Aespa "girls" dance break analysis | own observations
Vložit
- čas přidán 31. 07. 2022
- This is just a short analysis of the aespa members executing to Girls based on my own observation. Feel free to share your own opinion
song:
girls by aespa
tags:
#Girls #에스파 #psychorious #aespa_Girls
#SMP #SMPD #SMPFLOOR #슴피플로어 #aespakarina #aespawinter #aespaningning #aespagiselle #aespaedit #에스파 #danceanalysis #kpopdance #æspa - Zábava
Ning Ning really told i am a lead dancer material girl
Nignignig????😭😭😭😭
@@thedayis_rainy lmfaoooo
@@thedayis_rainy racially motivated 💔
@@nova-in9oh what do you mean??
Ning Ning is like Jihyo, a honorary lead dance
Karina and Ning Ning slayed the dance break. They were the only reason why it actually looked cool. Winter and Giselle who didn't add the slowmo effect just lost a lot of my interest when watching them. And Karina just slayed lmao.
Ning Ning is like Jihyo, a honorary lead dance
@@soobservo7540 jihyo is main dancer material tho twice just has strong dance members
You're righttt
And then there are people who say that Karina doesn't deserve this position. She freaking nailed it
There is lot changes happen in their dance position after Giselle came in..maybe they could've one strong dancer along with karina..but idk 😐
Ning Ning is like Jihyo, a honorary lead dance
both main vocal and lead/main dancer material
Yes agree
Yeah, but Winter is the lead dancer
@@brownieruby4984 💀 I thought winter’s fans like to call her main vocal
@@brownieruby4984 Just because an idol was assigned a certain position that doesn’t mean that really live up to that position. Ning Ning would be better for a lead dancer cuz imo her flow is just better and her moves are ,,fuller“ if that makes any sense. No hate to Winter
Ning Ning has really been standing out to me lately this this cb!!!! Love her energy (get into it yuh😂)
She's been standing out to me as well. What a dance machine
Ning Ning is like Jihyo, a honorary lead dance
@@soobservo7540 omg yeahh and both of them also got amazing voices... TvT
Karina and Ningning have really great energy and stage presence. Karina is an outstanding performer overall
Hmmm
karina really killed this dance break especially with the slow mo and leg movements. it made the dance break look so cool! i just wish the other members did the same because i feel like it would've looked better if done in karina/ning ning's way.
So true
Karina is the member which attracts me to watch more Aespa... AI Visual, Strong Dance Performer, Polite etc she has
NingNing literally owning that performance.
Ning Ning is like Jihyo, a honorary lead dance
Ningning and Karina actually, Karina's dance break is just as amazing as Ning's
@@youtubeisntallowingmetocom9062 Karina was dynamically very good, I was seriously impressed this time around.
@@shujinko2944 Ikr? She caught me eye in this era, I was in love with her locks and slowmo effects
Ningning is definitely an all round idol
They all are lmao
But she can't rap? Or can she? I've never heard her rap before
@@lifeisshort666 yes she can, they were on a radio show once where they all switched lines and she had done the rap part and she did a great job!
@@Kangchaeri oh ok thanks for being polite!
@@lifeisshort666 Yep she has, shes rapped karinas part in next level and also did a rapish part in illusion
Karina and Ning Ning slayed as always
Hmmm
And people still question Karina bring the main dancer lmao.
Ning Ning always slays the choreography idk why she's not a lead dancer
Really
Who's the lead dancer then???
@@lea9720 winter minjeong
I think it's because they wanna have 2 in dance line 2 in vocal line and 2 in rap line
Nahh ningning is good but def not as good as winter. Her energy is great though
@@dreammmssss4511 reminds me of Wendy in that regard
Karina's strong and precise moves
And Ningning's entire energy and body control, amazing queens
Hmmm
Karina and Ningning really nailed the performance. (Karina is the MAIN DANCER for REASON & Ningning is a lead dancer material)
Karina really amazes me during this dance break when I saw it first in the MV, sure the camerawork helped a lot but seeing her doing it so seamlessly just strengthen the fact that she's the main dancer for a reason.
