Actually, Ian Underwood was among the early Mothers, starting with We're Only in it for the Money, and Ruth (Komanov) Underwood was there shortly thereafter, starting with Uncle Meat. I could not make a top 10 Zappa album list and exclude Uncle Meat, Roxy and Elsewhere, and the beautiful and amazing The Yellow Shark. So on your list, I would use those three to replace Sheik Yerbouti, which I never liked, Joe's Garage, which I thought was just OK, and yes, Freak Out. I realize Freak Out was influential, and groundbreaking, but not something I really like to listen to. As for Sheik Yerbouti and Joe's Garage, I think there are several Zappa records that are better. In addition to the three I mentioned above, there's also Waka/Jawaka, The Man From Utopia, Ruben and the Jets, and Jazz From Hell, all of which I prefer over Frank's Sheik Yerbouti, Joe's Garage period. So I'm 70% in agreement with your FZ top 10. 🙂 The man changed my musical life, starting at about age 15.
@@sarahtonin4649 Yet dig that the gentleman doing these reviews of Zappa has his opinion and appreciation for such a long, and Stella career. It’s a rare treasure that such a gentleman takes on such a mission. I say…. spit on in his review! Zappa is certainly one of the most criminally misunderstood genius composers of human existence. Hats off for your passion and correction where you see fit yet, this analysis is fantastic!
@@sarahtonin4649 nor do I! Everyone has one, usually not so thoughtfully executed though. I appreciate the time and dedication put into these reviews! He has it right in his articulation of the times and body of work! We all have our favorites…… I appreciate watching and listening to someone who knows exactly what he is talking about. A rare occasion these days for all those thousands of reactionary fakes spawning a generic channel without a clue!
"The Ocean Is The Ultimate Solution" from the "Sleep Dirt" album is my favourite Zappa track. Terry Bozzio, Patrick O Hearn and Zappa. Just 3 musicians on this one. Mind blowing bass and drums and my favourite blistering and soaring Zappa guitar solo.
Once upon a time, must have been late spring '76 or thereabouts, three guys (Terry Bozzio, Dave Parlato and FZ) were jamming for 40 minutes. A bit later in the recording process for Zoot Allures Zappa meets Patrick O'Hearn and has him play a new basspart on a 13 min edit of that jam, replacing Dave Parlato's bass part. Zappa added some more overdubs (including that brilliant solo) and voila: The Ocean Is The Ultimate Solution.
I'd have put 'The Grand Wazoo' in there and for me it's pretty close to a number 1, in particular the track 'Eat That Question' is simply an awesome piece of well written music. However having over 120 Zappa albums released pre and post the passing of the great composer it get's harder and harder for me to define rankings so full on respect to you sir for boiling down Zappa's amazing catalogue to this list and obviously a fellow Zappa fan to boot, so well done.
I agree, The Grand Wazoo would've been in my top five. He went with the more popular Hot Rats, which was his only real representation of the early solo period between the original Mothers period and the trifecta of the Roxy era bands studio work: Overnight Sensation, Apostrophe, and One Size Fits All.
And like the previous album Waka Jawaka it was recorded during a difficult time for Zappa; he was recovering from injuries received when he was pushed off stage during a show at The Rainbow Theatre in London. He was in fact confined to a wheelchair and unable to tour for almost a year.
I bought Joe’s Garage when I was in college around 1990, it’s still may favorite to this day. Overnight Sensation and Apostrophe fill out my top 3 Zappa studio albums . I really dig his live albums as well, Live From New York being a particular favorite of mine. His book was also very entertaining. A very interesting and intelligent musician. He left us far too soon.
This is the best start to a day that I have had in some time. Thank you for your articulate critiques of the wise and wonderful albums of FZ. So very grateful for the sheer hilarity, scathing satire and musical brilliance of Zappa!
I really appreciate your insightful reviews! They've made me go back to the music I listened to back in the day, which is proving to be a very enjoyable experience.
Everyone has their own favorites. My top ten would include Uncle Meat and Grand Wazoo near the top. My only quibble is with the distinction between "live" and "studio" albums, which does not really apply to FZ. FZ did not simply release live versions of fan favorites. Almost all the live albums released in his lifetime (until the YCDTOSA series) were made primarily of previously unreleased compositions, and often were interspersed with studio material and overdubbed in the studio (first half of "Roxy & Elsewhere") . Zappa often spliced live material into "studio" songs (guitar solo on the "studio" version of "Inca Roads") or used live tracks as the basis for "studio" songs (most of "Sheikh Yerbouti" & much of "Joe's Garage). Zappa pointedly did not limit himself to these kinds of categories. But I guess you have to do something to narrow down his huge catalog of albums. Good review as always.
I wrapped a news paper around my head so I looked like I was deep... Excellent list, it included my top 3 Z albums, Apostrophe, Overnite, & One Size! Pondering the significance of short-person behavior In pedal-depressed panchromatic resonance And other highly ambient domains...
I really enjoyed your review. Zappa was a musical genius, I've been buying up every album I come across. I've recently done several Zappa stories on my channel. Thanks for the excellent review!!!
Thank you for your wonderful review and homage to one of most unique, iconiclastic, eccentric and enigmatic figures in pop music. I've been a fan of Frank's since 1970. I have collected 23 of his albums.
I’ve not been a Zappa fan until recent years. He’s a fascinating composer and musician, much too complex and rich with social commentary back in the day for me. Now with more time and patience, and releases from his vault, I am diving into his work. Thanks for your knowledge and take on his music.
You're like an encyclopedia, mate. Great analysis. Of course I've never met anyone who doesn't like Zappa. Hot Rats has never left my number one spot. I've bought it in every form (media) through the years and still love to play the remastered. Absolute musical brilliance. Mozart of Rock! Love all your choices and can add a few of my own. Well, done. Cheers.
