The Controversy on Horse Racing
Vložit
- čas přidán 6. 05. 2020
- None of the music is mine, some of the video footage is mine but most of it is not.
I did spend hours on research for all this information and editing for this video, hence the watermark.
This video goes over the significant positives and negatives of the horse racing industry. When taking a look at the horse racing industry from many viewpoints across the globe, it is not hard to come to the conclusion that is topic is much more complicated and deeper than originally assumed. The horse racing industry is part of the global economy in today’s world and is far too valuable to remove, while there are hundreds to thousands of horses that are injured or doped worldwide.
Many people will say there are no problems, both spectators and people within the business and industry. Then you will see welfare activists that call for the immediate halt of all drug use and abusive tactics used with racehorses. While it is clear that there needs to be some level of change, many say it is not enough. Organizations and governments have stepped in on some of the problems and enacted reforms for these issues. This is a global debate and the significant level of economic benefit from the horse racing industry wherever it is present is too valuable to halt horse racing altogether. It can be safely stated and assumed that the answer to these large over-arching obstacles and debates fall somewhere in the center of the spectrum with 'stop horse racing' on one end and 'change nothing about the current state of the industry' at the other.
Music: • Sad Emotional Dramatic...
Coloring: Sunnyvids
Other videos I have on this topic:
The Secret Side of Horse Racing (read the description to further your knowledge of this industry)
• The Secret Side Of Hor...
Sources:
Allin, Jane. “Horse Racing: The Chemical Horse .” The Chemical Horse - Drugs in Racing, Horse Fund , horsefund.org/the-chemical-horse-part-9.php.
Bélinguier, Bertrand. “The Economic and Social Contribution of Horseracing in Europe .” Pari Mutuel Europe, European Pari Mutuel Association , Sept. 2009, parimutuel-europe.org/Download/EPMA_Economic_impact_of_horse_racing_03Sept09.pdf.
Bernau, Alan. “History of Horse Racing.” History of Horse Racing, Alan's Factory Outlet, 2019, store.alansfactoryoutlet.com/History-of-Horse-Racing-s/1873.htm.
Campbell, M. L. (2013), Editorial. Equine Veterinary Education, 25: 489-492. doi:10.1111/eve.12087
Carter, Harold O, et al. “An Economic Analysis of the California Thoroughbred Racing Industry .” University of California , Giannini Foundation of Agricultural Economics , Oct. 1991, s.giannini.ucop.edu/uploads/giannini_public/d3/8d/d38dafc0-a55c-4cfe-a315-9996a828b0c8/342-thoroughbreds.pdf.
Evans, D., & McGreevy, P. (2011). An investigation of racing performance and whip use by jockeys in thoroughbred races. PloS one, 6(1), e15622. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0015622
Gramm, M., & Marksteiner, R. (2010). The effect of age on thoroughbred racing performance. Journal of equine science, 21(4), 73-78. doi:10.1294/jes.21.73
Goldberg, Ryan. “A History of Drugs in Racing .” Thoroughbred Daily News, TND Magazine , 2 May 2013, www.thoroughbreddailynews.com/pdf/magazine/Magazine-Drugs%20in%20Racing-Part%20I.pdf.
Horses to the slaughter: Editorial]. 2012. New York Times, Mar 27, 2012. ezproxy.uky.edu... (accessed October 1, 2019).
Kane, E. (2008). Anabolic steroids -- uses and abuses. (Cover story). DVM: The Newsmagazine of Veterinary Medicine, 39(4), 1E-6E. Retrieved from search.ebscohos...
Kane, E. (2012). Whip use in Thoroughbred racing: Is it necessary?. [online] Veterinary News. Available at: veterinarynews.....
Larkin, Malinda. “Horse Racing Eyes Changes to Stay Relevant .” Avma.org, American Veterinary Medical Association , 12 Oct. 2011, www.avma.org/News/JAVMANews/Pages/111101k.aspx.
