Dr. Raghuram Rajan On BJP Vs. Congress, Vote Banks & More | Explosive Podcast | The Ranveer Show 383
Vložit
- čas přidán 31. 05. 2024
- Breaking The Mould: Reimagining India's Economic Future - amzn.to/3Uu2JEG
Check out BeerBiceps SkillHouse's Video Editing Course - bbsh.in/bb-yt-vem
Use my referral code OFF40 to get a 40% Discount on a standard membership subscription.
Follow BeerBiceps SkillHouse's Social Media Handles:
CZcams : / @beerbicepsskillhouse
Instagram : / beerbiceps_skillhouse
Website : bbsh.in/bb-launch-yt
For any other queries EMAIL: support@beerbicepsskillhouse.com
In case of any payment-related issues, kindly write to support@tagmango.com
Follow Dr. Raghuram Rajan's Social Media Handles:-
LinkedIn: www.linkedin.com/in/raghuram-...
Breaking The Mould: Reimagining India's Economic Future - www.penguin.co.in/book/breaki...
Breaking the Mould: Reimagining India's Economic Future - amzn.eu/d/durOUiS
🎧 Listen To #TheRanveerShow On Spotify:
open.spotify.com/show/6ZcvVBP...
Link to our blog: beerbiceps.com/
In this part two of the economic episode, we welcome again Dr. Raghuram Rajan. He is the former governor of the Reserve Bank Of India and an Indian Economist. Between 2003 and 2006 he was Chief Economist and director of research at the International Monetary Fund.
In this episode, we will talk about the 2024 politics and the election season that is coming up. We will break down how religion is one of the major factors in Indian politics and how it dictates the decisions of the majority of citizens. We will also talk about the positive and negative of the current government and why we need a strong opposition.
This was an in-depth conversation about economics with none other than the former RBI Governor Dr. Raghuram Rajan. I hope you will like this knowledge-packed conversation and do not forget to share your thoughts in the comments.
(0:00) - Dr. Raghuram Rajan x Ranveer Allahbadia begins
(3:50) - His chill time
(5:35) - Religion
(9:00) - What did China do wrong?
(11:00) - How religion is included in politics
(16:20) - Positives and negatives of the current government
(20:30) - Tourism vs. Infrastructure
(23:00) - Biggest shame for India
(30:00) - His work in India
(34:00) - Criticism for content creation
(39:04) - About Nitin Gadkari
(41:14) - Atal Bihari Vajpayee government
(42:50) - Manufacturing vs. Service sector
(50:58) - Improving India’s education system
(1:01:35) - What should be the government's steps?
(1:05:10) - Thank you for watching
(1:06:01) - End of the podcast
#rbigovernor #election
✅ Subscribe To Our Other CZcams Channels:-
Ranveer Allahbadia (Hindi Channel):
/ ranveerallahbadia
TRS Clips (English Podcast Highlights):
/ theranveershowclips
TRS Clips हिंदी (Hindi Podcast Highlights):
/ @theranveershowhindi
BeerBiceps Shorts (English Shorts):
/ @bestoftrs
Ranveer Allahbadia Shorts (Hindi Shorts):
/ @bestoftrshindi
RAAAZ. :
/ @raaazofficial
RAAAZ Shorts :
/ @raaazshorts
BigBrain Plus :
/ @bigbrain_plus
--
Camera- amzn.to/3tRdGSk
amzn.to/3XsbYVe
Lens- amzn.to/3i5K5SH
amzn.to/3TX9lrj
amzn.to/3Oxwz6h
amzn.to/3i8hWdB
amzn.to/3XkQOZ3
Mic- amzn.to/3XE6Hdl
amzn.to/3TZfIuf
Light- amzn.to/3GDSaYK
Podcast Equiments- amzn.to/3tRZ9pt
amzn.to/3GGQNZs
SSD- amzn.to/3TW4Ltj
--
INSTAGRAM : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
FACEBOOK : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TWITTER : @beerbicepsguy
/ beerbicepsguy
@TRSOriginals
/ trsoriginals
WHATSAPP: BeerBiceps
whatsapp.com/channel/0029VaA5...
LINKEDIN : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TELEGRAM: @beerbicepsguy
t.me/beerbicepsguy
SNAPCHAT: @beerbicepsguy
----------------------------------------------
About :
BeerBiceps by Ranveer Allahbadia is the ULTIMATE self-improvement & self-help channel. We began as a channel only for fitness & health enthusiasts. Eventually, we started covering topics such as fashion, grooming, personal finance, etiquette, meditation, mental health, communication skills & even entrepreneurship.
Today BeerBiceps is the home for The Ranveer Show or TRS. A show where we host the world's greatest success stories and try digging out their secrets to success. Every conversation on The Ranveer Show is intellectual, deep & informational. We cover everyone from entrepreneurs to Bollywood film stars to even athletes. Every conversation is an EXTREME learning experience for the viewer.
