THAT chord progression and the only FOUR alternatives that really work

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 11. 07. 2019
  • 'How To Write Music' takes you through the whole process from inspiration to final piece. Award-winning composer Guy Michelmore outlines a systematic, straight forward approach to writing music. It gives you a structure and a workflow. So if you are struggling with how to write better tunes, or how to write a chord progression, how to finish a tune, any of these really common problems for anyone writing music, this guide will get you started.
    Getting Started With Music Theory: Free course!
    A brand new mini-series, teaching you the basics of music theory.
    Sign up here: thinkspaceeducation.com/signu...

Komentáře • 504

  • @ThinkSpaceEducation
    @ThinkSpaceEducation  Před 3 lety +3

    Getting Started With Music Theory: Free course!
    A brand new mini-series, teaching you the basics of music theory.
    Sign up here: thinkspaceeducation.com/signup/getting-started-with-music-theory/

  • @NullCreativityMusic
    @NullCreativityMusic Před 4 lety +476

    The music teacher that we wanted in high school but didn't get!

    • @sereanaduwai8313
      @sereanaduwai8313 Před 4 lety +5

      Absolutely.

    • @iliatilev
      @iliatilev Před 4 lety +4

      We didn't have music in my high school.. 😢

    • @pinkponyofprey1965
      @pinkponyofprey1965 Před 4 lety +2

      Oh, man, the memories of music in school just hurts! :(

    • @PaulBrownclk-me
      @PaulBrownclk-me Před 4 lety +4

      Both my main schools .. had music teachers that sucked ass.. (hope they are reading this) which is a shame because I'd have loved to learn music back then... But it's never too late!!

    •  Před 4 lety +4

      Most high-school music teachers took the only job they were possibly qualified to do. Those qualifications did not include personality, enthusiasm or the ability to motivate.

  • @samlee2562
    @samlee2562 Před 4 lety +256

    the progressions that don't end on a 4 or 5 chord tend to sound unresolved and are therefore potentially useful for a pre-chorus or bridge or a song that's supposed to sound unresolved 😉

    • @tristanbach4421
      @tristanbach4421 Před 4 lety +20

      I was thinking the exact same thing. And 6, 5, 4, 1 sounds like the end of a song.

    • @TheWorld_2099
      @TheWorld_2099 Před 4 lety +9

      Sam Lee - that’s exactly right..!
      After three patterns of four, you switch it up and go to the minor, and that’s a great transition to a different section.

    • @jamg6311
      @jamg6311 Před 4 lety +1

      Good point!

    • @davidpetersonharvey
      @davidpetersonharvey Před 4 lety +6

      @@tristanbach4421 right, the plagal cadence is totally acceptable, even though the perfect authentic cadence gives a stronger sense of resolution and finality. Wouldn't music be boring if we always did things the same way?

    • @megapolice1280
      @megapolice1280 Před 4 lety +1

      On 4 or 5 only in functional harmony. In modal , "cadances" placed not only at 4th or 5th step

  • @tfmarketing12
    @tfmarketing12 Před rokem +8

    Parents, if at all possible, give your children the gift of music. Your kids might find music lessons boring and tiresome at times, but they'll appreciate it when they get older. I wish I had learned this stuff when I was a child. And Mr. Michelmore, thank you for sharing your gift and your knowledge with us. 🙏

  • @whoisandrewblack5679
    @whoisandrewblack5679 Před 4 lety +51

    Checked out when he thought 6154 didn’t quite work. Off the top of my head “Hello”-Adele.
    Lot of personal interpretation here.

    • @Deodouranth
      @Deodouranth Před 4 lety +3

      I think I can make a one-chord song work with Adele though...

    • @jadeone
      @jadeone Před 4 lety

      Thomas Avasol yeah i’m not an adele fan really but she could sing on anything and it would be a lmao

    • @danzirvine
      @danzirvine Před 3 lety

      @SunTai its also the chord progression of taio cruz's song dynamite.

  • @Ultima2876
    @Ultima2876 Před 4 lety +119

    “This doesn’t work” 1 4 5 6. Tell that to the Trance people who use that progression in EVERY TRACK

    • @domwujek8900
      @domwujek8900 Před 4 lety +11

      They wont listen

    • @mehcustom24
      @mehcustom24 Před 4 lety +7

      yeah dude there are so many of these that apparently aren't "viable", but are used in so many top 40 and EDM tracks.