Marlin, David. “The Airways and Lungs.” The Horse, 22 June 2018, thehorse.com/125263/the-airways-and-lungs/.
Mitchell-Matheson, Heather. “Chain Use vs. Abuse Clarified by Horse Experts.” Horse Journals, 26 Aug. 2015, www.horsejournals.com/popular/horse-industry/chain-use-vs-abuse-clarified-horse-experts.
Rockefeller, John D, et al. “Medication and Performance-Enhancing Drugs in Horse Racing.” GovInfo, Authenticated U.S. Government Information , 12 July 2012,
www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CHRG-112shrg76248/pdf/CHRG-112shrg76248.pdf.
Russell, Mark, et al. “Economic Impact of the Horse Racing and Breeding Industry to Indiana.” Purdue Extension, Purdue University , May 2013, www.extension.purdue.edu/extmedia/ID/ID-445-W.pdf.
Is anyone else having problems with the audio?
i am
me
My problems with horse racing:
Whipping
Age
Pressure on the horses legs
@Julia Jankowska but we don’t jump horse 1m20cm as 2 year olds we wait until they are 4 or older to start jumping or riding and they don’t get up to the high fences for a while so they have time to adapt and build muscle
The whips are engineered to be softer than the average crop. They are foam-padded and make a slapping noise whilst being applied. Horses can get welts when the whips are overused, but jockeys try not to.
Pressure on the horses legs is the same as jumping. Weight comes down hard on the fragile legs of jumpers when they land on their forelegs after a jump. Same in horse racing. Both types of legs can handle it, unless there is an accident, which happens in both sports. Same in cross-country.
@@bella-xg8td I agree with you on the pressure on the horses legs but at the age many race horses are it’s too much pressure in my opinion
@@madi.equestriansj First off, I respect your opinion ;) Scientific evidence has proved that horses who are *ready* to begin racing at a young age actually can benefit from it. Horses have bones that adapt. If you train a horse right, they build what is called "breeze bone" that helps prevent the bone from snapping whilst running. So, actually, instead of breaking down the bones like people think, correct training, breezing, and the age the horse is ready to begin racing - some horses it it is two, others three or older - can build UP a horse's bones.
@@madi.equestriansj Sadly, modern American trainers don't understand how imperative it is to discard the traditional training methods and begin to focus on bone and muscle science and condition to train their horses. There is so much on the best way to train a racehorse I can't write it all out xD
I personally believe horseracing should be able to continue but under much stricter regulations as way to many horses die in the US and AUS from it, but i do believe a lot of owners and trainers really do care about their horses. I just think the bad ones need to be removed from the sport and much stricter regulations.
I dont think drugs should be used on horses. Yes, medications that are neccessary for horses are ok but the reason these horses are on pain killers is because of racing. And yes it helps some countries but exploiting animals is wrong in every way to me, especially in horse racing. They're seen as money cows
Agreed. In this case medicine is used wrongly.. Not for the benefit of the animals 😔
@@kikaequestrian1386 exactly. If the horse gets an injury, the least they could do is temporarily retire them til' they're healed. But no, they ignore it and give the drugs
Tedward Cullenary coming from a point of experience, many horses are not on painkillers, etc. when they are racing as many of these substances are banned and will come up on post-race swab tests. For example, have a look at Alligator Blood (horse) and that controversy recently in Aus. Horses that are injured or even slightly sore do go out to the paddock for a rest (which can be a few weeks or many months). I know where I work that our horses are regularly given trot-ups to check for signs of lameness and have regular vet visits if there is something wrong. You simply cannot generalise a whole industry from a few instances of abuse or neglect. Unfortunately all sports and disciplines will have bad eggs but as a whole, that does not make the sport bad.
