The Truth Is Worth It: Perseverance | Extended
Vložit
- čas přidán 29. 10. 2018
- Follow a New York Times reporter’s journey as she uncovers the stories of separated migrant families.
Learn more at nytimes.com/truth
Read the full investigation: nyti.ms/2qOS9sI
Subscribe to The Times: nyti.ms/2z9IX6f
I watch these commercials repeatedly. These commercials inspire me and excite me and remind me why I want and need to be a journalist. It’s been my dream since I was a little girl to work for the New York Times and I hope that one day it comes true.
Lol the nyt is liberal
Ewwww. So you want to lie and spin the truth? Got it.
@@grimey5.565This is just proof that the New York Times has journalists who are honorable.
The essence of investigative journalism.
Congratulations on the Grand Prix award from Cannes 2019!
This advertisement almost feels like a dramatic film, albeit a short one. Powerful!
This was chilling. Really appreciate all that you do @NYT
Caleb Burns Now build the wall so these Children aren’t forced across the border
Wow can't look away
Thank you journalists.
What an incredibly creative video. I love how the process from 'rumor' to 'confirmed' is shown in such a simple way. It's like looking at algebraic proofs, but news instead of letters and numbers. Even if people argue with the facts, this video shows the process of NYTimes to discover information, and in my eyes this increases their credibility. Well done, guys, your originality is excellent!
Amazing ad. Thank you for doing what you do.
Jeez this is ganna get interesting
this is so strong OMG~
Send them back together.
Send back the Europeans who invaded America?
@@TheEpicAB America wasn’t invaded. Most of the land was unmarked.
@@apricotmadness4850 The indigenous people were colonised, slaughtered and ethnically cleansed.
The cinematography and editing of this video is beautiful
Trolligarch Agreed...almost fit for a movie.
.. it’s sad.
Only watched this because the editing is beautiful dont really care for this kind of stuff
(Im like a kid sooooo)
(step up your game) (jk)
this is the most powerful video ive seen
They don’t talk about them anymore.
I know right, Funny how that all went away January 20th.
So many of you people don't seem to understand that there's a Universal Declaration of Human Rights where in Article 14, in which it states, that everyone has a right to seek asylum. Also, to call all of these people criminals is both ignorant and demonizing and does nothing but divide and spread hatred. While we can't understand each person's individual story because there's only so many things Journalists can do, to blame the parents and call them criminals is to ignore the stories that have been told and the other scenarios and possibilities, such as escaping a country where their lives, including those of their children, are threatened. So it would make sense for them to bring their kids. These comments utterly disturb me with the lack of empathy and understanding.
Joshua Snow THANK YOU someone who understands
Y I K E S
Joshua Snow go off sis
Joshua Snow If they were seeking asylum, they’d be going to a designated checkpoint on the border to announce their intentions, not trying to sneak across it. Furthermore, when seeking asylum, your supposed to go to a neighboring country to get out of immediate danger. However, many of these people come from central and South America, not a neighboring country like Mexico.
You act as if seeking Asylum is as easy as "going to the right place", but your analysis lacks understanding of the system and you're misunderstanding the definition of "neighboring country". This simply refers to the country they came from. It does not necessarily mean it has to be from a country connected to our own. Even a quick google search can tell you that. "A person may request asylum in any country outside their own; there is no obligation for an individual to claim asylum in the first country they reach." Keep in mind it says, "IN ANY COUNTRY outside their own." Any. Not to mention that because of Trump's legislations, he's making it harder for people to apply for Asylum and allowing a lower amount of people to do so, causing more people to use desperate measures. Does that mean that what they are doing is "legally right"? Of course not. But it means they are not led to their actions because they are bad people or criminals.
Keep in mind that once upon a time, The US turned away people seeking Asylum here from Nazi Germany, and after seeing what came of it, we broadened our perspective and understanding.
Asking for asylum isn’t illegal. Illegally entering is, but asking for asylum is not. They did not deserve to be separated. Parents who are arrested at least get visitation. They couldn’t see their children. The kids thought they were abandoned. Anyone who thinks this is humane to do should do a bit more thinking.
Just a perfectly done ad campaign. This is what investigative journalism looks and sounds like.
