What Were America's Christmas Monorails?

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 7. 06. 2024
  • Throughout the mid-20th century, shopping centers across the US enjoyed an unusual Christmas tradition: kiddie monorail rides. This short documentary takes a historical look at all of the known rides across the country, and investigates the theories about their manufacturer.
    Chapters:
    0:00 - Intro
    1:30 - Philadelphia, PA (Wanamaker’s)
    2:35 - Chicago, IL (Sears & Roebuck)
    2:49 - Milwaukee, WI (Boston Store)
    3:52 - Baltimore, MD (Stewart's)
    4:32 - Newark, NJ (Kresge-Newark)
    4:55 - Minneapolis, MN (Donaldson’s)
    5:24 - Grand Rapids, MI (Herpolsheimer's)
    6:09 - Manhattan, NY (Wanamaker’s)
    6:25 - Fort Worth, TX (Leonard’s)
    7:01 - Who Built Them?
    8:11 - Lyons, IL (Fairyland Park)
    8:43 - Who Built Them? Cont'd.
    10:01 - Syracuse, NY (Edwards)
    10:49 - Atlanta, GA (Rich’s)
    12:02 - Columbus, GA (Kirven’s)
    12:17 - Nashville, TN (Harveys)
    12:31 - Portland, OR (Meier & Frank)
    13:31 - St. Louis, MO (Stix, Baer & Fuller)
    13:54 - Jennings, MO (Stix, Baer & Fuller)
    14:10 - Pittsburgh, PA (Gimbels)
    14:37 - Pittsburgh, PA (Northway Mall)
    15:32 - Winter Park, FL (Winter Park Mall)
    16:05 - Rochester, NY (Midtown Plaza)
    16:43 - Moorestown, NJ (Moorestown Mall)
    17:06 - Wrapping Up
    This video is for educational purposes and is distributed for non-commercial use. It is not monetized or sponsored. All video footage, images and audio recordings are the property of their original owners and are used in accordance with Fair Use principles. If ads appear on this video, it means a piece of media was copyright-claimed and the ad revenue is being collected by the copyright holder.
    ---------------------------
    Support my work by leaving a tip:
    ko-fi.com/peterdibble
    Please Touch Museum, Philadelphia
    www.pleasetouchmuseum.org/
    Grand Rapids Public Museum
    www.grpm.org/
    Atlanta History Center
    www.atlantahistorycenter.com/
    Oregon Historical Society
    www.ohs.org/
    New York Museum of Transportation
    www.nymtmuseum.org/
    ---------------------------
    Music:
    “Left Bank One” by The Noveltones
    • The Noveltones - Left ...
    “Jingle Bells” by Mantovani
    • Anonymous: Jingle Bells
    “Jumpin' Jiminy Christmas” by Bert Kaempfert
    • Jumpin' Jiminy Christmas
    “Snowbound” by Wayne King & His Orchestra
    • Snowbound
    “Sleigh Ride” by Bert Kaempfert
    • Sleigh Ride
    “Winter Wonderland” by Bert Kaempfert
    • Winter Wonderland
    “White Christmas” by Billy Vaughn
    • White Christmas

Komentáře • 909

  • @peterdibble
    @peterdibble  Před rokem +264

    UPDATES: Viewers have shared verified proof of the following:
    (1) A store in Milwaukee introduced the first Rocket Express ride in 1945, a year earlier than all other sources have claimed. The store itself is not named in the article, but Boston Store is the only one that makes sense for reasons explained in the video. (Found by Shawn Langrick)
    (2) The Wanamaker's ride in Philadelphia was not retired in 1984 as widely believed. There is evidence of it running as late as 1987. (Found by Debbit Vit)
    (3) The Stewart's ride in Baltimore was not retired after a single season in 1946 as previously believed. It returned for a second season in 1947. The anecdote quoted in the video is still applicable since it didn't give a specific time frame. (Found by Fred Shoken & Ed Dobbins)
    Folks have also shared memories of these rides in other locations, but I have not been able to verify these. If more details are uncovered, I will update this comment to make a note of it.

    • @twistoffate4791
      @twistoffate4791 Před rokem +3

      Thank you for the update!!

    • @ablemagawitch
      @ablemagawitch Před rokem +11

      I noticed you had no mention of them being resold to other stores/malls, which when one store/mall removed them, they would have likely sold the package to another mall, shopping center or carnival operator (I'm rewatching the video again to make sure that was a lot of great information to process it all.., really great job tracing down all that information and putting together such a great video...). As the system would have had some value, so few would have possibly been reused. Theme parks do this with rides all the time, sadly to say my local theme park Carowinds sold their (full sized )monorail that when the ridership wasn't enough and they wanted the prime park entrance space for a big roller coaster attraction. The monorails trains and, system and tracks were sold to a resort in city of Mexico. (mid 1990's?) Which when they were taking down the tracks beams, they had taken all the track coming from that direction and the one track section on the left side of a vertical support down and the right side of track was still attached, waiting to be removed. A person driving a rental style "Box" moving van went on the wrong side and the height was not there for the truck. The impact smashed "grandmas' Attic" (the section extended over the cab of the truck) in a good 4-5 feet. As it was made from a light fiberglass and aluminum body verses a steel I beam track. Had they drove on the left side of the asphalt pathway instead of the right they would have been fine. Bad luck timing , a day later the track would have been gone . Just some random history that those of us around saw but sadly isn't documented anywhere. You sure wouldn't have written an article for the local paper or appeared on the local news if you wanted to keep your job....
      The irony of the monorail was when the park was opened in the early 1970's the plan was for the monorail that ran out over the parking lot (one of the issues, they didn't like riders not seeing the parking lot full) and then went out to where a hotel was going to be built at , in a way much like Disney World/Land. The sad irony is about ten years after the tore out the original theme park Monorail ride, their parking lot location had a hotel built right out there. With a detestation Outlet Mall and would have been served well by a monorail running from there into theme park. as the original owner had envisioned way back in the 19650's/1960's, whose family sold off the theme park in the early 1990's and has been in the every changing theme park ownership chains since. Gutting out all the slower family, (senior and/or disabled people friendly rides with low body shock factors), and little kid friendly rides for faster big attraction coasters. Much like Disney you can still see signs of where old buildings and rides were, that have been repurposed . Even where old steam trains used to run around the park, remember when every theme park had steam trains? Knowing where to look you could see where some sections of rails that were just paved over have poked through the asphalt, or the hot asphalt was pressed down even with the rail top from the combination of park vehicles and the summer heat. Revealing some history. Sorry to ramble but you seem like someone that would like old historical trivia few care about and current theme park owners don't want any history out there about it.

    • @williamsteriti2718
      @williamsteriti2718 Před rokem +3

      Thank you for this video I was born in 1959 so it was later than those were made but I still remember being a kid how great everything was those were really the good old days not like now with everything is so corrupt and filthy I thank you for this video it really made me just say wow ♾️✝️🛐♥️ LOL

    • @ivettvelazquez3853
      @ivettvelazquez3853 Před rokem

      So was there any other of these in Florida?

    • @twistoffate4791
      @twistoffate4791 Před rokem

      @@ivettvelazquez3853 Watch the video.

  • @sleeplessstu
    @sleeplessstu Před rokem +428

    Awhile back, I scoured the web looking for photos or information on this iconic Christmas monorail in Portland. It was one of the highlights of Christmas shopping in Portland when I was a kid. It created a magical toy store wonderland for kids back then. I took my son down there almost 30 years ago and it was still in operation back then ….I wish it was still around for my granddaughter. 😢

    • @desmeitit
      @desmeitit Před rokem +19

      They have it on display again at pioneer. It’s out in the open now instead of behind the glass. But yeah it was fun

    • @CapnCody1622
      @CapnCody1622 Před rokem +17

      I was a Portland kid in the 90s. This whole time I thought it was a dream I had seeing a monorail in a department store.

    • @lethrbear32
      @lethrbear32 Před rokem +11

      I rode that same monorail in 1978 and 79. We were living in Longview and left in 1980 after the eruption. It's good to be back though.

    • @pdxaviation
      @pdxaviation Před rokem +9

      So cool seeing one of the cars at Pioneer Place, nice to know at least some of it is being preserved.

    • @101rotarypower
      @101rotarypower Před rokem +1

      Does anyone know the address for the M&F it was located at in Portland?