Click here to Join BeerBiceps SkillHouse Course : bbsh.in/launch-yt
It's funny how You mentioned of Religion but not of Caste Reservation.
Perfectly Sums up" I Don't care for any country but only myself until I'm getting profit".
@@jfxuivcdgyv9746 atleast you are hones,but not in support t
पकोड़ा तलने वाली मोदी इकोनॉमिक्स से देश गर्त में ही जाए गा !
2004 में जब मनमोहन सिंह की सरकार बनी तो भारत सरकार पर कुल कर्ज 17 लाख करोड़ रुपए था। 2014 तक तीन गुना से ज्यादा बढ़कर ये 55 लाख करोड़ रुपए हो गया। जो सितंबर 2023 तक बढ़कर 161 लाख करोड़ हो गया है। पिछले 9 साल में भारत सरकार पर 192% कर्ज बढ़ा। व्हाट्सएप यूनिवर्सिटी के जाहिल बकचोदों को देश पर बढ़ता कर्ज नही दिखता बल्कि the fastest Growing economy दिखती है । पकोड़ा तलने वाली मोदी इकोनॉमिक्स से देश गर्त में ही जाए गा !
2004 में जब मनमोहन सिंह की सरकार बनी तो भारत सरकार पर कुल कर्ज 17 लाख करोड़ रुपए था। 2014 तक तीन गुना से ज्यादा बढ़कर ये 55 लाख करोड़ रुपए हो गया। जो सितंबर 2023 तक बढ़कर 161 लाख करोड़ हो गया है। पिछले 9 साल में भारत सरकार पर 192% कर्ज बढ़ा। व्हाट्सएप यूनिवर्सिटी के जाहिल बकचोदों को देश पर बढ़ता कर्ज नही दिखता बल्कि the fastest Growing economy दिखती है । पकोड़ा तलने वाली मोदी इकोनॉमिक्स से देश गर्त में ही जाए गा !
Ranveer I'm a big fan of your podcast... I'm addicted now.... I have a request pls bring Annamalai on your show
Annamalai🍷🗿
Yes ranveer bhaiya. Vote for Annamalai sir❤
That'll be great, watch his ANI's podcast
Agreed
Yes Annamalai is more reachable I suppose than migratory RR Soros extensions
Get Romila Thappar. She will make Raghu look like a saint.
Are bhai😂😂😂
Hahaha 😅
Are mat karo she will Make pappu also look good fir Modi k votes cut hojayenge
😂😂
This is the problem with india. People are turning into unintellectual ,rigid Minds who want to go back to 1500s to claim lands. Wake up man ,do something useful for your family and this earth
Working population of India men+ women =600million.
You think 600million will be cooks, maids, IT, or sending abroad? Without manufacturing you cannot provide jobs.
I agree on prioritising education
India's manufacturing sector contribution to GDP reduced from 16% in 2015 to 13% in 2023. Please share where it has increased? Women participation in workforce is declining over years with participation at 19% in 2023. Having working population alone won't help.
65 Years of secular poverty 📉
VS
15 years of Hindutva Growth 📈
What I understood from what he meant to say is that if we focus more on improving the citizen's capabilities in terms of education, ease of access to healthcare, ease of starting MSMEs, etc. then way more jobs will be developed and economy will grow at a higher rate than if we just focus subsidising enterprises for setting up manufacturing plant. Manufacturing is still the main goal (in my opinion) in terms providing mass employment but, his way of reaching that goal differs from the current government.
Please correct me if you think otherwise.
Ask him why he is coming to India in elections period when he have greencard of USA. Is he george soros funded?
Goberbhakt spotted😂😂😂
@@hgddbnxshjkjgszcbmkkxsfhldwtug yeah proudly andhbhakt
ignore these non sensical people bro@@shoorveer1243
by now, its very obvious
Why not ??
MY be criticise govt when it's most needed .
This is the best interview of Dr. Raghuram Rajan I have seen off late. He seems calm and it's actually good to get to know him and his ideas better. Great job Ranveer!👍
Call Annamalai plzzzzzzz.
Noted 😊
@@BeerBicepsits serious demand bro
@@BeerBiceps Please 🙏
@@BeerBicepsIt's serious demand from we bengalis too
Yes Ranveer.... So much is going on even in the Agriculture field. We would love to hear about the growth in Agriculture in our country and what it's going to be in coming 10 -15 years
He is following rahul baba's policy of "mohabbat ki dukan". I think he is an economist and he should have been able to give a roadmap for economic prosperity of this country.
I think it’s important to have this type of conversation . We will not progress as a Nation by destroying opposition party. We know democracy will be hijacked soon with this type of behaviour.
@@bobyabraham1959Democracy is being experimented from last 200yrs. Otherwise human race had prosperity without democacy for quite a long period of history. 🙂
He gave a roadmap but not for WHICH IS STILL A SLAVE TO THE WEST
@@bobyabraham1959democracy cannot bring prosperity to this Huge populated country come out of that logic 😅
He is not an economist. He was the only non economist chief of IMF.