How come we don’t just deport the child and their guardian since they do not want their child being separated from them.
All in the name of "deterrence" yo~ Zero tolerance and all that jazz...
Mario why dont we just put a child in prison with their arrested parent because they dont want to be seperated. That’s what you’re saying.
Why do the pathetic parents allow their children to be smuggled in?....
This a settlement by the 9th circuit Court of appeals out of SF. Criminal act by parent cannot cause child to be in detention. Sent parent back immediately, ie forgo hearing or separate children.
One reason they're being separated is because the 'parents' have no way of proving they're not child traffickers
Also there were similar events during the Obama administration, just to a very minimal level
(Corrected some wording as my information was inaccurate)
Jim L.Stone in America I commanded you to have a "innocent until proven guilty" standard that applies to "all person" according to your constitution, sayeth the LORD thy God
@@hotsexyjesus4367 That is due process works. This is a safety issue. Due process doesn't matter if safety requires expediency. The children are later returned after being proven to be related.
This is like the detention people go through prior to their trial. Guilt is in no way a requirement for detainment. Now go and study law before speaking.
Also children are not generally put in courts or places the adults are in. The kids get it much better.
@@user-do5zk6jh1k yeah you go and study how long it take to do DNA test 😂
@Lukey Padookey You seem like a person that didn't pass civics or anything similar to that. The constitution applies to everyone, immigrants documented or undocumented
Thank you for fine advertising and even finer reporting, NY Times (and Droga5)
Fantastic ad
My God My God My God!!!! 😭
I don't care what your American story is please stop flooding my timeline with propaganda ads.
They are kind of being rude because it they don’t know if those people are is innocent. And they’re just taking the children away
Heather Robson-Griffin and putting them in cages. And denying them proper medical care.
Need me to continue?
This was my daughter, commenting under my account. She's young, but she knows, and was trying to say that this is wrong. She is saying these people are innocent, and this treatment is wrong. She doesn't understand internet communication yet. But her moral compass is strong.
It’s simple. Don’t try to come here illegally and you won’t be separated.
Doesn't make this ok.
Bridgette Burns yes it does. When you have kids you shouldn’t break the law with them. These parents put their kids in bad situations.
@@Localtuff I know thats not okay either.None of it is.Why can't they just be bussed back .?
Bridgette Burns because they broke the law. Whenever an American citizen breaks the law we go to jail. Why should they get special treatment? Besides, they’ll just come back anyway.
In that case, the Europeans who came to America illegally through invasion should be separated
Woo
Yaaaay you made a successful observation! They are being separated because their parents broke the law, the exact same thing that happens to US citizens! Golden star
Bro really? Broke any law and the family are separated in America? Even jay walking? That's stupid....
@@amdasaba well not any law, but any law that requires arrest, like coming through the border illegally. For all we know who ever it is could be a criminal, and the only way we can know that is if they come through legally.
@@RealOldfir Didn't they also separated legal asylum seeker at legal port of entry?
americasvoice.org/press_releases/district-judge-trump-family-separation-policy-brutal-offensive-and-fails-to-comport-with-traditional-notions-of-fair-play-and-decency/
Even American citizen also got separated as well.....
www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/jul/11/us-immigration-family-separations-doj-us-citizens
Why can't you just keep them together after DNA test? Just deport them together if they don't qualified for immigration, why pay more to employ worker to take care of children separately?
@@amdasaba
That's called anecdotal, or an outlier. Happens in EVERY metric. Crack a book once in a while.
I like how the NYT had to curate the comments because they were so overwhelmingly negative.
saw this video as an ad and just had to swing by to comment that I love and support this policy, and might like to watch the video to learn whom i need to thank for protecting our american laws..... MAGA!
Man i would really like to hear your stance on this, rarely get the chance to talk to trump supporters in this day and age where noone discusses anything and every political group keeps to themselves, could you give me an opinional statement on the american-mexican border control policies?
I feel no sympathy for these people. Stay in your own country and fight for your freedom.
Chatty216 these are poor families with children who are trying to escape gang wars.
