Jewish klezmer vs Gipsy music - Train de vie

Sdílet
Vložit
  • čas přidán 8. 09. 2024
  • Jewish klezmer vs Gipsy music

Komentáře • 76

  • @tullochgorum6323
    @tullochgorum6323 Před rokem +9

    As two scorned outsider groups, the Romani and the Jews of Eastern Europe developed a close musical and cultural relationship. The host community would regularly hire these musicians for weddings and other celebrations.

  • @sidneycosman2899
    @sidneycosman2899 Před 11 lety +18

    John I cried. It's everything our people stands for. Shalom to the world!

  • @djfrankie7586
    @djfrankie7586 Před 2 lety +25

    Nobody can rock a party like gypsies or jews .. that joyful feeling when each tribe comes together and party that joyful feeling is just of this world .. plus our muisc and their jewish music you can feel the power the freedom and its not the same music doesnt sound like our gypsy music but yet i have feel the same energy .. godbless the jews and gypsies for having their own traditions for more then centuries now .. 🙏 maybe thats why some ppl were angry and hate at us for having our own way of life 🤔

    • @KnowledgeOfThePast
      @KnowledgeOfThePast Před rokem +4

      I think it’s because we were both different populations and nothing like the Europeans altogether. I’m part Jewish (Galician/Polish) and I’m sending love to the Romani people, we went through hell together and we still live today ❤️

    • @kresivarivkah612
      @kresivarivkah612 Před 4 měsíci +1

      I once lived with Hungarian Jews and Gypsies. I myself am Jewish. We used to party to the extreme. We had disco bulbs we'd use in our kitchen.

  • @eedobee
    @eedobee Před 5 lety +22

    An amazing move, but I still tear up whenever I remember the ending.

  • @nchamahmiller3218
    @nchamahmiller3218 Před 9 lety +31

    This is my all time favourite video of a Klezmer and Romani musical meet- it has the distinctive position that it is not made to commercialize any personal or commercial interests which plague 100% of all other videos currently available in You Tube on this subject.. This is a pure form of art. Long live the people who love art for is spiritual and solidarity value!
    Long live the People who provide us with such joy

  • @gengener
    @gengener Před 10 lety +18

    One of the best musical film scenes ever

    • @verandi3882
      @verandi3882 Před 7 lety +1

      from what film was that scene taken from ?

    • @user-ik1ud5fd1z
      @user-ik1ud5fd1z Před 6 lety +1

      Omar Brsli "Train de la vie", a French film

  • @first2nd2002
    @first2nd2002 Před 9 lety +40

    The name of the song is "Blestem (Cine iubeste si lasa)", a traditional song from Brasov County, Romania. It is essentially a scorned lover's curse, discovered by musicologist Harry Brauner in 1929 in a village named Dragus and made famous in Maria Tanase's rendition in 1937.

  • @naomiburn6359
    @naomiburn6359 Před 7 lety +11

    The musical piece of the first minute (or one vey much like it) was also featured in the movie Latcho Drom (highly recommended.)

    • @vpsoundlabs1956
      @vpsoundlabs1956 Před 3 lety +1

      Also played often by the late, great Nicolae Neacsu with Taraf de Haidouks

  • @aofg
    @aofg Před 15 lety +9

    Since when is "Cine iubeste si lasa" a Gipsy song? This legendary song (a curse-mourning) was discovered by Harry Brauner in 1929 in a small village in Brasov county sung by an old peasant. It was a amazing stroke of luck as in a few years that woman was dead and the song would have been lost forever. It's power comes from the soul of a woman abandoned by her lover. Incredible authentic.

  • @instanthellmurderer
    @instanthellmurderer Před 3 lety +9

    I'm from Brooklyn, NY. I see this type of crowd every day

  • @albertmartin8201
    @albertmartin8201 Před 3 lety +5

    Tears and pure joy.

  • @RictusGoelan
    @RictusGoelan Před 16 lety +4

    Am vazut filmul acum 2 ani! Este super!!! Si daca am inteles eu bine... R. Benigni a pornit de la scenario-ul acesta pentru "La vite e bella". Intermediu musical superb!!!!

  • @EngPheniks
    @EngPheniks Před 3 lety +4

    just listen to the sound of that violin bowed by a torn out string. You attempt the same and see how difficult it is.

  • @melaniekurilec-mangold4420

    Einer der besten Filme der Welt…

  • @user-vk2gm1he2u
    @user-vk2gm1he2u Před 2 měsíci

    my family is jewish, my maternal grandmothers family are roma converts (into judaism) and i grew up heavily influences by both cultures, and music definately played a big part

  • @NickyRikki
    @NickyRikki Před 11 dny

    As a Romanian Jew this warms my heart.

  • @MrJonnydelta
    @MrJonnydelta Před 11 lety +2

    glad you like it Sidney, we have similarities.

  • @emiliodibenedetto4654
    @emiliodibenedetto4654 Před 8 lety +2

    This is awesome!

  • @ricardoseller9361
    @ricardoseller9361 Před 8 lety +1

    Besten movie i ever see...Bachtales romale

  • @corkovits
    @corkovits Před 2 lety +2

    ye 2022. en dan.word ajax pioen.

