This is spot on, and I greatly appreciated the direct hands on comparison with the other 3 models. Rattly bracelet aside, it says a lot about the SPB143 that it even can make an appearance in this video with watches that cost 4-10x the price.
@@BowlOfSalmon Yep... Tbh , the spb143 just makes the pelagos irrelevant to me in my collection...Sure , it's obviously a much better watch...I just don't think i could justify the amount in price difference.. The seiko scratches that itch just fine.
@@876yuugt really eh...I've never heard that about the Tudor..What's wrong with qc? For me I find my modest spb143 with the uncle Seiko jubilee scratches my Tudor itch...Yes that sla is a beauty
I bought the 42mm and I absolutely love it. I love that it just blends in not worrying about getting it stolen extremely well made. Congratulations on your purchase and many journeys to take the watch on
Your conclusion actually supports its uniqueness while providing “character” 1) titanium (lightweight) 2) color of titanium (gunmetal) 3) bezel lume 4) bezel sunray 5) red ‘Pelagos text’ 6) square lume plots with blue lume 7) dial is a different shade of black vs gray, matte, inky 8) tudor shield logo on crown 9) 1st generation of the 39 Pelagos !!!! 10) endlink with OEM rubber strap and attachment Most importantly like u said it’s yours!!! U build memories around it….you add character to it not the other way around
You make me want one ! Oh right. It’s on the wrist. I need to do a follow up on this video. Claps bugs me. Sharp edges bug me. The lack of lume on the hands too. Otherwise. Great. Still boring. But great 😅
Loved the bezel sound comparison! Helpful review and agree, it does seem to lack something, despite being just about “perfect”. I wonder if the rehaut with cutouts was a large factor in the charm/character of its big brother 🤔
You hear it said in Special Forces communities such as the SAS that they look to recruit “the grey man” - a person who doesn’t stand out and can blend in. Sounds like this is the grey man of divers. And that sounds pretty perfect. Great video sir. Thank you!
Best video yet Tom! I love the Pelly39. It checks a lot of boxes. But, you said it right when compared to the Sub, it's probably going to be a filler until that call comes, IF that call comes.
Oh thanks man. This one was a struggle and I felt I lost eye of my video a bit because I spent a lot of time On finding the proper words and audio fixing
I got mine a little over a week ago and it's the best diver I've ever had, fits my small wrist perfectly, way better than a Sub for example. Great review, like you said, it definitely isn't the most exciting watch, but it can be the perfect diver if you like the size, lightweight nature of titanium and if you're not the "blingy" type of guy.
Amazing piece! I think Tudor has corrected all the faults with the previous Pelagos with this one. Impatient to see what dials they will manage to bring out in the future
I prefer the 58, because of the accents and refinements you’ve mentioned (though I went with blue), but it’s a great tool watch. No-nonsense, that’s how I would describe it.
What a great video Tom! Really enjoyed your take on this one. As a 58 and ND Sub owner personally I couldn’t find a place for the 39 in my collection, but that’s not to say I don’t like it. I was hugely impressed when I tried this on at the AD and have no doubt it’ll do wonders for Tudor amongst the general public, it’s a good looking watch. And you’re right, for sure we’re over-analysing things 😂 Wear it well and get that scratch count up! Cheers! 🖤
I’ve been waiting for this video! I totally agree with you. You can’t go wrong with any of these options. My favorite is still the BB58 for the more premium feel while still having character without worrying I’m going to get mugged lol. The SPB is such a knockout especially for the price. I’m still considering picking one up! The P39 is a great watch but I do feel like it is trying to be too many things at once. A tool watch with simple brushed finishing but also a Sub alternative with the all black look. I love it and again I love not feeling like I’m going to get mugged. But I would feel like I’m wearing a Sub homage which would bother me. The Sub is an icon and the no date is stunning. But at this point in my life, even if someone gave it to me for free I wouldn’t feel comfortable wearing it. It’s way too expensive, well known, and thief magnetic for me to actually wear out anywhere, especially because I wear divers as tool/everyday watches.
Awesome review. You make some really great points. I tend to only keep pieces that make my heart quicken a little, but maybe this can be the perfect piece to attribute your own story and character to as you suggest…after all it is very wearable and capable.
Love your take one it. For me there isn’t anything special that would make me want to join the hype train. Like most “divers” it is like the others where it is a great everyday watch. Don’t get me wrong your video makes it look cool. Tudor keep launching watch fan watches. The watches that draw people in. Great videography Tom. Your videos make the launch shots look amateur.
This iteration of the Pelagos is a slam dunk for Tudor. If they ever come out with a blue variation, I may have to consider it. Even though I think it may wear a little small for my personal taste. Truth be told, I'm very tempted to pick this up for my collection. But I must exercise patience....
I was on the list for this at two ADs until last weekend. Another watch that I had wanted for a long time surprisingly became available so I took my name off both lists, but still...this watch is the first Tudor that really made me go hunting for it. It fixed the things that made me not go get the BB58.
