The 10m 0.64 Wavelength Ham Radio Vertical Antenna - One of the Best

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 8. 09. 2024

Komentáře • 78

  • @Mechanics.Life80
    @Mechanics.Life80 Před rokem +19

    Man, you are so great at explaining the details with antennas. And that fact that you even spoke about your mistakes, don't see many doing that. Please keep making these videos! I have learned so much from you.

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před rokem

      Thanks, Mistakes are how we learn and we should always acknowledge them.

  • @jeffreyyoung4104
    @jeffreyyoung4104 Před rokem +3

    Back in the 70s and early 80s, they had the Penetrator and Super Penetrator verticals that out performed many of the verticals of 5/8 wavelength made by other manufacturers, the only reason others were sold was due to the price of the Hy-gain Super Penetrator being almost three times the competition!
    But you got what you paid for with the Hy-gain brand! They used aircraft aluminum, and excellent clamps. When the weather turned bad, the competition would literally fold and fall apart!
    The reason I bring it up, is many hams would also buy them and tune them up for 10 meters!
    The Hy-gain brand became one of my favorites and one I would buy again!

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před rokem

      I would be curious to see what these antennas actually were? I wonder how you could have compared to a 5/8th in practice? Build quality is worth paying for.

  • @chrissmith7655
    @chrissmith7655 Před rokem +2

    Hi , made a dipole ,turned it vertical, worked US, Brazil, Uraguay and more. Dead simple. Thanks.

  • @russellroberts2228
    @russellroberts2228 Před 2 měsíci +3

    Fascinating discussion of a rarely used DX antenna. I've built several 5/8 wavelength antennas throughout the years and have never been disappointed by the results. Thanks for the most informative video. Aloha, Russ (KH6JRM).

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před 2 měsíci

      Thanks Russ. The matching puts people off I think. Well worth the effort though.

  • @d3w4yn3
    @d3w4yn3 Před rokem +4

    Look... so, I've been tracking your videos for a long time, and every time I think to myself "Holy shnikeys!!! This guy is a mad genius!!!" you go and out-do yourself and prove that you are even smarter than I thought you were before. Well, you've done it again! Very well explained, and very motivational! The best videos aren't ones that just make you think, they are ones that make you feel like you can do the thing, and that motivates you to actually do something and not just think about it! You should be charging for this content!!!

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před rokem

      I really wouldn't call myself a genius but I do have some talents. I'm quite selfish really, for me to make content like this I need to be 100% commited into the project for myself. Once I sus it out then I really do enjoy sharing with others and I'm glad the motivation and encouragement is coming across. I get a lot of help for these projects from the community so its the least I can do to give back. More good content (I think to come soon).

  • @vincenzofidanza2539
    @vincenzofidanza2539 Před rokem +3

    Hello Colin few years ago I made a 10m 5/8 antenna by the plans of N2FFL. This antenna uses a 5/8 element and a classic inductor for impedance matching while the radials are only 103 inches. I did not use the capacitor that he uses, please check on his site. This antenna works vey well . I only use two radials because i do not have room for four. The radials extend about 3 feet on each side and than drop down, always because of lack of room. The tuning is quite broad extending to 29 and more Mhz by memory. Noise is quite low. I also made a 20 meters 5/8 vertical about 12.7 meters tall and the radials are 5.3 meters long . In this case I used your LC matching system. It tunes well but the bandwidth is reduced respect the broader bandwidth of the 10 meters 5/8 .

  • @garyh8315
    @garyh8315 Před rokem +1

    Colin, your attention to detail is 2nd to none. Well explained, well presented. Thankyou

  • @eddiepiecart6030
    @eddiepiecart6030 Před 22 dny +1

    I have a home brew 0.64 wave vertical.
    I did away with the matching transformer by using a 4 element capacitance hat.
    It really helped the bandwidth too and no matching device.
    Ben VK8GC

  • @timg5tm941
    @timg5tm941 Před rokem +3

    Excellent video Colin

  • @Dr-T
    @Dr-T Před rokem +2

    Good video Colin 😀
    I've been on 17m today and worked China with 5W FT8 using a 5/8 vertical.
    Interesting observation about your vertical being 'quiet'
    The higher Q the antenna, the less noise it receives. Its a bit like reducing the IF bandwidth of your RX. As you narrow the BW, the noise is reduced. Its the same for antennas -- so you are correct!
    When I get a moment I'll try and replicate your 10M antenna.
    One other way of making low value capacitors is to use double sided FR4 PCB material. I can't quite remember the rule but I think its about 1Pf per square mm. Great for QRP and maybe up to 25 watts but not too good for 100W and certainly not for 400w!
    73
    Bruce G4ABX

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před rokem

      Always value your feedback Bruce. I'm glad my low noise comment made sense. Its definitely quieter. Noticed the same on my 10m version. Some people were saying I should have used a tapped coil for a bigger bandwidth but that would just increase the noise. I'm keen to hear your thoughts on a 10m version 👍

  • @radiotests
    @radiotests Před 9 měsíci +1

    I'm here to follow your efforts and build my own Five Eight 10.

  • @quadcam24v
    @quadcam24v Před rokem +1

    A shootout between the Moxon and the 0.64 Vertical would be great.
    Your comment about everyone wanting an instant antenna is spot on, I have found doing POTA/WWFF that it gets easier to setup everytime you go out.

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před rokem +1

      I need to do this comparison but likely will be next winter when there's reliable DX there most days.

  • @russ_vee_jr4199
    @russ_vee_jr4199 Před rokem +1

    Interesting.
    Many, many cycles ago, I used to rag chew with the Brits on 29.000 (and up) on FM direct. No repeaters involved. I had a 3 element inverted Delta Loop, tuned for 10M repeater work, mounted on my roof. This placed the boom at about 40 feet.
    The band was open, not long after my sunrise, for most of their daytime. What a grand cycle that was, but I can't remember the years.
    I had a Kenwood TS-430 with the FM module installed. I'm not certain, but I think when operating in FM mode, the output was limited to 25 Watts.
    (A mind is a terrible thing to looooz)
    HaHa
    I'll put this antenna into my Bucket List, maybe to use this Fall/Winter.
    Actually, I'm planning on a Half Square for 20M later this summer and might also include one for 10M.
    Thanks for the video, Colin.
    BTW: You Do Good Work.....
    73 OM

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před rokem

      Perhaps the cycle in the early 80's? Ive heard to many veteran operators talk about how good it was. I've only been licenced from 2011. I had a hoot then with my 3 eli beam then a Hexbeam, regularly using 29mhz AM and a few watts. When the band is open the average joe is able to get a decent antenna in the air and feel like a "big gun" 🔫

  • @mortimersnerd801
    @mortimersnerd801 Před 7 měsíci +1

    ...there are a few folks around that can actually 'smell' RF...and they have a good sense and understanding on how things really work particularly on a practical basis rather than theoretical.. Colin is one of them.... you might have missed it but Colin's remark on putting 4 tuned radials on a half wave vertical (really a single band efhw) also makes good sense and might pull the takeoff angle to the horizon down another few degrees..I have limited resources here in Mexico so you have to work with what you got.... Richard VA7AA/XE1

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před 7 měsíci

      Dont know about that but appreciate the kind words 🙏

  • @JayN4GO
    @JayN4GO Před 9 měsíci +2

    Well done Colin. Explained very well. I’d opt to say this antenna Will complete with my Mosley ta33 with the beam at the base point of the vertical. Elevated verticals work very very well on 15.12.10 and 6m. Would love to hear the comparison with the moxy.

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před 9 měsíci

      Thanks Jay. I need to do the comparison with the Moxon but regardless I'm very happy with its performance.

  • @WECB640
    @WECB640 Před rokem +1

    OUTSTANDING video Colin! I agree, the .64 antenna is the best vertical.
    Now what I see from your first set of measurements,....it looks like Simsmith (a great program that I also use), gave you the correct approximate values, but it displayed them as a LOWPASS when they should be configured as a HIGHPASS (C - series, L - shunt on the load side). I wonder if this is a software glitch in Simsmith even though the screen says it is set to lowpass. I'm basing these findings on the data shown in the 4th schematic on the web page at 7:09 in the video. That bottom schematic shows 819nH (shunt) and 22.7pF (series) The first set of values from Simsmith (the wrong ones) are 819.7nH and 18.53pF and these are very close to what you ended up with, BUT they are presented with the incorrect schematic.
    Keep up the great work!! We need to build more, and buy less....just like our forefathers did. One doesn't learn much from buying a massproduced storebought item.
    73 OM

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před rokem

      I'm not sure, I ended up with approx what I highlighted at 7:09 1.4uh in series and 6pf in shunt. I know you can do it a number of ways. I certainly took a bum reading somehow initially.

  • @boxingday11
    @boxingday11 Před rokem +1

    Nice one Colin, will try this, have my Sigma 4 copy up and she works well, Patel is a great chap👍🏻.