  • @greghenrikson952
    @greghenrikson952 Před rokem +170

    I got to operate the monorail in around 1989/90 while doing temp work at Meier & Frank. That was during the "Santa Land" era. I would let the kids go around more than once. I remember being surprised that the doors just kind of folded closed and were secured with little wiggly bolts LOL. That whole place was magical and strange. It was about half shut down even at that point, with the 6th floor shut down and others at half speed. We were doing cleanouts of forgotten old features like a deli in the closed basement and a very old pharmacy on the mezzanine. There was a sub-basement that I swear was haunted. I also got to run the old elevators.

    • @Tenderbits
      @Tenderbits Před rokem +7

      I rode that in 1989 as a first grader in Portland. Thanks for the memories!

    • @danityvanityinsanity
      @danityvanityinsanity Před rokem +1

      Wow! What a fun place to work!😃👍✨💖✨

    • @solomonkane102
      @solomonkane102 Před rokem +3

      I ride it in 64 and 65.

    • @ablemagawitch
      @ablemagawitch Před rokem

      Glad you got to see the cool history of what used to be there. Done my fair share of work in spaces, no longer used and and visit others where the staff showed me the history of what was once there. One day getting to go to the store to actual see the merchandise will become popular again. Amazing how people complain about ""other "" people out in pubic, meanwhile the other people are complaining about them being the 'other" annoying people out public, at the same time usually.

    • @ddespair
      @ddespair Před rokem +1

      You might think this guy is old because he operated an elevator but when I was a teen I ran the stairs

  • @michaelhenderson6786
    @michaelhenderson6786 Před rokem +7

    “The gift of childhood nostalgia may be one of the greatest gifts of all”
    Love that! I’m saving that with the rest of my favorite quotes ❤

  • @kenflagg
    @kenflagg Před rokem +168

    I rode the Rochester monorail as a kid and absolutely loved it. At one point it went through a "tunnel" in a "mountain" and it was completely magical.

    • @vibrolax
      @vibrolax Před rokem +12

      My last memory of the Midtown Plaza monorail was seeing it in pieces as Midtown was slowly demolished.

    • @acer3573
      @acer3573 Před rokem +8

      I remember riding it and seeing Santa at Midtown when I was 5-7 (late 70s / early 80s)

    • @christinemcsunshine
      @christinemcsunshine Před rokem +5

      My grandmother had a picture of my brother, sister & myself waiting in line on the stairs at Midtown in Rochester to ride it. I honestly don't remember it though 😒 1974 or 5

    • @ImpressiveCharacterArc
      @ImpressiveCharacterArc Před rokem +3

      When I was in first grade, 1976, they bussed our entire class in at Christmastime to ride the monorail at Midtown.

    • @cuttersgoose
      @cuttersgoose Před rokem +2

      Yes..I forgot about the tunnel..and Santa... great memories of midtown

  • @fredblonder7850
    @fredblonder7850 Před rokem +199

    I’m impressed that they appear to have had a good safety record.

    • @ksevio
      @ksevio Před rokem +34

      Unless there was a large fire or something in the store, seems the worst that would happen is it gets stuck at which point you just need a stick to push it along or a stepladder

    • @ADBBuild
      @ADBBuild Před rokem +61

      Could be because it was based on an industrial grade system that was able to handle a lot more weight and constant use.

    • @JaidenJimenez86
      @JaidenJimenez86 Před rokem +20

      Yeah I'm wondering if perhaps they don't exist anymore due to inability to meet modern safety requirements. I can't imagine such a vehicle being in use nowadays - how would the vehicle be evacuated, is it attended, how does it stop in an emergency? Also, how did kids get in and out... a platform, ladder, or something else?

    • @Shinyarc
      @Shinyarc Před rokem +2

      @@JaidenJimenez86From the looks of it, they climbed in and out

    • @funone8716
      @funone8716 Před rokem +22

      @@JaidenJimenez86 For starters, today you couldn't call it a monorail. It would be required to be identified as a gender neutral rail.

  • @mackpines
    @mackpines Před rokem +206

    I was VERY lucky to experience the monorail at Meier and Frank.
    I went for the first and only time in 2004 when I was 7 years old.
    Probably rode it four or five times. I didn't want to leave!
    This was a great video. I've always been curious about the history of the monorail, who manufactured it and if other places had them.

    • @Reed81315
      @Reed81315 Před rokem +8

      That was the real holiday tradition I looked forward to every year when I was a kid

    • @ltipst2962
      @ltipst2962 Před rokem +9

      What a world dude. America certainly would have been exciting in the mid 20th century. Its always looked on across the pond as the true golden age I think

    • @dougmillerlasvegasrealtylink
      @dougmillerlasvegasrealtylink Před rokem +4

      I rode it se a kid in the 60’s

    • @ericstromberg9608
      @ericstromberg9608 Před rokem +5

      I got to ride it a few times in the mid Sixties! Amazing fun for a small boy!

    • @ronriesinger7755
      @ronriesinger7755 Před rokem +3

      Our daughters rode it every year until it closed. Much sadness at its demise!

  • @jayhuf64
    @jayhuf64 Před rokem +34

    I grew up in Portland and as a kid in the 70's my mom took me to Meier and Frank's every year to ride the monorail and see Santa, it's my favorite childhood Christmas memory. Thanks for the video!

  • @mrMYass
    @mrMYass Před rokem +10

    I rode on the one in Portland Oregon as a kid. It was at a department store called Meyer and franks. They had an entire giant room dedicated to “Santa land” and the was a North Pole themed building inside that had a staircase going up to the monorail. The whole experience of meeting Santa, walking through the prop Santa city, and then riding in the monorail and seeing all the toys was magical as a young kid. Sadly they got bought out by macys in the mid 2000s and then the store closed down.

  • @AverytheCubanAmerican
    @AverytheCubanAmerican Před rokem +26

    It reminds me of the Wuppertal one that started it all. The Wuppertal Schwebebahn in Germany was built as such because Wuppertal is located in a river valley (that's what Wuppertal means; Wupper Valley), and because of steep slopes, the original towns that now makes up Wuppertal expanded lengthwise (resulting in the thin shape of Wuppertal today). It wasn't suitable to build a tram nor an underground subway, so as a way to both unify the valley and find a place for transit to solve congestion, they built a suspended monorail that followed the Wupper River.

  • @dreadpenguinlord340
    @dreadpenguinlord340 Před rokem +5

    Neat! I think about monorails all the time... but then I do have a one track mind.

  • @deliawolfe
    @deliawolfe Před rokem +54

    The Grand Rapids Monorail was a feature of the Herpolsheimer's Department Store basement Toyland. The store itself was a mid-century modern structure built in the post war era. Provision for the monorail were incorporated into the design. In 1984, a large urban development called The City Center utilized a neighboring building owned by Gantos, a Michigan-based womens' specialty shop and the Department Store, which was remodeled into a smaller floorplan.. A multilevel indoor mall was built in the former (historic) buildings. It was designed by Daverman Associates and built by Dan Voss Construction Company. Using funds from the recent sale of Herpolsheimer's to Allied Stores and Historic Preservation Funds, the monorail was recommissioned and moved to the basement level of the City Center multilevel mall, where it operated during the Christmas Holiday Season in 1984 and possibly 1985. While the City Center Project opened to much fanfare and the monorail revived childhood memories of the glory days of locally-owned, department stores, the concept failed to revive interest in shopping downtown. Traffic was below expectations after the initial rush, and smaller shops, including Gantos, abandoned their leases. The entire project closed down and The Allied Store chain collapsed in the late 1980s. The Herpolsheimer's building was eventually purchased by the city and renovated into the Grand Rapids Police Department. But the Baby-Boomers who rode the monorail in the 1950s never lost their love for it, and sharing their memories Donating it to the Grand Rapids Public Museum and displaying it during the Holidays may be the only way to honor its history and magic..

    • @jonathanzobel1662
      @jonathanzobel1662 Před rokem +7

      This store was mentioned by name in the Polar Express movie.

    • @deliawolfe
      @deliawolfe Před rokem +10

      @@jonathanzobel1662 Chris Van Allsburg, the illustrator and author of the book, "The Polar Express" is from East Grand Rapids, Michigan.

    • @xr3dcrunkx
      @xr3dcrunkx Před rokem +2

      I live in Grand Rapids and was hoping someone would give more details on this. Thank you!

    • @sigsin1
      @sigsin1 Před rokem +2

      I was just going to write about this being one of my absolute favorite things at Christmas!!! I couldn’t remember if it was Herpolsheimer’s or Wurzburg’s.
      The last year I rode it was 1968.