Great podcast; at one point Ranveer was ignorant by overemphasising the role of entrepreneurship but Raghuram sir corrected him saying that its only the govt. which can solve problems like malnutrition, education at a large scale. In my opinion, even social entrepreneurship can't be scaled enough to make an impact on a nationwide scale. NGOs are fine, but even if considering that they are effective, not corrupt, idealistic, they cannot enforce change at a scale that the govt can.
That guy predicted our GDP numbers below 5% because he does not like current govt ! Now numbers fly in his face ! When he was with RBI, there were scams in banks like PNB and YES ! what was he doing ?
People like him should be in charge of the country. His vision about our country's future and how to fulfil that dream is just amazing. The way he talks about education, malnutrition, employment problems and so on, is really rare. Hardly our ministers and our media discusses and does an healthy debate on these topics.
Thanks to TRS as well for bringing him on the show.
But where the WhatsApp university fanatics in our country ever believe what's good for our country and what is not. Whatever one-sided media feeds them, is what they take it as holy grail. If Person A has done something, then that person would've thought well for the country and done it. So let's not question person A. It's awful to see our country go down this path of complete blindsidedness. It almost feels as though an entire generation has lost the capability of cognitive thinking by the way you see certain people comment or react on reels/Twitter. It's deeply concerning how most are completely oblivious to whatever wrong is happening in our country. India is truly losing its prime years all behind foolish propoganda. Truly awful!
I totally agreee to you
He is a traitor. Behind the sophistry argument lies the detail ie pinning India down
In which world do you live in ??? This agent Raghuram tried to bring Islamic banking in India!!
He is bit confused and talking bookish knowledge, ofcourse in good English. Standing near garbage, he is talking about deodorant instead of cleanliness. If you will side Rahul Gandhi because you want a stronger opposition, then it shows your level of thoughts. No comments on his economic knowledge
Man I am a real fan of your podcasts!! please bring Annamalai to the show! It would be a very interesting podcast. thanks
Sir iam big fan of your podcast
Pls bring modi for interview and ask why your going for elections before you're opening temples and pulwama and china border issues and so many is there .But modi is afraid of interviews in this democracy
Okay, but for what bruh ?? What will be the benefit of that Conversation ?? If he bring Annamalai to the podcast the only things he'll be doing will be Praising Modi, Trash talk about Rahul Gandhi nd Oppositions and Finally it will be about " HINDU KATHRE ME HOON ", " HUMKO BUS RAM MANDIR CHALICE ", "HINDU RASHTRA BANNA CHAHIYE "... 🤢🤦♂️
65 Years of secular poverty 📉
VS
15 years of Hindutva Growth 📈
Please bring jai sai Deepak once again 🙏
He's being paid by Modi. Really? Him?
Nah he thinks he is a know it all
We need someone more grounded and humble
@@killersgraveif u don't have any proof, don't talk shit here
@@AbcDef-el9jl Child he doesn't respect Gandhiji, is not secular and he glorifies Modi's words like as if he created the constitution. I'm sure he's paid. He's a lawyer, he's educated. And educated people don't vote for Modi
Sai Deepak for sure. Need him
I have a request pls bring Annamalai on your show .... i really want to know his view and is personality
Good and watch Tamil channels of so much interested
@@MrAyanakanti One cannot understand Tamil. Why don't you learn hindi, sire?
@@arpan9937LEARN TAMIL 😂😂😂
@@blablablaclaclacla9895 not interested, it's inferior to English.
@@arpan9937 YOU MUST BE FROM THE SUPERIOR RACE OF ARYANS OR NAZIS 😂😂😂😂
Interviewer don't have idea what to ask whom and don't know reality of the ground if you have another 1 podcast with him asked him why there are policymaking institutions like CPR were funded by west to be specific Bill gate and others when somebody is funding thise institutions how does it affect Indias geopolitics. Why there are only left loby who are controlling policymaking institutions with also nepo kinds were involved and when you are supporting congress the best secular party according to him doesn't it compromised Indias sovereign right to dicigen making. ( Now i offcourse will look like sanghi to RRR ) 🤝👍🙏
This guy is an good author but a failed economist
Sanghi spotted! Ur questioning an ex RBI Governor about his credibility. He was also a research director at IMF. He is no joke man. Just coz he is speaking against ur BJP’s BS demonetisation wont make him a failed economist suddenly. Isliye bolthe padayi Karo… Infact Modi failed miserably with demonetisation… It dint do shit to black money and no one got 15 lakhs in their account. Jumlebaaz party
@@sp3949Congress promised aloo Dalo sona niklega machine... Please tell them to release it 😉
@@arnavsharma2635 bhai tu ek bar crash course ki philosophy playlist dekh le fir tujhe thodi akal ayegi
@@arnavsharma2635 lol! 😂 Do some fact checking on what he said in that meeting! Not the edited clips released by your IT cell comrades!!