Yeah like how you clearly for yours
Why should the kids suffer because of the bad actions of the parents? Would an American kid be put in prison or jail if their parent committed a crime?
this is just horrible seperating a kid from their parents? that is just sad
True news.
Alzheimers.
Are the major media outlets capable of telling the truth?
Are you capable of distinguising truth and lie?
@@amdasaba yeah and this video is pure propaganda, the real question is can you?
@@foodhatesme I don't think you can buddy.
@@lolnowayfbi your right have no idea what I'm talking about! News flash children get separated from their "parents" at the border because there is no way for border control to tell if they are the parents or human traffickers. Plus your all hypocrites Obama had been doing exactly that and no one batted an eye.
@@foodhatesme > because there is no way for border control to tell if they are the parents or human traffickers
Lol DNA tests are real buddy
> Plus your all hypocrites Obama had been doing exactly that and no one batted an eye.
Nah, not same. Provide evidence pls.
PRESIDENT TRUMP IS DOING A GREAT JOB !!!
let's just let the whole world in
Why doesn't the petitioner, complain to the authorities en mass in their homeland the same way they are making demands on foreign soil to those that owe them nothing.
> they are making demands on foreign soil to those that owe them nothing
What do they demand?
A lot of them would get murdered in their homeland if they made too much noise; the local governments are often very embedded in criminal enterprise...lots of areas of central America are just so incredibly dangerous.
depart from me you who are accursed, into fire fit for the devil and his angels, for i was hungry and you gave me nothing to eat, i was thirsty and you gave me nothing to drink, i was a stranger and you did not invite me in, i needed clothes and you did not cloth me, i was sick and in prison and you did not look after me, they will answer lord when did we see you hungry or thirsty or a stranger or needing cloths or sick and in prison and did not help you, he will reply i tell you the truth, what you did not do for one of the least of these you did not do for me, matthew 25 v 41
Luckily they are coming to the US....anywhere else and separation might not be the worst thing to complain about. By the way, when did we start sending children of criminals to prison with their parents?
Where else is worse?
@@amdasaba well for starters Mexico lol, half of south America, almost all of central America, the entire continent of Africa except for a few nation states, Russia, Ukraine, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Syria, Nepal, North Korea, Sudan, Cuba and probably another 60-70 nations that are less mentionable but still worse.
@@Ethernet480 lol i asked for where else they would be treated worse than the US 😁👍 sorry if i didn't make that clear
@@amdasaba
Better yet. I ask you where is it better? Think long and hard before you answer.😁😁
@@amdasaba I was clear on the question and if you look above you'll see the answer. I forgot to also mention Vietnam. Check your own backyard before piping about other things you know nothing of.
wow nice video nyt keep up the stellar work, powerful and truthful
it’s just illegal, regardless of the motive, why does no one understand that, if we ran this country on feelings alone everything would get so out of hand, yes people would like to have better opportunities, but do it the right way and don’t break that law, if you do you’re going to suffer the consequences
You don’t have the faintest inkling of an idea how difficult it is to legally migrate into this country.
@@lunelilyonrunescape It doesn’t matter how difficult it is. There is no excuse at all for coming over illegally.
People realize this has happened since Bush right?
How many got separated under Bush?
@@amdasaba
Since Clinton. And look it up for yourself.
Children carry the consequences of irresponsible parents. Why would you put at risk your own children. I'm pretty sure they are aware of the problems and still go on to risk. Parents fault not children's. Sent children back to their parents
> Why would you put at risk your own children
Cause they want a better future for their child???
They are just following the laws they been given to enforce.
Why didn't Obama need to do this to uphold the law?
Thanh Ho Viet not to be rude but President Obama wasn’t quality passive he was a little bit more on the aggressive side.
@@pop-shot-rico6 huh? what is "quality passive"? He is tough on illegals and deported many, but he's not without common sense and compassion, unlike the current POS POTUS.
The Nazi trials in the 1940s & 1950s decided that ‘just following orders’ was not a legitimate defense in any case of war crimes or crimes against humanity. This is an established interpretation of law for almost eighty years.
@@amdasaba oh I meant to say he does not have the personality of a passive but more of an aggressive.
Children have to be taken for a short time. For medical,dental clothes and food. Most are sick and just wore out physically and emotionally. I blame the parents for using their children as pawns to get in faster (by passing )our laws.