  • @aliparlak8618
    @aliparlak8618 Před 3 lety +2

    I didn't expect Turkish dubbing x.x

  • @SenorKuso
    @SenorKuso Před 11 lety +3

    What are you talking about? I was talking about the dislikes video's interface, making a joke about a nazi. I actually borned on Belarus and living in Spain. Nedless to say that im looking to the future, also i have a very open mind. Saludos! :-)

  • @melaniekurilec-mangold4420

    I love this Movie so much…es ist sicher auf der Stufe mit entsprechenden andern Filmen…ich will (selbst Roma) nicht anmaßend sein…aber dieser Film prägt und ist musikalisch sensationell…

  • @SenorKuso
    @SenorKuso Před 11 lety +1

    OMFG!!! I just lol'd with your comment!!!! HAHAHAHAHAHA +1000

  • @bbmtucker743
    @bbmtucker743 Před 2 lety

    Greetings from the netherlands

  • @asd1245d
    @asd1245d Před 9 lety

    very cool movie!

  • @melaniekurilec-mangold4420
    @melaniekurilec-mangold4420 Před 4 měsíci

    Der Zug des Lebens

  • @AlTrianovitz
    @AlTrianovitz Před 8 lety +2

    Oy gevalt!!

  • @user-lz1wp8sw3v
    @user-lz1wp8sw3v Před rokem +2

    gyps*e is a slur nowdays. But this video is wholesome
    I only recently discovered that we both share the holocaust

    • @houseofhope6885
      @houseofhope6885 Před rokem

      There say 500 thousands but IT was more Gypsys maybe 1-2million also!!!! Never firget that😢. Atsigana Samuel abukaya Saya Gypsys are from Shimon Menashe Ephraim decandants of King David..... Maybe this is true maybe Not. I discover That WE are Scythian from Tribe Sindi AND Sigynnae wich for me IS saame Name as SIGANNE ZIGAN SINTI SINDI etc.... But you know what maybe Gitanos manashe from fremvh andalusia etc are from jewish North Kingdom ANCIENT KINGDOM Samaria god Bless you my Brother Shabbat Shalom❤

  • @enginfirol
    @enginfirol Před 10 lety +1

    Müthiş :)

  • @LCbas
    @LCbas Před 11 lety +11

    Hitler's worst nightmare..

    • @ferencfarkas2729
      @ferencfarkas2729 Před 10 měsíci

      Yeah poor Hitler 😢 ! Ever since he gone he’s been having nightmares and will continue to experience it for ever and ever 😢 .. and I hope he can see from down there that gypsies and Jews are larger in Europe than ever before 😢 .. poor guy all that killings for nothing 😢 cancer will eat your inside system as well 😢 feel very sorry for you 😢 I can all ready see how much you gonna suffer 😢 .. amen 🙏

  • @great.1973
    @great.1973 Před rokem

    👍👍🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔

  • @BrentTucker-dk1xc
    @BrentTucker-dk1xc Před měsícem

    Roma ❤

  • @scottbenlevi7976
    @scottbenlevi7976 Před 6 lety +2

    Poignant....

  • @surilvazzog3186
    @surilvazzog3186 Před rokem

    Te awen bachtale romale

  • @theGypsiePolish
    @theGypsiePolish Před 4 měsíci

    Wie heißt dieser Film ?

    • @erectilereptile7383
      @erectilereptile7383 Před 27 dny

      Du solltest die Zigeunersprache sprechen, die Deutschen haben dich unterdrückt, nicht wahr? Warum hast du nicht mehr Freude daran, eine andere Sprache zu sprechen?

  • @zagreb1352
    @zagreb1352 Před 2 lety

    What is the name of this film, please ?

  • @great.1973
    @great.1973 Před rokem

    Im Russian officer and will help you guys

  • @jotre8621
    @jotre8621 Před 10 lety

    is there a name for the song?

  • @gunngargunn858
    @gunngargunn858 Před 3 měsíci

    Все это балканская музыка
    А евреи и цыгане пришли из других стран и переняли эту музыку. Так что это балканская музыка

  • @claudiovip98v50
    @claudiovip98v50 Před 2 lety +1

    Jipsy are from israel i am

    • @JacobIX99
      @JacobIX99 Před rokem +1

      Gypsy are rooted from Indian lol..

    • @ferencfarkas2729
      @ferencfarkas2729 Před rokem +2

      Roma Gypsies are Indo Aryans lived in the north of india .. irony that the Nazis claim to be Aryan descendants lol 😂 .. we were the descendants of Indo Aryans our language dna proved that .. we were never Jewish or Israel .. Jews and Roma have similarities in their cultures and went through hell in Europe together.. but we the Roma were never from Israel or Jewish .. plz know some history before you say stuff ..

  • @matthewmann8969
    @matthewmann8969 Před 4 lety +3

    Have to say music is one of the few things I think Gypsies as a group are better then Jews at

  • @LCbas
    @LCbas Před 11 lety

    0:32 and two oldest hipsters

  • @great.1973
    @great.1973 Před rokem

    Stop get down now

  • @SenorKuso
    @SenorKuso Před 11 lety

    about nazis*

  • @user-dz4jl2yp7h
    @user-dz4jl2yp7h Před 8 měsíci

    Супер,супер, супер!