Ningning being extra and adding flavor to the move is the reason why she's also my bias!
Ningningggg is so amazing to see her perform her energy is amazing I’m shocked she isn’t in the dance positions
Hmmm
Karina was amazing start to finish with this choreo. Really cemented her main dancer status despite all the criticism she gets
That's why NINGNING is my bias
ningning slayed
Ning Ning is like Jihyo, a honorary lead dance
In love with Karina footwork
Karina is an ace 😍 she got the amazing vocal, she's the main dancer, she's the lead rapper, she slaaayy girls 🔥
She is all-rounder because she is super talented, Ace has a bit different meaning
@@moonlightsunshine6 karina is the Ace of the group, she surpass the level of other members.
@@certezarikkimaea.1514 ace has producing included when all rounder was around or just the thing most people talked about it was only about dancing,singing and rapping but then it turned into ace and that was only called that because the producing and songwriting category was added so karinas an all rounder not an ace
@@certezarikkimaea.1514 Ace in not the member who is good at everything, ace is the secret weapon of the company, it comes from phrase “ace in a hole” when you have a secret card to play poker, the company introduce Aces themselves. All-rounder is a member who is good at everything.
Karina's leg movements are just so satisfying to watch!!! Like I can watch her doing that thing allll day
omg every time i see another Ning Ning fancam by chance I am more convinced that she is the hidden gem of aespa
NINGNING REALLY ATE THE PERFORMANCE
Ningning really is the hidden gem in aespa
Ning ning is lead dancer for me.
she still lacks in a lot of aspects and techniques to be a lead dancer, maybe in 4 years or so
@@hyunlixxie2662 name those aspects one by one and let's discuss who's better between ningning and winter in those aspects. yall are confident saying winter is a better dancer because you still believe she's the lead dancer when aespa themselves said that they don't have fixed positions. you should know that fact by now.
@@hyunlixxie2662 bet you are a Winter bias hahaha. Clearly she is better than Winter, just SM favoring Winter cuz she is Korean and she has no main position unlike the other 3. They gave the position to Winter so that people think she is the ace when actually its Ningning and Karina
@@danissegomez7953 exactly my thoughts
@@uxzlmkju5820 I noticed that winter reacts to the music 'better' than ningning (idk what its called), like winter has better footwork and during the chorus of girls, she 'bops her head and shoulders' ig to the beat of the song more.
I'm soo shit at describing it sorry, ningning definitely has more enthusiasm and energy when she dances ,but has less technique than winter.
I think that is what the other person who commented was trying to say.
Ningning slayed her dance, as she should
YASH NINGNING REALLY ATE IT !!!!
I love the way Karina is such a perfectionist, her movements are perfect!!! And Ningning slayed the dance break, I really can't understand how she's not the lead dancer of the group... Great reviews, too!
Her control is not as good as in winter, and she is still within the limit. Ning Ning's dancing is sometimes very stiff and forceful, and her lower hand is not as stable as in winter. The reason why she leads the dance in winter is that"😅
@@mythhygj-vt8tj I think you just described winter not Ningning 😂
@@eulalia3468 What is being said is true. Winter and Liu Zhimin are both dance shoulders, but Ning Ning's dance is considered very good among the fourth generation lead vocals. However, Ning Ning's control and details are not as good as winter's
NINGNING OWNED IIIIT, SHE DANCE SOO WEL
don't forget about ningning facial expression too 🥵
Notice how Karina’s is different from the other’s. Not only did she execute every part perfectly, but during the beginning for the dance, she raises he hands as if to say “I know I’m amazing” while the others point at her. She’s the centerpiece of this dance as she should.
