Komentáře •

  • @burlatsdemontaigne6147
    @burlatsdemontaigne6147 Před 10 měsíci +21

    Mr Doyle's tank knowledge never fails to astound me.

  • @frankbodenschatz173
    @frankbodenschatz173 Před 5 měsíci +1

    Thanks for the discussion gents!

  • @richardprzybylek5847
    @richardprzybylek5847 Před 10 měsíci +9

    I always loved that little tank especially with the 105mm it looked like the infantry support vehicle was supposed to

  • @ivoferin8176
    @ivoferin8176 Před rokem +8

    Hilary is brilliant... Fortunate to have many of his books.

  • @tarjei99
    @tarjei99 Před 11 měsíci +8

    Fantastic to listen to an expert who obviously know what he talks about.

  • @HenrikFredriksson-oi4lz
    @HenrikFredriksson-oi4lz Před 17 dny +1

    If you ever visit Sweden - visit Arsenalen in Strängnäs, about 100km from Stockholm😊👍

  • @billd2635
    @billd2635 Před 7 měsíci +1

    Thank you much.

  • @rudithedog7534
    @rudithedog7534 Před 6 měsíci +1

    Love watching and listening to Hillary Doyle a true font of knowledge, and the you got to admit it is small and squat in profile and has a lot of bitting power just like a badger so I suppose that is where the nickname came from.

  • @GianmarioScotti
    @GianmarioScotti Před 10 měsíci +4

    Very nice and informative discussion, gentlemen. Thank you.

  • @j.f.fisher5318
    @j.f.fisher5318 Před rokem +15

    Muzzle brakes made ATGs much easier to spot. The smoke dissipated quickly but the rearward blast would raise dust and it spread out to the sides clearly marking the gun's location. That according to a Soviet tank officer's memoir.

    • @VenturiLife
      @VenturiLife Před 10 měsíci +5

      It's a trade-off, so the crew can get off a quick follow-up shot without being blinded by their own smoke.

    • @andrewemery4272
      @andrewemery4272 Před 10 měsíci +3

      Interesting. Thank you

    • @GerbenWulff
      @GerbenWulff Před 9 měsíci +2

      ​@@VenturiLife No, the main reason to add a muzzle brake is to reduce the recoil of the gun. That allows fitting a larger gun in a limited space.

  • @bRattusNorvegicusCBO
    @bRattusNorvegicusCBO Před 9 měsíci +2

    Originální konstrukce lt.38 ČeskoSlovenské republiky. Z kvalitního podvozku Praga montovali nacisti stíhač tanků. Používaný byl do konce války. Mimochodem Lt. 38 výrazně převyšuje Panzer l i ll. 😊

    • @AKUJIVALDO
      @AKUJIVALDO Před 3 měsíci

      Oh, look, later made light tank outperform older tanket and older light tank.
      Also, Germany created totally new, powerful Hetzer from obsolete chassis by using German components that old factory could manufacture.

  • @mycroft1905
    @mycroft1905 Před rokem +10

    Karlsson and Doyle; a formidable pairing. TFP

  • @neilwilson5785
    @neilwilson5785 Před rokem +3

    So interesting. Thanks for the detailed insight.

  • @Chipchase780
    @Chipchase780 Před 10 měsíci +5

    My favorite tank in wot. I know it’s a fighting vehicle, function over style, but I love the shape of the thing ! It makes me think of a large metal beetle with a very destructive sting at the front. Fascinating and informative video. I’d really like a large scale model of it.

  • @spinnetti
    @spinnetti Před 10 měsíci +1

    Nice.. I scratch built a bit later model in 1/12 scale for RC... Cool little machine. Learned a lot researching for the build.

  • @parker1ray
    @parker1ray Před rokem +4

    These tank destroyers were a love and hate relationship with the crews! The were very effective tank destroyers, but were a nightmare to fight!

    • @henryvagincourt4502
      @henryvagincourt4502 Před rokem +2

      I guess it depends on the crew, what would you want to be in a Tiger I/II or this? Given allied air power, lack of fuel, bridges that can't take your weight, I know where I'd be.

    • @paulfrantizek102
      @paulfrantizek102 Před rokem +2

      It was probably still better than being assigned to crew a conventional towed AT gun.

    • @whirving
      @whirving Před 10 měsíci +2

      I remember an interview with a US soldier who made sure to point out how effective those "little tanks" were.

