If you liked this video, check out my latest video where I talk about the issue with how Underdogs are written. Love yall, peace. czcams.com/video/Zo8d93O55Tw/video.htmlsi=igGwIKkdFsbwXoZi
The more I studied the Ubermensch by Nietzsche the more Luffy came to mind I was so excited to see the title and the vid didn't disappoint. Luffy is the final state, the child whom creates his own values and rejects things that don't matter to him
This is a great take on Luffy and it's why he stands out compared to other manga/anime protagonists and characters in general. Luffy, to me, always symbolized "the most free" because his actions reflect Taoist values. He is freeing the world as a byproduct of his personal goal and lays no claim to praise or accolades from it There's a remarkable depth to Luffy's character that's masked by his apparent simplicity - it's an intuition he has and the easiest way to describe it is for all the thinking that Luffy doesn't do, he intuits while upholding his values of freedom, fairness, and fun. Luffy has been like a breath of fresh air in that regard because of what he has removed or detached himself from. It's why he seems uncharacteristically wise in so many moments throughout the show - he lives in the present exclusively and doesn't cling to things He is already the most free, Pirate King or not
Very refreshing take on Luffy. The closing statement made me immediately think of Kamen Rider: Gaim and its tagline "just live more". A Nietzschian gem i cant recommend enough despite its childish appearance.
Luffy is "the child" I've made this connection years ago when I first read "The three metamophesis". He play freely and fiercly without fears. This characteristic is personified in the name "joy boy" and the Nika fruit. When he is in his awakend form, he is full of laughter and full of "joy".
I think it’s really important to contrast Luffy with Kid here. Kid has the same values of Luffy, similar willpower and goals, but he always fails while Luffy always suceeds. Kid is kinda what we in the west pictures to be a strong male model. Takes what he wants, doesn’t need anyone else, cruel because he has the right to be over those who fail to have the willpower to match him. Yet he lacks the child-like innocience that Luffy has making him fail while Luffy succeeds. It’s important to not just be strong in ideals and physicality, but also carry joy or else you will fall into nihilism. The way that Kid views connections to others as pointless due to being burned by Hawkins and Apoo while Luffy carries joy even after being betrayed by Robin, Sanji, and others
There's a form of Nihilism called Optimistic Nihilism. It's the acceptance that because nothing matters that is true freedom. They're not bound to anything and thus they can choose freely how they want to live. It's a life without the constraints of meaning so as such they make the meaning they choose.
@@Mephilic I don’t think we can label Luffy as that until we know his true dream. For now I think that is a very safe assumption to make, but there is always the chance that Luffy reveals he believes that this is fate rather than purely his own doing
Thanks man! I always found it fascinating the scene where Luffy was captured by Buggy , was about to be executed and yet he still smiled almost like he knew death won't stop him. There always have been a theme of destiny and fate surrounding his character and yet nobody talks about it. Just subscribed , keep doing what you want!
Much appreciated. And yes, that scene..... Don't look now but I intend to make a video centered around it in the future. Maybe in 2 months or so. I really appreciate your comment though, really inspires me to keep on going
Was watching Eric Dodson's lectures on Nietzsche and the first thing that occurred to me on his mention of "Dance and Laughter" was Sun God Nika. I am glad that someone else was able to put this resonance on paper better than I had the skills to. Great Video ❤️
Didn't expect a one piece video to touch on this subject. I always saw a blatant connection between Nietzsche's coming of the Übermensch and the prophesied return of the Messiah. The concept had been misinterpreted through the past. the Übermensch is not a state or a race, but a singular man. One with the willpower to set the entire world to right through not succumbing to the influence of those around them or their own desires, but do naught but what is right and live in Truth and freedom. It's poetic how the man who is famous for proclaiming the death of God would be one to fortell of his return. Great video, just whenever someone mentiones this concept from Nietzsche its all i can think about. God bless.
I think this fits quite nicely with my personal take on luffy because I had always thought of luffy as the absolute pinnacle of the Dao/Tao, just the pure destillation of that philosophy into a man Someone who just does, simply moving forward, not absent of thought, but absent of overthought
It's good to see that I wasn't the only one who saw the parallel between Nietzsche and one piece. There is a lot of parallel between Undermechen and the Celestial dragons. As well as the parallel of the camel, the lion and the child with Luffy's character journey.
WOW!!! I always has the doubt to do something and then I just give up so many time just by thinking too much. I'm so dumb. I should just do what I want to do without thinking too much, just like Luffy. I have so many regrets for missing a lot of opportunities. I really appreciate this video. It really help me and remind me exactly why I like Luffy. I should not think too much. I have 2 or 3 things which I really wanted to do and I think I will do those soon. Great Great Video 🎉🎉🎉 Subbed
great vid man! I love how, while Oda probably didn't sit down in 1997 and think about intentionally writing an ubermensch shonen protagonist, Luffy's behavior is still so accurately modelled by the philosophy. This is by far my favorite interpretation for why Luffy's absolute lack of internal monologue lends itself so well to a satisfyingly story, why he reads as both dumb and incredibly sharp at the same time, and why One Piece always feels like so much more than just a quippy "try hard and believe in yourself!" shonen battle manga.