Please release spiritual podcast. Also waiting for another Rajarshee Nandy podcast
Soon
Yes Rajashi Nandy sir❤❤
Rajashi Nandy sir❤❤
Please release early
@@BeerBicepspls bring ex muslim sahil to show true face of quran like ayaat 9.29, 9.123, 9.5 talks about killing non Muslims, 2.223 woman is farmland, allowance of sex slavery (laundiya) in 23.6 etc...
I once had a boss in the US who told me that if you haven't been fired then you have pushed your boundaries and limitations hard enough! You gained a follower and a fan with this podcast. I think the Indian brain trust is the country's biggest asset. We need to allow all voices to have a say (like what you have built within your organization). Dissent, debate, discussion and dialogue is the need of the hour!!
Thanks Ranveer for giving every side a voice and bringing such a highly respected economist on your platform . You always seem to be able to conduct your interviews so respectfully and effortlessly . Please continue doing interviews with good content . TRS clips does not do justice to content oriented interviews .
Yeh paid garbage ko kyo weightage de yaar
Dr Rahguram Ram Rajan is respected world over as a great economist. I dont know how much of a politician he is. His views I feel are utopian. We all know that open dialogue is the way forward for any democracy and for a country like India that aspires to be a first world country by 2047, but I doubt it’s going to happen. Not being pessimistic but writing a book about how to fix the system is not going to fix it. You have to get into the system to have any chance of fixing it and he is honestly an outsider right now
Good thing he is an outsider, TBH. I hope forever.
@@CakeorDeath420hhaa
The guy who suggests govt to print more money during Pandemic is a great economist?
A politician can never be an economist & vice versa. So both need independently to run a country successfully with out any interference.
@@RajeshGupta-nf9vn You are right but in reality there is always interference and no autonomy for the economist to work independently of the politician in power.
Raghuram Rajan talking about BJP running Centralized decision making while conveniently forgetting UPA was openly ran from Sonia's chapel at 10 Janpath
Tu kya BJP ka representative aur spokesperson hain, chatu gawar bhakt? Godi-media dekhte-dekhte brain-cell saad gya kya?
Bhai sarkar nda ki chal rhi toh criticize bhi usko ho karega na, har 2 second upa ka bhi verdict thodi dega same chiz ka
ur answer is a logical fallacy. read about logical fallacies.
Chhota politician spotted😅
actually there is no evidence of this happening... @sreenag1560
What Dr. Rajan is saying is that it's the journey that makes the difference. It's not how fast you reach the end by getting to the fastest growing economy, but make everyone increase their standard of living.
His explanation about how Nokia's manufacturing plant wasn't of much use to us was very useful. Kudos !!!! .
Ranveer is really good in podcasting. He knows how to carry on with a guest for a long amount of time and that is why I love watching this podcast.
Thanku so much for this wonderful podcast ❤️ ❤
I am so surprised RR does not seem to find anything good in what this Govt is doing - all the progress that has been made.
Criticism should be welcome in any democracy
@@GaneshJayaramanTheOne True - and that is why RR can speak so freely. His criticisms would appear more balanced if he acknowledges all the progress under the BJP. This is more visible to the India diaspora in the West -- where the regard for India has gone up dramatically after the BJP took over from the Congress. Its not just Modi (highest approval ratings of any leader of a major country) -- Jaishankar and many others in BJP.
@@pmundkur he spoke about direct benefits and infrastructure projects etc etc
@@GaneshJayaramanTheOneeven praises can be welcomed …
@@ginnip8670 govt should always do better, everyone need not be a cheerleader
Rajan makes some good points. The big missing element is the current geopolitics and what, if anything, he could have done if he were part of the government. The fact that he is working with the Tamilnadu government is interesting to say the least ;-)
Not just the “Dravida” gang of Tamil Nadu but he’s also with the Wokist new outfit called “Kria University” which is essentially Adharma🛑
he is a congress sellout thus he went to tamil nadu government to get something.
Thank You Ranveer.. In terms of long Run if Decentralisation can not be done then Police and Administration Services needs to be reformed and on urgency basis given Independent Power for Education, Health care development..
57:01 manufacturing in china has come with a huge cost to the peoples rights in those factories in terms of problematic work hours and such. It makes sense that indians prefer services that is a much more respected job. Shows our ambition i feel
Yes dont follow this harward guy follow what u believe in
How will you build self sufficiency if you only do services? If a war breaks out with China and they stop supply- your economy and life will collapse. Why else do you think the West is diversifying supply chains? With advent of AI the number of ppl employed by services jobs will become lower and lower - who will employ our 130 Crore ppl?