We're talking about her first verse right? If yes, then I agree. She killed that part
@@psychorious nope they talking about the dance break
@@aespa4genleaders584 woops my bad
I love Ning Ning's body posture when dancing, it's like a queen commanding for proper execution 🤣 Karina no doubt about being the main as always slayers! Winters upper locked movements really are good and what i always noticed too maybe she's a lot more focused on that parts, for camera works always focuses on faces and upper body, Giselle isn't a dancer material but she's really trying hard and you can clearly see developments ever since they started this era she sometimes lose focused on dancing that's why there's a lot of mistakes but i can see she's diligent enough and trying her best.
I agree :)
Ningning's stage presence😍😍
Ning ning owned this era.
Karina's is so satisfying....she's slaying as always 😌💫
Karina is one of my favorite female dancers of the 4th gen. I can’t quite explain but she has such a unique flavor, her style is almost masculine in a way. She hits every move with such power and sharpness and her footwork is so intricate always. And everything she does she does it with a very neutral expression which makes it all look easy.
She’s also starting to become one of my favorite idol dancers. I agree with your comment! She really has her own flavor!
For this specific dance break here would be my ranking:
1. Karina - Outstanding energy and her footwork is really good, definitely has firm arms and clear locks.
2. NingNing- Energy is amazing, very strong arms, torso rolls were on point as well, has very clear locks.
3. Winter- Has good energy, could use some work on more energy in her dancing, maybe focus less on arm drill even though she didn't quite isolate the right arm.
Giselle- Needs some more practice on energy and more clear arm placement. Also could use more arm strength as well, other than that she also has an outstanding arm drill.
I really love the way karina interpreted the leg movement, it gives the dance more natural groove and I feel if the members also learned it the way she did maybe they all would look more fluid together during their live performances
Karina is definitely the main dancer of the group. She gives the right emphasis to each dance step and executes it as needed.
For dance
1)karina🐻
2)ningning🐯
3)winter🐹
4)giselle🦄
Karina and ningning ate like yeji and chaeryoung karina like chaeryoung she can control her body and clean movements while ningning like yeji she got swag and power in her dancing don't hate on me I am not comparing I just wanted to give explanation in the best example
Yeah ..get it
Nigning improved so much
Im absolutely in love with Karina's footworks
Karina's footwork is insane tbh
Karina slayed and ate this!
i can’t do the leg/footwork part before that slow mo steps 😭
I mean, they're all doing it a little differently, but watch the demo :) It's mostly leg "in and out"
@@psychorious thank youu!
I can do the footwork hehehehehe!
I don't know why people keeps on sleeping on ning yizhou, lead dancer material girl 😭 her dancing has been actually standing out for me since debut era ❤️
Thank you for this educated analysis. Tired of kpop fan degrading and insulting the girls for fanwars and calling it "constructive critisism"
1. Karina
2. Ning Ning
3. Winter
4. Giselle
Ning Ning reminds me of Jihyo in the sense that she might not always have the greatest technique, but she always puts power behind her moves
Winter’s technique and attention to detail is always near-perfect! She’s an incredibly talented dancer, if she had more energy, that would be the cherry on top.
I’ve been saying this since day 1 and finally people see it. Ningning is actually lead dancer material. She adds her own fluidity and nuance to the dance moves that other members don’t add and she’s been doing this every era.
ningning ATE
Ningning and Karina 👑
Ningning is so energetic.
that's what I noticed too about karina when I watched her in hot n' cold! I love her lower body control.
For real! Her footwork is amazing!
Karina and ningning so good
karina's footwork is just amazing?!
Yeah Karina’s moves are really cool and under appreciated. She always has some extra stuff she adds too.
it's sad that in a lot of contents like studio choom, etc, the camera can't capture karina's footwork, i mean i get it, they want to show the hand rolling(?) part like they pulled the camera in, but it's just shame that we only notice the footwork on some videos..
Karina: clear, skillfull. Ning Ning: power, energetic. Winter: underdance, lack of energetic and details. Giselle: chaotic
i can definitely see now why Karina is main dancer, honestly they're not the strongest dancers overall, but Karina and Ning Ning are clearly the best
Sort of reminds me seulgi footwork
Ningning Girls era is just 🥵
Karina and Ningning 😍
Really loved that Karina and Ning Ning did every step and didnt rush through. Although there are always room for improvements. But it helped me enjoy the choreo throughout. There’s always more than just doing the step.