Amazing video all those clips of different animation were great. I too was inspired by luffy's behaviour/way of thinking/living when I realized luffy never thinks, either he does stuff or sleeps never pondering about stuff (past or future). I always wonder how does Oda sensei knows so much about world including history, human behaviour and so much more, How did he get time to learn all that when he has simultaneously been creating one piece most of his adult life. He must have worked very hard to create his life's work & passion. I try to apply the many good teaching one piece has in life! I love to read/watch media which can teach something along with entertainment please suggest any piece of media which you think I should check out!
I appreciate your comment. And it is indeed intriguing to me how much oda knows and is able to incorporate into his work. He's truly a remarkable individual. As for recommendations, I think for the most part my channel serves as a way to expose those pieces of media that truly mean something to us as individuals and to point out how they speak to us. That being said, I'd recommend series like hunter x hunter, the climber or vagabond as good starting points
@@Phantom-gz1mm I have read vagabond multiple times, almost finished climber so I will focus hunter x hunter! thanks for the response. and i just watched your other vids " why men gravitate towards... " and "pop culture.." they were good too, keep uploading new content I will be sure to watch them
@@kamaldeepatkar3081 much appreciated. And yes, lmk how you feel about hunter x hunter eventually. On that note, serial experiments :lain and children of the sea are also manga you can check out
Hunter hunter is literally my favourite anime ever. It has so many wonderful moments but I keep going back specifically to the chimera ant arc, with Meruem being my favourite character and his growth while playing a game being my favourite part of the whole show xd
Luffy genuinely inspired me to develop the outlook on life that I have now. I've had all of this philosophical background that I studied and pondered in hopes of developing it, but it took Luffy to make it click in place. Now I have this sensation of grabbing the infinite and ever-moving ropes of fate, twisting them around my arms and pulling, as absurd and pointless as predestined rebelling against fate may be. I've decided to do this, and will keep doing it, regardless of the bone-shattering, vessel-popping, muscle-ripping pain that the pull of these ropes causes, as long as I have arms and teeth. Should my arms be ripped off and my teeth pulled out, I would stand there, bleeding out, dying a proud man with a now bigger smile and no regrets.
Emerson is actually held in quite high regard by Nietzsche, even if they aren't 100% aligned. Things he said about him include: "a glorious, great nature, rich in soul and spirit” “the author who has been the richest in ideas in this century.” “Never have I felt so at home in a book" Not trying to hate. This is a good capturing of his values of recognition of the moment, and the vital, creative power of action. I definitely think Luffy fits the definition in many ways, and The crossover of people who actually read most of his works and are big anime fans is extremely low, so im thankful for this content nonetheless!
I appreciate you. And yes I'm aware of the high regard nietzsche held Emerson but for the sake of trying to stay on topic, I decided to omit that and just focus on the origins of the concept.
So if I get this correctly... Luffy is the Nietzchean Übermensch but not only that he is literally THE second coming of Jesus in the One Piece world (IC CK NI KA) and is simultaneaosly Maitreya of Mahayana Buddhism (Maitreya is basically a Second Coming figure in Mahayana Buddhism considering he is to be the last Buddha to incarnate in this physical plane to bring back to the public the knowledge of Dharma which is what Luffy is effectively doing after some 800 years since the previous JoyBoy and Zoro being an outright explicit Buddhism themed character and represents the Asura that became submissive to the Buddhas while staying true to it's nature)? Bravo Oda, you are one of a kind. It's worth mentioning that no one has done an Islamic or Hindu parallel yet with Luffy so I wonder what those will be (Is Luffy Kalki? The avatar of Vishnu that arrises during the 300 year period known as the receding Kali Yuga? I'm actual not knowledgable on Islamic Eschatology but I have to think they would have a messianic figure that would mark the end of days).
In Islam it is also the second coming of Jesus, but also along with the Mahdi, a messianic deliverer who will fill earth with justice and equity, restore true religion, and usher in a short golden age before the end of the world. Great analysis btw
As someone who grew up watching One Piece here ib Europe and also modeling my character when i was young after Luffy..... This really made me think. I read Nietzsche's works you mentioned in school and uni (since i'm german it's kinda mandatory) and also understand what he wanted to say and it is more relatable than ever as we approach even more challenging times. We all can become an Übermensch. If we deconstruct our conditioning and look inwards and heal.... and then let go of these regulations that eat away at past wounds. It's amazing how in a few minutes you could explain these complex thoughts well and connect it to Luffy. Thank you for sharing! I will forever keep Luffy as a rolemodel for myself and step forward into my future.
What an amazing video ! I'm a big one piece fan, and Luffy's behavior has been a source of inspiration for me. This take on his character, using work from a philosopher like Nietzsche convinced me that his behavior is definitely worth taking as an example. I'll come back to this video in the future for sure !
You're too kind, thank you. And hmm, I feel like there is definitely more to talk about on this subject because luffy is a broader character than he's given credit for.
I find the comparison with Nietzsches for Luffy is an interesting one because recently I've made comparisons between the ideals and concepts of freedom portrayed by Luffy and Aang from the last airbender. Aang, raised as a peaceful temple nomad remained a vegetarian his whole life as one would assume to be due to his respect for life. But as the avatar his ideals of freedom revolve more around balance and societal order. When I make this comparison to Luffy or that of even Joyboy it does feel weird to be a meat fanatic when at its core is striping the freedom away from another life, unless the view on freedom is centered around power and one's own ability to stand for what they represent. Ultimately, it comes back to Doffy's marineford speech lol
I mean, I suppose that depends on whether or not animals actually have "freedom." One can argue that it's part of an animals life to be eaten. Predators hunt prey. It's just the natural order of things.