    • @gillano
      @gillano Před rokem +3

      I rode the monorail at City Center as a kid in the late 80s, I don't remember it being only open during the holiday season, but maybe it was. It was still there when it became Mackies World a mall just for kids in the 90s I was too old to ride but I remember it running at this time. Also fun fact on Herpolshimers, the display window was the worlds largest when built, the glass is still there at the GRPD

  • @BrokenBuffer
    @BrokenBuffer Před rokem +42

    My dad told me about the monorail at the old midtown mall in Rochester NY that went through a large mountain called Magic Mountain, there was a Santa’s workshop inside and then you could meet Santa.

    • @coln84
      @coln84 Před rokem +7

      I remember this as a child. Eventually magic mountain disappeared but the monorail hung around for a little bit

    • @markcantemail8018
      @markcantemail8018 Před rokem +4

      Spendall . Midtown Santa , Mcurdy,'s Santa , Edward's Santa , B Foreman's Santa and cross Main Street to Sibley's Santa . It was possible to visit all 5 walking from one spot .

  • @ridetotheright1
    @ridetotheright1 Před rokem +3

    You may have resolved a mystery of my life. As a child who lived in Florissant, MO, I recall a Santa themed train ride that me and my sister took once. For some reason, without ever asking my parents, I thought it may have been a ride from when we visited London or perhaps a dream I had when I was a child. More than likely, it was one of the two monorail trains that were in the St. Louis area. Now, I will ask my mom today.

    • @lizkrinsky5209
      @lizkrinsky5209 Před 5 měsíci

      You probably rode the one at River Roads Mall in Jennings. I remember it well... one of my favorite Christmas memories.

  • @NostalgicNell
    @NostalgicNell Před rokem +22

    The monorail ride in Portland is still a vivid memory to this day. I LOVED going up the escalators of M&F 12 or so floor to the top floor to go for a ride.

  • @Frankjc3rd
    @Frankjc3rd Před rokem +2

    I remember riding the train in the Philadelphia Wanamakers when I was a kid. I always thought it was a different store other than Wanamakers but I can live with that.

  • @crusinscamp
    @crusinscamp Před rokem +9

    Ah, so it was Wanamaker's in Philadelphia! I have a fuzzy little snippet of memory riding one of these monorails in Philadelphia in the, say, early/mid-1960s. Dad use to take a day off from work before Christmas and our family would go down to the city; Wanamaker's, Gimbel's, Lit Brother's. There's be the train ride to the city, shopping, a nice lunch, a visit to The Christmas Village, and a weary trip by train back home.. It was a special day in the big city. Thanks for sparking the memories.

  • @fmgough
    @fmgough Před rokem +3

    So many memories riding the monorail as a kid in Rochester, NY at Midtown Plaza. Going to meet with the Big Guy at Christmas time. Sibley's, McCurdy's, The World Clock, brass trombone kazoos, trains, toys...man Christmas time in the ROC was awesome.

  • @thomasgraf1986
    @thomasgraf1986 Před rokem +100

    Very strong memories of the Portland monorail in the early to mid 90s as a kid. I remember having to ascend a series of escalators that got narrower and narrower for what seemed like forever before it opened up to a mystical winter wonderland with the monorail making its rounds. At one point the train went through a dark tunnel that had glow in the dark stars and planets painted on it. So very magical!

    • @Foxy02016
      @Foxy02016 Před rokem +2

      It got narrower and narrower as it slowly funneled out the adults

    • @paulm.newitt3246
      @paulm.newitt3246 Před rokem +4

      You brought back memories of me also there in 1960 as a little kid. It was cool, kinda cramped, but you jarred my memory about the smaller escalators!

    • @SpaceTimeManipulatorSTM
      @SpaceTimeManipulatorSTM Před rokem

      The whole atmosphere at the time must have been kinda creepy cause all of my memories of the time and place are more like bordering on nightmares.

    • @mjay4700
      @mjay4700 Před rokem +2

      Yes! The narrow escalators. I'm glad someone remembers that place/time so vividly. I too rode those escalators up to the Christmas/Santa Land with all the decorations, monorail, santa, etc. I can almost recall the smell of the store.

    • @drscopeify
      @drscopeify Před rokem

      ​@@mjay4700 It must be the same narrow old escalators as in the Macy's store in downtown Seattle (previously The Bon Marché store) it closed in 2020 but all of the floors I forget how man were all open back in the 2010s and I went riding up and down with my friends shopping it was a trip continuously going up and down them, pretty funny experience.

  • @PendragonDaGreat
    @PendragonDaGreat Před rokem +8

    For some helpful perspective because inflation is a thing:
    a 10 cent monorail ride in 1950 would cost just about $1.25 in 2022. That $6 doll at 5:15 would be about $75 today.

    • @Sashazur
      @Sashazur Před rokem +2

      So the monorail was an affordable thing for almost anybody, but that baby doll was a fancy present for a spoiled kid!

  • @roboftherock
    @roboftherock Před rokem +50

    That was a comprehensive compendium of child-carrying conveyances. You did a very nice job collating all those separate reports and handbills. Well done, sir.

    • @greglivo
      @greglivo Před rokem +4

      A magnificent memorial of miniature monorails

  • @steamgent4592
    @steamgent4592 Před rokem +5

    I rode those in John Wanamakers in Toyland in Philadelphia! Love those memories. It still exists in Philadelphias Please Touch Museum a kids museum. Sadly when Macy's bought the Wanamaker building it and the Crystal Room restaurant closed. All the kool stuff just about is gone now. But at least the Christmas organ light show goes on.

  • @carlkwasnjuk9518
    @carlkwasnjuk9518 Před rokem +5

    I was born in Philadelphia in 1967. All through my childhood my parents would take me and my siblings to John Wanamaker department store in center city Philadelphia ever year at Christmas Time. I don't remember paying for the monorail ride. I just remember riding it over and over again as my parents shopped and I would be looking to try to see what my parents might be buying me for Christmas. Wonderful memories. My wife and I started having kids in the late 1990's and I remember taking them to the Please Touch Museum. We have pictures of them sitting in the restored but stationary Monorail at this museum. Thank you for this video.

  • @denisearmbruster7478
    @denisearmbruster7478 Před rokem +27

    As a little girl, I lived in Atlanta, Georgia and rode on "The Pink Pig" in Rich's located in Downtown Atlanta. I remember that it ran all year long. During Christmas, Rich's would decorate it. I remember that was in the early 60's. I have very fond memories of those days. Thank You for this wonderful video!🐖🐷❤❤

    • @dT6E7hmja4iXjsJw
      @dT6E7hmja4iXjsJw Před rokem +7

      Me too! (Except little boy, not little girl.) I was 4 or 5 years old in Atlanta, so that would have been 1964-ish.

    • @highnoon9333
      @highnoon9333 Před rokem +4

      I used to work at the Atlanta History Center and we had one of the Pink Pig cars on display for years (not sure if it's still there and I moved out of state so I can't check)
      Edit: I'm an idiot. I should've watched the video before commenting haha!

    • @ablemagawitch
      @ablemagawitch Před rokem +1

      Did you get to go to Sid and Marty Kroft (sp?) land? Inside of one the malls if I have the history right. My parents made sure we didn't hear about as kids, as we would have wanted the family vacation to go to that , and not the beach which the parents preferred.

    • @CraigJones-gu2ye
      @CraigJones-gu2ye Před rokem +3

      @@ablemagawitch Sid & Marty Kroft was at the Omni, now CNN center in downtown.

    • @CraigJones-gu2ye
      @CraigJones-gu2ye Před rokem +2

      I remember the Pink Pig. I think it was moved to Lenox Square mall after the downtown store closed. I don't know what happened after Macey's bought out Rich's.

  • @AverytheCubanAmerican
    @AverytheCubanAmerican Před rokem +28

    Suspended monorails are most definitely my favorite kind of monorail. It's a neat concept, and it's easy to see why department stores knew families would enjoy them. Unfortunately not many of these suspended monorails exist. The majority of them are in Germany and Japan (Japan even built two in zoos, but they're both closed), though China is looking into building them in their cities with one in Chengdu that just opened in 2021. Memphis is the only city in North America that has one, but it hasn't operated since 2018 due to low ridership, leaving the monorail's future in jeopardy

    • @ablemagawitch
      @ablemagawitch Před rokem

      Wait to you learn about "Gyro Monorails" One track and the car rides on top. Which stays upright due to spinning gyro in the car. Amazing Tech that didn't catch on but was an interesting branch off .