Thank you for mentioning the lume on the hands. I thought I was going crazy since no other reviewer mentioned it looking weaker than the markers. I felt like it looked half as bright and thought mine was defective. That being said, it does last all night. And I do love the watch. I have had many watches and find this watch to be an acquired taste. The clasp isn't as robust even with the micro adjustments. I wish they got rid of the wet suit and added more micro adjustment slots.
I think it can just be explained because the material is different. In daylight(non lume) you can see they both have a different hue of white too. Hands have a more yellow Tone. I also wonder how sturdy that spring for the T fit adjustment will be over the years …
Me too! The lume on the hands is not as bright as the indices, I thought it was defective. Absolutely love the pelly39! And agree with Tom's review. Just enjoy it
Tom, your shots of the spb143 are making me salivate. Please do a standalone video this mate. It looks sooo good. I actually think it could be the best value packed watch along with a better execution than the Pelagos 39.
Your video editing is killer man! Keep up the good work and I'm sure your channel will grow! So glad I found you. I love the content. Can't believe you don't have more subscribers. I'll help change that! Cheers!
thank you mate. appreciate it .. it's a slow process for sure here .. and I'll admit sometimes it gets under the skin but on the other hand.. the ones that do follow are the real enthusiasts and not the trolls ;)
Thanks for the sub! That is an uncle straps (uncle seiko) jubilee.. honestly the only steel bracelet I ever liked on the spb unclestraps.com/products/oyster-bracelet-spb14x-62mas-reissue
Nice review. If Tudor had a fully indexed bezel like the FXD and keep the notched chapter ring around the case dial like the P42, that would have been something to stand in awe of. As it is, just not enough here to make me want this watch. A nice timepiece though. Enjoy.
Awesome video Tom! It’s an interesting one. I still think the 58 is the best option from Tudor, but i do like the new 39, im also enjoying the FXD a lot!! Be interesting to see your thoughts around the fxd vs 39 😁
Added the Pelagos 39 in November and it has been my most worn watch in the collection: Rolex Submariner 124060 Tudor Pelagos FXD MN21 Sinn 103 sa BE Sinn 856 S UTC Seiko SKX Custom YM Ninja Seiko Prospex Speedtimer 🐼 Studio Underd0g Watermelon 🍉 Casio Calculator Watch Casio F91W Not sure I would agree that the P39 is ‘boring’. It’s a great under the radar daily that is light to wear with great dimensions that doesn’t attract the attention of a Submariner. This is my 3rd Pelagos after l sold my LHD in 2021 when my AD called me for the Submariner allocation - never had an issue with scratches and it’s the same with my FXD and P39. Just don’t overthink things and just enjoy wearing your watches 😎👍
You summed it up well Tom. I also got it the week it was released and after just over a month I have just sold it. There was something confusing about how quickly the excitement faded on this one. It really just didn't feel special on the wrist after a few weeks and I decided that my money is better put towards something that elicits that excitement.
@@BowlOfSalmon also a consideration for me as I have a BB58 too but there is too big of a price differential on the secondary market between the two at the moment so financially the P39 lost out!
I’ve been contemplating the idea of selling off most if not all of my collection to help fund this watch. I also own the spb143 and kept saying that it is similar enough to hold me off of wanting the Pelagos but the want for it keeps coming back. My grail would be something a long the lines of a Tudor sub so the Pelagos 39 is pretty much the closest thing to that. I’ve recently sold my BB58 something about the snowflake hands and round markers left me wanting more. I wonder if this watch can be a one watch collection for me. Thank you for your review but from the sound of it makes me hesitant to buy.
Saying this As a big spb fan (and owner) I don’t connect with the p39 in the same way. Apart from the stuff that annoys mr. I guess it feels to modern for my taste to have the same connections. That saying I wish the spb was more refined and had that amazing movement that Tudor does have …
I really like it. The titanium looks great, and it's a serious dive watch. Not showy or pretentious. Great that they throw in a rubber strap too. They should improve the lume, though.
I feel like the Palagos is luxury enough, for me to enjoy actually wear it, not like a Sub, where i would be afraid of wearing it, or losing my “investment” if i got it damages. Also i don’t find it boring, i find it modern, even more then the sub or the 58, the Seiko is great, but i have several of them, i need something more special
Nice video and I agree with you and the person who made that insta comment. Really close to perfection but I don't connect with it as is. If it was all steel, I think I might be persuaded to grab one.
Great summary bro. I am struggling with this as an option. I have tried it on and felt the light weight did feel 'cheap' - but it ticks so many boxes. Was considering selling my ETA 41 BB for it. But I'm realising I love the heft of that watch. Both seems a bit crazy. But I LOVE the square lime plots + Snowflake. The round plots on the BB are a buzz killer. Unsure what I will do when I get a call from the AD.
if you really want a low-resolution sub get the Pelagos 42 with a date, it's the 1:1 placeholder and also a beautiful excellent watch. the 39 its nice but there's just something incomplete about the missing date that doesn't sit well
I think this would work better in blue (which I’m hoping might be forthcoming)… As an owner of several Black Bays and a Submariner, I find the square indices work best with the snowflake hour hand…
i love the pelagos 39, however my issue with it, is its simply just a watch. I feel like if it was a GMT, or it had a date like the rolex sub, Then i would buy it instantly. I know that sounds silly, as i absolutely love it, but yeah i just think a watch thats so plain like this one is (a nice plain) it should have just one extra feature to make it stand out a little.