    • @sayyyyid
      @sayyyyid Před 4 lety +1

      @@mehcustom24 you right in fact it sounds like EVERY prog house song ever lmao

    • @shanefiddle
      @shanefiddle Před 4 lety

      lol!

    • @32herz
      @32herz Před 4 lety +1

      :D I picked up that to, "the EDM Progression"

  • @ChrisDN
    @ChrisDN Před 4 lety +268

    Yea, they all work.
    I really dislike the phrase, "not viable".
    It's all about context and how you use them.
    I often worry that some people--particularly beginners--will take these kinds of video as fact.

    • @gepvpr
      @gepvpr Před 4 lety +4

      but it is fact, at the same time it isnt

    • @TheWorld_2099
      @TheWorld_2099 Před 4 lety +4

      Chris Norris - agreed, absolutely. Guidance is good, dogma isn’t.
      I am not implying that the composer in the video is being dogmatic, I’m speaking generally.

    • @jamg6311
      @jamg6311 Před 4 lety +6

      Agreed and what happens when you pair it with another combination but resolve it before you get back to the start.

    • @timeWaster76
      @timeWaster76 Před 4 lety +3

      This kind of analysis is stifling

    • @davidpetersonharvey
      @davidpetersonharvey Před 4 lety +18

      Right, because he's auditioning them in root position only and you get a different flavor using inversions to keep your cord times closer together. I imagine many of the others would be very useful if we didn't have the parallel fifth movement dragging them down.

  • @facteurkaloun
    @facteurkaloun Před 4 lety +1

    Great ! I'm litterally falling in love with this channel. I wish i could have such a teacher when i was at school. He proves that teaching music theory is not bound to be boring. Thank you very much. I am considering to buy the online course next month. Never too late to learn :)

  • @chrisjung5952
    @chrisjung5952 Před 4 lety

    Just discovered your channel and I quite enjoy it. I’ve been plinking around for years on keyboards without the vocabulary and theory to understand music properly. I find your approach understandable and fun. Keep up the great work!

  • @stevenpratt6986
    @stevenpratt6986 Před 4 lety +2

    I've been meaning to get around to exactly this experiment, thanks for doing a great job on it.
    New sub!

  • @DopamineOverload
    @DopamineOverload Před 4 lety +1

    Love every second of your videos. Utter brilliance, and useful info. Completely.

  • @7775Kevin
    @7775Kevin Před 3 lety

    Love your videos. Thanks for this one!

  • @craigsusen5551
    @craigsusen5551 Před 4 lety +1

    I can literally watch you do stuff like this all day. Carry on please.

  • @CraigDG
    @CraigDG Před 4 lety

    You're delivery is fun, random and ad lib and I love it. Glad I found this channel. Throughout my songwriting career which has spanned approx 38 years, I have more often than not tried to avoid this chord progression, simply because I prefer to write complex pop melodies away from the predictable, but that still work melodically. I really don't pull any influence at all from the 50s or 60s, or twelve bar blues music, which I guess is why my style is a little left of centre. Having said that, my personal listening taste does mean toward easy to listen to pop and ballads from the 70s and 80s. When all is said and done you can write a shitload of variations of melody from the norm f you really spend quality time on your songs. And this is always my aim when writing a new work..

  • @rodterrell304
    @rodterrell304 Před 4 lety

    I am so glad I found your channel because as an older musician/composer ,its good to see someone that knows DAW that I can relate to. I see you are using Cubase and I've started using it also. Thanks for the great tips and ideas.

  • @AtixaOfficial
    @AtixaOfficial Před 4 lety

    Thank you, good information, helped me to understand chords and how they work better! :)

  • @louisphilippemusic
    @louisphilippemusic Před 3 lety

    Thanks for this video , i really love this channel , its help me understand better about music theory

  • @producermz5694
    @producermz5694 Před 4 lety

    There's nothing quite like ending my day listening to an educated, well spoken and kind individual exploring the fundamentals of music. Thank you sincerely for sharing your perspectives and experience.