This is really interesting because I see Luffy as a contradiction of Nietzsche's Ubermench. Luffy is a Ideal Man but not by the definition of Nietzsche. He is strong willed but he lacks individualism. Luffy as far as I see is defined by his lack of Individualism. His freedom isn't built on his force of will (even though it drives him to his goal) but is enabled by the community he has built around himself to achieve that goal. In turn his will and strength is used to enable those around him to achieve their goals. This can easily be seen throughout the series from Water 7/ Enies Lobby to Wholecake Island but nevermore clearly in Amazon Lily and Post-Marineford. In Amazon Lily, we see Luffy who has had his community uprooted unable to fend for himself in the most basic way. He is trapped, in an island, lost, hungry, with no way get off. This shows the need for community that one needs to depend on. In Post-Marineford, Luffy who is on the verge of death and is mentally broken is brought forth from the brink of destruction by the existent of his crew, a community he has built. In a way Luffy can exist without the Strawhats and its the existence of the Strawhats that makes Luffy free. In a way, One Piece rejects the idea of the ideal man and proposes the ideal community, a community were each persons ability is applied towards achieving each others goal because on their own they can't achieve anything. It is each persons skill and support that allows Luffy to be the "Ideal Man" rather than his individual qualities.
I love this interpretation. And honestly this video isn't necessarily to be taken as law, but to open up a discussion about an overlooked aspect of the character. I look at a lot of what you referred to completely differently but I don't necessarily think you're wrong per say. Either way, it's great to see intelligent discussion of characters
Great video man! There is a lot of similarities in the philosophies of Nietzsche and one piece. For example the godly cast of dice. Where blackbeard is filled with resentment and takes the safest routes, choosing the strongest crewmates, not engaging if win isnt assured, luffy is allways casting the dice and affirming the moment even if it meant death, cause due to constant repetition he would not live a life wo those moments coming back for eternity
So fing well put homeboy! Great job in the desernment of truth beyond the waves of the shallow shore line and jumping into the deep ocean the old man mentioned. Bravo mate
I'm glad the video resonated with how you've felt. Honestly once you know about nietzsche's ideals, it becomes harder not to think of luffy and a few others
i haven't meet someone that could bring concepts and ideas out its ass like you did in my entire youtube watch. what aterrible interpretation of nietzsche
Instead of lamenting the fact you dont currently have the subscribers you deserve, i hope you will have them in the future. Refreshing takes paired with nostalgic anime. Homesick for a time long gone.
Cool video, I can see the correspondence between the conceptual figure of the Übermensch and some of Luffy's traits... Nevertheless, Luffy... Is... A... particular representation of... THE MONKEY KING (of pirates). (Maybe we can draw some similarities between Sun Wukong and the Übermensch as well, who knows)
For a long time now I've lived my life through the path that involves the most happiness, and so I've cast aside doubt, fear, insecurity, embarrassment, most that know me often describe me as free or unbothered, its truly a freeing idea, once you simply stop caring so much you can enjoy the small pieces of life, and its in the insignificant moments of life which we find the most importance, how often does one win the lottery? Not often enough id say, but how often does one buy groceries or other such mundane tasks, maximizing ones happiness, freeing oneself from permeance, conformity, secrecy, it is how I've found happiness, and now thanks to this video i have a concept which ties it all together, thank you my friend
Very unique and interesting video. Just a suggestion but try to make transitioning into manga panels less jarring, I thought it was distracting from the video. Keep it up.
Luffy is not an ubermensch. The idea of the ubermensch has to go through corruption of man of society to emerge as over man. Luffy bypasses the whole process. He never negotiates or wrestles with any ideals, with any becomings. He just is what he is.
I heavily disagree. While I do believe luffy has always been who he is, pretty much the entire story has involved him negotiating or wrestling with ideals, like in his battle with crocodile, or doflamingo or the entire battle vs katakuri which epitomises this point. Nietzsche himself just suggested a path he thinks that man could take to achieving that true potential, becoming the 'super man', luffy not following that exact path doesn't make him any less of one, rather it's whether or not he embodies those traits that determines his status, in this case, he happens to. Regardless tho, I still appreciate your comment, I love thoughtful discourse
Omg, i can't believe you actually saw my video. This video was heavily inspired by you and I feel honoured that it reached one of my inspirations. Hopefully we can work together somehow in future
there is a lot more left to be said about luffy but a Great analysis my friend. Luffy as a character can be easly disregarded as a goof ball a comedy character a happy go lucky guy ... but He is one of the greatest characters in all fictions a Joy boy a god . the nietzsches lens was a bit unexpected to me but a very good one . I more often bring up buddha when i explore luffy in a discution with my friends . great to see someone seeing more into luffy because the mainstream analysis videos like the one totally not mark did recently while good and has some on point observation can be a bit flat and dismissive also headcanony a bit putting worldly enterpretations and words in the mouth of this unworldly character .