@@BowlOfSalmon i suppose we do! I think my problem is that i really like the Pelagos, and i really want one. But i want the pelagos to scratch that itch, if that makes sense haha!
Thanks for this most excellent review. I got the 42mm Pelagos as I wanted a watch that also showed the date. Could not be happier. However, apparently I need a half link to size it properly. Take one out, it is too loose. Put it back in, it is on the tight size. The adjustable bracelet does not move it out enough to help. Any suggestion to how to size the bracelet? (I do not want to go with the rubber strap.)
I thought that was a great comprehensive video and after trying the new Pelagos on a few weeks ago I agree with all the comments you made which is why I will not be buying the new Pelagos. It left me cold and I much preferred the BB58 out of the two. To me the 58 had more quality and style.
just something cheap I picked up on amazon .. problem with tools like that is the user has to apply pressure on both sides .. getting it out is easy enough but getting it back in I don't have the motor skill do do it so i just push em in with the spring bar tool (and some tape on the lugs .. sometimes ...)
my love for the bb58 is a bit of a decline lately ... it is the better finished, better looking , more versatile watch tho ... Idk ... thought about moving it on but I can't get myself to do it either .. like i will regret it
Definitely enjoying it ! Maybe it’s not the most thrilling watch. But it’s really really good. Check this revieW from @wristswap. I agree 100% czcams.com/video/QtLsKCAS9Sk/video.html
@@BowlOfSalmon I’ve definitely noticed a surplus of posts on your IG of the P39; it’s such a damn photogenic piece and looks amazing in every shot. But it makes me think, could you be entering your honeymoon phase with the watch now? Myself, having a laughably hard time deciding whether this should be my first big boy watch purchase or the SBGA415. Yes, they are very different watches, but I do love my daily seiko divers and the thought of replacing them with a P39 makes me kind of… sad. Hence the leaning towards a GS that won’t necessarily be the everyday piece, but one that will put a smile on my face whenever I look at it. Decisions decisions!
I just stopped overthinking it .. and I really enjoy it .. but also .. its not fair towards my spb for sure ... and I should just let some watches go so I don't have an overlap because I really wanted to diversify a bit too :)
I never paid attention to that sound until now tho 😂 sounds a bit like the guy in the toilet next to you at the airport is having some intestinal issues right ? Too smooth 😂
I absolutely loved this watch. Now, I have it and… it’s too small. It almost looks like a toy watch. This is the weirdest thing, I know it’s 40mm on top but it looks and feels too small for my 18.5cm wrist. 😢
They just should have made a 39/40 mm version of the Pelagos without the escape valve. That would have been perfect. The original Pelagos is a tool watch. And this version wants to be a tool watch but also a more accessible watch which will appeal to the masses. Some will like that but I don't. I would rather buy the Pelagos FXD.
@@BowlOfSalmon I love the old Pelagos more than the FXD. Not a big fan of all the numbers on the bezel and I prefer the old blue better. So I still hope they will do a thinner version of the old Pelagos. And a few years ago I bought the NTH Nacken Modern Black. That was the perfect Pelagos for me. 40 MM, 11mm thick. Blue lume etc. So at the moment I'm happy with that one and pursuing other watch goals. Like the Omega Speedmaster! But someday the perfect Pelagos will come along and I will buy it.
To be honest even the Submariner is boring. Yes I recognize it's status and everything but it's a design that's inoffensive in its blandness rather than exciting. Derivative designs suffer from the same. However if the companies keep selling them there's no incentive to change anything and I'm probably in the minority.
That is true too. But nothing wrong with any of these in the collection. And when going down the rabbit hole… we can add something a bit more different too
Why would anyone want their dive watch to be 'luxurious'? It's a DIVE WATCH ... it's a tool ... and (hot take) you're a tool if you wear one but aren't a diver.
Looks or price ? And and what point is the price the factor for luxurious ? I love my seiko as much. Maybe even more at this point in time. But the p39 is moving up the ranks fast.
@@BowlOfSalmon Legit questions ... Your pointing at the meta point that it's kinda arbitrary; I get it ... I land roughly at the point where you sacrifice function for appearance / signalling ... And, I hadn't had coffee when I made original apparently-way-salty comment: I just want the p39 on my wrist noooow!
This is spot on, and I greatly appreciated the direct hands on comparison with the other 3 models. Rattly bracelet aside, it says a lot about the SPB143 that it even can make an appearance in this video with watches that cost 4-10x the price.
yep.. that Seiko is a beast ! and comparisons were the most requested feature when I asked around .. so there..I aim to please :)
@@BowlOfSalmon Yep... Tbh , the spb143 just makes the pelagos irrelevant to me in my collection...Sure , it's obviously a much better watch...I just don't think i could justify the amount in price difference.. The seiko scratches that itch just fine.