My 10 favourite albums (I'm starting from the bottom getting to the top) by Zappa are: 10. Lumpy Gravy (1968) 9. One Size Fits All (1975) 8. The Grand Wazoo (1972) 7. Hot Rats (1968) 6. Weasels Ripped My Flesh (1970) 5. Burnt Weeny Sandwich (1970) 4. Freak Out! (1966) 3. Absolutely Free (1967) 2. We're Only in It for the Money (1968) 1. Uncle Meat (1969)
Glad to see you tackled this almost insurmountable catalog. I must say this would mirror my own top 10, though not in the same order, except for one. Perhaps this is a sentimental favorite, but Sleep Dirt would definitely be in my top 10. And oddly, I’ve seen several discussions of One Size Fits All, and not one mentions the song, which my brother once described as possibly the greatest song ever written, Andy. A slight oversight that is easily forgiven. Enjoyed the video very much. Best to you!
Really enjoyable top ten video. Don't think i would be brave enough to actually do it myself with The Grandmothers massive output. All your choices are cracking!
Hi guys. My first ever CZcams comment and only my third like on a CZcams video. The other two being two other reviews of Freak Out! Some great albums on here and some of my personal favourites as well. I've been listening to Zappa properly for the past thirty years now and am amazed at just how eclectic and prolific he is/was as an artist. The way he mixed music genres, covered many topics and used satire and humour throughout his career has never ceased to amaze me.
Reviewers pick (in reverse order): 10. You are what you is; 1981 9. Joe's garage; 1979 8. Absolutely Free; 1967 7. We're only in it for the money; 1968 6. Over-nite Sensation; 1973 5. Apostrophe; 1974 4. Freak Out! 1966 3. Sheikh Yerbouti; 1979 2. Hot Rats; 1969 1. One size fits all; 1975.
I'd add, 'the complete Roxy' recordings would now be one of the finest Zappa albums as it's even better than the original offering having EVERYTHING from that great moment.
Your presentation is a wonderful job, what I'm missing is "just another band from LA" and the gorgeous "Fillmore East" both of which were my first exposure to Frank Zappa's music because they are so much rock music - as it is for me too Overnite Sensations. I'm from Europe, which probably influences my perspective.
Zappa takes time to sink in ... I bought You Are What You Is on double LP when it was released because I loved the single ... listened to the album but just did not "get it" ... a few years later I made a tape of it for listening to on a car journey ... then I was hooked .. . Joe's Garage and Sheikyerbouti were next .. . then on to Hot Rats and the Apostrophe / Overnight Sensation albums ... I would include Burnt Weeny Sandwich / Zoot Alures ... I also like the Them or Us and Broadway the Hand Way live albums ... I can appreciate the 1960 's material but am less keen on it. I do quite like Jazz from Hell and his classical work is worth checking out ... there are also plenty of "duds" in the catalogue because it is so vast . . . be wary of Uncle Meat / Just Another Band From L.A. ... Thing Fish . .. hiis instrumental guitar albums have spectacular playing but can be way too much so approach these carefully ... but the playing is awesome. So - in summary - an amazing catalogue to check out and once you "get it" you will be hooked ... have a good explore around CZcams / Qoboz (my preference) / spotify to see what you think ... the recommendations from the video are good suggestions ... Calum - Aberdeen - Scotland . .. P.s. also check out any local Zappa tribute bands in your area . ..
Love your reviews. Great choices, only you missed two of my favorite tracks: “The Torture Never Stops” and “Valley Girl”. But there are so many things happening on every one of his albums. You are in for a ride every time. Mos def not easy listening.
Thanks for the video. Based on your recommendations I listened to the Hot rats album. Although I listen and enjoy music it's quite rare to come away from an album and say that I really enjoyed that album. So much so that I put it on again and listened again. The Gumbo variations was absolutely amazing! I will have to try the others in the list next. Thanks again
Thank you. One Size Fits All is my favorite Zappa album and one of my favorites of all time. And it often gets overlooked. When you got down to number 4 and hadn't mentioned it, I thought for sure it wasn't going to make your list. Imagine my surprise when It came in at number 1. I actually have the sofa tattooed on my wrist. And my favorite song, of course, is Andy. Great list, by the way.
@@classicalbum You have Hot Rats at number two and mention Miles Davis Bitches Brew which was recorded around the same time. Arguably Hot Rats was just as much a cornerstone of Jazz Fusion as the Davis album and predates the Fusion of Return To Forever, Weather Report et al.
It's so difficult to pick a top 20 let alone a top 10, I love all his albums. If I were to pick a favourite it would be everyone of them, including live albums as they were like studio albums, everyone of them different. For me he was the greatest artist of them all, his music would kick you in the teeth and come back and kick out your dentures.
My top 5 ZAPPA albums are: 1 hot rats 2 overnite sensations 3 sheik yerbouti 4 one size fits all 5 apostrophe(,) Honerable mention.... you are what you is well, that's just me what can I say? Anyway stay safe.
I would have moved Overnight Sensation higher on the list but I think I agree with your #1 pick. Inca Roads has one of my fav guitar leads of all time, and it was a live recording! Omg!
A listening at a party in Copenhagen in the early 80'ies, (where a girl unknowingly put on Overnite, assuming it was heavy metal).. was my first listen! I FOUGHT everyone coming close to the turntable.. At the point where I was flipping the disc for the third time, I was overcome, and thrown out from that party.. but still felt it was a win... That was the night I became a fan, and has been ever since!
I bought my first Frank Zappa album a few years ago. Then I have now and again bought another one. Much on chance and the popular opinion online. I got nine now and eight is on this list! Pretty spot on I must say!