    • @christianfreedom-seeker934
      @christianfreedom-seeker934 Před rokem +1

      I think safety issues is the main reason for the failure of suspended monorail. The problem is children these days are too spazzed out to sit quietly in such a conveyance.

    • @ablemagawitch
      @ablemagawitch Před rokem +1

      @@christianfreedom-seeker934 The problem isn't "children today being spazzed", in the video it clearly explains that "Boomer Generation" children required the operators to have install screens over the window because they were throwing pennies and spitting loogies(Lugies?) at the shoppers below. The were ruined and had shoppers annoyed from 1950's and 1960's kids long before the kids of today even got a chance to ride them.
      Worse, they are dying form of amusement, just train rides in Amusement Theme Parks. Kids need more stimulation and are not as easily amused. Besides if they want to see what it like to fly above the heads, go around the room , ride any object or device they only need turn on their electronic tablet. These monorails just trains just do not draw people to justify their costs. That includes operation, maintenance, the labor to set them up and take them down and storage costs , with possible shipping costs. Are you taking your kids to the more or store to go ride? You may remember all the 25 cent amusement rides outside of stores, where did they all go? They didn't make money because the Boomer kids in the photos didn't put money into them for kids to ride them, not enough time for the kid to ride it, you not paying a quarter for X amount of minutes.... They live without it and so these amusement devices went away. Boomers screwing up for every generation after them....All why complaining about how they were discriminated against by older generations when they were younger.
      These monorails are sadly like electric train sets, this just isn't market for them. Stores don't sell them, even Toys-R-Us didn't stock model trains stuff before they shut down. Minus the "Thomas The Tank Engine" plastic playsets, which kids out grow when they out grow thomas, there are not toysets for them. The companies chose to go after the 50+ market for the higher disposable income amounts where they could charge more. Which has left Trains costing a lot, with the market for them shrinking as the generation that grew up with them is dying off. Sadly there isn't a lot of youth influx into the hobby, model rocketry and R/C (both Remote and Radio Controlled with gas engines) planes have equally shared said fate.
      Which isn't the kids fault. They're no more "spazzy" than younger kids and if they are today, they are likely put on medication. Something that didn't happen to Boomer kids that had these rides then decided not to pay the ride costs for their kids all in the value(more of false claim) for teaching the value of money or some shit.....
      The seat up was actually fairly stable it would take a carload of combine coordination to generate enough force to make the suspended car even start to have issues or the upright support base plates on the ground. This basic under hung track dolly carriage system is in use in numerous other industries.

    • @stephenkeever6029
      @stephenkeever6029 Před 5 měsíci

      Other than Wanamaker's, the Philadelphia Zoo had a monorail from 1969-2001. However it was not a suspended monorail. Avery, always fun to catch your comments!

  • @bradfordfermin4688
    @bradfordfermin4688 Před rokem +10

    I hope this doesn’t come across as rude, but I am in awe of your sub count. Found your channel a few days ago, and just finished binging every video you’ve put out. You have a remarkable knack for taking seemingly mundane topics and generating some of the most captivating content out of them. I genuinely get sad when each and every video ends, wishing for more. This comment gets thrown around a lot on CZcams, but you GENUINELY deserve millions of subs for the level of storytelling you consistently put out. I feel privileged to have found this channel before so many others. Keep up the world-class work 🙏

  • @yansatoussaint2266
    @yansatoussaint2266 Před rokem +4

    I lived in St.Louis from 1964-1974 and remember riding the monorail called the Gumdrop Express at the River Roads Mall in Jennings,Mo. The Gumdrop Express was located in the JC Penny toystore and you had to go through the back door and up some metal stairs to board the train. Wonderful memories of my childhood in St.Louis. Thanks for this video!

    • @kentonkloos3490
      @kentonkloos3490 Před rokem +1

      Hi Yansa, I too rode the one in Jennings..tons of fun. I don't remember the other one in St . Louis, did you ever ride it?

    • @lizkrinsky5209
      @lizkrinsky5209 Před 5 měsíci +1

      It was in the you department at Stix Baer and Fuller. At one point it even had the mod 60s style Christmas Angel on the front that were used on their Christmas boxes that year. I think the next year it became The Gum Drop Express. What a great mall it was back in the day: and that huge WoolWorth's

  • @kristiewisniewski9704
    @kristiewisniewski9704 Před rokem +3

    My Great Grandmother use to take me to the one at Wannamakers in Philadelphia. Such a great Childhood memory!

  • @maxsmodels
    @maxsmodels Před rokem +4

    A great trip in the way-back machine. Thank you sir.

  • @markcantemail8018
    @markcantemail8018 Před rokem +6

    Midtown Monorail was ours in Rochester , N.Y . I took a very young Nephew to Ride it before they took it apart , so he could have the Memory . I was up set that they would not let me ride , a Large Adult . So many Decades of Fun for the Family . We would go Downtown for Xmas shopping all day . If you played your Cards right you could visit 5 Santas in one Day .

  • @richekay
    @richekay Před rokem +2

    I remember riding the Rocket Express in the early 1960s at Wanamaker's in Philly. What a wonderful, magical memory. Thanks for the flashback.

  • @christophertstone
    @christophertstone Před rokem +6

    5:50 That's me in the front of the train, two of my sisters in the second row. Would have been about 1989.

  • @taylorward3773
    @taylorward3773 Před rokem +38

    Wow this brought me back to my childhood! Used to visit Santaland in Meier & Frank every year as a kid, my family always wanted me to go on the little monorail but I was so scared lol Finally went and did it one year and I've never forgotten it!

    • @mackpines
      @mackpines Před rokem +5

      I think a lot of us were a little nervous the first time riding it. I certainly was but, you were with others your own age and once you were moving and able to look down and wave at everyone that's what made it a memorable experience.

  • @nancylaino712
    @nancylaino712 Před rokem +7

    I remember the monorail in Wanamakers in Philadelphia very well. It was always one of the highlights of the Christmas season for me and later on, my kids. We still remember fondly the monorail and the iconic Christmas light show at Wanamers. Great memories!

  • @thelostborough5214
    @thelostborough5214 Před rokem +17

    There are pics of me on the Midtown one, and I remember seeing it at the mall, but I cannot for the life of me remember the experience of riding one. Still a unique part of Rochester's Holiday traditions. Awesome to see the monorail lives in at the NYMT and occasionally at the Roc Holiday Village.

  • @pacnwsupra
    @pacnwsupra Před rokem +8

    I rode the Meier & Frank monorail a few times in the 70s. Fast forward to 1991 and I made my way back up to Santa Land with some friends after work one evening. Being a weekday, the place was deserted. I somehow convinced the crew to let me ride again even though I was significantly taller. With no kids in line, I came in under the weight limit and so it was a go. Imagine trying to cram my 6'4" frame into that tiny space. We got the door closed and off I went. The discomfort was totally worth it as the train went along the route and I got to look down on my friends below.

    • @LymanPhillips
      @LymanPhillips Před rokem

      That's outstanding. I would have done the same myself. I hope you took pictures. Did they have to rub you with butter and use a shoehorn to get you in and out?

  • @AFoxGuy
    @AFoxGuy Před rokem +23

    Boys, a new Peter Dibble Video has Arrived!

  • @raydunakin
    @raydunakin Před rokem +4

    This was fascinating! I've never heard of these before. I was pleasantly surprised to hear that at least two of them lasted into the 21st century.

    • @dougmarsh9074
      @dougmarsh9074 Před rokem

      The Meier and Frank 'rail would likely be running today if Macy's had not shut down the store and ended generations of happy family memories.

  • @modelermark172
    @modelermark172 Před rokem +7

    I'm 63, and I have memories of riding the one at Stix, Baer & Fuller in St. Louis, MO (shown at 13:32) in 1966 shortly after I turned seven. I hadn't thought about this in decades! Thanks for doing all the research, and posting this!

    • @calessel3139
      @calessel3139 Před rokem +1

      That interesting. I'm 56 and grew up in West County during the 1970s. Unfortunately I don't remember a monorail at any Stix Baer & Fuller department stores in the St Louis area. But our family only visited West County Mall, South County, Crestwood, & North West Plaza. So I'm guessing either it wasn't installed at any of these locations or that it had been taken down by the 1970s.