  • @synthartist69
    @synthartist69 Před 4 lety +28

    Many of the progressions that Don't Work for you actually do work when you combine those with progressions that Do Work for you.

    • @TheWorld_2099
      @TheWorld_2099 Před 4 lety

      synthartist69 - haha...!
      Well there it is: Chords that do and don’t ‘work for you’

    • @rickeyjones729
      @rickeyjones729 Před 4 lety

      That's the biggest part of music that should be taught were trying to find u..... and how u make it work there just concepts u can create so much when u take away the can't a d just play.

    • @digitig
      @digitig Před 4 lety +1

      His point is about sequences that work in a loop. Lots of them work of they're moving you to somewhere else.

  • @StephenOlner
    @StephenOlner Před 4 lety

    What an awesome lesson and the enthusiasm was inspiring !

  • @capthook1
    @capthook1 Před 4 lety

    Thank you, great vid! Don’t forget the many different contexts in which these progressions can be applied. The different sequences can be used for different types of cadences and also build ups, and then that unresolved feeling can work perfectly.

  • @robertbarner7626
    @robertbarner7626 Před 4 lety +8

    Some of the ones you didn't like I I thought would work great. Probably depends upon the genre of though too. I could hear them in Future Bass music, which can sound kind of random sometimes. Great video for when I get stuck for a chord progression!

  • @jamg6311
    @jamg6311 Před 4 lety

    Dudes cool! Thx for the tutorial!

  • @michellessard7047
    @michellessard7047 Před 4 lety

    Awesome instruction 😊 ,thank you so much ! 😊👍👍💖

  • @mvh2275
    @mvh2275 Před 2 lety

    Excellent! Thanks for sharing

  • @mymockumentary9716
    @mymockumentary9716 Před 4 lety

    nice explanation and thanks for your upbeat personality :)

  • @Vissepisse11
    @Vissepisse11 Před 4 lety

    Watched 7 minutes yesterday and spent some 70+ minutes today engaging in this very clever musical practice / listening exercise!

  • @andycordy5190
    @andycordy5190 Před 2 lety

    I'm comfortable with borrowing here and there to get what I want from a line, either musically or lyrically, something I've heard in many songs I admire. Thanks to your videos, I've taught myself to manage a chord progression as it spills over into the next line, borrowing accordingly without breaking into complex time signatures which my little brain can't handle. So the expected four chord chain becomes a five, followed by a three and I have used the next near diatonic chords to subvert the expectation in a familiar sequence. Your video on inversions has helped enormously with that.

  • @jonathanredman8497
    @jonathanredman8497 Před 4 lety

    It just clicked - you're Guy Michelmore. Great energy in your videos.

  • @MarioLucianAndreano
    @MarioLucianAndreano Před 4 lety +1

    I honestly give a Like to every video from this channel already from the intro...I have no doubt the rest will be good

  • @paolomaggi8188
    @paolomaggi8188 Před 4 lety +1

    You are a really a fantastic music teacher! Thank you !!!!

  • @disneyfamily5158
    @disneyfamily5158 Před 4 lety

    Just wonderful on so many levels Guy, thank you! Do you have any videos that show the software side of things? What you use, tutorials, etc?

  • @raykellfoster8461
    @raykellfoster8461 Před 4 lety +1

    You my friend..... are a Beast ! Loved this ! :) quite fun !

  • @medec021
    @medec021 Před 4 lety

    Thank you. Great stuff.

  • @gwynevans6088
    @gwynevans6088 Před 4 lety

    Hi Guy great stuff love your energy and videos. :)

  • @stuffnuns
    @stuffnuns Před 4 lety +1

    Thanks for this. I have to mention your wonderful music room. Beautiful with all the glass and greenery outside. Perhaps not practical for recording live instruments with all the reflective surfaces, but, beautiful nonetheless.

  • @jeffrey322
    @jeffrey322 Před 4 lety

    All of the sequences you say no to are excellent as transitions or endings, however. Thank you for going thru these!

  • @vivektyagi6848
    @vivektyagi6848 Před 4 lety

    As a newbie the experimentation exercise just widened my horizon. Thanks.

  • @MaxMustermann-qn3lw
    @MaxMustermann-qn3lw Před 4 lety

    Very cool - good job!

