Bill Lipe - Before Lake Powell / Memories of Glen Canyon
Vložit
- čas přidán 9. 05. 2012
- www.verdevalleyarchaeology.org
Dr. William Lipe is an archaeologist with expertise in the
North American Southwest, archaeological method and theory, and cultural
resource management. His Ph.D. (Yale 1966) was based on fieldwork in the
Glen Canyon area of southeastern Utah. Subsequent major field projects have
included work in the Cedar Mesa region of Utah and the Dolores region of
southwestern Colorado. Since the 1980s, he has collaborated with
archaeologists at the Crow Canyon Archaeological Center in Cortez, Colorado
on studies of Pueblo settlement patterns, community organization, and
socio-cultural change in the Northern San Juan region of Colorado and Utah
The more time I spend in the area, the more convinced I am that the dam was a huge mistake and what a tragedy it was to inundate one one of the greatest wonders of the natural world.
I spend a few weeks every year down there exploring away from the water. The re-emergence of the canyon and its wonders is something to behold.
P.S. I live in Moab and am an avid river runner. I’m good friends with Roy Webb and I just shared the link to this fine presentation with him. Once again, thank you very much for making this available via CZcams, it’s greatly appreciated!
I appreciate this video. Thank you 😊 I have lived in the Bullfrog Basin for almost 20 years. I have watched the lake steadily decline. Seeing this video makes me appreciate the historical low water levels today in 2022. I am thrilled to see areas like Hite Marina get back to its natural state. The biodiversity seems to be bouncing back. I can now imagine people living on/near these rivers. It has been just a vast empty landscape with a canyon full of water. Now that it is less than 25% full, it is much more beautiful to me. The sweeping fields of grass. The birds, bugs, and bees. It's amazing to watch Hite become what it was. 👏
Omoomomooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooomomoooooomooooooomooooooomomoomomomomomomoomomomomomoomoomomomomomomomomomomomomomoomomomomomomomoomomomomooooooooooooomooooooooomomoooomomoomomomomoooomomomomoooomomomomomomomomomomomoomomomoomomomoomomomomoomomomooooomomomomoomomomoomomomomoomoomoooomomomoomomomomomomooooomomooomomomooomomooooomomoomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomoomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomoomoomomoomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomoooooomomomomomoomomomoomomooooooooooomomooomomoomomomomomomomomomomomomomooomomoomoomomoomomomomooomomomomomoooooomooomomooooomoomoooooooooooooooooooooooooomomoooomoomooomomomoooooooomoooooooooomoomomomomooomooomomomooomoooooooooomomoooomooooooooomoooooooomoooomomomomooomomomoooomomomomoooomomooomomoomooooooooooomomoomooomomomomomomooomomoomomooooooooomomomomomomomoomomomomomoooomomooomoomoomomoooooomooooomomoooooomooomomooomomomomomooooomomoomomomoooooomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomoomomomomomomomomomomoomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomoomomomomomomomomomomomomomomoomomomomoomomomoomomomomomoooomomomoooomomoomomomoooomoooooooooooomoomooomomomomomoooooomomomomomomomomomooomomomomomoomomoomomomoomomomomomomomooomomomooomomomoomomoooooooooomoomomomomomoomoooomoooooooooooooomomomooomomoooomomoomomomooooooomooomomooomomomomomomomoomomomooomomomomomomomomomomomomoooomomoomomomoooooooooooooooomoomomoooooooooooomomomoooooooooomomomoooomomomomooomoomoomomomoomooomomomomomomoomomomomoooooomoomomooooooooooooooomomomoooomooooooooomomooomomomoomoooomomomoomomooomomooomomomomoomomooooomomooooooooooooooooomooomooomomomoooooomoooomoooooooomoomomoooomomomoomoomooomooooomoooomoomooomoooooomomomooooooomoooomomoooooomooooooooomomoooomoomomoomomomomomomooooooooooomoomomooomoooooooooooooomoooooooooooooooooooooooomoooooooooooooooomooooooooomooooooooooooooooooooooooomomoooomomomooomomooomooomooooomomoomomooooooooomoooooomomooomomomooomomomomoomomoomomoomooooooooooooooooomomoooooomoomoomomoomomoooooomomomoooomomoomomoooomomoomomomooomoomomomoooooomoooomomoomoooooooooooomoomomoomomoomooomooooomomooomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomoomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomooomomomoomomomomomomoooooomomomoomoooooooomoomoomomoomomomoomomoomomomoomomooooomomomomoomomomomomooomomomomomomooomomomomomomoomomoomomoomomoomomomomomooomomomoomoomooooomomooomomomomoooooooomoooooooooooomomomoooomoomomomooomomomomomomomomomooomomoomoomomoomomooomomooomomomoooomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomoomomomomoomomomomomomomomomomomomomooomomomomomomomoooooomooooooomomomomoooooooooooooooooooooomoomoomomomooooomomomomooomooomomoomomooomooomomomoomomomoomomomooomoomomooooooomomomomomomoomomomoooooomomooooooomooooo
Omomomimomomomoiooomomoiooooooooooooooooooioiioooiiooiooioooooooooooooooooooooooooiiiioimiiooooiooooooooooimiiioiioioooiiiiiiooooiooooooooooooooooomomoomoomomoomomomomooooooomooooomooooomomomoomomomoomomoomoomoooomomooooooomoooooomooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooomooomooooooooooooooomomooomomooomomomomomoomomooomoooooomomooomomooooooooooooooooomomoomoomomomooomomomoooomooomooomoomomoomomomomooomomomoomomomoomomomoomomomomomomooomomomoomomooomomomoomomomoomomoooomoooooooooooooomomomomomomooomomomooomoomomooomomoomomomomoomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomoomomoomomomomomomoooomomooomooomoooooooomoooooooomooomoomomomomomomooomomoomomomomoomomoomomomomomomomomoomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomooomoomooooooooooooomomooooomooomomoomomomoooomomomooomomomomoomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomoomomomomomomomomomoomomooomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomooomomomooomooooomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomooomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomomoooomomomomomomomooomomomomoomomoomomomomomomomomomomomoomomomomoooomomomomoomomoooooooomomoomooomoomomoomomomoooooooooomoooooomoomomoomoooooomoomomomomomomomomomomomomomoomomomomomomomomoooooooomoooooooooooooomomoooomomomomomoooomomomomomomomomomoomomoomoomomomomomomomoooooomoooooooooooooomoooooooooooomoooooooooomomoooomoooooooooooooooomoomoomooooomooooooooooomooooooooomoomooomomomomoomomomooomomomooomomomooomomoomooooooooooomomoooooomomomomoooomomoomomomoomomomomomomomoomomomomomomomomomomomooomomoooooomooooooomoooooooomoooooomomooomooooooomomomoooooomooomomoomomoomomooooomomooooooooooooooomoooomoooooooooooooomooomoooooomoomomoooomoomomomomoomomomomoomomomomomomomoomomomomoomomooomomomomomomomomooomoomomomoooomooomomoooooomimomomoomomiooooooomooomooimiimimimiimimiimimimimimiiimimimimimimimiiimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimiimimimimimimimimimimimimiimimimimimi
M
Mimiimimimimimimimi
Miimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimiimiimomomoimimimimomomomomomomomomomoimomomomoomomomomomomimoooomomomoomomooimomomomoomomomoomomomomoomomoomooimoomomoiiiiiiimimimimiiimiimimimiimimimimimimimimiiimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimiimimimimimiimimimimiiiiiimimimiimiiiiimimiimimimiiimiiimimimimimimiimimimimiimimimimiimimiimiimimimimiiimimimiiimimimimiimimimimimimimiimimimiiimimimimimimimiimiimimimimimimimimimiimimimimimimiimimimimimimimimimimimimimimiiimimimimimimiimiiimimiimimimiiimimiimimimimiiiimimimiiimimimimimiiiimimimimiimimimiiiimiiiimimiiiiimimimimimimimimimimiimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimiimimimimimimimiimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimiimimimiimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimi
Mimimimimimimiimimimimimimiimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimiimimimimimimimimimim
Iimo
M
I’m Mimi
Mom
I’m
Imi
Mm
I’m
I’m
I
I
Im I’m
I
Imi
M
I’m
Imimom
I’m
Iimomomoomimimimimimimim
I’m
I’m
I’m
Imimom
I
I
I’m
Imim