    • @user-fw3fq3de3z
      @user-fw3fq3de3z Před 10 měsíci

      id want a ferdinand

  • @briankrause2359
    @briankrause2359 Před 10 měsíci +3

    I always felt the Jagdpanzer 38t was the 'cute little sister' of the Jagd Panther... They share a lot of similarities in profile, but not size (or I assume deadliness...). I don't know why, must be some genetic markers left over from my grandparents/parents, but I still think German tanks look 'cool' in spite of all the awful events associated with WW2 and the Nazi Regime. I was recently at the Canadian War Museum in Ottawa and it had many WW2 vehicles, including Sherman/T-34 etc, but only standing beside the German armor (they have a Panther (Ausf A), Jagdpanzer IV, and PzKw 2) caused any primal excitement/awe.

  • @d.l.hemmingway3758
    @d.l.hemmingway3758 Před 10 měsíci +2

    You know since the US Marines are doing away or have done away with their tanks, but likely still need some sort of Direct Fire artillery for bunker busting and such perhaps a modern version of the Jagdpanzer 38t Hetzer should be developed.

  • @jamesdavis9569
    @jamesdavis9569 Před rokem +6

    That janitor is so fired.

  • @createdeccentricities6620

    Compact AFV with a powerful gun, but . . . gunner had to arch his body over the breech to load it, it was cramped, and I've heard that it leaked.

    • @obsidianjane4413
      @obsidianjane4413 Před rokem

      The ergonomic design was so bad you'd have to think it was subtle sabotage.

    • @Br1cht
      @Br1cht Před rokem

      Yes... We all have heard that several times.

  • @whirving
    @whirving Před 10 měsíci +1

    That is a scholar, Mr. Doyle.

  • @madigorfkgoogle9349
    @madigorfkgoogle9349 Před 10 měsíci +1

    haha, they never bothered to look under the paint of the barrel.
    In reality every single JPz.38t has a thread at the end of the barrel under a cover screwed on.
    It is a standard Pak.39 gun not any vehicle specialized KwK gun, it wasnt specially produced for the "Hetzer" and every Pak.39 had muzzle break screwed on as a standard feature.
    The prototype JPz.38t was even tested with the muzzle break, it was found out that its not needed since the most powerful ammo will not be used with "Hetzer" and the muzzle break is reveling the gun position much easier, so on production the muzzle break was omitted and the thread was covered by a simple mantle cover.
    There are also few photographs from war production in Czech factories, showing the production of JPz.38t where you can clearly see that every vehicle has the thread on the end of barrel. There is also a clip for German surrender, where you can see a passing by "Hetzer" with the muzzle break mounted on, so some commanders did use it (probably to lengthen the barrel life?). There are also some pictures from WWII field showing "Hetzer" with no thread cover mounted.

  • @65bravo
    @65bravo Před 8 měsíci +2

    The name "HETZER" can be found in original documents.

  • @marceletiennou5182
    @marceletiennou5182 Před 10 měsíci

    Encore en service dans l’armée suisse dans les années 70,80

  • @markbrandon7359
    @markbrandon7359 Před 10 měsíci

    Bruce Compton has a very early made 38T with the same gun mantlet

  • @markbrandon7359
    @markbrandon7359 Před 10 měsíci

    And Comptons 38T has a working remote MG

  • @stevebohlin7245
    @stevebohlin7245 Před 9 měsíci

    Hetzer was more a tank destroyer (panzerjager/jagdpanzer) than an assault gun (sturmgeschutz).

  • @Rich1ab
    @Rich1ab Před 10 měsíci

    OMG He mentioned modelers!!! Nerd Yay!

  • @princeofcupspoc9073
    @princeofcupspoc9073 Před 10 měsíci

    Just stopping by to say "IT'S NOT A HETZER." Thanks.

  • @obsidianjane4413
    @obsidianjane4413 Před rokem +1

    Very cool concept, poorly implemented. Its amazing the crews made the things effective at all.

    • @henryvagincourt4502
      @henryvagincourt4502 Před rokem +2

      Given the allied bombing, and the German circumstances, it's a fine vehicle, liked by the crews and did the business.

    • @travisrolison9646
      @travisrolison9646 Před 9 měsíci

      Silly nazis should have been building these and the stugs from the start with the 4 as the tank and then replace the 4 with panthers and tigers.
      They wasted so much by having so many types of vehicles and wastes on tiger 2s, jagtigers and such.

  • @Joe-bx4wn
    @Joe-bx4wn Před 17 dny +1

    Baby Sturmgeschutz

  • @joachim.r.6539
    @joachim.r.6539 Před 10 měsíci

    Was ein Käse,Dick und Doof bei der Arbeit.