Lonnie Stevens What would you have these parents do, stay in a country is full of gang wars and watch their children die of starvation and violence in front of them? Do you actually understand why they are taking this long terrible journey to a place that doesn’t welcome them? They are not coming here for fun. They are coming in hopes of surviving.
@@ClaudiaKensit ask the 1200 families that lost loved ones to these so called migrants last year that question. Also we were talking children being separated from parents for a short time. The children dont understand neither the parents. We have to protect everyone else from any disease they may be carrying. The medical care for the kids must be done because they are the most likely to have to carry and if they do the parents will to. After the ones come that want to assimilate and obey our laws respect our customs. You can take as many home with you that you can afford. Our welfare system is over loaded now with freeloaders. I GO TO THE GROCERY STORE AND GET MY LITTLE $100 shopping. Here comes a emigrant with a buggy full of steaks and fish all sorts of things and paying with food stamps. Did I mention driving a much nicer vehicle? So where is the justice for the american taxpayers? They all hear of american generosity thats why they come. Our welfare system is nown all over the world as the best it gets. We caint support the world. But as I said I have no problem with people like you taking in as many asYOU CAN SUPPORT.
@@lonniestevens7963
> Children have to be taken for a *short* time.
*Typically, children asking for asylum are held by the Office of Refugee Resettlement for less than two months.* Then they are released to a sponsor. That can be a parent, a close adult relative, or foster parents.
*Her niece didn't have an official birth certificate, so she was detained for 16 months.*
www.npr.org/2018/06/11/618831715/more-than-10-000-migrant-children-are-in-u-s-government-custody
Yeah, "short"
@@lonniestevens7963 > 1200 families that lost loved ones to these so called migrants last year
Need source for that.
@@lonniestevens7963 > We have to protect everyone else from any disease they may be carrying.
Why do you need to separated them to do so?
> After the ones come that want to assimilate and obey our laws respect our customs.
They do.
> You can take as many home with you that you can afford.
What? Are you talking about adoption?
> Our welfare system is over loaded now with freeloaders.
Who specifically?
> Here comes a emigrant with a buggy full of steaks and fish all sorts of things...
Cool story grandma
> They all hear of american generosity thats why they come.
They came for the American Dream.
> Our welfare system is nown all over the world as the best it gets
Lol no.
> We caint support the world.
No one asks you to.
> But as I said I have no problem with people like you taking in as many asYOU CAN SUPPORT.
Easy.
One yes children have been separated from there parents this doesn't disprove anything about why we separated them two what does the government or any body have to gain from separating children from parents
> what does the government or any body have to gain from separating children from parents
Deterrence. Jeff's zero tolerance policy.
Excuse me. The title should be: separated illegal migrants.
Can we stop making this a left or right issue and address that these are PEOPLE AND CHILDREN who will have post Trumatic stress disorder from being forcibly separated. Not to mention the cases of sexual violence that have come out in detention centers. This is truly DISGUSTING and we need to have this discussion
they are subjected to worse sexual violence on the way here...please start with blaming the parents and then we can also address shortcomings elsewhere. People have such a hard time placing the onus.
Only if the situation requires it. If the child is in danger. They didn't show his answers. If Trump answered in a way that looked bad, they would had accually shared his other answers. The rest of this video made no sense. Trump did not say he was having children just grabbed because there parents made them walk a thousand miles or because they may not actually belong to the parent. The conclusion people are jumping to. All he said was, if necessary. They separate the child, when the adult is wanted for sexual assault, murder or other things. They do not put children in jail. If an American is arrested and nobody is their to take the child, CPS takes them too. CPS is the one responsible to getting the child back to the parent, when appropriate and in few cases that is never.
It’s horrible that all those parents put their kids through this knowingly while they broke our laws. Shame. Send em back to whatever country they came from so they can get their family back together and learn some respect for another country’s laws and sovereignty.
Most of the kids aren't even related to the parents
Source...?
@@lifeunbridled THE GOVERNMENT
OK, but that’s not a source. 🤷🏼♀️
Could not skip this ad when it came up. Even had to look for it. We're here because of Trump. And Putin. And the non-sense electoral slave-states college. And we can't blame Trump supporters. They are fooled into hating the world.