I myself, whom is in the industry, agree with this point/topic. From all my racing experience, there is no proven point in drugs. In the early 2010s, I used Lasik on my racehorses (keep in fact that I was still pretty new to the industry at the time) and used it as a prevention. After a year or so, I started used a Flair Strip and Lasik on all my horses. After a year of more education and learning experience, I realized how much money I was wasting and how stupid I looked, so I decided to start using the Flairstrip only, and it's worked, both on my bleeders and non bleeders.
The racing industry is trying their best to handle the situation. By 2021, Lasik will be banned on major American tracks and hopefully, in the future, Lasik will be completely banned. Fees have doubled for a positive drug-test, and the amount of time to pay the fees have made it harder to pay them. If you don't pay, it's a suspension. The list of illegal substances have doubled, maybe even tripled, and I sure am glad. I hope that theu make a 1 strike and your out kind of thing. If your horse is positive, your "out" (suspended).
*LASIK is a legal substance used to prevent bleeders from bleeding*
Racing is very bad for horses.... I wish they would stop racing
Me also😒
Love Horses Forever But we gotta remember Secretariat...
@@kikaequestrian1386 So I guess you didn't learn anything from the video, huh? I myself own racehorses, and would write an essay regarding the positives and negatives on horseracing. But I'm not. Why? Because every time I do, people think I'm wrong and they're right, even when they have little to no experience. Ignorance.
@@ciaradominguez1468 I do have experience... Yes thankfully there are good owners like you, and riders.. But here where I live its maybe up to 10%...Maybe where you live there are more good riders, but as any industry exploring animals, where there is money I don't support it... I don't hate the people like you who are responsible, and loving their animals, but by the experience and some facts, there aren't many of you😔
Kika Equestrian the industry wouldn’t survive if it was only a small percentage of owners and tracks doing the write thing. You might want to fact check yourself
I have seen the horse racing world from close and I can confirm that there is not place for horses’ well being there.
i dont understand how horse racing can be a sport its horse killing
Personally, I think that the idea of "horse racing" isn't bad. The concept of thoroughbreds running against one another is phenomenal and unique. Although, people in this industry have taken it to a whole new level. The amount of cons overwhelm the positives, which is why I said no to actually becoming a professional jockey.
Yes, the idea is good, but the horses are forced to run at dangerous speeds. But why can't people just leave it at that? Performance enhancing drugs? Really? Why can't horses at least be raced in their natural state, no drugs, wiping, or shocking.
@@justpaelen Agreed ^^
I support this 1% out of 1000%. The 1% is Secretariat
Im against racing, i dont care about the economic benefits its terrible. I dont even like saying racing is part of the equine community
generally wondering, jockey club and other sources have concluded that it is beneficial to race them young, but you never included that
They crave foals because the people are impatient. They just cant wait to test out their new money cow
Tedward Cullenary huh?
Tedward Cullenary what? Who told you that? They race them young because it’s a fairly easy job for horses (galloping on a flat surface) and it has been scientifically proven to not be detrimental to their growth.
Early! I support the racing industry 10000%
I personally think that one of the positives of horse racing is how well some of them take care of their horses. Of course, some aren't cared for as well as others, but most of the time they get pretty good care. (Like grooming, stable time, pasture time, etc.) The thing I am most against though, is how young they get put onto the track. 2 years old? Seriously? Running races? That should be illegal. People say that horses don't have emotions, but *all* animals have emotions. Breaking in a horse at *2* years old damages their mental health more than some people might know. The suggested age to even put WEIGHT on your horse is 3 and a half years old. NOT 2 years old. I feel like it should just be banned altogether. The weekly rate for horse deaths in jockey racing is 24 per week. 24 racehorses die every week due to racing. I know people are going to come at me, but if it's a sport that kills animals it should be illegal. Yes, all horses do die in every sport. However, it is mostly to natural causes, not because they slipped on a wet track and collapsed because of how young they are. I feel the same way about rodeos. If it kills animals, *IT SHOULD BE ILLEGAL.*
Edit: Some people might get confused so I'm going to clear this up ahead of time: When I refer to rodeos, I'm talking about the ones where they get unbroken horses and try to break them in, or zap 500 bolts of electricity (My memory is a little fuzzy on this) into a horse and they take off bucking. It causes horses pain and horses die from it. I've seen a horse have its leg torn off, dangling by a thread after being thrown in with its predators. It is abusive, cruel, and needs to be illegal.