  • @rockmail1
    @rockmail1 Před 4 lety

    Very helpful. Thank you.

  • @MildredStain
    @MildredStain Před 4 lety

    I love these kinds of analyses. I will sometime chart out my options too. What I also like to do with these common changes is play with the base set by swapping out alternate chords. Like swap a C maj for and Amin or Emin to see if it works in the context of the change. It's turned quite a few not so good changes into something interesting and usable.

  • @andrewcath4615
    @andrewcath4615 Před 4 lety +9

    6154 was the quintessential sound of top 40 edm a few years back

  • @StevenCasteelYT
    @StevenCasteelYT Před 4 lety

    Watched two videos. You're relatable. Thanks for sharing.

  • @andrewsmith9440
    @andrewsmith9440 Před 4 lety +1

    "6514, mehish" lol. You are a terrific and fun teacher! You make learning music theory fun and memorable. Thank you!

  • @VintageMusicGearTV
    @VintageMusicGearTV Před 4 lety

    Thanks for sharing going off to write a song very inspiring thanks

  • @whackoization
    @whackoization Před 4 lety +38

    Actually I look at these progressions in a different way maybe because I'm a studio producer but for me I see progressions for different purposes. Some progressions are perfect for intros, verses, bridges, choruses and outros.

  • @HealthyBodyForLife
    @HealthyBodyForLife Před 4 lety

    Dude. I stopped the video at 0:23 to see if I knew where this was going. My mind is blown. Thank You!!!

  • @Devr0ss
    @Devr0ss Před 3 lety

    Thanks for all the amazing content. This video was great, but I would like to know what you are doing with your left hand to get such nice sounding full chords and a little ornamentation as well. I play along to all of this with just triads on the right hand and I am trying to learn how to use my left hand. I also noticed you sometimes play the second part of the number sequence lower rather than higher than the 1, makes a big dif. Thanks!

  • @CR1992..
    @CR1992.. Před 4 lety +2

    They all work just fine, and it's all about the rythm and tempo.

  • @danquay9504
    @danquay9504 Před 4 lety

    Yes I found this very useful, to help build my own Dance tracks face, great tips I definitely use this, thanks I find the suits my track, brilliant

  • @vikingwolf1544
    @vikingwolf1544 Před 3 lety

    awesome thank you, a 9 min video explains yrs of my music theory great job.....

  • @ThomasCorfield
    @ThomasCorfield Před 4 lety +2

    Another great video, Guy. Thank you. "The 50s one": I remember my music teacher describing it as the "ice-cream change", presumably because of teenagers hanging out at ice-cream parlours.

  • @AwesomeOpenSource
    @AwesomeOpenSource Před 4 lety

    I'm working on a progression now, that I like, but just can't get a melody around....so frustrating. Saw this, and though why not change the order a bit and see how it sounds. Thank you.

  • @alfredtherien7791
    @alfredtherien7791 Před 4 lety +2

    1564 is actually a (very slightly) modified version of the oldest sequence in the book, 1514-also in the form 1415. It was used extensively from the very beginning of the Baroque period, and on through the Classical and Romantic styles. It’s also been ubiquitous in Folk music as well as Country music. It basically consists of an oscillation between the tonic (I), the dominant (V), and the subdominant (IV). The 6 is actually a substitute for the 1. You might visualize it as: I V7 I6 IV.

  • @crabflag
    @crabflag Před 4 lety

    I like this guy. He is fun and talented. I feel like he could discuss music in depth all day.

  • @LukaBelle
    @LukaBelle Před 5 lety

    I appreciate these videos so much.

  • @MarkPetrieMusic
    @MarkPetrieMusic Před 5 lety +56

    Great video! A lot of the progressions you’re rejecting actually sound amazing with inversions and modified chords (sus4, 9s)

    • @ThinkSpaceEducation
      @ThinkSpaceEducation  Před 5 lety +19

      yes but its interesting to look at it stripped down -no inversions or sus 4s

    • @daviddelayat-dnapictures
      @daviddelayat-dnapictures Před 5 lety

      You're right ! My prefered ones are those ones !