The NYT are heroes
Not once was a commercial done in this subject when BHO was in office and the very same thing happened under his administration... what a bunch of Hippocrates
Do the “parents” have any proof or documentation that the child in question is their offspring?
Where is the video for citizen families permanently separated from their loved ones by illegal aliens murdering them?
Karl Kessler where is the video for civilian families permanently separated from their loved ones by legal citizens murdering them?
So these 700 children deserve to be traumatized because a handful of gang members who happen to be Mexican have killed people who happen to be American?
You should change it to Lying Is Worth It $$$
what about american families seperated by CPS for profits from selling their children by social security title 4 sec D which pays states to seperate US families
It’s not our fault that the parents are bring their children and them across the border illegally!!! You democrats have to understand that our police and border agents are just doing their job. ITS NOT OUR FAULT ITS THE PARENTS FAULT!!!!
Right!
> ITS NOT OUR FAULT ITS THE PARENTS FAULT!!!!
IT'S YOUR FAULT YOU SEPARATED THE CHILDREN FROM THE PARENTS.
So its the parents fault to give the child a new life? the parents dont want thier children to suffer just like they did. So what is that statue in new york? a decoration?
My mom run away from force labor and child abuse. She came here because she thought about us. She dint whant us to suffer just like she did. If i was born in mexico, i would come to the usa. To get a better job to have a bright future. Because no one tells me what to do or not to do. Because i care/fear for my life and my future family.
The same excuse nazi used after ww2: just following orders and doing their jobs
Where was the New York Times 10 years ago?
EXACTLY
I like how they dont say illegal immigrants and how all they are about is bashing politicians on the right and Democrats get a free pass to do whatever stupid thing they want and never get called on it...
Build the wall and install gun batteries every 100 yards that shred anything coming within 1000 feet of it.
My kids would be taken from me if I cross over to mexico. So I dont do it because it is bad parenting. Do it legally like thousands do.
It’s child abuse , their parents shouldn’t try to come to this country illegally! Don’t make it America’s problem 🤨
Are you ABSOLUTELY SURE this only happen to illegals?
Your ignorant comment doesn’t deserve a reply😠
These stupid parents knew the risks. Stop breaking laws.
Doesn't make it ok.
Sad u used this topic as an ad.
Don’t jump the boarder then lmao.
Doesn't make this ok.
What would you do in their situation? You dont know really what is going on in detail on the other side to those who do. You are stuck with your family in a country that is in a state of constant gang war, a bunch of the most brutal dictators fighting eachother. Do you stay in poverty, always getting by with only scraps you gathered from the day before, without even a proper water supply, electrical grid or basic sewage system and risk the danger of you and your family being massacred, only ending a life of pain an misery? Or do you risk it and, in your perception, try to start a new life, the cost of which is only the breaking of a rule? You know you wont do anything bad anyways, you aint there to cause no trouble, the only negative effect is the breaking of a rule which, in your case, protects noone. You cant blame them for their actions, any human would do this. And even if, even if you say that they are at fault, YOU ARE PUNISHING THE KIDS IN THE WORST WAY POSSIBLE FOR THE ACTIONS OF THEIR PARENTS OVER WHICH THEY HAD NO CONTROL OVER. How do you justify that? Making the Child responsible for the actions of their parents? And im even gonna play the christian card here since most likely based on statistics you belong to that faith, jesus said "treat others like you would want to be treated". Excuse me, your hipocracy is skyhigh.
AMNESTY NOW
How about AMNESTY NO!
I swear it's my kid can I have money and a house now.
AND same people also support abortion which is seperation from the mother but permanently
Myia Garrett yes but that’s the mothers choice. This is the government forcibly taking you away.
Please report this immediately. Most definitely misleading. Sick and tired of Seeing BS pop up.
what do you mean misleading?
Looks like someone datamined code of the newest update for NPC 6.3.5
Thank god for free press. This is eerie, hard to believe a US administration did this.
And still doing this.