Great Stuff Barry! When you said you were doing this I wrote my top ten as well so here they are. 10- Absolutely Free 9- Bongo Fury 8- Freak Out 7- Roxy & Elsewhere 6- Hot Rats 5- One Size fits all 4- Apostrophe 3- Overnite Sensation 2- Zoot Allures 1 Sheik Yerbouti
In no particular order: 1 - One Size Fits All 2 - Apostrophe 3 - Hot Rats 4 - Overnite Sensations 5 - The Grand Wazoo 6 - Joe's Garage part 1 7 - Studio Tan 8 - Waka Yawaka 9 - Burnt Weeny Sandwich 10 . Chunga's Revenge
I agree your statement regarding the amount of albums Zappa has put out it is a hard choice to pick only 10. A couple of my favorite songs, Peaches En Regalia and Billy the Mountain!
The very first Zappa album I bought was Apostrophe and remains my favourite. I played the song Uncle Remus over and over. But for sheer weirdness I have a perverse affection for Lumpy Gravy.
You Can't do That on Stage Anymore (vol.3), yep live recordings, yep even including songs from different gigs united with some kind of magic glue, but what the hell, that's an absolutely fantastic album :)
Great job of your top 10, I also Like Weasels Ripped My Flesh, the song Directly From My Heart to Yours, a Little Richard song, Zoot Allures,I Saw Zappa live during this period, Chunga's Revenge, Cruising With Ruben & the Jets,Cheap Thrills!!!
1. Over-nite Sensation 2. Uncle Meat 3. One Size fits All 4. Freak Out 5. Studio Tan 6. Burnt Weeny Sandwich 7. Only in it for the Money 8. Absolutely Free 9. Weasels ripped my Flesh 10. Sheik Yerbouti
I thoroughly enjoyed watching and listening to your thoughts on Zappa's top 10 and I think it is spot on except I'd have Sheik Yerbouti lower down. My ear is drawn to less noisy music these days. I'm also staring at Ben Watsons book which I've just purchased wondering when I will have enough time to focus properly on reading it. I have a few days off next week so that's settled. I've also been writing to my teenage nephew and sending him Zappa CD's all of which he has on your list except Sheik & Joe. One Size is my favourite as well, and I Inca Roads Guitar solo is sublime. Thank you.
You can't argue with anyone's top 10 Zappa albums. I'll be returning to this to listen more fully when I'm not distracted. While the order of the albums you mention would change for me (or anyone I imagine), the additions I'd include are Reuben and the Jets (which I always enjoy) and Burnt Weenie Sandwich for the violin solo by Sugar Cane Harris. And Grand Wazoo for its jazz fusions second only to Hot Rats.
Though my list would be different, I agree with many choices and with your #1. “Inca Roads” was simply mind boggling to any musician that heard it. It’s difficult now to understand how far ahead of its time it was. Interestingly, the guitar solo was a live recording of a different song, spliced in. After moving to LA some 36 years ago one revelation was how many more of Zappa’s references made sense. "Camarillo Brillo" is goofing on people mispronouncing Spanish city names ("Cam-ah-ree-o"). Anyhow, great job, and I’m glad that for once you couldn't sneak in a “Topographic Oceans” reference... 😉
amazing to take on this task, but you handled it very well indeed....just for my own personal listing, two albums that would have to find their way in the top ten are 'zoot allures' and 'sleep dirt'....but that's just me...brilliant my friend...peace...rocky
Glad that 'You Are What You Is' gets a mention. The vocal orchestrations alone are astonishing never mind everything else that's going on. As I'm a Zappa nerd who can't resist an opportunity to write a list , here's my top ten: 1. Studio Tan 2. Civilization Phaze III 3.Only In It For The Money 4. Uncle Meat 5.You Are What You Is 6. One Size Fits All 7.Ship Arriving Too Late 8.200 Motels 9.Orchestral Vol 1& 2 10.Sleep Dirt
This has to be subjective because FZ released 400 albums (or it feels like it). All I would do with this is move Joe's Garage up. I've only heard 3 triple albums in my life and the other two have a lot of crap on them. A listen to Joe's Garage now for me does reveal that the album is actually fillerless and actually tightened by the story and its nature as a concept album. It really is a high point in his career and by his words one of his proudest achievements. The other one is Lumpy Gravy.
Joe’s Garage was the first Zappa I ever heard, last week actually. Heard it 3x in a row, immediately became obsessed. lmao It’s a way of life I love it ;)
I remember falling in love with Zappa in the late 70's at 15yo when my friend played Another Band From LA. I was hooked even though it was not his best, in my opinion. When I bought We're Only in it for the Money afterwards I was perplexed and didn't understand the record. Played it a few more times and thought (and still do) that it was an absolute masterpiece! Uncle Meat was next, and on and on.... Couldn't get enough. One I've never liked is Absolutely Free although certain parts I love, could never bond with that one. They are all so different and that's really amazing in itself.
I would place '200 Motels' up there with the best of his work. It has such a range of music on it and would probably be my desert island disc. It is very hard though to choose, and certainly I would not question your other choices at all. His body of work was outstanding.
Nice list. I always find it hard to rank Zappa albums because his sound constantly evolved throughout his career. At the moment, my fav is You Are What You Is but I enjoy all of his records.
@@classicalbum You mention that album getting little airplay or getting banned but the video for the actual song YAWYI in particular caused a stir over it featuring a double of then President Ronald Regan being given the electric chair.
@@classicalbum Also the opening song Teenage Wind was apparently inspired by the song Ride Like The Wind by American Yacht Rocker (if it's OK for me to use that term) Christopher Cross who was an old school friend of bass player Arthur Barrow. I only found out quite recently that Zappa even did a version of that song himself. Which I had no idea about.
I bought Sheik Yerbouti on CD around 1994. I took it home and listened to it in its entirety in a single sitting. I then immediately listened to it again in its entirety. Amazing album. It blew my mind to discover the basic tracks were live recordings. Oh, and the liner notes are hilarious.