    • @modelermark172
      @modelermark172 Před rokem +1

      @@calessel3139 I don't remember exactly where it was located; only that I had memories of riding a monorail in a department store. I do remember that it wasn't at a shopping mall - those were a few more years down the road. I also remember that we went "downtown" for the ride, so it was probably the huge SBF store on Washington Avenue. The ride may have been there before or even after I rode it, but we never went back any other year, so I don't know when it was taken down for good. I'm sorry you never got the chance to ride the SBF monorail.
      I've always liked transportation, and most of my memories were of visiting the National Museum of Transportation on Barrett Station Road in Kirkwood. And whenever we went to the Zoo; I was mainly interested in riding the narrow-gauge Zooline Railroad, which opened when I was about three years old. Also, earlier the same year my mom and dad took me to ride the monorail, my dad took me for a ride on the Hodiamont streetcar the last day it ran in May of 1966. I literally caught the end of an era . . . .

    • @calessel3139
      @calessel3139 Před rokem

      @@modelermark172 I loved the Transportation Museum too!! We actually lived only a few miles west from Barret Station Road, so I was constantly dragging my poor dad over there on the weekends! 😆 And of course I also loved the train at the zoo (along with the animals). Yeah, it a bit sad that I missed the monorail but it's actually pretty cool to learn that at least we had one!

    • @modelermark172
      @modelermark172 Před rokem +1

      @@calessel3139 I took my own son there a few times, (once we were lucky enough to see the docents start up the Chrysler Turbine car,) and he rang the bell on the Big Boy. After decades of that bell being rung by generations of kids, the rope actually cut a slit in the metal of the cabin! One day, I hope to take my grandkids to do the same.
      I also remember that when I was nine, my mom and my aunts took me to Union Station for a ride on an actual, standard gauge passenger train pulled by a diesel locomotive. Good times!

    • @calessel3139
      @calessel3139 Před rokem

      @@modelermark172 👍

  • @jakeearley3842
    @jakeearley3842 Před rokem +2

    Rode this at Kresge's Newark NJ store in the early 1950's. Even more exciting for me was when I was allowed to ride the wooden escalators by myself, all the way to the top floor and back! Simple pleasures!

  • @StLouis-yu9iz
    @StLouis-yu9iz Před rokem +12

    One of the four you were unable to identify was at Famous-Barr department store here in StL. This WAS the first in the Midwest
    When it was replaced they sold the older one to Stix Baer & Fuller (so they weren’t totally lying ;)

    • @The2Flyboys
      @The2Flyboys Před rokem +5

      @@StLouis-yu9iz Hello; life-long St. Louisan here, raised in the 60s. Do you know if the monorail at Famous Barr operated year 'round? If memory serves, there were no Christmas decorations up the only time I rode one, probably in '66. The store wasn't at all crowded that evening - perhaps due to either the time of day, or more and more shopping being done in the suburbs - and I was the only kid on the ride. I also remembering hearing the distinctive march-like tune played on the PA when it was time for the store to close. I've been fascinated by anything that moves people since I was about 4 years old, and remember how excited I was just to see that monorail, let alone ride it.

    • @peterdibble
      @peterdibble  Před rokem +1

      Thanks for sharing, do you know where I can find more information to help verify these rides?

    • @StLouis-yu9iz
      @StLouis-yu9iz Před rokem +1

      @@peterdibble Hey Peter; I love your channel!
      I deleted my comment about Scruggs, Vandervoort, & Barney because that one was just from blogs with no sources so I am not sure if it was true. The one at Famous Barr I learned about through a St. Louis Globe Democrat (a once prominent but now defunct newspaper) article in my local library. If you search for it online there is a picture on Pintrest that comes up easily.
      Would love to see more great videos on rail transit :] I know you like the transit of the more unique variety, but maybe sometime you could do a video on historic trolley networks in general. The Lou's historic streetcar system would be a great way to cover this topic. After all, the 'Trolley Song' is from Meet me in St. Louis, a 'Streetcar Named Desire' was written and based on a trolley line in St. Louis, and the 1944 World Series between the StL Browns and StL Cardinals is known as the Streetcar Series because of how extensive the network was. Plus, there has been a new heritage style one constructed recently (a fascinating topic itself) called the Loop Trolley if you wanted to discuss the resurgence of streetcars in this potential video.
      Just some ideas for future content.
      Thank you for creating such high quality and interesting content and replying to my comment!

    • @StLouis-yu9iz
      @StLouis-yu9iz Před rokem

      @@The2Flyboys Thank you for sharing! :] I believe it only ran in December. I share your passion for transit (especially rail). Have you heard about the project to overhaul every station on the Metro and hopefully they will approve the plan for the new North/South line soon! Also make sure to check out the Loop Trolley when it starts up again next Spring if you havent had a chance to yet! :]

    • @peterdibble
      @peterdibble  Před rokem +2

      @@StLouis-yu9iz Thank you! I'll write down those suggestions and look into that. There's a few rail/transit topics I would like to cover in future videos. :)

  • @jamesgreen451
    @jamesgreen451 Před rokem +8

    I rode the monorail in Wanamaker in Philadelphia. I was 5 or 6 and was amazed with toys and people. This had to be in 1964 or 1965 and Christmas shopping in Philadelphia was an adventure. I also remember the moving figures in Lits windows. Too bad it all gone now.

  • @dudeabides1532
    @dudeabides1532 Před rokem +4

    I also grew up in the Portland area. I remember riding the monorail at Meier and Frank downtown almost every year as a kid in the 80's. As far as the actual monorail cars themselves, I remember that they were built for child-sized riders. Adults couldn't fit inside. Good memories. Thanks for the video.

  • @memathews
    @memathews Před rokem +2

    Christmas 1959 was my first ride on the Rocket Express at Meier & Frank in Portland Oregon. Our family had just moved up from California and we were shopping in downtown when we visited Santaland for the first time, the first of many monorail trips. My wife remembers her rides on the monorail and we took our children to ride the monorail in the mid-1990s. Sadly, Santaland and then monorail were disbanded once M&F was sold to the May Company and eventually renamed to Macy's. Great memories now renewed through your video, thanks!

  • @davidwayneprins
    @davidwayneprins Před rokem +3

    I remember riding the one at Herpolshimer's in Grand Rapids, Michigan when it had the train theme. In the mid 1980s, Herpolshimer's and a neighboring department store (whose name I forget as it had gone defunct by this time) were combined to form a four story (plus basement) shopping mall in downtown called City Centre (using the French spelling). The City Centre monorail ran around the basement which was a food court.
    The mall was a flop almost right away. Herpolshimer's was later purchased by Lazarus and when Lazarus went bankrupt and closed this store, many other stores terminated their leases based on a "there will be an anchor store" clause. A children's themed mall called Mackey's World then opened (thus the dinosaur theme). It only lasted a few years.
    The building is now the Grand Rapids Police Department. GRPD donated the monorail to the GRPM.

    • @johnsulaski2962
      @johnsulaski2962 Před rokem +1

      I believe for a very short time in the 1990's that this location was operated as Steketee's department store and the train (while possibly not operational) was still located there and hanging from the monorail. Also, I believe there was talk/discussion of what to do with the train and eventually it was decided it would be donated to the Grand Rapids Public Museum - as in the early 2000's expanded from east of the Grand River to west of the Grand River. I have visited it a few times at GRPM.

  • @jhonezcronic
    @jhonezcronic Před rokem +4

    My Aunt took me to the Wanamaker one EVERY DECEMBER we rode the train downtown... ate pancakes with the Fat Red Suited man.... and i rode that monorail.... well into the mid
    80's

  • @WesternOhioInterurbanHistory

    The fact that so many were preserved makes me very happy. I love the art-deco look, blimp tail, and windows similar to the GM New Look buses.

  • @craigtiano3455
    @craigtiano3455 Před rokem +5

    I rode that Monorail at Wannamaker's in Philadelphia as a child. Wannamaker's also had an incredible pipe organ and a light show in the grand atrium for Christmas.
    Gimbels, down the street, had a little train that rode through a small village of houses festooned with all the things children would want for Christmas. It was a traditional 12" gauge electric rail, not a monorail.

    • @ameyring
      @ameyring Před 10 měsíci

      Philadelphia is very fortunate that the monorail was kept on display at both the old and new Please Touch Museums for kids to climb into.

  • @keybyss98
    @keybyss98 Před rokem +23

    I’m generally happy with growing up in the 2000’s, but sometimes I find some of the “kiddie stuff” of the mid 40’s-60’s to be so frickin’ cool to the point of creating jealousy to mini me. 😩
    We had kid-sized shopping carts (“Just like the grown ups!”) and these little plastic “car” add-ons to shopping carts that kids could ride on while the parents shopped, so it was kinda fun, but this would’ve been the cherry on top for my childhood shopping experience!