@@flow2tech Its better looking as well. For me at least.
The SPB143 is going to blow up in a few years it's definitely a sleeper
@@876yuugt really eh...I've never heard that about the Tudor..What's wrong with qc? For me I find my modest spb143 with the uncle Seiko jubilee scratches my Tudor itch...Yes that sla is a beauty
I bought the 42mm and I absolutely love it. I love that it just blends in not worrying about getting it stolen extremely well made. Congratulations on your purchase and many journeys to take the watch on
Thanks man. I’m starting to wonder why I never considered the pelagos
Fantastic review Tom - pretty much sums up my own feelings about the watch. Keep it up.
Thanks for watching man.. glad I'm not talking bs only :)
Your conclusion actually supports its uniqueness while providing “character”
1) titanium (lightweight)
2) color of titanium (gunmetal)
3) bezel lume
4) bezel sunray
5) red ‘Pelagos text’
6) square lume plots with blue lume
7) dial is a different shade of black vs gray, matte, inky
8) tudor shield logo on crown
9) 1st generation of the 39 Pelagos !!!!
10) endlink with OEM rubber strap and attachment
Most importantly like u said it’s yours!!! U build memories around it….you add character to it not the other way around
You make me want one ! Oh right. It’s on the wrist. I need to do a follow up on this video. Claps bugs me. Sharp edges bug me. The lack of lume on the hands too. Otherwise. Great. Still boring. But great 😅
Loved the bezel sound comparison! Helpful review and agree, it does seem to lack something, despite being just about “perfect”. I wonder if the rehaut with cutouts was a large factor in the charm/character of its big brother 🤔
Well I actually never liked the rehault and cutouts too much…. 🫣
Love the ASMR dial turning portion! 😂
Right?! haha
You hear it said in Special Forces communities such as the SAS that they look to recruit “the grey man” - a person who doesn’t stand out and can blend in. Sounds like this is the grey man of divers. And that sounds pretty perfect. Great video sir. Thank you!
well said ! Thanks 🙏
Hey Tom, I enjoyed the footage and genuine take on the Pelagos form an owners perspective. Excellent 👍
Thanks Peter. I really appreciate you visiting my little channel 🙏🙏🙏
@@BowlOfSalmon love your work mate 👍
@@BowlOfSalmon PS I only just found your instagram handle, subbed as well 👍
Perhaps the best review of this watch. You state my exact thoughts almost at 100% accuracy concerning the P39. I think I’ll be keeping mine.
Too kind 🙏
That intro was FIRE
Thanks. I try to make that at thing on my videos. So have a look around 🙏
Best video yet Tom! I love the Pelly39. It checks a lot of boxes. But, you said it right when compared to the Sub, it's probably going to be a filler until that call comes, IF that call comes.
Oh thanks man. This one was a struggle and I felt I lost eye of my video a bit because I spent a lot of time
On finding the proper words and audio fixing
Best demo of bezel sound on the internet.
Thx. I should probably stop being lazy and record more audio when handling watches
I got mine a little over a week ago and it's the best diver I've ever had, fits my small wrist perfectly, way better than a Sub for example.
Great review, like you said, it definitely isn't the most exciting watch, but it can be the perfect diver if you like the size, lightweight nature of titanium and if you're not the "blingy" type of guy.
Totally. That said. I feel I was rather negative about the p39. Yet. It doesn’t leave my wrist much these days
Your shots have made me even more wanty for the 39, each to their own on the styling points.
Absolutely man ! You will enjoy it. Thanks for watching and hope it comes soon
Great review! Appreciate all the wrist shots with the rubber!
Thanks man ! Tried to put in as much as possible
I like my watches to be simple, minimalistic and not stand out, so I can wear it every day and forget its there..this is perfect..
Yip. It’s super good at all that
Realistic verdict 👍🏻 The footage is outstanding, as always!
Thanks man. Yeah. But I do
Think I sound more negative while I’m not really … 😂
Probably the best pelagos 39 review
Amazing piece! I think Tudor has corrected all the faults with the previous Pelagos with this one. Impatient to see what dials they will manage to bring out in the future
Same here. Wallet is not
I prefer the 58, because of the accents and refinements you’ve mentioned (though I went with blue), but it’s a great tool watch. No-nonsense, that’s how I would describe it.