1. Hot rats (top 10 albums of all time easily) 2. One size fits all 3. Joe's garage 4. Overnite sensation 5. Apostrophe 6. The grand wazoo 7. Sheik Yerbouti 8. Waka Jawaka 9. You are what you is 10. The man from utopia
I started picking up Zappa los around 75. My older brother turned me on to overnight sensation. I had 45 different LP's before it was over. And I only scratched the surface. Some were bootlegs. Freak out is one of my favorites. Zoot Allures. Live in New York. Shut up and play your guitar. Of course apostrophe and overnight sensation. The bootlegs we're all live European. Never had cruisin with Ruben and the jets. Or we're only in it for the money. The best thing about Zappa, so to speak, is my introduction to captain beefheart.
Pretty fantastic! I may not agree with his rankings (Which I do not.) but his commentary is interesting and that makes him likable. I love to have a conversation with the guy.
Thank you for your wonderful reviews and ranking of Mr. Zappa's studio recordings . I've been a long time fan of Frank's. I have 24 of his albums. Here are my top tens favorite Frank albums. 1. One Size Fits All 2. Overnite Sensation 3. Burnt Weenie Sandwich 4. Hot Rats 5. Lumpy Gravy 6. Apostrophe 7. The Perfect Stranger 8. We're Only in it For the Money 9. Freak Out 10. Sheik Your Booty
@@classicalbum Thank you for your comment. Is it safe to assume that this comment came from across the Pond? It's not everyday I receive international messages and comments Lol.
Cool you consider 'You are what you is', it's rarely mentioned in the Zappa classics 👍 I am far from a Zappa fan, in fact I'm quite critical on some of his output, but with this album (and Joe's Garage), Zappa's sense of humour and the music go well together without getting too high-brow arty. I was just about to write: 'I would have added One size fits all' - and there it suddenly is. Note to self: watch the whole thing before commenting 😆
Learned quite a bit here. Can’t help but agree with so many of the choices here, however my list would include Lumpy Gravy and the Grand Wazoo which may even be my number 1.
My favs in random order: 1) Apostrophe ( ' ) 2) One Size Fits All 3) New York 4) Roxy & Elsewhere 5) Make a Jazz Noise 6) The Best Band you Never Heard in Your Life 7) Overnite Sensation. 8) Fillmore 1971 (with FLo & Eddie 😊) 9) Freak Out 10) Tinseltown Rebelion And since only 10 albums go in a top 10 I make it a top 11, Zoot Allures 😅 with Black Napkins 🤠
A very underrated album I think more so than many of his others. Uncle Meat should be notably for King Kong. An epic track which was a staple of many of his live concerts and every version of it was different.
You do the best album analysis that I have ever seen. Fantastic presentation and a great deal of thought.
Actually, Ian Underwood was among the early Mothers, starting with We're Only in it for the Money, and Ruth (Komanov) Underwood was there shortly thereafter, starting with Uncle Meat.
I could not make a top 10 Zappa album list and exclude Uncle Meat, Roxy and Elsewhere, and the beautiful and amazing The Yellow Shark. So on your list, I would use those three to replace Sheik Yerbouti, which I never liked, Joe's Garage, which I thought was just OK, and yes, Freak Out. I realize Freak Out was influential, and groundbreaking, but not something I really like to listen to. As for Sheik Yerbouti and Joe's Garage, I think there are several Zappa records that are better. In addition to the three I mentioned above, there's also Waka/Jawaka, The Man From Utopia, Ruben and the Jets, and Jazz From Hell, all of which I prefer over Frank's Sheik Yerbouti, Joe's Garage period. So I'm 70% in agreement with your FZ top 10. 🙂 The man changed my musical life, starting at about age 15.
@@sarahtonin4649 Yet dig that the gentleman doing these reviews of Zappa has his opinion and appreciation for such a long, and Stella career. It’s a rare treasure that such a gentleman takes on such a mission. I say…. spit on in his review! Zappa is certainly one of the most criminally misunderstood genius composers of human existence. Hats off for your passion and correction where you see fit yet, this analysis is fantastic!
@@mvm5375 Yes, that was in no way a criticism of his top 10. It's all opinion, isn't it? He asked for ours,
and I have no shortage of opinions. 🤓
@@sarahtonin4649 nor do I! Everyone has one, usually not so thoughtfully executed though. I appreciate the time and dedication put into these reviews! He has it right in his articulation of the times and body of work! We all have our favorites…… I appreciate watching and listening to someone who knows exactly what he is talking about. A rare occasion these days for all those thousands of reactionary fakes spawning a generic channel without a clue!
I totally agree. It's a brilliant review channel.
Hot Rats is simply sublime. In my view, not only Zappa's best album but one of the best ever recorded. Now THAT's saying something!!!😆
And I love that he puts One size fits All at #1. That's hard to argue, definitely a underrated LP. He has the balls to put it out there. Well done!
But it just might be a one shot deeeeeeal!😊
"The Ocean Is The Ultimate Solution" from the "Sleep Dirt" album is my favourite Zappa track.
Terry Bozzio, Patrick O Hearn and Zappa. Just 3 musicians on this one. Mind blowing bass and drums and my favourite blistering and soaring Zappa guitar solo.
The best guitar solo of all time. Starts exactly halfway through.
Amazing underrated Zappa song!
Once upon a time, must have been late spring '76 or thereabouts, three guys (Terry Bozzio, Dave Parlato and FZ) were jamming for 40 minutes.
A bit later in the recording process for Zoot Allures Zappa meets Patrick O'Hearn and has him play a new basspart on a 13 min edit of that jam, replacing Dave Parlato's bass part.
Zappa added some more overdubs (including that brilliant solo) and voila: The Ocean Is The Ultimate Solution.
My first Zappa record was Freak Out. I still have it today! I'm a lifelong fan.