Raghuram Rajan is either deluded idiot or a biased propagandist of the Congress or likely both. We all know he hated being kicked out for trying to be independent while Modi is not the kind of person to take too many opinions. Butthurt RR is now aggressively coming and promoting books and podcasts with an anti Modi narrative - consume everything he says with a big table spoon of salt. Did you see him on the Bharat Yodo Yatra discussing economics with that Nincompoop?
Dr.Raghu Ram Rajan has helped congress Parivar more good than to serve people of this country. You may agree or disagree but The Fact and the results shouting out loud and the difference is clear. He might be a good economist but not a decision maker or leader. HE could not make independent decisions in his era. He had to abide by Sonia Ghandhi. FACT FACT.📃
Could you elaborate? Perhaps give your sources for these "Facts".
Because if you had see the previous podcast he did with ranveer, you'd know the policies and reforms he implemented during his time as governor that were directly taken from the recommendations he made in reports during his time as the chief economic advisor.
@@prakharmishra4453 they are speaking other words with their mouth. They don't have full knowledge about this statements and they just paste it any where for criticism. They don't have specific sources for their claims.
@@prakharmishra4453 policies and reforms he said are half lies, he doesn't have the vision for India that's why he resigned and left and now is coming back for the election time period. he is clearly abided by the congress as he also joined pappu in bjy
read the recently released white paper in parliament you will understand how he performed. @@prakharmishra4453
The fact is that there is democratic backsliding under BJP.
Congress party is a private limited company led by Gandhi family 😂. They failed as opposition.
they failed as a party , congress is still only party which can get votes irrespective of vote bank but ek parivar kee gulami unko yahaan tak le aayi
How have they failed as an opposition ?
@@MandeepSingh-bv2zw is that a rhetorical question?
BJP hasn't held a leadership election since a long time. Bjp President Nadda has already exceeded the 6 year term allowed by the party constitution. Still no election. Whereas Congress has already publicly conducted a leadership election with Kharge winning it. Look who's talking about democracy!
@@justanotherview3243so Your saying the Most popular person in Congress who got voted internally was TRULY - KHARGE ?? Are YOU HIGH Or just that NAIVE?
Wonderful conversation, and its good to hear from the man himself. Great respect for Dr. Raghuram Rajan. Its like reading from a book listening to him first hand 😊
You mentioned Hindutva that's fine.
Now let's talk about Caste based reservation and let's see how good our Country is
so true. This is a cancer that has spread too far and is hindrance to country’s progress.
Bhai zyada tar sc st ki seat to khali hi rehti h
I watched first episode. It was fantastic conversation to extent of Economics. Even though he was trying to mask his ideology don’t think it came out well 😊. On another note , Ranveer you are hitting new levels with your podcast. More power to you buddy. May you grow from strength to strength.
I hope Dr. Rajan joins Congress and implement all his beautiful visions on secularism, democracy etc. Hope he succeeds in Congress and not be superseded by the Gandhi family. Good luck to him ;)
Listening to Mr Raghuram Rajan speak in this 2 part podcast has broadened my horizons.
Kudos to Ranveer and his entire team for delivering such high quality content to us.
Keep up the good work 👍
Please bring Annamalai. Ranveer bhaiyya we are waiting for Annamalai sir
How can someone mistake him for anything else. One of the smartest, nation loving, thoughtful, proud hindu I have ever heard. Even thought I am not a hindu, All the positivity, love for the religion i have gained is from ppl like him and on the other hand, Modi, BJP, RSS take me away from hinduism.
good one, a lot of varied perspective
Bro I don't know when I became addicted to your podcasts.... Your geopolitical podcasts help me a lot for my SSB preparation
Glad to hear that. All the best ❤
A talented economics 😂😂😂
@BeerBiceps bhai please do a podcast with ashwini upadhyay please ranveer bhai please india need ashwini upadhyay to come to every podcast and you'll be amazed by his PIL's file
good talk.. this guy makes so much of sense.
Bhai do a podcast with shubhash palekar who dedicated his life for farming in natural way. Youth are not choosing farming as a career while no. Of farmers declining year by year which may result serious food crisis in future
Number of farmers is not decreasing
When you can't counter a person's argument, target the person. Most of the people who are commenting on this video have not watched the whole video.
It was a very good fairly non biased conversation.
❤
A podcast on indian diaspora as to why people leave, where do they go, what they contribute and which sectors, why they come back, and how do they reintegrate?
why people want foreign citizenship and then want to return to India. Many have children abroad then want to come back.
He is comparing our uni with China but conveniently misses that in China 100% admissions are based on merit and in India only 40% are based on merit and rest are reserved.
Can you say casteism and casteist mentality of majority of people ended? No one wants reservation, but the still majority of lower are suppressed. The day this bs ends reservation ends.
@@Quangrav10....it never ends ......but u people are ok with who got job with 30 marks instead of good merit
@@pavanmallela3451so you are okay with some castes not given education, no resources to compete with upper caste who have controlled everything for thousands of years.