The blue brings that no nonsense look better. I kinda want to get my hands on one
What a great video Tom! Really enjoyed your take on this one. As a 58 and ND Sub owner personally I couldn’t find a place for the 39 in my collection, but that’s not to say I don’t like it. I was hugely impressed when I tried this on at the AD and have no doubt it’ll do wonders for Tudor amongst the general public, it’s a good looking watch. And you’re right, for sure we’re over-analysing things 😂 Wear it well and get that scratch count up! Cheers! 🖤
thx Ryan ! yeah.. there is def overlap if you would own all four here. and yes, time to just enjoy this one
Same here plus I have a few more rollies
Great video Tom. Really well done! I’ll let you know my thoughts tomorrow 😉
🫣😂🥳
I think this watch could develop character with the right color options/combinations, Blue, Green, White, Red.
if they brought out some exciting/bold colors i think that would be incredible
Oh yeah. Definitely. And curious what they will do next
And they may add to that in the future
I’ve been waiting for this video! I totally agree with you. You can’t go wrong with any of these options. My favorite is still the BB58 for the more premium feel while still having character without worrying I’m going to get mugged lol. The SPB is such a knockout especially for the price. I’m still considering picking one up! The P39 is a great watch but I do feel like it is trying to be too many things at once. A tool watch with simple brushed finishing but also a Sub alternative with the all black look. I love it and again I love not feeling like I’m going to get mugged. But I would feel like I’m wearing a Sub homage which would bother me. The Sub is an icon and the no date is stunning. But at this point in my life, even if someone gave it to me for free I wouldn’t feel comfortable wearing it. It’s way too expensive, well known, and thief magnetic for me to actually wear out anywhere, especially because I wear divers as tool/everyday watches.
find my match in overthinking a decision ! :). feel you for the sub feelings . i have the same ...
Awesome review. You make some really great points. I tend to only keep pieces that make my heart quicken a little, but maybe this can be the perfect piece to attribute your own story and character to as you suggest…after all it is very wearable and capable.
The watch fits me. But yeah. Who knows in a year how I feel. I never sold one of my serious pieces thus far tho …
Great video, Bowl. Please keep us updated on your thoughts as you get to know the watch better.
Will do … At this rate I need a sotc video every 2 months …
Love your take one it. For me there isn’t anything special that would make me want to join the hype train. Like most “divers” it is like the others where it is a great everyday watch. Don’t get me wrong your video makes it look cool. Tudor keep launching watch fan watches. The watches that draw people in. Great videography Tom. Your videos make the launch shots look amateur.
I agree and I think you can even hear me thing the same thing In this video. 😂
This iteration of the Pelagos is a slam dunk for Tudor. If they ever come out with a blue variation, I may have to consider it. Even though I think it may wear a little small for my personal taste. Truth be told, I'm very tempted to pick this up for my collection. But I must exercise patience....
Blue will rock for sure
I was on the list for this at two ADs until last weekend. Another watch that I had wanted for a long time surprisingly became available so I took my name off both lists, but still...this watch is the first Tudor that really made me go hunting for it. It fixed the things that made me not go get the BB58.
I guess you would also preferred a steel bb58 without the goldie accents ?
@@BowlOfSalmon just a better bracelet and clasp. I'm not a savage🤣
Great story. Awesome review. I really enjoyed it.
Thanks a lot man
Thank you for mentioning the lume on the hands. I thought I was going crazy since no other reviewer mentioned it looking weaker than the markers. I felt like it looked half as bright and thought mine was defective. That being said, it does last all night. And I do love the watch. I have had many watches and find this watch to be an acquired taste. The clasp isn't as robust even with the micro adjustments. I wish they got rid of the wet suit and added more micro adjustment slots.
I think it can just be explained because the material is different. In daylight(non lume) you can see they both have a different hue of white too. Hands have a more yellow Tone. I also wonder how sturdy that spring for the T fit adjustment will be over the years …
Me too! The lume on the hands is not as bright as the indices, I thought it was defective. Absolutely love the pelly39! And agree with Tom's review. Just enjoy it
Awesome review and amazing footage!
Thx bro
Tom, your shots of the spb143 are making me salivate. Please do a standalone video this mate. It looks sooo good. I actually think it could be the best value packed watch along with a better execution than the Pelagos 39.
I might have to do that :) it's getting more screen time in the next video !
Your video editing is killer man! Keep up the good work and I'm sure your channel will grow! So glad I found you. I love the content. Can't believe you don't have more subscribers. I'll help change that! Cheers!
thank you mate. appreciate it .. it's a slow process for sure here .. and I'll admit sometimes it gets under the skin but on the other hand.. the ones that do follow are the real enthusiasts and not the trolls ;)
Brilliant vid! You just got a new Subscriber 😊 what’s the bracelet on your SPB143?
Thanks for the sub! That is an uncle straps (uncle seiko) jubilee.. honestly the only steel bracelet I ever liked on the spb unclestraps.com/products/oyster-bracelet-spb14x-62mas-reissue
Thanks!
Nice review. If Tudor had a fully indexed bezel like the FXD and keep the notched chapter ring around the case dial like the P42, that would have been something to stand in awe of. As it is, just not enough here to make me want this watch. A nice timepiece though. Enjoy.
Just a blue p39 would change it tho. I love the fxd. Just fixed lugs and nato only wouldn’t be my thing tho
What a great and balanced review. Good job.
Much appreciated! thx
Awesome video Tom! It’s an interesting one. I still think the 58 is the best option from Tudor, but i do like the new 39, im also enjoying the FXD a lot!! Be interesting to see your thoughts around the fxd vs 39 😁
I’d love the fxd for sure. But I also would want to be able to put other straps and bracelets on it …. Blue 39. It’s just a matter of time no ?
Great video!