Great List, I just wanna say Chunga's Revenge will always be my favorite FZ album.
I'd have put 'The Grand Wazoo' in there and for me it's pretty close to a number 1, in particular the track 'Eat That Question' is simply an awesome piece of well written music. However having over 120 Zappa albums released pre and post the passing of the great composer it get's harder and harder for me to define rankings so full on respect to you sir for boiling down Zappa's amazing catalogue to this list and obviously a fellow Zappa fan to boot, so well done.
Yes. Blessed Relief.
I agree, The Grand Wazoo would've been in my top five. He went with the more popular Hot Rats, which was his only real representation of the early solo period between the original Mothers period and the trifecta of the Roxy era bands studio work: Overnight Sensation, Apostrophe, and One Size Fits All.
And like the previous album Waka Jawaka it was recorded during a difficult time for Zappa; he was recovering from injuries received when he was pushed off stage during a show at The Rainbow Theatre in London. He was in fact confined to a wheelchair and unable to tour for almost a year.
Yes, the Grand Wazoo, Waka Jawaka, Uncle Meat, Sleep Dirt and Burnt Weeny Sandwich.
@@danu6718Don’t forget weasels 😈
Strongly agree with your choice of number 1. "One Size Fits All" stands out from the rest of the catalogue.
I agree. I could easily make 10 top 10 lists, and , “One Size…” would always be number 1. Magical.
I bought Joe’s Garage when I was in college around 1990, it’s still may favorite to this day. Overnight Sensation and Apostrophe fill out my top 3 Zappa studio albums . I really dig his live albums as well, Live From New York being a particular favorite of mine. His book was also very entertaining. A very interesting and intelligent musician. He left us far too soon.
Sheik Yerbouti is such a great album.
Love the list!One size fits all is my favorite too!The guitar solo on Inca Roads is the absolute best!!
This is the best start to a day that I have had in some time.
Thank you for your articulate critiques of the wise and wonderful albums of FZ.
So very grateful for the sheer hilarity, scathing satire and musical brilliance of Zappa!
This is probably the most sophisticated album reviews of Zappa I've yet seen. Insightful and spot on.
I really appreciate your insightful reviews! They've made me go back to the music I listened to back in the day, which is proving to be a very enjoyable experience.
Everyone has their own favorites. My top ten would include Uncle Meat and Grand Wazoo near the top. My only quibble is with the distinction between "live" and "studio" albums, which does not really apply to FZ. FZ did not simply release live versions of fan favorites. Almost all the live albums released in his lifetime (until the YCDTOSA series) were made primarily of previously unreleased compositions, and often were interspersed with studio material and overdubbed in the studio (first half of "Roxy & Elsewhere") . Zappa often spliced live material into "studio" songs (guitar solo on the "studio" version of "Inca Roads") or used live tracks as the basis for "studio" songs (most of "Sheikh Yerbouti" & much of "Joe's Garage). Zappa pointedly did not limit himself to these kinds of categories. But I guess you have to do something to narrow down his huge catalog of albums. Good review as always.
I wrapped a news paper around my head so I looked like I was deep...
Excellent list, it included my top 3 Z albums, Apostrophe, Overnite, & One Size!
Pondering the significance of short-person behavior In pedal-depressed panchromatic resonance And other highly ambient domains...
I really enjoyed your review. Zappa was a musical genius, I've been buying up every album I come across. I've recently done several Zappa stories on my channel. Thanks for the excellent review!!!
Thank you for your wonderful review and homage to one of most unique, iconiclastic, eccentric and enigmatic figures in pop music. I've been a fan of Frank's since 1970. I have collected 23 of his albums.
I’ve not been a Zappa fan until recent years. He’s a fascinating composer and musician, much too complex and rich with social commentary back in the day for me. Now with more time and patience, and releases from his vault, I am diving into his work. Thanks for your knowledge and take on his music.
You're like an encyclopedia, mate. Great analysis. Of course I've never met anyone who doesn't like Zappa. Hot Rats has never left my number one spot. I've bought it in every form (media) through the years and still love to play the remastered. Absolute musical brilliance. Mozart of Rock! Love all your choices and can add a few of my own. Well, done. Cheers.
My 10 favourite albums (I'm starting from the bottom getting to the top) by Zappa are:
10. Lumpy Gravy (1968)
9. One Size Fits All (1975)
8. The Grand Wazoo (1972)
7. Hot Rats (1968)
6. Weasels Ripped My Flesh (1970)
5. Burnt Weeny Sandwich (1970)
4. Freak Out! (1966)
3. Absolutely Free (1967)
2. We're Only in It for the Money (1968)
1. Uncle Meat (1969)
Thanks for this. It's a welcome reminder that, since flogging my vinyl a lifetime ago, I haven't repurchased nearly enough Zappa.
I think you got the rankings listed pretty well. I was so glad you chose "One Size Fits All" as number one. It's my favorite.
Glad to see you tackled this almost insurmountable catalog. I must say this would mirror my own top 10, though not in the same order, except for one. Perhaps this is a sentimental favorite, but Sleep Dirt would definitely be in my top 10. And oddly, I’ve seen several discussions of One Size Fits All, and not one mentions the song, which my brother once described as possibly the greatest song ever written, Andy. A slight oversight that is easily forgiven. Enjoyed the video very much. Best to you!
'Joe's Garage' also contains one of Zappa's typical musical jokes /tours de force. Look out for it, all through the album.
Really enjoyable top ten video. Don't think i would be brave enough to actually do it myself with The Grandmothers massive output. All your choices are cracking!
Hi guys. My first ever CZcams comment and only my third like on a CZcams video. The other two being two other reviews of Freak Out! Some great albums on here and some of my personal favourites as well. I've been listening to Zappa properly for the past thirty years now and am amazed at just how eclectic and prolific he is/was as an artist. The way he mixed music genres, covered many topics and used satire and humour throughout his career has never ceased to amaze me.