I
Mi
Mm
I’m
I’m
I
I
I’m
I’m
I
Mimimim
I’m
I’m
I
I’m
Imimom
Iimomomomiimimiimimimi
M
Imi
M
Imimom
I’m
Imimom
Imi
M
I’m
Imi
M
I’m
I’m
Imi
M
I’m
I
Mimi
Mimimimimi
M
I’m
I
Imi
M
Imi
MMO
Mi
Mimi
Mimimi
Mi
Mm
Imi
M
I’m
Mimi
Mi
M
I’m
Imim
I
Imi
M
Imimomomomomomomiim
Imimo
Mi
Mimimimimimimimimimimimim
Imimomomomomomomimiimimimimimimimiiimimmimiiimimimimim
Iim Imim
Imimm oyou Mimi
Iioiimo
IOh m
Iimo
MiOh m
MOh I’m
I
IOh m
I’m
Iim
Imim
Imim
Iimo Imim
Imimomomomomomoimimimimimimimimimimimimiimimiimim
I’m
Imimomomo
Mimimimimimimim
Imimomomomomomomi
Mimi
Oh 😫 mimight just mimiimimimiikmimimiimimmimiimimimiiimimim im milol miand mmomimimimiand mimimimimimand imand imimomand oimomom omilol lol 😝 mo😝 moyou mooiyour was mo🧺 momiyou you momimimimimimimiimmimimimimiimiimimimimimimiimimimimmm
Imimomooimomooimimi
MoimiOh
MiOh m
Imimom
I
Immimimimimimim
Imimoimomimimimimimimimimiiim imiomomoimiiimiiimiimimi mmomiiimiimimim
Iim
Iimomo moiii mi
M
IOh mimiyou iimomo
Mom
I
IOh Imim
I
Iimo mii mom I’m
I’m
Immigration minim
Imimom I
Mimimimimimimimiimimimimimimimimiiimimimiimimimmimimimimimimimiiimimimimimimimimimimiimomoiimimimimimimimimimimimmimipoimimimimimimimim
Immimimimiim imimiimimim mimiyour miyour your miimimike mimimiwill has mimimimiimimimimimimimimimimimimimiimimiimimimmimimimimimimimiimimimi
Mimimimimimim
Imi
IOh I
Mi
MimOh imOh mi
I’m
I
M
Iimomo
Mimiiim
I
MimimimOh iiomimimimimimimimimimimiimimimimimimiimimimiiimimimimimimimimim
Mimimioimimimiimimimimimimimimimiiimimimiiiimimimimimimiimimimimimimiimimimimm
Imimimmomomo
M
Oh ii😫 m
😫 i😫 mi
Imi
Oh miOh
Imim
I’m
Imi
M
Imim
Imimim
Iim
I
Miiiimimi
Mimi
I’m
Iim
Iim
I’m
I
Imi
Imimimo
M
I
Iim
Iiimimi
Mi
M
Imi
Mom
I’m
Imimimo
M
I’m
Imi
M
Imimimomomomomoimimimi
Mimimim
Iimomoiimimimimi
MiimiomimimimiimiimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimiimimimimimimmimiI’m mimimimimiI’m mimimioimiimimiimimimim
Imimimo Imim
you immyou imiyou might mimiii miyour miimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimimim
Imimimomomomom
Imimim
Imimi
Mom
Imimimomomomomomiimimimi
Miimimimimimimimimi
Mimim
Imi
ImOh iOh Mimim
Imimimm
Imimimo mimimimimimim
Imimimomomo you migot your code might mimimi mimimior or miyou Mimimim mimiilol mor imior mi
Mi
MOh you got miiimimiiiimiimiimim
I’m
Mi
Oh mi😫 you have Mimimim miMimimim with my dad miMimimim
Oh m
M
I’m
I’m
M
Iimo
M
Im i mi
M
Im
II’m mom
Imim
M
Im
Im
Iim
I miiidon’t m
Imigo mi
M
IOh m
IiiOh m
I
Im
Iimo
M
Im
IOh
It’s m
Imi
Mi
Oh 😫
M
It’s cool mimimi
MimiOh you got migot mto I’m sorry 😣 m
Iit’s mi
Iit’s mimyou iyou mi
Myou im
Wow! These pictures and this presentation are amazing. Thank you for showing the original Glen Canyon. These ancient civilizations have always intrigued us.
I was raised in Hanksville, UT & have wondered for over 30 years now what lies beneath. So appreciative of this presentation & all the men & women who worked on surveying Glen Canyon
We had a video presented to us in high school, 1979, of glen canyon before. Have never forgotten how beautiful it was.
Really nice talk, images, love the vintage video from the 1950s. Bill Lipe is a very good speaker and has had great adventures in the canyons. Thank You.
Just watched this last night. Absolutely a treasure.
The juxtaposition of mindset from the 50's until now (2022) astounds me. If this opportunity happened today, the bureaucracy would have changed the experience completely. Thank you.
Thankyou for your presentation, I was lucky enough to spend 3 or 4 weeks a year for 30 years on the lake exploring it's beauty. Many high school friends from upstate New York lived and worked at Wahweap Marina and also worked for the Park Service in the 70's, 80's and 90's. Before the dam a few thousand people got to enjoy that part of the river, after the dam millions of people got to enjoy cool blue water of Lake Powell it's sandy beaches and hidden coves next to towering rock formations. Dams don't work forever but I am grateful for the memories.