Just want to pop in and say I have been around people who live ON the racetrack (like San Luis Ray Downs) and have done extensive and life-long research, and I myself have researched extensively, and the horse racing industry is not the only equestrian sport that has problems like these. Cross country, jumping, both of these sports also have drugs and abuse. I've seen horses abused in dressage. I wish people would realize that each equine sport has problems of their own. Running, racing, is something that horses have done for centuries. Mustangs can run over 12 miles a day up to 50 mph on rough terrain, and Thoroughbreds are BRED to run and they love it - it comes naturally. Just like horses love to jump and their legs can withstand the mass and weight that comes down on their "fragile" forelegs every time they land a jump, our horses can withstand running, like the Mustangs. I am not defending the entirety of the racing industry, because there IS fraud, abuse, and drugs, I will not deny it. But I cannot just turn my back on it, because we can fight to change it, and I'm not going to walk away from this industry and join - let's say - cross-country thinking I'll get away from all the bad stuff, because I will find the same abuse, drugs, and death there, as well.
The racing industry is the only sport that counts their deaths. It is the only sport that has the Supreme Court and the government and laws involved within. And people are continuously fighting to make it a better place. I am fighting, my friends are fighting, and a law was just passed that we all hope will make some differences.
I am not saying this to you, Horse Source, but to others: please educate yourselves before saying things like "racing is very bad for horses, I wish they would stop racing." Running is a natural occurrence, and with the proper training, horses can very much withstand the demand of racing. They have bones that adapt. Drugs don't happen with every trainer, and drugs also don't happen all the time in jumping, for example, but there has been doping in high-level jumping many times. It's not just the sport I love dearly, and that helped me get through an extremely hard spot in my life.
Please educate yourselves, thank you.
If you want any questions answered, I can answer them, and then make up your mind whether or not it is something that should be stopped. :))
I forgot, running horses at a young age actually helps develop their bones for later years. But it very much depends on the horse. Zenyatta wasn't ready to race as a youngster, and that was beneficial to her, the way her connections waited. But Secretariat was.
Could not watch because sound did not work
I love your videos so much 😍🖤 never close your channel you are so successful 😍💖💖💖
Really good an informative Video
I am against racing. I don't care about the economic benefits, when it's about the lives of animals... I hate it, and will never support it 😔
Kika Equestrian But we still have to remember Secretariat
@@profkara Unfortunately that is a rare case... At least in my country, and countries I know.. No hate 🙂
Kika Equestrian no hate taken. I just love him and all of the race horses... and Secretariat’s owners, not all of the other ones
@@profkara Me too. I also as a kid use to love racing. 😃Until I saw the bad side of it. 😔I am a vegan-equestrian, and in my country there is a bit different belief around animals, horses.. So I don't agree on industries which involve animals, and even competitions. But I am happy there are the rear examples of good owners 🥰
Kika Equestrian 👍
So the only positive fact is money? Money and possession destroy people and other lives.
Horse racing all in all should illegal. It kill around 700-800 horses a year which is nearly 10 horses per week. Please, do not support this awful industry that is abusing and killing so many innocent creatures.
Its shocking
Hi
This was great, I have been researching "horse handicappers favorite" for a while now, and I think this has helped. You ever tried - Deyandon Harrowing Dominance - (should be on google have a look )?
It is a smashing one of a kind product for discovering how to get exclusive horse betting tips without the headache. Ive heard some super things about it and my buddy got excellent results with it.
Love the video 💘💘💘💘💘