The fact you put absolutely free on this list is perfect! that’s too sweet since it’s in my top 5 so far
It's so good!
Reviewers pick (in reverse order):
10. You are what you is; 1981
9. Joe's garage; 1979
8. Absolutely Free; 1967
7. We're only in it for the money; 1968
6. Over-nite Sensation; 1973
5. Apostrophe; 1974
4. Freak Out! 1966
3. Sheikh Yerbouti; 1979
2. Hot Rats; 1969
1. One size fits all; 1975.
One Size Fits All is my favourite Zappa album too !
I'd add, 'the complete Roxy' recordings would now be one of the finest Zappa albums as it's even better than the original offering having EVERYTHING from that great moment.
Your presentation is a wonderful job, what I'm missing is "just another band from LA" and the gorgeous "Fillmore East" both of which were my first exposure to Frank Zappa's music because they are so much rock music - as it is for me too Overnite Sensations. I'm from Europe, which probably influences my perspective.
Thank you for watching
The one I've been waiting for! Thanks
Hope you like it!
@@classicalbum I certainly did and always do
Good selections and commentary. You picked 3 of mine.
As always, very nicely done. We wore the grooves off those early Zappa/Mothers records at university. I'd have to say WOIIFTM. is my #1.
Gumbo Variations is easily one of the best instrumentals Zappa ever did. Really contributes heavily in making Hot Rats a great piece.
Can't say I've ever listened to a Frank Zappa album. I will be now! So much music, so little time...
Zappa takes time to sink in ... I bought You Are What You Is on double LP when it was released because I loved the single ... listened to the album but just did not "get it" ... a few years later I made a tape of it for listening to on a car journey ... then I was hooked .. . Joe's Garage and Sheikyerbouti were next .. . then on to Hot Rats and the Apostrophe / Overnight Sensation albums ... I would include Burnt Weeny Sandwich / Zoot Alures ... I also like the Them or Us and Broadway the Hand Way live albums ... I can appreciate the 1960 's material but am less keen on it. I do quite like Jazz from Hell and his classical work is worth checking out ... there are also plenty of "duds" in the catalogue because it is so vast . . . be wary of Uncle Meat / Just Another Band From L.A. ... Thing Fish . .. hiis instrumental guitar albums have spectacular playing but can be way too much so approach these carefully ... but the playing is awesome. So - in summary - an amazing catalogue to check out and once you "get it" you will be hooked ... have a good explore around CZcams / Qoboz (my preference) / spotify to see what you think ... the recommendations from the video are good suggestions ... Calum - Aberdeen - Scotland . .. P.s. also check out any local Zappa tribute bands in your area . ..
Lucky you ! Barry's list is a great starter for ten.
Love your reviews. Great choices, only you missed two of my favorite tracks: “The Torture Never Stops” and “Valley Girl”. But there are so many things happening on every one of his albums. You are in for a ride every time. Mos def not easy listening.
Thanks for the video. Based on your recommendations I listened to the Hot rats album. Although I listen and enjoy music it's quite rare to come away from an album and say that I really enjoyed that album. So much so that I put it on again and listened again. The Gumbo variations was absolutely amazing! I will have to try the others in the list next. Thanks again
Thank you. One Size Fits All is my favorite Zappa album and one of my favorites of all time. And it often gets overlooked. When you got down to number 4 and hadn't mentioned it, I thought for sure it wasn't going to make your list. Imagine my surprise when It came in at number 1. I actually have the sofa tattooed on my wrist. And my favorite song, of course, is Andy. Great list, by the way.
Thanks for listening
@@classicalbum You have Hot Rats at number two and mention Miles Davis Bitches Brew which was recorded around the same time. Arguably Hot Rats was just as much a cornerstone of Jazz Fusion as the Davis album and predates the Fusion of Return To Forever, Weather Report et al.
Andy is mind blowing!
Has there ever been a Zappa fan, who is not well spoken? Great video my friend.
Excellent you know your stuff
Great review of a difficult artist to review
Heya mate, loved the video! Chose some killer albums there, I'd add WakaJawaka, Grand Wazoo and Sleep Dirt for sure
It's so difficult to pick a top 20 let alone a top 10, I love all his albums. If I were to pick a favourite it would be everyone of them, including live albums as they were like studio albums, everyone of them different. For me he was the greatest artist of them all, his music would kick you in the teeth and come back and kick out your dentures.
Great video. My favs are: Sunburst Finale / Zuma / Red Rose Speedway. Thanks.
I love You Are What You Is and Joe's Garage. Plus Freak Out is insane and so so good
It's the Utility Muffin Research Kitchen (not Center).
My top 5 ZAPPA albums are:
1 hot rats
2 overnite sensations
3 sheik yerbouti
4 one size fits all
5 apostrophe(,)
Honerable mention.... you are what you is well, that's just me what can I say? Anyway stay safe.
No Uncle Meat, No Lumpy Gravy, No Burnt Weeny, No Weasels, I’m sure you can guess my favourite Frank era.
I would have moved Overnight Sensation higher on the list but I think I agree with your #1 pick. Inca Roads has one of my fav guitar leads of all time, and it was a live recording! Omg!
Agree 100%... That solo was however edited, but to perfection..
A listening at a party in Copenhagen in the early 80'ies, (where a girl unknowingly put on Overnite, assuming it was heavy metal).. was my first listen! I FOUGHT everyone coming close to the turntable.. At the point where I was flipping the disc for the third time, I was overcome, and thrown out from that party.. but still felt it was a win... That was the night I became a fan, and has been ever since!
I bought my first Frank Zappa album a few years ago. Then I have now and again bought another one. Much on chance and the popular opinion online. I got nine now and eight is on this list! Pretty spot on I must say!