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před rokem

      Worked him many times years ago on my old Hexbeam. Sometimes each day

  • @GordonHudson
    @GordonHudson Před 7 měsíci +1

    That might be a close match on 10 MHz too. Im working on a vertical that will cover both bands. Basically a quarter wave on 10MHz with a coil that lowers the resonant point on 28 MHz to make it nearer the bottom of the band. It will end up closer to 5/8 on 10m. GM4SVM

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před 7 měsíci

      Thats a good shout. I will sweep 30m next time its up. The matching unit may throw it off but it could be bypassed.

    • @GordonHudson
      @GordonHudson Před 7 měsíci +1

      @@MM0OPXFieldRadio I think a dual band vertical is doable. I'm certainly going to try it. 3/4 wave isn't too good for angle of radiation, but if I make it electrically longer it might work. Without a coil it will be resonant about 29.5.

  • @michaelrichardson4884
    @michaelrichardson4884 Před 9 měsíci +1

    Only just found your channel and glad I did (apart from needing an interpreter - kidding) very nicely presented and content and technical and smartly assesed all details. Poss only 2nd of yours I watched because after 1st really knew I needed to subscribe. You already have a great 10M Mox (we should liase) and still build and use another type for the same band. I like that very much. All the best. G7VYH and 73's

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před 9 měsíci

      Appreciate the comments. I love my 10 and 15m Moxons. Time unfortunately gets the better of me and I struggle to get the physical R&D time in. I need to get the feed arrangement sorted to dual band the 15/10m version as that suits most gardens. I also have a very nice Hexbeam for 20-10m nearly built.

  • @ea6wu
    @ea6wu Před 8 měsíci +1

    Thanks for the video!

  • @g0fvt
    @g0fvt Před rokem +1

    Well done again, very well explained and presented. I am surprised you did not stay with 1/4 wave radials though (unless I misunderstood that part), You may find that 1/4 wave radials perform slightly better. As for the vertical section... it MIGHT be interesting to use ladder line shorted at top and bottom to simulate a fatter conductor, it may give you some bandwidth advantage. Or possibly shorted at the bottom and cut to slightly different lengths at the top. Regarding the noise... it MIGHT be your decent polar diagram, "ignoring" ground based interference sources very close to the antenna. FWIW MMANAGAL can also create matching circuit values... Keep up the good work, 73

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před rokem +1

      Thanks. I used the 0.67 radials as these are a supposed improvement over 1/4 wave radials. who knows. I used 1/4 wave radials on the 17m version. The Smokin Ape did a video recently demonstrating the matching network in MMANA and the results were not far away from my actual values used.

    • @g0fvt
      @g0fvt Před rokem +1

      @@MM0OPXFieldRadio I don't know the answer but 1/4 wave radials should be very low impedance. I will give it some thought. 73

  • @charlieoscar09
    @charlieoscar09 Před rokem +1

    Great video Colin and such and interesting aerial. Can you do another video on air

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před rokem

      I will do sometime but likely the autumn or winter when the band opens again for reliable DX.

  • @richardfryer3695
    @richardfryer3695 Před 9 měsíci +1

    ...going to try both the 5/8 and the 1/2 wave Colin and compare the difference. I have the room to tinker high up on a flat concrete roof full of rebar. My 80m 1/2 wave does resonate on 10 meters, but it's way too high in the band to be useful, unless you're really into FM repeaters. You, The Evil Lair (who has a thing for "Experts"), and Bret from Survival Coms sold me on the Fair Rite 264325002, and it's improved efficiency due to form factor. I've scored 2, not an easy task in small town Mexico.. Tnx again... Richard VA7AA

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před 9 měsíci

      Good luck. Keep me updated on how it goes. I dont think there will be much difference between the pair.

  • @PatAutrey
    @PatAutrey Před 5 měsíci +1

    just thinking out loud, have you ever tried feeding a vertical antenna with ladder line, to get a doublet multiband result. This works quite well for inverted V dipoles, just wondering if it would work on a vertical - of course a tuner is required

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před 5 měsíci

      No I haven't. I dont hava a balanced tuner but it will be a good antenna. Tim built this and made some videos on it.

  • @eugene-anthony4823
    @eugene-anthony4823 Před rokem +1

    Very interesting video, thanks! It seems to me that it is not necessary to conduct a detailed calculation of matching and make them constant, but simply install a L-Match. This will make it easier to quickly and accurately tune the antenna in various other places. Also, what if, instead of all those radials, I installed a folding aluminum mat with a GTU?

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před rokem

      Yes, your right in general an L match would work and likely more broad banded but. The match shouldn't change if you have it of the ground. The aluminium mat would likely work if you have this ground mounted.