Abe gadhe China mei caste system nhi tha aur wha religion bhi non existent hai, majority population atheist hai. Ek baat aur, wha zada govt ke against bolega toh jail mei daal bhi denge
RR views are so logical. Wish our politicians could pick his brains, implement his ideas so that the lot of our people will improve .
Beautiful analogy between foxcon and apple. Lot of our people are involved in design engineering however not in india. What we need to ensure is to not have intellectual property in india but to retain our talent in india
Technocrats must stick to technocratic discussion rather than enter into political thought, like participating in Bharat jodo Yatra. It helps make their case of neutrality and removing prejudice
The only topic TRS podcast did not touched is agriculture. Podcasts on spirituality, finance, army, startups, geopolitics, politics, history but not agriculture why?
It takes courage to ask such questions man.
Really nice to see bright minds like Dr. Raghuram Rajan share their thoughts.
I think Raghuram Rajan’s thinking is flawed looking at the current state of affairs in India.
He is thinking long term like a professor sitting among the elite intellectuals. Talking of focusing on high end research & design in India, etc. instead of focusing on manufacturing as an immediate solution.
My question to him is that, Are we treating services like a step child and discouraging growth there? NO
We have never discouraged IT / services sector to do research & innovation in India. They are strong enough and growing at full steam on their own. Government has not discouraged them.
On manufacturing his argument is that we are overspending through subsidies in PLI scheme for low end value addition assembling. Hence government should remove its emphasis from there.
He is not looking at the current state of the ‘quality of demography’ in India who want millions of jobs. Millions in rural agriculture sector need to move out to some other livelihood. Remember these guys are inadequately educated / skilled. They are not suitable to for high end IT sector/ R&D, etc. jobs.
The only sector which can absorb these people in short term and medium term is low skilled jobs in manufacturing. Services cannot offer them jobs (except low end ones like cleaners, watchman, etc.). Hence what does the government do in short & medium term to solve the impending crisis?
This problem of short & medium term doesn’t even come to his mind. He is in his euphoria and talking of long term growth solutions which I agree should be the ultimate goals India needs to aspire for.
He is talking like a consultant who has never worked on a shop floor, giving impractical solutions to the supervisor there.
His question on Why private investment is not happening in India? Simple answer is reform labour laws to allow ‘hire & fire’ in manufacturing. This will enable large manufacturing to shift out of china to India instead of going to Vietnam & Bangladesh. In India manufacturing wants to remain MSME scale so that they remain invisible to the inspector raj of labour department. This is where government has done nothing. Government should be focusing on removing restrictions in the labour laws. Large scale manufacturing will automatically move to India from China providing short & medium term solution for the job market for next 20 years. By then India should be ready for the phase what Raghuram Rajan is aspiring for.
We need to be practical in our approach.
@@shrishri8898 I have worked in the Textile industry at CEO & Board of Director level position in the leading Textile mills in India. I am now retired since past 4 years.
I have seen the gradual & consistent closure of large-scale units - 80 mills in Mumbai & 60 mills in Ahmedabad, and so many other cities like Kanpur, Calcutta, Coimbatore, Gwalior, Delhi, etc. This happened after the famous Dutta Samat strike in the year 1980. It happened for the simple reason that "hire & Fire" was prohibited by then Prime Minister Mrs. Indira Gandhi by amending the 'Industrial Disputes Act-1947' during Emergency in 1976.
Are you aware that even today, you cannot LAYOFF, Retrench or close an industrial unit employing more than 300 workers unless you get the permission from the Government. Which never comes.
Hence from 1980s India lost out to China in manufacturing due to these very reasons. India jumped on the band wagon of Service - IT Sector as no such stringent conditions of not allowing "Hire & Fire" apply there as they fall under "Shops & Establishment Act."
It is a pity that no one talks of this root cause of stringent labor laws. Large scale units have practically vanished from labor intensive industries. Most of them are MSME scale of operations. Large Scale units only remain in industries which have high level of automation & Robotics deploying very less labor compliment.
What does it say when a so called economist who is asked about positives and negatives, picks up Majoritarism as his first point. I would expect him to highlight about economics the areas for improvement.
And he doesn’t stop with “majoritarianism” but he peddles SICKularism too❗️
He brought MANIPUR , Hunger index, targeting Opposition…. 😂
Ranveer, you are doing a great job. Very valuable challenging arguments and insights.
Hey ranveer, I've had the privilege of watching nearly all of your enlightening videos, each a treasure trove of wisdom for the young and old alike. I suggest creating short takeaway notes from each video to add even more value for your viewers. It might take time, but it's definitely worth considering.
You said at last that you need to see how it pans out and then adjust, but then when the govt adjusts, you say that they don't have consistentcy in their policy? What should the govt do in this case?
RR seems to be mellowed out, looks like somehow he wants to be back in BJP books post seeing future of congress😂.
More than his congress affiliation i am skeptical about his Deep state connections.