Fascinating! I really enjoyed the archival footage and seeing the scale.
Such an awesome story . He got to see things no one else will probably ever see again.
Probably will now
Wrong Bizzle
Wonderful video thank you SO MUCH
Any more Glen Canyon before it was drowned much appreciated
This is an excellent presntation 10 Stars
2022 and Glen Canyon is definitely coming back. Who knows what will happen with the lake at this point.
An excellent video, thanks very much for posting!
I went to HS in Moab and my dad was a Forest Ranger on the LaSalle Forest. In 1955 I was a sampler working with a geologist on top of Cummings Mesa that is in the background of a number of your photos. We spent 30 days up there living in a tent and scouring the lenses of the Morrison formation for any radioactivity. My employer, Rare Metals Corp. (div of El Paso Natural Gas) had a uranium mill in Tuba City and were looking for high grade to sweeten up the intake ore. I have slides from the air showing the key slots being cut into either side of the canyon for the dam. I am a certified airplane pilot and mechanic from Utah State and an industrial engineer from Cal Poly. The annual rainfall in Moab during the 50's was 8-11 inches. Now, thanks to Lake Powell it is around 20. Now there are birds and squirrels, greenery and millions of hard working people enjoying fishing, boating and scenic camping in an area that was the most dry, desolate, dusty, barren landscape I have seen.
10-12 thousand years ago there were hundreds of people living on top of Cummings mesa at 6000 feet and surrounded by water. Dr Cummings stripped the artifacts which are on display in Tucson. I think that what happened on the Columbia River and Lake Bonneville about the same time is similar to what happened on the Colorado River in the Glen Canyon area.
Nice presentation and so terrific to see the old photos of the pre-dam canyon!
So much was lost.
This was a great talk. I enjoyed learning about the sites and early archeology. I'm reading a book by Childs & Preston called Thunderhead which is an archeological thriller about that area. It was interesting to see how the area is laid out.
Thanks for posting this.
This was amazing. Thank you.
Whoa! What have I been missing out on, my heart is about to jump out of my chest, wonderful discoveries! What an astounding adventure for you Hombres. I'm was an explorer of the central Texas backcountry and have basically seen all the sites here destroyed to some major degree and hiking access to lands outlawed. So many archeological and spiritual sites dug up and paved over, heartbreaking.
What a wonderful gift you have given us in this lecture
It is a nightmare scenario that so many of those sites are now underwater, but better than bulldozed and paved over!
Thank you for this video and this channel!
Great hiking in TX, I was raised by timber consultant so I have left my share of foot prints. Are you around the Llano uplift or out on the Llano?
this should have a million views at least
Before flooding this was the most beautiful canyon in the world.
I very much enjoyed this.
Excellent, thank you!
Honesty:"We didn't do a very good job on Desert Archaic." When is a culture lost or only misplaced? After 25 years in the Glen/Wahweap/Paria Canyon area, I have realized that archeologists have missed the vast number of Archaic glyph sites here, and they are far more numerous than Pueblo or Basketmaker sites. Archaic lithics are so deep in some tributaries that BLM handed out gravel leases on them. Essentially, every Archaic artifact I've seen is made from dinosaur fossils, which constitute all of the area gravel sites, including the one for the dam's concrete. They are faint with age, but many glyphs stretch from canyon rim to floor, some well over 100 feet tall. These are not stick or simple geometric figures, but highly accurate representations. They appear to be 3,000-4,000 years old. Most common images: triangular faces that have been cut from a skull and worn as a mask (Schaafsma), human skulls, stacks of decapitated heads or heads hanging from poles, birds of prey, hunting scenes with birds of prey, buffalo, mountain lions and fish, of which some are caught in nets. They were collecting dinosaur skulls and putting artwork on them. Lithics are so deep, and giant glyphs so numerous, that some Desert Archaic were here in greater numbers at times than the Pueblo or Basketmaker. The natives depicted bear no resemblance to either Navajo or Pueblo people of the region today. While a vast number of glyph sites are under water, hundreds (probably thousands)of giant glyphs line the walls above the lake and far into Grand Staircase & Vermilion Cliffs, and as far as the Waterpocket Fold, San Rafael Reef and the Uinta Basin. Some of these are geoglyphs visible from the air.
instablaster
wow the history we are never taught...
Need to take pics and document before the govt decides to change history.
Proof of Noah's flood
100% upvotes!
Not anymore... two shitheads downvoted it :(
@@than217 - and thankfully the downvotes are no longer visible.