I agree, there is a lot to explore with luffy. I think he's one of the broadest characters in fiction, which is obviously a by product of being the main character of one of the most expansive works of fiction ever. I noticed that there isn't really actual 'analysis' of luffys character and more like a narration of his attitude or things he's done or something. I have many thoughts on Luffy in different aspects but those will be for future videos. Appreciate you for watching
yeah man i've been wanting to make videos about luffy for somtime but the time never seem to come among other things of course but this character has captivated me in a way like no one else did exited to see what you'll make next and hopefully i'll make mine by then hhhh Let's meet in the new world @@Phantom-gz1mm
Ever since I read "How to Philosophize with a hammer and sickle" by Jonas Ceika I was more interested in Nietzsche. But seeing Nietzsche's thought being connected to my favorite work of art (One Piece) really gives me incentive to dive deeper into Nietzsche
i wonder if oda projects his own way of living into One Piece & Luffy, or does he do this unconsciously? Driven by the universe? I would love to know more about that man…
After a sea of slop video essays, this is actually a really good one. One nitpick, Luffy is not the titular character because the title of his story is One Piece, not Luffy. That's just semantics tho
If I could, I would travel to the Past and show Nietzsche the Manga with the screaming Rubberman and say "Siehe, dein Übermensch" (Behold, your Ubermensch)
Liked the video but it was hard to watch due to the sound of your voice peaking. If you figure out that issue it will be a lot more pleasant to listen to you in the future. Also, "Descartes" is pronounced like [Dekart]
Forgot to reply to this previously but yes you are definitely right. My microphone isn't the greatest at the moment but I intend on getting a high quality one in the near future, so hopefully that resolves the issue. I appreciate all constructive criticism
The titular character of one piece? Luffy name is not one piece😂😂😂 titular means ‘in the title’, so Harry Potter is the titular character of Harry Potter, for example. Hope that clears that up, good video!
Thank you. And yh a couple of people pointed that out lol. I always for some reason thought titular character was synonymous for main character. Thanks once again and appreciate you for watching
If you liked this video, check out my latest video where I talk about the issue with how Underdogs are written. Love yall, peace.
czcams.com/video/Zo8d93O55Tw/video.htmlsi=igGwIKkdFsbwXoZi
The more I studied the Ubermensch by Nietzsche the more Luffy came to mind
I was so excited to see the title and the vid didn't disappoint.
Luffy is the final state, the child whom creates his own values and rejects things that don't matter to him
Much appreciated, I'm glad the video was able to reflect the things you observed.
Hey, i'd been waiting to make a video to this topic. And u did. Finally action has to happen outside the mind. Luffy is somewhat Zarathustra
This is a great take on Luffy and it's why he stands out compared to other manga/anime protagonists and characters in general. Luffy, to me, always symbolized "the most free" because his actions reflect Taoist values. He is freeing the world as a byproduct of his personal goal and lays no claim to praise or accolades from it
There's a remarkable depth to Luffy's character that's masked by his apparent simplicity - it's an intuition he has and the easiest way to describe it is for all the thinking that Luffy doesn't do, he intuits while upholding his values of freedom, fairness, and fun. Luffy has been like a breath of fresh air in that regard because of what he has removed or detached himself from. It's why he seems uncharacteristically wise in so many moments throughout the show - he lives in the present exclusively and doesn't cling to things
He is already the most free, Pirate King or not
Wow, this comment is damn near better than the video itself 😂 appreciate you for watching and commenting, and I absolutely agree
Facts bro
Very refreshing take on Luffy. The closing statement made me immediately think of Kamen Rider: Gaim and its tagline "just live more". A Nietzschian gem i cant recommend enough despite its childish appearance.
Appreciate you. And thank you for the recommendation, I'll be sure to check it out
as a philosophy major and a huge one piece fan i must say that this was INCREDIBLE!! such an interesting watch
This means a lot. The fact I could impress a philosophy major is wild to me
Currently philosophy student, and same for me... so good job👍@@Phantom-gz1mm
Luffy is "the child" I've made this connection years ago when I first read "The three metamophesis". He play freely and fiercly without fears. This characteristic is personified in the name "joy boy" and the Nika fruit. When he is in his awakend form, he is full of laughter and full of "joy".
I think it’s really important to contrast Luffy with Kid here. Kid has the same values of Luffy, similar willpower and goals, but he always fails while Luffy always suceeds. Kid is kinda what we in the west pictures to be a strong male model. Takes what he wants, doesn’t need anyone else, cruel because he has the right to be over those who fail to have the willpower to match him. Yet he lacks the child-like innocience that Luffy has making him fail while Luffy succeeds. It’s important to not just be strong in ideals and physicality, but also carry joy or else you will fall into nihilism. The way that Kid views connections to others as pointless due to being burned by Hawkins and Apoo while Luffy carries joy even after being betrayed by Robin, Sanji, and others
There's a form of Nihilism called Optimistic Nihilism. It's the acceptance that because nothing matters that is true freedom. They're not bound to anything and thus they can choose freely how they want to live. It's a life without the constraints of meaning so as such they make the meaning they choose.
@@Mephilic I don’t think we can label Luffy as that until we know his true dream. For now I think that is a very safe assumption to make, but there is always the chance that Luffy reveals he believes that this is fate rather than purely his own doing
when you referred to luffy telling chopper to shut up and you said "stop questioning what could be, and decide what is" was AMAZING
Ah I appreciate you
Thanks man! I always found it fascinating the scene where Luffy was captured by Buggy , was about to be executed and yet he still smiled almost like he knew death won't stop him. There always have been a theme of destiny and fate surrounding his character and yet nobody talks about it.
Just subscribed , keep doing what you want!
