherein2050 becouse me and they miss luhan together whit he brother EXO
@@kingwaterdragon8040 i don't understand at all
@@Comebackherein2050 We miss luhan singing with all the EXO members and miss him back on stage singing and dancing in a soft and harmonious voice
Chen, my beautiful angel with your amazing voice
Chen💙
첸 가창력 대박이다..
this is the miracle i need in december... ot12 😢
me too
Kay Lim good
can they please be 12 again? that's the miracle of December I really want! I cry everytime I see luhan miss him with exo!
Yeaa :(
yeah i really cant imagine that their not complete now!!!
Really miss them... alot...
OT12 :(( I miss the 12 naugthy and funny handsome wolf boy's :((
julia locon I'm having a major OT12 throwback right now.. and.. and every video I play.... ;______________;
Is anyone here in 2020?
I really miss Luhan tho
actually all of them, OT12 :(((
edit: Yo, hold up! I didn't thought this will blew up! Lets Support them Always ❤️
sis yes 😭
Mee🙋😭
Me 😭😭😭
I’m here as newbie exol 😭
Ot12 in our heart forever ❤️❤️😭😭
A 10 year-ago song that touched my heart back in 2015 to the point to become an EXO-L. It still touches my heart in 2024
엑소.. 당신들은 내 첫사랑이였어 그땐 정말 이 노래 들으면서 눈물 한바가지 흘리고 그랬는데... 지금도 가끔은 눈물흘린다........
한때 엑소 너무나 사랑해서 모든걸 다 도배하고 엑소엘인더 티내고 다녔던 그시절이 있었는데,, 루한 넌 내최애였어,, 이때가 좋았던 그시절이 그립다
I miss these days seriously 😢 I know maybe Kris,Luhan and Tao are more successful as solo artists than they would ever be as Exo group but I still miss them all. This video made my heart hurt so much!
I do too huhu
I don't like the pain, the tears and the heartbreak, but I still come back here to celebrate the magnificent voices of these gifted young men! Facts: EXO slays any genre! I will love and support them until the very end!
3:10 baekhyun just made his clear voice a little deeper plus....my favorite part of the song
😭Luhan and Lay we miss you ❤️
Why can't lay be with ot9? Is he even gonna be part of their shows in 2019. He said he'd be there when the boys need him. Don't the boys need him now?
Ohh luhan!!! He's a jack of all trades.
Want ot12-- Kris tao
We are one my tears are falling
tao too
Lay never left the group
@@Jungyu9799 no he did not but we still miss him
썸네일보고 안 들어올 수가 없었다...그냥 이상하게 그러네..
they are all amazing but CHEN IS A WHOLE DIFFERENT LEVEL like his voice is a light through the clouds from heaven to people's heart
and oh his superpower is lightning
Baekhyun's voice sounded like an angel.. Chen's voice is so powerful. And Luhan.. God how much I miss Luhan 😪 his voice is so damn good as well
2017 i still miss luhan saw much :(
Mimi the crazy he is an chineese singer and a actress now, you can see him anytime xD
The movie he acted in fighter of the destiny is a hit xD
Mimi the crazy 2018 I still miss my Lulu , chicken not my style and panda. And my tears always flow.. 😭
Mimi the crazy
*me too 😔💔*
YlevolEfles1892 Gap
*me too 💔💔*
miracle in december is never failed make me crying.n luhan on the thumbnail make me cry even more:( miss u uri lulu
I still get emotional everytime I think about how exo started with 12 members.. ㅠㅠ
경수야 넌 노래야......제발........
제발...
배우도 좋지만 나는 도경수음색에 환장하는 인간이라..🤦♂️
첸 오빠 안녕 난 엑소 루한 에 유전자 피주이자 막내여동생이에요
노래 좀 해줘 제발..
ㄹㅇ 경수 음색깡패인거 스엠만몰라 스엠만몰라 스엠만몰라....
ugh jongdae solo voice really powerful but when all sing they voice become one without someone really strong. i love y all:3
Yes he so amazing
왜 눈물나려 하냐
옛날생각 나면서 추억 여행하게 되네...
제발 겨울앨범이라도 내줘....
팬 아닌데도 이노래 들으면 저때가 생각나고 눈물난다..
luhan keeps improving with each performance ;____;
Even though I became EXO-L when EXO already lost three members, I promised to myself that I'll support them 'till the very end. I feel the pain you feel as I watched their video as ot12. I miss them even though I'm not by their side from the very start. You, senior EXO-Ls--Exotics are so lucky. You know everything that happened to them---tough times or not. You're so tough and brave too. You make our boys so famous. You defend them. You stay by their sides when they need the strength even though it's hard for you too. Respect.
And the fans of KrisHanTao who still supports EXO until today, I respect you. You didn't let go. And my respect to yours is growing knowing that you defend them too. You're tough.
And me, as an EXO-L, promised to stay by their side until the very end. To be their shield. To support them. To defend them.
Let's all stay as ONE. Are we one?
EXO-Ls, let's love! Saranghae💖
Amen. We are one. You wrote this so perfectly.... i have tears in my eyes😢🤧💖
우리 모두는 그것을 그리워합니다. 그러나 우리는 그들이 자신들의 이유로 떠났던 것을 기억해야하며, 우리는 그것을 존중해야합니다 (당신이 무례하다고 말하지 않고) 모든 구성원이 성공하고 건강 해지기를 바랍니다!