    • @REDARROW_A_Personal
      @REDARROW_A_Personal Před rokem +5

      I know the feeling. As someone who was growing up in the late 90s through early 2000s in the UK there used to be so meny cool toys for kids. I remember getting the Argus Catalogue as a kid a circling what I was hoping to get on Christmas. Now days I still go into Toy Stores and I just find there not being that much variety. The last store that really had that was Toys R Us, which since having gone bankrupt and restarted has also cut down on variety. I miss a lot of the cheep toy companies such as Realtoy and New-ray. Got some really nice stuff from the despite it was cheep.

    • @REDARROW_A_Personal
      @REDARROW_A_Personal Před rokem +2

      I also used to remember the Kids Shopping Carts. I never really used them as my mom let me push the main cart, but everything was diffrent and more fun back then.

    • @mfbfreak
      @mfbfreak Před rokem +1

      In the 2000s, some garden centres had little christmas trains in their shops in the Netherlands. Pretty small, but same idea.

    • @audreyholmes9751
      @audreyholmes9751 Před rokem +1

      Yeah my store that I work at had those shopping cars with the wheels in them...store had to hide em cause people kept stealing them

  • @alexclement7221
    @alexclement7221 Před rokem +10

    Rochester Monorail: You called it a "permanent addition" to the Midtown Plaza, but it wasn't permanent. If you look at the picture at 17:31, you can see that the uprights which held the track were just standing there, unmounted. I assume a few of them were mounted in some way temporarily, but the entire thing was packed up and put into storage shortly after New Year's Day, and wasn't set up again until just after Thanksgiving.

    • @jasonchilders9819
      @jasonchilders9819 Před rokem +2

      Compared to the other stores and malls, Midtown's was permanent in that is was there until the mall closed in 2007, instead of being there for a couple of seasons, IMHO.

  • @vaughnvdg
    @vaughnvdg Před rokem +3

    In Philly the monorail was on the 8th floor of John Wanamaker….I remember riding on those slow escalators anxious to get up there in the 70s…great memories…..REAL CHRISTMAS

  • @Redman_O-Gauge_and_Tech_Stuff

    I remember the Philadelphia Wanamaker installation. That, the light show and the gigantic brass pigeon are all. solid memories of when I was 4 or 5. 71 / 72. And seeing Santa there of course.

  • @brentahrend3845
    @brentahrend3845 Před rokem +4

    I remember riding the Meier & Frank monorail in Portland, Oregon during the late 90's/early 2000's. I had no idea how lucky I'd be as one of the last generations to ride it! I remember the glowing star tunnel and Christmas scenes only visible from the ride. It must have been unique from the other monorails that seemed to only ride above toy displays. Santa Land was a whole floor of the building dedicated to a Christmas village display, with Santa photo ops, animatronic reindeer, and the monorail. It was truly a magical place.

  • @viperchrisz4
    @viperchrisz4 Před rokem +16

    Recently I started remembering going on one of these and decided to look them up. I spent years thinking it was just a childhood fever dream I had and was really happy to find out it was actually real and I went to the one in Portland as a kid 😊

  • @SupremeLeaderKimJong-un
    @SupremeLeaderKimJong-un Před rokem +9

    While Newark may no longer have a department store monorail, it still has their streetcar/light rail system. Also known as the Newark City Subway, the original system opened in 1935. The line expanded to Newark Penn Station in 1937. The system used PCC streetcars up until 2001, when they were finally replaced by a light rail built by Kinki Sharyo (who has manufactured Shinkansens).
    The line expanded again in 2002, with new stations at Silver Lake and Grove Street. Finally, a new line was completed in 2006 that connects Newark Penn Station with Newark Broad Street, the two major NJT commuter rail stations of Newark, built as the first phase of the Newark-Elizabeth Rail Link (which remains proposed).

    • @bertdellaluna5612
      @bertdellaluna5612 Před rokem

      For years I rode the Newark City Subway starting at the old terminus with the very funny turn behind Kielbs Bakery on Franklin Avenue at the Belleville / Newark line. I would park in the free parking lot across from Stephen Crane Village and walk the two blocks to the station. As an adult I would ride to Broad Street, cross Military Park to my job on Park Place by the old Public Service building that had a mannequin of Ready Kilowatt in one of the windows.I rode the old subway cars thru Branch Brook Park for many years and now I have ridden the new light rail a few times. It's just not the same.

  • @davidconnell1959
    @davidconnell1959 Před rokem +3

    I was probably in my thirties before I realized that the point of the monorail at Wanamaker’s (where my grandmother was an accountant) was to get the five of us kids off our mother’s hands while she did the Christmas shopping. Between waiting in an endless winding line, taking the ride, and going around another bunch of times, she had hours with all of her kids happy and out of her hair!
    Christmas and Wanamaker’s makes you a Philadelphian, if you were born in the 50s or 60s.

  • @gobbletegook
    @gobbletegook Před rokem +4

    What a great piece--and a trip down memory lane! As a kid, we rode the ROCKET EXPRESS at the Milwaukee BOSTON STORE (Closed in 2018, Bon -Ton Bankruptcy). The last year was 1968 or 1969 that I know of for the monorail operation. There wasn't one at GIMBELS...I don't know why people keep "thinking" that. It cost 25 cents to ride...and they had a "Secret Santa Gift Shop where kids (under the age of 12) could shop for small little gifts (think sample size) for Christmas as well. Years later, I worked at the Downtown store that it was located in, and the I BEAM that it rode on was still attached to the ceiling.

    • @petercrowl9467
      @petercrowl9467 Před rokem +1

      While I, who was a child in Milwaukee from 1952 through let's say 1960, have no recollection of a monorail there. I do recall "Secret Santa" though. It was, IIRC, a way for children to buy gifts for parents and such who were there at the store with them. Generic gifty stuff like wallets and such.

    • @gobbletegook
      @gobbletegook Před rokem

      @@petercrowl9467 And of course, small bottles of things like ENGLISH LEATHER, BRUT, and HAI KARETE! The bottles were exact replicas, even down to the wooden cap that ENGLISH LEATHER had...just in miniature! Good times!

  • @islanduck
    @islanduck Před rokem +3

    This is another gem by Peter!

  • @pauldavis1943
    @pauldavis1943 Před rokem +2

    I remember taking my son to the Portland monorail in the late 90"s Thanks for the video!

  • @mjay4700
    @mjay4700 Před rokem +2

    We rode the Portland, OR Meier & Frank Christmas train back when I was a kid in the 1990's. It was magical and I too have that "I often think I dreamed or imagined it" feeling. It's a core part of my "fleeting glimpse of childhood memories" that often comes with nostalgia.

  • @DannyGibes
    @DannyGibes Před rokem +4

    I grew up in the Milwaukee area and remember riding the Boston Store monorail so it must have kept going into the early 1970's. I was born in 1968. My mom took us to Breakfast with Santa and then we rode the monorail looking down over the toy department. God I wish somewhere there was a picture of it!

    • @kickthesky
      @kickthesky Před rokem +1

      I was born the same year and remember riding it as a young boy in the early 70s. It had to be after 1972 because we weren't in the area until then. I kept thinking it was at Gimbels, but like the guy in the video said, it could just be me mixing things up. Gimbels just had the best Christmas everything back then, so it is easy to associate all of the cool Christmas stuff in Milwaukee to that one store.

  • @oregonumc1202
    @oregonumc1202 Před rokem +3

    I rode the Herpolsheimers one in the mid 50's in Grand Rapids, MI . . . we lived in Muskegon about an hour's drive west of there, but each Christmas season we would make the pilgrimage to the toy department there and I'd get to ride above the Lionel train displays . . . all those orange and blue boxes . . . so many sweet dreams! :)

  • @maureenmccann9002
    @maureenmccann9002 Před rokem +1

    I grew up in Rochester NY and I remember riding the monorail the first year it opened. Both my boys rode it too when they were older. A fond member of a place was so magical at Christmas time.

  • @whereisthedollar
    @whereisthedollar Před rokem +1

    Ahh, this was great. Times were good for kids back then. Before cell phones, FB and social media. A Kid had to use his/her imagination. Brings back memories and the count down of days too Christmas Day.