    • @banterbanter
      @banterbanter Před 5 lety +5

      Great video thanks but please dial back the massive 4 second cathedral reverb :)
      On headphones anyway its killing me haha

    • @ThinkSpaceEducation
      @ThinkSpaceEducation  Před 5 lety +29

      @@banterbanter What reverrrrrrrrrrrrrbbbbbbbbbbbbbbbb?

    • @TheMentalblockrock
      @TheMentalblockrock Před 4 lety

      Yes, inversion will make them work.

  • @grippinbooty6773
    @grippinbooty6773 Před 3 lety

    THANK YOU!

  • @christianferreras4758
    @christianferreras4758 Před 4 lety +2

    Thank you for this.
    PS: THAT place is so peaceful.

  • @TheWorld_2099
    @TheWorld_2099 Před 4 lety

    This was a very good experiment, great ear training.
    I do want to say that with some of the progressions that you were calling “random“,
    I probably would’ve done different inversions so that the voice leading wasn’t so overbearing...that would probably soften the sounds and make those chords more accessible to your ears.

  • @anton.vechakes
    @anton.vechakes Před 4 lety

    I’m from Russia and your accent is real pleasure for my ears. No cockney😄
    And of course your style of talking and thinking is so attractable. Thank you just for the fact that you are exist😁👍

  • @TomyKuss
    @TomyKuss Před 4 lety +1

    Thanks very much. This was really inspiring! Is there a comparable progression in minor?

  • @hahiho
    @hahiho Před 5 lety

    Thank you so much😁

  • @ALLMIGHTSTUDIO
    @ALLMIGHTSTUDIO Před 4 lety +13

    The progression IV - V - I - VI its a good idea when you substitute the I chord with the III and add the minor seven to the V and you have:
    IV - V7 - III - VI
    Hundred of J-pop music its based on this progression and you, if want, can alterate, substitute or color some chord.
    But I think this progression is rare nowdays in the western Pop music.
    Another funny progression its:
    I - V - V/VI - VI - II/IV - I - IV - IVm
    Is another super common in the J-pop style and I think all of this progression its based on the concept of the alternative IV - V - I - VI that you have rejected.
    Thanks for all your videos, you are awesome!

    • @JeiShian
      @JeiShian Před 4 lety +1

      Thank you for the interesting post :)

    • @ALLMIGHTSTUDIO
      @ALLMIGHTSTUDIO Před 4 lety

      @@JeiShian not at all!

    • @YVZSTUDIOS
      @YVZSTUDIOS Před 4 lety

      That's interesting! :D
      I knew about the IV - V7 - III - VI progression but wondered if it only works in a Major key? Is there some sort of a equivalent progression for something in a Minor Key? because not all J-pop songs are written in Major, right?
      And what does V/VI or II/IV mean?

    • @ALLMIGHTSTUDIO
      @ALLMIGHTSTUDIO Před 4 lety +3

      @@YVZSTUDIOS Yeah, its working in the minor key, it is: VI - VII - V - I
      If in C major we have: IV - V - III - VI
      in the A minor (relative minor of C)
      we Have: VI - VII - V - I
      But basically share the same chord: F - G - Em - Am
      This concept its for all key.
      V/VI mean V grade of the VI grade of the key of the song or the key in that portion of the song. Is complicated at the begin, this concept is called: "secondary dominant".
      Any chord can be preceded by a dominant, in this case if we are in the C major tonality the V of VI mean: E7
      Because E7 is the dominant of Am, the VI grade of C major tonality.
      This is for all key and relative minor.
      Sorry for my poor english and not very didatic but i'm Italian and this kind of arguments aren't simple to transpose.

  • @danabarnes4751
    @danabarnes4751 Před 2 lety

    Brilliant as always. Don't be afraid to pedal those chords with whatever.

  • @joey4track
    @joey4track Před 5 lety +1

    New video from Guy makes me a happy guy

  • @LindaMissad
    @LindaMissad Před 5 lety +1

    Interesting. Never thought about taking one chord progression and twisting it into it's many variations. thanks for the video.

  • @THEREALDATALORD
    @THEREALDATALORD Před 4 lety

    Man I love your videos.