Very good talk!
Rivers are like veins to a human...they are necessary and vital for the earth to be healthy. If you mess with them you could be damaging more than you think!
Exactly 💯
Wonderful!
It’s so sad why they did here. As someone from a younger generation, I first learned about the wonders of Glen Canyon from John McPhee’s “Encounters with the Archdruid”, about David Brower.
It's 2021 and the lake is at it's lowest level since they built the damm. Part of me says I hope it never fills again. But I live in Southern California and we're at the end of the line for water.
I came here to watch this video after watching a National Geographic video on Glen Canyon and Cathedral in the Desert. I hope the dam never fills again, too.
I love this guy, anyone know a man named Jack Snobble? He was a Western Exploration teacher I had in the early 80's
I"ve always wanted to know what lone rock looks like out of water
Mark Brand I must have missed it. At what point in this video did they show Lone Rock? I'd love to see it!
go now
How the guys going to think about old things when young ladies are around?
Olollllllllllllollooolllllillooloilllllllllllllllllllllollolllklklllklllllollolololoolllllllllkolkkklololklkoolllollollolkkoololoooolkokoolokoo(klllllllolllol)llkklooo)lkkklollloolklllooloolooo)(I'll llo)llololllllllloololkollolllok I'll look(oklllllloll)klll look kkoklollllkkk ko kk koollkolkllollkkkkkolkkkololloloolllllkoolook)kkk look k(lklll)oo)kkkkkolllkoll)(lloloklolloollolkolkolkk(ok(klllllllolllol()kk kk((lol lol loll(okklllokk I'll I'll loll l(kklklook(k(kkkkkkkklklkkkkkkkk KK 9kkkkkokokkklk((oolook(kkkk(kllklolo(kkkkkkk(k
Kkkkkkk((l((kkkokko
Look to(
P
Kkklkollolok
Lololol on kk kk loll okklllokk o
Oooooo
Kko
K
(
Okooooooooko
Okklllokk)
(K((
(K
Ppp
The good news is, glen canyon is coming back.
It’s almost back to its natural state now, they are finding everything from before it was flooded.
John Powell tagged on horse bends famous descending sheep native drawings
The federal government never gave a dime for the Navaho Nation land flooded, nor any power from the Glen canyon dam electricity
Break the damn!!
Trying to use outboards on a shallow river! What on Earth?
This is literally why New Zealander, Bill Hamilton, invented the jetboat in the 1950s: it will run in 3cm of water.
And get you to places nothing else can, lickety-split!
Video of Glen Canyon before Lake Powell: czcams.com/video/zJeXB-gf0Ag/video.html
Fab
Shields and swords. Interesting.. anyone else see that...
This guy predicted the future 10 years ago! Get rid of the dam and return the canyon to its natural beauty!! The dams are just screwing up things anyway!
THEY BURIED THE PAST OF MY PEOPLE WITH WATER.
take down the dam
I’m as reactionary as a small-town Texan can be, but after a half-dozen trips to southern Utah I’ve decided the dam is an abomination.
Really incredible how reliant such intelligent archeologist were and are on such a flawed and highly inaccurate pile of BS Radio Carbon Dating is. The absolutely absurd results gained from RCD are completely worthless. When a single item is tested using RCD and no 2 results are ever found to be even remotely alike and are offered with a plus minus of 500,000 years something should tell them that RCD as a theory is great but, as an actual result is complete garbage?
I would like to present archeology in general to examine just how EU theory is real and highly common sensible. It should be obvious that LITERALLY EVERYTHING is tied to ELECTRICAL ENERGY!!! So when we see the poles shift, the sun emit its Cyclical Nova event, these peoples were not scared of other Peubloans they prepared for the Cyclical Nova Extinction event. Their drawings were depicti9ns of sites seen in the sky as Electrical Energy discharge.
Time to wise up and see the obvious tie we and every living and nonliving thing we have ever encountered is tied electrically perhaps tye sooner we will not be diminished to zero perhaps many many more of us will survive.
Exactly !!!!
REPENT GOD IS PUNISHING AMERICA FOR IT'S SINS AROUND THE WORLD !😢😢😢
All done for money.
Plenty of canyons to explore without draining lake powell.
A thousand times more people enjoy the lake than ever hiked that canyon. Get over it!
Climate change coupled with unrestrained development is draining Lake Powell. Get over it!
Douche bag weekend warriors are more important than an entire region of life and perfect beauty ... bro you're basically dog food
Lake Powell like Jerome Powell is empty and being attacked 🤣 Buy #Bitcoin to stop the corrupt
Pathetic little troll