우리는 하나 다❤
This made me cry😭
I feel the same way. Perfectly put in words.. 👌
Tao :'(
They all sing so beautifully but Chen amazes me every single time.
If you look into lyrics you ll understand this song is a mixture of emotions , mainly D.O and Baekhyun's parts are about sweetness of love ,sweet memories they had,thankfulness towards her wanting to be with her again but Chen's part mainly is regret , blaming himself for selfishness , and longing with regret . What a masterpiece .
What about Luhan's part ??
@@aishaexo-l611 Luhan's emotion is more of being at peace after the breakup
Miss Luhan so much 🤧
눈물나 너희 좋아한지 벌써 4년째인데 왜 이렇게 힘들까... 좋아하면 좋아할수록 생각이 많아져 그냥 아무것도 모르던 이때가 그립다 널 좋아했던 이때가 그리워
I'm LITERALLY fucking crying. GOSH! I MISS LUHAN SO MUCH ;-;
Jungcock your name omg 😂😂
Yixing is beautiful.
7 years.... im back here to hurt myself
Me too 🤧
Me too
yes me too😭
Me too😭😭😭
Same
December 2019 and it's still a song that makes me cry.
I miss luhan. 😭
EXO❤🍱💞💟💘💝💜💟💞❤🍽🍚❤🍷📦💟💘💘🍝💞💞❤🏝
Me too.I miss luhan so much 😭😭😭
@@nakowithk-popmyanmar1416 KrisTaoHan went on the same stage again.
@@edenmariesoriano1354 yessssss
who is here after 5 years crying?
OT12 IS MY LIFE😭💔
idk 1020 huhuhuhu 😭😭💔💔
me
I am crying
me😭
me ofc :(
The moment I realized Lay was playing the piano was the moment my bias list was destroyed
Chen's voice always sends shivers down my spine. Their voices are all so beautiful together
came back because special christmas stage 2020. missing this song, really i am.
I miss them 😭
I miss them 😭😭
I'm here Christmas Day 2020
i miss them😢
Same 😥😥😥😥
I CRIED BECAUSE OF LUHAN
:(( I MISS LUHAN OF EXO
My manly bias luhan miss u .
My galaxy style kris miss u.
My cute panda tao miss u.
이게 9년전이라니 미친...
Went back after listening to Hongseok, MJ, Hyonjin, and seungwoo version.
they were so good..
same but now I'm here crying over how exo used to have 12 members and now some of them are in army/came out of army😭
Same 😥😥😥😥😥
YEAAA
same for me...I suddenly miss ot12 huhuhuhu
I WISH THIS EXACT MEMBERS WILL SING THIS AGAIN IN DECEMBER. IM HOPING FOR A MIRACLE.
It will be nice if they do 😭😭😭😭❤️
Ot12 forever
루한오빠 현빈이 친유전자맍잖아
@@빈-c5b 무슨 말이에요
MIRACLE for real😭
How many more Christmas and December we will count? 7 december already passes and nothing changes :((( i’m so sad My God
yixing😍😍😍😍😍
I come here after watching exo performance killing voice at dingo, i’m cried so bad when their started to sing miracle in december, remember when their sing it with luhan :(
I always come to cry because I miss them so much when Luhan is with EXO I really miss them a million words I can't say only love, love and miss you all (EXO ot 12) always😭😭😭
Whenever I listen this song I cannot appreciate them individually because there song touched me as if one person is singing this song . Chen was so amazing , I can feel the song better because of his voice and same for beakhyun . D.O was as amazing as usually , beautiful voice and finally luhan , luhan voice look soo youthful and and he always will be my bias . Love luhan , love exo
Luhan looked like a baby here. Love him and miss him sooooo much. He will always be in my heart.
ever time I listen to this song and hear chen voice I always get goosebumps and cry Idk why
Same girl it's okay💖
Lay playing the piano . . .so soft
My Luhannie 😭💔...
I can't even describe how much I miss him, he was the reason I got into exo/kpop I really just wish sometimes that none of 2014 events happened.
Seeing his face in the thumbnail made my eyes tear up instantly...
I miss you bambi ❤💔
#ot12
이 시절이 너무 그립다 그냥 다른거 신경 안쓰고
엑소만 바라보면서 열렬하게 좋아했던 시절
Luhan and Kris and Tao have their own path. I have to admit they left a big hole in EXO but day after day I can see that it okay if they leave cause EXO WILL STAND TALL AND STRONGER THAN EVER
I hope Kris, Luhan, and Tao will meet EXO member which will come and can comeback OT12 again, but i think about it is very impossible:(
It's impossible they have left EXO officially now , they still can have a collaboration atleast...
존나 웃겨 아니 실은 안웃겨 최신댓글들 다 과거형이야 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ사랑했었다..좋아했다...
ㅎㅎ......(웃긴데 눈물나온다..)
지금 그쪽도 과거형이죠....??
아놔 님도 ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ 이게 더 술퍼
i fell off of my bed when i saw that lay was the one playing piano
***** I.KNOW.RIGHT.
Me too *^*
***** same
Lay is so talented
4 best vocalist together....miss luhan