In his regime due to inflation destroyed MSME the biggest job generator sector in India, yet he is mum about it.
Why there is no question about ills of congress rule?
It is so heartening to see you set a cultural benchmark for young people in India. As an educator and psychologist, I feel a deep sense of concern for the student community in India. The education system has more often than not killed their curiosity and hunger for knowledge and personal development. Your podcast is novel because it connects young talent to their real world contexts. It helps them identify problems, think critically, and imagine solutions. It brings in the wisdom of the greatest teachers in different domains. This is real education. Best wishes! You bring hope.
Can you please invite Nina Aouilk? She is a survivor and activist on honor killing, and her story must be heard. This practice is still happening to so many girls and women around the world…
This conversation could have been a lot more focused.
It's bad enough that much of it is superfluous, much of it is also rhetorical on the obvious, not forgetting some of it are outright contradictory (in a circle).
Questions should have been off of g'ment statistics and there are plenty of it to go by too - enough for a 10-hour session at least.
An as ex entrepreneur and manufacturer of EVs, it took us 8 months to get a GST Refund. S56 of the CGST Act mandates it to be done in 60days. This is 1 instance which has added to my dying hopes of manufacturing. Unlike services, manufacturing involves a lot of interfaces with both state & central govts.
Decent conversation. I am from Quetta and have no intention to comment on internal Indian politics. Here to learn from a scholar and from an intelligent host. Dr Raghuram's comments about communal tensions (Manipur) having economic root causes (jobless growth, limited opportunities) resonates. Balochistan has experienced the same in the 1990s. His comment about the tendency to fetishize manufacturing at the expense of other avenues of growth is also wise. So is his emphasis on the role of government as an enabler for unleashing a society's true potential...which requires a focus on issues like child malnutrition, education and health. As someone from Quetta, it saddens me. We are so similar. But we can't benefit from each other's wisdom and shared heritage.
A good show, Ranveer. You were almost sucked into the rightwing eco chamber but the Indian spirit, the decency, the kindness in you live. Stay blessed.
Faraz
When any person speaks opposite of BJP people: *"Let me highlight all the failures of this man as he is highlighting Bjps failures"*
Well said❤👍🏻
Why not? 🤔
It is all sided.
Do u think Congress or any local party supporters would honour the person who speaks against their leaders? Look, how Congress leaders brutally trolled Gulam Nabi & others for giving the right feedback.
But you people think ONLY BJP is like this. BJP is far better in comparison to other parties.b
@@Agnosticc As a Indian citizen your loyalty should lie with you country, not some political party. When you vote, your vote should be for the interest of the nation, not to make a part win.
That requires taking criticism for whoever is in the current govt. That's the only way to hold them accountable.
When the masses prioritise a political party over the country you get a totalitarian regime, who serves only itself not the people.
Don't be naive.
@@prakharmishra4453 excalty
Thanks for this podcast🙏🏻❤
My pleasure 🙏🏻❤️
Thanks for the video
In India Ram a d Rahim live in Peace.Dr,You are real
Raghu Ram,icon of real dharma...
Dr, Iam not an Economist, but read your wonderful book on Reimaging Indias Economic future..
Really admire your gut and grit ,zeal and zest...
Your opinion on the characteristics of an authoritarian got.. Wow you have in your mind the present scenario...India need such hi fy, Sci fy technocrats to take India go high...to scale the sky....
Tributes and salutes for your contributes..
Expect more from you in the up coming years
Jay Shree Ram
Jay Shree Ram 🙏🏻❤
Jay Shree Ram🙏🏻❤
Jay Shree Ram🙏🏻❤
@@Trendo839 Jay Shree Ram ❤🙏
Jay Shree Ram❤🙏
1:06:40 appreciate the effort to remain centrist. One suggestion i would have is bring more moderate and centrist people. U mentioned u bring extreme right and extreme left but maybe moderates need to be amplified. Concept of the overton window is something I have also been thinking about so maybe that will be useful. Loving the conversations on both channels. Definitely expands my viewpoints and made me more tolerant to a certain side haha. Faves are the doctor podcasts and the politicians since both are people u dont hear much from. Getting into the military podcasts at the moment.
I thiught RRR lost his mind while watching him on X.
But he got some sensible points!
I back him in some areas of improvement which our country is needed.
Working at the Development Monitoring & Evaluation Office, NITI Aayog it was fun to hear about evaluation's importance in policy making. So much to say on this topic. Uffff 😃😃😃
Greate podcasts, helps to develope a overall knowledge about the poliotics & economy.
Please bring HG Amarendra Prabhu 🙏❤️
Great episode. Learned so much in a single podcast about economics, governance and many more issues, explained in such a simple way. I have always been a great admirer of Dr. Rajan, powerhouse of knowledge, humble and inspirational.
from 2004 to 2014 no specific projects were even thought of for improving nutrition of children...Even prior to 2004 there are no specific projects to improve the nutrition since independence...