Much appreciated. And yes, that scene..... Don't look now but I intend to make a video centered around it in the future. Maybe in 2 months or so. I really appreciate your comment though, really inspires me to keep on going
Didn’t expect to find a vid like this about Luffy, Amazing vid man
Much appreciated. I always try to provide unique perspectives on different aspects of media
Was watching Eric Dodson's lectures on Nietzsche and the first thing that occurred to me on his mention of "Dance and Laughter" was Sun God Nika. I am glad that someone else was able to put this resonance on paper better than I had the skills to. Great Video ❤️
Much appreciated. And now you mentioned this, could you perhaps leave a link to this lecture, I'm intrigued
@@Phantom-gz1mm czcams.com/video/m2PpS_kthTA/video.html
czcams.com/video/1bDeWmLIHn8/video.html - This is part 4 "Laughter, Dance and the Will to Power"
" I must believe only in a god who knows how to dance "
"I don't think, but I still am"
Swapping supremacy for freedom, equality and friendship is an actual ‘sigma move’
Didn't expect a one piece video to touch on this subject. I always saw a blatant connection between Nietzsche's coming of the Übermensch and the prophesied return of the Messiah. The concept had been misinterpreted through the past. the Übermensch is not a state or a race, but a singular man. One with the willpower to set the entire world to right through not succumbing to the influence of those around them or their own desires, but do naught but what is right and live in Truth and freedom. It's poetic how the man who is famous for proclaiming the death of God would be one to fortell of his return.
Great video, just whenever someone mentiones this concept from Nietzsche its all i can think about.
God bless.
both blackbeard and luffy are almost perfect candidates for Ubermensch
I think this fits quite nicely with my personal take on luffy because I had always thought of luffy as the absolute pinnacle of the Dao/Tao, just the pure destillation of that philosophy into a man
Someone who just does, simply moving forward, not absent of thought, but absent of overthought
This is interesting
It's good to see that I wasn't the only one who saw the parallel between Nietzsche and one piece. There is a lot of parallel between Undermechen and the Celestial dragons. As well as the parallel of the camel, the lion and the child with Luffy's character journey.
Appreciate you for watching. And I have a lot of stuff related to luffy that I want to talk about but all in due time
insanely good video man
cooked as always
Much appreciated
WOW!!! I always has the doubt to do something and then I just give up so many time just by thinking too much. I'm so dumb. I should just do what I want to do without thinking too much, just like Luffy. I have so many regrets for missing a lot of opportunities. I really appreciate this video. It really help me and remind me exactly why I like Luffy. I should not think too much. I have 2 or 3 things which I really wanted to do and I think I will do those soon. Great Great Video 🎉🎉🎉 Subbed
Thank you, and I'm glad this video was able to inspire you.
great vid man! I love how, while Oda probably didn't sit down in 1997 and think about intentionally writing an ubermensch shonen protagonist, Luffy's behavior is still so accurately modelled by the philosophy. This is by far my favorite interpretation for why Luffy's absolute lack of internal monologue lends itself so well to a satisfyingly story, why he reads as both dumb and incredibly sharp at the same time, and why One Piece always feels like so much more than just a quippy "try hard and believe in yourself!" shonen battle manga.
Thank you. And I absolutely love your comment, and I'm glad that I was able to convey the exact sentiments I hoped
Amazing video all those clips of different animation were great. I too was inspired by luffy's behaviour/way of thinking/living when I realized luffy never thinks, either he does stuff or sleeps never pondering about stuff (past or future). I always wonder how does Oda sensei knows so much about world including history, human behaviour and so much more, How did he get time to learn all that when he has simultaneously been creating one piece most of his adult life. He must have worked very hard to create his life's work & passion. I try to apply the many good teaching one piece has in life!
I love to read/watch media which can teach something along with entertainment please suggest any piece of media which you think I should check out!
I appreciate your comment. And it is indeed intriguing to me how much oda knows and is able to incorporate into his work. He's truly a remarkable individual. As for recommendations, I think for the most part my channel serves as a way to expose those pieces of media that truly mean something to us as individuals and to point out how they speak to us. That being said, I'd recommend series like hunter x hunter, the climber or vagabond as good starting points
@@Phantom-gz1mm I have read vagabond multiple times, almost finished climber so I will focus hunter x hunter! thanks for the response. and i just watched your other vids " why men gravitate towards... " and "pop culture.." they were good too, keep uploading new content I will be sure to watch them
@@kamaldeepatkar3081 much appreciated. And yes, lmk how you feel about hunter x hunter eventually. On that note, serial experiments :lain and children of the sea are also manga you can check out
@@Phantom-gz1mm i will check them out and let you know for sure how they felt!
Hunter hunter is literally my favourite anime ever. It has so many wonderful moments but I keep going back specifically to the chimera ant arc, with Meruem being my favourite character and his growth while playing a game being my favourite part of the whole show xd
You better quote Luffy when he says "I don't want to be a hero, because heroes have to share the meat!"
Better be in this video. Better be.
Missed opportunity
i dont think that quote has anything to do with what hes talking about
A video on Nietzsche and Luffy? You might convince me to finally pick up One Piece again
Do it
Luffy genuinely inspired me to develop the outlook on life that I have now.
I've had all of this philosophical background that I studied and pondered in hopes of developing it, but it took Luffy to make it click in place.
Now I have this sensation of grabbing the infinite and ever-moving ropes of fate, twisting them around my arms and pulling, as absurd and pointless as predestined rebelling against fate may be.