Where did you get your strap shown at 7:46? It makes the Pelagos look awesome.
thats a CNS cnswatchbands.com/products/premium-strap-gray-1 but one at 20mm tho ... so there is some gap
Great video brother, and congrats again!
Thanks for the visit man !
Great video as always! Keep up the good work
Thanks a ton man.I appreciate the comment
Added the Pelagos 39 in November and it has been my most worn watch in the collection:
Rolex Submariner 124060
Tudor Pelagos FXD MN21
Sinn 103 sa BE
Sinn 856 S UTC
Seiko SKX Custom YM Ninja
Seiko Prospex Speedtimer 🐼
Studio Underd0g Watermelon 🍉
Casio Calculator Watch
Casio F91W
Not sure I would agree that the P39 is ‘boring’. It’s a great under the radar daily that is light to wear with great dimensions that doesn’t attract the attention of a Submariner. This is my 3rd Pelagos after l sold my LHD in 2021 when my AD called me for the Submariner allocation - never had an issue with scratches and it’s the same with my FXD and P39.
Just don’t overthink things and just enjoy wearing your watches 😎👍
I'm still not bonding with it much ...
Dream collection 🔥
I know. Not my sub tho 🫣
Blue with a date, best one.
Should be 👌
You summed it up well Tom. I also got it the week it was released and after just over a month I have just sold it. There was something confusing about how quickly the excitement faded on this one. It really just didn't feel special on the wrist after a few weeks and I decided that my money is better put towards something that elicits that excitement.
still struggling with that thought too... but for me its the bb58 on the bench atm ...
@@BowlOfSalmon also a consideration for me as I have a BB58 too but there is too big of a price differential on the secondary market between the two at the moment so financially the P39 lost out!
Awesome video! What watch box is that?
Mine 😀. Blackchest uk
I’ve been contemplating the idea of selling off most if not all of my collection to help fund this watch. I also own the spb143 and kept saying that it is similar enough to hold me off of wanting the Pelagos but the want for it keeps coming back. My grail would be something a long the lines of a Tudor sub so the Pelagos 39 is pretty much the closest thing to that. I’ve recently sold my BB58 something about the snowflake hands and round markers left me wanting more. I wonder if this watch can be a one watch collection for me. Thank you for your review but from the sound of it makes me hesitant to buy.
Saying this As a big spb fan (and owner) I don’t connect with the p39 in the same way. Apart from the stuff that annoys mr. I guess it feels to modern for my taste to have the same connections. That saying I wish the spb was more refined and had that amazing movement that Tudor does have …
Fantastic assessment of the 39, but my attention was on that Nanuk 904 utilized as watch stowage.
check out www.blackchest.co.uk for custom versions !
I really like it. The titanium looks great, and it's a serious dive watch. Not showy or pretentious. Great that they throw in a rubber strap too. They should improve the lume, though.
agreed. i should do a follow up on this.. i'm aftraid the small quirks annoy me more than I wanted to admit at first
I've been wearing a $7 Paw Patrol children's toy watch for a week now. It's been a hilarious time.
So … what is your kid wearing ? 😅
Amazing video man! 🔥🔥🔥
thanks a lot man. not a bad case either
I feel like the Palagos is luxury enough, for me to enjoy actually wear it, not like a Sub, where i would be afraid of wearing it, or losing my “investment” if i got it damages. Also i don’t find it boring, i find it modern, even more then the sub or the 58, the Seiko is great, but i have several of them, i need something more special
Kinda agree with most of it. I love the no nonsense look of the pelagos. Some things started to bother me. I’ll do a follow up vid soon
Great photography and edits on this video. That poor seiko bezel.
Thanks for watching! yeah .. it sounded a bit pathetic there didn't it ? haha :) (I kinda always giggled over the alignment of the lume pip)
Nice video and I agree with you and the person who made that insta comment. Really close to perfection but I don't connect with it as is. If it was all steel, I think I might be persuaded to grab one.
Great summary bro. I am struggling with this as an option. I have tried it on and felt the light weight did feel 'cheap' - but it ticks so many boxes. Was considering selling my ETA 41 BB for it. But I'm realising I love the heft of that watch. Both seems a bit crazy. But I LOVE the square lime plots + Snowflake. The round plots on the BB are a buzz killer. Unsure what I will do when I get a call from the AD.
thanks for watching ! give it a chance tho ..
@@BowlOfSalmon ok gonna buy it lol
if you really want a low-resolution sub get the Pelagos 42 with a date, it's the 1:1 placeholder and also a beautiful excellent watch. the 39 its nice but there's just something incomplete about the missing date that doesn't sit well
I kinda like a simple 3 hander visually. Until I need to check the date 😂
I think this would work better in blue (which I’m hoping might be forthcoming)… As an owner of several Black Bays and a Submariner, I find the square indices work best with the snowflake hour hand…
i will be stunning in blue
i love the pelagos 39, however my issue with it, is its simply just a watch.
I feel like if it was a GMT, or it had a date like the rolex sub, Then i would buy it instantly. I know that sounds silly, as i absolutely love it, but yeah i just think a watch thats so plain like this one is (a nice plain) it should have just one extra feature to make it stand out a little.