Thanks for your review. Has some of my favorite albums included. Zappa was a musical genius and an equal opportunity offender
Great Stuff Barry! When you said you were doing this I wrote my top ten as well so here they are. 10- Absolutely Free 9- Bongo Fury 8- Freak Out 7- Roxy & Elsewhere 6- Hot Rats 5- One Size fits all 4- Apostrophe 3- Overnite Sensation 2- Zoot Allures 1 Sheik Yerbouti
Good stuff!
In no particular order:
1 - One Size Fits All
2 - Apostrophe
3 - Hot Rats
4 - Overnite Sensations
5 - The Grand Wazoo
6 - Joe's Garage part 1
7 - Studio Tan
8 - Waka Yawaka
9 - Burnt Weeny Sandwich
10 . Chunga's Revenge
Sleep dirt is one of my favorites. So unique
I've heard exactly one of these! I'll have to explore further...
Dude, the rabbit hole is deep and wide... Enjoy the ride...
I agree your statement regarding the amount of albums Zappa has put out it is a hard choice to pick only 10. A couple of my favorite songs, Peaches En Regalia and Billy the Mountain!
The very first Zappa album I bought was Apostrophe and remains my favourite. I played the song Uncle Remus over and over. But for sheer weirdness I have a perverse affection for Lumpy Gravy.
You Can't do That on Stage Anymore (vol.3), yep live recordings, yep even including songs from different gigs united with some kind of magic glue, but what the hell, that's an absolutely fantastic album :)
all 6 YCDTOSAs are worth having......
nothing like them anywhere !
Great job of your top 10, I also Like Weasels Ripped My Flesh, the song Directly From My Heart to Yours, a Little Richard song, Zoot Allures,I Saw Zappa live during this period, Chunga's Revenge, Cruising With Ruben & the Jets,Cheap Thrills!!!
1. Over-nite Sensation 2. Uncle Meat 3. One Size fits All 4. Freak Out 5. Studio Tan 6. Burnt Weeny Sandwich 7. Only in it for the Money 8. Absolutely Free 9. Weasels ripped my Flesh 10. Sheik Yerbouti
I thoroughly enjoyed watching and listening to your thoughts on Zappa's top 10 and I think it is spot on except I'd have Sheik Yerbouti lower down. My ear is drawn to less noisy music these days. I'm also staring at Ben Watsons book which I've just purchased wondering when I will have enough time to focus properly on reading it. I have a few days off next week so that's settled. I've also been writing to my teenage nephew and sending him Zappa CD's all of which he has on your list except Sheik & Joe. One Size is my favourite as well, and I Inca Roads Guitar solo is sublime. Thank you.
You can't argue with anyone's top 10 Zappa albums. I'll be returning to this to listen more fully when I'm not distracted. While the order of the albums you mention would change for me (or anyone I imagine), the additions I'd include are Reuben and the Jets (which I always enjoy) and Burnt Weenie Sandwich for the violin solo by Sugar Cane Harris. And Grand Wazoo for its jazz fusions second only to Hot Rats.
If you really want a challenging listen, check out Weasels Ripped My Flesh. Very avant-guard but it became my favorite of his over time
One size fits all, is my fav, followed by Hot rats, Joes garage, and Overnight sensation.
Though my list would be different, I agree with many choices and with your #1. “Inca Roads” was simply mind boggling to any musician that heard it. It’s difficult now to understand how far ahead of its time it was. Interestingly, the guitar solo was a live recording of a different song, spliced in. After moving to LA some 36 years ago one revelation was how many more of Zappa’s references made sense. "Camarillo Brillo" is goofing on people mispronouncing Spanish city names ("Cam-ah-ree-o"). Anyhow, great job, and I’m glad that for once you couldn't sneak in a “Topographic Oceans” reference... 😉
You've nailed it here...I would have picked the same.
Got to see Dweezil play Hot Rats in its entirety several years ago. Amazing show. He played a bunch of other Frank classics, too.
I love Joes Garage especially the first one. I might go for Hot Rats as my favourite but I dont know them all, not even close
I just looked at Wikipedia and it says he did 62 albums! And another 62 albums released posthumously. I had no idea.
amazing to take on this task, but you handled it very well indeed....just for my own personal listing, two albums that would have to find their way in the top ten are 'zoot allures' and 'sleep dirt'....but that's just me...brilliant my friend...peace...rocky
Glad that 'You Are What You Is' gets a mention. The vocal orchestrations alone are astonishing never mind everything else that's going on. As I'm a Zappa nerd who can't resist an opportunity to write a list , here's my top ten:
1. Studio Tan
2. Civilization Phaze III
3.Only In It For The Money
4. Uncle Meat
5.You Are What You Is
6. One Size Fits All
7.Ship Arriving Too Late
8.200 Motels
9.Orchestral Vol 1& 2
10.Sleep Dirt
Also "Where Did I Leave My Car Keys" 1984 release.
Orchestral Favorites...🥇
You Got It My Friend
I've always felt that Weasels & Joe's Garage 1,2 & 3 are also very underrated LP's too. Again, good job.
This has to be subjective because FZ released 400 albums (or it feels like it). All I would do with this is move Joe's Garage up. I've only heard 3 triple albums in my life and the other two have a lot of crap on them. A listen to Joe's Garage now for me does reveal that the album is actually fillerless and actually tightened by the story and its nature as a concept album. It really is a high point in his career and by his words one of his proudest achievements. The other one is Lumpy Gravy.
Joe’s Garage was the first Zappa I ever heard, last week actually. Heard it 3x in a row, immediately became obsessed. lmao
It’s a way of life
I love it ;)
Always dug Zoot Allures. The Torture Never Stops was probably my favorite Zappa song.
Agreed.
Yep. I’m just gonna go ahead and getting “liking” this video out of the way so I can focus on drinking coffee and savoring all 26 minutes of this.