  • @bluemouse5039
    @bluemouse5039 Před 6 měsíci

    How would you like to be a crew member inside the Hetzer in the summer time, 4 men hot and sweating in a cramped hot compartment with little ventilation maybe sitting in a ambush position for hours

  • @rdallas81
    @rdallas81 Před 10 měsíci

    Its a hertzer!
    Lol

  • @YamatoPower9000
    @YamatoPower9000 Před 10 měsíci

    That guy sitting there looks pretty dry... Could you give him a glass of water at least?

  • @blasperezybarra8737
    @blasperezybarra8737 Před 10 měsíci

    Never was called "Hetzer"

    • @chateaudesespoir1380
      @chateaudesespoir1380 Před 10 měsíci

      Incorrect, there is actual war time official documentation referring to the Hetzer

  • @randysurline4651
    @randysurline4651 Před 10 měsíci +1

    Us it. Still up techs the invaders coming for our women

  • @arnedeneeff1183
    @arnedeneeff1183 Před 10 měsíci +1

    Heard solar powered tanks are doing quite well in the Ukraine Russia war
    The wind powered didn’t go that well
    😂😂😂😂😂

  • @gregchijoff9959
    @gregchijoff9959 Před 10 měsíci +1

    Zelensky will take it! How much?

  • @rogerbourke5570
    @rogerbourke5570 Před 9 měsíci

    I hate to say this, but aren't these just old Nazi fanboys with trainspotter mentalities? What, actually, is so important about these vehicles? Discuss.

    • @rudithedog7534
      @rudithedog7534 Před 6 měsíci +2

      Strange thing to say from a person who actually sought out and watched this clip on German armour from WW2. Are you a closet fanboy too?

  • @guarmiron5557
    @guarmiron5557 Před 10 měsíci +1

    I knew a guy in the Free Masons who had become and officer in the German military in 1943. He ended up in Hetzers and in two years of fighting on the Eastern Front he had 3 of them knocked out from under him. He didn't loose any crewmen with the TDs that were killed under him so that speaks to the crew survivability of the vehicle. He said he liked the vehicle and that the gun was pretty good even against the more and more modern Soviet tanks that were appearing at the time.

    • @Tom_Quixote
      @Tom_Quixote Před 10 měsíci

      They were knocked out "under him"? Was he sitting on top?

    • @guarmiron5557
      @guarmiron5557 Před 10 měsíci +4

      I spent many years in tanks as an officer. In the mess all the commonwealth tank commanders (in their 60's reliving the old days) who had a tank killed under them would say it was knocked out from under them. Remember the cavalry longs for the old days with horses so a lot of the horse terminology remains in commonwealth tank units. I knew Rad well (Radley-Walters) and he told me the stories of having tanks knocked out from under him (the descriptor he used as well) including one time in which he woke up in a tree after being blown out his hatch.
      I assume my German friend (Hetzer platoon leader) in the Free Masons had just picked up on the terminology from his decades since the war spent in Canada.

    • @rdallas81
      @rdallas81 Před 10 měsíci +1

      ​@@guarmiron5557good words

  • @fransnilsson7333
    @fransnilsson7333 Před rokem +1

    Schweeden made a lot of those nazi weapons

    • @jamesh2321
      @jamesh2321 Před rokem +6

      the 38t as a light tank and as this tank destroyer were chiefly produced by Skoda, a Czech company.

    • @fransnilsson7333
      @fransnilsson7333 Před rokem

      @@jamesh2321 ..yupp and who owned Skoda

    • @jamesh2321
      @jamesh2321 Před rokem +5

      @@fransnilsson7333 what are you driving at? When founded, it was part of the Austro-Hungarian state. Pilsen, the HQ, eventually became part of the emergent Czechoslvak state. There were investors from Volkswagen at one point, and even interest from the Asian market, but there is no record of Swedish ownership. The Landswerk tanks that look like Skoda werks products were license built copies. Kinda like how everyone and their brother licensed the FT.

    • @mattbowden4996
      @mattbowden4996 Před rokem +4

      @@fransnilsson7333 The Czechs? Certainly not Sweden...

    • @fransnilsson7333
      @fransnilsson7333 Před rokem +1

      @@jamesh2321 You are right..i appologise...Scania-vabis delivered some engines to the THN export variant, and sweden built some 250+ on licens

  • @OIFIIIOIF-VET
    @OIFIIIOIF-VET Před 10 měsíci +2

    That beauty on the left........