I've decided to do this, and will keep doing it, regardless of the bone-shattering, vessel-popping, muscle-ripping pain that the pull of these ropes causes, as long as I have arms and teeth.
Should my arms be ripped off and my teeth pulled out, I would stand there, bleeding out, dying a proud man with a now bigger smile and no regrets.
This is best comment I've read so far. This is a beautiful piece and the kind of introspection I hoped to inspire with this video
I'd add that Luffy, especially after Gear 5, embodies Neitzsche's praise of 'cheerfulness' in The Gay Science.
Cool video!!
Thank you. And yes, keen observation
Emerson is actually held in quite high regard by Nietzsche, even if they aren't 100% aligned.
Things he said about him include:
"a glorious, great nature, rich in soul and spirit”
“the author who has been the richest in ideas in this century.”
“Never have I felt so at home in a book"
Not trying to hate. This is a good capturing of his values of recognition of the moment, and the vital, creative power of action. I definitely think Luffy fits the definition in many ways, and The crossover of people who actually read most of his works and are big anime fans is extremely low, so im thankful for this content nonetheless!
I appreciate you. And yes I'm aware of the high regard nietzsche held Emerson but for the sake of trying to stay on topic, I decided to omit that and just focus on the origins of the concept.
So if I get this correctly... Luffy is the Nietzchean Übermensch but not only that he is literally THE second coming of Jesus in the One Piece world (IC CK NI KA) and is simultaneaosly Maitreya of Mahayana Buddhism (Maitreya is basically a Second Coming figure in Mahayana Buddhism considering he is to be the last Buddha to incarnate in this physical plane to bring back to the public the knowledge of Dharma which is what Luffy is effectively doing after some 800 years since the previous JoyBoy and Zoro being an outright explicit Buddhism themed character and represents the Asura that became submissive to the Buddhas while staying true to it's nature)? Bravo Oda, you are one of a kind. It's worth mentioning that no one has done an Islamic or Hindu parallel yet with Luffy so I wonder what those will be (Is Luffy Kalki? The avatar of Vishnu that arrises during the 300 year period known as the receding Kali Yuga? I'm actual not knowledgable on Islamic Eschatology but I have to think they would have a messianic figure that would mark the end of days).
You.... Just gave me like 20 different video ideas 😭
Daymmm bro daymm...
In Islam it is also the second coming of Jesus, but also along with the Mahdi, a messianic deliverer who will fill earth with justice and equity, restore true religion, and usher in a short golden age before the end of the world. Great analysis btw
As someone who grew up watching One Piece here ib Europe and also modeling my character when i was young after Luffy..... This really made me think. I read Nietzsche's works you mentioned in school and uni (since i'm german it's kinda mandatory) and also understand what he wanted to say and it is more relatable than ever as we approach even more challenging times. We all can become an Übermensch. If we deconstruct our conditioning and look inwards and heal.... and then let go of these regulations that eat away at past wounds. It's amazing how in a few minutes you could explain these complex thoughts well and connect it to Luffy. Thank you for sharing! I will forever keep Luffy as a rolemodel for myself and step forward into my future.
Thank you for watching and sharing this comment!. This is a very beautiful insight, and I'm glad I was able to convey the message effectively
This is something I was strangely thinking last week, and it has become manifest. Thank you.
well researched and put together video
Much appreciated
Great video! You are one of the very few who understand Monkey D Luffy.
Thank you. You're too kind
This explains Luffy’s character even more better. The way how you explain and dive deeper to his character brings peace to my every being😌
Thank you. That's high praise and I'm very appreciative of that
@@Phantom-gz1mm Your welcome👍✨
What an amazing video ! I'm a big one piece fan, and Luffy's behavior has been a source of inspiration for me. This take on his character, using work from a philosopher like Nietzsche convinced me that his behavior is definitely worth taking as an example. I'll come back to this video in the future for sure !
Much appreciated. I'm glad the video was able to resonate as intended
Not to glaze or anything but such a decent video/essay. Definitely some erudite piece of work yet so authentic which we love to see. Made my evening
Appreciate your kind words.
Wow Such a refreshing vid Would love to read a longer version of this as an article or in a journal. Amazing work!!
You're too kind, thank you. And hmm, I feel like there is definitely more to talk about on this subject because luffy is a broader character than he's given credit for.
Thank you for this. It reminded me of my own dream ba of freedom, the freedom to create and invent. I cannot shy away, so thank you
You're very welcome
I find the comparison with Nietzsches for Luffy is an interesting one because recently I've made comparisons between the ideals and concepts of freedom portrayed by Luffy and Aang from the last airbender.
Aang, raised as a peaceful temple nomad remained a vegetarian his whole life as one would assume to be due to his respect for life. But as the avatar his ideals of freedom revolve more around balance and societal order.
When I make this comparison to Luffy or that of even Joyboy it does feel weird to be a meat fanatic when at its core is striping the freedom away from another life, unless the view on freedom is centered around power and one's own ability to stand for what they represent.
Ultimately, it comes back to Doffy's marineford speech lol
Very well thought out writeup. Appreciate you for watching
I mean, I suppose that depends on whether or not animals actually have "freedom." One can argue that it's part of an animals life to be eaten. Predators hunt prey. It's just the natural order of things.
