But Murray Perahias Bach is also sublime and georgeous, and Nikolaevas, and Sokolovs, and Pogorelichs, and Freys, and Andreshevskys and, and, and, and... Everybody of them has something... The rest more or less are personal emotions
that's very subjective. I find Nikolayeva's performance much more beautiful. But, in general, according to youtube viewers (view count) her version is a close second to Gould's.
Viewing a clip does not mean one finds a performance to be the best! It just means it was watched. There is a dreadful clip of Gould playing a harpsipiano contraption with countertenor Russel Oberlin that I have watched quite a few times, with my mouth agape, and shown others too -- many views!! -- but it is still dreadful. (this was a reply to JumpDiffusion, who used youtube viewership counts as a proxy for liking/beauty)
I only find Gould's toccatas (bwv 910-916) as untouchable. Many other Bach's compositions are played better by other people (Sokolov, Nikolayeva, Tureck, Shiff....). Gould's choice of tempo is sometimes puzzling if not weird. Sometimes he goes way too slow or way too fast. But it's just me. Some people prefer only Gould's Bach and no one else.
Sairam Open auditions 2024 Sri Sathya Sai Universal Symphony Orchestra. Since 1995/2024 it has been active worldwide under Music Director Founder and Conductor Maestro Prof. Giuseppe Savazzi Maestro Giuseppe Savazzi invited by Baghavan Sri Sai Baba to found and direct the Sathya Sai Symphony Orchestra with the aim of bringing together peoples and nations at beyond one's political or religious beliefs. Sound is music as the only divine supernatural entity that communicates to us all together. Since 1991 I have been carrying out this project open to all of you without distinction. Sairam 🙏 Prof. Maestro Giuseppe Savazzi member of Rotary Club of New York District 7230 blessing to all of you from India 🇮🇳 Music Director and Founder of the Sathya Sai Universal Symphony Orchestra in Putthaparty Founder and music Director of the Rotary Youth International Orchestra with Lufthansa Sponsor since 1990. in šāʾ Allāh إِنْ شَاءَ ٱللَّٰهُ Sairam 🙏🇮🇳❤️🙏
I have enjoyed some Chopin and other performances by Cherkassky (I think even some Bach), but I think this performance is very poor and is especially poor Bach -- in fact one of the worst performances I have ever heard by a fine musician. He seems to be seeking attention with many unnecessary "moment by moment" changes and superficial little tricks, without inwardness where needed. He drags the tempo down to no purpose, and frequently whatever momentum is inherent in the music is derailed by all his fussy attention-seeking changes.
Почему раньше не знал этого гения?! Величайший пианист!!!!
Помню Шуру в Спб. В начале 70 х в Большом зале Филармонии и в 90е,когда он играл у Петропавловской крепости. Бесподобно❤
Cherkassky was a pupil off the great Josef Hoffman, where he studied and lived with his parents in Baltimore USA.
My beloved Shura applying his magic to a great masterpiece! Thank you very much ADGO!
пишут какой то бред в коммент.,когда исполнение мастерское и бесподобное!🎹💥
SUBLIME, GORGEOUS,
But Murray Perahias Bach is also sublime and georgeous, and Nikolaevas, and Sokolovs, and Pogorelichs, and Freys, and Andreshevskys and, and, and, and... Everybody of them has something... The rest more or less are personal emotions
I like the performance very much. It is his own understanding of what Bach wrote, hearing his perspective on the work makes it more interesting to me.
i guess I'm kinda off topic but does anybody know a good site to stream new series online?
@Derrick Howard i watch on FlixZone. You can find it by googling :)
@Dangelo Elliot Yea, been watching on FlixZone for since march myself :D
@Dangelo Elliot thank you, I went there and it seems like they got a lot of movies there =) Appreciate it!!
@Derrick Howard Happy to help :D
チェルカスキーは一時ドイツで人気を博したそうですね。ピアノの熟知した神童中の神童といわれただけあり素晴らしい演奏だと思います。彼のライブでは会場全体を一体化させてくれました。
The incomprable Shura
Mam wrażenie, że niektóre piękne kompozycje Jurka Chruścińskiego z Teatru Witkacego w Zakopanem są wariacjami na temat tej Bachowskiej Partity
23:40
Very close second best to Gould's version.
Thank you so much for posting this!
I wouldn't say close second. Second, maybe. I have listened to 60+ players play this piece and nobody comes close to Gould's version.
that's very subjective. I find Nikolayeva's performance much more beautiful. But, in general, according to youtube viewers (view count) her version is a close second to Gould's.
Viewing a clip does not mean one finds a performance to be the best! It just means it was watched. There is a dreadful clip of Gould playing a harpsipiano contraption with countertenor Russel Oberlin that I have watched quite a few times, with my mouth agape, and shown others too -- many views!! -- but it is still dreadful. (this was a reply to JumpDiffusion, who used youtube viewership counts as a proxy for liking/beauty)
I only find Gould's toccatas (bwv 910-916) as untouchable. Many other Bach's compositions are played better by other people (Sokolov, Nikolayeva, Tureck, Shiff....). Gould's choice of tempo is sometimes puzzling if not weird. Sometimes he goes way too slow or way too fast. But it's just me. Some people prefer only Gould's Bach and no one else.
Why are people so obsessed with Glenn Gould? Why are the same people so obsessed with ranking?
Sairam Open auditions 2024 Sri Sathya Sai Universal Symphony Orchestra. Since 1995/2024 it has been active worldwide under Music Director Founder and Conductor Maestro Prof. Giuseppe Savazzi
Maestro Giuseppe Savazzi invited by Baghavan Sri Sai Baba to found and direct the Sathya Sai Symphony Orchestra with the aim of bringing together peoples and nations at beyond one's political or religious beliefs. Sound is music as the only divine supernatural entity that communicates to us all together. Since 1991 I have been carrying out this project open to all of you without distinction. Sairam 🙏
Prof. Maestro Giuseppe Savazzi
member of Rotary Club of New York District 7230 blessing to all of you from India 🇮🇳 Music Director and Founder of the Sathya Sai Universal Symphony Orchestra in Putthaparty Founder and music Director of the Rotary Youth International Orchestra with Lufthansa Sponsor since 1990. in šāʾ Allāh إِنْ شَاءَ ٱللَّٰهُ Sairam 🙏🇮🇳❤️🙏
sona! mejor al clave
ピアノがポリフォニーの楽器だと証明する!
今や、世界はピアノの本質を完全に見失った！
左を向いても右を向いても、どこを探しても見つからない…
唯一、Ivo P.のみか?
I have enjoyed some Chopin and other performances by Cherkassky (I think even some Bach), but I think this performance is very poor and is especially poor Bach -- in fact one of the worst performances I have ever heard by a fine musician. He seems to be seeking attention with many unnecessary "moment by moment" changes and superficial little tricks, without inwardness where needed. He drags the tempo down to no purpose, and frequently whatever momentum is inherent in the music is derailed by all his fussy attention-seeking changes.
It would be interesting to know whose performance is the best for you...
@@user-ep3kc7gv2y Leonhardt, Scott Ross, Hantai... stop futzing around with piano versions.
Who made You the Authority on the way Bach should be played. I think you should take some more time studying and then have your head examined.
@@larrykatz3333 Spoken like a true Non Pianist
Hahahahahahahaha