  • @Nick_G7IZR
    @Nick_G7IZR Před rokem +2

    Isn't it the case that the height of the antenna is the critical element here and that a 1/4 wave who's tip is at the same height as a 5/8 wave will perform just as well over anything apart from a theoretical perfect ground?

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před rokem +1

      Yes and I know the articles you are referring to. Over perfect ground there is nothing to split hairs. Practically I think the installation is easier with this as your gaining height without raising the feedpoint.

  • @theradioham
    @theradioham Před 18 dny +1

    Nice Colin, where do you get your wire from

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před 18 dny

      This stuff was from Cablecraft. It was about 16p/m. Now up to about 20p/m I think.

  • @PatAutrey
    @PatAutrey Před 5 měsíci +1

    How close are you to the coast. just wondering if you're getting an assist w the salt water

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před 5 měsíci +1

      Im a good bit away. Probably 8 miles as the crow flys at least.

  • @johnratcliffe6438
    @johnratcliffe6438 Před rokem +1

    That's a low noise floor considering you are using a vertical. Are you going to market this antenna as a commercial product, as you did with the Ajustiwave?

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před rokem +3

      Afraid not. Adjustiwave was about trying to get some of my extensive R&D costs back and that long since stopped. I just like trying new things.

  • @PatAutrey
    @PatAutrey Před rokem +1

    Are you aware of any multiband antennas that can be made using a coil and capacitive section of coax or are they always monoband?

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před rokem

      Afraid not. Effectively you what you need is a variable length antenna with an autotuner at the feedpoint to achieve what your talking about.

  • @2EOGIY
    @2EOGIY Před rokem +2

    The length should be exactly 2/π, which gives 0.637*λ

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před rokem +2

      I wont get my knickers in a twist over 0.03%, probably not measurable on performance.

    • @paulsengupta971
      @paulsengupta971 Před rokem

      Mmm, pie. Do you need a π match for that?

  • @stevenmcc6052
    @stevenmcc6052 Před rokem

    Main concern is usa guys say the 5/8 wave is no flame thrower.
    My thoughts are most guys your trying to contact are on beams etc so horizontal. So the only people dx who should get you well are other verticals. A good link would be a 5/8 talking to a 5/8

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před rokem +1

      That's not true for ionospheric propagation. The polarisation gets screwed up in the ionosphere so may not stay vertical or horizontal. Line of sight or tropospheric propagation maintain their polarisation. Ideally you would have identical beams for HF, one vertical and one horizontalnto allow you to switch back and forth when there is fading for example.l

    • @stevenmcc6052
      @stevenmcc6052 Před rokem +1

      @@MM0OPXFieldRadio
      Yes sometimes a rotation of your signal by 90deg would hit a beam 100% but not all of the time.
      Ive seen a guy with 2 rx one with vert ant and one horiz ant. He said signal heard shifts from ear to ear. As one drops out its all in other ear.

  • @kellypaws
    @kellypaws Před rokem +1

    I need to try a different antenna. I've never even *heard* a station from India on 10 here.

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před rokem

      Worked him many times at the old QTH on my Hexbeam. He has good ears when you see how far down he was here. if you have a clear take off you should be OK.

  • @trig6712
    @trig6712 Před rokem

    Cheers Man " er Whit Next HI thanks

  • @eddiepiecart6030
    @eddiepiecart6030 Před 18 dny

    Why are the radials so long?

  • @markfeltham9456
    @markfeltham9456 Před 11 měsíci

    0.64 is not the way Owen did it Colin
    He actually makes it a tad shorter, he designed one for me for 20 metres and didn’t agree with the 0.64 “old wives tale”

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před 11 měsíci

      Just read the document. I don't have a fraction of the knowledge of Owen. Pragmatically I agree if you are in the ball park it will be good enough. The only true way is to measure field strength at differing distances and angles which is nigh on impossible. Modeling is only so good. Get the antenna length in that realm and a bit plus or minus wont be noticable.

  • @larrynorris8775
    @larrynorris8775 Před rokem

    too much talking

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před rokem +1

      Cant please everyone im afraid. Viewer retention time is much higher on this video over my average so I'm doing something right. Everything I said had a point and I wasn't explaining what I had for my dinner last night.

    • @ptsmonvideo
      @ptsmonvideo Před rokem +1

      @@MM0OPXFieldRadio That’s Chuck Norris cousin. He was expecting more action 😂

    • @MM0OPXFieldRadio
      @MM0OPXFieldRadio  Před rokem

      😂😂😂