This video reached me in the algorithm
This is really interesting because I see Luffy as a contradiction of Nietzsche's Ubermench. Luffy is a Ideal Man but not by the definition of Nietzsche. He is strong willed but he lacks individualism. Luffy as far as I see is defined by his lack of Individualism. His freedom isn't built on his force of will (even though it drives him to his goal) but is enabled by the community he has built around himself to achieve that goal. In turn his will and strength is used to enable those around him to achieve their goals. This can easily be seen throughout the series from Water 7/ Enies Lobby to Wholecake Island but nevermore clearly in Amazon Lily and Post-Marineford. In Amazon Lily, we see Luffy who has had his community uprooted unable to fend for himself in the most basic way. He is trapped, in an island, lost, hungry, with no way get off. This shows the need for community that one needs to depend on. In Post-Marineford, Luffy who is on the verge of death and is mentally broken is brought forth from the brink of destruction by the existent of his crew, a community he has built. In a way Luffy can exist without the Strawhats and its the existence of the Strawhats that makes Luffy free. In a way, One Piece rejects the idea of the ideal man and proposes the ideal community, a community were each persons ability is applied towards achieving each others goal because on their own they can't achieve anything. It is each persons skill and support that allows Luffy to be the "Ideal Man" rather than his individual qualities.
I love this interpretation. And honestly this video isn't necessarily to be taken as law, but to open up a discussion about an overlooked aspect of the character. I look at a lot of what you referred to completely differently but I don't necessarily think you're wrong per say. Either way, it's great to see intelligent discussion of characters
this channel is really underrated i have been binge watching after i found this video
Aww, I really appreciate that. Thank you for watching
Finally someone is speaking ❤
I liked the video before I start, I knew I would like it.
Much appreciated
Great video man! There is a lot of similarities in the philosophies of Nietzsche and one piece. For example the godly cast of dice. Where blackbeard is filled with resentment and takes the safest routes, choosing the strongest crewmates, not engaging if win isnt assured, luffy is allways casting the dice and affirming the moment even if it meant death, cause due to constant repetition he would not live a life wo those moments coming back for eternity
Indeed. Great point. I'd suggest you check out my recent video, where I also point out some other blackbeard parallels
Arguably one of the greatest video essays I have watched
Much appreciated
So fing well put homeboy! Great job in the desernment of truth beyond the waves of the shallow shore line and jumping into the deep ocean the old man mentioned. Bravo mate
Much appreciated
Underrated channel. Can't believe you have less than a couple thousand subs.
Much appreciated man. And hopefully we get there, in due time.
Legendary video, keep it up man.
Appreciate you. I'll do my best
More of that brother !!
Appreciate it
Very interesting take on luffy. Beeing free means also beeing free of you inner dialogue and just be present
great video man. I came to the same ideas as well but you perfectly articulated it all very well. new subscriber!
@@HP-tw6tl much appreciated
I've literally been meaning to talk about this for the past 3 months and have not had the time. I'm so glad someone else has noticed it too.
I'm glad the video resonated with how you've felt. Honestly once you know about nietzsche's ideals, it becomes harder not to think of luffy and a few others
@@Phantom-gz1mm What are the few others that could fit
@@EmpteeBluffs Aizen from bleach and Kojiro from vagabond come to mind
i haven't meet someone that could bring concepts and ideas out its ass like you did in my entire youtube watch.
what aterrible interpretation of nietzsche
Thanks for watching!
I love the delivery of this whole video I was gripped all the way through, amazing work!
Thank you
Instead of lamenting the fact you dont currently have the subscribers you deserve, i hope you will have them in the future. Refreshing takes paired with nostalgic anime.
Homesick for a time long gone.
Cool video, I can see the correspondence between the conceptual figure of the Übermensch and some of Luffy's traits... Nevertheless, Luffy... Is... A... particular representation of... THE MONKEY KING (of pirates). (Maybe we can draw some similarities between Sun Wukong and the Übermensch as well, who knows)
This is an awesome perspective on Luffy. Great video, thanks for sharing your thoughts!
Much appreciated. Thank you for watching and hopefully subscribing lol.
Subscribed right away, looking forward to more content!@@Phantom-gz1mm
Wow . What a video. I was playing a game when I started , but I had to give my full attention.
Excited to see your future videos
Much appreciated. Comments like this motivate me to such a massive extent
My favourite philosopher and my favourite media combined , i absolutely adore this
Thank you
Did you actually say Monkey D Luci? Love it!
I was reading Zarathoustra and one piece and i was struck by the parallels
Video cuts short at the end, but great video!
Apologies for that, accidentally cut it short because there's a copyrighted section. Wish I could fix it. Anyway, I appreciate you for watching
went in thinking it would turn into "luffy is a sigma grindset gigachad" but this was a pleasant surprise
For some reason a lot of people thought this too but glad you stuck around
the best description of luffy philosophically
For a long time now I've lived my life through the path that involves the most happiness, and so I've cast aside doubt, fear, insecurity, embarrassment, most that know me often describe me as free or unbothered, its truly a freeing idea, once you simply stop caring so much you can enjoy the small pieces of life, and its in the insignificant moments of life which we find the most importance, how often does one win the lottery? Not often enough id say, but how often does one buy groceries or other such mundane tasks, maximizing ones happiness, freeing oneself from permeance, conformity, secrecy, it is how I've found happiness, and now thanks to this video i have a concept which ties it all together, thank you my friend
You're most welcome, and this is a beautiful comment
Im sold brother, thanks
Nice vid, How long this took you?