  • @ACE324MINER
    @ACE324MINER Před rokem +8

    My uncle used to run the monorail at wanamakers, according to him the monorails were very overbuilt for what they were, he reckons they could easily carry the weight of a pickup truck and run with no issue, another thing he mentioned was how loud these things were, they ran on 48 volts DC, and could be heard running throughout the building but aside from that they were very simple and reliable, wonderful to see how much effort you put into this

    • @mysteriesoftherealm
      @mysteriesoftherealm Před rokem

      I think this is old world technazmia repurposed and these building weren't malls originally, the story of them has been re-written and sold to us as kiddy rides, and that's why there is confusion about where they came from.
      How come there are no pictures of them being built into the mall?
      who were the crews? This is a major operation .
      If the narrative is true, we would have comments on this video from the huge construction crews that it would take to do this in so many location around the country.
      Why have the workers and the history vanished? business doesn't work that way, lets be logical.
      The news or newspaper didn't want to interview the builder and crews of such an awesome idea?
      Doesn't add up.
      The companies didn't want press coverage for an amazing product? I don't buy that at all.
      I believe they were robust, because something isn't true here.

  • @krmtrains
    @krmtrains Před rokem +24

    I really enjoyed your video, as it brought back many memories. I rode the train in St. Louis when visiting my grandparents, probably in 1968 when the “Gumdrop Express” debuted. I’ve had foggy memories of riding that train, and large gumdrops attached to it. Later, in the early 90’s, we took our son to ride the train at the former Herpelsheimer’s store in Grand Rapids, Michigan. Thanks so much for the research and presentation!

    • @yansatoussaint2266
      @yansatoussaint2266 Před rokem +5

      I grew up in St.Louis in the 60's and 70's and remember the Gumdrop Express at the JCPenney toystore in the RiverRoads Shopping Mall. As a senior it's been my dream to win the Powerball and have myself a monorail built because I enjoyed them so much as a child.

    • @funone8716
      @funone8716 Před rokem +1

      @@yansatoussaint2266 Buy lotsa tickets!

    • @lizkrinsky5209
      @lizkrinsky5209 Před 5 měsíci +1

      ⁠@@yansatoussaint2266 it wasn't at Penny's. It was there before they added the Penny's. In was in the Toy Department at Stix Baer snd Fuller. It went around the toy departments out the transom window into the mall and turned around by the large Christmas tree in the mall and came back. It was so magical. Great memories about it.

    • @yansatoussaint2266
      @yansatoussaint2266 Před 5 měsíci +1

      @@lizkrinsky5209 Are you talking about the Gumdrop Express at River Roads Mall in Jennings or the Gumdrop Express downtown at Stix,Baer and Fuller? You might be right because my mind has gotten a little foggy over the years and my family left St.Louis in 1974.

    • @lizkrinsky5209
      @lizkrinsky5209 Před 5 měsíci +1

      @@yansatoussaint2266the one at River Roads. I barely remember the one downtown. We used to go to River Roads a lot when I was a kid.

  • @Jarekthegamingdragon
    @Jarekthegamingdragon Před rokem +1

    Portland resident here, born in '91. Maaaan this unlocks memories deep forgotten for me. I don't even remember what the store looked like in detail. I just remember the experience. I do remember that sharp drop off wall. That's right at the start when it first starts moving.

  • @WilliamDilbeck
    @WilliamDilbeck Před rokem +2

    I remember the Pink Pig at Rich's in Atlanta. I saw it, but was too timid to ride it !

  • @caryblocker1989
    @caryblocker1989 Před rokem +13

    I was born in 1964 and rode the monorail in Leonard’s toy land in Fort Worth, TX. I think it was removed sometime between 1967 & 1970. There is a museum in the back of the M&O grill on Carroll street owned and operated by members of the Leonard family with lots of pictures and memorabilia, including the monorail and their private subway line.

    • @elizabethsmith3374
      @elizabethsmith3374 Před rokem +1

      My mom was born in 63 and she says she never rode the monorail but remembers it though and knew immediately what I was talking about when I was talking about it

    • @worldtraveler930
      @worldtraveler930 Před rokem +2

      I remember as a Very young kid being angry that I was not allowed to write it At All and that was in the middle seventies also IF I remember correctly the museum says it was actually built by the shops that manufactured and maintained their Subway system!!!

    • @colormedubious4747
      @colormedubious4747 Před rokem +1

      @@worldtraveler930 The subway cars were used PCC streetcars (manufactured by St. Louis Car Company in the 30s/40s) purchased from DC Transit. I used the Tandy/Leonard's subway once in the mid 90s, before it was permanently closed in 2002. I regret not taking photos of it. :(

    • @worldtraveler930
      @worldtraveler930 Před rokem +3

      @@colormedubious4747 You and me both!! I just expected that Such a Useful and Iconic part of Fort Worth to Always be around and in use!! 🤠👍

    • @vanmassey6885
      @vanmassey6885 Před rokem

      I can remember going to Leonard’s but do not remember riding the monorail.

  • @martinharrison9957
    @martinharrison9957 Před rokem +5

    Wow! I have memories of riding the Newark, NJ toyland monorail in the very early 50s.

  • @billriley6649
    @billriley6649 Před rokem +2

    Thanks for this, I loved riding the monorail at Kresge's in Newark NJ at Christmas time combined with a visit to Santa

    • @bertdellaluna5612
      @bertdellaluna5612 Před rokem +1

      Me too and it was great! Newark and the world were very different then.

  • @Yurong247
    @Yurong247 Před rokem +10

    Always a great day when I open CZcams to a new video from you! Thank you for the great content!

  • @badkittynomilktonight3334

    I'm glad so many of these were preserved. Hopefully one day some of them can be resurrected in some way.

    • @ablemagawitch
      @ablemagawitch Před rokem

      Resurrected no, Newly re-manufactured possibly yes. It's like saying "we can't build a Saturn V rocket that took to the moon with Apollo any more" today in the USA. If we did such to rebuild one we would spend billions to make the infrastructure for the same to build a rocket that is over half a century behind current materials and knowledge. That would suffer greatly from penalties in weight, limited thrust, cargo capacity, etc. Those old electronics, kids in the 1980's had more computer power in their home computers than the combined computer power that flew to the moon.
      So if we ever get back to people going to malls and stores, maybe Amazon will make people come to their distribution centers to pick out and pick up your own orders.... After they kill all the competition. If so we could have the possibility of these added as amusement for children, in such centers. Sadly large toy stores (RIP Toys-R-US and Toy Circus) and even department stores with large stocks of toys are in the past. Shopping malls are failing and stores that once preferred to be in the mall want independent store fronts that can operate by their own hours. You need people to hang out in the mall but today's youth often has behavior problems that make them unwanted and unwelcomed because some of them can't behave and socially ostracized by their peers for it. They smaller stores still want the big anchor stores close but all being in one shared building, just sadly isn't the case.
      People are equally to blame for being to rushed today to deal with parking their car, walking to and around a mall to shop. Although I wish these kid monorails would be rebuilt & installed for kids to enjoy today, but they would all need electronic displays in front of their seats. The days of riding in trains and looking down things from up high being enough for a novelty has equally passed.

  • @Ingineerix
    @Ingineerix Před rokem +4

    For those that are curious about how the system worked, From what I can tell, they had a 3-phase transformer/rectifier that provided 48 volts DC that was somehow remotely controlled by the operator station, Then the 48V was delivered to the track where there was a copper "third rail" mounted next to the monorail I-beam. The DC motor was located at the rear of the train (pusher) on the final bogey. You can see the 3rd rail in the picture at: czcams.com/video/-uW-AeI4q6Q/video.html. There were non-powered bogeys located the the head of the train and at every joint. The powered bogey at the back of the train contained brushes to pick up the 48VDC power and deliver it to the motor, and apparently there was also wiring to power lights on the cars. The 48V was used because it eliminated the electrocution hazard. Apparently, this was a standard product from Louden, the rocket express company just added their cars to the Louden motor bogeys. The Louden branded motorized monorail is even still sold: www.accomhs.com/products/patented-track/louden/louden-cranes/louden-monorail-systems/

    • @Ingineerix
      @Ingineerix Před rokem

      There's also a good view of the 3rd rail and wiring at: czcams.com/video/-uW-AeI4q6Q/video.html The "pusher" bogey is shown here: czcams.com/video/-uW-AeI4q6Q/video.html

    • @funone8716
      @funone8716 Před rokem

      Thanks for posting this......Fascinating!

  • @Yankee_Doodle_Dandy
    @Yankee_Doodle_Dandy Před rokem +7

    I must have been part of the last generation of kids to go on the Portland monorail at Maier & Frank’s. The building is still there but it’s a hotel now.