  • @LEAK88925
    @LEAK88925 Před 4 lety

    very useful sir thank you

  • @liorneuman2198
    @liorneuman2198 Před 4 lety

    I enjoyed that. thanks

  • @jimmy2minutes
    @jimmy2minutes Před 4 lety

    Im new to the piano and the Penny just dropped. Wow. At first I was not sure at all what was going on. Then tested it out and l was right. I'm gobsmacked. Thanks.

  • @farley333
    @farley333 Před 4 lety +16

    The stepwise thing can work if you use inversions and melodically play with the bass a bit. :)

    • @thebassist122
      @thebassist122 Před 4 lety

      My thoughts exactly.... also could be cool with extensions and subs.

    • @simonvanroij4182
      @simonvanroij4182 Před 4 lety +1

      Yeah also I love the I IV V vi progression just not the way he played it

  • @frankwagner2161
    @frankwagner2161 Před 5 lety +2

    Interesting look into how the 4 chords could be used...thank -you

  • @cowboyflipflopped
    @cowboyflipflopped Před 3 lety +1

    Thanks for this! I wonder if you'd be interested in making a video that explores substitutions, such as swapping a minor for a major chord, or the double dominant for the dominant, or adding 7ths, or diminished, or augmented chords.

    • @Alpha_7227
      @Alpha_7227 Před rokem +1

      Trouble with alot of music written today it's just in major and minor.

  • @richardliew2725
    @richardliew2725 Před 4 lety +1

    Very good 👍 Sir I have learned something senseable hello from Malaysia

  • @e.p.g9572
    @e.p.g9572 Před 4 lety +1

    I want to be like u when i grow up. Great video!

  • @VoidloniXaarii
    @VoidloniXaarii Před 5 lety +2

    Thank you

  • @derekfernandez7701
    @derekfernandez7701 Před 4 lety

    4:50 6541 - But I like this one! At the end of a phrase maybe? (don't know music terms sorry!) I really appreciate how you went through them all so we could hear them! Love this! ❤️ PS Part of the reason I clicked your video was your choice of font! Lovely! 😊

  • @JohnFRodgers
    @JohnFRodgers Před 4 lety

    Some of the alternate progressions might not work well as a repeating loop, but they can be used to create the desire to resolve to a particular chord. These less-than-ideal progressions can be used to powerful effect in a pre-chorus or bridge, to draw extra emphasis to the coming chorus or next bridge.

  • @glenben92
    @glenben92 Před rokem

    i'd love this as a series

  • @protiliusproductions
    @protiliusproductions Před 4 lety +1

    Watches all these cool progressions in awe... Eyes bulge as host says “I don’t really like that.”
    “I’ll take that MIDI if you’re not interested. Every song needs a good bridge.” (Chuckles.)

  • @mastropicalofficial8552
    @mastropicalofficial8552 Před 4 lety +3

    6514 is the late 2000’s Dr Luke favorite (Dynamite, Perry, Kesha). Funny how some you feel arent OK are David Guetta et al progressions!!!

  • @gerardocorrea9559
    @gerardocorrea9559 Před 4 lety

    Great video.

  • @BrokTheLoneWolf
    @BrokTheLoneWolf Před 4 lety

    They all sound great.

  • @AmberlightES
    @AmberlightES Před 4 lety

    They all work! Its a matter of preference and their application.

  • @NeZversSounds
    @NeZversSounds Před 4 lety

    Amusing video. Love it! There were many chord progressions that clearly didn't work for you but sounded great. 6145 and 6415 are used in many electronic dance music songs... well in EDM is filled with progressions that have 6 & 4 dominating chords (like 654 or 456 and throwing in the 1 sometimes). But it gets funnier when looking at Iron Maiden songs :D

    • @stevenuttley
      @stevenuttley Před 4 lety

      6145 is pretty much 'I Got Rhythm'and 1001 other tunes on the same sequence.

  • @real6411
    @real6411 Před 4 lety

    Thanks very much

  • @pd177
    @pd177 Před 4 lety +1

    And when you want to introduce a little tension? Delay the resolution?

  • @davemilnes1147
    @davemilnes1147 Před 4 lety

    Of course, the pedant in me wants to point out you can't really have 'four' alternatives...but the rest of me wants to say how much I enjoy your videos!