Don’t we get other watches to scratch that itch ? 😂
@@BowlOfSalmon i suppose we do! I think my problem is that i really like the Pelagos, and i really want one.
But i want the pelagos to scratch that itch, if that makes sense haha!
Buy the pelagos 42, that one has a este window
Nice video! Where did you get that grey nato strap?
That was the cns premium one making a camera (google cheapest nato straps )
Thanks for this most excellent review. I got the 42mm Pelagos as I wanted a watch that also showed the date. Could not be happier. However, apparently I need a half link to size it properly. Take one out, it is too loose. Put it back in, it is on the tight size. The adjustable bracelet does not move it out enough to help. Any suggestion to how to size the bracelet? (I do not want to go with the rubber strap.)
Doing a video soon as a follow up. Uncle seiko has a ti bracelet I really like ! I’ll check for half links
@@BowlOfSalmon Thank you, Tom.
Brilliant video!
Thank you! (really? i've been beating myself up on this one ...)
@@BowlOfSalmon It is informative, makes some really interesting points, is thorough and well-produced!
I thought that was a great comprehensive video and after trying the new Pelagos on a few weeks ago I agree with all the comments you made which is why I will not be buying the new Pelagos. It left me cold and I much preferred the BB58 out of the two. To me the 58 had more quality and style.
There is no bad choice here. Just preference. But I agree 200% with your bb58. But they are different style of divers too. Thanks for watching ! 🙏
Great video. Can I ask for details about the spring bar tools at the beginning? Looking for a new one which compresses both sides at the same time
just something cheap I picked up on amazon .. problem with tools like that is the user has to apply pressure on both sides .. getting it out is easy enough but getting it back in I don't have the motor skill do do it so i just push em in with the spring bar tool (and some tape on the lugs .. sometimes ...)
@@BowlOfSalmon Thanks for the reply and I typically end up with a straight spring bar tool as well.... Keep up the great work!
Great Video. Feel nearly the same about. I think I still want a Sub. But I although think to sell my BB58. Would you take the P 39 over the BB58?
my love for the bb58 is a bit of a decline lately ... it is the better finished, better looking , more versatile watch tho ... Idk ... thought about moving it on but I can't get myself to do it either .. like i will regret it
@@BowlOfSalmon you will regret it. Not many simple black dial divers have as much character as the BB58. I’d hold onto it!
@@brett233 that are my thoughts too. But I have Seamaster 300 triology too. So they are very similar. Best Alex
I think if someone (me) was only going to buy one dive watch for their collection, the P39 is the perfect choice.
I agree (if they stop looking at watches after that) ... sounds like marriage
Love the watch but have always preferred stainless steel as I'm not a big fan of the duller/darker look.
Does Titanium get darker with time/patina?
It’s my first titanium. I have no idea tbh. But I shared the same concern. It’s different but I still like it a lot
Now that you’ve had the watch for a longer period of time, has your opinion changed? Do you find yourself loving it more?
Definitely enjoying it ! Maybe it’s not the most thrilling watch. But it’s really really good. Check this revieW from @wristswap. I agree 100%
czcams.com/video/QtLsKCAS9Sk/video.html
@@BowlOfSalmon I’ve definitely noticed a surplus of posts on your IG of the P39; it’s such a damn photogenic piece and looks amazing in every shot. But it makes me think, could you be entering your honeymoon phase with the watch now?
Myself, having a laughably hard time deciding whether this should be my first big boy watch purchase or the SBGA415. Yes, they are very different watches, but I do love my daily seiko divers and the thought of replacing them with a P39 makes me kind of… sad. Hence the leaning towards a GS that won’t necessarily be the everyday piece, but one that will put a smile on my face whenever I look at it. Decisions decisions!
I just stopped overthinking it .. and I really enjoy it .. but also .. its not fair towards my spb for sure ... and I should just let some watches go so I don't have an overlap because I really wanted to diversify a bit too :)
Great review.
Glad you enjoyed it man ! thanks
Your SPB143 bezel sounds very different from mine. My SPB143 sounds much more like your Sub bezel. Maybe I just got lucky?
I never paid attention to that sound until now tho 😂 sounds a bit like the guy in the toilet next to you at the airport is having some intestinal issues right ? Too smooth 😂
I have a Tudor Pelagos!!!! Never mind, I just found out it's actually a $150 Tactical Frog.
Frogs are underrated
P39 & BB54 are the perfect combination! You dont need a Sub anymore! 🙂
Agreed. I’d be torn for the new 41mm tho
@@BowlOfSalmon Nice model, but too big & too fat for me.
Nice review 👍
Thanks! 👍 returning viewer ? this one seems to have some more attention than usual
@@BowlOfSalmon Just came across your channel, now subscribed 👍
Great review, love it! Cheers fullsetphil
thanks for dropping in man !
Nice video !
Thanks!