  • @augustusofprimaporta3721

    11:49 I lived in Atlanta until I was 4 or 5, and for years, I had memories of riding a pink-colored train or roller coaster at a mall of some sort. I could never find anything to confirm this, but seeing that train in all its glory finally provided this nearly forgotten memory with the context it demanded. Thank you.

    • @star-army
      @star-army Před rokem +2

      My kid, who was 3 at the time, was able to ride on one of the last Pink Pig rides, during its final year in 2021. It was a tracked style rather than the original monorail. It's sad you don't see these around anymore.

  • @Spacek531
    @Spacek531 Před rokem +11

    I remember going up in the Meyer & Frank tower and riding the monorail around, maybe 2004? One time the operator wanted to "race" the train down the platform to the operator's console, but was too late so we got 3 laps that ride.

  • @cw8359
    @cw8359 Před 3 měsíci +1

    Thank you for posting this! I rode on the SBF monorail in St.Louis when I was very young. For years, I could not find anyone else who remembered it until a few years ago and had thought I’d imagined it. Thank you for bringing one of my earliest childhood memories back to life!

  • @AMStationEngineer
    @AMStationEngineer Před rokem +2

    John Wanamaker's, Broad and Market Street's.... Such memorable times, replaced, over time, by dead malls, FedEX/UPS delivery trucks, and online purchasing.....

  • @ryanpatterson5224
    @ryanpatterson5224 Před rokem +3

    This channel is a gold mine

  • @sterlinsilver
    @sterlinsilver Před rokem +5

    I would've loved this. Monorails have always been my favorite

  • @garycrabtree4738
    @garycrabtree4738 Před rokem +2

    I was born in 1956 and I can remember riding the train at Leonard’s in Fort Worth. So it had to still be running in the early to mid 60’s.

    • @worldtraveler930
      @worldtraveler930 Před rokem +2

      I can in my earliest of memories remember Not being allowed to ride the Monorail At All but as I'm only 53 that means Leonard's had to have run that monorail into the seventies I also remember something in there museum for leonard brothers talking about ther Monorail having been built by the same shops that built and maintained their own Subway systems!! 🤠👍

  • @Ryanstuff
    @Ryanstuff Před rokem +1

    I grew up in Rochester NY and the monorail at midtown plaza was so magical. Looked forward to it every year. It took you through a mountain and up to see Santa. It really was amazing.

  • @jimbailey3998
    @jimbailey3998 Před rokem +9

    Nicely done video. I rode the Portland Oregon Meier and Frank Monorail on the 10th floor toyland in 1958-1965 as a kid of 5-12. Great memory.

  • @jst7714
    @jst7714 Před rokem +11

    I just visited the former Philly Wanamaker store today (video release date nonetheless). It is a very grand store, shame it’s been shrunk to only 3 floors. I imagine the 8th floor was magical!

    • @gigglesmurf2004
      @gigglesmurf2004 Před rokem

      Oh it has? That’s sad to hear. Even recently Macy’s still had the light show on in the center atrium that goes up to the 6th floor at least. If not the 8th. I’m going to ask my mom if she remembers this.

    • @tonytwostep_
      @tonytwostep_ Před rokem +2

      @@gigglesmurf2004 The light show does still occur in the building, which is on the 3rd floor of the Macy's. The escalator rides are very long so I'm assuming each floor of macy's is actually multiple of the building itself.

    • @gigglesmurf2004
      @gigglesmurf2004 Před rokem

      @@tonytwostep_ Thanks. It’s been so long my memory is fuzzy.

  • @cuttersgoose
    @cuttersgoose Před rokem +1

    I remember riding the Rochester midtown monorail as a toddler... and then seeing it on display at the museum of transportation some 40 years later... thank you for putting this video together...what great memories

  • @jamesmonroe7903
    @jamesmonroe7903 Před 7 měsíci +2

    I’m a lifelong St.Louisan and I remember riding the train at the St.Louis Zoo as a kid-it’s only in recent years that I’ve been finding out about the monorails at Stix,Baer&Fuller in the 1960’s-supposedly both wore out by the end of that decade and were not replaced-I never knew about Famous-Barr ever having one but I remember watching a TV special on PBS-9 in the mid-90’s about St.Louis Xmases past-and it included footage of a floor-mounted “Christmas Train” at Vandervoort’s Downtown store-it was an open-top ride that took children all the way around the store’s first floor-the TV special didn’t have any footage of the monorails at Stix or Famous however-wonder if anyone ever took and saved any film on those long-ago rides? PS-that was so cool to learn that while many parts of the country never had one of these childhood wonders-St.Louis had TWO of them!!! Wish at least one of them could have been put on display at our wonderful Museum of Transport in mid-St.Louis County!!! BUMMER!!!BUMMER!!! A magical time for STL!!!

    • @lizkrinsky5209
      @lizkrinsky5209 Před 5 měsíci +1

      I don't think they wore out. I think the lease on them ran out.

    • @jamesmonroe7903
      @jamesmonroe7903 Před 5 měsíci

      @@lizkrinsky5209 Coulda been either way-some of the kid monorails were still going strong outside of St.Louis in the 80’s and 90’s!!! A childhood dream!!! A real Christmastime treat!!!

  • @susanlangley4294
    @susanlangley4294 Před rokem +11

    Great detective work. I am so impressed by your exemplary research and look forward to your posts.

  • @tedneb3459
    @tedneb3459 Před rokem +3

    I agree with your conclusion that there was only one monorail in Milwaukee. I remember riding it in the very early 1960s, and I never could remember whether it was Gimbels or Boston Store since they were very similar buildings located very close to each other. But I remember that it was located on one of the upper floors of the building, which jibes with your information on the Boston Store installation, and I've never heard of a second monorail in the city.
    The ride did travel above the toy department and lasted only a couple of minutes. I recall being the only person on the ride at the time. And I recall that their Santa Claus scared the crap out of me.

  • @aliciapotts3074
    @aliciapotts3074 Před rokem +1

    Well produced as always Peter....Thanks for the memories!

  • @JeffDeWitt
    @JeffDeWitt Před rokem +2

    For years I had vague memories of riding one of these, a few years ago figuring out it was the one in Herpolsheimer's. I'm sorry none of these are running anymore, and it's sad seeing the names of all these great old department stores that are long gone.

  • @desmeitit
    @desmeitit Před rokem +3

    13:47 I got to go on that Portland ride before it closed, and that’s one of my earliest memories, being born in 2000 I was only 4 when I closed

  • @dshack4689
    @dshack4689 Před rokem +3

    Thanks for sharing, this was amazing to watch and learn as I don't think we ever had these in Australia (we did have the mini Dragon Rollercoaster at "Tops" the top of the Brisbane Myer Centre mall but that's a rollercoaster not a suspended monorail). I wonder if partly the success of these monorails in terms of safety is they weren't new developments they were based on extremely mature industrial technology so perhaps a lot of the engineering and safety and lessons to learn had already been well established during the war years industrialisation. Impressive research and I applaud your tenacity for verifiable facts instead of hearsay alone - amazing detailed effort! (I was originally getting annoyed at the number of ads scheduled into this video, but your content and detail and research kept me a fan, great effort!)

  • @nicholassheffo5723
    @nicholassheffo5723 Před rokem +1

    Outstanding work!!!! Will view more ASAP.

  • @richardneilan2392
    @richardneilan2392 Před rokem +2

    Very interesting and enjoyable. Thanks for putting this all together, and best wishes for Happy Holidays!

  • @RetroCards
    @RetroCards Před rokem +3

    Wow Peter! I have never seen this before. It did certainly pull at my heartstrings. I worked in these dept stores of the era as a teen and later after college. It was a magical time. What a great job you did preserving this! Cheers, Diane Dempsey, Retro Christmas Card Co.

  • @SG-wo3cw
    @SG-wo3cw Před rokem +3

    I rode the Meier and Frank (Portland) monorail as a kid in '59 and '60.
    My daughter rode it in '97-'99 (then was too big).
    BTW - no charge. Just get in line and ride it over a great Santaland.

  • @landonjones1516
    @landonjones1516 Před rokem +2

    Excellent research Peter! Thank You for your fine work!!

  • @ElDJReturn
    @ElDJReturn Před rokem +2

    I never knew about these but they sound delightful! Thanks for yet another well researched and produced video.

  • @Lacostelp
    @Lacostelp Před rokem +5

    My dad was the Portland OR Meier & Frank store manager for 10 years until 2006 when the change to macys happened I have photos of riding it as a kid and still remember doing so..