Thank you. And honestly this took me more hours than I'd have liked. Maybe upwards of 10 to 15, but I'm glad it came out OK.
Finally someone who r in my wavelength much appreciate it bro
Very inspiring! To achieve this mindset of the present moment i would really recommend meditation on a regular bases.
I’m going to watch this video a few times because I hope it will stick with me
Very unique and interesting video. Just a suggestion but try to make transitioning into manga panels less jarring, I thought it was distracting from the video. Keep it up.
Thanks for watching. I'll definitely take that critique into consideration for the future
734th like!👍
Awesome and insightful video!😁
Couldn’t have said it better myself!🤘😎🤘
Much appreciated
Such a well made video essay... keep em coming!
Thank you. That means a lot, I'll do my best.
this was fascinating. also, the edit is phenomenal
Thank you. I appreciate comments like this
Good video. Lacks some grip.
thank you for the video. I found your analysis very interesting
Luffy is not an ubermensch. The idea of the ubermensch has to go through corruption of man of society to emerge as over man. Luffy bypasses the whole process. He never negotiates or wrestles with any ideals, with any becomings. He just is what he is.
I heavily disagree. While I do believe luffy has always been who he is, pretty much the entire story has involved him negotiating or wrestling with ideals, like in his battle with crocodile, or doflamingo or the entire battle vs katakuri which epitomises this point. Nietzsche himself just suggested a path he thinks that man could take to achieving that true potential, becoming the 'super man', luffy not following that exact path doesn't make him any less of one, rather it's whether or not he embodies those traits that determines his status, in this case, he happens to. Regardless tho, I still appreciate your comment, I love thoughtful discourse
hmmm
Omg, i can't believe you actually saw my video. This video was heavily inspired by you and I feel honoured that it reached one of my inspirations. Hopefully we can work together somehow in future
there is a lot more left to be said about luffy but a Great analysis my friend.
Luffy as a character can be easly disregarded as a goof ball a comedy character a happy go lucky guy ... but He is one of the greatest characters in all fictions a Joy boy a god .
the nietzsches lens was a bit unexpected to me but a very good one .
I more often bring up buddha when i explore luffy in a discution with my friends .
great to see someone seeing more into luffy because the mainstream analysis videos like the one totally not mark did recently while good and has some on point observation can be a bit flat and dismissive also headcanony a bit putting worldly enterpretations and words in the mouth of this unworldly character .
I agree, there is a lot to explore with luffy. I think he's one of the broadest characters in fiction, which is obviously a by product of being the main character of one of the most expansive works of fiction ever. I noticed that there isn't really actual 'analysis' of luffys character and more like a narration of his attitude or things he's done or something. I have many thoughts on Luffy in different aspects but those will be for future videos. Appreciate you for watching
yeah man i've been wanting to make videos about luffy for somtime but the time never seem to come among other things of course but this character has captivated me in a way like no one else did
exited to see what you'll make next and hopefully i'll make mine by then hhhh
Let's meet in the new world @@Phantom-gz1mm
Damn I needed this!
Ever since I read "How to Philosophize with a hammer and sickle" by Jonas Ceika I was more interested in Nietzsche. But seeing Nietzsche's thought being connected to my favorite work of art (One Piece) really gives me incentive to dive deeper into Nietzsche
This makes me happy to see. I'm glad the video resonated as intended. Thanks for watching
THAT is a CRAZY title.
Hahaha
Thanks for the vid, it's well written !
i wonder if oda projects his own way of living into One Piece & Luffy, or does he do this unconsciously? Driven by the universe? I would love to know more about that man…
Great video, love to see good video essays❤❤
After a sea of slop video essays, this is actually a really good one. One nitpick, Luffy is not the titular character because the title of his story is One Piece, not Luffy. That's just semantics tho
Thank you. That means a lot. And hahaha, noted for when next I do a luffy video
This is amazing, thanks!
Love the vid, unique and cool comparison
Much appreciated
thats an insanely interesting outlook on luffy, wow
Thnx
great video
Thank you, I really appreciate it
good one
Thanks.
bro tricked me in thinking it is a german video, anyways I can understand english so Im listening
Nice vid bro 👍
Great vid man
If I could, I would travel to the Past and show Nietzsche the Manga with the screaming Rubberman and say "Siehe, dein Übermensch" (Behold, your Ubermensch)
brah good video
Liked the video but it was hard to watch due to the sound of your voice peaking. If you figure out that issue it will be a lot more pleasant to listen to you in the future.
Also, "Descartes" is pronounced like [Dekart]
Forgot to reply to this previously but yes you are definitely right. My microphone isn't the greatest at the moment but I intend on getting a high quality one in the near future, so hopefully that resolves the issue. I appreciate all constructive criticism
Luffy seems to me to represent Plato's the form of the good more than Neitczhean Uberman
Perhaps. No other perspective is necessarily wrong, this video is just opening discourse to the existence of such perspective in the first place
This applies to Goku as well and Luffy is inspired from Goku
The titular character of one piece? Luffy name is not one piece😂😂😂 titular means ‘in the title’, so Harry Potter is the titular character of Harry Potter, for example. Hope that clears that up, good video!
Thank you. And yh a couple of people pointed that out lol. I always for some reason thought titular character was synonymous for main character. Thanks once again and appreciate you for watching
Nice Video
Much appreciated