  • @iansouthward7991
    @iansouthward7991 Před 4 lety

    You have behind you the makings of what would be my perfect man-cave, if I had the space, the wife who wasnt uptight about clutter and the collection would need a DX7 and Juno somewhere, Sadly 6 guitars and a Yamaha keyboard is all I can have in a small apartment.... I just love the sound of that sequence

  • @cjthomasmusic
    @cjthomasmusic Před 4 lety

    I have a question about breaking the chords into voicings for strings. I know it's common to have the bass and cello play the bass notes in octaves. Is this referring to the ROOT notes or the BASS notes? For example (and why I'm asking), if you're using inversions for smooth chord transitions would you have the cello and bass playing the lowest notes in the chord (say E in a first inversion C chord) or the root note (i.e. playing C even if it's an inverted C chord). I hope this question makes sense. Thanks!

  • @Choral-Tenor
    @Choral-Tenor Před 4 lety +5

    Well, you never get to the "why"... So, here's a couple of thoughts on that.
    1. Those four chords give you all the notes in the scale, so there's no ambiguity about the key (you don't need the vi chord for this)
    2. You get more major chords than minor (3 to 1), so there's no doubt about the sonority. Contrast ii-iii-viiº-vi.
    3. You have a I! ...and a resolution back to I. And you don't feel the resolution is too strong, because it's plagal rather than authentic. Leave out the I and you don't have this problem (vi-viiº-V-IV, for example)
    4. The vi chord functions like a deceptive cadence, saving you from I V I, which might feel too cadential to keep repeating.
    So why is it that you accept vi-IV-I-V but not IV-I-V-vi or V-vi-IV-I (well, you changed your mind about that one)? I think it might be because you're thinking in four-measure phrases in 4/4 time. Why does that matter? Because the relative strength of the beats of the 4/4 measure is paralleled by the stronger and weaker bars in the four-bar phrase. This helps to reduce the impact of the V and IV chords in the cycles you prefer, while increasing their impact in the cycles you don't favour. That doesn't explain vi-I-V-IV, but that was "yes and no".
    I'm not too keen on I-V-IV-vi (retrograde) but it's quite nice as I-viiº-IV-vi... (retrograde with substitute dominant function).

  • @MacroMihir
    @MacroMihir Před 4 lety +3

    When I saw the title of the video on my homepage, I knew it. "Oh yeah... THAT one." I clicked, and I was correct.

  • @gregt4202
    @gregt4202 Před 4 lety +1

    Love your videos! I agree with your findings, but sometimes an interesting melody can be teased out of those "ho-hum" chord progressions. Or a small change to Emin in lieu of Amin can evoke a very pleasing sequence.

    • @WillayG
      @WillayG Před 4 lety

      I thought so too. Actually more than half of them kinda worked for me.

  • @carolinemoore8121
    @carolinemoore8121 Před 4 lety

    Awesome!!! :)

  • @mithunkalamegam6753
    @mithunkalamegam6753 Před 4 lety

    Interesting video..I always wanted to someone to through this chord progression..Does the minor scale and modes have any such cliché chord progression???

    • @davidste60
      @davidste60 Před 4 lety

      Yes - czcams.com/video/j-j4g0ktPGw/video.html

  • @stanstevens6289
    @stanstevens6289 Před 4 lety

    I'm intregued by the Pianoteq you're using. Never heard of this before and I'd by interested on you opinion of it, do you have a review? Do you use it in the DAW or just stand alone?

  • @roryburgin9650
    @roryburgin9650 Před 4 lety

    4, 5, 6, 1 is used well in the song "berth". I really dig that song

  • @aljamesproductions
    @aljamesproductions Před 4 lety +1

    The reason these chords are so popular is historical songwriters are afraid to step out of the winning sequence, which I get. Hit Songs on radio why break the formula? But you have bands like prefab sprout who write great tunes for the sake of making great music that breaks moulds. Great video. Love your work.

  • @markjackson2924
    @markjackson2924 Před 4 lety +1

    all my progressions always start on 1 or 6 and this makes me feel better about it

    • @raphaelkasongo8377
      @raphaelkasongo8377 Před 4 lety

      4 works too. or even 2. See it as a sub. 2 can sub 4 in a progression and 6 can sub 1. You should try it xD