Obama did this more than trump
The same was happening under the Obama administration people are just drawing attention to it not because it is trump
@@simonw.6720 No, it wasn't.
lexas4 it literally was. Do your research. Pay more attention to the other outlets, besides the NYT and CNN which are notorious for their biased reporting. Find the facts and then make an informed decision.
Parents who go to prison are separated from their children too. My advice to illegals would be to stay home and go thru lawful channels to get here.
Pppl went through legal channel and still got separated, what's the next move?
Word
NYT is now a toilet paper company.
Yeah! Does this mean I don’t have to be separated from my kids, when I go to jail? 🤔
It's not a NEW policy!
Break the laws there's consequences. No sympathy here
> No sympathy here
You're not human then.
@@amdasaba I mean theres a law for a reason plus none of these people look under. They are breaking the law after all.
@@jasonbrewer6714 what the heck is "look under"? You said it like they commited murder or smt... Crossing border illegally is just a misdemeanor, equipvalent to jaywalking. If Obummer can do his job w/o separating families, why can't Trump?
@@amdasaba malnourished* and Obama did do it in his presidency
@@jasonbrewer6714 why would how ppl look affect our judgement of their crime?
Point me to any source that said Obummer did this intentionally to 1000+ families in
Trump 2020.
New York Times, constantly playing with words. 'We don't need to make sense. We can play around with the english language, and people will listen to what we say, because we have learned how to form sentences. to form. sentences. words. We learned words one day in school. Watch. Our Ad. Give me a break, NYT!
New York Times
The former newspaper
The guilt trip is real
Because it's not ok.
That's what happens when you are a criminal. American parents don't take their kids to jail when they break in someone else's home.
Do not teach your kids to be criminals.
> The Department of Justice (DoJ) told a federal judge Tuesday that it may have mistakenly separated a father and toddler who could both be US citizens for as long as a year, in the process of enforcing the Trump administration’s “zero-tolerance” immigration policy.
www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/jul/11/us-immigration-family-separations-doj-us-citizens
Hmmmm.....Really make you think.....
@@amdasaba
That's why it was called a mistake. Shocking isn't.
Obama did this btw
Not on this scale and for deterence purpose FYI
Orange man bad - npcs
Orange fan mad! Orange man's Vlad!
Womp womp
Come here legally, doesn't happen. I treat any immigrant with respect. The ones coming don't care about the US. Side with lawlessness, Jesus will say "depart from me". Side with following the government and respecting the emporer, Jesus won't tell you to depart from Him.
Sincerely,
A legal, child of legal immigrants, citizen of the United States of America.
Ohhhhhh news flash:
The Department of Justice (DoJ) told a federal judge Tuesday that it may have mistakenly separated a father and toddler who could both be US citizens for as long as a year, in the process of enforcing the Trump administration’s “zero-tolerance” immigration policy.
www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/jul/11/us-immigration-family-separations-doj-us-citizens
Be careful out there, citizen~ :D
Our border is effed up! Now buy my Newspaper!
So you had no issues when Obama did this? Interesting.
who cares who did this? what's important is that its happening and it needs to change.
The New York Wast of Times
Wow omg this is horrible, I feel so bad for the kids it's so heartbreaking💔
I hate Trump and ALL the Republicans, there so cold-hearted and evil wtf😕!!
Sigh... I always report this type of propaganda. You should too
Yup, reported you
Why don't you just lobby your congressman to get rid of freedom of press, it will make suppressing true things that trigger you easier, sayeth the LORD thy God
@@hotsexyjesus4367 I'm not against freedom of the press, I'm just playing the CZcams game. My people get flagged, demonitized, and suspended/banned all the time. What other option do I have on CZcams but to fight back against the other sides propaganda?
Joe D. Opposing freedom of press IN PRACTICE because other people get banned for violating the terms they agreed to. Very American of you, sayeth the LORD thy God
@@hotsexyjesus4367 So its my sides fault when we get censored by the liberal left complaints, but we are 'practicing' opposition to freedom of the press when we counter by complaining about the left wing propaganda. Yea that sounds fair.
TRUMP 2020
This hasn't touched my heart. Honestly they are dumb enough to come here with no papers. :) MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN! 🇺🇸
It's incredible the amount of fools that believe this ad
Stay out!