I absolutely loved this watch. Now, I have it and… it’s too small. It almost looks like a toy watch. This is the weirdest thing, I know it’s 40mm on top but it looks and feels too small for my 18.5cm wrist. 😢
Yeah. I can imagine. Fxd for you maybe ?I’m 16,5. 39-41 is safest for me. But I don’t mind the 42 speedy or explorer 2. either
My wrist is 6”, do you think the clasp will be too ‘long’ after removing a few links to size to my wrist?
I had 3 links removed but I’m 16-16,5cm. Try @thespeedyshutter on IG for a compare
Seem a tad too small at 39.. I prefer the FXD over this..
I love the fxd but fixed lugs stopped me there
Yup can only go on a nato no bracelet.
They just should have made a 39/40 mm version of the Pelagos without the escape valve. That would have been perfect. The original Pelagos is a tool watch. And this version wants to be a tool watch but also a more accessible watch which will appeal to the masses. Some will like that but I don't. I would rather buy the Pelagos FXD.
Do it. Great watch that fxd.
@@BowlOfSalmon I love the old Pelagos more than the FXD. Not a big fan of all the numbers on the bezel and I prefer the old blue better. So I still hope they will do a thinner version of the old Pelagos. And a few years ago I bought the NTH Nacken Modern Black. That was the perfect Pelagos for me. 40 MM, 11mm thick. Blue lume etc. So at the moment I'm happy with that one and pursuing other watch goals. Like the Omega Speedmaster! But someday the perfect Pelagos will come along and I will buy it.
...why dont you have waaay more subscribers at this point? mind boggling
i don't post weekly ... and YT is more difficult to have that " community " like on IG.. but thanks .. it would help getting on some forums ;)
@@BowlOfSalmon you deserve way more subs. Production value and storytelling are really good ... keep it up
LOL. If ever needed, you can send morse code with that clasp!
I should have put in a das boot sequence 😂
What’s your wrist size?
16 - 16,5 cm. 3 links out
@@BowlOfSalmon thanks, I’m 15.5, so might be pushing it
How large is your wrist?
16 - 16,5cm
@@BowlOfSalmon alright thanks
The bezel is 40mm, why does everybody go with that it's 39mm? Because it's in the name and because of the case diameter? "The Emperor's New Clothes"
True. But it’s advertised as a 39 🤷♂️
To be honest even the Submariner is boring. Yes I recognize it's status and everything but it's a design that's inoffensive in its blandness rather than exciting. Derivative designs suffer from the same. However if the companies keep selling them there's no incentive to change anything and I'm probably in the minority.
That is true too. But nothing wrong with any of these in the collection. And when going down the rabbit hole… we can add something a bit more different too
no one fuckin need a 500 meters, this watch is perfect
I got a deep bathtub tho
Great dimensions. Boring watch. This is the embodiment of "the safe option". If that's your thing, you'll absolutely love this.
hey.. i wasn't even arguing about this in the video ;)
Boring as in perfect beater/toolwatch right. Doesn't have to be eyecandy with every watch imo
U need a BB 58 blue….I have a new one if you like…
Thought crossed my mind before
@@BowlOfSalmon today is the day!
I added a flik flak
Hey. You probably beat the trend. Just look at swatch …
How big is your wrist? I’m worried that it may not be big enough for my wrist at 39mm
I'm at 16 - 16.5cm ... have a look at my SOTC video for some more wrist reference shots for bigger watches too (explorer 2, speedmaster)
Complains about the watch being boring while having the most boring monotone voice while reviewing it…
I’ll be a sport and take it as constructive feedback. Bye now
This is the kinda watch you buy to enjoy it yourself albeit mundane and nothing special.
Good summery. I got (yes .. sounds posh ) others that are special for me
I've had my watch for 2 months now and it's way more scratched up than yours......but great watch anyway.
I rotate a lot 😂
You're paying for that "complementary" rubber strap..... Its all in the price.
Ofcourse. Hurts less like this tho
That clicking sound on the clasp……yikes
Guess this is not the kind of asmr that turns you on ? 😂. A lot of titanium watches accentuate this more so it seems ….
Why would anyone want their dive watch to be 'luxurious'? It's a DIVE WATCH ... it's a tool ... and (hot take) you're a tool if you wear one but aren't a diver.
Looks or price ? And and what point is the price the factor for luxurious ? I love my seiko as much. Maybe even more at this point in time. But the p39 is moving up the ranks fast.
@@BowlOfSalmon Legit questions ... Your pointing at the meta point that it's kinda arbitrary; I get it ... I land roughly at the point where you sacrifice function for appearance / signalling ... And, I hadn't had coffee when I made original apparently-way-salty comment: I just want the p39 on my wrist noooow!
Its too light feels cheap
🙄 It’s you who associates light with cheap
@@BowlOfSalmon true my friend, I can't get my brain to not work that way,but you're right it's my issue not anyone else's sorry
Super boring piece, but not as boring as the new Tudor Ranger
almost a constructive comment . i knew you had it in you
lol@@BowlOfSalmon
Perfectly boring. Too expensive for boring.
Good news is that are watches for everyone out there. What’s your preference ?
TOO SMALL
Im not a marriage counselor