That's a knowledgeable podcast ever ranveer 🥰😍
Thank you for watching 🙏🏻❤️
Epic episode Ranveer. The episode brings in such a fresh perspective.
This was the best, the most honest and meaning full episode I have seen till date the points were clear and the opinions were not biased at all both the parts were all about our country and how can the government can improve the lives of the poor and common man.
Sir Raghuram Rajan always appreciated your thoughts your are really an idol to many
Can you make a video on Yuri bezmenov ideological subversion of Bharat please 😢
He is a hardcore modi hater
This was your best pod cast, engaging and informing from start to end.
What a lovely podcast! Because it has given me so many topics to reflect on!
Is he the same person, who was saying, why India want to be superpower, and India should not become a superpower.😅Very non sensible 😂.
I think India should come to manufacturing heavily, and also work on soft skills😊
Our Country need intellectual men like Raghuram Rajan 👍🇮🇳
hahahahahaha!
No he better be there in US
Couldn’t leave the conversation in between. Addressing Malnutrition and improving education should be primary goal of country. Room for criticism is must and it’s positive to take it as a constructive feedback. Best thing to know that you are applying it in your work. Good work team🎊🎉👍👏
Understanding the Apple-Foxconn Employment Ratio
Apple, with a market capitalization of $3 trillion, employs around 160,000. Foxconn, with a market value of about $50 billion, employs approximately 770,000 workers. For every employee at Apple, Foxconn employs nearly 300 people. This ratio starkly illustrates the vast difference in job creation potential between the high-tech and manufacturing sectors.
The Implications of the 1 to 300 Ratio. This discrepancy underscores the essential truth that, for developing economies like India, industries capable of employing large numbers of people are invaluable for economic development and social stability.
Ok, but the billion dollars subsidy being given to micron would only employ 5-10K people "directly"...
Indirect employment in this comparison could be more in the case of high tech manufacturing due more influx of money....
Always a Learning experience to hear Raghuram sir 😊 He's the best in the Business !!
Hope you enjoy this conversation
One more podcast ft. Suits Allahbadia ❤❤🧿🧿. Was waiting for valentines day special solo podcast but even this is 🎉🎉
Thank you for watching ❤
Ranveer ji, always a great knowledge take away in your Podcasts. And you have become a huge platform too as your intellectual Public outreach is enormous. Much Power to you. I hope Annamalai and Annamalai like figures from states like Telangana, WB, Kerala etc come up for a podcast too..
For manufacturing to thrive, in my opinion, some things that are required to be done are :-
1. Skilled manpower
2. Easy finance
3. Less regulation on all fronts
4. Efficient justice delivery system
5. Corruption free environment so that there is level playing field for competition to thrive and no crony capitalism
6. Top Universities which invest in innovation and partnership with industry
7. Huge markets (Domestic and / or International)
8. Good infrastructure and logistic support
9. Tax regime that promotes and incentivizes productivity
10. Economic environment that promotes savings and attracts investments from across the world
J Sai Deepak Part 2 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Hopefully soon 🤞🏻
For many of us, seeing mr. Ranjan with raga on his silly picnic walks across India, was more than enough to primarily dismiss him and his views..
Spot on 👍
It will be great, if the content creators can make subtitles in all Indian major languages so the common people can get educated as well !!!
One of the finest podcasts ever heard really amazing and it was like a knowledge bank we were heard.
BJP bots are getting triggered in comments for no reason.
We are Indians above every political affiliation or leaning, remember that.
Jay hind ❤
Jay Hind 🙏🏻❤️
Beautifully done 👍🏻❤
RRR knows stuff he's mostly practical but still he leans towards Rahul saros syndicate
Glad to hear him again
Enjoy 😊
Can u bring pm modi ??😁😁
Abhi possible nahi..
Modiji jab retirement le lenge..maybe then possible..
Then republic tv will control the narrative😂
People are waiting for him since 10 years to ask unscripted questions
No - he is beyond garbage called Beer Biceps’ the only person who is worse than Rahul is Ranveer! Such nonsense absolute nonsense this is! Unbelievable that such garbage is being dumped on viewers
Exactly what we need in our country.... Every time there is political debate on social media its about religion coz its easy to gain votes. But the solution for India to grow is to focus on the fundamental development, Jobs, education, Research These are the things we need. We need to see and work on the strength we have. India is capable of producing million of services coz we have the great minds, But this will only work if it is converged in a sustainable manner, More Private sector should participate in education system coz there are so many students and competition is in every field... and to aid that Government should encourage... So its a mutual helping of both Public and Private sector... Good education= new innovation= new jobs so R&D should be encouraged
Even I was thinking that Ranvir was picking up a pro-government line. But I am happy to see that I was wrong. Hats off for the right questions, Ranvir.
who said govt is not focusing in service sector? at this point he is just saying anything to criticise the govt.
One of my favourite person .