Karina's arm lock is fire🔥🔥🔥
Karina slayed
Love Ningning's energy
Winter is a good dancer but she needs to put more energy
And Giselle needs more nd more practice
BRO KARINA AND NING NING SLAYED DANCE BREAK😳
ningning should be as center more.. she would eat
Karina Queen dancer 🤗🤗👏👏👏👏👏👏
Ningning slayed oh yasss 🔥
No cap, only Karina did justice to the real choreo of that dance break. Ningning exerted effort and got a good side along with Karina. Both of them serve talents
I do appreciate Gigi and Winter tho, I didn't like how they did the dance break. It felt like 'let's save energy up until the end' vibe
To be fair Winter has to hit some high notes after this dance break so I understand why she can’t put all her energy into it.
Ning Ning showing that wanting to be there and trying hard can mean more than raw skill
wow ningning also capable become lead dancer
Ning Ning should be given more dance breaks......I feel like she we handle them......She's really good plus I love her energy.
Easy for Karina as she stayed at the same spot while giselle and ningning and to move to different places . 🫠 but ningning dance looks more powerful and energetic
Ningning slayed so much omg idk that she is a good dancer??
NING NING
1. Karina
2. Ningning
3. Winter
4. Giselle
Ningning being lead dancer material and having the best stage presence
And Karina is Amazing too
love how everyone in the comments is praising my Ning
They all are really improving dancing
For me, ning ning dances w/ more energy and stage presence i know winter is a great dancer but for me she's not giving great energy, her facial expression is blank like she's doing nothing i dont hate her but i think they give her the lead dancer position just because she's pretty
My opinion..
Poor Giselle,u deserves more ❤Your dance is amazing and so addictive ❤❤
ning ning ate
NING NING main dancer.
People need to stop sleeping on NingNing. She eats CONSTANTLY in every comeback in every category. My sis is an ace
Ning ning the best dance performance, the body so flexible and nice to see than the other...
Balance body measurement,not like see robot/ statue make rigid dancing which I see this part Karina & winter their back, chest, hip, Waist looks rigidly and Bending...
Ning Ning be dancing like the rent is due
Ning ning is giving me Lead dancer vibessss
NingNing ate.
This is why Karina screams main dancer to me ❤
Karina 👸
it's been 3 weeks since their cb and the dance practice hasn't been released yet. That's why I decided to analyze their dance break instead :)
It’s just an idea, but you don’t have to:) You could use the “Studio Choom” full focused video. I love your dance analysis, keep going👍🏻
@@daveh.8911 I could try, but there's some reasons why I wouldn't use it
1. there's a chance that my video will get blocked. Not sure tho, haven't tested yet.
2. they're wearing high heels and tight clothes. I want them to be fully committed to the choreo.
I believe they will release their dance practice once the mv has reached 100 million views.
@@psychorious they’re dance practices are more cameras work view. They haven’t done one since next level
@@fireprincess17bowling95 oh that’s true. Then I guess there might be no analysis
Ningning is actually the second best dancer after karina deal with it
You are so obsessed with discrediting winter, ningning didnt even do the arm drill right in any of the performances, winter still better than her
She’s really not, being the best performer in the group does not equal that she’s also a better dancer. Winter is better at dancing than ningning all the way whereas ningning is a better performer.
Only for this dance break, NingNing struggles with lower body control, alignments, lack of technique, musicality and more tbh. Winter’s only major weakness is her energy and dynamics.
@@lizuh2803 winter energy?
@@crmf I said “only for this dance break” forgot to put the usually (as in second best dancer only for the dance break)
NINGNING
Let’s take some time to acknowledge that among Ning’s platforms are higher than the rest of the girls and she’s still slaying this dance break like it’s NOTHING!
Ningning is too underrated in this fandom and beyond
Ningning and Karina have really good body control. Winter's moves are sharp but lack a little energy.