Thank you - I hope it doesn't disappoint
I love early Zappa. Anything after 1974 I think is a bit patchy. His sixties albums I think are perfect.
One size fits all is a perfect album
@@andrewdyke5561 It sure is, Andrew. Lovely record, and not a note of filler.
Extrapolation recorded 18 January 1969
Hot Rats released October 10, 1969
Bitches Brew released: March 30, 1970
I remember falling in love with Zappa in the late 70's at 15yo when my friend played Another Band From LA. I was hooked even though it was not his best, in my opinion. When I bought We're Only in it for the Money afterwards I was perplexed and didn't understand the record. Played it a few more times and thought (and still do) that it was an absolute masterpiece! Uncle Meat was next, and on and on.... Couldn't get enough. One I've never liked is Absolutely Free although certain parts I love, could never bond with that one. They are all so different and that's really amazing in itself.
Absolutely free Is kind of a bad al un to get you into Zappa, i know that for experiencie
Yup, same, same for No 1 & No 2.
I would place '200 Motels' up there with the best of his work. It has such a range of music on it and would probably be my desert island disc. It is very hard though to choose, and certainly I would not question your other choices at all. His body of work was outstanding.
I'm 48 yp and my first listen when i was twenty ; since i've bought all those ten albumus but my fav is "200 Motels"
Nice list. I always find it hard to rank Zappa albums because his sound constantly evolved throughout his career. At the moment, my fav is You Are What You Is but I enjoy all of his records.
Yeah I agree
@@classicalbum You mention that album getting little airplay or getting banned but the video for the actual song YAWYI in particular caused a stir over it featuring a double of then President Ronald Regan being given the electric chair.
@@classicalbum Also the opening song Teenage Wind was apparently inspired by the song Ride Like The Wind by American Yacht Rocker (if it's OK for me to use that term) Christopher Cross who was an old school friend of bass player Arthur Barrow. I only found out quite recently that Zappa even did a version of that song himself. Which I had no idea about.
I bought Sheik Yerbouti on CD around 1994. I took it home and listened to it in its entirety in a single sitting. I then immediately listened to it again in its entirety. Amazing album. It blew my mind to discover the basic tracks were live recordings. Oh, and the liner notes are hilarious.
Wonder where Bobby Brown is , these days....
@@larryzigler6812 Dead. Probably.
@@mournblade1066 While on the tower of power?
1. Hot rats (top 10 albums of all time easily)
2. One size fits all
3. Joe's garage
4. Overnite sensation
5. Apostrophe
6. The grand wazoo
7. Sheik Yerbouti
8. Waka Jawaka
9. You are what you is
10. The man from utopia
I started picking up Zappa los around 75.
My older brother turned me on to overnight sensation.
I had 45 different LP's before it was over.
And I only scratched the surface. Some were bootlegs.
Freak out is one of my favorites. Zoot Allures.
Live in New York.
Shut up and play your guitar.
Of course apostrophe and overnight sensation.
The bootlegs we're all live European.
Never had cruisin with Ruben and the jets.
Or we're only in it for the money.
The best thing about Zappa, so to speak, is my introduction to captain beefheart.
If someone tells me not to eat any yellow snow I will take it as a philosophical gem I suppose
Pretty fantastic! I may not agree with his rankings (Which I do not.) but his commentary is interesting and that makes him likable. I love to have a conversation with the guy.
If I want to get into an artist that I’m not familiar with, I see if you’ve done a video (like this) and then go from there. Many thanks
I’ve been listening to Absolutely Free a lot recently.
I didn’t really get it earlier at all.
Anything ‘66 to ‘75 will do me
Thank you for your wonderful reviews and ranking of Mr. Zappa's studio recordings . I've been a long time fan of Frank's. I have 24 of his albums. Here are my top tens favorite Frank albums.
1. One Size Fits All
2. Overnite Sensation
3. Burnt Weenie Sandwich
4. Hot Rats
5. Lumpy Gravy
6. Apostrophe
7. The Perfect Stranger
8. We're Only in it For the Money
9. Freak Out
10. Sheik Your Booty
Great list
@@classicalbum Thank you for your comment. Is it safe to assume that this comment came from across the Pond? It's not everyday I receive international messages and comments Lol.
Cool you consider 'You are what you is', it's rarely mentioned in the Zappa classics 👍
I am far from a Zappa fan, in fact I'm quite critical on some of his output, but with this album (and Joe's Garage), Zappa's sense of humour and the music go well together without getting too high-brow arty.
I was just about to write: 'I would have added One size fits all' - and there it suddenly is.
Note to self: watch the whole thing before commenting 😆
Learned quite a bit here. Can’t help but agree with so many of the choices here, however my list would include Lumpy Gravy and the Grand Wazoo which may even be my number 1.
Good critical analysis. I love OSFA too.
My favs in random order:
1) Apostrophe ( ' )
2) One Size Fits All
3) New York
4) Roxy & Elsewhere
5) Make a Jazz Noise
6) The Best Band you Never Heard in Your Life
7) Overnite Sensation.
8) Fillmore 1971 (with FLo & Eddie 😊)
9) Freak Out
10) Tinseltown Rebelion
And since only 10 albums go in a top 10 I make it a top 11, Zoot Allures 😅 with Black Napkins 🤠
Nothing here retracts from the impression of Zappa as a sleazy misanthrope.
"One Size Fits All" is his best album....a beautifully performed, sonically rich and well composed album...
"Uncle Meat" needs a mention.
A very underrated album I think more so than many of his others. Uncle Meat should be notably for King Kong. An epic track which was a staple of many of his live concerts and every version of it was different.
I sincerely hope "Apostrophe" is in there. It's my personal all time favorite. It's the first Zappa I ever heard at 13 years young in 1977.